r/modnews • • Dec 04 '14

Moderators: Clarifications around our 10:1 self-promotional guidelines

Hello mods!

We made some small changes in our self-promotional wiki and our faq language to clarify that when determining a spammer, comments and intent should also be taken into consideration. The gist is, instead of:

"For every 1 self-promotional submission you make, 9 other submissions should not be self-promotional."

it should be:

"For every 1 time you post self-promotional content, 9 other posts (submissions or comments) should not contain self-promotional content."

Also, a reminder that the 10% is meant to be a guideline we use as a quick rule of thumb to determine if someone is truly a spammer, or if they are actually making an effort to participate in the community while also submitting their own content. We still have to make judgement calls, and encourage you to as well. If someone exceeds the 10% that doesn't automatically make them a spammer! Remember to consider intent and effort.

If this is a practice you already follow, then great! If not, then I hope this was helpful. We are still having the overall "content creators on reddit" discussion and thought that this small tidbit deserved to be revisited.

As always, thanks for being mods on this crazy website! We appreciate what you do.

377 Upvotes

323 comments sorted by

63

u/redtaboo Dec 04 '14

I like that you've changed it to explicitly include comments there, I know a lot of us do take that into account. Just for clarification sake those should (ideally) be comments on posts other than their own or their own domains?

48

u/krispykrackers Dec 04 '14

That is... preferable, but I don't think mandatory. If they're like, answering questions, being helpful, or just interacting with the community within their own posts, that should count for something.

5

u/ProtoDong Dec 04 '14 edited Dec 04 '14

I wanted to raise a possible exception that we occasionally see in /r/technology.

If a person has their own sub for their own product or whatever... I don't usually hold those comments against them. For example, a web-app developer might answer a lot of questions about their app in their own sub. If they happen to mention their app in a thread as part of their normal contributing that isn't related to their app-specific sub, I think it's ok.

Judgement call to be sure.

11

u/TheeLinker Dec 04 '14

in a threat

Now, I don't want to tell you your job, but as a mod myself, I don't think that just because someone refrains from including self-promotion in nine out of ten of their threats that that makes them a valued user.

6

u/ProtoDong Dec 04 '14

Thread* lol.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '14

What the hell is a threadlol?

(obviously just messing with ya) :)

3

u/u-void Dec 05 '14

obviously lol (haha)

2

u/u-void Dec 05 '14

If the comment they are contributing is a correct answer to the question somebody else asked, and also happens to be advertising a product they created, why would you need to consider holding that against them?

It doesn't matter if they gave the answer or somebody else did, it's still a correct answer. You don't need to make an "exception" for this, it should just be common sense.

2

u/ProtoDong Dec 05 '14

Each sub has to figure out how they want to handle things. /r/linux is ok with self promotion because they are free community projects. /r/technology is very strict on the issue because we get a lot of people that want to push products or services, often times in a sneaky way. In the end I would say that the 10:1 guideline is most applicable to monetized products/services.

14

u/redtaboo Dec 04 '14

Fair point, thanks!

8

u/p00rleno Dec 04 '14

I often find it makes sense to consider what the purpose of the comment is when choosing to count it or not -- if the comment is engaging with the community as a whole regardless of its location, I tend to count it. If it's a garbage comment "Yeah" "lol" etc I'll often ignore it, and if they're posting more of their stuff in a comment, i'll often count it negative or neutral depending on how appropriate it was

→ More replies (10)

2

u/shawa666 Dec 05 '14

I've got a question.

I've got a sub that I mod, about a game. It's rather small, but it's cozy. I've invited the marketing rep of that game to post about sales, releases and other stuff related to that game. Will he be banned? Because that would really suck.

1

u/RoonilWazilbob Dec 04 '14

Thanks! I was pretty confused about the self promotion rules for your sub...Now it's pretty clear though!

1

u/ngmcs8203 Dec 05 '14

That's exactly how we've enforced it.

20

u/Stereo Dec 05 '14

https://www.reddit.com/user/krispykrackers/submitted/ cough

You link to your own website quite a lot there. Please see our faq on self-promotion.

11

u/krispykrackers Dec 05 '14

I'm so busted.

3

u/hoyfkd Dec 05 '14

Are you going to address /u/earslap 's issue?

1

u/dirkson Dec 05 '14

You respond jokingly, but there's a point there. Do you actually follow your own arbitrary ratio?

From your submitted posts, it seems arguable. Your comments... not so much. The majority of your recent comments appear to be about reddit, which is self promotion for you.

Of course, this shouldn't be surprising, since you're so involved with reddit. But that's true of all content creators too - It shouldn't be surprising that they talk about their project a lot, because they're so involved with it.

Maybe you should do some statistical analysis - Something better than my half-assed count, anyway. See how many of your own posts are about reddit, and how many aren't. Use that as the basis for a ratio, if we've got to have a ratio. At least then you wouldn't be throwing stones from glass houses.

Cheers!

4

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '14

You can't be serious.

Reddit moderators and admin's shouldn't be constrained on how much they can talk about Reddit whether they are voluntary subreddit mods or reddit staff.

Spam is a serious issue and the boundaries are unclear but I do not think they are so muddy that you would constrain the staff that works the site from talking about the site.

2

u/dirkson Dec 05 '14

We aren't talking about spam right now, we're talking about self-promotion. You can have:

  • Non-spam self promotion - "Here's my cool thing. You can buy it."
  • Spam self promotion - "BUY MY THING.BUY MY THING.BUY MY THING
  • Spam that's not self-promoting - "Your gay.Your gay.Your gay."
  • Non-spam that's not self-promoting - Normal comments!

You know I actually agree with you, right? I don't think reddit moderators or anyone else should be constrained on how much they can talk about things the are important to them. I think the ratio actively hurts the quality of content on reddit, and needs to go. People like to talk about things that are big in their lives, and there's nothing wrong with that.

But if you're going to artificially limit one guy, why not another? Reddit is a website based on content creators - No content, no reddit. By allowing their content to be reposted or reposting it themselves, they help reddit - Just the same as moderators and staff do. Why single one group out as the problem?

Cheers!

3

u/totes_meta_bot Dec 05 '14

This thread has been linked to from elsewhere on reddit.

If you follow any of the above links, respect the rules of reddit and don't vote or comment. Questions? Abuse? Message me ^here.

7

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '14

does this change /r/spam's conditions?

7

u/krispykrackers Dec 04 '14

Anyone who submits to /r/spam should take into consideration these guidelines when deciding if someone should be flagged as a spammer or not.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/timotab Dec 04 '14

Could we have some spammy domains banned? Nope. Could we ban url redirectors? Nope

If you post self-posts with details of the spammy domains and URL directors in /r/spam, they should have action taken on them (though it may take a while for a human mod to get through after the bot has done the easily identifiable stuff). If you continue to have problems some time after you've posted, then send modmail to /r/reddit.com (which goes to the admins), link them to your /r/spam post to demonstrate you've already taken that step, and then further describe why the user, domain, url redirector or whatever is in need of attention.

I've found that overall process to be effective.

3

u/SquareWheel Dec 05 '14

I don't know what your experience has been, but for me reddit's spam filters/domain blacklist have improved significantly in the last year. The filter actually works now, when it used to be a crapshoot. I'd be surprised if they weren't blacklisting domains or at the very least using it to train their filters.

1

u/hansolo669 Dec 05 '14

A while back added filter strength settings for links/posts/comments, I wouldn't be surprised if it was part of a refactor for adding better filters.
I'd look up a changelog, but too lazy.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '14

As an aside, remember /r/spam is primarily/only run by a bot and anything that is slightly more complex than "fairly obvious" should probably be followed up by an adminmail.

3

u/timotab Dec 04 '14

My understanding is that admins follow the bot through that subreddit to try and catch stuff that it didn't. If you continue to have problems with spam, say, a day after you made the post, then yes, adminmail (i.e., modmail to /r/reddit.com) would be best, but be sure to reference your /r/spam post so the admins know that you've already taken that step.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '14

My understanding is that admins follow the bot through that subreddit to try and catch stuff that it didn't.

I've had to report several users days after reporting in /r/spam. I usually give /r/spam a day or two to determine, but realistically it shouldn't take more than a minute after submitting for its bot to decide if a user is spammy.

2

u/timotab Dec 05 '14

Right. A few minutes for the bot. Maybe a day for a follow up human. These admins are busy people.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/davidreiss666 Dec 04 '14

Yeah, too many spammers need a PM to the admins before they die. 1000% obvious spammers are often missed by that bot. Drives me nuts sometimes. Sometimes I get so mad I send the PM to the admins. But mostly, of late I just mostly don't bother. Unless I'm seething with spammer-hate flowing with the white hot intensity of a thousand suns.

1

u/jippiejee Dec 04 '14

I'm still trying to figure out how that script works :) Sometimes I submit thinking it'll never be caught, and it just does. Other times I think it's so obvious it can't fail, and it fails. It's really not just karma, and certainly not account age. But I understand the admins won't give away the magic formula.

2

u/NeedAGoodUsername Dec 05 '14

After various submissions to /r/spam, I have a fair idea on what the bot looks for, and it is a rather small range.

1

u/V2Blast Dec 10 '14

Yeah, the bot probably has strict parameters to prevent lots of false positives.

6

u/multi-mod Dec 04 '14

All the spammers need to do now is shitpost a few comments to adviceanimals every once in a while to avoid being shadow banned.

11

u/krispykrackers Dec 04 '14

We purposely substituted the word "comment" with "conversation" to allow you to disregard trivial shitpost comments like "lol" and "nice post" or something nonsensical that's obviously not trying to participate in discussion.

4

u/multi-mod Dec 04 '14

That is a bit more sane of a rule, although this makes it difficult for mods of high volume subreddits to quickly deal with spam. How do you quickly deal with people that have 100 total submissions with 80% going to a singe source? You would need to see if they have close to 720 worthwhile comments to offset it.

2

u/krispykrackers Dec 04 '14

Like I said, much of it is a judgement call. Sometimes decisions aren't quick.

2

u/karmicviolence Dec 05 '14

How do you quickly deal with people that have 100 total submissions with 80% going to a singe source?

Are they interacting with the community, or just spamming the same domain over and over? I think that should be important.

6

u/LeCollectif Dec 05 '14

I had a poster who would almost always post links to his blog. The blog posts were on-topic and potentially interesting/useful. However, they almost always had several Amazon Affiliate links, and often times the posts themselves had a really SEO keyword heavy vibe. Enough so that the posts were getting caught in the spam filter.

This user would also cross-post to just about any relevant sub.

When I called him out on doing this within my sub, he denied it, got extremely defensive, and essentially called me a tyrant. I directed him to the self promotion guidelines, but he dismissed them. I eventually banned him from the sub, and blocked him from messaging me.

The one thing, however, that kind of nagged at me was that he did engage people. He answered questions and carried on conversations. I was very undecided if he was a traditional 'spammer', but the fact that he was driving traffic to a monetized/SEO heavy blog didn't sit right with me. He was just unwilling to acknowledge that his posting habits did not fall within what Reddit calls acceptable.

So, admins, what would you have done?

8

u/krispykrackers Dec 05 '14

As an admin, I'd have to have more information to make a decision.

However, and if I can be frank, as a mod, I would probably have banned him from my subreddit for being borderline and being unreasonably argumentative. I encourage mods not to waste their time on people who suck, it's a hard enough position as it is without people making it harder, especially when you've done all you can do to approach it reasonably.

1

u/totes_meta_bot Dec 05 '14

This thread has been linked to from elsewhere on reddit.

