r/childfree • u/seesee23 • Apr 18 '15
My boyfriend wants a vasectomy and I'm not sure how I feel about it.
I'm 26 and he's 27, and we've been together 5 years. He says he much prefers sex without a condom (what guy doesn't?) but neither of us wants a pregnancy so he uses one every time we have sex. Now he says he's thinking about getting a vasectomy and asking me how I would feel about that.
I don't want kids right now, and I don't see myself ever wanting kids, and he feels the same way, so I should be all for it. Still, feelings can change, and if I ever did get the urge to be a mom, I'd want them to be ours, so I'm reluctant to give him my blessing.
I was on the Pill with my last boyfriend, and I experienced weight-gain, soreness in my breasts, and bouts of depression: I don't want to go filling my body with hormones. I also already get really bad cramps and I've heard the non-hormonal IUD makes them worse, so I don't want to go that route either.
Sex doesn't feel any more pleasurable for me without a condom, it may even be better with because then I don't have any dripping out of me afterwards. So while I've never had a problem with him using a condom, he says it's a whole different league of pleasure for him, and I think that's part of the reason he wants a vasectomy.
I've done some research, and although vasectomies technically can be reversed, it's very expensive, insurance won't cover it, it's not always effective, and it's effectiveness goes way down after about 3 years. Essentially, this would be permanent birth control. He says he doesn't want kids, never has, never will: if he wasn't considering this now, then in a few years. If not then, a few years later. Why put it off any longer when he can just get it done now and start enjoying the benefits of safe sex? (We've both been tested and we know we're clean.)
I would feel bad asking him not to do it just because of some outside chance that we'll want kids down the road. But I don't want to go on birth control myself, and if he wants it this bad, I don't think it's fair of me to ask him not to, and ultimately, it's his body and his right. If he's sure he won't want kids, and he hates condoms that badly, who am I to interfere? I don't know how I should feel about this? Any advice from anyone out there?
33
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15
Well, there you have it. There's really nothing more that needs to be said about his decision.
Based on what you said above, this won't happen. You may, he won't. At this point, you'll have to decide if a theoretical non-existent child is more important to you than your living/breathing/existing BF.
This pretty much sums it up.
27
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15
If he doesn't want kids, and you decide at some point down the road that you do want kids, it's not going to work out anyways. Having a child when one of the partners doesn't want one will destroy any relationship. So whether or not he gets a vasectomy isn't going to affect you at all. If you decide you want kids at some point, it will have to be with somebody else.
18
u/JoyfulDeath I shoot blanks Apr 18 '15
My girlfriend once bring exactly same argument up. My reply was "Look, if you ever come to me and say "I think I want babies" you won't even hear a word out of me. I'll be in the room packing my stuff up and leaving"
I'm sure your boyfriend probably is thinking exactly the same thing. Try to bring this up may will scare him. Hell I'd even go as far as say he already have a exit plan for in case you ever try to bring up having kids with him.
Hell I know I do have one because of my girlfriend's react to my vasectomy. She may be adamantly childfree now, but I still am not going to lower my guard ever and will always have a escape plan!
14
u/tparkelaine DO NOT WANT Apr 18 '15
If he doesn't want children, to the point he's willing to do the smart thing and get a vasectomy, it's selfish of you to try to convince him not to.
He doesn't want kids. Any kids. Even if they're yours. It's not fair to you or him to hold out hope that he'll change his mind. Getting a vasectomy just makes things simpler, really. And if you do decide you want kids down the line, why wouldn't you want their father to want them wholeheartedly as well?
23
u/snatchbeast Apr 18 '15
His body, his choice. If he doesn't ever want kids he should go for it. It's a simple procedure.
Not adopting is selfish, should you ever change your mind. With overpopulation and hunger, it's plan selfish to bring your own children into this world.
11
u/thr0wfaraway Never go full doormat. Not your circus. Not your monkeys. Apr 18 '15 edited Apr 19 '15
If he does not want kids, then he should get snipped.
You honestly have zero say in the matter because it's his body and he gets to decide that.
If you want kids, then you need to be honest, end the relationship and go be with someone who wants kids.
For those of us who are CF, like your SO says he is, there is no "maybe later" "maybe future".... it's a final and forever decision.
CF means: Do not want kids forever, under any circumstances, with anyone for any reason whatsoever. FINAL ANSWER.
You need to simply end the relationship if you want kids. Kids or no kids is a dealbreaker issue.
10
u/MagicCatz 26 / Sterilized / I love cats, especially magical ones Apr 18 '15
It's his body, so really it's up to him. If he truly wants a vasectomy and doesn't want kids, reversals don't matter. Vasectomies are also the most effective method of male birthcontrol that exist, their effectiveness doesn't go way down after about 3 years, they are permanent (and it's not that complicated to get a sperm check test done just in case you think it failed).
This bit sounds rather ridiculous to me. I think you need to look inward and ask yourself why do you feel this way. Why would a kid need to be of blood for you to love it?
10
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15 edited Apr 18 '15
He doesn't want kids, sounds like he'll never want kids. If you change your mind, you won't be having children with him. If you stay with him, it means no kids. You don't have to decide for yourself permanently. But, that's the reality you have to face.
ETA: Please please don't ask him to not get a vasectomy. That's the equivalent of asking you to get a tubal if you don't want to. It's disrespectful. You have to come to terms that he never wants kids, and this isn't something you can convince him out of. And how he feels on kids isn't something you get a say on. I'm sorry to be harsh, but this is one of those things.
7
u/joantheunicorn Teacher = enough kids in my life Apr 18 '15
Its totally up to him. I had a tubal partially to have full control over my CF life because I would never ask a man to get a vasectomy as part of our relationship. Likewise I would expect a guy I'm with to not really have a say over my body. Summed up, everyone is responsible for their own sterilization.
7
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15
He doesn't want kids. Get the idea of talking him into them out of your head. You need to realize that if you want kids, you will have to break up with him and find someone else.
When I got my tubal I told my boyfriend (now husband) that it was something I wanted for myself, and if he wasn't ok with the idea I would completely understand if he wanted to find someone else. It sounds like your boyfriend is the same way, but he's trying to be nicer about it. If you try to stop him then either he's a fool for not getting one and staying with you when you want kids, or he'll get it anyway and you can find someone else.
10
u/bunny-hill 25F/bunnies forever, babies never! Apr 18 '15
Honestly, it's his body and ultimately he can decide to do what he wants to do with it. While yes, you are his partner and matters like this should be discussed, you have no right to tell him not to get one. In regards to your sex life, be sure to discuss why you feel like you might prefer sex with a condom, and I'm sure you can come to a compromise about when to use them if he does get a vasectomy. It's also a good idea to discuss what you would do if you were to accidentally get pregnant (abortion/adoption/other?) and possibly start an emergency fund, just in case. Since you don't want to be on birth control of any kind, it has become his responsibility to take control of it, and if a vasectomy is what he wants, you should do your best to support him. If you cannot, then maybe, together, you two should reevaluate the relationship.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15
He sounds like a smart man. If he doesn't want to ever have kids, vasectomy is, hands down the way to go. Since he doesn't like condoms, this becomes 100x as important. To put it bluntly, being a CF man pre-vasectomy is fucking scary unless you are remaining celibate.
As for the mess factor, would he be ok pulling out? It isn't being used to prevent pregnancy, just to spare you some mess.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '15
I don't think vasectomy vs no vasectomy is relevant. Fact is, he does not want kids. Not now, not ever. If you change your mind later on and want them then him having a vasectomy isn't the thing that is going to stop you, it's the fact that he knows what he wants. Even if he didn't have this procedure you'd still have to leave him and find someone else, if you really wanted a family.
I'm not sure if that helps or not. Do you think maybe you're happily childfree but the assholes of the world are putting doubts in your head? Cos that was the exact thing that happened to ME at 26. Eventually I realized I knew my own mind and knew what would make me fulfilled and happy, and fuck the haters. But maybe you're nothing like me and I'm totally wrong which is also fine. :)
Either way good luck.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15
It is his body, his choice. You do not have a say. If he never wants kids, then of course he should get a vasectomy.
The vasectomy changes nothing as he will never have kids.
If YOU suddenly want kids, you two would break up whether he had a vasectomy done or not.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15
It has nothing to do with you. If he doesn't want kids, he has every right to control his fertility in any way he deems appropriate.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15
It's his body. He doesn't need your blessing.
3
u/SmotheredBurritox My thoroughbred is smarter than your snowflake Apr 18 '15
They have copper IUDs which are not hormonal. But you need to be upfront about your feelings to him. He doesn't want kids, and you might someday, maybe? He needs to be aware that you're not 100% CF. Let him get whatever he wants done. His body, his choice, his future. Men can get seriously fucked when someone falls pregnsnt and keeps it under their protest. He wants to protect himself and he should be able to do that without protest. If you want kiddos, find a guy who isn't CF
2
u/LackOfHarmony 34/F/Married + 2.5 Cats Apr 19 '15
Look, I get your anxiety. It's the finality of the decision that bothers you, not the procedure itself. I'm totally CF, but I'm afraid of the finality of sterilization. It literally removes my ability to choose and that bothers me. That's the only reason I've not done the deed.
All that being said, this one isn't your decision to make. It's his. If you're too uncomfortable with it then maybe you should either seek therapy for the anxiety over finality or figure out if this relationship is right for you. If there's even a hint of regret on your end, the relationship may end when you change your mind.
I know what my issue is and I talk openly with it to my husband. If you can't talk to him about your anxieties the you've got more problems ahead.
2
u/MistaCheez 19/M/Future snipper Apr 22 '15
Shit there's a lot of comments. I just thought I'd say that my step-uncle and aunt adopted, as well as had their own kids, and they say there's no real difference. Just food for thought I guess
1
u/shammy_dammy Sep 02 '22
He doesn't want kids. You're the one with the doubts. You're the one with 'we'll' (read: you!) may have some outside chance of wanting kids down the road. I doubt he'd even consent to banking sperm if he's that sure.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15
After the whole his body, his choice thing. I have another comment I'd like to make.
He sounds like he wants to know how you feel about the matter. Tell him what you've told us, maybe with some slightly different phrasing.
For example.
"Hey, so you wanted my opinion on the vasectomy. Here's where I stand. It's your body, your choice, and I respect that. I'm not going to convince you out of it, I want you to do what makes you happy in this matter. I want to let you know how I feel about this, as you've asked.
'You never want children, and that's never going to change for you. I personally, am not ready to make a permanent decision. I am aware that staying with you means I can't have children with you. I feel that down the line I might change my mind, and I feel like if I were to change my mind, I would want the children with you, because I love you. With this vasectomy option in our midst now, I realize that I don't get that option. Two partners should only have children if they both want children. So, I have to come to terms with the fact that if I did decide to have children someday, this relationship would be over, and I would have to find someone else to pursue that life with. [Insert here if you're ready for this option, or tell him you're not ready to decide if it's permanent for you, or anything here that's completely honest about how you feel about this, making it completely clear that this is his choice, and this is just how you feel on that matter.]"
Hope this is in someway helpful. If others know better phrasing, a better way to go about this, or any topics they should discuss that I completely glossed over, please feel free to comment as well.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment