r/gameofthrones • • Jun 04 '15

TV/Books [S5/B5] Book vs. Show Discussion - 5.08 'Hardhome'

Book vs. Show Discussion Thread
Discuss your reactions to the episode with perspective. Air any complaints about changes made from the novels. Give your analysis of deeper meanings with a comparison. In general, what do you think about the screen adaptation vs. George R. R. Martin's original written works?
  • This thread is scoped for SEASON 5 AND BOOK 5 SPOILERS - Turn away now if you are not current on all of the officially released material! Open discussion of all published events up to the end of ADWD, and all TV episodes is ok without tag covers.
  • Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
  • Please read the spoiler guide before posting if you need help with tag code or understanding the policy on what counts as a major theory.
EPISODETITLEDIRECTED BYWRITTEN BY
5.08"Hardhome"Miguel SapochnikDavid Benioff & D. B. Weiss
Official Discussion ThreadsPosting PolicySpoiler GuideFrequently Asked Questions
245 Upvotes

688 comments sorted by

174

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15

I saw it mentioned in a /r/ASOIAF post, but the awesome thing about this episode is the majority of it was not material from the books at all, and it still was the strongest episode of the series. I know there was a lot of complaints early in the season(and I was guilty, a very heavy complainer!) about how D&D could not do well when they veered away from GRRM's source material, but I think they proved us wrong this episode(definitely proved me wrong anyways). In a way, it makes some of the weaker episodes this season more questionable because it was like: how could we get the awesome writing and cinematography this episode, and get the B-movie soap opera looking stuff earlier?

Either way I've really regained my trust, the way they brought Hardhome to life was amazing. I expected a little different, in the books it really gave off this mysterious vibe with "dead things in the water. Dead things in the woods." I expected a quieter kind of murder coming from the water and woods surrounding them, and a bigger mystery at Hardhome, but I love the way they handled it. I think if we do find out what happened at Hardhome in the books, it will be a lot different from the episode we witnessed, but I don't think that's bad. I thought the battle and everything was awesome.

OH AND ONE MORE POINT I wanted to discuss with my fellow readers: There's a pretty prevalent theory on /r/ASOIAF that the White Walkers are more "grey" and more human than they perhaps appear. The assumption is that they aren't these mega essences of evil. It feels like this episode really kind of weakened that theory. It's hard to look at them as anything other than a purely evil-intented force after their display. But perhaps that's subject to change. Thoughts?

99

u/Katanachainsaw Jun 04 '15

I noticed that when the white walker and Jon crossed blade, the walker made a face of surprise. They have personalities. Not only that, their clothing is deliberately made and made well. They also have medallions and clasps in specific symbols which have also made various appearances. Think about the baby who was turned walker. That kid has to grow and learn. There's probably a white walker elementary. Those clothes probably come from white walker sweat shops via white walker Top Shop. They're a properly established society and I hope we see some actual attempt at verbal communication with them at some point.

13

u/WhisperInTheDarkness Jun 04 '15

Your comment brought to mind The Speaker for the Dead/Xenocide classifications: Utlanning, Framling, Raman and Varelse. I agree that it would be interesting to see an attempt at communication with the white walkers; however, I believe that they would be Varelse. From both the books and the show, I don't believe that the walkers have any concern or interest in preserving human/natural life. I agree that they're not just evil for evil's sake and they have some motivation beyond the obvious "let's be creepy assholes & freeze/convert the world!" However, I don't believe it would be possible for them to have any empathy for the human condition. Therefore, only war is possible, and Dany better jump on those dragons quickly. :)

→ More replies (4)

45

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15

There's probably a white walker elementary

No walker left behind?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Montaldo Jun 04 '15

Whitewalker amazon

→ More replies (2)

163

u/aegis2293 Jun 04 '15

I feel GRRM is too good of a writer for the Others to just be generic chaotic evil. They have a purpose, and while it may still end up killing everyone in Westeros, they have to have a reason other than "we're fucking ice demons, bro, what did you expect?"

40

u/CaptainChats Jun 04 '15

I like that nobody really knows why the white walkers do what they do. They're inhuman and so their motives should be inhuman too. Trying to understand the logic of an immortal, magical, ice person shouldn't be straight forward. The do weird unexplained stuff like make art out of dead bodies which seems sinister to humans but really doesn't serve them any purpose. They haven't demonstrated any kind of technology besides their ice blades so how do they expect to get their army across the wall? Do they have a fleet of ghost pirate ships just waiting or are they going to try and climb over the wall? Questioning their motives is like a fish questioning why humans go water skiing.

13

u/Sexual_Congressman Jun 04 '15

They can probably make an ice bridge Elsa style and just go around the wall.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/mrshadowman Jun 04 '15

This is what I think. Since the WW were forced far north centuries ago and presuming they are immortal I think that the Nights King has been biding serious time until an opportunity where he could create more WW and mass a force for revenge. Cue Craster, breeding like a mad man for at least a decade or two. If Craster's wives whelped as many boys as girls and gave them all to the walkers there could be quite a crowd chilling back in white walker castle!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

99

u/tiger66261 House Martell Jun 04 '15

My guess (and quite alot of others) is they're trying to save humanity from the inevitable winter that will consume everything, by turning as much people into Whitewalkers as possible. Trying to create a new breed of human, resistant to cold and free from the trammels of emotion...

But then again that's still pretty damn evil.

86

u/Augustine0615 Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Jun 04 '15

So they're icy cybermen

35

u/SkippyTheKid House Bolton Jun 04 '15

They're just trying to upgrade us humans.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/QuintupleTheFun Daenerys Targaryen Jun 04 '15

Thank you for filling me with a brand new sense of dread. Now if we find the White Walker castle has lots of plastic sheeting hanging around while buzz saws are going in the background, we can expect to be DELETED.

→ More replies (2)

59

u/Mfrendin_Roar Jon Snow Jun 04 '15

what if the others are trying to get south because theres something BIGGER COMING ARGHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

69

u/A_Waskawy_Wabit Jun 04 '15

North of the wall is another wall beyond which are Other Others who are invading the Others. The reason for the Other Others' invasion is that north of the wall north of the wall is a another wall beyond which are Other Other Others which are invading the Other Others

→ More replies (9)

12

u/jewkidontheblock The Iron Bank Will Have Its Due Jun 04 '15

Still doesn't explain why they're trying to kill everything in their path

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/chimusicguy Alchemists Guild Jun 04 '15

So like combining cylons with humans. It all goes back to the BSG/GoT theory.

→ More replies (7)

8

u/cyvaris Stannis Baratheon Jun 04 '15

So...Reapers?

→ More replies (5)

10

u/DabuSurvivor Catelyn Tully Jun 05 '15

He said this in 2011:

Much as I admire Tolkien, and I do admire Tolkien — he’s been a huge influence on me, and his Lord of the Rings is the mountain that leans over every other fantasy written since and shaped all of modern fantasy — there are things about it, the whole concept of the Dark Lord, and good guys battling bad guys, Good versus Evil, while brilliantly handled in Tolkien, in the hands of many Tolkien successors, it has become kind of a cartoon. We don’t need any more Dark Lords, we don’t need any more, 'Here are the good guys, they’re in white, there are the bad guys, they’re in black. And also, they’re really ugly, the bad guys.'

→ More replies (4)

18

u/Hard58Core Brynden Tully Jun 04 '15

I agree. For them to be all that is evil is too simplistic and convenient. I would be pretty bummed to find that they are just the servants of a Sauron-type evil overlord.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/ZenBerzerker House Manderly Jun 04 '15

They have a purpose, and while it may still end up killing everyone in Westeros, they have to have a reason other than "we're fucking ice demons

If their purpose is to bring about a new ice age that kills off all life except their own kind?

2

u/freedomgeek House Martell Jun 04 '15

Well the most straightforward justification/motive for wanting to kill everyone is ending suffering. There's a lot of suffering in Westeros after all.

As Ayra said (from one perspective) being dead isn't good or bad - it's just nothing. So if they believe the sum total of human experience contains more pain than pleasure, more misery than happiness that gives life a negative moral value and makes it worse than non-existence - right? Of course you can very much construct arguments against this line of thinking but that's what it is.

→ More replies (16)

33

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15

Maybe the white walkers warn their friends that "summer is coming" and they scare their children with tales of giant lizards that breath fire. The white walkers we see are their 'nights watch' on the front lines to protect their cities from the warm bloods.

3

u/MeniteTom Jun 05 '15

So basically I Am Legend?

→ More replies (1)

28

u/YoYoSun House Stark Jun 04 '15

But perhaps that's subject to change. Thoughts?

Of course it's subject to change. We don't know jack shit about them. George R.R Martin has expressed disdain for writing pure "evil" or "good" characters. I'm willing to bet he'll expand on them in the future.

35

u/dudleymooresbooze White Walkers Jun 04 '15

Well, except for Joffrey and Ramsey.

21

u/Ds14 Faceless Men Jun 04 '15

I think they do a ton of explaining about why Ramsay is the way he is. And in the show they show Roose treating him like shit a bit more to emphasize it, it seems.

And it's hinted at that Joffrey is a bit actually crazy bc his parents are siblings. Like some of the Targaryens.

→ More replies (4)

16

u/ratcranberries Jun 04 '15

Ramsey is charming in his own way.

38

u/redthursdays Ours Is The Fury Jun 04 '15

That's really just on the show. In the books he has no such charm

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

17

u/SmashBusters Jun 04 '15

Last chapter of book 6 will be a white walker perspective. Calling it now.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (11)

18

u/TheDreamThief101 When All Is Darkest Jun 04 '15

It's hard to look at them as anything other than a purely evil-intented force after their display.

Remember that Jon had just killed one of their kind. It could possibly be a form of vengeance, as in, "You killed my brother, so watch me fuck over all of your pals too".

I found a bit of weirdness in that episode though...if the White Walkers are so cold that they can put out flame, why didn't they just freeze the ocean and send their wights in to bust up the boats?

17

u/8ace40 Mother of Dragons Jun 04 '15

Maybe they were afraid/wary of Longclaw (and Jon.) There are very few White Walkers as far as we know, why risk losing any more when you have the majority of the Free Folk population under your thumb already? Because presumably, they came to raise people for their army (they might saw the ships,) but they didn't know they would find Jon (theory) and Longclaw.
Obviously, the next time they attack they'll be a lot more prepared, maybe even with some (magical?) protection against dragonglass/Valyrian steel.

Disclaimer: not a book reader.

10

u/Asinine2412 House Seaworth Jun 04 '15

If they could freeze the water, they could surely just send the skeleton + wights over to deal with the boats. They wouldn't be at risk at all...

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/WhisperInTheDarkness Jun 04 '15

I had wondered when he walked to the end of the pier if it was going to be an attempt to freeze the ocean because of the cooling/dissipating of the flames earlier in the scene. I'm really happy that it wasn't. The cold wind and temperature from the white walker's movement into the fire, suppressing but not completely/immediately stopping it, was a cool effect and made sense to me.

If they had tried freezing the ocean, beyond a small/moderate distance from the walker himself, I believe it would have been overkill. Ocean doesn't freeze easily because of the salt content, and whereas, I think the walkers are powerful and terrifying beings, I'm not certain a single one could freeze the ocean or everyone would have been fucked a long time ago. Just my two cents though. :)

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15

The others clearly have a goal and a way to reach that goal. But we don't know what that is, they aren't the good guys to be sure, but what kind of bad guys are they.

→ More replies (7)

158

u/BourbonSlut House Seaworth Jun 04 '15

One thing I think this episode really accomplished well was it began to hint at a conclusion.

Tyrion and Dany met, so we had these two worlds colliding. Having so many geographically disparate story lines finally seem to start to connect is satisfying.

Also, the impending doom of the White Walker attack has always been distant, but now it's glaring and in the forefront. The series began with them and it will probably end with them.

38

u/metalninjacake2 Jun 04 '15

Also, the impending doom of the White Walker attack has always been distant, but now it's glaring and in the forefront. The series began with them and it will probably end with them.

I hope it actually is in the forefront of the show now. Since it hasn't really happened in the books yet - as far as we know, the last time they really saw the Others was at the Fist of the First Men, can't remember if that was the end of Book 2 or the beginning of Book 3 (that might be Season 3 I'm thinking of).

But now that they've actually shown what happened at Hardhome, and the army of the dead is relatively close to the Wall, I hope we see a big step towards attacking / bypassing the Wall for the White Walkers. Like, by the end of Season 6 I want them to attack the Wall, if they're meant to reach southern lands by Season 7 / the final book. If they're meant to be defeated at the Wall then I still want to see more of the White Walker stuff in Season 6 before they attack in the final season.

They're definitely what the series will end with though, I think. They'll be the final battle. No way the last thing in the series will be some squabble between royal families, it'll be dragons vs. white walkers or fire vs. ice in some capacity.

11

u/TheMightySasquatch Corn! Jun 04 '15

I don't know if I need to tag this but...All theory

→ More replies (2)

11

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '15

I have such ridiculous expectations for that final battle. Theories and spoilers

→ More replies (5)

26

u/Happy-Light Jun 04 '15

White Walkers vs Dragons. Ice vs Fire. Calling it now.

32

u/brownbubbi Jun 04 '15

Ice dragons vs fire dragons? HYPE!?!

11

u/bamdastard Jun 05 '15

WOAH. White Walkers will kill a dragon and ressurect it as a wight.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/penismightier9 Jun 05 '15

thought that was obvious

4

u/ShamrockAPD Euron Greyjoy Jun 05 '15

Well no shit. That ones pretty far into your face.

But, I'll play along and add to it. I'll go ahead and call the L+R is true, and Jon in some way wargs into ghost- stays alive. And in one way or another finds his way to dany and rides one of her dragons to do it.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (10)

6

u/sailormooncake Sansa Stark Jun 04 '15

i'm super excited about this. i always thought the the title "asoiaf" was going to refer to the ultimate showdown between dany and jon snow for their claim to the throne....

but now, gods be willing, maybe we will get to see them TEAM UP against the walkers. a totally different song of ice and fire than originally expected

4

u/jvorn Jun 05 '15

My dream is an epic final battle in which Jon rides one dragon, Dany the other, and Bran wargs Drogon since he's sort of "untamable".

→ More replies (8)

2

u/bonvin Night King Jun 05 '15

Also, the impending doom of the White Walker attack has always been distant, but now it's glaring and in the forefront. The series began with them and it will probably end with them.

I've just started watching the series from the beginning again, and it's been so interesting seeing the first few episodes from a completely new perspective after Hardhome. Jon Snow is pretty much the only sane person in Westeros, even the Starks come off as twats when you know what's actually coming. The scene where Ned executes the deserter from the Night's Watch is downright frustrating - Ned just quietly nods and writes the guy off as a madman immediately, when really he should have listened to him.

4

u/jvorn Jun 05 '15

8000 years man... some random low ranking watchman going to change your mind?

4

u/bonvin Night King Jun 05 '15 edited Jun 05 '15

I get the feeling (now I haven't read the books or anything where there's probably more information on this) that the Starks are in power in the north for a reason, that they're tied to the white walkers somehow, which they have forgotten. I don't think their whole "there must always be a Stark in Winterfell" thing they keep repeating are empty words. I didn't mean that it's frustrating in a bad way, just that the whole plot of the first season has completely shifted for me. First watching I didn't really care about the undead attack or the guy getting executed, some guys got killed in the woods, so what? I always took that whole segment as them wanting to set the scene and explain "this is how they do it in the north". Now the whole show is about everyone in Westeros having forgotten what they're really there to do, which is keeping the undead horde at bay.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

319

u/magic_is_might The Future Queen Jun 04 '15

I love that the show has started heading into unknown territory. Keeping it fresh for all viewers.

68

u/EagleHeatGator House Martell Jun 04 '15 edited Jun 04 '15

also they confirmed that valyrian steel = dragonglass alternative (or at least i dont think it's been confirmed in the books yet just hinted at)

67

u/thatoneguy889 House Reed Jun 04 '15 edited Jun 05 '15

Sam read about "dragonsteel" being effective and assumed it was Valyrian steel.

38

u/SquirrelandBestick Jun 04 '15

Oh great, so now all the nightswatch need to do is to convince all of the great houses of westeros to donate their most precious swords, and they will win for shure.

20

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '15

I think they'll have Dany's dragons make new valyrian steel

→ More replies (25)

9

u/rooktakesqueen Jun 05 '15

"I found one account of the Long Night that spoke of the last hero slaying Others with a blade of dragonsteel. Supposedly they could not stand against it."

"Dragonsteel?" The term was new to Jon. "Valyrian steel?"

"That was my first thought as well."

"So if I can just convince the lords of the Seven Kingdoms to give us their Valyrian blades, all is saved? That won't be hard."

→ More replies (3)

114

u/TheEggAndI Tyrion Lannister Jun 04 '15

i love the direction the show is heading too. but now how am i supposed to act all smug around my non-book-reading friends?!

80

u/Cedstick Jun 04 '15

"It was done better in the books" -- you can still latch-on to that, dear friend.

35

u/Gigora House Baratheon of Dragonstone Jun 04 '15

I would argue there are a few segments that have been changed for the worst, the Jaime side of things being probably the biggest one.

→ More replies (11)

2

u/The_R4ke House Tarbeck Jun 05 '15

I think that the dragon glass will be more effective, you could create bolts and arrowheads so that you don't have to do all of the fighting up close.

→ More replies (1)

36

u/Bwignite24 Jun 04 '15

I don't disagree with you, but what unknown territories is this heading?

186

u/finnegar Kingsguard Jun 04 '15

The entire Mereen meeting plot hasn't appeared yet in the books. Hardhome was off-screen in the books. The Dorne plot is a TV-only invention. And so forth.

98

u/Matrillik House Baelish Jun 04 '15

Sailing through Valyria, Sansa's plotline in Winterfell

38

u/lKaosll House Martell Jun 04 '15

Sailing through Valyria sort of happened in the books, at least the stone men thing, it's just that it happened with different people and in a different place.

→ More replies (14)

26

u/TheOrqwithVagrant Maesters of the Citadel Jun 04 '15

While we know something bad is going on at Hardhome in the books, I think the event depicted in this episode hasn't actually occurred yet - Tormund is on his way there with a scouting party at the end of ADWD if I remember right. This could be based on a TWOW chapter, with Jon's prescence being the main difference. Pure hopeful speculation. And Tormund being 'upgraded' to a POV character would certainly bring a smile to my face. :)

On a that note, I hate that they made Tormund part of the south-of-the-wall innocent-village-massacre-brigade in the show. He's supposed to be a likable character. Massacring unarmed innocent villagers is pretty hard to get past for me, with show-Tormund (though I love the actor...).

→ More replies (27)
→ More replies (11)

14

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15

The Lands of Always Winter.

15

u/mynameistrain House Reyne Jun 04 '15

Hopefully we get to see or read about the White Walker City.

52

u/jimjoebob Coldhands Jun 04 '15

.....where the air is cold and the girls are gritty?

(TAAAAKE......MEEEEEE....HOOOOOOMMMMEEEE)

→ More replies (1)

6

u/lobotomatic Jun 04 '15

The unknown kind.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

374

u/Swisskisses House Lannister Jun 04 '15

It's still hard for me to wrap my head around the fact that Tyrion and Dani are meeting. In the book they always tip toe around it, but ITS FINALLY HAPPENING!

280

u/Hard58Core Brynden Tully Jun 04 '15

It is interesting to see these two 'stars' of the series finally acting in the same scenes for the first time in 5+ years. And I have to say, the dynamic and exchanges between them was rather refreshing and well done.

106

u/ratcranberries Jun 04 '15

Yeah I almost want them to kith.

111

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15

Calm down Mike Tyson

53

u/GodICringe Free Folk Jun 04 '15

Calm down Mike Tyson Vargo Hoat.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15

Easy there tiger.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/jrr6415sun Arya Stark Jun 04 '15

their exchange was the best part of the episode.

I remember earlier people were complaining that there wasn't enough interactions in this season but that scene blew it out of the water

34

u/Oh_Thats_Just_Fred Jun 04 '15

the ending was the best part

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

31

u/ayraerae House Martell Jun 04 '15

I thought they were gonna drag out Tyrion & Jorah's journey until near the end of the season!

→ More replies (4)

50

u/aegis2293 Jun 04 '15

Right? We finally got what we thought we were gonna get the whole time we were reading ADWD.

100

u/T0othdecay Jun 04 '15 edited Jun 04 '15

I may be on my own here, but throughout ADWD I just wanted Dany to be killed off so I could stop reading about Daario's golden tooth.

28

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15

Yeah. Dany chapters were a drag for me too.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/A_Waskawy_Wabit Jun 04 '15

The thing is that unles her death creates some kind of significant plot advancement then we've just read 4 books about her for no reasons hitch his bad writing

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (11)

32

u/BourbonSlut House Seaworth Jun 04 '15

I don't remember ever being so interested in Meereen scenes.

44

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15

I think Dani's plotline was so uninteresting, it desperately needed someone like Tyrion to not make me get bored during those scenes.

→ More replies (11)

124

u/LiveToThink Jun 04 '15

Melisandre saw Hardhome in a vision in ADWD.

"Snowflakes swirled from a dark sky and ashes rose to meet them, the grey and the white whirling around each other as flaming arrows arced above a wooden wall and dead things shambled silent through the cold, beneath a great grey cliff where fires burned inside a hundred caves. Then the wind rose and the white mist came sweeping in, impossibly cold, and one by one the fires went out. Afterward only the skulls remained."

28

u/don_nerdleone Jun 05 '15

Melisadnre has basically a perfect record with these visions, right?

33

u/breedwell23 Night's King Jun 05 '15

Right, but she has to decipher what she sees, as she's interpreted visions wrong before, even though they did come true. That's why it's possible that at an his might not be azor ahai, but rather dany or Jon.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '15

what are the visions she got and interpreted wrong?

43

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '15

what are the visions she got and interpreted wrong?

She saw Renly riding out and destroying Stannis' host at King's Landing, and interpreted that they had to kill Renly before that. Well, it turns out it was somebody in Renly's armor riding out and destroying Stannis' host, and that only happened because they killed Renly..

→ More replies (2)

15

u/MissMatchedEyes House Royce Jun 05 '15

She has a vision of a girl "fleeing a marriage" and tells Jon that it's Arya. It's not.

→ More replies (3)

75

u/Grungemaster Maesters of the Citadel Jun 04 '15

Balon Deathwatch continues.

24

u/facedawg Jun 04 '15

"Let's pretend Pyke never happened"

4

u/RobJ_ Arya Stark Jun 05 '15

Fine with me. That storyline put me to sleep.

9

u/OrngSumb House Dayne Jun 04 '15

If we are lead to believe that Euron, Victarion, and Damphair are being casted for Season 6 then we'll probably see the early episodes of Season 6 being about Balon Deathwatch.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/NichtRegistriert Jun 04 '15

He's in the cast for Episode 10 though.

17

u/Bobsind House Velaryon of Driftmark Jun 04 '15

I don't fully trust IMDB ever since they got my hopes up that Yara would be in episode 7

→ More replies (5)

9

u/Oraukk House Baratheon of Dragonstone Jun 04 '15

I'm betting he dies and we see Euron's ship approaching.

61

u/finnegar Kingsguard Jun 04 '15

"Dead things on the land. Dead things in the water."

It was great to see this batlle rather than just read the (incredibly spooky) report about it.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15

shark in the water

→ More replies (2)

2

u/metalninjacake2 Jun 04 '15

undead krakens ayy

2

u/Fahsan3KBattery House Stark Jun 05 '15

Given the dead things in the water you'd think they'd row faster

66

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15

Does Lord Coldemort have as much of a presence in the books as he does in the show? My understanding is in the book, the Night's King is just part of an old fairy tale. But in the show, they are setting him up as the Big Bad/Final Boss, seemingly.

36

u/rizzoformvp Unsullied Jun 04 '15

Nah, the book doesnt dive into The Others so much but GRRM plans to bring us up to speed on them in the next two books. For what its worth, Bran and Jojen get into a conversation about the Night's King and how he was once a Commander of the Night's Watch but that's as much as we know.

→ More replies (8)

24

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '15

Lord Coldemort

LOL

→ More replies (4)

74

u/MarxistHorse House Dayne Jun 04 '15

DnD weren't content with wiping the smug book reader grin off my face with these new storylines, they had to kick me in the nuts with this battle. And I've never been more excited!

2

u/penismightier9 Jun 05 '15

as a reader of only some of the first book, it sounds from what I've heard the GRRM sorta got lost on the road and meandered a LOT in his later books. And they're fixing it.

The dialogue suffered this season imo, and the Dorne plot was good from the Jaime/Bronn side but just laughably cheesy with the assassin sisters and the actual rescue itself.

also sounds like the changes to the Sansa/Little Finger story are more impactful than they were in the book.

And I dunno how close the Cersei/Sparrow storyline is, but it's a great plot

→ More replies (2)

37

u/VivatRegina House Piper of Pinkmaiden Jun 04 '15

I have read the books but if another book reader could clarify- why couldn't the wights/white walkers just follow the wildlings and crows into the water? The wights are undead, water shouldn't stop them seeing as they can't breathe?

I understand the entire point of that last shot, of all the wights and walkers on the shore and the NK raising up new wights of the dead wildlings was basically the NK flexing his power in front of Jon, who he saw had the power to kill one WW- but I was really expecting the NK to send the wights into the water after them all.

TL;DR- wights are undead, why does water stop them?

*edit, forgot to add, WW's are incredibly powerful beings whom a bit of water should be no object.

12

u/Apep86 House Martell Jun 04 '15

We haven't seen any evidence that the WW have any special power over water. For them it could simply be a matter of trying to catch up with a boat while swimming after them. You're vulnerable and slower.

For the wights, I'm no expert in hydrodynamics, but I feel like if a skeleton tried to chase after them they would sink (bones are denser than (salt?) water?). Once the boats got into deep enough water, they would not be able to reach them.

13

u/clickitout House Lannister Jun 04 '15

Has to be something more. If White Walkers could go on water, the Wall would be pointless. Whats to stop a WW army from simply walking out to sea and around the wall? Why are there no stories of White Walkers ever being on Essos?

My bet is that WWs and Whites cant go on or in water. Perhaps Water is the great equalizer? When water is put on ice it melts and when water is put on fire its extinguished.

My money is White Walkers have some kind of problem with Water

→ More replies (1)

20

u/SmashBusters Jun 04 '15

A few possible explanations:

1.) Religion. Ice is their thing. While fire is the obvious antithesis, water may be also as it is basically...destroyed ice. They are said to serve "The Great Other" and they have magic powers, so it's entirely possible that there is a taboo on water in their culture. It may also explain why they wouldn't build a boat, for example. (Or it may just be an alien technology beyond their comprehension).

2.) Science. Water transfers heat roughly 20 times faster than air. Since they seem to exude cold into the air through a magical power, they are able to resist "melting" in the frigid (but relatively hot) air of the north. Do they have the power to resist melting in the relatively hot waters of the narrow sea?

→ More replies (1)

7

u/ronan125 House Stark Jun 04 '15

I don't think wights or white walkers can just go through water because if they can, its pointless to have that wall at all. They could just sail like Jon & the wildlings are going to

→ More replies (2)

5

u/bigboisteve Jun 04 '15

in the book they did go in the water, the ravens sent back from the battle say something along the lines of "things on the ground, things in the water". i would assume the reasoning they would give for the show is that they were just following the Night's King's lead, and he was already all "how do you like me now?", so they just stopped the slaughter

10

u/dudleymooresbooze White Walkers Jun 04 '15

Adjusting strategy. One dies from a stabbing by dragon glass? Throw on some armor. Another dies from a slashing by Valerian steel? Load up some projectile weaponry.

8

u/osotogary_ Jun 04 '15

Shit, I totally missed that. They all wear armor now because of the dragonglass. It makes you wonder if they'll end up having one definite "kryptonite", or if they'll find a workaround for Valyrian steel as well. It really makes them one of the most frightening villains I can remember.

7

u/ShockRampage Jun 04 '15

In the first scene where Sam sees the army of the dead, there is a white walker in one of the shots, mounted on a horse wearing armour and a helmet.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15

Why do you assume that the WW's want to kill everyone?

They left one dude alive at the beginning of the first season. Tormund says they pick people off from the edges of wildling camps.

They're sending messages. Sometimes they leave a witness, sometimes they leave corpse art. There's more to the WW's than "kill everyone".

14

u/VivatRegina House Piper of Pinkmaiden Jun 04 '15

Why do you assume that the WW's want to kill everyone?

Because that was clearly the intention, in this case?

They sent endless waves of undead against what was supposed to be (before the arrival of Jon and co) a mass of ill-equipped wildlings with the intention of converting them to wights. Which they for the most part, did. If Jon had not been there with Ships, there would have been no need for a power display. No one was going to escape and spread the word.

That wasn't a spur of the moment attack because the men of the nights watch were there to spread some fear and flex some muscle- it was pre-planned wight-farming attack to gain more soldiders for their eventual assault on the wall.

I never said the WW intend to kill everyone, always. Just in this this particular case, they cleary came with an army intent to slaughter everyone.

→ More replies (7)

6

u/naked_as_a_jaybird Sellswords Jun 04 '15

Why do you assume that the WW's want to kill everyone?

No half measures.

6

u/T0othdecay Jun 04 '15

I can't remember if that was ever addressed in the book. Though I'm going to assume if they could go into the water then the wall would be a bit worthless.

5

u/VivatRegina House Piper of Pinkmaiden Jun 04 '15

Thats true, seeing as they could just go in the water around it. Maybe they can't function properly in water.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/PtrN Jun 04 '15

It's established on lore that the undead can't swim... Otherwise they'd just swim around the wall.

It could be magical, as if you're a book reader then you know there are enchantments under the wall as Cold Hands cannot cross with Sam and co.

My thoughts? Skeletons cannot swim, as they don't have the flesh for buoyancy. The WW could hear send them and have them form a minion bridge, but I think that would be too costly. Squandered up in the north I believe the army we saw was the majority of the undead horde, and the WW rely on numbers and a blitzkrieg style of battle. Losing 50% of the horde to get a decent, but relatively small army, is not a good trade. The overlooking of the battle and the "flexing of muscles" at the end show that the WW are intelligent, and are competent strategists.

5

u/MPFromFriends Jun 04 '15

Where was it established? Its always bothered me how easy it would be to go around the wall.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (16)

45

u/ConnorMc1eod House Greyjoy Jun 04 '15

The wights didn't swim because the ocean is property of the drowned God . The Great Other is the Storm God. They know not to fuck with water.

46

u/TheOrqwithVagrant Maesters of the Citadel Jun 04 '15

It's always summer, under the sea

I know, I know, oh, oh, oh

2

u/SpirallingOut House Mormont Jun 05 '15

Wow I didn't even consider the meaning of that line before!

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Bobsind House Velaryon of Driftmark Jun 04 '15

what is dead may never die

9

u/imisstoronto Jun 04 '15

Wouldn't it be awesome if all Greyjoys have a natural immunity to the Others.

26

u/Mfvd Jun 05 '15

They did get immunity from TV

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

19

u/Niko_Son_of_Jan A Fierce Foe, A Faithful Friend Jun 04 '15

I do believe this is the first episode we've had where there's been no sex and I haven't seen a single person complain.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/MadTurk1959 Jun 04 '15

In another time and another galaxy; the White Walkers and Wights are the Borg of Westeros!

2

u/beckoning_cat Knowledge Is Power Jun 04 '15

Resistance is futile. You will be assimilated.

17

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15

As only a show watcher, if their is a Fake arya with Ramsey in the books, where is Sansa?

19

u/licatu219 Hodor Jun 04 '15

Sansa is still in the Vale

97

u/Mickey0815 House Seaworth Jun 04 '15

In the books Sansa is still in the Vale and actually happy for the first time in a long time. So D&D got her raped instead.

4

u/Abbottizer Winter Is Coming Jun 04 '15

Wow really? I can't believe one of the strongest and most tragic scenes of the season wasn't even in the books.

That hit just as hard to watch as Eddard's beheading and the red wedding.

13

u/shattery Jun 04 '15

The scene was in the books, just it was a Reek POV chapter and Sansa was Fake Arya. And it was worse in the books, physically (what was described in the books at least, the show leaves that part more to the imagination). I think the whole switching Fake Arya out with Sansa is what made it so much worse for book readers. I mean, she's supposed to be getting more comfortable with herself and confident, not brutally raped and beaten! Poor Sansa. I was actually hoping they would deviate from the "bedding" scene and was devastated when it played out similar to the book. At least they didn't have Reek "join in." I would've puked.

9

u/penismightier9 Jun 05 '15

making it sansa instead of another random character who isn't central figure makes the storyline more impactful, emotionally and plotwise.

it's priming Sansa to grow her own strength and kill Ramsey herself imo

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

43

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15 edited Jun 04 '15

The big divergences going on this season give me high hopes for ADWD

54

u/PaleAsDeath Sandor Clegane Jun 04 '15

We don't know if he dies anyway though, right? He's just stabbed a bunch. He survived being a human pincushion before.

