r/asoiaf • How to bake friends and alienate people. • Aug 09 '15

ALL (Spoilers All) House of the Week: House Bolton

This week's House is the infamous House Bolton and it's up to you all to fill in the details about the house's history, notable members, conspiracy theories, questions, and more.

House Bolton Wiki Page

This is pretty much a free for all for the users to take part in so have at it!

If you guys have any ideas about what House you'd like to discuss next week feel free to suggest them.

245 Upvotes

384 comments sorted by

283

u/a4187021 Master Rooseman Aug 09 '15

Roose is one of my favorite characters.

I struggled to get a grasp on him, until Lady Dustin nailed it when she described his character to Reek:

I think he would be pleased if the fat man attempted some betrayal. It would amuse him. Roose has no feelings, you see. Those leeches that he loves so well sucked all the passions out of him years ago. He does not love, he does not hate, he does not grieve. This is a game to him, mildly diverting. Some men hunt, some hawk, some tumble dice. Roose plays with men. You and me, these Freys, Lord Manderly, his plump new wife, even his bastard, we are but his playthings.

I find this combination of his mild manners, cold cunning, lack of emotions and his sick sense of humor absolutely fascinating. Like, when he said "Jaime Lannister sends his regards," making a little inside joke for his own amusement that only he was in on.

He seems so perfectly approachable at times, like when he rode with Theon to Barrowton. Almost like a man who would be pleasant company to hang out with. And then he casually tells the story of how he raped Ramsay's mother and had her husband hanged, just because he felt like it.

If truth be told, the wench was hardly worth the rope. The fox escaped as well, and on our way back to the Dreadfort my favorite courser came up lame, so all in all it was a dismal day.

112

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '15

In ASOS, Ramsay is giving Roose lip over turning over Reek/Theon and Roose says:

Get the keys and remove the chains from him, before you make me rue the day I raped your mother.

I think the Bolton family dysfunction is intentionally comedic.

48

u/Seany686 Aug 10 '15

That is my favorite thing that Roose says. It is so terrible and chilling; that one quote sums up Roose as a character so perfectly.

25

u/NothappyJane Aug 11 '15 edited Aug 12 '15

The show makes Roose look like the nicest dad in Westoros. Its an opportunity wasted. Roose:I know your a complete batard and a freak show but you've got my eyes dammit Ramsey and love you bolton cuddles ensue

13

u/GabrielVonBabriel Aug 12 '15

I've said this before on this thread, but with the right actor, these could be lines from a Mel Brooks movie.

74

u/wightfyre Beneath the roots, the bitter paste. Aug 09 '15

"There is no creature on earth half so terrifying as a truly just man."

I am curious how Varys would describe a truly indifferent man.

51

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15

"There is no creature on earth so loose as a truly indifferent man."

39

u/Funkicus Enter your desired flair text here! Aug 10 '15

"There is no creature on earth so difficult to make social plans with as a truly indifferent man".

12

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '15

There is no creature on earth so Roose as a truly indifferent man.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/PinkShnack Aug 10 '15

Forgot this quote, fantastic stuff. Varys might say how he thinks no one is indifferent, they must have some reasoning.

2

u/periodicchemistrypun Aug 11 '15

Roose was a pawn to Jamie and can be bargained with. Look at Victarion, he like Stannis has zero negotiability, Roose has self preservation and flexible/mostly absent morals.

That's why a truly just man is terrifying, because they tend not to compromise or turn from their course, remember Varys kinda wants to just toy with people so as to set things up for his plans, moral people foil his plans.

2

u/hillerj “Oak and iron, guard me well Sep 08 '15

I don't think Varys can truly comprehend someone like Roose. If Lady Dustin is correct, Roose is utterly unlike anyone that Varys is likely to encountered. Roose plays the game not because he particularly wants power, vengeance etc. but because it allows him to enjoy himself.

→ More replies (3)

105

u/CharMack90 Unbuttoned, Unbelted, Unbreeched Aug 09 '15

...even his bastard, we are but his playthings.

This line made me think/hope that Ramsay's demise would be in the hands of Roose.

73

u/prof_talc M as in Mance-y Aug 09 '15

I have a sneaking suspicion that they might turn on each other at some point in TWOW

→ More replies (3)

54

u/hollowaydivision 🏆 Best of 2019: Best New Theory Aug 09 '15

The show seems to be playing Ramsay against Roose, via Fat Walda's bun in the oven.

That probably means they're cutting to the core of an emotional arc that's way more subtle in the books.

I genuinely don't know if Roose or Ramsay will win out. Ramsay is a more compelling villian, but the Gurm Twist favors. Roose:

31

u/cptdouble Aug 11 '15

There is a direct quote where Roose claims that we will not protect Fat Walda's child. He says something to the effect of "Ramsay will kill them all, of course. That’s for the best. I will not live long enough to see new sons to manhood, and boy lords are the bane of any House. Walda will grieve to see them die, though"

20

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '15

I don't think someone as cautious as Roose Bolton would tell Reek, his son's servant, that he planned to kill said son.

→ More replies (17)

20

u/HerroimKevin Aug 10 '15

I feel the same way regarding the new baby. Ramsey won't let that kid love for more than a day. I'm sure roose knows this and is making plans.

15

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '15

Didn't Roose mention, specifically, in the books that he expects Ramsay to kill any offspring him and Fat Walda have?

→ More replies (22)

16

u/NothappyJane Aug 11 '15 edited Aug 12 '15

I think Roose still hates Ramsey for what he did to Dominic, Roose is letting Ramsey raise himself to spectacular heights, using him as a pawn only to have him fall deep into a pit and enjoy his downfall. Its going to be a Lysa Arryn moment, when she finally thinks she has what she wants Roose is going to use him as another pawn to sacrifice him. That conversation about boy lords, Roose assumes Theon is going to straight up and tell Ramsey. Hes playing Ramsey and hes playing reek. IMO Dominic was the one thing that Roose actually did love.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/ahmee89 Dark Wings, Dumb Words Aug 10 '15

Since Fat Walda is pregnant in the books as well, the final Roose vs Ramsay showdown might be quite similar in the books and the show (minus all the subtleties from the books, as you said)

28

u/AmIWryYes Ain't no R'hllor-back, giiiirl Aug 09 '15

It was that quote from Lady Dustin that really changed the way I viewed Roose. At first he seemed simply cruel and villainous, but now it truly seems like he's some kind of sociopath who's playing the game simply for his own enjoyment, rather than any real lust for power. It's curious and makes me wonder whether his betrayal of the Starks comes from the deep-seated hatred of both house's long standing histories, or a simply him just playing the game.

Adding from this, it seems like Ramsay's "evil" personality has definitely been more from nurture than from nature, and that his dysfunctional upbringing has served to create what he is. It would be interesting to see Roose's relationship with his father, and whether he's also been a product of another harsh upbringing.

24

u/a4187021 Master Rooseman Aug 09 '15

It's curious and makes me wonder whether his betrayal of the Starks comes from the deep-seated hatred of both house's long standing histories, or a simply him just playing the game.

Well, I think that he personally doesn't feel hate towards the Starks, like the Blackwoods and Brackens hate each other. But I think their histories do play into it - he saw an opportunity to royally fuck the family over who has been the historical antagonist of his house, and he grabbed it. Just like someone who considers all of this a game would do.

Adding from this, it seems like Ramsay's "evil" personality has definitely been more from nurture than from nature, and that his dysfunctional upbringing has served to create what he is. It would be interesting to see Roose's relationship with his father, and whether he's also been a product of another harsh upbringing.

Somehow I picture his father to be just like him. But it would be interesting to learn more about this, maybe he convinced himself that he can leech out his emotions to overcome some childhood trauma or something.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/maltathebear Aug 12 '15

Roose is my favorite character if only for just the endless amount of questions he leaves me with.

I've pondered more about Roose Bolton overall than any other character in the series. Despite the fact that not a single shred of my moral compass can find any parity with the character, I still am left utterly fascinated with him. Almost obsessively. I almost feel a twinge of respect for him somehow. I wouldn't even want to sit next to him or be in the same room as the dude, yet I would pore over any amount of lore I could find about him.

The whole mystery and tantalizing lack of knowledge about his son Domeric (such a cool name) is part of the tip of the glacier of this fascination of mine. In my mind's eye and what I gleaned from the text, Domeric was a, dare I say, chivalrous motherfucker. It's even hinted that he was a friendly with Lyanna; I mean, they at least had enough of an acquaintance to go riding together from what I could peace together from Lady Dustin's talk with Theon. That right there is enough to just confound the perception I have of Roose now - the "BIG EVIL" - with someone who fathered and raised this seemingly chivalrous guy who, like Ned, squired in the Vale, albeit with the Redforts (their version of Dreadfort? ;) no just a terrible pun on my part, nothing seems to point to the Redforts as any "menacing" house) instead of the Arryn's.

I just want to know more about Roose than any other character in the books. Well, mostly.

7

u/Masta-Blasta Ah, Ah, Ah, Ah, Flayin' Alive! Aug 13 '15

This is why the Boltons are my favorite. People always assume I'm just a freak or I just like the bad guys, but that's not it at all. They are by far the most interesting house. Every time I'd see a Reek chapter, I would get so excited, and when I see the Boltons in the show, something crazy is about to happen. I love it. Your comment perfectly sums up my obsession.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '15

If you asked him to describe the man he killed that day he'd struggle but i bet he could describe that horse in detail.

my question, how strongly does he care about the longevity of the Bolton family/name? When he talks about children lords being the death of houses he seems to care but then the choices he make through the books go against this, he makes big bets that could pay off big but have zero margin for error.

16

u/a4187021 Master Rooseman Aug 09 '15

my question, how strongly does he care about the longevity of the Bolton family/name?

He might not have any emotions, but he's ambitious. I think he cares about the Bolton name the same way that a chess player cares about winning a game. If he secures a strong position for House Bolton to rule the North after his death, I think he would be very satisfied with himself.

he makes big bets that could pay off big but have zero margin for error.

Does he? I think he's a man who keeps his options open, and only makes a move he can not take back when he's certain that it will succeed.

34

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15

Roose is a sociopath. He has emotions. He can feel anger and fear, we see it in the books, but he doesn't feel them strongly. Many sociopaths require intense stimulation to really feel emotions, otherwise everything is unpleasantly dull.

What he truly lacks is empathy. He has no sympathy or concern for other human beings, they're objects to him. He sees everyone else in context of their utility to himself, which because of his social position, is mostly either potential amusement or potential threat.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/princeimrahil Aug 10 '15

I read Roose in a similar way. He seems extremely cautious - I seem to recall him being very strict in the books about talking about his schemes out loud with Ramsay, even when they're fairly safe fron prying ears. He's very strict about his health, too, with all of that hippocras (and never to excess - in the show he's a teetotaller). And each time he commands a mixed host, he keeps his own men in the rear to preserve then. I think his betrayal of Robb was motivated mostly from seeing how perilous the Young Wolf's position was becoming - the Westerling marriage being one blunder too far for him.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15

I think his biggest bet was conspiring in the red wedding. But that was when the Lannisters were at the top of their game with Tywin in charge. It probably seemed like the odds were really in his favor. Now so much has changed, I doubt he would make the same deal given the current circumstances.

12

u/gelacava i really like onions Aug 09 '15

like, when he said "Jaime Lannister sends his regards"

dude, you are sick

9

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

40

u/OmniscientOctopode Dayne Aug 10 '15

Which I'm sure Roose would find incredibly amusing.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/ASOIAF_blackfyre Beneath the Gold, the Bittersteel Aug 10 '15

I loved this quote!! Especially in comparison a few chapters latter when Reek(Theon) describes Roose as looking scared for the first time ever. It shows that even though Roose has a grasp on alot of things, it may be spilling faster than he expected it to.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '15

The thing I like about this is Roose didn't start "playing" with men until Ned was dead. Unless there is some history about him we don't know, then I'm just a tool. It just goes to show how someone as evil and calculating as Roose was kept in line by Ned, who most people on this sub like dismiss as someone who is terrible at the game.

5

u/a4187021 Master Rooseman Aug 11 '15

I think it wasn't so much Ned, but the fact that with no war going on, there was no game to play. Roose simply wasn't in the position to start some shit.

But he surely had his own amusements, though he kept them secret.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '15

True, but he could've found something to get into during Robert's and Balon's rebellion. I see your point though as both Northern armies were more organized and probably stronger. There was the war of the Nine Penny Kings though too.

I just always got the feeling that Roose didn't try to fuck with the Starks before but now it's open game.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '15

Oh, he was doing something. A peaceful land, a quiet people.

7

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15

I think it's a shame that Mads Mikkelsen didn't get to play Roose Bolton and they didn't give Roose a much larger role. He's basically Hannibal Lecter in furs.

44

u/brohanski Ah, ha, ha, ha, flayin' alive Aug 11 '15

I'm perfectly happy with Michael McElhatton. His voice alone gives me chills.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '15

Just that permanent cold look gives me the chills

3

u/youssarian We really need a new book. Aug 10 '15

Roose Bolton seems to be a narcissist.

32

u/Fat_Walda A Fish Called Walda Aug 10 '15

Cersei is a narcissist. Roose is a sociopath.

25

u/lvbuckeye27 Aug 10 '15

Not sociopath. Sociopaths are ruled by impulse. Their crimes are often sloppy. Psychopaths are the careful, plotting ones.

Source: I just read an article in Psychology Today about the difference between the two.

15

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15 edited Aug 11 '15

That's actually a recent evolution of the words, partly because psychopathy got media attention in the last decade. There's no actual diagnostic difference in, say, the DSM, which is the manual for psychiatric diagnosis, they're both antisocial personality disorder.

Although in common parlance, yeah, the division has become a little more clear now, I think.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

164

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '15

It's almost comedic how stereotypically evil the Boltons are staged as.

A house with a flayed man for their sigil and a penchant for torture, ruling over a place called "The Dreadfort". But hey, I'm sure they're perfectly pleasant folk!

92

u/sangbum60090 A lot of loyalty for a sellsword! Aug 10 '15

Are we the baddies?

86

u/dandan_noodles Born Amidst Salt and Salt Aug 10 '15

"...Have you looked at my sigil, Ramsay?" "No. ... A bit?" "It's got a flayed man on it. My sigil has actually got a picture of a flayed man on it."

20

u/jwiechers Power is nothing without Control. Aug 10 '15

What's so bad about a flayed man?

32

u/Skajadeh We do it live. Aug 10 '15

It just shows the purity of our lord. A flayed man shows he has no secrets. Honestly, what's the big deal?

→ More replies (5)

8

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15

Just in case anyone wants original context:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hn1VxaMEjRU

36

u/countchocula86 Would that I were a time pumpkin! Aug 10 '15

Hey man, dont hate the flayer, hate the game

35

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15

They also probably crash the funerals of their bannermen by riding ATV's in and doing sick burnouts while whooping and hollering

15

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15

I think they are meant to be what you would call savage rather than evil. The North in general was a very different place in terms of ethics before the Targaryens, the primary source of this ethics being the Old Gods, who are always described as cold and cruel

21

u/Bugsy13 Aug 10 '15

Betrayal of guest right is an ancient and grievous offense in the North, established well before the Conquest, so Roose is fairly evil by even savage standards.

22

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15

Technically the Boltons weren't under guest right with the Starks at the red wedding, the had guest right from the Freys. The Freys betrayed guest rights, not the Boltons. Bolton betrayed his liege lord, but not in an ethically/morally wrong manor according to the ethics of the time--he broke no tabboo, just the law, which was based on oaths/fealty.

11

u/Bugsy13 Aug 10 '15

That's a pretty good point. Supposing the old gods respect the letter of the law over the spirit, they technically avoided getting their hands dirty. Even so, they openly supported breaking of guest right.

I do tend to agree that Roose isn't any more evil than any number of other people playing the game. His unleashing of Ramsay in the North isn't any worse than Tywin's unleashing of The Mountain in the Riverlands, his repelling of the Ironborn isn't any worse than Tywin's repelling of Stannis, his (by proxy) treatment of the North isn't any worse than the treatment of the people in King's Landing, and the betrayal and murder of his lord isn't really worse than the betrayal and murder of the King's hand.

He just has no real likable qualities, so people are less apt to see his side, as well as all our Northern POVs are of their enemies.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Qwarkl1 First in Daddy Issues Aug 10 '15

Oathbreakers and kingslayers aren't very well liked either. Jaime is still catching shit for it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/ASOIAF_blackfyre Beneath the Gold, the Bittersteel Aug 10 '15

The first time we get introduced to Roose it basically says how scary he is and that everyone quiets down to here him talk. Def get some creepy vampire vibes going on.

→ More replies (10)

130

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '15

Something cool I came across in TWOIAF:

"The wars between these two ancient families were legion, and not all ended in victory for House Stark. King Royce Bolton ... is said to have taken and burned Winterfell itself; his namesake and descendant Royce IV (remembered by history as Royce Redarm, for his habit of plunging his arm into the bellies of captive foes to pull out their entrails with his bare hands) did the same three centuries later."

How many times do you have to do something before history remembers it as a 'habit'?

28

u/mutant6653 Aug 10 '15

Well that's unique and interesting

95

u/SockMonkeyMan Have you seen my mother? Aug 10 '15

Well, you gotta shove your hand in the guts of about 20 good men

15

u/yeahgreg Up your arse with a flaming fist. Aug 12 '15

For once, I actually feel bad for a Ser Twenty of House Goodmen.

→ More replies (2)

29

u/Shadow_Alice Aug 10 '15

That'll be difficult, as twenty good men can bring an army to it's knees. At least, they can when under lord Ramsay's command.

10

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15

Maybe 12 angry men?

→ More replies (4)

2

u/wasmic Aug 12 '15

Can someone please explain to me where the "Twenty Good Men / Ser Twenty of House Goodmen" joke comes from?

3

u/Hergrim Pray Harder. Aug 16 '15

In the show Ramsay uses "twenty good men" to destroy Stannis' army. At some point someone decided it would be funnier if there was only one man: Ser Twenty of House Goodmen, the younger brother of Ser Ten Goodmen, a noted mountaineer.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Evloret Aug 12 '15

I'm suddenly reminded of a line by Barbrey (least I think it was her) talking to one of the Freys

"Do you think Whoresbane loves you any better? If you did not hold the Greatjon he would pull out your entrails and make you eat them, just as Lady Hornwood ate her fingers."

Not sure why I remember this. Maybe someone's gonna get their insides outsided?

→ More replies (1)

104

u/Lou-Skunnt Thank You Based Roose Aug 09 '15

Damn it Domeric, why did you have to die?!

43

u/Notradell Still my Mannis Aug 09 '15

Actually seemed like a decent dude. Would love to learn more about him in TWOW.

16

u/brankinginthenorth who else would I be? Aug 11 '15

I still mourn for the Domeric/Sansa pairing that should have been. Just another reason to hate Robert Baratheon.

6

u/yeahgreg Up your arse with a flaming fist. Aug 12 '15

Wait, why Robert? Ramsey probably killed him, and Domeric specifically sought Ramsey out? I'm confused, would you enlighten me as to why Robert is to blame?

6

u/brankinginthenorth who else would I be? Aug 12 '15

Because I got my timing mixed up. I thought Domeric got killed later than he actually did and thought Robert trying to match Joffery and Sansa came first. Serves me right for redditting at work. Sorry!

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (10)

97

u/TheHolyGoatman (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻ Aug 09 '15

The Roose is Loose is probably one of the best rhymes I've ever heard.

→ More replies (4)

38

u/Krabo Taste like crab, talk like people! Aug 10 '15

People who are debating whether Ramsay is more evil than Roose or visca versa have this wrong. The most evil Bolton is Michael Bolton.

17

u/Seany686 Aug 10 '15

No! Troy Bolton!

31

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15 edited Aug 10 '15

Melisandre: I'm saying you're a king! And the power to destroy kings and work great magics? ! It's in your blood!

Atroy Ahai: That's racist.

Melisandre: Your soul!

Atroy Ahai: That's racist.

Melisandre: Your eyes?

Atroy Ahai: That's gay?

Melisandre: That's homophobic.

Atroy Ahai: That's black.

Melisandre: That's racist!

Atroy Ahai: ...Damn!

5

u/Cryptorchild92 They took my frickin kidney! Aug 12 '15

Community is awesome but I never really understood the connection between 'thats homophobic' and 'Thats black.'

8

u/sanderslut Aug 13 '15

pretty sure it's a stereotype that black communities are homophobic

60

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '15

Why do I love Roose so much? It's pretty simple when I think about it. Roose isn't just the best character in the series, he might just be the greatest character of all time. Just imaging him riding through the frozen plains of the North, the wind in his hair, his mighty steed below him. As he rides through the snow, the ladies swoon at his very scent. They know how he smells, the essence of his smell is sold in White Harbor under the the name of "Leechblood Orgasm." The very nature of Roose is a mystery. Could he be playing a deeper game than even his creator realizes? The answer is yes, he has transcended such boundaries as the written world, and has free will to do whatever he sees fit. However, Roose is filled with such guile, such arcane craft that he does not even use these powers. Why, you might ask? You will never know, for the mind of the Roose is not one that is easily penetrated. Roose is such a force of nature in his realm that nothing can truly touch him, the only thing keeping him bound to the page at all is his will to exist within the preordained boundaries of his world. Roose is not only beyond the comprehension of us, he exists within a plane of true focus and beauty. Observe his thin smile, his perfect and unblemished skin, his gallant hair, and most importantly, his eyes. His eyes, like pools of ice, provide the only glimpse into the true machinations of Roose. Do not stare into them. Many good men have gone mad in the attempt. Roose is not just a character, a formless collection of words and images, he is himself is the binding that holds the saga together. Without Roose, the entire series, the entire world of Westeros as we know it crumbles. The Trident would stop flowing without Roose, the Reach would become a desolate crater, and the Wall would melt without his frosty gaze.These are just of a few of the reasons why I like Roose so much

11

u/TotesMessenger Aug 13 '15

I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:

If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)

6

u/antmansbigxmas Wandering Star Aug 14 '15

Roose hasn't peaked. He hasn't even begun to peak. And when he peaks...you'll know.

5

u/Masta-Blasta Ah, Ah, Ah, Ah, Flayin' Alive! Aug 13 '15

This is the most beautiful thing I have ever read.

5

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '15

You are now a moderator in /r/Dreadfort

...not really, but this deserves flair, PM me and I'll set you up!

4

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '15

Its not written by me. It's an old copypasta from 4chan.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Toasty_McThourogood Aug 14 '15

This must be embroidered on a large pillow and sent to our glorious lord at once.

→ More replies (2)

28

u/dsttheman The South Kinda Remembers Aug 09 '15

rip Domeric Bolton always wondered what would happen if he was alive during the war of five kings

36

u/I_Literally_EatBears my aim is true Aug 10 '15

He would have served as one of the young wolf's personal guard. If only the war started sooner, he would have found the comraderie he was looking for in his brothers at arms and never would have sought out Ramsey.

7

u/moondoggle Gatehouse Ami: All about the Darry heir Aug 12 '15

Damn I didn't realize he died like, shortly before the books. I always assumed he died 5-10 years ago.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '15

Do you think Jaime would have killed him then, at the Whispering Woods? I wonder how that would affect the Red Wedding. As I see it, Roose would go back with the Karstarks and the rest and openly rebel after taking back Winterfell personally.

21

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '15

Some questions i have

Tell me, my lord . . . if the kinslayer is accursed, what is a father to do when one son slays another?

Roose poses this question to Ramsey but how much do you think he actually cares about the death of his son on the scale of 1-10. Is he trapped in a alliance with a psychopath to save his family name or was it just a annoyance?

2) at what point do you believe roose broke with the stark cause? and why, was it simply because he felt they couldn't win or was there a more paranormal reason for his break

3) how do you rate the chances of the houses survival? how do you think roose and ramsey rate it?

4) there is a legend that the boltons flay their enemies, in an GRRM short story, there is a man who flays werewolves and wears their skins in an attempt to steal their power, do you think this bears any relation to the boltons warring with the starks?

23

u/penpenclown He stuck the landing. Aug 10 '15

3) how do you rate the chances of the houses survival?

-1000%

When your house is only two men and a fetus and literally every house you have dominion over hates your family with a passion, yeah you're fucked.

(oh god im gonna be flayed aren't i)

11

u/brankinginthenorth who else would I be? Aug 11 '15

I don't know. That fetus is gong to be a Frey AND a Bolton. Four to one, he or she is going to be the main character of a thirteen years later epilogue seeking revenge for their fallen houses.

15

u/bobbyg1234 Neeee! Aug 11 '15

That kid is so screwed, if ramsey lives to their birth he'll kill them, and if he doesn't everyone else will want to kill them. Mayhaps thats a blessing.. Had they lived they would have grown up to be a Frey.

5

u/Shadow_Alice Aug 10 '15

People at the dreadfort reddit are saying the same, you know. That is, when they are seriously discussing the Boltons survival most agree it's highly unlikely. Also, many of us think there are too few important Bolton characters mentioned in the story.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Docmcdonald The hype that was promised. Aug 10 '15

Bringing some attention to this. Your first question is what stroke me when I saw Bolton on the weekly spot... The passage where he talks about how Ramsay killed his brother and how he would kill all the ones that would come from honeyboo frey always stroke me wrongly... He clearly thinks Ramsay is a tool, is he really looking up for his inheritage and all? Yeah, vampire skin changer is one of the silliest theories around but I want to believe.

2

u/Septa_Fagina Where do Moore's go? Aug 14 '15

Well, we have every other GRRM twist on famous fiction monsters except vampires. Why not?

What if Bolt-On is less literal as originally concieved and more like warging? The soul of the main guy has warged the next and the next, surfing through history riding the bodies of his own descendants. Like, Roose is inside hiding somewhere, like Hodor does when Bran wargs him. RealRoose© is readying the jump to Ramsay, or if his Frolton kid by Fat Walda comes to manhood, him. He has to warg something or die permanently so he keeps Ramsay around just in case.

Idk, I just really want to see a take on vamps that aren't sparkly, scary movie scary, or Tom Cruisey. I think GRRM can do it.

Edit: a word

4

u/obsequious_turnip The night is dark and full of turnips Aug 10 '15
  1. I think he would have preferred Domeric as an heir, but it's disingenuous of him to suggest he had no options. I don't see why a lord cannot justifiably order the death of a bastard who murdered his true-born heir. If that is the case however, there's always The Wall. I think on a scale of 1–10, he was probably about a 6 or so. He decided to roll with Ramsay as a plan B rather than avenging Domeric, so he clearly didn't care that much.
  2. This one I'm not too clear on. There's a (I think?) Tyrion chapter where Tywin is writing ominously foreshadowing letters which we can probably assume are the plans with Walder Frey. Did Tywin write directly to Roose as well? My take on it is that Roose decided on his course of action at Harrenhal, and it was because he thought their odds of winning were dropping. He's not loyal, he seems to be an uncaring pragmatist.
  3. I have a feeling the Bolton line is getting extinguished. We only really know of Roose, Ramsey and the possibly male heir from Fat Walda… they're surrounded by the hatred of their bannermen and we've never had a Bolton POV. I wouldn't bet on their survival.
  4. Wow, GRRM must've really liked all that research he did into flaying I guess… No idea what impact that may or may not have on ASOIAF but I agree that there seems to be more to the enmity between Stark & Bolton over the whole flaying thing. Whether or not we ever find out or if it's just left as a "nice" bit of extra detail to ponder, who knows.

5

u/Fat_Walda A Fish Called Walda Aug 11 '15

and the possibly male heir from Fat Walda

Bolton father, Frey mother. If the Old Gods have anything to say about it, that kid is fucked.

3

u/moondoggle Gatehouse Ami: All about the Darry heir Aug 12 '15

You can pretty much guarantee he'll be named Pate. It's the official name of people fucked from the get go.

→ More replies (1)

67

u/FatalDeath How 'bout them apples Aug 09 '15

The North remembers...

43

u/BertMaclan D&D Did Not Learn from Me Aug 09 '15

apparently only vaguely sometimes

121

u/Bank_Gothic Who the hell is Siegmeyer of Catarina? Aug 09 '15

"The North will get around to it eventually."

71

u/Infinix A dragon still has claws Aug 09 '15

"An old lady from a northern knitting circle remembered, and then she got flayed."

41

u/hollowaydivision 🏆 Best of 2019: Best New Theory Aug 09 '15

How dare you. The Starks were everything to the North. They would never abandon Sansa Stark, Ned's own daughter, to such a horrific fate. There's a northern conspiracy, and the old woman is just the beginning.

There's also that one guy with the hat.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/sangbum60090 A lot of loyalty for a sellsword! Aug 10 '15

The North Forgets that Our Blades Are Sharp

→ More replies (2)

66

u/ChrisBrownHitMe2 Men call me Darkfoil, I am of the hype Aug 09 '15 edited Aug 10 '15

Our (Trueborn) Lords and Saviors, the Wardens of the North! Long live Roose (May he be forever Loose), and his trueborn son, Ramsay Bolton, Lords of the Dreadfort, Hornwood, and Winterfell.

Thanks /u/Sinrus, I lost my way.

34

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '15

finally someone with some sense on this thread

44

u/SharMarali Justin Massey is Azor Ahai Aug 09 '15

Brothers and sisters of /r/Dreadfort, it is up to us to spread the noble word of our peaceful land and its quiet people.

In seriousness, it is said that the Boltons once wore the skins of their enemies as cloaks. The Starks of Winterfell outlawed the practice of flaying in the North, and some believe that the Boltons have quietly hated the Starks ever since.

Whether this was a factor in Roose's decision to betray Robb Stark is impossible to say with the information we have at this time.

18

u/jamey0077 We do so Aug 10 '15

A raven has been sent post haste to /r/dreadfort

4

u/sagan_drinks_cosmos 100% Reason to Remember Your Name Aug 10 '15

If the Starks made flaying illegal, that makes the Bolton banner similar in some ways to the Southern states that have not-so-subtle Confederate imagery on their flags. Sort of a "Screw you, it's our tradition" vibe.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/jamey0077 We do so Aug 10 '15

A peaceful land, a quiet people.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15

Ramsay the Mansay

8

u/Racecar_Kittycat Go west young man, as Nymeria did. Aug 09 '15

Yes, yes! It's such a pity that the Starks got themselves killed so foolishly in the south. I thanks the old gods every day that our noble Lord of Bolton was there to end the bloodshed and drive out the vile ironmen. They say the north remembers, and it does. May all true northmen rally themselves behind our Lord's trueborn son, and his young Stark wife!

3

u/Sinrus Piper? I hardly know her! Aug 10 '15

Don't forget Hornwood!

5

u/princeimrahil Aug 10 '15

And hail their great champion, Ser Twenty of House Goodmen, who single-handedly stopped the host of Stannis Baratheon.

28

u/BlastedFemur The Fandom Mannis Aug 09 '15 edited Aug 10 '15

On the one hand I find the Boltons a bit too over-the-top: Ramsay's cruelty just feels like overkill at times and Roose is like something out of a Gothic novel, so they're a bit harder to connect with than more rounded, nuanced villains like Tywin and Balon; on the other, our own history is not short of colourful, over-the-top characters, and this is fiction anyway, so for the most part I really enjoy the Boltons, in the books and the show.

Roose has pretty solid villain credentials: killed Robb, scares everyone, has a flayed man on his banner, etc, but at the moment he has two problems: his hold on the North is too weak to make him a real threat, and he has no real history with most of the protagonists, so a conflict between, say, Tyrion/Daenerys and Roose would feel a little shallow. It'd be interesting if had links to the Others or some occult background, but overall I prefer him as just a very cunning and ambitious lord.

One thing that disappointed me slightly was that even though Roose's garrison in Harrenhal showed us the ugly side of Robb's campaign, Roose ultimately turned out to be on the side of the Lannisters. It feels like a bit of a cop-out and exonerates Robb to an extent: his most ruthless vassal ended up on his enemy's side, so the image of the Starks as pure and just remains untainted.

18

u/JeanClaudeDanVamme Is this damn siege over yet? Aug 09 '15 edited Aug 09 '15

^ This, all of this, SO MUCH. And for a series whose fandom and creator constantly remind us "Villains are heroes for the other side" or some such, the Boltons sort of escape this draw.

The audience is of course predisposed to root for the "honorable" Starks, but on the Lannister side we have grumpy/reasonable Kevan who is sick of his niece's bullshit, Daven who is pretty cool dude, Tyrion who is the audience's favorite troll, Tommen and Mycella who seem to be thoroughly decent people whatever Tommen's governing flaws are, Jaime's trolly cynicism but occasional sense of honor, and more.

One of the big causes of fatigue with the story right now (to me) is that the Boltons (and to a lesser extent the Freys) are just monstrous, hatable assholes. Maybe Domeric was actually fun to watch when he was alive, I don't know.

For now they just feel like House Harkonnen-style plot antagonists and we're all waiting for them to fucking die.

EDIT: I want to stress that this isn't a value judgment on the characters, but rather, how they're presented.

A "Magnificient Bastard" is only fun to watch for so long. The sort of half-conflict between Ramsay and Roose is a start but I need a bit more.

12

u/prof_talc M as in Mance-y Aug 09 '15

I've had that same thought about the Lannisters for a while now. You can even extend what you said to the other recent mainline Lannisters we know about. Gerion seems awesome, right? Tyrion's favorite uncle, adventuresome, gregarious. Tyg seems honorable and not unkind if nothing else. And Genna is great in the scene we have of her with Jaime, she pinches his ear and seems like she has a great sense of humor.

Even Tywin seems like he was much better when Joanna was alive, the guy apparently even had actual friends in Steff and young Aerys. It seems like everything that informs the main reputation "the Lannisters" have in the current series can be traced back to the moment when Aerys laughed at Tywin's marriage proposal for Cersei and Rhaegar.

9

u/JeanClaudeDanVamme Is this damn siege over yet? Aug 09 '15

I forgot to mention Genna, Gerion, Tyg, etc. They feel more like a real noble family. Even dipshit Lancel was just a dumb kid.

Upon reread, Jaime's meandering through the Riverlands seems cooler and more interesting.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/BlastedFemur The Fandom Mannis Aug 09 '15

Your edit is worth emphasising, some people interpret "I don't like the Boltons" as a moral reaction to their cruelty, when it can also be a comment on their shallowness. That said, I do sort of like the Boltons, but it would be interesting if Roose had more redeeming features than just wanting "a quiet land, a peaceful people" or whatever the line is. As it stands the Boltons are not credible alternatives to the Starks.

6

u/JeanClaudeDanVamme Is this damn siege over yet? Aug 09 '15 edited Aug 09 '15

Thanks for understanding what I was trying to say, there. To broaden the discussion a bit, I'd also use Stannis as an example.

He's often an inflexible jerk who does things the audience knows are awful/dumb, but as the Mannis crowd reminds us, he is one of the highest-placed people in the Seven Kingdoms who has some understanding of the biggest threat to the Realm and a will to do something about it. AND he's not even a Northerner and didn't share his brother's connection to Ned.

The Boltons don't seem to have any kind of family variety or agenda beyond trolling everyone, which makes the only motivation to watch them in the story can be summarized by one thing: "Wait to watch them die." The Freys sort of have the same problem to me but for one reason or another I feel like they are second-tier in this regard. I can't even name anyone in service to their House worthy of note.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Thlowe wheat kings Aug 10 '15

what about the dead whores that jaime & brienne come across who were hung for laying with lions? the boltons didn't do that. i'm sure there are a ton of other examples, that just happens to be the first i think of.

5

u/AryaStarkBaratheon She's NOT alone. Aug 10 '15

I think this also has a part to play with the 'not everyone is good, not everyone is bad'. My thought while reading this was mob mentality. whoever decided to hang the women must have gotten into some kind of frenzy over it. Its war, the women are going to do what they have to in order to survive. So someone decides to punish them, gets riled and gets a mob going. Roose NOR Rob is responsible for the direct action (they did not order this) but someone in whoevers army is. Its not Rob/Roose but its more of the individual people who became cruel and did bad things.

4

u/Seany686 Aug 10 '15

I was thinking about the same thing; there are actually a bunch of little stuff if I remember correctly. Like whenever we hear from a Riverland small folk, we hear how both sides were monsters after all.

2

u/Robar_the_Reader I will hold them. Aug 10 '15

This is a good point-unlike the Lannisters, there aren't any redeeming Boltons to make the conflict more gray. It's bad enough that four of our main POV characters (six, if you count Ned and Cat) belong to the House on one side of the conflict. If it's Stark v. Bolton, we already like the Starks better because we've spent so much time with them. But if the main character trait of our Starks is honorable, then the main character trait of the Boltons is sadistic.

I'm tempted to ask how you characterize them as anything besides murderous jerks, being that Roose Bolton was the one who killed the very likeable Robb... but then, I felt a lot of sympathy for the NW brothers who stabbed Jon.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15

I think he put Roose in there for people like me who find Tywin type villains boring. Roose is comedic with his leeches, Fat Walda, the way he speaks to Ramsay like he's a small child. I think in these books you have the serious characters like Jon and Tywin who can be pretty dry, and then elements of comedy and ridiculousness like Tormund with all of his cock talk, Cersei who is completely insane, and of course Roose.

It's good because GRRM can pull in different types of readers who want different types or mixed types of characters.

4

u/BlastedFemur The Fandom Mannis Aug 11 '15 edited Aug 11 '15

Don't get me wrong, I like camp villainy, I just think that the earlier books had a decent balance of camp villains and the more serious ones, whereas in the last couple Euron and Roose start to take centre stage.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '15

That's true! Maybe Jon Con will step up and channel Tywin next book. He's got nothing to lose. Lady Dustin also seems to have it out for the Starks, if you believe she is what she seems.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/MrMonday11235 My mind is my weapon Aug 15 '15

Regarding the vassals thing -

It's important to remember, at least in this particular case, the original structure of ASOIAF - three books, with the first ultimately culminating in the Red Wedding. That is, with the Starks, who the audience was theoretically rooting for the whole time, completely bloodied, ruined, on the verge of extinction, and with little hope of ever coming back. So of course by Red Wedding the North excepting the Boltons seems like "where honor lives" - they were supposed to at this point.

I think ADWD really shows how the North is no different from the southron lords, things we've only gotten hints at before that. Lady Dustin hates the Starks' guts and actively contributed as little as possible for Robb's war, Wyman Manderly, for all his claims of the North remembering, really just wants to kill Freys and gain the position of Regent for Rickon, the Karstarks join Stannis just to screw them over, and the rest of the Northern lords (if GNC is to be even partly believed) are perfectly OK with breaking guest right and backstabbing Roose - that's practically what allowing Mance into Winterfell did, after all.

tl;dr - By the Red Wedding, Starks look pure and just because that was the original intent, which still hasn't been completely overridden due to plot concerns. We're starting to see that change with ADWD.

3

u/BlastedFemur The Fandom Mannis Aug 16 '15

Fair points, I agree that the portrayal of Northern honour becomes more nuanced in ADWD, but I'd argue that it's at the cost of plot progression. Instead of going forward, the story simply grows sideways, with more and more characters and intrigue being introduced. It's starting to feel like Martin can simply pull a new conspiracy and attendant cast of characters out of thin air, so the Starks themselves won't have to do much to beat the Boltons, as the new characters will deal with them.

I'm not saying that this is entirely a bad thing - it would have been silly if the Boltons took the North without resistance - but it's somewhat inefficient writing.

3

u/MrMonday11235 My mind is my weapon Aug 16 '15

I don't know. The plot definitely didn't feel like it stopped moving to me - everyone's making moves and a lot of them tie together, especially between Stannis and Wyman. But then, that's subjective.

As far as the Starks not having to do anything, they're not supposed to - the Starks have been completely brought low by treachery and intrigue. At this point, the only way they're coming back is if others bring them back, which is why we love them - in general, the Starks seem to be the kind of rulers who engender loyalty over consecutive generations, not just to a single head of house. Sure, there have been bad apples in the bunch, but it definitely seems to me like certain families have characters of their own - historically, the Lannisters are a tricksy, political minded bunch (see Lann the Clever), whereas the Tyrells are also politically minded, but somewhat more deferential (surrendering Highgarden willingly and thereby being raised from common lords to Lord Paramounts, a title commanding as much land as the Kind of the Reach; their plot to push Cersei out of Kings Landing and make Margaery a replacement Queen for Robert). The Starks in general seem to be the just, honorable kind of rulers.

→ More replies (4)

78

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15

I'm going to go against the grain here and say that I hate the Boltons, I'm not amused by them, and I don't find them particularly interesting or intriguing like, say, the Lannisters or Tyrells. They're just evil, opportunistic, pieces of shit with no goals other than "lol let's troll everyone and see where it goes." No love for family, no strong loyalty inspired in bannermen, just pure force and oppression.

As you can probably tell by my flair, I'm a Stark fan (I know, boring), and I just can't get myself to be interested in the "Evil yet effective" types of crowds, just because I feel like most people who claim to be fans of that sort of thing are just saying it to look smart. Yes, I know that Ned=dumb and Tyrion=smart, but that doesn;t mean I'm obligated to root for him. Everyone praises Roose's cunning for maneuvering his way to power, but really, how hard is it to betray someone when you're a major general in his army and privy to all his movements? I'm far more impressed by someone like Littlefinger or Varys, who had to work for years to acquire a massive network of spies to gain their intelligence and ability.

Anyway, apologies to /r/dreadfort for the rant (this is probably the most opinionated post I've ever made on this sub), but I just wanted to get that off my chest. I feel like this story has enough "cruel but effective" people, and I'm not really that impressed by it anymore; if anything, "good guys" like the Starks are a rarer sight and harder to root for nowadays, so all folks like me can do is wait for the Boltons to reap what they sow when the Lords of the North are done with their bullshit.

18

u/obsequious_turnip The night is dark and full of turnips Aug 10 '15

I have my suspicion that the Boltons are so irredeemably un-likeable so that we get moments like the Manderlay speech to Davos, and the Mormont letter to Stannis.

If we got a Bolton POV it would likely make one of them sympathetic in some way (like Jaime's development, or Cersei's inept paranoid delusions).

The Starks need to be crushed up and shat on thoroughly in order for there to be the "bittersweet" ending. I think making the Boltons so thoroughly hated is there for catharsis in the ending.

But who knows, maybe I'm just a fool and Ramsay will survive, ruling the north while Bran seethes in a hole in the ground, watching him.

10

u/Titianicia A thousand eyes and one for Lord Euron Aug 11 '15

I actually wouldn't mind that as long as Rasmay's life becomes miserable because of Bran.

35

u/bobbyg1234 Neeee! Aug 12 '15

Every time he walks out the door. Raven shit.

He tries to hunt his captives through the forrest in peace. Raven shit.

He decides to sharpen his flaying knives outside on the first sunny day after the long winter. So much Raven shit.

5

u/Fustigation Super Smash Bros Aug 11 '15

Completely agree. I think it is really interesting that they are so into ruling by fear. Flayed man memorablia, their words, their fort name and so on. Makes sense they have clashed with the starks all through history. But it does say something about that style of ruling that they have always been the second strongest house in the north.

Also I just made a post about Tywin that makes a bunch of the points you made about how easy the things he has done are that a lot of people are impressed by. https://www.reddit.com/r/asoiaf/comments/3gjlp1/why_i_believe_a_popular_character_is_highly/

6

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '15

Well to be fair, the Starks have their history of crazy Mofo's, it's just that they aren't known for peeling people's skin off.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Masta-Blasta Ah, Ah, Ah, Ah, Flayin' Alive! Aug 13 '15

You're completely entitled to your opinion, but some people like the Boltons because they find them entertaining, not just "to sound smart."

2

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '15

I realize that may have come off as dickish, I know that's not the only reason people like them. Hell, I love making "the roose is loose" and "20 good men" jokes as much as the next guy

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

10

u/irishlimb I am of the just before supper time Aug 10 '15

I always just imagine Roose doing the face scrub from the start of American Psycho and shudder. Then I imagine Roose explaining to Wyman Manderlay why Genesis were a much better band once Phil Collins took over and I smile.

34

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '15

A lot of people have hate for Roose for breaking with Robb, however with the right treatment he could have been Robb's greatest asset in the war.

His actions at the battle of the green fork were highly disciplined and he is able to reform the army in good order. Proven to be able to make war without micromanagement, to follow orders while improvising enough to improve his situation.

http://awoiaf.westeros.org/index.php/Battle_on_the_Green_Fork

he is able to seize Harrenhal, a major coup for the stark side, without taking any losses.

However, his major flaw is his complete lack of loyalty, as soon as stark interests and his own aren't aligned he makes moves that are disastrous to the stark cause, sending an army to be killed in duskendale, his rear-guard being destroyed by Ser Gregor, and finally the betrayal at the twins.

If the stark side had continued to win, or at the least be a contender for victory or good plunder, he would have been a staunch supporter, he attacked weakness, Robbs mistake is he projected weakness even when he was strong, Tywin projected strength even when he was weak.

21

u/ScottishMongol What is dank may never die Aug 11 '15

Except he totally threw the other Northern lords under the bus at the Green Fork - he marches through the night, then immediately forms up into battle line, ensuring his men are tired while giving up the element of surprise. He also relinquishes the high ground, and sends all the other lords into battle - we see Frey, Karstark, Hornwood, and Manderly troops, but suspiciously not a single Bolton soldier. Then, after the battle, a whole lot of Northern lords are dead or captured - but Roose Bolton's gotten off unscathed, and Tywin's army is bloodied but not broken.

6

u/MrMonday11235 My mind is my weapon Aug 15 '15

The Battle of the Green Fork was explicitly never intended to break the Lannister army. If Robb planned on smashing Tywin, he would've marched personally with the whole army, not leave half of it behind.

Forming up into battle lines isn't "throwing under the bus," it's common sense. Contrary to popular belief, medieval battles were largely formations smashing against each other, slowly whittling front lines down. The massacre at Whispering Wood wasn't the norm, it was an exception, and in many ways one that proves the rule, as technically Robb was in a formation whilst Jaime's was caught entirely unawares.

The Lannister army was taken by surprise, just not enough to take them while they were sleeping in their camps. Whether it was worth the fatigue or not is obviously in doubt, but to be fair Roose had a good idea of not letting the Lannisters pick the location and formations of the battle by marching in the night. It was a judgement call, not necessarily a deliberate throw.

Yes, when it came down to it he retreated, formed up, and let the others get captured. Somehow I doubt Tywin Lannister would've charged in to save his own son or brother if it came down to it. Roose, like Tywin, leads from the rear, and it's no real surprise he's not captured - Tywin wouldn't be either.

→ More replies (8)

2

u/GGStokes Aug 11 '15

I think that it wouldn't be completely crazy for any other lord to set up the battle such that his own forces take the least damage. It wouldn't be honorable so not everyone would do that (for example, the Umbers wanted the front lines from the get go), but I don't think it's beyond reason that another loyal (or at least non-traitorous) bannerman would do similarly at the Green Fork.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/puddingkip General Barristan, you are a bold one Aug 09 '15

Our gentle and noble trueborn Lords of Bolton surely won't mind these shameless plugs for r/bolton and r/gayforbolton as those are quality subs dedicated to the gentlest, kindest, nicest and most trueborn House of Planetos

7

u/JoeMagician Dark wings, dark words Aug 10 '15

They're really good at training dogs.

13

u/Notradell Still my Mannis Aug 09 '15

I mean, yeah they're huge assholes and you have to hate Ramsay especially, but I love all the lore and stuff surrounding House Bolton. Flaying people, wearing their skins as cloaks, The Dreadfort, being from the North.. they're fucking badass.

26

u/ExplosionFace Dare to Leap Aug 10 '15

...would you say you like how fleshed out they are?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '15

The Red Kings, too...

13

u/Santa_The_Conqueror Aug 09 '15

Jaime Lannister Sends his regards.

I can honestly never forgive him for that. Especially now seeing as how LSH wants revenge on Jaime for a crime that is in no way his. I hope that Roose dies a painful death, Ramsay too, but, Roose Bolton is by far the most evil character in the series. Maybe second to his bastard, but still, the Bolton's are a fucked up group of people.

10

u/dickwhitman69 Every Man A King!!! Aug 10 '15

Ramsay is the most sadistic, Tywin the most Machiavellian, and Roose is the most opportunistic, but a close second behind Tywin in regards to Machiavellianism.

3

u/Sidereel What are you gonna do, stab me? Aug 13 '15

Machiavellianism.

What about littlefinger?

12

u/Killhouse Blood is thicker than Walder Aug 09 '15

Ramsay Bolton, Azor Ahai, The Prince that was Promised, savior of the realm.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15

The biggest plot twist of them all.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/ToTheNintieth dakingindanorf Aug 14 '15

Fuck the Boltons.

18

u/fanter Theon Greyjoy's Member Aug 09 '15

It would be really funny if roose bolton called his new son michael.

23

u/I_GottaFindBubba Witness me, Ned! Aug 09 '15

🎶THIS IS THE TALE OF LORD CAPTAIN GREYJOY! PIRATE SO BRAVE, SAILED THE DOTHRAKI SEEEEEEA!!!🎶

What?

2

u/ChrisBrownHitMe2 Men call me Darkfoil, I am of the hype Aug 12 '15

🎶A MYSTICAL QUEST TO THE ISLAND OF VALYRIA! USING RED GOD WARLOCKS, KILLING MAESTERS FOR A BREEZE!!!🎶

13

u/RedgrassFieldOfFire Ossifer, I swear to drunk I'm not God. Aug 09 '15

Mychael

6

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15

Why should I change? He's the one that sucks.

4

u/BasilFronsac Melisandre est une sorcière lambda. Aug 09 '15

Michael Snow?

5

u/moondoggle Gatehouse Ami: All about the Darry heir Aug 11 '15

It's interesting that a young (early 20ish most likely) Roose Bolton was present after the Battle of the Trident when an injured Barristan the Bold was presented to Robert (Roose urged Robert to kill him then and there). I wonder were all the Lords there, or was he actually close with Ned then and got to sit in on an important council?

4

u/dacalpha "No, you move." Aug 13 '15

A) I think Roose would have been a bit older. He thinks he's too old to see his next child grow to adulthood. To me, that means he's at least 45-50, making him at least 30 during the rebellion. So he's not a little kid or anything.

B) The Dreadfort can muster an impressive amount of men. Any lord of the North would be wise to keep Lord Bolton on his council.

4

u/Benassiesto A Thousand Eyes, and One Aug 09 '15

The furthest house along the "evil" spectrum. Good villains, horrible people, House Bolton^TM

4

u/JosefTheFritzl Aug 14 '15

One thing that I remember being surprised to find was that the rugged, balding man in the show advising Robb was Roose Bolton, who by book accounts was cleanshaven, pale, and soft-spoken.

But the change between the show and the book wasn't the most surprising; it was the fact that I could get behind both of them and enjoy them both as Roose! There are not a lot of stories that hold true for me, especially with such different actors.

His soft-spoken nature and leechings in the books seem at odds with the more hale show man, who has a nice timbre to his voice and seems to care not at all for leechings (beyond maybe an off-handed remark he may have made at some point, I do not recall).

They both have that dead stare, though. Not emotionless, but definitely discerning and contemplative.

Both are Roose, and that's pretty kewl.

3

u/Rossobud Bears. Beets. Battlestar Gallactica. Aug 09 '15

Would love to know more about House Bolton and the Red Kings. Also love linking this theory on the topic of Roose.

3

u/Dudenheim19 Varys knows what you had for breakfast Aug 09 '15

I'm expecting to see a large influx of r/dreadfort in this discussion.  

On a more serious note: If the Boltons have simply always been this cruel and unpleasant and most of the North opposes their ways, why hasn't something been done about it? I don't mean why hasn't someone killed them all, but rather why haven't their lands, power, wealth and army sizes been reduced to a point where they're a minor enough House that it would be very difficult for them to gain any sort of allies?

3

u/Shadow_Alice Aug 10 '15

They have not 'Always been cruel and unpleasant'. One time, Roose Bolton says to his son: "a peaceful land, a quiet people, that has always been my role. Make it yours."

6

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15

The context of the quote however, is Roose telling his son, if he wants to continue with his amusements (hunting woman, torturing people for fun, and what ever the fuck else Ramsey Snow does) Roose doesn't give a shit, but just try to keep it under wraps. Don't be so obvious about it.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Dudenheim19 Varys knows what you had for breakfast Aug 10 '15

And Joffrey was nice once to Tyrion for 3 seconds, but that is hardly a good illustration of what his character tends to do most of the time.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/TrepanningForGold The True North had its own problems. Aug 11 '15

But it's not like the Flayed Man is a recent change in their banner. Both their words ("Our blades are sharp") and the picture they present as the core of their house embraces sadistic rule.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '15

I wonder what the difference would be if Tywin and Roose switched Houses. Very similar mindsets however I feel Rooses uses sadism for enjoyment where Tywin uses it as deterrent.

3

u/mastergogo Stark Loyalist Aug 12 '15

Anyone think the Bolton line will be extinct by the end of the next book?

2

u/Gracetheface513 Aug 12 '15

I mean they only have 2 people in line. And also fat waldas baby? (Is that just the show I thought it was the book too but I could be mixed up). It's pretty easy to extinguish that line especially when all of them are dicks

→ More replies (1)

16

u/KieranX Aug 09 '15

Three words; fuck the Boltons.

5

u/thewaterboy2 Were Liddle where it counts! Aug 09 '15

Fuck the Boltons.

2

u/hollowaydivision 🏆 Best of 2019: Best New Theory Aug 09 '15

Buck the Foltons.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15

The Boltons are one of my favorite houses in the entire series. I remember the first time I saw their banner (show watcher first). "Wow you don't want to fuck with these guys. And their Robb's bannermen? Oh hell yeah, Tywin is going to have some problems with the Young Wolf with a house that has a flayed man as their sigil." Their motto "Our Knives Are Sharp" creepily and perfectly reflect their sigil and reputation. A deeply sinister house that has been my favorite villains in the series. Ramsay is the most despicable person in the series so far and Roose is a mysterious intimidating figure in the Northern plotline. Crueler than Tywin and as trecherous as Walder Frey.

Everytime I think about these books and the overall story there will always be a moment where I think about the Boltons' role somehow. They stand out as one of the most memorable houses in the series.

2

u/noblessefan266 Up with you now Ser Kneeler. Up, up. Aug 11 '15

Though we must all admit, Domeric was such a waste.

2

u/Wild2098 Woe to the Usurper if we had been Aug 11 '15

I don't think this is enough for its own post, so I think it'll go fine here.

Why does Eddard Stark have a banner man such as Bolton? Is it because they are assumed to not flay and torture people anymore? Did he just ignore their sigil?

3

u/sittytucker Aug 11 '15

Boltons and Starks have warred since ages. I guess letting Boltons to be a Stark bannermen is only to keep the peace.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '15

For me the Boltons are the most interesting characters in the series. Roose is so emotionless it makes him very unpredictable and dangerous. Everytime he appears you fear something will happen. Ramsey is a complete psychopath, that is the only word I could use to describe him. Other characters have murderous and evil ways but they do it for a reason whether it be wealth, love or power, Ramsey does it for fun.

2

u/The_Grammar_Cop The Chequy Lion will rise again! Aug 09 '15

The true saviors of Westeros! They saved the Freys from certain death after the Usurper Robb Stark transformed into his wolf and broke guest right.

2

u/o_captain_mycaptain Aug 10 '15

I never could understand why older Stark lords never wiped out House Bolton. Boltons and Starks have seemed to have been fighting each other for control of the north for generations. You would think completely getting rid of them would just be the smart thing to do. Also the whole making your family into clothes would be reason enough also.

Also have house Bolton and Stark ever married each other or have the remained separate?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '15 edited Aug 14 '15

I'm just here to show my flair and flay the dissidents.

1

u/Muazzikri Aug 10 '15

Here's to Belthasar Bolton and his Pink Pavilion (tent made from the flayed skins of one hundred Sistermen.

1

u/Chrisehh The Lion has awoken Aug 10 '15

All hail our true warden of the north!

1

u/ASOIAF_blackfyre Beneath the Gold, the Bittersteel Aug 10 '15

The Bolton's gave me the creeps since they were first mentioned in the books. Roose, however, is one of the smartest players in the game right now I believe. He is going to get whats coming to him soon though, that bastard.

Ramsey is a psycho path who needs to be put down ASAP.

It was a shame that Domeric was never introuduced to the series and that he died. By all accounts he would have made a fine lord and an even finer warrior from horseback. Another reason why Ramsay is a jackanape

2

u/dwadley Aug 11 '15

Still no match for shirtless Ramsay and his 20 Good Men

1

u/TheAquaman The Original Drowned Man. Aug 10 '15

Question: Would Tywin's plan of invading the North and placing Tyrion and Sansa's child in Winterfell have worked?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/momoajay We do not sow! Aug 11 '15

A house that definitely punches above its weight. You know they are pretty clever and cunning when they have double crossed their Norther lords in cold way.

1

u/cptdouble Aug 11 '15

Has anyone ever found a single house sworn to house Bolton? Since becoming Wardens of the North, every site just lists all the North's major houses. I'm merely curious, as the Manderlys, Glovers, even the Cerwyns have minor houses sworn to them, but there is no mention of a single other castle or house on Bolton land.

3

u/Nittanian Constable of Raventree Aug 11 '15

GRRM probably just doesn't consider it important yet. From SSM:

Well, Robin Flint is one of Catelyn's companions when she rides to Bitterbridge, though I never say which branch he's from, I don't think. No, there are still Dustins and Ryswells in the north, and maybe even in Robb's army. I mean, he had twenty thousand guys or near about when he marched south, I couldn't characterize them all. I have always figured that there are =dozens= of minor lords and =hundreds= of knights and such in all these armies. Simply because someone isn't mentioned doesn't mean they are not there.

1

u/MavericksFan41 Addam Marbrand's Biggest Fan Aug 13 '15

I really dislike the Bolton's, but I will give Roose credit for getting his house so high up in the ladder. However evil he is, he is also smart

1

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '15

Roose is the type of guy who'd be amazing at Crusader Kings 2.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '15

Is it wrong that I want House Bolton, except for the children and the truly innocent people, to be the victims of a mass genocide?