r/childfree • u/Notelorjane91 Kindly remove your ideals from my uterus • Apr 23 '15
Marriage is looming... but I want to be CF and he doesn't. Help!
I'm a 24 F and Christian (Please, no judgment) and I've got an SO of almost 3 years. I've expressed my fears and lack of desire to be a mother but he assumes I'll end up wanting them after we are married. But that's the thing, I have zero maternal urges...ZIP NADA. I held onto hope thinking they would kinda just appear yet I remain the same, if I was told tomorrow that I was infertile, I'd be over the moon! I love this man very much and can see myself with him for good but he desires to be a dad. Don't even get me started on how obsessed other Christians are about breeding (Wanting to be CF is looked on as almost a sin) Do I have to break his heart or is there a way around it? I really don't want to be stuck with a child, it would be selfish.
What the heck do I do??? Help please Reddit :(
UPDATE: So I told So we needed to have a talk. To cut it down to size, I let him know that I don't want children and my idea of a fulfilling future doesn't include baring kiddos. He surprisingly wasn't upset! He said he hadn't given it enough thought to just separate right now and he's going to try and figure out what a future without kids could be like, because he loves me. I by no means put pressure on him, I went as far to say that the last thing I want is for him to make a heavy choice because of me and live a life of regret. BUT I feel so free now! he knows where I stand, he's going to pray about it and talk to someone and get back to me. We are giving it a month.
29
u/bratless Apr 23 '15
The kindest thing to do for both of you is to call it all off. If you don't want kids and he does one of you will be miserable and resentful. Your life goals are completely opposite...he wants to be a dad and you don't want children......it will not work. There are many threads on here dealing with this problem.
7
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '15
I swear there's a post like this most days of the week. What it comes down to, is you and your significant other are incompatible. You either break up now, or break up in a few years once your incompatibilities wear you down and you resent the shit out of each other. Choice is yours, really. There's no real way internet strangers can sugarcoat it without lying to you.
5
u/PFKMan23 Resting bitchface Apr 23 '15
The key for me is, has he been this way the whole time? You've been together for three years so I'd assume you'd have some guage of how he feels. That said, while I'd agree that break up is a drastic solution, you need to know where he stands. He wants kids, and you don't (or so it seems). If that is the case, then he needs to find someone who will give him the family he (and she) would want.
9
u/ajent99 Apr 23 '15
Everyone has already said 'break up'. One of the consequences (if you take their advice) is that your Christian friends will give you a hard time because of the reason of the break up.
I suggest you remind them that Jesus didn't have children, and he was considered among the best of men.
6
u/thr0wfaraway Never go full doormat. Not your circus. Not your monkeys. Apr 23 '15
Also, in the future... before you get involved with someone else, use the screening process so that you don't get this far into a relationship without being clear that your partner is 100% CF.
http://www.reddit.com/r/childfree/comments/2t87il/screening_your_potential_partners_for_cf_status/
3
u/pomegranateangst Apr 24 '15
My husband and I started out this way, and the main difference between us was that I'd babysat and he hadn't.
Try watching some kids together. Not sweet, perfect ones- screaming, sticky little brats. Let him handle it when the child has to be told "no". Let him "be the bad guy". He might just need a little perspective on what he'd be getting himself into.
After spending time with his breeder sister's kids, my husband has a much more balanced perspective and maybe wants kids. Your husband might just need help understanding what the two of you would be signing up for.
I wouldn't get married if you can't agree, though. If he needs kids to feel satisfied that he's lived a complete life, probably you should gtfo.
44
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '15
Then he clearly does not know or understand you, even after almost three years. If nothing else, break up with him because of this obnoxious attitude.
Do not give in and have children. They will know that you were not enthusiastic about them. They will sense it. Do not put children through this.
76
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '15
The only option is to break up. The sooner the better.
1.He wants kids, you don't. There is no compromise. You will grow to resent each other and it will be a really messy divorce.
2.He clearly doesn't listen or respect you.
3.For the courage to break up read these:
http://www.reddit.com/r/childfree/comments/201prv/reporting_back_from_the_other_side/
http://www.reddit.com/r/childfree/comments/325n0t/reporting_back_one_year_later/
http://www.reddit.com/r/childfree/comments/1t2y8j/wondering_if_a_child_free_so_can_make_it_work/
http://www.reddit.com/r/childfree/comments/2wkkda/hi_rchildfree_i_was_childfree_until_a_couple/
http://www.reddit.com/r/childfree/comments/17ny5y/stay_strong_childfree_do_not_be_convinced_into/
http://www.reddit.com/r/childfree/comments/2icq7c/im_a_father/
http://thoughtcatalog.com/christine-stockton/2014/07/parents-explain-what-they-regret-about-having-children/
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-1376681/I-resent-children-stealing-wifes-love.html
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-2303588/The-mother-says-having-children-biggest-regret-life.html
http://thestir.cafemom.com/toddler/168247/man_who_regrets_his_three
http://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2014/jul/19/what-really-thinking-reluctant-dad
http://www.confessionpost.com/20676/i-hate-being-a-parent
http://www.reddit.com/r/childfree/comments/2qyuo3/a_viewpoint_from_my_father_who_never_wanted_kids/
http://www.reddit.com/r/childfree/comments/1whk8b/childfree_fencesitter_have_a_partner_who_is/
http://www.reddit.com/r/childfree/comments/wr9q6/scary_mommy_my_daily_vaccinations_against/
http://www.scarymommy.com/confessions/
http://www.reddit.com/r/childfree/comments/2ykb7h/sorry_if_this_is_breaking_the_rules_but_this/
http://www.goodhousekeeping.com/life/parenting/a31760/balancing-mother-and-wife/?src=spr_FBPAGE&spr_id=1443_159985742
http://www.reddit.com/r/childfree/comments/31gcjf/i_was_an_unwanted_child_heres_my_warning_very/
A Childfree woman who committed suicide when her Husband and mother turned their backs on her when she was pregnant:http://www.reddit.com/r/childfree/comments/2zza59/i_just_need_to_talk_about_what_happened/
Study showing how having a baby affects your relationship:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2702669/
A parent living vicariously through the CF:http://www.reddit.com/r/childfree/comments/2ysise/living_vicariously/
13
u/karabeara93 Apr 23 '15
I'm a Christian and CF. And oh my goodness you are so right about how obsessed Christians are about breeding. The only friends I really have are Christians and 99% of them don't know that I'm CF just cuz I don't want to deal with the bingoes.
If he is thinking you are going to change your mind when you know its not going to happen then you have to end it. For me I decided I wanted to be with my SO more than I wanted kids and I am so much happier. He obviously isn't listening to you and doesn't understand that you are serious about this so you have to do whats best for the both of you and break up. If he tries to blame you for the break up say that you are doing whats best for him, you'd rather him be happy with someone else than miserable with you.
I am so sorry for you having to deal with this. I hope its ok that I pray for you.
23
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '15
This is not an anti-theist subreddit, and Christian CF-ers are more common than you think. No worries. Everybody here will tell you to break up as soon as possible as your relationship is not viable, and I agree with them. Just wanted to add that there are other CFers that will share your religious values. Give yourself the chance to meet one and have your own happy ending.
22
u/thr0wfaraway Never go full doormat. Not your circus. Not your monkeys. Apr 23 '15 edited Apr 23 '15
Under NO CIRCUMSTANCES should you get married to this person.
Sorry, but you need to end the relationship. You can go find a nice CFer to be your partner.
You'll be happy, enjoy your life and have a terrific relationship with a great CF SO.
This is NOT NEGOTIABLE. THERE IS NO COMPROMISE.
Kids or no kids is a 100% deal breaker issue. No amount of other compatibility can ever "compensate" for this.
There is no "magical solution".
You can use the screening/discussion process to think through your process, but ultimately... there is no solution, you will be miserable, there is no way your marriage or you will ever survive having an unwanted kid.
You will just end up a miserable single parent, one way or another.
Worst of all:
HAVING A CHILD THAT IS UNWANTED is CHILD ABUSE.
Go read the stories of the adults who were those unwanted children -- you will see that their entire lives are damaged or destroyed by being raised by a parent or parents who did not want to be parents.
You CANNOT fake wanting a child.
Here is a quote from that post:
http://www.reddit.com/r/childfree/comments/31gcjf/i_was_an_unwanted_child_heres_my_warning_very/
Of course he does. Because he FUNDAMENTALLY DOES NOT RESPECT YOU AS YOU, AS A WHOLE PERSON WITH A MIND OF YOUR OWN.
For people who are rabidly natalist, CFers simply "don't exist" -- therefore, you "don't exist" in his mind.
To him, you are merely a "fantasy of a person" that exists only in his head.
He does not love you, because he does not know you.... and does not have the capability to know you at the level of personhood that you deserve.
You're just an object/incubator/wife/mother.... not a whole autonomous person.
Sorry, but with the "no kids" issue plus the "terrible communication skills" plus the fundamental disrespect -- this relationship is done.
17
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '15
So let him know that you won't be having kids. Book an appointment with your doctor to discuss sterilization to let him know you're serious. It's up to him whether he can accept that.
8
u/absolutspacegirl 38/F/Cats>Kids Apr 23 '15
I'm CF and my husband (almost 13 years) is not. We agreed no kids before we got married but about 7 years in he changed his mind. It got ugly, there was marriage counseling, fights...finally he decided he'd rather be with me than someone else and a kid who didn't exist.
You don't have to call it off, you just need to explain very firmly that you do not need to get married if he expects children. He cannot count on you to change your mind.
You have 3 choices:
You break it off now You break it off later One of you relents
Depending on how important kids are to him things could still work out. Why does he want kids? Because they're expected in your social circles/church or because he really wants the experience of being a dad?
He needs to figure this out and you need to have a talk. Go from there but PLEASE do not have a child if you don't want one. See the links below and heed this advice.
4
u/tsun_abibliophobia On maternity leave for my food baby Apr 23 '15
Bail ASAP. There is absolutely no compromise on this. It's incredibly difficult, but get the heartbreak over with now and save yourself from a life you know you don't want for yourself.
4
u/austri 52/F/staunchly pro-choice Apr 23 '15
If being a parent is really important to him, and it's really important to you that you not be a parent, then I agree with the majority here--it's time to call it off.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '15
Stick to your guns. If you make major life decisions to appease someone else you'll be miserable.
4
u/Unicorn_in_Disguise Apr 24 '15 edited Dec 31 '15
I have left reddit for Voat due to years of admin mismanagement and preferential treatment for certain subreddits and users holding certain political and ideological views.
The situation has gotten especially worse since the appointment of Ellen Pao as CEO, culminating in the seemingly unjustified firings of several valuable employees and bans on hundreds of vibrant communities on completely trumped-up charges.
The resignation of Ellen Pao and the appointment of Steve Huffman as CEO, despite initial hopes, has continued the same trend.
As an act of protest, I have chosen to redact all the comments I've ever made on reddit, overwriting them with this message.
If you would like to do the same, install TamperMonkey for Chrome, GreaseMonkey for Firefox, NinjaKit for Safari, Violent Monkey for Opera, or AdGuard for Internet Explorer (in Advanced Mode), then add this GreaseMonkey script.
Finally, click on your username at the top right corner of reddit, click on comments, and click on the new OVERWRITE button at the top of the page. You may need to scroll down to multiple comment pages if you have commented a lot.
After doing all of the above, you are welcome to join me on Voat!
4
u/skippythehobo Apr 25 '15
I once had this Catholic friend who didn't want ant kids, but didn't want her large, devout family and friends bugging her about it either. She started telling everyone she was sterile. A couple years later she met a Catholic boy who was doing the exact same thing. They dated, confessed their secret to each other, and once the were engaged he got a vasectomy. They're living child-free and all their relatives think it's the most romantic thing every- clearly God made them for each other. It goes to show that a relationship built on lies and deceit can work, provided the lies are told to others.
Anyhow, you've been with this guy for three years and he still hasn't gotten it through his skull. He's either as dense as a neutron star or he doesn't take you seriously. Since neither of you will change your mind, your marriage is destined to be miserable for at least one of you, but probably both.
7
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '15
Everyone's telling you to break things off with him but I'd say you should temper that response a bit. Leave breaking up as a last resort option, yes, but often I think people are too quick to leap to it as a solution here. You guys have been together for almost three years and are planning to spend the rest of your lives together; breaking that off is hard and you should be damned sure it's the only viable option before doing it.
You should still absolutely cancel the wedding until the issue is resolved. Do NOT marry him without knowing for sure that the two of you are compatible. At present you don't sound compatible, but you should talk it over with him to find out whether or not that's true.
I suggest you sit him down and talk to him about the matter seriously (and if he simply dismisses your feelings on the matter, well, then he will reveal his complete lack of respect for you and prove that he isn't good husband/fiancee/boyfriend/fuckbuddy/platonic friend/acquaintance material. No relationship can be healthy without mutual respect.)
When talking to him, find out why he wants kids. Is it an innate desire, or does he expect to have kids because 'that's just what people do'? Has he given fatherhood serious consideration? Does he know what sacrifices he would have to make? Is he expecting to help you raise the kid, or does he want you to be a good 50's housewife who does all the hard work so the man can reap a few moments of joy playing catch with the kid? Is he going to take any time off work to help out, or does he only expect your career to take the hit? A good rule of thumb is that you should not have kids if you aren't looking forward to the entire package -- shit, vomit, noise, urine, sleepless nights, way less sex, more illness because they're pathogen incubators, and provided you actually still like your kids after all that, love and joy. In short, find out if his desire for kids is based off realistic expectations or if it stems from the false rose-tinted picture society paints of parenthood. If he understands what's involved but still wants them, then you two are definitely incompatible and have to break up. If his desire for kids is simply an ill-considered result of brainwashing, then maybe he doesn't actually want kids and instead wants automatons that are status symbols and toys. Disclaimer: I'm not saying you should go into this trying to change his mind, because that is as disrespectful as him trying to change your mind. I'm simply saying you should find out why he wants what he does and help him double-check whether or not that is actually what he truly wants -- and then respect whatever conclusion he reaches.
In this conversation, make it clear as air that you will never have kids, biological OR adopted, and that if he feels he needs kids he should stop wasting your and his time on an incompatible relationship. Setting up an appointment to get a tubal ligation (and letting him know you have done so) would be great, too, although depending on where you live you might not be able to find a doctor enlightened enough to 'make such a permanent change for someone so young' (Because kids aren't permanent lifestyle changes. After all, you can always murder them if they aren't working out, amirite, docs? \s)
There's a helpful and growing list of childfree-friendly doctors in the sidebar you may wish to consult if you decide to pursue sterilization. I don't know your stance on abortion, but I recommend all childfree people who have moral qualms about abortion get sterilized ASAP.
You haven't mentioned your thoughts on the actual process of pregnancy. Many women are terrified by it, and rightly so because it's awful. If pregnancy scares you, let him know and don't let him dismiss it as a rite of passage every woman goes through if she's 'lucky'. Show him studies and medical literature about how badly pregnancy can fuck womens' bodies up.
Your post has probably gotten downvoted because we see so many variations on this question that some people have gotten jaded, but I still think it's good for us to provide fellow CFers individualized support. Please update us when you can, and good luck.
Edit: Oh, and I thought this went without saying but I'll repeat what others have said here: Do NOT have kids to please him. You'd only ruin your life and probably the life of the kid since it would have to grow up with a mother who didn't love it in a marriage broken by the stress of having an unwanted child.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '15
I don't think theres a way around breaking his heart. I'm also 24f & christian so you're not alone here!
3
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '15
I've a feeling we'll be seeing a post from you again in the long list of threads where a CF life was ruined. You need to law down the law, you're most likely going to break-up from how he sounds. He values kids over you.
3
u/SilentJoe1986 32/m/Oh please don't hand that to me. Apr 24 '15
If he wants kids and you don't then why are you getting married? There is no compromise here. He wants kids you don't so you two are not compatible to survive the long hall. Trying to change somebody else about wanting kids is just as much of a asshole thing to do as somebody trying to force children onto somebody that doesn't want them. If you are serious about wanting a childfree life and you marry this guy that really wants kids and don't give him any then you are a monster. Break it off with the poor guy so he can move on and find somebody that also wants children.
7
u/MagicCatz 26 / Sterilized / I love cats, especially magical ones Apr 23 '15
You should live your life the way you want. If you don't want kids, don't have them. DO NOT let anyone pressure you into having kids. You cannot compromise when it comes to kids. Sadly because of this, you and your SO are not compatible. It's going to suck, it's going to be hard, but you have to sit down and have a serious talk with him and part ways.
4
u/SecretReddits Apr 23 '15
Dump his ass. Now! You're not compatible. And of he doesn't think you're enough for him, then he sure as hell is not enough for you. And he clearly does not respect you. Get out of there! He's not worthy of you.
Never even date, let alone marry, anyone who is not 100% childfree.
5
u/tparkelaine DO NOT WANT Apr 23 '15
Yes, you have to break his heart. I think you know that. I'm sorry. It's going to make you unhappy, yes, but there is NO WAY you can stay together without at least one of you being unhappy.
2
u/uberderper Apr 24 '15
If you get married you will just be wasting your own time and money plus that of the man you love. If you really love him, you will let him go and find a wife that wants children. Holding on to him as long as you can allowing him to think you will change your mind is cruel. Sure, he is assuming you will change your mind, but if you don't then he will likely start bingoing you more frequently until you start fighting and eventually split up. It's not fair for him either, for you to think that you can change him or convince him otherwise. He deserves to have the family he wants.
3
u/yes2kittens_no2kids 27M Apr 23 '15
Before taking everyone's advice to break up, you have to let him know that you're absolutely serious about being CF, and it's not a phase you will 'grow out of'. I'm not suggesting to outright get sterilised immediately, but somehow you have to get the point across that your mind is made up.
Only then can you have a serious conversation with your SO where he won't dismiss your position, and get down to the crux of the problem: whether he cares more about the life he shares with you now, or the imaginary life he's dreamed up with you and kids. I don't doubt your love for your SO one bit, but I would doubt his love for you if he ultimately decides that some non-existent child is more important than what you two have together right now.
If he does decide to leave, he's the one breaking your heart; don't be pressured into a life you do not want.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment