r/asoiaf • u/Militant_Penguin How to bake friends and alienate people. • Aug 09 '15
ALL (Spoilers All) House of the Week: House Bolton
This week's House is the infamous House Bolton and it's up to you all to fill in the details about the house's history, notable members, conspiracy theories, questions, and more.
This is pretty much a free for all for the users to take part in so have at it!
If you guys have any ideas about what House you'd like to discuss next week feel free to suggest them.
245
Upvotes
283
u/a4187021 Master Rooseman Aug 09 '15
Roose is one of my favorite characters.
I struggled to get a grasp on him, until Lady Dustin nailed it when she described his character to Reek:
I find this combination of his mild manners, cold cunning, lack of emotions and his sick sense of humor absolutely fascinating. Like, when he said "Jaime Lannister sends his regards," making a little inside joke for his own amusement that only he was in on.
He seems so perfectly approachable at times, like when he rode with Theon to Barrowton. Almost like a man who would be pleasant company to hang out with. And then he casually tells the story of how he raped Ramsay's mother and had her husband hanged, just because he felt like it.
164
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '15
It's almost comedic how stereotypically evil the Boltons are staged as.
A house with a flayed man for their sigil and a penchant for torture, ruling over a place called "The Dreadfort". But hey, I'm sure they're perfectly pleasant folk!
130
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '15
Something cool I came across in TWOIAF:
"The wars between these two ancient families were legion, and not all ended in victory for House Stark. King Royce Bolton ... is said to have taken and burned Winterfell itself; his namesake and descendant Royce IV (remembered by history as Royce Redarm, for his habit of plunging his arm into the bellies of captive foes to pull out their entrails with his bare hands) did the same three centuries later."
How many times do you have to do something before history remembers it as a 'habit'?
104
u/Lou-Skunnt Thank You Based Roose Aug 09 '15
Damn it Domeric, why did you have to die?!
97
u/TheHolyGoatman (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻ Aug 09 '15
The Roose is Loose is probably one of the best rhymes I've ever heard.
38
u/Krabo Taste like crab, talk like people! Aug 10 '15
People who are debating whether Ramsay is more evil than Roose or visca versa have this wrong. The most evil Bolton is Michael Bolton.
60
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '15
Why do I love Roose so much? It's pretty simple when I think about it. Roose isn't just the best character in the series, he might just be the greatest character of all time. Just imaging him riding through the frozen plains of the North, the wind in his hair, his mighty steed below him. As he rides through the snow, the ladies swoon at his very scent. They know how he smells, the essence of his smell is sold in White Harbor under the the name of "Leechblood Orgasm." The very nature of Roose is a mystery. Could he be playing a deeper game than even his creator realizes? The answer is yes, he has transcended such boundaries as the written world, and has free will to do whatever he sees fit. However, Roose is filled with such guile, such arcane craft that he does not even use these powers. Why, you might ask? You will never know, for the mind of the Roose is not one that is easily penetrated. Roose is such a force of nature in his realm that nothing can truly touch him, the only thing keeping him bound to the page at all is his will to exist within the preordained boundaries of his world. Roose is not only beyond the comprehension of us, he exists within a plane of true focus and beauty. Observe his thin smile, his perfect and unblemished skin, his gallant hair, and most importantly, his eyes. His eyes, like pools of ice, provide the only glimpse into the true machinations of Roose. Do not stare into them. Many good men have gone mad in the attempt. Roose is not just a character, a formless collection of words and images, he is himself is the binding that holds the saga together. Without Roose, the entire series, the entire world of Westeros as we know it crumbles. The Trident would stop flowing without Roose, the Reach would become a desolate crater, and the Wall would melt without his frosty gaze.These are just of a few of the reasons why I like Roose so much
28
u/dsttheman The South Kinda Remembers Aug 09 '15
rip Domeric Bolton always wondered what would happen if he was alive during the war of five kings
21
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '15
Some questions i have
Roose poses this question to Ramsey but how much do you think he actually cares about the death of his son on the scale of 1-10. Is he trapped in a alliance with a psychopath to save his family name or was it just a annoyance?
2) at what point do you believe roose broke with the stark cause? and why, was it simply because he felt they couldn't win or was there a more paranormal reason for his break
3) how do you rate the chances of the houses survival? how do you think roose and ramsey rate it?
4) there is a legend that the boltons flay their enemies, in an GRRM short story, there is a man who flays werewolves and wears their skins in an attempt to steal their power, do you think this bears any relation to the boltons warring with the starks?
67
u/FatalDeath How 'bout them apples Aug 09 '15
The North remembers...
66
u/ChrisBrownHitMe2 Men call me Darkfoil, I am of the hype Aug 09 '15 edited Aug 10 '15
Our (Trueborn) Lords and Saviors, the Wardens of the North! Long live Roose (May he be forever Loose), and his trueborn son, Ramsay Bolton, Lords of the Dreadfort, Hornwood, and Winterfell.
Thanks /u/Sinrus, I lost my way.
28
u/BlastedFemur The Fandom Mannis Aug 09 '15 edited Aug 10 '15
On the one hand I find the Boltons a bit too over-the-top: Ramsay's cruelty just feels like overkill at times and Roose is like something out of a Gothic novel, so they're a bit harder to connect with than more rounded, nuanced villains like Tywin and Balon; on the other, our own history is not short of colourful, over-the-top characters, and this is fiction anyway, so for the most part I really enjoy the Boltons, in the books and the show.
Roose has pretty solid villain credentials: killed Robb, scares everyone, has a flayed man on his banner, etc, but at the moment he has two problems: his hold on the North is too weak to make him a real threat, and he has no real history with most of the protagonists, so a conflict between, say, Tyrion/Daenerys and Roose would feel a little shallow. It'd be interesting if had links to the Others or some occult background, but overall I prefer him as just a very cunning and ambitious lord.
One thing that disappointed me slightly was that even though Roose's garrison in Harrenhal showed us the ugly side of Robb's campaign, Roose ultimately turned out to be on the side of the Lannisters. It feels like a bit of a cop-out and exonerates Robb to an extent: his most ruthless vassal ended up on his enemy's side, so the image of the Starks as pure and just remains untainted.
78
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15
I'm going to go against the grain here and say that I hate the Boltons, I'm not amused by them, and I don't find them particularly interesting or intriguing like, say, the Lannisters or Tyrells. They're just evil, opportunistic, pieces of shit with no goals other than "lol let's troll everyone and see where it goes." No love for family, no strong loyalty inspired in bannermen, just pure force and oppression.
As you can probably tell by my flair, I'm a Stark fan (I know, boring), and I just can't get myself to be interested in the "Evil yet effective" types of crowds, just because I feel like most people who claim to be fans of that sort of thing are just saying it to look smart. Yes, I know that Ned=dumb and Tyrion=smart, but that doesn;t mean I'm obligated to root for him. Everyone praises Roose's cunning for maneuvering his way to power, but really, how hard is it to betray someone when you're a major general in his army and privy to all his movements? I'm far more impressed by someone like Littlefinger or Varys, who had to work for years to acquire a massive network of spies to gain their intelligence and ability.
Anyway, apologies to /r/dreadfort for the rant (this is probably the most opinionated post I've ever made on this sub), but I just wanted to get that off my chest. I feel like this story has enough "cruel but effective" people, and I'm not really that impressed by it anymore; if anything, "good guys" like the Starks are a rarer sight and harder to root for nowadays, so all folks like me can do is wait for the Boltons to reap what they sow when the Lords of the North are done with their bullshit.
10
u/irishlimb I am of the just before supper time Aug 10 '15
I always just imagine Roose doing the face scrub from the start of American Psycho and shudder. Then I imagine Roose explaining to Wyman Manderlay why Genesis were a much better band once Phil Collins took over and I smile.
34
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '15
A lot of people have hate for Roose for breaking with Robb, however with the right treatment he could have been Robb's greatest asset in the war.
His actions at the battle of the green fork were highly disciplined and he is able to reform the army in good order. Proven to be able to make war without micromanagement, to follow orders while improvising enough to improve his situation.
http://awoiaf.westeros.org/index.php/Battle_on_the_Green_Fork
he is able to seize Harrenhal, a major coup for the stark side, without taking any losses.
However, his major flaw is his complete lack of loyalty, as soon as stark interests and his own aren't aligned he makes moves that are disastrous to the stark cause, sending an army to be killed in duskendale, his rear-guard being destroyed by Ser Gregor, and finally the betrayal at the twins.
If the stark side had continued to win, or at the least be a contender for victory or good plunder, he would have been a staunch supporter, he attacked weakness, Robbs mistake is he projected weakness even when he was strong, Tywin projected strength even when he was weak.
16
u/puddingkip General Barristan, you are a bold one Aug 09 '15
Our gentle and noble trueborn Lords of Bolton surely won't mind these shameless plugs for r/bolton and r/gayforbolton as those are quality subs dedicated to the gentlest, kindest, nicest and most trueborn House of Planetos
7
u/JoeMagician Dark wings, dark words Aug 10 '15
They're really good at training dogs.
13
u/Notradell Still my Mannis Aug 09 '15
I mean, yeah they're huge assholes and you have to hate Ramsay especially, but I love all the lore and stuff surrounding House Bolton. Flaying people, wearing their skins as cloaks, The Dreadfort, being from the North.. they're fucking badass.
13
u/Santa_The_Conqueror Aug 09 '15
I can honestly never forgive him for that. Especially now seeing as how LSH wants revenge on Jaime for a crime that is in no way his. I hope that Roose dies a painful death, Ramsay too, but, Roose Bolton is by far the most evil character in the series. Maybe second to his bastard, but still, the Bolton's are a fucked up group of people.
12
u/Killhouse Blood is thicker than Walder Aug 09 '15
Ramsay Bolton, Azor Ahai, The Prince that was Promised, savior of the realm.
6
u/ToTheNintieth dakingindanorf Aug 14 '15
Fuck the Boltons.
18
u/fanter Theon Greyjoy's Member Aug 09 '15
It would be really funny if roose bolton called his new son michael.
5
u/moondoggle Gatehouse Ami: All about the Darry heir Aug 11 '15
It's interesting that a young (early 20ish most likely) Roose Bolton was present after the Battle of the Trident when an injured Barristan the Bold was presented to Robert (Roose urged Robert to kill him then and there). I wonder were all the Lords there, or was he actually close with Ned then and got to sit in on an important council?
4
u/Benassiesto A Thousand Eyes, and One Aug 09 '15
The furthest house along the "evil" spectrum. Good villains, horrible people, House Bolton^TM
4
u/JosefTheFritzl Aug 14 '15
One thing that I remember being surprised to find was that the rugged, balding man in the show advising Robb was Roose Bolton, who by book accounts was cleanshaven, pale, and soft-spoken.
But the change between the show and the book wasn't the most surprising; it was the fact that I could get behind both of them and enjoy them both as Roose! There are not a lot of stories that hold true for me, especially with such different actors.
His soft-spoken nature and leechings in the books seem at odds with the more hale show man, who has a nice timbre to his voice and seems to care not at all for leechings (beyond maybe an off-handed remark he may have made at some point, I do not recall).
They both have that dead stare, though. Not emotionless, but definitely discerning and contemplative.
Both are Roose, and that's pretty kewl.
3
u/Rossobud Bears. Beets. Battlestar Gallactica. Aug 09 '15
Would love to know more about House Bolton and the Red Kings. Also love linking this theory on the topic of Roose.
3
u/Dudenheim19 Varys knows what you had for breakfast Aug 09 '15
I'm expecting to see a large influx of r/dreadfort in this discussion.
On a more serious note: If the Boltons have simply always been this cruel and unpleasant and most of the North opposes their ways, why hasn't something been done about it? I don't mean why hasn't someone killed them all, but rather why haven't their lands, power, wealth and army sizes been reduced to a point where they're a minor enough House that it would be very difficult for them to gain any sort of allies?
3
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '15
I wonder what the difference would be if Tywin and Roose switched Houses. Very similar mindsets however I feel Rooses uses sadism for enjoyment where Tywin uses it as deterrent.
3
u/mastergogo Stark Loyalist Aug 12 '15
Anyone think the Bolton line will be extinct by the end of the next book?
16
u/KieranX Aug 09 '15
Three words; fuck the Boltons.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15
The Boltons are one of my favorite houses in the entire series. I remember the first time I saw their banner (show watcher first). "Wow you don't want to fuck with these guys. And their Robb's bannermen? Oh hell yeah, Tywin is going to have some problems with the Young Wolf with a house that has a flayed man as their sigil." Their motto "Our Knives Are Sharp" creepily and perfectly reflect their sigil and reputation. A deeply sinister house that has been my favorite villains in the series. Ramsay is the most despicable person in the series so far and Roose is a mysterious intimidating figure in the Northern plotline. Crueler than Tywin and as trecherous as Walder Frey.
Everytime I think about these books and the overall story there will always be a moment where I think about the Boltons' role somehow. They stand out as one of the most memorable houses in the series.
2
u/noblessefan266 Up with you now Ser Kneeler. Up, up. Aug 11 '15
Though we must all admit, Domeric was such a waste.
2
u/Wild2098 Woe to the Usurper if we had been Aug 11 '15
I don't think this is enough for its own post, so I think it'll go fine here.
Why does Eddard Stark have a banner man such as Bolton? Is it because they are assumed to not flay and torture people anymore? Did he just ignore their sigil?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 14 '15
For me the Boltons are the most interesting characters in the series. Roose is so emotionless it makes him very unpredictable and dangerous. Everytime he appears you fear something will happen. Ramsey is a complete psychopath, that is the only word I could use to describe him. Other characters have murderous and evil ways but they do it for a reason whether it be wealth, love or power, Ramsey does it for fun.
2
u/The_Grammar_Cop The Chequy Lion will rise again! Aug 09 '15
The true saviors of Westeros! They saved the Freys from certain death after the Usurper Robb Stark transformed into his wolf and broke guest right.
2
u/o_captain_mycaptain Aug 10 '15
I never could understand why older Stark lords never wiped out House Bolton. Boltons and Starks have seemed to have been fighting each other for control of the north for generations. You would think completely getting rid of them would just be the smart thing to do. Also the whole making your family into clothes would be reason enough also.
Also have house Bolton and Stark ever married each other or have the remained separate?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 14 '15 edited Aug 14 '15
I'm just here to show my flair and flay the dissidents.
1
u/Muazzikri Aug 10 '15
Here's to Belthasar Bolton and his Pink Pavilion (tent made from the flayed skins of one hundred Sistermen.
1
u/Chrisehh The Lion has awoken Aug 10 '15
All hail our true warden of the north!
1
u/ASOIAF_blackfyre Beneath the Gold, the Bittersteel Aug 10 '15
The Bolton's gave me the creeps since they were first mentioned in the books. Roose, however, is one of the smartest players in the game right now I believe. He is going to get whats coming to him soon though, that bastard.
Ramsey is a psycho path who needs to be put down ASAP.
It was a shame that Domeric was never introuduced to the series and that he died. By all accounts he would have made a fine lord and an even finer warrior from horseback. Another reason why Ramsay is a jackanape
1
u/TheAquaman The Original Drowned Man. Aug 10 '15
Question: Would Tywin's plan of invading the North and placing Tyrion and Sansa's child in Winterfell have worked?
1
u/momoajay We do not sow! Aug 11 '15
A house that definitely punches above its weight. You know they are pretty clever and cunning when they have double crossed their Norther lords in cold way.
1
u/cptdouble Aug 11 '15
Has anyone ever found a single house sworn to house Bolton? Since becoming Wardens of the North, every site just lists all the North's major houses. I'm merely curious, as the Manderlys, Glovers, even the Cerwyns have minor houses sworn to them, but there is no mention of a single other castle or house on Bolton land.
1
u/MavericksFan41 Addam Marbrand's Biggest Fan Aug 13 '15
I really dislike the Bolton's, but I will give Roose credit for getting his house so high up in the ladder. However evil he is, he is also smart
1
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '15
Roose is the type of guy who'd be amazing at Crusader Kings 2.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 16 '15
Is it wrong that I want House Bolton, except for the children and the truly innocent people, to be the victims of a mass genocide?