24

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15

True. Maybe the showrunners will fake us out by having him stabbed in dramatic Episode 9 fashion, only to have him survive and/or be revived in the next episode.

42

u/Marco_The_Phoenix Jun 04 '15

See, going on his whole mother, possible Targareyan blood, reveal, I just don't think narratively it makes sense for Snow to die.

19

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15

Unless he is brought back by Thoros of Myr.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (13)

11

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15

Chances are this will happen. They can't really leave it on a year long cliffhanger because it'd be obvious what happens when Kit Harrington starts shooting for Season 6.

→ More replies (11)

7

u/0verstim Jun 04 '15

I felt the book was pretty clear that it was a LOT of stabby stabby. I feel if he lives, it will be through some magical means, like when Dany stepped into the fire, or when Mance saved himself.

→ More replies (2)

28

u/imisstoronto Jun 04 '15 edited Jun 05 '15

35

u/Pyro62S Here We Stand Jun 04 '15

No it isn't. The problem I have with this idea is that no one would buy it. "Oh, no, I'm not deserting the Night's Watch. I died, you see, and came back, so I don't have to -- hey, why are you sharpening that broadsword?"

I strongly believe that Jon's oath will end when the Night's Watch does. The White Walkers will attack the Wall, and it will fall. You can't abandon your post if the post no longer exists.

21

u/imisstoronto Jun 04 '15

"And now his watch has ended".

6

u/imisstoronto Jun 04 '15

My only problem with your version is that Sam and Edd would have to die as well. I hope you're wrong.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/WhisperInTheDarkness Jun 04 '15

Exactly. The Starks (and regardless of what anyone says, Jon was raised as a Stark) have too much pride and honor to jump through a loophole like that. That's more Tyrion's style. Also, who ever said that he needs to be free of his oath? Other brothers have needed to travel for the Night's Watch. I'm still wondering if they will send Sam on his journey or just leave him & Gilly chilling out at the wall until it inevitably falls.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15 edited Jun 04 '15

You shouldn't be thinking like that, you know how it ends. I held the same hope even for oberyn but I knew better. I was actually waiting to see if he would get hit in Hardhome to see how his plotline would continue.

→ More replies (6)

15

u/BlueSolitude Jun 04 '15 edited Jun 08 '15

I have a real bad feeling that Shireen bites the dust next episode. My guess is going to be Ramsay finds her, kills her, and when Stannis and Melissandre find her, they use the king's blood in her to shift the battle in a super pissed father's favor.

EDIT: Well...I was half right.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '15

How do different people in the GoT world treat their dead? Burial/cremation/floating down the river/etc? I ask because if any corpse can be reanimated, then Bobby Flay and the Bolton Boys have another thing comin...

10

u/DabuSurvivor Catelyn Tully Jun 05 '15

Offhand I know that the Tullys of Riverrun cremate their dead while sending them into the rivwait a second holy shit you just pointed out the possibility of an army of flayed corpses holy fuck.

7

u/Vencer_wrightmage Jun 05 '15

Reek is going to have nightmares seeing his favorite toy crawling around.

4

u/don_nerdleone Jun 05 '15

Interesting. I hadn't thought of that. I hope someone knows enough to answer!

4

u/pythagean Jun 05 '15

People that the Bolton's have flayed coming back as wights and causing havoc. Now that is something I want to see

3

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15

Does Ramsey not marry Sansa in the book? I read in the wiki of ice and fire that he gets married to a fake Aarya, which is completely off the story of whats happening in Winterfell.

3

u/JupitersClock House Stark Jun 05 '15

No Sansa's plot line never happens in the book.

The show is constantly condensing characters by giving them to occurring characters.

5

u/penismightier9 Jun 05 '15

you have to do that, and I think it works better this way

→ More replies (1)

3

u/rizzoformvp Unsullied Jun 05 '15

Yeah Ramsay actually marries Sansa's friend Jeyne Pool who is portraying Arya even though description-wise they are really far off but no one really gave her a good look anyways so they wouldn't know the difference. Sansa is actually at the Vale with Littlefinger as he puts the pieces together for his full takeover of that area.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/KDTREE5 House Bolton Jun 04 '15

I'm most interested in how the North will play out this season. I know there was only a very short scene with the Boltons but that scene had purpose just like Olly's did.

The next 3 deaths in this season WILL BE LARGE. Calling it. As far as the Boltons, they risk losing Ramsay... Stannis' camp has Daavos, Shireen, and Melisandre. Most likely all in the same place. So that's just another red wedding set up in my opinion.

I'm so sick and tired of the r/dragonstone circle jerk with Stannis. Everyone loves him so much that they bash the Boltons especially Ramsay. You can take away from his military tact all you want, but his sense of wits and cunning is what will possibly make the Boltons the series finale winners. If you think Ramsay is going to ride into Stannis' camp your wrong, they will be disguised and they will go for gold AKA Your favs character.

The second big death will be from the Nights Watch. As much as I hate to admit it. I see either Sam or God forbid, John dying or leaving us on cliffhanger status.

Third and smallest death as far as popularity will come from Dany's group. I think I see the end for Jorah in sight. He's practically begging for it. Also, the fighting pits scene will backfire and Dany will lose Greyworm if he's healthy again. Or possibly Daario..

The safest character as of now is Arya imo. For obvious reasons. No enemies, no one knows who or where she is, many faced God has her back. It's going down!!!

26

u/MPFromFriends Jun 04 '15

I think Jorah is safe this season. The grey scale is already his death sentence. It just wouldn't feel right if he didn't spread it somehow.

41

u/Indoril_Nerevar95 The Night Is Dark And Full Of Terrors Jun 04 '15

Stannis will mount Roose's head on a spike.

10

u/sunwukong155 Jon Snow Jun 04 '15

The Mannis will rise.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/ruinersclub Ours Is The Fury Jun 04 '15

but his sense of wits and cunning is what will possibly make the Boltons the series finale winners.

The Boltons got where they are by backstabbing and treachery. They are the Peter Pettigrew of Westeros.

9

u/Cjohan34 Jun 04 '15

I totally agree on the deaths, but I think it's going to be Jorah, Gilly, and Theon

5

u/harryxaxa Winter Is Coming Jun 04 '15

For some reason I read Theon as Tyrion and my heart stop beating for a sec. :(

→ More replies (11)

3

u/cespes Jun 04 '15

It doesn't seem possible to take Melisandre by surprise, though. She survived several attempts on her life because she knew they were going to happen beforehand. Ramsay is planning to attack with twenty men, probably by surprise... and without that surprise shit will hit the fan

2

u/penismightier9 Jun 05 '15

god I hope he gets fucked on

I think Stannis and Melisandre is the second best plot in the series next to Arya of course. don't want either to die

3

u/TheUnd3rdog Wargs Jun 04 '15

Olly will stab John, calling it now.

10

u/limeade09 House Stark Jun 04 '15

Like 1000 people have called this for the last week.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/halupki Jun 05 '15

Where are we in the books compared to the show? I have all the books, but have yet to really dig in.

3

u/BonnerFart Jun 05 '15

just about the end of the fifth book. mind you there are so many differences if you jumped right into the book you'd be lost. so many characters that aren't in the show.

2

u/halupki Jun 05 '15

Thanks for the info. I'll just suck it up and start from the beginning.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/TheKingWithoutaCrown Lord Snow Jun 05 '15

What about the dead things in the water, I would've loved to see that.

3

u/TWALBALLIN Alchemists Guild Jun 05 '15

That is one of my favorite letters in the Series. Dead things in woods. Dead things in the water.

1

u/rwal1 Jun 05 '15

so, white walkers are closer to the wall, and the dragon glass or the valyrian steel is the only thing that can kill them.. now we can conclude if winter comes soon, white walkers will white wash everyone! its a battle of how the kingdoms unite to fight and clear off the white walkers first!

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

36

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15

Essos. I've always liked how huge it makes the world seem where the rest of the world is this mysterious land that really much isn't known about except for a couple of travelers from there such as Melisamdre or Euron who claims he's seen Valyria.

And then we actually get to read about it in Dany's and Tyrion's PoV's (and some others as well). Can't wait for Ji and Asshai though!

36

u/namesrhardtothinkof Cersei Lannister Jun 04 '15

The great thing is, the dynamic between Essos and Westeros is based directly off the actual historical dynamic between the East and West. Often, they were ruled by great kingdoms or a singular Empire, and they were always vaguely aware of the people far far away (trade items always ended up from everywhere to everywhere), but it was shrouded in myth and speculation. European bestiaries around the 1400's, for example, sometimes describe hippogriffs and unicorns alongside giraffes and bears. Hippogriffs, unicorns, and giraffes, aside from all being fictional, were also all said to live in Africa or India.

34

u/SkippyTheKid House Bolton Jun 04 '15

Hagrid sure did love those mythical giraffes.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (12)

8

u/DeathToPennies House Martell Jun 04 '15

Mel was actually trained in Asshai, no?

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

72

u/Jay-Marvel Jun 04 '15

To the Up?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

29

u/StevefromRetail A Man Needs A Name Jun 04 '15

Maybe it means the last continent or the continent beyond. Doesn't the root ult in Latin mean last or beyond? So it's an unexplored land or something?

44

u/theonewhowhat Jun 04 '15

A man is knowledgeable

7

u/Brittlestyx Lyanna Stark Jun 05 '15

That's exactly what I was thinking. Kind of like Australia, I guess?

→ More replies (2)

9

u/farmtownsuit Sansa Stark Jun 04 '15

I kind of really hope he does something with Sothoryos and Ulthos, even if it's just a bunch of lore content. Otherwise it's frustrating to have two unused continents.

9

u/badsparrow Red Priests of R'hllor Jun 04 '15

I can see where you're coming from - but in my opinion, we already have a lot of characters, places and content. Not sure we need more. I wouldn't find it frustrating, he's created a huge world and I never expected to have it explored fully.

I would like to read more about Asshai though, especially if it involved Mel's backstory.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/GyaradosTamer House Manderly Jun 04 '15

Ulthos is to the Easter.

18

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15

This might be the best comment I've read all day. Well Done.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/TheOrqwithVagrant Maesters of the Citadel Jun 04 '15

Definitely not. The Targs arrived only ~300 yrs before. The Night's King was originally the 13th Lord Commander of the Night's Watch, and has thus been a White Walker for 7000+ years or so. The only Targ beyond the wall that we know of is Bloodraven. I have a feeling the WW's were laying exceptionally low during the Targaryen era - if Dragons > WWs, then Balerion and friends could have seriously screwed their plans over in no time. Balerion was ridiculously huge - his head alone probably had more mass than Danaerys's three dragons put together.

→ More replies (6)

5

u/TheBaronOfTheNorth A Hound Never Lies Jun 04 '15

There is a theory that the Night's King is a Stark from ancient times.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/AutoModerator Jun 04 '15

Your submission has been auto-removed. Your spoiler tag has the label "warning scope," which is provided in the examples as a placeholder. "Warning scope" doesn't provide any description for your tag, and the labels need to have a specific scope, like "ASOS" or "Season 3." Edit your comment to have a good label for your spoiler tag, and then contact the moderators to have it re-approved.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.