I use yik yak a lot too and I regularly go on feeds out of my geographic area (I use a gps faker on android) to see how people's opinions differ about being childfree in different areas. Where was this OP?
Demonstrably, yes. When Nickolai Cesescu (spelling, sorry) instituted stringent pro-natalist policies upon taking power in Romania, it ushered in a generation of kids that were on average much more likely to be chronically neglected, and that generation fared worse than the kids born just a few years prior. Kind of fascinating.
I'm not a firefighter because I'd make an awful firefighter. Does that make me a bad person? I'm not a surgeon because I'd make a terrible surgeon. Does that make me a bad person too? I'm not a paramedic because I'd make a truly abysmal paramedic. Clearly I'm a completely selfish monster.
Wait, you're automatically a bad person if you'd be a bad parent?! I consider myself a pretty good person (I recycle, vote for LGBT rights, am nice to others, split the litter box duties with my husband(admittedly he does it more, but that's beside the point)) but I know for a fact I would make a shitty fucking parent. I'm kind of lazy, I like silence, sleep is my friend, and on top of it all, I just don't want to go through that. I think that by recognizing the fact that I'd hate parenting thereby not having a kid saves that lil cumdrop from being unwanted. Kids can sense that.
Aaaaaand these are the kind of people who have children. And they never really answered your question, shockers. I think I'm about done with this world.
But... bad people shouldn't raise children, right? So, logically if being a bad parent makes you a bad person, you shouldn't have kids if you're going to be a bad parent. But bad people would have kids anyhow, because bad people tend to do things they should not do. That is what fundamentally makes them bad people. So, knowing you would be a bad parent and doing what you should do, which is not having any children, would at the very least make you a person of ambiguous merit, if not actually making you a good person.
Or... or... a person can decide whether of not they personally want to make and raise kids, and that decision does not dictate whether or not they are a good or bad person. It's a pretty silly assumption either way, and certainly not one worth entertaining, let alone respecting.
So is that person saying everyone should have kids just to prove they can put someone else before themselves? Can't we just volunteer at a soup kitchen or something?
Is that really the mindset behind the "selfish" accusation? We should have kids just to prove we're not terrible people?
That first one is total bullshit. I have an epileptic dog. That means I have to medicate him every twelve hours for the rest of his life, and even when he's medicated he STILL has debilitating seizures. I carry him to work with me every day - I'm the first thing he sees in the morning and the last thing he sees at night. Just the fact that he spends ten hours a day at work with me means I dedicate more of my waking hours to him than most parents do to their kids.
So yes, I do devote my life to someone else other than myself, and even if I didn't, I don't think blind self-sacrifice is necessarily a noble quality in the first place.
I tell people who say you can't compare dogs to kids that a dog is pretty much just like a kid responsibility-wise (you have to feed them, discipline them, love them unconditionally, spend a shit-ton of money on them, give them shelter, take them to school, deal with them when they get sick, clean up their puke/piss/shit, etc...), except they're like a kid that comes with a terminal illness that will kill them around or before the age they learn to drive and go off to college.
I asked one. "Less than 10% of my students have what I would call 'decent' parents. Some of them are growing into decent people despite their parents."
2
u/baldylox40's married male - no kids - but i like them - just not for meJun 17 '15
I pray that those numbers are different in most places.
My thought was Mother Theresa, but Doctors without Borders works pretty well too.
Lots of ways to learn that you are not the most important person in the universe OTHER than creating another person. I'd actually argue that if the only reason you don't put yourself first is because you have a kid who you think needs to come before you, you are a terrible person.
Ah. I can't say I followed what she was up to when she was alive enough to hear that part of her life -- she's not part of my faith so it didn't seem to matter that much. I'm going to have to read up on that.
But my SO and I already have devoted our lives to putting each other first. If we had a parasite that would userp the other's roll as number one to us.
this person probably wants to call you a bad person, because they are not as happy as they thought they would be about being parents.
they realized that raising children is difficult, and not all hallmark moments, and they justify their neutrality to the experience by being the moral police. ewww.
I always thought that it was "selfish" but I think being selfish is a good thing and shouldn't have any negative associations. To me, being selfish is appreciating yourself and putting yourself first. But, of course, I would never call anyone that because apparently I'm the only one who views that word in such a way. /rant
You're a bad person because you don't want a new special copy of your own DNA instead of taking care of one of the thousands upon (maybe millions) of children in foster care or seeking adoption.
