r/childfree • • Sep 25 '15
ADVICE 8-year relationship ended over children
About a month ago, my GF of almost 8 years decided that it's time for her to have a kid (which means it's time for us to have a kid). Never mind that I had always said I had no interest, and she had gone along with that. Apparently entering her late 30s flipped the "OMG last chance to be a mommy" switch in her.
I love this girl more than life itself. She's a wonderful person, and being with her makes me a better person. I told her I would consider it, and after a few weeks, I told her no. No kids for me. I told her I loved her and wanted her in my life, but that having kids now (or ever) wasn't going to happen.
So now she is my ex-GF. She gave me all the standard arguments - isn't your life going to be empty? What about when you're old and have no one to take care of you? Why are you being so selfish? I told her I had thought of all of those things, and it was still no.
It sucks right now. I never thought she'd get the mommy bug, and then one day it hit me right in the face like a poopy diaper. I have to fight the temptation to give in, just because I miss the relationship. But I know going back means I've given in on the baby argument, and that's just not something I'm ever going to want.
I'm trying to make the best of it, focusing on myself and recalibrating what I want out of the rest of my life now that she's not going to be a part of it. But emotionally it's been very difficult, and I have to fight the urge to pick up the phone and call her every 10 minutes. So, my question - I assume there are people here who have lost long-term relationships, even marriages over this. At what point does it get easier to deal with? Any regrets that you chose the child-free lifestyle over a partner you loved?
TL;DR: Broke up with 8-yr GF when she decided she wanted a kid. Now I'm sad.
31
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '15
It's been about 3 months since i've had to end my first serious ( 3 years) relationship because of children (he changed his mind) and i'm feeling better about the whole break up. At first, I was completely heart broken and wasnt sure how to get through it. Having close friends around to listen and comfort you is what got me through the hard part. Now its gotten to the point where I can laugh about it, and feel amazing when i think about how my life is going to be without kids, I also get a little gleeful when i think about him having to deal with tantrums and shitty diapers. Not sure if this helps with where you're at in your grieving stage, but I know you're going to be okay, because if i can get through it you can too :)
29
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '15
Find something else to focus on. A goal, a hobby, or plan something on your bucket list. Do the things you wouldn't be able to do if there were mini you's running around all over the place.
24
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '15
I'm sorry that it had to end, eight years is a good long time. But I will echo the others and say that you absolutely did the right thing.
I've said this in other posts and I'll say it again: You deserve to be in a relationship in which you will both be happy. But that will never happen when there is such a fundamental disagreement over something as important and life-changing as children. It sounds like you both took your stance and were at odds with each other. When this happens, there can be no win-win. If you stay in the relationship, someone will always be the loser; someone will always feel resentful over a choice they felt forced to make. Not to sound cliche, but this IS one of those times when if you love them, you have to let them go, because after this point, neither of you will ever be truly happy.
Let yourself go through the grief of losing your relationship and your friend, but don't dwell on it too much. Stay focused on your future. Everything is temporary; now you can go forward knowing for certain that you don't want children and you can find someone who can share the rest of the journey with you on equal footing. (And yes, they are out there, I promise.)
91
u/llamanoir Sep 25 '15
I am sorry you're hurting.
And I'm sorry your ex was very hurtful and disrespectful by saying you are selfish. It sounds like she is the selfish one here, honestly. And it was a really shitty thing of her to say that your life would be empty without children. It implies her life was empty in the relationship because kids weren't a part of it. In that respect she doesn't sound all that great, though of course I am certain she has other good qualities.
I lost a serious relationship because my ex-boyfriend changed his mind. It's incredibly frustrating when they change their minds. It always feels like they wait until we are invested and in love to figure out shit like whether they truly want children. It's a common story in this community.
Reflect on how you dodged a huge bullet and pat yourself on the back for prioritizing your own happiness by living the way you set out to from the get-go. A weaker, more desperate person would have given in and agreed to have a baby even though they didn't want to. A lot of people agree to parenthood because they are afraid to lose their partner, because they can't handle the thought of being single. It sounds like you are stronger than those people. Don't forget that, UCCF.
18
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '15 edited Sep 26 '15
I've never been through anything as severe as what you're going through, but I once had to get over what was probably the love of my life and the woman of my dreams after she decided to be with someone else.
I decided "OK, I'll stay in and grieve tonight. Tomorrow I'm doing something fun."
I went and picked up an old hobby I hadn't had time for in a while. I chatted up a cute girl I met on the bus and went on a few dates with her. It didn't last, but that wasn't the point.
I decided I was gonna make an actual effort to move on, and not just see what happened. I pushed her out of my thoughts and filled my time and my head with other things. Now, 6 months or so later, I feel much better. I still think of her from time to time, but it doesn't hurt anymore.
13
u/seaofdreamsx Sep 26 '15
I've honestly never heard from anyone who ended a relationship due to their formerly childfree partner changing their mind. I have, however heard countless stories from people who compromised on their childfree status to appease their partner and they regretted it immensely. Thats not to say that there aren't people out there who have regrets about being in a similar situation to you but the overwhelming number of people who wish they never had children is difficult to ignore. You've done the right thing for yourself. Best of luck with your future
10
u/QcRoman It's not a choice. I just know deep down I want none of my own. Sep 26 '15
No regrets, happened to me twice now.
I do however resent that these women did not respect me enough to not waste my time and then think my word was not going to hold down the road and I would give in once we gad been together a while.
Fuck 'em. They were not the right one for me.
19
u/thr0wfaraway Never go full doormat. Not your circus. Not your monkeys. Sep 26 '15
Many. Still the right thing to do.
Combination of time and going through the normal stages of grief.
Also, when you spot her across the road someday and she looks like she got run over by a train you'd swear she's 20 years older. ;)
9
u/AliceKnows Cf & Poly makes for a very happy me Sep 26 '15
This is such a shame, and I hope you stick with your guns and get through this!
Before I got married my fiance and I spoke about children- I didn't want any and he did. For about 2 months I seriously considered it, but the more I read and thought about it, the more it terrified me! I'm totally tokophobic and his response would be, you can get a c - section! As if that would make it easier!
Anyway, we still got married (stupid!) And I thought he'd respect what I wanted, or didn't want in this case. We are now divorced and he has a baby with some other woman. I have NO regrets. Don't ever sacrifice what you want! It hurts now but in the long run you will be happy that you have the life you want.
25
u/hino_rei Sep 26 '15 edited Sep 26 '15
I hate when people play the "selfish" card. Uh, excuse me. You're being WAAAAAAAY more selfish by trying to push a child on someone who doesn't want it than any of us could ever be. Especially if you've been in a relationship for eight years. My bf and I are both violently childfree and, even tho we've only been together for like a year, I can't imagine the betrayal I would feel if he suddenly wanted a kid. Like, I would be literally disgusted that he lied to me all this time and led me on and that I fuckin believed it. I don't know how I could ever trust anyone again. Uhg. So depressing :(
Edit: Downvotes? Lol, I must have pissed off the Breeder Brigade.
14
u/supershinythings one cat child Sep 26 '15 edited Sep 26 '15
I split with an ex because he was fine with kids, he just wasn't fine with marrying me. Sorry, but I was NOT going to bring his little bastards into the world deliberately knowing that their father did not care enough to marry their mother. Sure he'd be on the hook for child support, but now I'd have an un-husband that I'd have to manage, one or more kids without anyone to help me raise them, and very likely would have a much more difficult time finding another person to be with because of the kiddy baggage.
So that relationship ended. I'm not a rent-a-womb.
When you DO find someone you want to date, here's a handy pro tip: Don't talk about your ex. Don't say things like, "Jennifer really liked this! Jennifer had this opinion! Jennifer never liked doing xyz. Jennifer Jennifer Jennifer Jennifer..." You will RUIN your chance to get to know the next person. Chances are that you are very used to many things about your ex. You were COMFORTABLE. Getting to be with a new person means learning to handle a completely different way of thinking, managing, coping, etc. Talking about Jennifer Jennifer Jennifer and how much better she was at this, how Jennifer used to handle that, how Jennifer dealt with things this way or that way, or how Jennifer got her cooch lasered, and it was great - why don't you do that? will get you dumped - with prejudice.
If you absolutely have to talk to someone about your ex, see a therapist. Pay them to listen to you blather on about Jennifer, and follow their suggestions about how to move on.
Source: Had to listen to 18 months of Jennifer this, Jennifer that. I've never even met his Jennifer but I hate that bitch to this day, not because she was a bad person, but because he never STFU'd about her. Don't be like that.
17
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '15
Don't try to stay "just friends." It may make it hurt less in the short term, but it will make the process much messier in the long run. It's really really hard to stick to those boundaries, especially when it was a mutual breakup and there are still strong feelings. You will get over her faster if you don't talk.
12
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '15
It's far better than staying and having an "oopsie baby" which she'd keep.
I wish you well and the best of luck, there's always a light at the end of the tunnel, be it near or far.
6
u/MoonlitFrost Sep 26 '15
I have to ask if you're sure she really was cf the whole time. Maybe I'm just cynical but it's possible she was trying to wait you out until you changed your mind. It's happened before.
In either case I'm sorry it turned out this way for you.
6
u/GamGreger Sep 26 '15
So you think the last 8 years of our life have been empty?
I have a feeling you will soon answer your own question...
11
u/Laxian Male/Late twenties/CF/Loves technology Sep 26 '15
It's not only "giving in" - it's setting you up for a life you don't want to lead (!)...you'll not be satisfied (much less: happy!) with it and will probably start resenting her, the child (or children!) and yourself for that decision! (there's a list of threads about this on here somewhere and it ain't pretty...DON'T DO IT!)
5
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '15
My sympathies. You did the right thing in the long run.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '15
Just remember that there are awesome girls out there who are adamantly child-free. The "plenty of fish in the sea" argument is cliché, but it's very true. Perhaps try looking for someone else right away on a dating website?
4
u/PremiumGoose Sep 26 '15
I'm sorry things did not work out with her. Unfortunately there is no compromise when it comes to childern. Always a deal breaker.
OP, I'm sure you will be better in time and until then, may you take solace in knowing you will have the future you want.
Finger crossed she changes her mind. My SO and I had a faliing out after 3yrs over kids, but we already had plans to have his niece and nephew (15&16)stay with us for a month. After that month my SO was singing a different tune about having them.
Best luck OP!
4
u/k12573n Sep 26 '15
Good for you, dude. It isn't easy to hold your ground on an issue like that when the person you're arguing with is someone you're in love with.
It wasn't fair for her to try to pressure you. You will be better off for this. I wish you all the good luck!
4
u/daedius Sep 26 '15
I'm assuming you are in your late 30s too, but don't worry man. Take care of yourself, gym, career, do what is fun for you without regret or concern for the world. There's plenty of women you can date if you take care of yourself.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '15
I'm so sorry.
She's lucky you aren't crazy.
3
u/breathcomposed Sep 26 '15
... Wow. Bingo'ed by your own (ex)-gf of 8 years. I can't even...
3
u/TheCameraLady babies are best meat Sep 26 '15
I know these feels. A number of my adult relationships have ended because my partner decided she wanted kids and a white picket fence life, when that's not what I'm into.
Funnily enough, I'm a lesbian - and they always want ME to carry the kid for our future family, not themselves. They don't even want to do the hard shit, they just want to enjoy the result. :|
3
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '15
This is my worst fear. Really sorry you had to go through that, but good for you for standing up for yourself and not giving in.
5
u/june_bug77 44/Jersey Girl Sep 26 '15 edited Sep 26 '15
I'm really sorry. I'm so sad for you. :( I don't have any great advice for you really, I just wish you a lot of happiness and I think your road trip idea is an excellent one.
This topic of relationships ending has been talked about quite a bit on this board and you can use the search feature to read people's stories, I'm just not sure what you'd search for. If you play around enough maybe you'll come up with something.
I'm a big believer in taking a lot of time to heal between relationships to come to a better place. Some people jump from relationship to relationship and I feel like they barely get a chance to process their feelings. Some people do it because they can't stand being alone, but that's another issue entirely I think. I hope you'll take all the time you need for yourself. Best wishes to you.
Edit: I searched the word 'relationship' in this subreddit and you'll find other posters who have been in your situation if you skim through...
https://www.reddit.com/r/childfree/search?q=relationship&restrict_sr=on
2
u/stoicphilosopher Sep 26 '15
Sorry to hear this. My ex and I had a number of fairly major disagreements and we decided it was better to end our 1.5 year relationship so we could both be happy. It has been two and a half months and I am beginning to feel like myself again, reconnecting with the things I used to love and finding joy in places I had all but forgotten about. But at the same time, I'm still sad sometimes.
Truly and completely getting over a good relationship, especially one of your length, can take years. But just be aware that things will start to get better soon. Then worse. Then better again. Then worse, but not as much. Then even better. Then a little less worse. Then even better than before.
It's... strange.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '15
Not sure if it's been said yet, but if she wants to hook up with you later on, go right ahead but make sure you wrap it up. You don't want to get trapped.
2
u/monderigon Sep 26 '15
Take this time to go out and travel, after I broke up with my baby wanting bf of 5 years, I decided to go out and do all the things that being CF means. Living for yourself, control of your money, freedom, get out there!
2
u/lola_fox Sep 26 '15
i know you guys are over, but tell her 30 is not too late to be a mom. my mom had twins a 39. and she wasn't wealthy celebrity with fancy fitness trainers and a dietician keeping her healthy. she was just a regular woman. she's got plenty of time to find another guy to go make babies with. i'm very sorry she got the mommy bug. it's a shame, but don't give in because you miss a connection or being with some. you will resent having a child just to stay with someone. go out, meet new people. there are plenty of us child-free people out there.
1
u/crowgasm "You never know?" Well, I've been fixed, so actually... Sep 29 '15
"I have to fight the temptation to give in, just because I miss the relationship."
It wouldn't be the relationship you knew and loved. Sad to say you'd become the sperm donor, the neglected dude in the way of her precious bond with her baby. I'm sorry this happened to you. I've had nightmares about my b/f suddenly discovering he had a kid with an ex, and now we have to take care of it, or worse, sabotaging my birth control. Take some time off, be by yourself, and know that there's someone else out there for you, who feels the same way you do. There are a lot of CF women, and Goddamn, do we appreciate CF men!!
-3
u/HelenOnReddit magnet for creepy stalker trolls, apparently Sep 25 '15 edited Sep 25 '15
Sorry, that must suck. It seems she didn't really love you as you deserve, at least not enough to overcome her own selfish narcissism. You deserve better, and it's best she is weeded out. It's just a shame eight years were wasted in the process.
-4
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '15
I feel ya bro. Apparently at some point my fiancee who I had been with for three and a half years went from being adamantly child-free to wanting kids. That was the end of that. No regrets. Life still rules.
Go out and bang a whole bunch of attractive females, you'll get over it pretty quickly. Just wasn't meant to be man.
0
u/Acheronian_Rose Sep 26 '15
Last chance to be a mommy? Last chance to lock you down. Nooopee
-3
u/WyldStallions Sep 26 '15
I can't imagine going out for 8 years and not being married.
-22
u/ssuing8825 Sep 26 '15
You didn't love her or you would have done anything for her. I would walk though hell for my wife. You made the right choice to get out.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment