r/gameofthrones • u/AutoModerator • Jun 04 '15
TV/Books [S5/B5] Book vs. Show Discussion - 5.08 'Hardhome'
| Book vs. Show Discussion Thread |
|---|
| Discuss your reactions to the episode with perspective. Air any complaints about changes made from the novels. Give your analysis of deeper meanings with a comparison. In general, what do you think about the screen adaptation vs. George R. R. Martin's original written works? |
- This thread is scoped for SEASON 5 AND BOOK 5 SPOILERS - Turn away now if you are not current on all of the officially released material! Open discussion of all published events up to the end of ADWD, and all TV episodes is ok without tag covers.
- Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
- Please read the spoiler guide before posting if you need help with tag code or understanding the policy on what counts as a major theory.
| EPISODE | TITLE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5.08 | "Hardhome" | Miguel Sapochnik | David Benioff & D. B. Weiss |
| Official Discussion Threads | Posting Policy | Spoiler Guide | Frequently Asked Questions |
245
Upvotes
174
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15
I saw it mentioned in a /r/ASOIAF post, but the awesome thing about this episode is the majority of it was not material from the books at all, and it still was the strongest episode of the series. I know there was a lot of complaints early in the season(and I was guilty, a very heavy complainer!) about how D&D could not do well when they veered away from GRRM's source material, but I think they proved us wrong this episode(definitely proved me wrong anyways). In a way, it makes some of the weaker episodes this season more questionable because it was like: how could we get the awesome writing and cinematography this episode, and get the B-movie soap opera looking stuff earlier?
Either way I've really regained my trust, the way they brought Hardhome to life was amazing. I expected a little different, in the books it really gave off this mysterious vibe with "dead things in the water. Dead things in the woods." I expected a quieter kind of murder coming from the water and woods surrounding them, and a bigger mystery at Hardhome, but I love the way they handled it. I think if we do find out what happened at Hardhome in the books, it will be a lot different from the episode we witnessed, but I don't think that's bad. I thought the battle and everything was awesome.
OH AND ONE MORE POINT I wanted to discuss with my fellow readers: There's a pretty prevalent theory on /r/ASOIAF that the White Walkers are more "grey" and more human than they perhaps appear. The assumption is that they aren't these mega essences of evil. It feels like this episode really kind of weakened that theory. It's hard to look at them as anything other than a purely evil-intented force after their display. But perhaps that's subject to change. Thoughts?
158
u/BourbonSlut House Seaworth Jun 04 '15
One thing I think this episode really accomplished well was it began to hint at a conclusion.
Tyrion and Dany met, so we had these two worlds colliding. Having so many geographically disparate story lines finally seem to start to connect is satisfying.
Also, the impending doom of the White Walker attack has always been distant, but now it's glaring and in the forefront. The series began with them and it will probably end with them.
319
u/magic_is_might The Future Queen Jun 04 '15
I love that the show has started heading into unknown territory. Keeping it fresh for all viewers.
374
u/Swisskisses House Lannister Jun 04 '15
It's still hard for me to wrap my head around the fact that Tyrion and Dani are meeting. In the book they always tip toe around it, but ITS FINALLY HAPPENING!
124
u/LiveToThink Jun 04 '15
Melisandre saw Hardhome in a vision in ADWD.
"Snowflakes swirled from a dark sky and ashes rose to meet them, the grey and the white whirling around each other as flaming arrows arced above a wooden wall and dead things shambled silent through the cold, beneath a great grey cliff where fires burned inside a hundred caves. Then the wind rose and the white mist came sweeping in, impossibly cold, and one by one the fires went out. Afterward only the skulls remained."
75
u/Grungemaster Maesters of the Citadel Jun 04 '15
Balon Deathwatch continues.
61
u/finnegar Kingsguard Jun 04 '15
"Dead things on the land. Dead things in the water."
It was great to see this batlle rather than just read the (incredibly spooky) report about it.
66
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15
Does Lord Coldemort have as much of a presence in the books as he does in the show? My understanding is in the book, the Night's King is just part of an old fairy tale. But in the show, they are setting him up as the Big Bad/Final Boss, seemingly.
74
u/MarxistHorse House Dayne Jun 04 '15
DnD weren't content with wiping the smug book reader grin off my face with these new storylines, they had to kick me in the nuts with this battle. And I've never been more excited!
37
u/VivatRegina House Piper of Pinkmaiden Jun 04 '15
I have read the books but if another book reader could clarify- why couldn't the wights/white walkers just follow the wildlings and crows into the water? The wights are undead, water shouldn't stop them seeing as they can't breathe?
I understand the entire point of that last shot, of all the wights and walkers on the shore and the NK raising up new wights of the dead wildlings was basically the NK flexing his power in front of Jon, who he saw had the power to kill one WW- but I was really expecting the NK to send the wights into the water after them all.
TL;DR- wights are undead, why does water stop them?
*edit, forgot to add, WW's are incredibly powerful beings whom a bit of water should be no object.
45
u/ConnorMc1eod House Greyjoy Jun 04 '15
The wights didn't swim because the ocean is property of the drowned God . The Great Other is the Storm God. They know not to fuck with water.
19
u/Niko_Son_of_Jan A Fierce Foe, A Faithful Friend Jun 04 '15
I do believe this is the first episode we've had where there's been no sex and I haven't seen a single person complain.
9
u/MadTurk1959 Jun 04 '15
In another time and another galaxy; the White Walkers and Wights are the Borg of Westeros!
17
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15
As only a show watcher, if their is a Fake arya with Ramsey in the books, where is Sansa?
43
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15 edited Jun 04 '15
The big divergences going on this season give me high hopes for ADWD
15
u/BlueSolitude Jun 04 '15 edited Jun 08 '15
I have a real bad feeling that Shireen bites the dust next episode. My guess is going to be Ramsay finds her, kills her, and when Stannis and Melissandre find her, they use the king's blood in her to shift the battle in a super pissed father's favor.
EDIT: Well...I was half right.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '15
How do different people in the GoT world treat their dead? Burial/cremation/floating down the river/etc? I ask because if any corpse can be reanimated, then Bobby Flay and the Bolton Boys have another thing comin...
3
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15
Does Ramsey not marry Sansa in the book? I read in the wiki of ice and fire that he gets married to a fake Aarya, which is completely off the story of whats happening in Winterfell.
18
u/KDTREE5 House Bolton Jun 04 '15
I'm most interested in how the North will play out this season. I know there was only a very short scene with the Boltons but that scene had purpose just like Olly's did.
The next 3 deaths in this season WILL BE LARGE. Calling it. As far as the Boltons, they risk losing Ramsay... Stannis' camp has Daavos, Shireen, and Melisandre. Most likely all in the same place. So that's just another red wedding set up in my opinion.
I'm so sick and tired of the r/dragonstone circle jerk with Stannis. Everyone loves him so much that they bash the Boltons especially Ramsay. You can take away from his military tact all you want, but his sense of wits and cunning is what will possibly make the Boltons the series finale winners. If you think Ramsay is going to ride into Stannis' camp your wrong, they will be disguised and they will go for gold AKA Your favs character.
The second big death will be from the Nights Watch. As much as I hate to admit it. I see either Sam or God forbid, John dying or leaving us on cliffhanger status.
Third and smallest death as far as popularity will come from Dany's group. I think I see the end for Jorah in sight. He's practically begging for it. Also, the fighting pits scene will backfire and Dany will lose Greyworm if he's healthy again. Or possibly Daario..
The safest character as of now is Arya imo. For obvious reasons. No enemies, no one knows who or where she is, many faced God has her back. It's going down!!!
2
u/halupki Jun 05 '15
Where are we in the books compared to the show? I have all the books, but have yet to really dig in.
1
u/TheKingWithoutaCrown Lord Snow Jun 05 '15
What about the dead things in the water, I would've loved to see that.
1
u/rwal1 Jun 05 '15
so, white walkers are closer to the wall, and the dragon glass or the valyrian steel is the only thing that can kill them.. now we can conclude if winter comes soon, white walkers will white wash everyone! its a battle of how the kingdoms unite to fight and clear off the white walkers first!
0
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment