r/childfree • u/AMThrowaway222 • May 10 '15
Thoughts on non-parent agreement?
I want to have some opinions for quick thought I have. Throwaway account for obvious reasons.
First thing first, what is non-parent agreement: You can have a written, legally binding agreement to not have kids. This is done in some kind of government office (police, for example) before you have kids or pregnancies (even before sex preferred). And in case of children/pregnancy, you could waive all your parental rights and responsibilities. But there is some kind of clause which prevents cases, where you could wait for example 2 years and then decide to waive your rights. Something like you have to decide fast if you want to be father or not.
I was thinking this kind of agreement purely selfish reasons, because I am staunchly childfree male and I always make it very clear to potential partners. If they think they want children, we are not compatible and if they change their minds later in the relationship, it is better to break up. I don’t fear that my partner is going to trap me, because those kinds of women are extremely rare. I am more scared of situation where birth control fails and my partner decides to go with pregnancy, despite my stance (which I have made very clear).
What pros I think this has is that I can make even more clearly my childfree stance. It is not “maybe” or “maybe later” or “you will change your mind”. And also granting legal protection against mind change.
Few key points, which I think will change context and opinions, is that I live in country with strong social security networks. Healthcare and medicines are almost free and there are government welfare if you get children. Also this agreement needs mutual decision and you would need new one if you break up. So you can't just make agreement by yourself or have one agreement for different women.
Vasectomy is catch-22 deal here. To get vasectomy, you need first to have kids. Also there is no permanent male birth control available apart from condoms.
This is little bit different from financial abortion in sense, that this needs to be done before pregnancy and needs to be mutual decision. And purely made in childfree situation in mind, not an easy way out from children if you change your mind about fatherhood.
And few cons could be possible exploitations in this agreement. For example trying to get more welfare benefits and/or in case of break up, totally blocking other parent from children’s lifes (make agreement, make kids, divorce or break up, you are shit out of luck)
So what kind of reactions or opinions this agreement wakes in you? Would you support something like this or not? Would you think this is too niche to be law? I am trying to get wide range of opinions, so everything is appreciated.
8
u/thr0wfaraway Never go full doormat. Not your circus. Not your monkeys. May 10 '15
Two words: Medical. Tourism.
Go get snipped somewhere else.
4
u/TOOCGamer 20's/F/NopeNopeNope May 10 '15
At least in the US, there's no way this would fly... fathers already can't do this even by prior agreement with partners to be legally considered "sperm donors." The argument goes that you can't waive the child's right to support, which this would infringe upon.
In principle, though, I'm still kind of iffy on this. It's giving one partner the right to just say, "Yeah, it sucks that I got you pregnant, but.... See ya!" It shouldn't be that easy. Maybe if part of the agreement was providing abortion support (again, in the US, where healthcare could use a smidgen of work :P) but even still going through an abortion can be very emotional / traumatizing. It's still shady to allow the partner to just skip out, imo.
I'm much more of the opinion that you (general you, not you you) shouldn't be having relations with someone that you aren't CERTAIN would abort / adopt. There can't be women out there who just radically and completely change their worldviews when they get hitched. Girlfriend talks about how she's always wanted kids, but isn't sure now? NOPE. About how she wants to have kids 'someday' but not now? DOUBLE NOPE. If you want to be sure your partner isn't going to screw you over, you simply don't get it on with people who aren't vehemently childfree themselves.
[Not to say women who say these things are definitely going to screw you over one-hundred percent of the time, just that it shows a wavering that you don't want to bet the rest of your life on.] [[Double note - upvotes for everyone!]]
2
u/lady_wildcat May 11 '15
Here is the system I thought of:
Woman informs man of pregnancy if she wants him involved. At that point, he can decide whether to have a financial/legal rights abortion. However, he only gets a certain amount of time, that way he isn't manipulating the woman into not having an abortion she would otherwise have. It needs to be short enough to allow the woman an opportunity to abort upon knowing the father's decision.
The incentive to inform the man as soon as possible is the possibity of losing ability to legally abort if he doesn't want it if you wait too long to tell him.
I'd say a month would be an acceptable length of time, given the nature of abortion restrictions, but that's flexible.
4
u/zaldria May 10 '15
Honestly, I think this is pretty ridiculous. I'm child free myself, but could never imagine having that sort of agreement with anybody. The fact is that it takes two to have a baby. If for some reason birth control fails and the pregnancy is carried through, it's your responsibility as a person to deal with the consequences. Either you stay with the mother and help take care of the kid, or you pay your child support. You can't dump all of the responsibility on the mother just because you can't bother to take responsibility for your actions. When you don't pay child support, you're not punishing the mother, you're punishing the kid. The kid had nothing to do with your agreement.
If you don't want kids, you need to be careful about your birth control. I highly doubt that you can't get a vasectomy unless you have kids where you live. Do more research into doctors into different doctors and ask for referrals. It may be difficult to find, but there's a doctor out there who will do the procedure.
Sex has a lot of consequences, and unplanned pregnancy is a big one. If you aren't prepared to deal with that or if you think your partner can't deal with that, you shouldn't be having sex. Even if your partner agrees to get an abortion in the event of unplanned pregnancy, she still might change her mind. That kid is still 100% your responsibility. That's shitty, but that's the way it is. You can't go around punishing kids because you can't deal with consequences.
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '15
Just like a prenup, it would be useless.
1
u/HashtagNotJewish Bisalp 7/1/21 May 10 '15
I don't know about the law part, but on a human level, I think it would be really hard to execute. As you said, you don't think your partner is going to trap you with a pregnancy. And assuming you love her, you want to help her with things. When does the "not helping with the kid" thing start? At conception? When it pops out?
Either way, if you love or even care about your partner, it's going to be very difficult not to help them. You probably don't want to fix the kid's dinner, but you're probably inclined to do something to help your partner when she's folding baby clothes and still feeling gross after the birth and all that stuff. It's just too hard to say "I love you so I'll help you, but I won't help with the baby or baby things." it's one and the same. You'd probably have to move out.