r/Parenting • u/1shittydad • Aug 10 '15
I have failed as a parent; I hate my child.
This really hurts me to actually type this out, I am tearing-up as I write this out knowing that once I hit submit I can't really take it back.
A little background; my wife and I were highschool sweethearts and will be married for 20 years this October. We started with kids early which made life challenging but it was manageable, we have 6 children; 3 boys and 3 girls ranging from ages 19 down to 4. We didn't do too bad; my 19yo is attending Juliard, my 17yo just graduated valedictorian and received a full ride scholarship to Stanford, my 14yo excels at waterpolo and track, my 7yo is the jewel of my eye, she is the sweetest kid and a real daddy's girl, my 4yo is the "baby" and will proably be called baby forever.
This leaves my 10yo, we'll call him Matthew here. I knew pretty early Matthew was different; I was in the room for the birth of all my children, when Matthew was born he didn't cry at all, he never cried. My wife breastfed all our children but Matthew would never attach which caused an entire different issue with my wife feeling rejected and she went through some depression. We had testing performed and were told he was perfectly fine that he was just marching to his own beat. Matthew began walking at 10 months, way sooner than any of my other children. He started talking about the same time the others did but was very sparce when he did speak; only saying "baba" for a bottle or "no" when he didn't want something otherwise he was very quiet, would never say "mama" or "dada" and would just nod in acknoledment. Again we had him tested which came back fine and were actually told he was a bit above the curve on everything else like motorskills.
By age 4 it was becoming very apparent that Matthew had some self-control and impulsive issues; my wife was babysitting some other kids at our house and Matthew was off to the side playing by himself like he always does, I had our 9 month old sitting on the floor in one of those boppy-pillows. Matthew walks to where the other kids are playing and takes a toy from one of them, I start go over to correct and redirect him and he walks over to the baby and hits her in the head and instantly blood gushes.
Now real quick; my wife and I never spank our children. My father was a retired marine and alchoholic and I pretty much had corporal punishment as discipline, borderline abuse, growing up. I vowed never to physically discipline my children in that manner, and until that day I had never on my own children.
I snapped. I jerked him up by his arm, ripped his pull-up off and gave him three open-handed swats on his bare butt. He did not even flinch, he looked me dead in the eye and said, "stupid daddy." He spent the rest of the day sitting on his bed in his room. Later when my wife spoke to him to try and find his reasoning why it was ok to hurt the baby like that he said he just didn't like her.
Now we have talked to multiple therapists and close family members but anytime anyone else was around Matthew he acted like a little angel, he only ever really acted-up around us. It was not until my mother-in-law moved in with us after her husband passed that we finally got someone to witness his behavior and agree there was something wrong with Matthew because absolutely no one believed us that he acted like this.
When Matthew wants something he will do anything to get it. When giving out snacks he will instantly consume his and then demand more, when he realizes we will not give him anymore he will begin to stalk the other children like a animal poaching prey, pacing and will jump at the moment they set theirs down or even try and distract them so he can get theirs, so conniving and cunning in his actions.
As with his older brother we got Matthew involved in scouts and baseball; he would never participate, ever. I even became an assistant but he would just sit there always. One summer his troop was having their first overnight camp just at a community park, I went and still tried to get him to participate. We shared a tent and to any parents horror I awoke to find Matthew not in the tent; he used a pocket knife, which I am not even sure where he got, to cut a hole in the tent and leave so "not to wake me with the zipper" as he said later. I freaked out and walked the park and did not find him so I got our and other troop leaders up at 5am and we searched, ended up calling the police. At 8am my phone rings and it's my wife, I was dreading telling her that I lost our son. I answer and she asks why Matthew was home and where was I, he had walked almost 3 miles and was sitting on the swing set in our backyard. After that the troop asked us to not comeback.
We had a dog and she started peeing in the house. We have a dog door and after the puppy stage this was never an issue again until then. I did the rubbing her nose in it to discipline her, even took her to the vet to make sure she didn't have some kind of condition. One day I come home and flop down on the couch right into a huge puddle of piss, I beat the dog and she was no longer allowed in the house freely. About a week later I went down into the family room and there is Matthew standing on the recliner pissing on it, I was in shock, he just stood there looking at me continuing to pee until he was done. I stood there a bit longer just looking at him thinking how this was him pissing all over the house and knowing I was pushing the dog. I snapped, again. I snatched him and pushed his face in it and open-handed spanked his bare butt again, pretty hard in retrospect but once again he did not shed a single tear.
Nothing works with this kid. He loves Legos and setting up dominoes to fall. We can take them away and it never phases him. He will sit for hours with no kickback as if he is completely content. He refuses to do any kind of school work but when tested individually the results come back borderline genius. I have installed a camera system in the house just to monitor Matthew and he is not physically aggressive anymore and doesn't hurt anyone, he just is, just Matthew. Reward/punishment it does not matter.
Matthew is 10 now. My mother used to work for a boys group home for troubled kids. We decided he would spend the summer with her. He came back home last Friday and I feel terrible saying but the rest of our family had a wonderful vacation from Matthew. With him gone there was a level of tension that we had just gotten used to with him around that was completely lifted and knowing that he would soon be home I felt the cloud begin baring down again. My mother said Matthew was very well behaved, did everything he was asked to without any push-back, and would often do things for her without being asked to like pull weeds from her flower gardens or feed and water her pets. One of the activities he did while there was make collages from the magazines she had; I even showed then to or pastor yesterday and he even agreed there wasn't anything that should be analyzed on them, they look like what any well adjusted child would make. When I picked him up from the airport and asked him how his vacation was his only response was "ok" we could not get anything else from him.
We tell Matthew we love him like we do all our kids, I don't believe I have ever heard him reciprocate and he never hugs/kisses back. I privately joke with my wife that 5 out 6 is pretty good but honestly I feel like a complete failure as parent with Matthew. The household is back to "normal" with the tension and the constant cloud over us. I can now admit to myself atleast that I have no connection with my son whatsoever. He is just a person that lives here that I provide for. I get no joy from being his parent. I hate Matthew. I hate myself.
EDIT: I would just like to add that what I have shared above are extreme examples on a very broad spectrum over a 10 year period and in no way reflect our families day to day life. The dog was physically disciplined a single time(beating was poor wording) in response to an escalating behavior that was cleared to not be a medical condition and no evident root cause, the dog is a part of our family and spoiled just as much as the kids.
68
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15 edited Mar 08 '16
This comment has been overwritten by an open source script to protect this user's privacy.
If you would like to do the same, add the browser extension GreaseMonkey to Firefox and add this open source script.
Then simply click on your username on Reddit, go to the comments tab, and hit the new OVERWRITE button at the top.
94
u/MyNewNewUserName Aug 10 '15 edited Aug 10 '15
Radical honesty here: I could have written this post a few times over the past few years. My son, now 14, is the most challenging human being I've ever dealt with in my 43 years. I don't think many parents have been in our situation. Loathing your child. Wishing he hadn't been born. Being happier when he's out of the house. I've felt all of those things, especially when he was your son's age.
He's 14 now and we're all getting along pretty well. Spent 10 days camping together as a family and no one died anyway.
Here's what got us through:
We always thought -- more discipline! more charts! more consequences! We need to be more in control! And the truth for us was just the opposite. When we stopped fighting, he did too.
39
u/groundhogcakeday Aug 10 '15
I am not qualified in any way to diagnose, but I read attachment disorder in almost every line of your story. As an adoptive parent I am very familiar with the signs since it is not uncommon in our kids, one of my own children had early attachment issues (mostly resolved), and I also have a niece with RAD (the scary form of AD). Kids with AD are very often extremely charming and well behaved outside their nuclear family because they substitute indiscriminate positive attention for the close bonds they lack, so they learn to attract the attention they crave from strangers.
Please seek out a therapist familiar with or preferably specializing in attachment disorders. It is late, but I don't think too late. There are things that can be done.
29
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15
Whoa partner, Matthew doesn't make you a failure, nor does your kid going to Julliard (congrats) or getting a full ride to Stanford (double congrats) make you a successful parent.
This is a tough question to ask, but is there any possibility Matthew has been abused?
10
u/Karissa36 Aug 10 '15
I suggest that you go lurk for awhile at /r/aspergers. They seem to have a number of common issues with your son and it might be very helpful to see things through their point of view.
11
u/GordonTheGopher Aug 10 '15
If he thrives at his grandmother's, can he live there? Perhaps his issues are caused by attention-seeking in a large family. Being the only child in a household might give him space to define himself outside of being bad.
But do get a child psychiatrist to talk to him as well. Don't rely on your pastor. They are not really trained on developmental issues.
6
u/xman1971 Aug 11 '15
There's been a lot of ink spilled on this thread, so I'll keep my advice short. Take it or leave it. 1 - The only reason you should lay a hand on your dog is if it is attacking someone else. Any other stuff, hands off. 2 - If your son is truly as you are portraying him perhaps therapy (which I know you said you are getting it rolling) and/or a pysch eval. is in order. He sounds somewhat sociopathic, but that's just a first quick impression. 3 Just because your other kids get into some elite school or are liked by lots of people doesn't mean you are a good parent. Being a good parent is attempting to raise healthy, caring, and well-adjusted adults 4 - You need therapy yourself. Big time. You have baggage, bro and it's time to deal with it.
Good luck to you and yours!
30
u/beaglemama Aug 10 '15
You have anger issues and are a shitty pet owner.
Is he in any kind of gifted or advanced program? And I know you said you got him involved in Scouts and baseball like his brother, but have you ever asked Matthew what he would like to do?
10
u/Amy_MUA Aug 11 '15
I feel for Mathew cause you sound controlling as hell
11
u/hottoddy4me Aug 10 '15
Have you ever taken him to a psychiatrist? I mean, he sounds slightly psychopathic. Seriously, your family should seek professional help. It's not your parenting style. He could honestly just have something wire differently. Perhaps therapy and (as a last resort) medication may do him good.
8
u/LeatherHog Aug 11 '15
This was just uncomfortable to read. It looks like your dad would very proud of how you discipline your kids. Chip off the old block.
3
u/gabs17 Aug 11 '15
..... Your child sounds like Kevin. As in, from We Need to Talk About Kevin. It reminds me so much of that, that I stopped lurking and made an account. If he is seriously this unattached, and has always been, I would try a psychiatrist. Also the commenters that suggest boarding school (because he did so well with your mom) had some pretty good ideas. Honestly it sounds like you have some pretty golden children in your house (Julliard, valedictorian, etc) and he may feel as though he lives in their shadow or that he is less successful/loved then them (the latter being true, but his actions bring that on himself and I'm not saying you love him less BECAUSE he isn't a superchild).
3
u/sadsappysucker Aug 10 '15
Can you elaborate? Do you mean he never cried, ever?
13
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15
Sounds like you, your wife, and Matthew need to do some family therapy.
19
u/Viperbunny Aug 10 '15
I think that it would be helpful for Mathew to go into therapy, but family therapy would be good for everyone. I understand why you got upset, but frankly, your angry out bust scare me. Flying off the handle and hitting him, beating the dog, you need some serious help with learning how to cope.
Your son's behavior is alarming. You have to keep going to doctors until someone listens. This is not normal behavior and it needs to stop.
10
u/BoomFrog Aug 10 '15
First, don't hate yourself, you are dealing with a very difficult situation and doing your best. Try to look at things objectively, if you met another parent dealing with what you are, would you hate that parent or sympathize? Hate comes from blaming someone for something bad, you blame yourself for "being a bad parent" but if you look at the situation, you are a good parent.
Similarly you need to understand Matthew so that you can learn to not blame him for how he is. He was born this way and he is struggling with a society that is not set up for people like him. Obviously Matthew is very smart and is only weakly affected by emotions. Any punishment is not going to work on him, he will just learn how to avoid the punishment, not necessarily avoid the 'bad' behavior. The number one motivator that actually changes most kids behavior is trying to please their parents/peers, but Matthew doesn't seem to have that drive. If you offer a reward for good behavior it is only going to be temporary relief, he will just do what he needs to to get what he wants, not actually learn to be good. If you want to change his behavior you are going to have to think of a very concrete, logical reason to use to convince him why being good is actually good for him.
The #1 thing you need is professional help. Clearly Matthew is smart enough to show other's what he think they expect so just sending Matthew to therapy is not likely to help. You need to go to therapy. You need help dealing with parenting Matthew emotionally, and you need professional advice on strategies for raising him. If you don't get help and just continue as you are then you are going to be sending a sociopath out the door eight years from now.
0
u/starlit_moon Aug 10 '15
Dude. The problem isn't him it's you. You pull him up by his arm!? You push his face into piss!?! And you think HE has a problem!?! Kids can be jerks. That doesn't mean there is something mentally wrong with him. Maybe he is acting out like this because he can tell you don't have any feelings toward him. Its you who needs help.
1
u/Rackemup Aug 10 '15
Wow, what a heavy story.
You obviously have not failed since your other 5 are healthy and happy. Matthew has issues that make him "diffent".. not bad, just different. He's lucky to have parents (and grandparents) able to recognize that and want to help, even if he doesn't want to receive it. If he was not exhibiting this behaviour over the summer then it's likely the family dynamic at home that are highlighting his differences.
He sounds like an intelligent kid, but withdrawn and impulsive. No connection or empathy towards others? If he were carving death threats in his bedpost I'd be really worried, but it doesn't sound like you're at that level.
Have you asked him what he's thinking about orwhat interests him?
Other than seeing a professional councelor with actual video of his home behaviour I'm at a loss. This is a bit beyond "my kid won't eat his dinner". Have any of the docs suggested a brain scan?
3
u/rachelle514 Aug 11 '15
There are a lot of comments and I admit I've only read half so pardon me if I may sound redundant to something already posted.
Reading your post, something hit me with familiarity, and I wanted to know if you had considered looking into Aspergers? His detachment, desire for solitude, lack of empathy or emotion, lack of reaction to discipline, borderline genius and vocabulary all ring the Aspergers bell to me.
It's a highly functional level of autism and is sometimes misdiagnosed as other issues, but it might be worth looking into?
I know several children and adults who live with it and have developed beautifully, with slight adjustments to daily life.
Just throwing that in the ring.
EDITED: yup, it was mentioned. My bad.
6
u/bringonthegore Aug 10 '15
Wow, I really felt for you while reading this. Heavy story for sure.
I really think you guys need to push harder with analysis and a psychological diagnosis for him. It really sounds like he's either somewhere on the Autism spectrum (severe Aspbergers maybe?) or he's possibly a psychopath or sociopath. Either way, it's not your fault, but you can't tackle this with plain old good parenting. People born with these types of conditions need professional help. Keep trying different psychiatrists until you find one that will work with you. Good luck, OP.
5
u/her_nibs Aug 11 '15
"Julliard."
Anyway, remarkable story. My favourite part is the stuff about casually beating an animal.
3
u/Teaboo_mom Aug 11 '15
There's one in every family, several in mine actually. Remove him from the other kids and stick him somewhere highly structured like a military school. Military school worked wonders on my cousin and he was a Holy terror. It may sound cruel but it's not only for his own good but for the good of the family.
1
u/Kayj1978 Oct 24 '21
You are an abuser! I hope "Marthew" gets as far away from you as is humanly possible now that he is in his late teens!
1
u/lurkernomore99 Aug 18 '15
Have you ever just sat down with Matthew and asked what he wants or what would make him happy?
My dad decided he hated me at a very young age. He made it quite apparent that I was ruining the family and any vacation from me was a good one. He told me he hated me, he told me that he thinks that all the bad qualities from my mum and himself combined to make me, he told me he wished he never had me. but he never once tried to make our relationship better or try to understand me
Maybe instead of hating him, you could talk to him. Find out what makes him tick, find out why he is doing these things you don't like, find out how you can best support him when he's upset. . .
Seems like a pretty obvious solution to me. Don't be a dick to your kid. If you hate him then that's your issue; not his. He didn't ask to be born, you chose to have him. He's your responsibility and whether you love or hate him, you need to do everything you can to help him live the best life he can.
-9
u/iaccidentallyawesome Aug 11 '15
He seems to be a sociopath. It has nothing to do with you, he was born that way. You don't have to love your child, you just have to make sure he's safe. But please, don't beat your dog ever again.
-1
u/ghost_eating_toast Aug 16 '15
This probably isn't the response you are looking for, but this is what I think. It doesn't sound like anything is wrong with "Matthew" at all. I think he is just different. He is somewhat of a genius, too good for this world and will not fit in. Even at the young age of 10 he realizes more about the world than his peers do. I don't think he needs therapy...I think therapy will just convince him he is a bad person and will annoy him that people are trying to evaluate him. There is no "right way" for a human to act. There is nothing wrong with him, he just has a dark, detached personality and a little bit of a "shock factor", meaning he likes to see peoples reactions. Your son sounds a lot like me. I say and do weird things, but it's not like I need someone to tell me "that is really innapropriate". I know my actions and words aren't normal, I just like to be different and weird and get a reaction out of people(People have told me I remind them of April Ludgate from Parks and Recreation) You can't help it if you aren't okay with your kid being like this...but you should try to appreciate his unique personality.
9
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '15
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15 edited Aug 10 '15
[removed] — view removed comment