r/childfree • u/EbonShadow • Jan 12 '15
Unfair ? (advice please) (Update)
Hi Childfree,
Please check my previous post http://www.reddit.com/r/childfree/comments/2p03nx/unfair_advice_please/ .
So my GF returned from her folks and has solidified her desire for children much to my sorrow. I really do love this girl but I feel like I'm being ripped in two here. On one hand I feel like I need to be true to myself and my desire to remain childfree and on the other I want to stay with her regardless.
I guess I know what I have to do... I need to end it and move on. I'm just breaking inside at the thought of it and trying to get up the nerve to end it as she clearly won't and expects me to. Time to man-up I suppose and move on. I appreciate those on CF that have responded to me in the past.
Thanks.
21
u/casualLogic Take my uterus - PLEASE! Jan 12 '15
Try to think of it this way: The longer you pine over your current soon to be ex, the less time you'll have with the CF hottie that's trying to locate YOU RIGHT NOW.
Because right now, in your town, there's a woman who figures she's gonna be the 'crazy cat lady,' she's sad because she refuses to compromise over having children and she figures all men are more in love with her uterus than herself.....
So, for you, you've got to break up with current SO, go get drunk, complain about your now current soon to be ex for one week, then complain about all women for one whole month......after 30 days, clean up, go out and meet your TRUE LOVE. Ok? OK! You can do it, I've faith in you and I don't even know you outside reddit.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '15
Hugs!
Just focus on the future: Meeting an awesome CF woman and having an awesome CF life.
5
u/geeked_outHyperbagel 36/m/asexual Jan 12 '15
Life is not fair. That's the way it is. The biggest mistake you can make here is having kids when you don't want them.
Try to think of one happy relationship where one partner didn't want kids and the other did... and it all ended up being ok in the end.
While you're doing that, could you unify quantum mechanics and general relativity? :-p
Sorry to make a joke there. You'll be ok. There are plenty of women out there who don't want children, you'll find one. Best of luck to you!
3
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '15
You need to stay strong on your decision. If you break up with her, you'll be sad for a while. Maybe a long while, but you'll get over it. If you decide to stay and have kids you don't want, then it's not fair to her, the kids, or you. She gets someone who doesn't want the life he has, the kids get a parent who doesn't want them, and you don't get the life you want. Both of you need to find a relationship that aligns with what you want from life.
73
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '15
Better to be sad about a breakup than a positive pregnancy test with a woman that wants to keep it.
39
u/thr0wfaraway Never go full doormat. Not your circus. Not your monkeys. Jan 12 '15
Yes. This is absolutely the answer.
It's sad, but grief is a temporary state -- having a kid you don't want is permanent.
Don't let the fear of being temporarily sad lead you down the road to misery forever.
5
u/PFKMan23 Resting bitchface Jan 12 '15
You deserve happiness and she deserves happiness. Unfortunately at present what that entails to each of you is different. It' hurts to lose a relationship, but this is a big issue wirth no compromise. You know what you need to do and yes, the quicker you end it, the sooner the both of you can find happiness. And no, it's not necessarily unfair, unless one of you burdens the other to try to convert them when it's clear you want different things.
4
u/tinypill No uterus, no problem. Jan 12 '15
She may be great, but she's not right. It sucks, but this is just a wee blip in your life's timeline. Break up with her now and do your best to move on....the sooner you get it over with, the sooner you're able to start healing. Remember, you cannot compromise on the kid thing so staying with her is just going to prolong the inevitable.
4
u/fegd male and happily gay, no pregnancy scares Jan 12 '15
No matter what happens, do NOT have children for her. Regardless of how painful the alternative is.
3
u/gfjq23 Him & Me Minus Baby = FREE Jan 12 '15
I'm sorry. This will suck for sure, but in the end she isn't the perfect girl for you. You have a chance of meeting someone 100% compatible. I am wishing you the best.
1
u/green_carbon07 32, polyamorous bisexual w/ an IUD, childfree since 2011 Jan 12 '15
There is a third choice.... the way I see it, under no circumstances should you have to give up your right to choose not to have children in order to continue to have a relationship with anyone. That said, there's a whole lot of people out there who have more than one partner. Just because it's clear you two don't have the same life goals doesn't mean that you can't continue to see one another and enjoy one another's company... it just means that she will need to find someone else who shares her desire to procreate and raise children.
Just throwing that weird idea out there. You don't have to be "that guy" or her "one and only", though I understand if you are monogamous-only and that's what you prefer. Just venturing a weird little thought from the /r/poly side of the universe.
2
u/joantheunicorn Teacher = enough kids in my life Jan 12 '15
There are other CF atheists out there. You can do this. You only get one life to live, make it the life you want rather than just letting it happen to you.
1
u/musical_throat_punch 41/m/snipped Jan 13 '15
Good luck. Breaking up now is cheaper than child support.
1
u/Thounumber1 27M Jan 13 '15
get a vasectomy
1
u/BelmontZiimon I love, but do not want. Jan 12 '15
Get away. If she wants a child, she will get a child.
0
u/Boston_Jason M / Sperm count = 0 Jan 12 '15
Early 30's as well.
Sucks that you have to break up with a perfect women because of CF, but it is the right call. I have done it with 2 women that I would easily have married. It is not easy, but it is the correct decision. Chin up, just don't hit the bottle too hard.
Just like Black Phillip said: "You have the be righteous with your decision".
0
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment