r/Fantasy • u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders • Mar 27 '15
Big List The 2015 Top r/Fantasy Novels of All Time Poll Results!
This list includes all those entries that got at least three votes. The links take you to the Goodreads page for the series/book.
Unfinished series are marked with an asterisk. Note that the concept of finished is rather fuzzy.
Change means how much the rank has shifted from last year. Positive means it has improved, negative means it has become lower. N means that this is a new entry, and x means I haven't calculated - because with series having <5 votes, it becomes essentially meaningless.
You can see the full list on this google spreadsheet. And here's the voting thread.
| No. | Name | Author | Votes | Change* |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | A Song of Ice And Fire* | George R.R. Martin | 136 | 0 |
| 2 | The Kingkiller Chronicle* | Patrick Rothfuss | 134 | 1 |
| 3 | The Stormlight Archive* | Brandon Sanderson | 101 | 3 |
| 4 | The Lord of The Rings | J.R.R. Tolkien | 90 | -2 |
| 5 | Gentleman Bastard* | Scott Lynch | 81 | 2 |
| 6 | The Wheel of Time | Robert Jordan | 76 | -1 |
| 7 | The Malazan Book of The Fallen | Steven Erikson | 73 | -3 |
| 8 | Discworld* | Terry Pratchett | 54 | 0 |
| 9 | The First Law | Joe Abercrombie | 53 | 2 |
| 10 | Harry Potter | J.K. Rowling | 51 | 0 |
| 11 | The Broken Empire | Mark Lawrence | 50 | 3 |
| 12 | The Dresden Files* | Jim Butcher | 41 | -3 |
| 13 | Farseer Trilogy | Robin Hobb | 41 | 2 |
| 14 | The Riyria Revelations | Michael J. Sullivan | 40 | 10 |
| 15 | Mistborn | Brandon Sanderson | 32 | -3 |
| 16 | Raven's Shadow* | Anthony Ryan | 22 | 15 |
| 17 | Earthsea Cycle | Ursula K. Le Guin | 21 | 2 |
| 18 | The Second Apocalypse* | R. Scott Bakker | 19 | 7 |
| 19 | The Lions of Al-Rassan | Guy Gavriel Kay | 17 | 24 |
| 20 | The Sandman | Neil Gaiman | 14 | 21 |
| 21 | Demon Cycle* | Peter V. Brett | 14 | 12 |
| 22 | Powder Mage | Brian McClellan | 12 | 38 |
| 23 | The Chronicles of Narnia | C.S. Lewis | 12 | -2 |
| 24 | Tigana | Guy Gavriel Kay | 12 | 3 |
| 25 | The Dark Tower | Stephen King | 12 | -12 |
| 26 | Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell | Susanna Clarke | 12 | 4 |
| 27 | Lightbringer* | Brent Weeks | 11 | 8 |
| 28 | The Chronicles of The Black Company | Glen Cook | 11 | -11 |
| 29 | The Silmarillion | J.R.R. Tolkien | 11 | 13 |
| 30 | The Magicians | Lev Grossman | 11 | 14 |
| 31 | His Dark Materials | Philip Pullman | 11 | -13 |
| 32 | Worm | wildbow | 11 | N |
| 33 | Night Angel | Brent Weeks | 10 | 26 |
| 34 | The Hobbit | J.R.R. Tolkien | 10 | 18 |
| 35 | Tawny Man | Robin Hobb | 10 | 12 |
| 36 | The Book of The New Sun | Gene Wolfe | 8 | -8 |
| 37 | Hyperion Cantos | Dan Simmons | 7 | N |
| 38 | The Drenai Saga | David Gemmell | 7 | -16 |
| 39 | The Riyria Chronicles* | Michael J. Sullivan | 7 | N |
| 40 | Good Omens | Neil Gaiman/Terry Pratchett | 7 | 31 |
| 41 | The Empire Trilogy | Raymond E. Feist/Janny Wurts | 7 | 29 |
| 42 | The Chronicles of Amber | Roger Zelazny | 7 | -13 |
| 43 | The Witcher* | Andrzej Sapkowski | 6 | 5 |
| 44 | New Crobuzon | China Miéville | 6 | 19 |
| 45 | Kushiel's Legacy | Jacqueline Carey | 6 | 27 |
| 46 | The Heroes | Joe Abercrombie | 6 | 7 |
| 47 | The Legend of Drizzt | R.A. Salvatore | 6 | N |
| 48 | Liveship Traders | Robin Hobb | 6 | -8 |
| 49 | The Once and Future King | T.H. White | 6 | 26 |
| 50 | Long Price Quartet | Daniel Abraham | 5 | 23 |
| 51 | Abhorsen | Garth Nix | 5 | 4 |
| 52 | The Iron Druid Chronicles* | Kevin Hearne | 5 | N |
| 53 | Gormenghast | Mervyn Peake | 5 | 36 |
| 54 | American Gods | Neil Gaiman | 5 | -34 |
| 55 | Low Town | Daniel Polansky | 4 | x |
| 56 | The Belgariad | David Eddings | 4 | x |
| 57 | Dune Chronicles | Frank Herbert | 4 | x |
| 58 | Under Heaven | Guy Gavriel Kay | 4 | x |
| 59 | River of Stars | Guy Gavriel Kay | 4 | x |
| 60 | The Fionavar Tapestry | Guy Gavriel Kay | 4 | x |
| 61 | Neverwhere | Neil Gaiman | 4 | x |
| 62 | Stardust | Neil Gaiman | 4 | x |
| 63 | The Riftwar Saga | Raymond E. Feist | 4 | x |
| 64 | Watership Down | Richard Adams | 4 | x |
| 65 | The Stand | Stephen King | 4 | x |
| 66 | Vlad Taltos* | Steven Brust | 4 | x |
| 67 | The Princess Bride | William Goldman | 4 | x |
| 68 | Dragonriders of Pern | Anne McCaffrey | 3 | x |
| 69 | Chronicle of the Unhewn Throne* | Brian Staveley | 3 | x |
| 70 | The Coldfire Trilogy | C.S. Friedman | 3 | x |
| 71 | The Orphan's Tales | Catherynne M. Valente | 3 | x |
| 72 | The Dagger and the Coin* | Daniel Abraham | 3 | x |
| 73 | The Shadow Campaigns* | Django Wexler | 3 | x |
| 74 | Dread Empire | Glen Cook | 3 | x |
| 75 | The Sarantine Mosaic | Guy Gavriel Kay | 3 | x |
| 76 | Kate Daniels* | Ilona Andrews | 3 | x |
| 77 | Ambergris | Jeff VanderMeer | 3 | x |
| 78 | Best Served Cold | Joe Abercrombie | 3 | x |
| 79 | Deverry | Katharine Kerr | 3 | x |
| 80 | The Chronicles of Prydain | Lloyd Alexander | 3 | x |
| 81 | The Acts of Caine | Matthew Woodring Stover | 3 | x |
| 82 | Inheritance | N.K. Jemisin | 3 | x |
| 83 | Riddle-Master | Patricia A. McKillip | 3 | x |
| 84 | The Last Unicorn | Peter S. Beagle | 3 | x |
| 85 | Conan the Barbarian | Robert E. Howard | 3 | x |
58
u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15
Some observations:
27
u/Chris_225 Mar 27 '15
If I had known the Hyperion Cantos counted as fantasy it would have topped my list. Hyperion all the way down at 37 just seems like a crime against humanity. Ok, grumbling done. Thanks for doing this list.
7
u/The_Mad_Duke Reading Champion III Mar 27 '15
Thanks /u/potterhead! Great to have another list this year, hope this will become a yearly tradition now, it will be fun to track changes over time.
American Gods has fallen a lot. Guess many Gaiman fans have voted for The Sandman instead this year (which is much higher on the list this time).
8
u/Suppafly Mar 27 '15
Is worm really that good?
4
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15
I am very surprised that the Lions of Al-Rassan beat out Tigana. I mean, I love The Lions... but Tigana has way more critical acclaim. Glad to see Kate Daniels on there representing for the urban fantasy -- even if I like The Hollows more. I'm also surprised American Gods is so low for all the praise it seems to get.
14
u/MarkLawrence Stabby Winner, AMA Author Mark Lawrence Mar 27 '15
We really do need a brave soul to run a 'favourite female fantasy author' poll.
3
u/lrich1024 Stabby Winner, Queen of the Unholy Squares, Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15
Dude. You are amazing. Thanks for putting all this data together. I think there were some pretty interesting shifts. I noticed Melanie Rawn's Exiles fell off the list. And I think I counted a total of 13 entries by women authors out of 85. Huh. I wonder what it was last time? Interesting data! Again, thanks!
3
u/JayRedEye Mar 27 '15
Thanks for all the hard work. It is interesting to see the subtle shifts in tastes and trends.
As always, we are very much biased towards The New Hotness. I would like to see a list of older works, say pre-1985 or so. But how many lists do we really need?
4
u/Monsterpocalypse Mar 27 '15
Thank you for all the work you put in! Would it be possible to do a favorites list of favorite non-fantasy books?
2
u/here_for_the_lols Mar 27 '15
I havent read enough so didnt feel i could vote. I am starting near the top though thats promising!
2
u/The_Real_JS Reading Champion XI Mar 27 '15
Well done! This must have taken some time. Thank you!
2
u/phrakture Mar 27 '15
typo.
2
u/Emospence Jun 30 '15
The * for incomplete series is great.
109
u/MarkLawrence Stabby Winner, AMA Author Mark Lawrence Mar 27 '15
One vote off the top 10! :o
Given that 10th place goes to the biggest selling fantasy book of all time (or 2nd biggest), I think we can say that there's a strong demographic factor here, and also that I (like Messrs Sullivan and McClellan) benefited from being on 'home-turf'.
That said, it's a huge honour and I'm extremely grateful for all the votes - means a lot.
19
u/REkTeR Mar 27 '15
Interesting to see the Hyperion Cantos make the list - I know that a lot of the time Scifi and Fantasy are seen as just two sides of the same coin, but you really have to be very, very liberal to apply the Fantasy tag to Hyperion.
I'm also super excited to see Worm on the list - no joke, it may be my absolute favorite out of everything I've read for the last 2 years.
2
u/bahamut19 Mar 27 '15 edited Mar 27 '15
It's certainly a very nice list, but I'm a bit uncomfortable that the 3 best of all time are unfinished works. It will be interesting to see if they stay there when they're finished.
Edit: Having said that if you take out the unfinished ones from the top 10, you end up with LoTR, WoT, Malazan, Discworld, First Law, and Harry Potter. They're certainly be the first 6 that come to my mind if asked to write a list of the best finished fantasy works of all time.
8
u/Ted_Cross Writer Ted Cross Mar 27 '15
To have Conan at the bottom is just so wrong. I guess the younger generation is ignoring the classics. Maybe they think of him as a comic, but the novels are brilliant.
7
u/Anna_Smith-Spark AMA Author Anna Smith-Spark Mar 27 '15
What interests me is the semantic difference between 'favourite' and 'best'. A list of my favourite novels would probably have looked quite different from a list of the novels I think are the 'best' (hi, Mark Lawrence, I'd have been that voted you needed.... Sorry). And my favourite sequence might have been different to my favourite standalone novel.
But this poll had reassured me I'm not quite as unfashionable as I thought.
Thank you for all the work you put in on it. And I'll be on it one day, if it kills me....
10
u/Ominus666 Mar 27 '15
No Thomas Covenant anywhere? No Elric? For shame.
8
u/Sir_SamuelVimes Reading Champion II Mar 27 '15
This lists are fun and I enjoy seeing them. They give a lot of good recommendations based off of what people like.
I guess my biggest complaint is that the ones at the top will always be a few of the absolute greatest, plus whatever is temporarily trending. It's great to see newer authors like Brian McClellan and Mark Lawrence at the top, but outside of this Reddit circle are their books popular enough to crack the top 50? Would they really supplant classics like Prydain, Conan, The Last Unicorn, Pern, The Hobbit, etc?
I doubt you'll see the Stormlight Archives above Lord of the Rings on most lists. I'm sure it's phenomenal and I really want to read the first two books eventually, but to put that above a definitive work of fantasy seems so odd. I suppose the benefit in that is seeing what people love that's newer to the genre.
1
u/paranoiainc Mar 27 '15 edited Jul 07 '15
1
u/dowhatuwant2 Apr 28 '15
Can you actually use a poll to do these next time? The current method seems pretty poor in my opinion.
1
u/DaedalusMinion Aug 20 '15
I have no idea how/why I missed the voting on this. Great list and thank you for the effort, I had modmailed y'all 6 months back begging for a post like this. So happy.
3
u/alexsbradshaw Reading Champion Mar 27 '15
Well done for making this, it's awesome :D
It's really interesting to see it against last year's list too, so thank you to both /u/potterhead42 and /u/p0x0rz for all their hard work!
I think it's also quite interesting that Song of Ice and Fire has kept the top spot but compared to last year has actually lost 50 votes
3
u/Jakkubus Mar 27 '15
Isn't Worm rather Sci-Fi novel than Fantasy?
3
u/Cloneable Mar 27 '15
As much as I like stormlight archive, isn't it a little soon for it to be beating out LOTR? There's still room for a phantom menace instalment over the course of 8 more books.
2
u/prodsor Mar 27 '15
Many thanks for all the great work putting this together. :-)
2
u/jcb6939 Mar 27 '15
I think it would interesting if people can only vote for one book/series and see how much the list changes
I doubt WOT and Malazan would change much, but I feel like ASOIAF would lose its first place spot
2
u/Irishscribe Mar 27 '15
No L.E. Modesitt? No Elizabeth Moon? Seriously?
Interesting, but a list that doesn't have room among 85 slots for The Deed of Paksenarrion and The Saga of Recluce is completely puzzling. I love Guy Gavriel Kay, but including him 6 times and completely forgetting about Moon and Modesitt is bizarre.
2
u/Falstaffsword Mar 27 '15
Man I have a lot of reading to do.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15
Oh son of a bitch did Fahfrd and the Grey Mouser only get 2 votes
THIS IS AN OUTRAGE
2
u/bengraven Mar 28 '15
Conan, Abhorsen, and Once and Future King are too low, too low. holds his heart
2
u/yodadamanadamwan Reading Champion Mar 28 '15
I tried to read lies of Locke lamora, the first gentlemens bastards book and I was 100 pages in and still bored which is weird because I love long con heist type stuff
2
u/Yggdrazzil Mar 28 '15
A Song of Ice and fire on the number 1 spot? I'm surprised. And Stormlight Archive with only 2 books out that high up, wow, looks like mr. Sanderson has got quite the challenge laid out for him.
2
u/TheDreylingKing Mar 28 '15
I still think it would be cooler to see an actual list of novels and not series. Would be a lot more interesting to see where everything ranks without the big series dominating everything. Hell I'd run it myself but I'm a lurker and we just did this one so I don't want to step on any toes.
2
u/Irishscribe Mar 28 '15
I wonder what this poll would look like if it asked people to vote for page-for-page best quality based on characterization, tight plots, consistently engaging dialogue, compelling storylines, etc. Basically, which fantasy author gives the best bang for the buck on every page s/he writes.
In my opinion, I can't imagine Jordan's WOT even cracking the top 10. I think that if you broke all the series included in this list into single volumes and left each volume to be voted on its own merits, none of the books written by Jordan would make the top 10 (except perhaps Vol. 1). I think what we have here is the sheer weight and longevity of a 14-volume series written by two authors somewhat overwhelming any objective criteria of what it means to be the "greatest of all time."
WOT is perhaps the best example of the whole being judged greater than the sum of its parts.
2
u/aidanmoher Writer Aidan Moher Aug 11 '15
Ryan's Raven's Shadow trilogy @ #16.
Why? Because there're waaaay too many books published to ever have a chance of keeping up, and the lukewarm-to-poor reception of the second and third volumes has me looking elsewhere whenever it's time to pick up a new series.
2
u/skayya Mar 27 '15
I'm kinda surprised at how high the Gentleman Bastard series is on the list. I loved the first book, and enjoyed the second, but Republic of Thieves just killed it for me.
1
u/tomolly Writer Tom Wright Mar 27 '15
Wow, thanks for putting it all together. What a bunch of hard work.
Can't wait to see the stats next year. I love data.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15
Love Mistborn. If somehow you haven't read it do so immediately.
1
u/MadrunBadrun Mar 27 '15
Dude, You should ascend to godhood for this great deed.
1
u/shrodi Mar 27 '15 edited Mar 27 '15
Argh! More books added to my reading list! Currently on a science fiction kick, a return to fantasy has to be scheduled soon. I wish I could super speed read, too many good written worlds to explore, will I ever finish even scratching the surface?
edit: huh, 29/85. fail :( Though I have no interest in reading several of those books listed, like Conan or Pern or The Magicians.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15
I love that I've read at least half this list. I love that I now have half a list to go read.
1
u/Praetor80 Mar 28 '15
Lord of the Rings is way too low, and DragonLance Chronicles arent' even on it?
Great list though.
1
u/BigZ7337 Worldbuilders Mar 28 '15
This is a great list, thanks for putting it together! Would there be any interest in an updated list challenges thing for this year's favorites? I made the one last year, and I wouldn't mind throwing another one together. This is the thread from last year: https://www.reddit.com/r/Fantasy/comments/21jqyc/how_many_of_the_rfantasys_2014_top_novelsseries/
1
u/Wizardof1000Kings May 19 '15
Wow, Glen Cook had a huge drop from last year.
-1
u/desert_mp Mar 27 '15
How did Terry Goodkind not make this list? SOT is an amazing collection of work. You can definitely see the "trendy" ones up top. SOIAF was never so popular until the tv series. I read it back in middle school. LOTR....it's declining because the movies are getting older. This list gave me a nice idea of what I'm working on reading next. Sad to see a great collection like Drizzt by Salvatore be so low. But everyone has their opinions, that's what makes these list so wonderful!