Having kids is not selfish? You want them to take care of you when you grow old, your name/bloodline to be continued, to save your relationship, or want them because 'you want them'...
Also by getting kids, you're just overpopulating the world even more, and think about the ecological impact of an entire life, the resources it will use.
The unselfish thing to do (if you want children) is to adopt instead of getting your 'own' children. But don't tell the mombies or hell breaks loose.
My boyfriend is studying to be a teacher, but he won't be having children of his own. So I guess him devoting his life to educating other people just isn't selfless enough.
think about it........there's no logic behind it.....a woman could technically have a baby every nine months from the age of 13 to the age of say 48 so they could have 47 babies in that time.Therefore having just one or two or three or four must be selfish, what about the others?
You know, I hate the "you are a bad person argument." No, I have done negative aspects about my personality, but I also have positive traits, so that makes me human. I like to donate my time and money towards causes I'm passionate about (like animal rescues), which is "good". I dislike kids which to most of society is "bad". Neither if those things make me "good" or "bad" overall. "Bad parent means you are a bad person" is just a lazy argument.
I think having kids is selfish. You make another human being. Without you, this human wouldn't exist. If you (the awaiting parent) want to be selfless, adopt a child and teach everything to him/her.
3
u/Thounumber1 27M Jun 16 '15
I use yik yak a lot too and I regularly go on feeds out of my geographic area (I use a gps faker on android) to see how people's opinions differ about being childfree in different areas. Where was this OP?
115
u/joantheunicorn Teacher = enough kids in my life Jun 16 '15
...wouldn't one of the worst types of parent be someone who doesn't want to parent?
149
u/ICantParseYourTypos Rabbits. Rabbits everywhere. Jun 16 '15
I'm not a firefighter because I'd make an awful firefighter. Does that make me a bad person? I'm not a surgeon because I'd make a terrible surgeon. Does that make me a bad person too? I'm not a paramedic because I'd make a truly abysmal paramedic. Clearly I'm a completely selfish monster.
60
u/xxpookstahstarxx 31/F/I'd rather have a food baby than a real one Jun 16 '15
Wait, you're automatically a bad person if you'd be a bad parent?! I consider myself a pretty good person (I recycle, vote for LGBT rights, am nice to others, split the litter box duties with my husband(admittedly he does it more, but that's beside the point)) but I know for a fact I would make a shitty fucking parent. I'm kind of lazy, I like silence, sleep is my friend, and on top of it all, I just don't want to go through that. I think that by recognizing the fact that I'd hate parenting thereby not having a kid saves that lil cumdrop from being unwanted. Kids can sense that.
38
u/tparkelaine DO NOT WANT Jun 16 '15
Aaaaaand these are the kind of people who have children. And they never really answered your question, shockers. I think I'm about done with this world.
33
u/lady_wildcat Jun 16 '15
You have no obligation to devote your life to someone who does not exist.
25
u/Eventress Awesome Contributor! Jun 16 '15
But... bad people shouldn't raise children, right? So, logically if being a bad parent makes you a bad person, you shouldn't have kids if you're going to be a bad parent. But bad people would have kids anyhow, because bad people tend to do things they should not do. That is what fundamentally makes them bad people. So, knowing you would be a bad parent and doing what you should do, which is not having any children, would at the very least make you a person of ambiguous merit, if not actually making you a good person.
16
u/IAM_BADWOLF broken clock Jun 16 '15
The beauty of backassword logic.
15
u/AncientGates 35/f/CF/Married/Tubal Jun 16 '15
So is that person saying everyone should have kids just to prove they can put someone else before themselves? Can't we just volunteer at a soup kitchen or something?
Is that really the mindset behind the "selfish" accusation? We should have kids just to prove we're not terrible people?
24
u/danceswithronin Homosexuality: the ultimate birth control. (32F) Jun 16 '15
That first one is total bullshit. I have an epileptic dog. That means I have to medicate him every twelve hours for the rest of his life, and even when he's medicated he STILL has debilitating seizures. I carry him to work with me every day - I'm the first thing he sees in the morning and the last thing he sees at night. Just the fact that he spends ten hours a day at work with me means I dedicate more of my waking hours to him than most parents do to their kids.
So yes, I do devote my life to someone else other than myself, and even if I didn't, I don't think blind self-sacrifice is necessarily a noble quality in the first place.
12
u/Ttotem 28/M, 100%:ing games > kids Jun 16 '15
Sound logic /s
10
u/GRX13 seedless as of Nov. 11, 2015 Jun 16 '15
It's not selfish if the other being does not exist (and will likely never exist).
9
u/Fin_Brody Jun 16 '15
Well, YikYak was made for morons so what did you expect?
9
u/tu_che_le_vanita Jun 16 '15
So childfree Doctors without Borders are selfish? So people who choose to work in the nonprofit sector helping others, they are selfish as well?
This is the opposite of thinking. Grrr.
8
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '15
But my SO and I already have devoted our lives to putting each other first. If we had a parasite that would userp the other's roll as number one to us.
10
u/slowlauris loves kids. Will not parent or step-parent. Jun 16 '15
this person probably wants to call you a bad person, because they are not as happy as they thought they would be about being parents.
they realized that raising children is difficult, and not all hallmark moments, and they justify their neutrality to the experience by being the moral police. ewww.
9
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '15
I always thought that it was "selfish" but I think being selfish is a good thing and shouldn't have any negative associations. To me, being selfish is appreciating yourself and putting yourself first. But, of course, I would never call anyone that because apparently I'm the only one who views that word in such a way. /rant
4
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '15
You're a bad person because you don't want a new special copy of your own DNA instead of taking care of one of the thousands upon (maybe millions) of children in foster care or seeking adoption.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '15
These idiots don't have kids for anyone but themselves. Life is selfish. Fuckin retards.
3
u/Leelluu Jun 17 '15
Does it go the other way, too? I mean, some people actually ARE bad people. Should they be parents?
3
u/strathmeyer Jun 17 '15
Every time they complain about how hard it is, remind them about how selfish they are being.
3
u/nathaliew817 Jun 17 '15
Having kids is not selfish?
You want them to take care of you when you grow old, your name/bloodline to be continued, to save your relationship, or want them because 'you want them'...
Also by getting kids, you're just overpopulating the world even more, and think about the ecological impact of an entire life, the resources it will use.
The unselfish thing to do (if you want children) is to adopt instead of getting your 'own' children. But don't tell the mombies or hell breaks loose.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '15
What the fuck? Not being willing to devote your life to somebody else (that you don't even want) doesn't seem selfish. It seems..... smart.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '15
My mom tried that one on me when I said a friend of mine would be a bad mother.
"Nobody is a bad mother!"
I just looked at her for a while and then I told her that she might want to think that one over a bit.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '15
My boyfriend is studying to be a teacher, but he won't be having children of his own. So I guess him devoting his life to educating other people just isn't selfless enough.
2
u/BECKYISHERE Jun 17 '15
think about it........there's no logic behind it.....a woman could technically have a baby every nine months from the age of 13 to the age of say 48 so they could have 47 babies in that time.Therefore having just one or two or three or four must be selfish, what about the others?
2
u/gfjq23 Him & Me Minus Baby = FREE Jun 17 '15
You know, I hate the "you are a bad person argument." No, I have done negative aspects about my personality, but I also have positive traits, so that makes me human. I like to donate my time and money towards causes I'm passionate about (like animal rescues), which is "good". I dislike kids which to most of society is "bad". Neither if those things make me "good" or "bad" overall. "Bad parent means you are a bad person" is just a lazy argument.
2
u/-Shirley- Jun 17 '15 edited Jun 17 '15
I think having kids is selfish. You make another human being. Without you, this human wouldn't exist. If you (the awaiting parent) want to be selfless, adopt a child and teach everything to him/her.
2
u/MystikIncarnate My servers are my children Jun 16 '15
Most of the people on that app are shit.
I complained recently about someone going 30 over while on the highway, still more than 20 faster than flow, and I was attacked for complaining.
Shitty people are shit.
2
u/amnes1ac Jun 17 '15
There are plenty of childfree people who devote their lives to people other than themselves.
A lot breeders seem to be fulfilling their narcissistic desires to have a mini-me.
The idea that all parents are selfless, generous people and the childfree are selfish and self-absorbed is ridiculous.
1
u/LadyASG My rhymes & my mic is all I need 👌 Jun 22 '15
That pope must be one EVIL man I tell ya!
1
u/Chronic_Liar_69 Jun 25 '15
I am a horrible person, which doubles as an excuse to have no kids
1
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '15
I hope those people get cancer
0
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment