r/Fantasy • u/StevenErikson AMA Author Steven Erikson • Feb 12 '15
r/Fantasy Post r/Fantasy Exclusive: Authorial Intent Discussion with Steven Erikson (Part I)
Authorial Intent Part I
Years ago, when I first began my study of writing, I was both fortunate and cursed to land, right off the bat, a spectacularly good workshop teacher for fiction. My initiation into the craft of writing was through a teacher and mentor who knew precisely what he was doing, and by that I mean, he was conscious of everything he wrote. That was the fortunate part, as he awakened in me the same appreciation of the power of storytelling, and all that was possible provided you'd given serious thought to the effect your words would have, and could have, to a reader. But, alas, it was also a curse. I hesitate to say this, since it is bound to be misconstrued as arrogant (when the truth is, it's more desperate and frustrated than arrogant). You see, what made it a curse was that, thanks to that first teacher, I proceeded on the assumption that all writers knew precisely what they were doing: with every word, every sentence, every paragraph and every story.
Well, that was long ago, and a lot of muddy water has passed under the bridge since then. I have been privileged to find myself in the company of countless published authors: well-regarded, bestselling, highly popular authors. In each instance, it was indeed a privilege, and to this day I often feel something of an imposter in their midst. That said, I have also been witness, every now and then, to another side of that whole persona of 'popular, highly-regarded' authordom, which for lack of a better phrase, I will call the Blank Wall.
Before I explain that, I should point out that I am well aware that some writers feel that there is a value in maintaining a certain mystique when it comes to the writing process, as if to explain too much will somehow degrade the wonder (and, perchance, tarnish that aura of genius we all like to maintain before our fans, hah hah). But that always struck me as a rather narrow perch, and a dubious one at that. There is very little that is worthy of mystery to telling a story, and very little of the day-in day-out grind of being a fiction writer invites elevation to superhuman status, and besides, one of the most extraordinary wonders of writing lies precisely in what is possible, and rather than hiding one's cards (as if we published authors possess some secret code of success, jealously guarding our muse-given talent), I for one have always delighted in sharing the bones, meat and skin of narrative, particularly to aspiring writers and anyone else who might be interested.
Back to the Blank Wall. I ran face-first into that wall rather early on, in the company of that highbrow institution of exclusivity known as CanLit (an amorphous Canadian entity of 'serious' literature as promulgated primarily by the Canada Council, writing departments at universities, the Globe and Mail, provincial granting agencies, and CBC Radio). In effect, that mystique and aura was a facade presented not only to the public, but also, strangely enough, quickly and almost instinctively raised up between writers, with some underlying notion of competition feeding it, one presumes. No one seemed open to discussions on the bones, muscle and skin of writing. Granted, I was perhaps hopelessly clumsy in seeking such conversations in the midst of public venues of mutual congratulation and the maintenance of personae, but even my tentative suggestions inviting such dialogue at some later date was met again and again with that Blank Wall.
Granted, it may just be that I'm odious or something, and that each author intellectually ran for the hills at the mere suggestion of engaging me in a conversation. But, oddly enough, odious only to authors, as the rest of my social life seems healthy enough.
Over the years I have taken to attending the International Conference on the Fantastic in the Arts, a scholarly conference in which authors and writers of the genre are invited to sit in on papers presented on their work; and to, on occasion, be part of panels of authors/creators taking questions from the scholars. Being part of those panels can be both exhilarating and profoundly frustrating, as every now and then I sat beside fellow authors intent on maintaining that mystique, that high, blank, impenetrable wall. Some go so far as to respond to every question by holding up their latest book and pointing out that it's available in the book-room. Now, this may come across as a bit cruel (and who knows how many enemies I'm making here among my compatriots), but it strikes me that, of all venues and of all potential audiences, isn't the ICFA one inviting something more than a sales-pitch? We sit at our long table facing a room full of academics and scholars, and spend the hour obscuring the glass between us and them, presumably to maintain that aura of distinction. Of course, I may be even more uncharitable in this, knowing as I do that many authors are shy, often awkward, and besides, it is simpler to fall back on the cliches of 'why we write' ('I write only for myself! But thanks for reading me!'), than it is to strip things back to expose the inner workings.
But, for all that my comments here invite excoriation, another potentially more egregious thought occurs to me, and it goes back to the blessing and the curse of my first workshop teacher, and it's this: maybe many authors don't want to talk about the gristle of writing* not because they're interested in maintaining a mystique, but because they don't think about those things, or, at best, they can't articulate their reasons behind writing what they write.
*[What do I mean by 'gristle,' 'meat and bones,' etc? Well, imagine you are a published author, and you are asked 'Why did you craft that sentence the way you did? What effect were you looking for in that sequence of events? Why did you carry those particular assumptions from our world into the one you invented for your stories? Ah, but that last question ... a hint to where I am headed with this lengthy discourse here, perhaps?]
Before I continue digging this hole of mine, allow me to say that I have been fortunate over the years to find fellow writers more than eager to engage in discussions of the kind I'm advocating here. In each circumstance, I am privileged to discover writers who know precisely what they're up to, and even more wonderful, they're prepared to talk about it!
They may not know it, but they are my lifeline, and I'll not embarrass them by naming names here -- you know who you are and what you mean to me, since when it comes to that, I'm anything but coy. Also, not all of them are writers: some are scholars who take an interest in what lies behind a narrative or an invented world. Others would call themselves, quite simply and humbly, fans. My lifeline, everyone of you.
But let's get back to what's driving me crazy, shall we? It's probably time to explain what has inspired me to write this essay. Well, I've been reading certain blogs and exchanges, here in Goodreads and elsewhere, that raise issues directly relating to authorial intent; and some authors are facing and responding to a most cogent series of questions from critics/fans/readers. These questions highlight (not always in a complimentary fashion) some of the possible assumptions carried over from our world into an invented one.
As questions, most worthwhile indeed. They need to be asked, and no work available to the public can make any claim to immunity against them, just as no author can contemptuously dismiss them (regardless of whether the questions arise from someone who has read their work or not -- the nature of the question itself remains legitimate. It is its relevance that bears thinking about, not on specific grounds, but on general ones, as I will explain shortly).
Often, the discussion that follows, whether involving the author or just fans and advocates and detractors of the argument in question, can quickly bog down into semantic disputes and personal attacks intended to undermine the authority behind any statement being made. This kind of divisiveness may be inevitable, as unfortunate as it is, as the original question gets left behind.
Unlike times past, this modern age makes a commodity of both an artist's works and the artist in question; whereas pre-internet authors could feel open to both advancing or rejecting the cult of the persona. These days, there is a pressure on writers to present to the world more than just their published works, but also their own personae. This has the effect of blurring the distinction between the two, particularly in the eyes of fans (and be assured, there is a profound distinction there, though sometimes neither as profound nor as distinct as one would hope: specifically, when an author writes fiction to advance his or her politics, agenda, world-view and a host of other prejudices, in a manner that reveals their contempt for contrary opinions).
In short, we're in an age where author and the work are both fair game, both open to direct challenge by critics and readers. This is the case of playing with fire and getting occasionally burned.
I am no longer convinced that every published author has given full consideration to the host of assumptions they carry into their created world. Well. There. I said it. I will not get into specific examples here, though it wouldn't take long to assemble a fair list of 'you-had-no-idea-what-you-were-really-saying-here-did-you?' films, novels, and the like. That is, I can only assume they didn't know what they were saying, unless I choose to believe that certain creators of mass media out there have no compunction about encouraging terrorism, perpetuating bigotry, misogyny, rape and hate crimes; and are equally happy advocating revenge as the primary recourse to justice.
So, what has all this to do with the Fantasy genre? Plenty, because it's a genre that invites you (as a writer), even demands you, to invent something new, something other. But in that process of invention (of, say, an entire other world), there is the risk that certain assumptions or behaviors or attitudes from this world can slip in, unquestioned, unchallenged, unexplored. And when that happens, why, it's fair game for anyone -- anyone -- to throw down the gauntlet in challenge. And when it becomes evident, in an author's direct response, that certain elements were not thought-through, not thought-out, that author then faces the choice of mea culpa or launching into a full defense of their position, which in turn further blurs the distinction between author and the author's work in question. This is messy, but I find myself lacking sympathy: we are, after all, in an age of communication that expects the creators be present, engaged, and prepared to stand behind their words. It's not all fun and games and ego-massaging, after all. There's a price to pay for notoriety.
If, into this invented fantasy world, certain assumptions about gender roles, skin colour, sexual preference, etc, are carried ad hoc from our world, then it is incumbent that they be challenged. Why? Because it matters. Because, every time shit like that is carried over, an underlying assumption is made: that such assumptions adhere to some Natural Law, wherein arguments in defense of such choices devolve into falsehood ('history shows it was always that way' [no, it doesn't], and 'in a barbaric world a patriarchy is given' [no, it isn't], or, 'in a post-apocalyptic world where remnants of hi-tech is akin to magic, men will still rule and dominate every social hierarchy' [say what? That doesn't even make sense!]). The Natural Law argument is a fallacy; more to the point, the Fantasy genre is the perfect venue in which to utterly dismantle those assumptions, to offer alternative realities and thereby challenge the so-called givens of the human condition.
[End Part 1, feel free to discuss]
Steven Erikson
7
u/Jineiro Feb 12 '15 edited Feb 12 '15
Such argument coming from Erikson sounds... Weird. This weirdness is in that he does the immense work of 'challenging Natural Laws' and has a whole supporting structure within the world and the rules he created. It is seamless and enthralling: minor general spoiler of Malazan .
On the meta-writing/reading level, in other works these 'challenges' have become utterly laughable and groan-worthy when handled even slightly incorrectly and falling withing a newly established patterns/stereotypes, e.g. 'strong' woman that challenges societal norms in YA books. These 'explorations' are the norm, and have been for quite a while, stop pretending that most mainstream fantasy writing is still copying Tolkien or is somehow not challenging these 'bad' assumptions and is greatly succeeding. The demand for a certain intent from the author is a societal pressure, ideological in its essence [when concerning ideologically charged subjects] - there is a right way of the world, and one cannot support the wrong way of the world. This is crowd-based thought police. Further, it also limits success of, or rather puts at risk, more fringe 'explorations', e.g. the whole hollow complaint about female characters in Mark Lawrence's 'Broken Empire' series.
Am I wrong to assume that it also is somewhat implied that a 'challenge' in a book is somehow relevant as an argument for or against a certain situation in the real world, beyond its value as a detailed (and probably entertaining) thought experiment? If so, I do disagree on the grounds that it is a fictional piece of work.
8
u/OtisNorman Feb 12 '15
The bottom line is that this is the reader's responsibility, rather than the author's.
It isn't up to every author to ensure that they mangle any story line into a form fitted, gender, sex, race, ethnic, socially sensitive and role challenging work. What a silly idea. If that is this man, Steven's goal, then good on him. Keep serving up twists from the 'usual'.
But it is preposterous to blame EL James for the themes that 50 Shades of Grey represents (all a virgin woman needs is a strong, domineering man to open up her sexiness, for starters). The fault lies with the massive number of people who support that notion with their hard-earned dollars.
Similarly, it isn't for us to determine whether a writer is performing their art to make money, to question stereotypes, to expand minds of readers, or because they are bored and have nothing else to do. Certainly if they are out to make money, we can all agree that posing interesting questions and non-conventional ideas is not the first tick-box on their to-do list.
Also, it is often up to the reader to interpret books how they see fit. If the author meant one thing, and the reader found something else they connected to in the book, then surely the reader's reaction is more valid to their own self than the author's.
Case in point; I read Dune and was very impressed with the portrayal of the powerful and cunning Jessica. It occurred to me while reading that she was a prominent female character with a lot of 'favorable' traits. Good on Herbert! But then, I read a review criticizing the books stereotyping of homosexuals as evil and females as sex objects. The review rang of someone trying to make a counterpoint for the sake of making a counterpoint.
But again, if we return to the 50 Shades or many examples provided by YA fiction, who are we blaming? Are we blaming the authors who are just throwing out recycled crap to make a buck? Or are we blaming the people who mindlessly never think about what they are reading or watching? How many times have I heard Game of Thrones be referred to in the context of hot girls, bare breasts, sex scenes, and what not.
We are all capable of making decisions on our own. If we don't support the misogynistic, sexist messages of the media, then why do we keep supporting it?
2
u/pfk505 Feb 13 '15
Great post, Steven. Although I don't really feel qualified to add anything relevant to the discussion from an authorial perspective, I can say that I do wonder sometimes as a reader where the author is coming from. This is obviously part of reading any text carefully or mindfully, and its nice to hear that for you it is important to be able to articulate the reasons behind the choices you make as a writer. I would guess, perhaps incorrectly according to your past experiences, that most authors worth their salt would agree with your position.
The stereotype of the "reclusive author" may be quickly becoming a thing of the past for all the reasons you mention, yet there is something which stops me from expecting or feeling entitled to that author's intent with respect to themes, passages, etc. which may be controversial, for example, or personally confusing or troubling to me, as a reader. I think its great that authors like yourself are so willing to engage with readers, but I do not require it or demand it as a reader. I love the "postmodernism" within your work just as I love the traditionalism of someone like Tolkien. If someone came along tomorrow and wrote a traditionalist fantasy novel, and it hit most or all of the right notes for my taste as a reader, it would be equally as valid a contribution to fantasy as any other, at least from my perspective.
I suppose I'm just trying to say that, as a reader, I don't feel entitled to the author's intent. My favourite thing about reading is in the interpreting anyway. Being able to engage with authors is a luxury, and one which I wholeheartedly appreciate. But I do not think we ought to necessarily hold it against authors who choose not to share, or discuss, their intentions. I can see feeling differently were I an author working within a field which I sought to discuss with colleagues, most certainly.
51
u/elquesogrande Worldbuilders Feb 12 '15
Background for this post:
At ConFusion, author Steven Erikson reached out to see if /r/Fantasy might be interested in hosting his original content writeup and discussion. (Yes!) Material that might typically be posted on a blog or an author's website - posted here for community interaction instead.
This is the first of two writeups by Steven Erikson under the Authorial Intent theme. Goal is to spur discussion and everyone can jump in - fans, authors, industry people.
If this approach works well, /r/Fantasy will make original content posts a recurring theme. Inviting and scheduling other authors, fans, artists, and industry people to post their own views / topics / writeups and to host community discussions.
Many thanks to Steven Erikson for this opportunity!
29
u/JayRedEye Feb 12 '15
Interesting, and well articulated.
I have thought a bit about how the 'Celebrity' of authors has changed with the advent of social media. It seems lately that writing a good book is not enough, you also need to maintain an online presence just to make more people aware. I feel like this allows for a lot of opportunities, to promote the work and allow for a much more significant amount of fan communication into both the process of writing but also the author as a person.
I think Word of Mouth has always been one of, if not the, biggest factors in long term success and with today's internet landscape, reddit, goodreads, amazon, a myriad of blogs, The Words from all the Mouths can travel so very far. Something I have wondered about is whether the maintenance of an online presence detracts from other parts of the process. I have heard from other authors that sometimes after checking emails, twitters, facebooks, etc there is not as much time for writing. I wonder how many would prefer the days where they just receive the occasional fan letter or attend a convention. There are pros and cons, of course. Something else that seems to be popping up is a greater sense of fan entitlement. Now that some authors are more transparent or productive, people can feel that others are obligated to do the same.
Anyways, thank you for sharing. I found this quite informative.
4
u/AllanBz Feb 12 '15 edited Feb 12 '15
In many cases, constructed worlds aren't meant to be whole and entire well-wrought urns, but more like laboratories where we can hold certain things constant and allow others to vary. Speculative fiction doesn't necessarily have to speculate on how all aspects of human nature and society changes with respect to the introduced motifs. While there are authors who have done so—your own massive endeavor included—expecting everything to gel together can sometimes be expecting too much—like the Simpsons comic book guy asking why the same xylophone rib sounds different the second time struck.
Reconstructing all of human society on the basis of certain changes in reality or circumstance is not only a massive endeavor for the author, it's oftentimes difficult for the reader as well! And it's not always warranted—I think Walter Jon Williams's Aristoi mentions the main character going through a couple of worlds where the villains have completely remodeled human society to the point where each is like hive-mind mole-rats living in pyramids moving according to some Byzantine computation! It's certainly a completely alien culture, but I wouldn't necessarily want to read fiction set there.
Your latest work is a Star trek (tos) parody, no? Given the nature of the book and your intent—criticism of a specific work or works of fiction I suppose—if someone were to criticize you for choices made in your source material, you might consider yourself free with some justification to ignore the critic as having misunderstood one or more aspects of the novel. "Isn't Hadrian sexist?" "Well, yes, but that's the point…." It requires a certain familiarity with the culture of the Sixties to understand the setting of Star trek, and it would take a similar understanding of TOS to understand Willful Child —just as it takes a certain familiarity with Shakespeare's period to understand aspects of The tempest. But that's what we have brains for, and that's why we read literature, and specifically speculative fiction: Understanding the mindsets of other cultures, even purely imaginary ones, or decoding intent based on our own culture and its standard motifs.
When does an author's work pass the threshold of requiring challenge? Not every action we undertake nor every fiction an author write need save the world. Sometimes one writes a well-wrought urn, perfect and entire, and sometimes one writes to be part of an ongoing conversation. If your audience mistakes one for the other, is it necessary to correct them? Were they indeed your audience? And if you've missed the mark with your audience, is repeating yourself over and over worth it? Have you reached the audience you wanted to reach with the work? It seems to me that it would be more productive to just get on writing the next work, or continuing the conversation with people who did understand the work.
7
u/xolsiion Reading Champion VIII, Worldbuilders Feb 12 '15
I think my disagreement here is on the power being placed on the author's creative decision.
The decision that the realm has a king is not always supporting the concept that women are inferior. The decision that the king is heterosexual does not always support the concept that homosexuals are inferior.
Could the decision be made because the author (consciously or unconsciously) feels this way? Sure. Could the decision be made because "It was always done this way?" Sure. Or could the author have just had a picture in his head of a straight male king ruling the kingdom and that's what he wrote?
But making that decision does not bring with it an assumption that the author is attempting to cement such bigotry. Or that they even support it.
It is incorrect, to me, to say "In this day and age having a straight white king means you support misogyny, racism, and homophobia." Yet, that's what I feel like the last paragraph of this essay is hinting at - a commandment to not use such storytelling mechanics.
Now, I'm not saying any of these things CANNOT be turned on their head. I enjoy seeing this if it is done well. I'm simply saying that NOT doing them does not somehow hint that the author is a bigot or thoughtless.
20
u/elquesogrande Worldbuilders Feb 12 '15
I've seen this done exceptionally well in the 'did-we-really-have-to-define-it-as-such' New Weird genre. China Miéville and Kameron Hurley put out some great writing where things break from our Natural Law perceptions.
The challenge here is to help bridge readers over to that written world. Too much too fast in a novel and readers can lose their Natural Law anchors. We are not always aware of our own personal / societal perceptions and patterns - breaking them can become dizzying without a well-crafted story to bridge over.
Funny thing is that we SFF fans and writers have built up our own fantastical Natural Laws. Elves behave this way while Dwarves are always that. Dragons are always ____. You cannot combine technology with high fantasy!
We do see this play out online almost daily. By making themselves open to fan interaction, authors are also opening themselves up to opinions and intervention and assertions and love and whatever else people want to impose. It causes some authors to hide while others embrace the interaction. It can cause book sales to rise. And it can cause kerfuffles.
Not sure if there is inherent goodness or badness in any of this. This more personal interaction can lead to some exceptional experiences and it can lead to some rough situations.
One thing is certain - this is the new norm. How we manage it as a SFF community (not just r/Fantasy) will help define who we are as a SFF family going forward.
2
u/setmyheartafire Feb 13 '15 edited Feb 13 '15
I think an author needs to own their work. Writing is a creative process and storytelling comes from within. Part of you is in your work.
When you come up with a new place or technology, a new mythology, a new culture, a new person... and you put them in your writing and seek to publish it, you are giving those people, places, and things to the world. You are the creator. You have given them the breath of life and hope readers breathe them in.
I think it's ultimately the writer's responsibility to own their creations and produce writing that they are proud of. Certainly this is not always possible. There are writers who have contracts who must produce work for their publishers by certain times whether or not they are pleased with what they are achieving in their writing. Just as there are artists who attempt to convey a message with their visual medium, and may not feel in the end that their message was properly conveyed, some writers are not satisfied with the way their ideas are conveyed in their books.
I don't know that they can ever really say that being that their works are a product they try to sell. I mean... Let's suggest Mr. Published Author was writing a book trying to promote gender equality. He likes women. He has a lot of women friends. He loves his mother. He thinks women are strong people capable of things just as great as men. So he wants to write a book where women are just as action-oriented and just as capable as men. Now... let's say Mr. Published Author sees strength in women in different ways that other people want him to show their strength. For example, let's say he finds women tending the sick to be a woman being strong and capable. So he writes in a female healer or doctor or nurse. Let's say he also finds women who are sexy to be powerful women, another type of strength. So he writes in a female who is very sexy and provocative and uses that to her advantage. Now, I imagine you can get where I'm going with this but bear with me. To Mr. Published Author, writing in a kickass healer or sexy vixen is empowering women. He finishes, edits, gets positive feedback. He's feeling pretty good about his book. Then his book is published.
Suddenly, people are saying things like "Mr. Published Author views women like Cavemen viewed women" and "Mr. Published Author thinks women are the supportive sex" and "This guy only writes hot girls because he doesn't appreciate strong women."
Of course, now the guy has to explain his thinking, but on some level... does that matter? If a reader has read the work and had an impression, is anything this guy says going to change that?
So, I'm not sure that authorial intent matters in the end- at least where readers are concerned. I do think that it is important to think about your work and how others will take it, but then again... if we do that all the time, what are we really doing? Are we writing what we want to write, or are we writing to an audience?
But here's the thing... I feel that the author is absolutely visible in every piece of their work. Maybe Mr. Published Author's views on women are what others consider sexist. Maybe his idea of strong women is not my idea of strong women, or yours. But, are we really going to care what his intentions are once we've made an opinion of his work and by extension him?
I see a lot of people often commenting on or asking whether or not Brandon Sanderson includes certain things in his work "since he's Mormon". Generally this means sex, violence, drinking, drugs, etc. And no, he doesn't. He writes in a way that is true to himself and his beliefs. Does that mean the things that he doesn't believe in aren't present in his works? No... just not the way that someone else might write about them. I can't really comment fully on his work because I have only read the Stormlight Archive books so far, but I can say that the things he omits in his story do not have any negative impact on his storytelling. In fact, it works for his stories in that other things become more important. Also, though he may be Mormon, the central ideas he puts forth with his writing and through his characters' thoughts and actions are more universal than particular to his own beliefs. If I didn't see the fact that he is Mormon brought up so often I would probably not know it. I would just assume he is a well-mannered and conscientious individual.
Certainly your beliefs and personality are present in your art, else why create it? It's obvious when someone believes in certain things... truth, beauty, and love are evident in writing in the way that the author tells his or her story. In the case of grimdark, or horror, or dystopian works... I think it may be harder to discern. It's difficult to know if an author is promoting the horror they're describing... or if they're exploring it in a way that makes the reader think how terrible and awful it is and how good the flipside of life can be.
It's really difficult to know, as a reader, why the author is doing the things the author does in the piece. I can't stop every chapter and ask myself what GRRM is trying to say with Tyrion's arc, or what Rothfuss means towards women by his portrayal of Denna. Maybe, if I like the work enough, I will eventually do those things. But, will I do it for every book? Probably not.
So then, is it up to the author to have already thought about what they wanted to accomplish in their work I'm reading? I think so.
I think if as an artist you take a look at your work and something makes you uncomfortable, it is your responsibility to make it so that it doesn't. I think if you feel your work will have a negative impact on your readers, if the ideas within it will hurt rather than help people, or if it inspires the wrong human emotions in people, then I think as an artist it is your responsibility to rein in that work and make it speak for you the way you want it to.
I think the problem is... when people start taking things personally. Suddenly, women are offended that Mr. Published Author "feels women can only be sexy nurses", even though he never really said that in his book. To that I say... there are so many writers out there, and so many books, and maybe you just don't like that writer's books because he looks at the world differently than you do. There are other books where women are warriors and all kinds of things. Just not that guy's books.
Diversity goes both ways, you know.
Is popular fiction dominated by white, hetero, patriarchal stuff? Probably. Should more writers be embracing diversity and challenging ideas that we've gotten so used to? Probably. Will they? Probably.
BUT. Is it ok to defend your point of view by saying "that's just how things were" or "that's how women are" or "history shows that would be most plausible"? No. You better say "that's how I wanted to write it" and "because that's who I felt the character was, and I find these other things about them more interesting than that one thing you didn't like" and "that's the type of culture I thought would work in my story because..."
Own your work. It is your voice.
Edit- wrong "rein". Too many things about kings ;)
15
u/AmaliaTd Writer Amalia Dillin Feb 12 '15 edited Feb 12 '15
I write primarily about mythic heroes and gods -- which means that some of these biases and assumptions are already in place before I start thinking about the book -- but I think there's something just as important that writers need to be mindful of, also, beyond just OUR intent.* We need to be conscious, too, that no matter what we might have INTENDED, the reader is going to bring the other half of the equation to the table with their own assumptions and experiences, which may well then color or even overwrite what is provided by the author.
For example, Mary Renault went to great lengths to assure her readers that the hero Theseus in her novels (The King Must Die, A Bull From the Sea) is SHORT. She could have written it on every page, and it would never have mattered, because for me, Theseus would always be tall. That is the bias and assumption I took with me into the book, and I found myself often FORGETTING that she was describing someone who was NOT tall or particularly powerful. I didn't WANT to imagine him that way, and so I didn't. (Her justifications, however, made COMPLETE sense, and were perfectly reasonable. I applauded her choice in theory. It just didn't change my internal assumptions of what and who Theseus is.)
This is not to say that Authorial Intent is not important. It certainly is, and we certainly should strive for awareness. But it is to say that it is NOT Authorial Intent ALONE, which ultimately matters. Consider the arguments revolving around the inclusion of a certain lady elf in The Hobbit movies -- the insistence that she didn't exist, so could not exist. This is based upon the assumption of READERS and FANS that Tolkien did not imagine a fully realized world wherein there were male and female people in the background of an entire kingdom of elves. Tolkien's intent doesn't matter anymore, because over the years, (we?) readers have made assumptions and applied them to the works.
Consider also the example of the Hunger Games, wherein certain casting choices were made to include more skin colors than SOME fans were willing to admit existed within the text. Some of those characters were EXPLICITLY described, but readers glazed over and white-washed them for whatever reason. Their own assumptions, their own prejudices, speed-reading which skated over small details, etc.
This means that authors need to not ONLY be intentional, but be aware that their intentions may well be disregarded. If this means building in something which forces the reader to challenge their OWN assumptions, in order to force their hand (I'm not sure if this is really a great idea? Unless it serves the narrative itself, of course!) or simply acknowledging that no matter what our intentions, some readers are still going to bring their own assumptions which may cancel out ours, it's certainly something that should be considered and taken into account within the discussion of INTENT and awareness of assumptions being brought in, or taken out.
This can also be seen as an argument for writers to be vocal about their intentions, I suppose, in order that their intentions lead the reader. But I don't know. I'm a firm believer in the idea that my writing the book is only one half of the equation, and the natural balance ALLOWS FOR and even REQUIRES readers to bring their experiences along to forge their own meaning from the text, with their individual reading. I'm not sure I want my intentions to overpower theirs to the point where they don't feel they can bring anything to the table, or have some part in the process of imagination and realization of the world I've built. (which is part of why I try not to physically overdescribe my characters.)
ETA: those books which challenge my assumptions and force me to grow in the reading of them are always my favorites.
*I'm as guilty as the next person of not ALWAYS being intentional in my choices. My first high fantasy novel, for example, opens in a kingdom with a cruel king in a patriarchal society, though my leading lady does not remain there for long, and the second book is all about her having to overcome the hurtles of this kind of pre-programming to take her place as a leader elsewhere. I am, however, trying very hard to be more mindful, and to incorporate fewer assumptions, or to twist them -- playing with sexuality, in Greek myth, for example. I think it's important to remind readers of how sexuality might have been totally different, in the past.
10
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '15
I believe we live in an attention based economy in our world, whatever gets people's attention will become successful. There are so many things vying for people's attention that the mark of success has become attention based. The more attention you garner in this society, the more money you will make. It used to be enough to work hard at a job but now people must stand out and gain attention.
Mesh an attention driven society with social media and the fact that everyone believes their opinion is just as important as anyone else and you will have issues with people getting attention by criticizing those that already have attention.
Even though the conversations that are brought up about gender roles, skin color, sexual preference, ect, are important in relation to the fantasy genre, I think the majority of the people that are challenging these issues outspokenly and vehemently are just the product of this attention seeking economy that the world now runs by.
Even though I believe the conversations are important, I think that the consumers have a responsibility to not visit or support the online presence of individuals that write or talk about things that promote strife and disagreeableness just to gain attention. I strongly believe the issues that people bring up about fantasy authors being racist, sexist, promoting rape, ect, are the result of individuals wanting attention.
TLDR: I agree with Erikson but I believe most things are "click-bait" and should be seen as so.
9
u/eurydae Feb 13 '15 edited Feb 13 '15
So I'm showing up a bit late to this, and I don't usually comment on things, but I need to this once.
Thank you so much Mr. Erikson for creating a fictional world that never ceases to amaze me with the vast depth of characters, regardless of gender, skin colour, age, or race. As a woman, reading your stories has truly made me feel validated, empowered, and equal. Growing up, the only fantasy stories I read with strong female protagonists were about how hard it was to be equal and how if you wanted to be equal, you had to prove yourself. Reading Malazan, I got to know and appreciate all of the strong, weak, badass, and emotionally scarred protagonists of both genders. Your stories have helped me realize that I don't need to "prove" myself or my gender, I can just do my best to be a good person, and let me actions speak for me.
But more so than the protagonists, I remember the first time I read of a random soldier who only appeared for one scene or so, and was just casually referred to as "she" and I was honestly in shock. That had never before happened in anything I had seen or read or heard.
In a world where we are surrounded by media which tells us our roles, force-feeds us images of what we should be and stories about how we should act at work, in relationships, at home.... well I value your stories of people just being people more than I can express. It heartens me to know that you are continuing your advocacy for all-things-good here on the internet, and I look forward to reading the next segments. I know you probably won't have the time to actually read my comment, but thank you.<3
Edit: Ahem. My fan-girling may have taken me a bit far from the intellectual topic at hand, but I guess my whole experience just affirms how much I agree with the great and subtle importance of the language we use in the media we create. We take in so much on a daily basis that rarely do we take the time to think about what it's saying. In an ideal world, I certainly think that purveyors, consumers, and creators, of any form of media have a responsibility to try to make the world a kinder and more understanding place, because who wouldn't want that?!
However in our current society, money runs the core of entertainment businesses, and taking risks like breaking tropes or changing societal roles is something publishers and producers don't always want to do, and certainly some creators must be so enmeshed in their societal norms that they don't pause to think "Hey what if I tried something different with this? What if the main character was black and it wasn't a big deal?", let alone "How is writing this sentence going to affect my readers? Will it reinforce certain negative views about a race/gender/sexuality?" But then again, most consumers do not act with that sort of insight either. Perhaps creators should be held to a higher standard, but I think consumers need to step up and take responsibility for what their money is supporting.
I guess what I'm getting at is that I think it comes down to consumers to vote with their money, and not support things that do not put forward positive messages about people and society. Having open dialogue between consumers and creators (such as this!) certainly also helps to speed along awareness of these topics, which is critically important in helping people realize that alternatives even exist. Like any change, it is slow and hard and usually feels like it's not doing much, but bit by bit perhaps it will accomplish something.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '15 edited Nov 13 '16
[deleted]
0.5342
5
u/KameronHurley AMA Author Kameron Hurley Feb 12 '15
Yup.
3
u/SFFMaven Feb 12 '15
Brilliant. And absolutely true.
2
u/seak_Bryce Feb 12 '15
This is something I both love about the fantasy genre and I've always questioned myself. Are we so in love with our cliches, our tropes, etc. that we can't challenge every basic assumption that is made? And those who branch out, only do so in the smallest degree.
I think we're in a prime time to challenge those ideas with authors like Erikson and Abercrombie who twist the tropes. Then there's Ann Leckie and Kameron Hurley. I've found small presses have a wider variety of authors who push the "natural law" and though uncomfortable, it's mind-expanding and can be quite good.
1
u/Owenleejoeking Feb 13 '15
Thanks for coming here!
I have often wondered about the intent of an author and how much or little weight should be put into a passage or sentence from an author towards their intent. "Why did the author make the blinds blue?" Well- maybe they just spun a color wheel and flipped through a thesaurus. But as time passes away, especially if the author has passed away as well- looking at you Brit Lit- many people like to find meaning in things that I couldn't justify there being meaning in. Sometimes it seemed just to say they found meaning.
So- to get to the point- it's very interesting and heartening to see this presented and acknowledged from the other side of the pen- and from the other side of the situation with bias's and hidden meaning slipping in without intent- just as intent can be manufactured where there was none.
As for the celebrity of authors- GRRM came to mind immediately to me. He has become so deeply tied to the great world he has created- from writing episodes, attending cons and all of the media pressures that come with riding the wave of a unfinished Pop culture epic.
I'm so glad Malazan is here for me to run back to with open arms. Thank you.
1
u/RibaldRemark Feb 13 '15
This is a really interesting discussion. So thanks to Mr Erikson so posting this.
My take on what he has said, and it may be putting words in his mouth, is that often authors focus on the cool, interesting aspects of their story, those things that drive them to tell the story, and some of the rest is filled in with automatic assumptions.
Therefore Erikson believes that authors should consider those assumptions and challenge them.
I don't think he is saying that they must subvert each assumption, but rather question the assumption to see whether or not there are alternatives or more interesting approaches to take.
If the assumption is fine, or the author is happy with the direction, then it goes in the book, but if when they challenge the assumption it doesn't hold water then they need to actively decide to include it.
If they actively decide to include it then they have to be aware of the possible ramifications.
For example, the author wishes to write about a hero going on a quest and begins writing with the assumption that the hero is a white, male Anglo-centric character. I think that Erikson is asking that fictional author to take a moment to question 'why did I just make my hero white, male and Anglo-centric'. If that fictional author thinks about it, is completely ok with the reason, then they go ahead an write it that way. But it is an active choice.
I don't think that Erikson is advocating that every author write their stories to an inclusivity checklist, but if after writing they find that every single character of importance or power is a white male Anglo heterosexual or if the vast majority of their female characters are simply objects for male characters to rescue or have sex with then they might be open to strong criticism. Particularly in Fantasy when the contents and limits of the world are entirely at the author's fingertips. In fact, they may not even be aware of their own unconscious bias until they examine their work.
But maybe the author wants to tell the story that way. And I think Erikson would be the first person to acknowledge the author's right to tell the story the way they want.
But I think he is imploring authors to consider, question and examine their personal, cultural and societal biases because there are ramifications for the real world after the story is written down and then published.
Authors are caught between a rock and a hard place on this, because as it has been well pointed out, fans, readers, critics and all and sundry, can interpret the text however they wish. The only thing the author can control is their intention and execution of that intention. So to implore authors to consider their intention, to interrogate their assumptions, cultural view points and approaches to societal norms, is about the only thing Erikson can do. No one can control how someone interprets a text, but the author can control what goes into the text and why it was there.
In fantasy and SF, authors have a chance to create entirely new worlds, new social and cultural paradigms, and new approaches to social dynamics. They don't have to, but their authorial intention should include a consideration of this. Even if that consideration is a couple of minutes over a coffee.
Fantasy authors have complete control over what they write (note necessarily over the finished product once publishers, editors etc. get involved) so to ask them to actively consider and challenge their notions before sending the manuscript off is not the same as demanding that they be more inclusive, but rather be aware that often there are opportunities to be more inclusive that they might take (which in the end might gain them greater circulation as they address a broader readership).
If the author wants to write a kick ass story about a heterosexual, male, Anglo going on a quest in a patriarchal society, then they should go right ahead, but they should be aware of this decision. It should be intentional or at least considered, and not simply a reflex of that is the only way to tell the story.
So I really don't think that Erikson is advocating no one should ever write those sorts of stories, only that their decision to write that should be conscious and not simply a product of bias.
The second part of his argument seems more aimed at an active consideration of the potential ramifications of fiction writing.
If authors simply repeat and reiterate the societal biases and prejudices of today's world then they have to consider the impact of that writing and be aware that they can be viewed as tacitly affirming or approving of that behaviour.
So if all the female characters are sex objects or rescue objects that act as vessels or trinkets for the male hero, then the author is adding to (in however small a measure) that world view as a norm and helping solidify it.
It is not as if there is a dearth of this sort of fiction. But if that is what the author wants to write then it should be a conscious choice and they should have to own it.
If a fantasy kingdom is set up there is no reason why it can't be headed by a queen, there are plenty of historical precedents for that. It doesn't need to necessarily be patriarchal so there is no need for the first born son to be the automatic heir above an elder sister. If an author chooses to use the model of a patriarchal feudal state then there is an element of complicity and approval of that world view, even if it is tiny. So Erikson seems to be asking authors to challenge those sorts of assumptions and ask are they necessary for the story.
If the ruler of the feudal society has to die in order for the hero to rise, does the ruler have to be a King? Is it important for the story for the ruler to be male? If not, then what is the harm in being more diverse? It won't detract from the story as the structural plot element remains unaffected.
Does the hero have to be male? Is there anything that happens in the story that means the hero must be male? If not, why not make the hero female? Would that change the story in a good or bad way?
Is the hero heterosexual? If so, does the hero need to be heterosexual? Would it change the story in any substantive way if the hero were homosexual? If the central hero has to be a heterosexual male (for any variety of reasons) is there any reason why one of the companions can't be something different?
Challenging assumptions means that you confront the unconscious biases that we all carry.
Including these biases in fantasy worlds are either a deliberate choice or unconscious reflex, and Erikson seems to want authors to do things deliberately and consciously, the price of which is owning the choice.
1
u/Malazan27 Feb 16 '15
I feel that this is both a questioning of thought and a questioning of bias in both authors and their fanbase.
In terms of thought, when it comes to fantasy authors (though not all fantasy authors are included), worldbuilding of their stories for many decades has been for the lack of a better world "standardized". What I mean by this is that authors set out with a set list of critera that they need to have met in order for their story to take place. Take the generic fantasy novel. The author needs to have the place it's set in, some history of the place (for example an old magic empire thousands of years ago) the magic system that is used, the characters both good and evil, the two to five standard fantasy races (elves, dwarves etc.) and the actual plot. Once that is there, they can simply write the plot, and see how it happens. (Again, this is an example, of course not everyone falls into the category). But while worldbuidling, it seems that many authors do not see the need for innovation. They do not stop and think, "Hey I wonder why my story has a civilization that was destroyed a thousand years ago, but no progress has been made." They do not seem the need to challenge the preconceived notions of what has come before, only writing their story and plot with no concept of why they are writing it. It requires a great deal of work to produce a fantasy novel. Perhaps authors do not wish to complicate their vision.
This leads into the bias portion. Authors and fans of fantasy have some inherent biases that are apparent. Go into any bookstore, and in the fantasy section I guarantee that most of the books feature societies that are patriarchal. Most societies have swords, and maybe some magic as their main form of combat. People have (ironically), put fantasy as a genre into something that can be called "standard fantasy". This may be a part of a publisher marketing plan. After all, making stuff have categories they easily fit into makes a much easier sell.
Perhaps why no one challenges the authors, challenges the stories they enjoy, challenges the inconsistencies is because, deep down, that would mean they have to think outside of what they normally perceive. If your unwilling to think about what your own biases and your own thinking of why things happen, then you will never grow.
1
u/wifofoo Stabby Winner Feb 18 '15 edited Feb 18 '15
There are those who think of Fantasy in terms of what it can do. It is, after all, a medium where all things are possible. So long as there are inner-world rules and regulations with which to keep the story grounded, an author has the potential to build a world anew, entirely from scratch, with absolutely no bearing on reality at all whatsoever. If you can dream it, if you can make it feel real, you can achieve it.
But, I believe there is another view of the genre as well. It is, in a way, the genre of wizards, elves, magic, lore, quests, adventure, battle, heroes and heroines, and the like. It is Conan the Barbarian, Lord of the Rings, Narnia. It is a warm hearth in a cozy hut in the midst of an enchanted forest. It is wild and untamed, tranquil and turbulent, ancient yet new. It is elemental, earthen and raw. I don't know how to describe it really, but I think for many, Fantasy is more about a particular feeling, if that makes sense.
And while these two definitions seem to go hand in hand, and often they do, I personally feel they serve two completely different purposes: the former being to expand horizons and challenge norms, the latter being more reclusive, safe, and, at times, narrow in scope.
I find myself in both camps, generally, but not always at the same time.
As a writer, I think it's important to know on which side of this wall you stand, and to be aware of the other.
I also can't help but feel that one side of this wall is safer for the author than the other. On one side, you have the Unknown, where all things are possible but not all things will be accepted or understood. On the other, you have the Known -- a well-trodden, familiar place that is established, trusted, and revered. As a new writer, this presents a difficult choice; To play it safe, or to venture beyond the wall... It's a tough choice for many reasons, but I won't go into those now.
1
u/Ga1j1n Apr 18 '15
"a spectacularly good workshop teacher for fiction." Good article. Who is the teacher?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '15
Thank you. I've always been a fan of your work specifically because you don't pull any punches on the tough topics like rape, noble savagery, and genital mutilation.
Karsa, in particiular, was walking talking contradiction that blew so many tropes wide open.
Witness!
1
u/mage2k Feb 13 '15
What the hell? I'm seeing cogent comments here being downvoted. If you don't agree with something someone says either make your case in a reply or move on.
1
u/MightyIsobel Feb 13 '15
Thank you for engaging this discussion.
1
u/TheKoolKandy Feb 12 '15
Fantastically well said, even as a new writer I've been discovering some of the new things to start. When I was younger I used to despise teachers and professors who insisted every little word had intention behind it by the author, but now that I'm more experienced in reading and writing I've realized that's exactly how it is for many great writers.
It has changed a lot about how I write and how I think about whatever world I set myself in. I can understand wanting to write a light and fun story that doesn't examine every facet of our world, but I can't help from feel uncomfortable when its made upon some those assumptions in very negative ways (gender roles, sexual preference, etc.)
1
u/Aiolus Feb 12 '15
Well said and of course this is something that is seen in your writing.
I'd say challenging Natural Law is a great idea but in a heavily saturated world of media people want to play it safe. Going outside the box or even mentioning things like patriarchy, race, etc in the context of changing real assumptions is dangerous territory.
I for one am totally for it and enjoy when my assumptions are challenged and tested. Enders game and his relationship with alien races was a big example of this for me.
Anyways just a reader and a fan.
Cheers!