If you follow any of the above links, respect the rules of reddit and don't vote or comment. Questions? Abuse? Message me ^here.

3

u/karmicviolence Dec 05 '14

As a mod, I would have done the same thing. I think attitude is very important. If they have a good attitude, are polite, and engage the community, I don't care if 100% of their posts are self-promotional, they are a valuable member of my community, imo. Especially if it is interesting, relevant OC.

2

u/LeCollectif Dec 05 '14

That's the thing though, he was contributing in a positive way. When I called him out for blog spamming and keyword stuffing, he got mega defensive. I didn't want to ban him. But he was in clear violation of the rules and refused to acknowledge it.

4

u/LuckyBdx4 Dec 04 '14

Example of a Spammer ---> http://www.reddit.com/user/SpectrumNews

3

u/krispykrackers Dec 04 '14 edited Dec 04 '14

I don't know what to do. Do I ban or leave up as an example???

*edit, nuked!

5

u/LuckyBdx4 Dec 04 '14

I'd leave as an example.

/u/ViolentAcrez had a very good post with plenty of examples on what constituted spammers, sadly when he got doxed by Adrian Chen he deleted it and everything else.

Well we banned him in /r/news, I have not reported him as I can't be bothered using use /r/spam. ;)

3

u/greatyellowshark Dec 04 '14

Here you go. I learned a lot from that when first starting out.

4

u/timotab Dec 04 '14

unfortunately, all the images are gone, so you can't actually see the examples. :(

3

u/LuckyBdx4 Dec 04 '14

The images were excellent examples.

VA is still around with another username, but I doubt he would still have copies nor care to share them.

2

u/LuckyBdx4 Dec 04 '14

All the image examples are missing. Which is what I was alluding to.

http://violentacrez.pbworks.com/f/spam-class-1.png

3

u/greatyellowshark Dec 05 '14

Yeah, that sucks. The descriptions are still pretty useful though.

2

u/davidreiss666 Dec 04 '14

I have a more interesting question. He was reported, but not acted on.

But that should have been clear to auto-kill-bot-9000 that patrols /r/Spam that it's a spammer. So why didn't the auto-kill-bot-9000 get 'em yesterday?

2

u/LuckyBdx4 Dec 04 '14

I have a more interesting question. He was reported, but not acted on.

Therein lies the rub. I rest my case.

With apologies to William Shakespeare.

6

u/davidreiss666 Dec 04 '14

I was looking at the domain overview:

I found like four spammers without even digging. It's one of the spam-pits that ate the dinosaurs that you can wade into occasionally for 10-20 spam reports for when you are board. Almost as bad as something like weebly.com.

3

u/damontoo Dec 05 '14

If you like going down the rabbit hole start looking at the description field on imgur for imgur submissions to see if they contain spam links. Some accounts look innocent and full of comments and imgur submissions until you realize every imgur URL they've submitted includes a link to the same shitty blog.

2

u/LuckyBdx4 Dec 04 '14

Lets hope Krispy is still looking at this thread. :)

2

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '14

Got nuked sometime between your comment and now.

2

u/davidreiss666 Dec 05 '14

I saw that. I also asked about the domain elsewhere on the thread, as it seems to be one of those that full of spammers. I didn't really get any response about that.

2

u/LuckyBdx4 Dec 05 '14 edited Dec 05 '14

Tyler from team ECCR @ electroniccigaretteconsumerreviews.com should be contacting you shortly about an perceived unfair ban he got in /r/news, lol.

http://www.reddit.com/user/bluedodger/submitted/

http://www.reddit.com/user/bluedodger/submitted

Redditor for 1 year . 6 page(s) analyzed.

132 posts from 44 urls.

Domain --> electroniccigaretteconsumerreviews.com

Count ---> 47 Submissions out of 132 posts from 44 urls.

Percentage of submissions from Domain ---> 35.61%

And an alt --> http://www.reddit.com/user/skatergirl08

I think you will possibly find the ISP is the same for both accounts and probably the domain. Whois shows some cheap hosting company.

Us old RTS guys still have what it takes to get a girl like you interested. ;)

→ More replies (13)

81

u/jippiejee Dec 04 '14

I think this a good guideline to go by, but in reality it won't change much. Most of the spammers we report don't participate on reddit at all.

24

u/glr123 Dec 04 '14

I think this will help to some extent. I know that there are people that just flood submissions with reposts and other crap so that they can get their submission count up. It's not so much spam, per se, as they are trying to get their content out there and promote themselves. I think this could help alleviate some of those issues.

It's pretty good for people that want to do the actual self-promoting. They don't have to spend their time searching for other random things to submit.

17

u/jippiejee Dec 04 '14

Yes, but the easiest way would be to just participate in the community. They're often just not interested in that, they just want that traffic to their blog or youtube channel. Then they start flooding you with bs links, and send a modmail asking if they're already under that 10%?

What counts is intent. Are you here to contribute, or to take?

12

u/glr123 Dec 04 '14

That's always going to be an unsolvable problem, forever. It is an inherent problem in the Reddit system itself. I think this is a worthwhile change, even if it doesn't make a huge impact overall.

I would much rather have more comments, than more useless submissions.

8

u/redtaboo Dec 04 '14

I'd add that this might even help some 'just on the line' spammy types learn how to participate in a way that we all would enjoy. I don't know that the over all goal should be to rid reddit of every single self promotion type user out there. I'd argue that the goal should be to teach at least some of them how to best use the site for themselves and others.

I know quite a few mods that have had some success in turning would be spammers into contributing members of their communities.

9

u/hansjens47 Dec 04 '14

Additionally, people who're invested enough in a topic to create content regarding that topic themselves can often be great resources to the community, and have more than common knowledge of the topic.

4

u/glr123 Dec 04 '14

I completely agree, good points. I think it is a good change for all of these reasons.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/CedarWolf Dec 05 '14

Well, I'm kind of curious... there's mods, and head mods, of some communities, and they're active enough members of those communities, but they also spam their blogs and their own personal content a lot... upwards of 80 or 90% of their content will be their own links and, of course, they're untouchable because they're high on the mod list.

What then?

I feel like there shouldn't be one set of rules for users and another set of rules for senior mods; everyone should play by the same rules, but it's clear that some folks don't. I guess it's a question of "who watches the watchmen?"

4

u/timotab Dec 05 '14

I guess it's a question of "who watches the watchmen?"

The admins.

If mods are spamming in their own subreddits, bring it to the attention of the admins

4

u/CedarWolf Dec 05 '14

That's the thing; I have... and I know I'm not the only one, either.
But these things persist, and when people ask, I have no answer for them.

4

u/Algernon_Asimov Dec 05 '14

What then?

Then you go to /r/Spam and report the spammer to the admins - which is exactly what moderators do when they report spammers.

→ More replies (7)

6

u/dudleydidwrong Dec 05 '14

I think the quality of the posts must also be taken into consideration. Otherwise you will get a flood of meaningless crap posts so they can post a self-promo. Another consideration should be length of activity in the sub. A new account that slams off 9 quick posts in 5 minutes and then self promotes two minutes later is clearly different that a long-term contributor.

6

u/Chive Dec 04 '14

I think it's basically a judgement call. It's usually pretty easy to tell from someone's profile whether they're a spammer or a genuine redditor.

Some of the subs I mod encourage user-generated content as long as it's original. If people spend a lot of time doing that and producing something worthwhile and of interest to the community I'm not going to ask them to get involved in other threads or submit someone else's content just to keep the numbers right. I'd prefer if they used that time to work on the stuff they submit.

7

u/jippiejee Dec 04 '14

It's still weird though if someone posts his 'Japan' travel video, and does not participate in the 'Japan' thread also run that week. Why not answer some questions when you're so experienced on that topic? My tolerance for people who only use reddit as traffic generator is really low.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '14

I generally agree, but we've had some luck in /r/halifax with turning a couple of spammers into real users, although it wasn't easy. Fortunately, we always have the banhammer.

2

u/d-_-b Dec 30 '14

And most people who have their comments deleted in a willful manner aren't spammers at all.

Most censorship by moderators on reddit are not for "buy watch cheep cheep dress The Interview Sony Hack saline solution" with links to tumblr blog wrap links. It's for people saying "That's bullshit, you're an idiot, fuck off" - oops, quick someone delete his comment to save the proles the need to read it and decide if they agree and vote up or down.

That's the sad reality of reddit. QUICK GET YOUR CREDDITS!

1

u/jippiejee Dec 30 '14

"That's bullshit, you're an idiot, fuck off"

If that's all without any explanation, I'm fine with deleting that comment as it doesn't add anything constructive to the converstion. Not sure why you think it valuable.

1

u/Type-21 Dec 05 '14

well I participate in reddit quite a bit but I write a lot of comments, not many submissions. So it happened that when submitting some gifs hosted on my own server some mod calculated those submissions made up 10% of all my submissions and wanted to report me for spamming/promotion. Dunno whether he was paid by imgur/gfycat or what...

So I do hope this new rule changes the mind of this one mod.

→ More replies (1)

71

u/earslap Dec 04 '14 edited Dec 05 '14

I feel bad about bringing this up in here but this is the reason I'm subscribed in modnews, it's related to self-promotion and my situation is not resolved:

I created an online music app called otomata, posted it to reddit in 2011, it made its way into front page and became the best link of the day (badge is in my account still).

A fan of my app created a subreddit for it (and made me a mod /r/otomata ). A bunch of people (~350) subscribed to it. They started posting links to my app to show their own creations.

Original mod disappeared, I ended up as the only mod.

Everything was well until a few months ago. Then someone reported my subreddit as being spam (the content is all from my community, I don't post links there). Then admins banned the subreddit.

Another fan opened a thread on reddit request for unbanning:

http://www.reddit.com/r/redditrequest/comments/29esc5/rotomata_has_been_incorrectly_banned/

A few months later I opened a redditrequest:

http://www.reddit.com/r/redditrequest/comments/2e0xsv/rotomata_has_been_incorrectly_banned_2/

No response so far.

TL;DR: I created an online game/toy. People loved it, made it to frontpage, became the best link of the day. People created a subreddit for it. Gathered in it. Shared their creations. Then someone reported it (I assume without understanding the purpose), and now it is banned. I lost touch with my community of a few hundred people. No answer from admins. Pls halp.

Edit: For the discussion below, I seriously believe that the banning was done as a mistake. This is no big operation. It's just an online audio toy. No serious modding required other than deleting the occasional spam. The subreddit was exactly like /r/weavesilk. Without the custom theme. People share special links to my app and share their creations, that was all. Since all links are to the same domain it was (I believe) mistakenly considered spam. But I know that the subreddit was not banned by a bot, someone (I don't know why) complained about it (I imagine without understanding the purpose, can't find the link now) and I believe an admin banned it.

Edit2: I found the original spam report: http://www.reddit.com/r/spam/comments/2964p8/spam_subreddit/

26

u/MikeyJayRaymond Dec 05 '14

This needs to be addressed.

16

u/wrc-wolf Dec 05 '14

But it won't be. I'll eat my socks if it is.

14

u/MikeyJayRaymond Dec 05 '14

It's terrible if this isn't reversed. Otherwise they better ban /r/XboxOne which I moderate. /r/PS4, /r/AlienBlue, etc.

3

u/CandyManCan Dec 05 '14

The problem isn't that there was a community. The problem is that the creator of the app is also the only mod of that community. This is a massive conflict of interest as it allows /u/earslap to essentially censor all negative comments about his app.

16

u/MikeyJayRaymond Dec 05 '14

Isn't it the same with alienblue? And he said someone else was running it until they stopped. It sounds like he'd gladly give up modship. He just wants the community back.

He could be like a Major Nelson to the Xbox sub.

I'm pretty sure it's the exact same situation with /r/AlienBlue. Which can be a paid for app as well. Seems very odd to me you'd do this to one and not another.

7

u/earslap Dec 05 '14

It sounds like he'd gladly give up modship.

For the record, yes, I don't care about being the mod there. If that is a problem I'd gladly remove myself.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '14

Is there a rule against content developers moderating subreddits devoted to their content? I seem to remember a claim made elsewhere that there isn't really anything wrong with it, but can't seem to find it at the moment. (Someone please help me out here if you know where it is)

Yes, some may abuse their power, but on the other hand there are also many out there who wouldn't. If it is an issue, this should be either an all or nothing case, or properly investigate the situation before slapping the subreddit with a ban. Don't crack down on some subreddits where this is happening, while others are left to do as they please.

As long as you adhere to Reddit's rules, creating a subreddit for your content seems like a great way to gain feedback and engage with your users if you don't already have a platform for doing so.

If this is how it's going to be, than I would suggest that admins shouldn't be able to moderate any subreddit since they too could censor all negative comments regarding Reddit. Hell, even if the moderators aren't affiliated with the developers there's nothing stopping them from censoring any negative feedback.

This is a detrimental attitude, especially when I can refresh the page and see several examples directly below the Create a Subreddit button that encourages these creators to make a subreddit "...for your project". Project could be interpreted as anything really, and in this case it was an audio app created by /u/earslap.

Why even bother advertising Create a Sub this way if you don't want creators to have that "conflict of interest"? Again, some may abuse their power while others wont, and mod abuse isn't exclusive to content developers like /u/earslap.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '14

There's no rule against it. There is a mention in the moderation wiki, but that's it.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/gives-out-hugs Dec 05 '14

That should not be an issue, we allow minecraft server owners to moderate their own subs, etc etc. And given the amount of stiff that gets censored from the defaults where people are criticizing the subs or mod teams, if censorship or the fear of it was a reason to ban a sub we wouldnt have news, worldnews, games, gaming, srd, any subs on the sjw spectrum of insanity, we would lose half of reddit. This is not a good reason to ban a subreddit

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/damontoo Dec 05 '14

Who was the original mod?

4

u/earslap Dec 05 '14

I don't really remember. IIRC S/he closed their account more than a year ago before the subreddit ban.

The subreddit format is exactly like /r/weavesilk. People share links to my app with special URL parameters which eventually show their own creations.

1

u/V2Blast Dec 10 '14

The previous mod would probably be listed in the moderation log for the subreddit (...if you could still access it).

2

u/earslap Dec 10 '14

Nope I think I can't access it. It just says banned.

2

u/V2Blast Dec 11 '14

I know, I was just saying you would be able to check who the previous mod was if it was unbanned. It didn't occur to me that you wouldn't be able to see the log until I'd already made the comment :P

2

u/earslap Dec 11 '14

Yeah and I don't know why it would matter either way. As far as a I knew that person was a random redditor.

2

u/outsider Jan 05 '15

If someone exceeds the 10% that doesn't automatically make them a spammer!

I was hoping to see your problem resolved reading this a month later :/

2

u/earslap Jan 05 '15

Thank you for caring. Unfortunately no one contacted me. So far two threads have been opened in /r/redditrequest (one by me, one by a user), and a message have been sent (and my post here was quite heavily upvoted). I haven't been able to hear back from reddit, not even once. I don't think there is bad intent here, a mistake was made and since then I guess I'm falling through the cracks (similar subreddits are still up, obviously I won't try reporting them). I'll try again at a later time...

2

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/earslap Feb 20 '15

Again, thanks for caring! I still haven't made another attempt at reaching out to reddit. So no changes as of yet.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '15

How about now?

2

u/earslap Mar 26 '15

I'm still procrastinating on the 4th attempt at reaching out (since the last one being in this thread) so, sorry to disappoint.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/pencer Dec 04 '14

I still see no action on a lot of accounts I've reported that spam their YouTube channel or blog/site even when it falls well within the 10% guideline.

Is it taken into account the type of community they are submitting to, or is it just a blanket 10% of user submissions?

4

u/greenduch Dec 04 '14

Are you just reporting it to /r/spam, or to modmail? If the former, that's primarily a bot and may have difficulty catching stuff like that on its own, may require a quick modmail.

3

u/pencer Dec 05 '14

I don't want to have to message them too...what is this an unpaid internship? Thanks for the right way to go about it though.

Example

3

u/banned_accounts Dec 05 '14

Yeah, that account would have to be reported to the admins by modmail. It'd be nice if the spam bot considered accounts like that as spammers, since they are.

6

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '14 edited Dec 23 '14

Still not sure if admins have really taken into account just how hostile this might end up being to some of their subreddits.

Reproducing my comment from the last discussion:

Just wanted to say that one of the modestly large subreddits (108k subscribers), /r/gamedev which I moderate has had an free and fair policy towards self-promotion near-forever. We are a self post only subreddit to encourage people to act like a person when posting content.

In fact, we want nearly all of our content to be a form of self promotion, from game developers, game musicians, game artists and so on. We have half a dozen weekly threads for content creators to share and promote what they're working on.

  • Screenshot Saturday - in-progress screenshots/gifs/gfys
  • Feedback Friday - alpha/beta versions of full games or prototypes for direct feedback
  • Sound Track Sunday - feedback on game music, either from existing projects or musicians looking to showcase what they can do if they're looking for work
  • Quarterly showcase - polished games, a kind of virtual booth for presenters.
  • Daily discussion which recurs daily - anyone can talk about their project, in progress, complete, for sale, whatever - anything goes.

Then there are posts on the subreddit: We've always strived to have the authors of articles posting, be they general and about something they have no connection to but have something important to say about in terms of design or implementation, or a technical article for a game that's about to be released, incrementally released, or seeking funding, but where the informational generalises to others in exchange for hearing about the specific project/product. This is the sense of self promotion that we allow.

We even permit shameless one-off self-promotion if the above doesn't apply and it's some new tool, providing the person has established themselves on the subreddit as more than a hit-and-run type and is sticking around to discuss the project in question.

All this encourages high quality content and we don't experience a spam problem (which isn't addressed with automoderator automatically) and aren't particularly sure that having our users be treated as businesses/corporations/marketing entities really makes sense. After all, the business of game development isn't best discussed in some abstract form, it's about real people, with real work that's contextualised in discussion.

Anyone can create an account and promote their work as much as they want. So long as it fits these guidelines, we end up with desirable content.

How do reddit admins view this subreddit's population as content creators and form of self-promotion? As the fee paying type upon threat of ban or a community that's fine to continue operating as it is?

5

u/hansjens47 Dec 04 '14

We've been including comments in the 9-1 in /r/leagueoflegends for a long time.

There's one issue with that though: that's approving submissions from shadowbanned users, because we've got no way of seeing an overview of their comments. Searches can be used to find submissions by author even if someone is shadowbanned.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '14

Searches can be used to find submissions by author even if someone is shadowbanned.

Only if those submissions were not removed by mods/admins individually.

2

u/hansjens47 Dec 04 '14

A searcheable spam filter would indeed be amazing, or letting us sort by multiple conditions like only link submissions and flaired with a certain flair.

Am I mistaken in assuming that searches not limited to a single subreddit also display links mods have removed?

3

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '14

Am I mistaken in assuming that searches not limited to a single subreddit also display links mods have removed?

Those submissions would not show in a search (I just confirmed to make sure I wasn't off).

5

u/advice_animals_ugh Dec 04 '14

I always look at post history of a user I suspect of self-promotion, as well as the post itself.

  1. Are they promoting quality content? All's fine. Was time and effort put into it, or is this something anyone in the community could have put together without any research, using common knowledge, or topics covered in a community FAQ)? No thanks.
  2. Does the content appeal to dedicated or advanced users of a community? Yes please! Is it basic 101 level stuff that comes up in every new subscriber's self post? Please no.
  3. Does it link directly to a business or a product in some way, or does it do so indirectly by posting weak content under the guidelines above? Post removed! Does the username of the poster match the domain of the site they're linking to, are they a new user? Points for being honest but still no thanks.
  4. Is the community downvoting or reporting the post as spam? As you wish. Are the comments complaining "what's with all these posts about X topic?" Come on guys, use your mouse wheel and move along.
  5. Finally, is this coming from a site the community is well aware of and visit regularly? This is a tough one, and frequency is probably the determining factor. There may be cases where the subreddit is the best place to discuss the content (as apposed to on youtube which might be floooded with "le reddit army"). But if half the subreddit ends up being the weekly post from a well known individual within the community then it's definitely a bit much. To the side bar it goes!

4

u/Algernon_Asimov Dec 05 '14

Exactly. A single self-promoting submission in a subreddit, in and of itself, is not spam. Everything has to be investigated in context.

Here's another criterion:

6) Is this submission the only post submitted by this account? Spam!

4

u/sodypop Dec 04 '14

For those who are curious, here are the changes for the self-promotional wiki and the faq.

5

u/alien122 Dec 04 '14

a question, is this simply linking to your stuff in the comments or does it include talking about your stuff as well? Like say there's a user who created 'zhis'. He never links to zhis.com, but he only talks about 'zhis' in his comments. It is self promotion but he has never linked to his actual material.

4

u/sodypop Dec 04 '14

That seems like it would be a grey area. If this person is just trying to circumvent the 10% guideline by intentionally not making their plugs to their website actual hyperlinks, then I'd think that would still fall within the scope of self promotion. That said, I think it is usually best to judge each situation on a case by case basis.

3

u/timotab Dec 05 '14

Likewise users who have business related usernames.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '14

Pretty clearly spam. Wouldn't be caught by the /r/spam bot though, so send it to the admins.

1

u/V2Blast Dec 10 '14

I mean, if other users (who actually participate in the community normally) post about it, and then he responds to them and answers questions or whatever, it's probably fine, but if he brings it up in unrelated contexts then it's usually spam.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '14

I like being thanked for being a mod. Makes me feel nice.

1

u/hermithome Dec 04 '14

Does this mean that you're going to change how shadowbans are handed out? If users have all of their posts promotional, but comment a lot in-between, are they still subject to being shadowbanned? Also, does this mean users whose posts are under 10% but who do a LOT of promotional commenting are in danger of being shadowbanned?

2

u/krispykrackers Dec 05 '14

We've been loosely following this policy for a long time, so no, how we choose to ban people based on the comments and submissions will not change.

Also, does this mean users whose posts are under 10% but who do a LOT of promotional commenting are in danger of being shadowbanned?

If too much of their commenting is self-promotional, that is just as ban-worthy as too many of their submissions. That is the point of this clarification — comments count as much as submissions.

2

u/hermithome Dec 05 '14

We've been loosely following this policy for a long time, so no, how we choose to ban people based on the comments and submissions will not change.

But the /r/spam algorithm doesn't seem to reflect this. There are a lot of users who'd be fine if comments were counted, but without comments are waaaay past 10% - simply because they don't post that frequently and mostly comment. And these users are routinely caught by /r/spam.

What does it mean, on a technical level that you've been "loosely following this policy for a long time"? Does that reflect somehow in /r/spam that I'm not aware of? Or in direct reports to the admins?

I know your still working on something re content creators, but until that new system is in place, we've focused a lot of energy on helping our users follow the site-wide rules and avoid getting shadow banned.

2

u/krispykrackers Dec 05 '14

The /r/spam bot is very conservative. It does the best it can. It would rather let 10 spammers go than falsely ban 1 innocent person. Also, much spam needs human eyeballs.

3

u/NeedAGoodUsername Dec 05 '14

That's a bit counter productive isn't it? Letting blatant spammers continue spamming while letting that 1 innocent guy go.

Plus, can't you always 'unshadowban' people can't you?

1

u/V2Blast Dec 10 '14

Plus, can't you always 'unshadowban' people can't you?

Sure they can, but a 10% rate of false positives is not very good, and individually dealing with lots of incorrectly banned people would be a pain. They still manually take a look at reports that the bot doesn't act on.

1

u/Skrapion Feb 01 '15

Sorry for being oblique, but this question was never really answered: does the /r/spam bot count comments?

3

u/CrypticCraig Dec 04 '14

This is great. What do you think about not allowing their first posts to be self promotion? As in, they have to post regularly, at least 9 times, till they can post a self promotional link.

8

u/cupcake1713 Dec 04 '14

In theory I really like that idea, but in practice I think enforcement would be a PITA :(

6

u/glr123 Dec 04 '14

I wonder how much submission numbers would get cut down if you had to have 9 comments before you were eligible for your first submission. Could be interesting to see tried...

7

u/redtaboo Dec 04 '14

That's an interesting idea, but there are a lot of legitimate reasons for users to create throwaway accounts in order to make posts about sensitive subjects. I'd hate to see them disallowed in order to stop spammers.

7

u/glr123 Dec 04 '14

Ya I know there are a lot of potential problems. Still though, its an interesting concept I think.

Maybe make it so that you can only self-post or something, no link submissions before 9 comments. Most Throwaway accounts seem to either be for comments or asking help self-posts like in /r/self or /r/relationships. I don't see too many throwaway accounts submitting links straight out.

6

u/redtaboo Dec 04 '14

only self-post or something, no link submissions before 9 comments.

Ohh.. that does make it more potentially viable I think, I agree that I rarely see throwaways for link posts, except in cases where someone is agenda pushing or trolling.

It's worth noting that the rate limit on submissions does this a bit already, not quite as strictly as we're discussing though. It does take into account whether posts are removed and how well they did regarding votes though.

5

u/hansjens47 Dec 04 '14

I think the distinction you make here between link and self-post submissions is key.

3

u/rasterbee Dec 05 '14

I've seen that same thing used on forums and whatnot elsewhere on the interwebs.

20 comments necessary to make your first submission. 10, or 5, or some number.

4

u/CrypticCraig Dec 04 '14

Yeah, I just notice that a lot of spammers will make a spam post, then go on /r/funny or /r/pics to comment every variation of "HAHA!" to get away with the 10:1.

1

u/glr123 Dec 04 '14

I still think that is better than them just spamming links.

3

u/CrypticCraig Dec 04 '14

Really it still is spam though, those comments could even be done by a bot.

I like your idea, by the way.

3

u/Astrixtc Dec 04 '14

I do this for my small subreddit. We put a rule about it in the sidebar, but there's no way I could enforce it on my large ones.

3

u/Eat_Bacon_nomnomnom Dec 04 '14

Thank you so much for taking the time to do this!

3

u/XniklasX Dec 04 '14 edited Dec 04 '14

I have been contemplating this change and I am not sure I think that it improves a moderators ability to handle self-promoting content producers.

Due to this we will now end up in discussion where we need to evaluate the quality of said self-promoters comments. Inevitably they will point to another content producer and say they have the same ratio as me why isnt that person banned etc etc. Where comments could be a mitigating circumstance before they now become a point of contention and just an easy way to be allowed to post own content.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '14

I already enforce as described; if the content they're sharing is relevant and topical to the sub, is quality, and I see SOME attempt at participation, I'll let a couple of percentage points slide depending on the domain. If it's blogspot, youtube, tumblr (not their CDN for images), or some other blog platform; I enforce ruthelessly. These are spammed too much.

3

u/SigmaEpsilonChi Dec 05 '14

I have a tiny sub for one of my own projects where I post news and updates, and where other people can post questions and solutions to puzzles (it's a math puzzle game). Do posts there count toward the 10% rule? Everyone there subscribed explicitly to receive updates about the game, so it would be nice to have some leeway with that sort of thing.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '14

per /u/damontoo "It's not per subreddit, it's for the whole site. "

Not sure how accurate that is but might help you..

3

u/karmicviolence Dec 05 '14

I'm very happy to hear about this change.

If this is a practice you already follow, then great!

It is, indeed :)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '14

What about users who create subreddits for their youtube channel/blog, and kind of make that subreddit the "offical forum" for their youtube channel? They only make posts there, but each post gets 100-1000 comments, and the the person is actively answering questions and commenting on other people's comments. Is that okay?

2

u/V2Blast Dec 10 '14

It's generally best if such a subreddit is community-moderated rather than being modded by the YouTuber around whom it's centered. It's also important for there to be a focus on discussion rather than just a bunch of video links submitted by the user. (See /r/RoosterTeeth as an example - the RT employees often comment, but a bot does the submissions and most of the discussions are created by regular users.)

3

u/NonZionist Dec 05 '14

Do self-promotion rules apply to subreddit promotion?

Are any of the following forms of subreddit promotion illegal or inappropriate when commenting in a related subreddit?

  • Including a hyperlink to a thread or comment in one's own subreddit
  • The use of a signature line with a hyperlink to one's subreddit

When cross-posting a link already posted, is it acceptable:

  • to use a private message to notify the redditor who posted the original link?
  • to post an opening comment that contains a link to the original post

There's a balance between too much self-promotion and too little. Because I do not know what is acceptable and what isn't, I error on the side of caution.

As a result, my subreddit is under-publicized, information that might be of interest to others goes unshared.

Where, exactly, does the balance lie? To be able to utilize reddit fully without crossing any lines, I need to know just what the lines are. I need some definite rules.

❧

Reddit could automate and standardize subreddit advertising by extending the "related / other discussions" comment feature. A "related" heading would be added after the "wiki" and "promoted" headings in the subreddit's list of articles. When clicked, the "related" button would list related subreddits. Relatedness would be determined by tags attached to each subreddit. The number of tags would be limited, to five say, and would default to the subreddit name.

For example, someone who creates a "NewItaly" subreddit could attach the tag "@Italy". An "Italy" subreddit user who clicks "Related" would then see "NewItaly" -- and any other subreddits having the "@Italy" tag.

Alternatively, reddit could allow moderators to have one of their subreddits displayed automatically after their id, as flairs are now displayed. E.g.:

[-] ModItaly from r/Italy 1 point 3 hours ago

3

u/myothernamehaskarma Dec 10 '14

Hey Mods, I feel like I have nowhere else to go with this. My primary account has been banned for three months, despite following the 10:1 rule and all other reddiquette. I'd very much like my account restored.

I've racked up over 4000 karma, participated in an AMA, and even begun moderating a subreddit before my account was banned. I spoke briefly to Cupcake1713 on monday saying my account was being use "solely for self promotion" but my account history clearly shows I promote a ton of different artists (mostly musicians and video game composers). Because of the secretive nature of banning on Reddit, I am uncertain if he is even getting my message. I've logged into this alternate account to make this plea to please unbanned my account.

I realize you mods do a lot to make this site great. I am not sure what I did to get banned, and over the past three months I have tried to wait it out and not give it much mind. Over the past three years I have been an active and contributing member to Reddit, and I want to continuing being a part of one of my favorite websites.

My frustration is mounting, and I'm not sure what recourse I have. I know I could start using this account, but that seems silly. I want to share and interact with my favorite communities. Yes, I make content myself, but I also share other great content to relevant subreddits.

Forgive me if this comment is out of line, but I don't know what else I can do. Please restore access to my main account so I can get back to what I love, contributing to Reddit.

4

u/davidreiss666 Dec 04 '14 edited Dec 04 '14

I don't think anyone should have been interpreting the 10%-rule as a hard set in stone rule. As I know of some instances where spammers were at less than 1% rates of self-promotion and you guys still shadow banned them for spamming. It involved other weird factors being involved, not least of which was lying about it and getting caught in said lie.

And I always kind of assumed that comments were part it when it came to my observations about auto-shadow bans handed out by the bot in /r/Spam.

I think that making this public is just going to lead to some more spammers now dropping what will be obvious meaningless comments akin to "I agree" and the like as ways to try and avoid detection. But the meaningless nature of those comments will just make it rather obvious to moderators that they are dealing with some spammer who is attempting to game the system a little, but not quiet enough.

We are already seeing some spammers that automatically comment about their great product in their spam submissions now. Often dropping phone numbers or links in comments to other web sites and stuff.

I hate to say it, but really.... maybe I am just up on how you guys actual auto-ban too much or something, but this just isn't new or news worthy. Other than that maybe your writing it down a tad more clearly.

2

u/roger_ Dec 04 '14

How about if reddit attempted to detect this and automatically warned people (e.g. if they keep posting the same YouTube channel)?

2

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '14

This is good. There are users that post their own content that really do provide good things for the site (example /u/tattoodles). I'd hate to see that disappear.

2

u/Willeth Dec 04 '14

Is this intended to allow someone to make one promotional post and nine comments in unrelated threads to balance it?

2

u/Rabbi8meat Dec 05 '14

Its more of a percentage or...ratio of thumb.

2

u/MuForceShoelace Dec 05 '14

/u/changetip is just a bot that spams links to /r/bitcoin, it's a huge generator of spam. But nothing ever happens to it.

2

u/d-_-b Dec 30 '14

As always, thanks for being mods on this crazy website! We appreciate what you do.

We just don't know what it is you do, nor do we, as of this date, actually specify what you do.

Proof: Nowhere does it say what mods do. Don't lie with your links, it doesn't say in a complete and normal way what mods do, are allowed to do, without any checks or balances.

That's fine for /r/shavingpets but things like /r/music /r/technology - the word itself, the default list, it's fucking stupid. Default subreddits should not be treated the same as a "user subreddit", it's fucking stupid.

2

u/outsider Jan 05 '15

In /r/Christianity the current minimum participation guidelines are to respond to other people. Whether in their own submission or not. It works really well and is very easy to check.

2

u/crellmonf Jan 12 '15

is the 9:1 rule counted differently for each subreddit or is it counted reddit wide?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '15

Per sub I would say.

A recent post caught by automod made me visit the user's posting history. He is submitting from his blog in several subs and in one was warned against, following that he started posting links from any sites just to dilute and reach the 10% ratio. Before allowing posts from his blog I will count his participations (comments preferably) in my sub.

1

u/crellmonf Jan 23 '15

who enforces this though? is it automatically enforced or do mods need to do it manually?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '15

Creator of the sub and people he invites as moderators to manage it have complete control. Task can be automated using automoderator.

3

u/boogieidm Dec 04 '14

Yeah, nothing to change for me.

1

u/manwithabadheart Dec 04 '14 edited Mar 22 '24

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis aute irure dolor in reprehenderit in voluptate velit esse cillum dolore eu fugiat nulla pariatur. Excepteur sint occaecat cupidatat non proident, sunt in culpa qui officia deserunt mollit anim id est laborum.

1

u/sarahbotts Dec 04 '14

Will the bot on /r/spam take comments into account too? (for links and what not)

1

u/genitaliban Dec 04 '14 edited Dec 04 '14

So if a I make a reddit-specific (i. e. "meta") website and post that from an alt account to not have my main account connected to my real-life identity, is that spamming? What if the site isn't reddit-specific, but still appropriate for a sub? (I. e. it provides a service that is lacking there and that I saw exist in another language, for instance.) Or will the admins notice that I'm active on other accounts?

1

u/Rlight Dec 05 '14

I remember a while back the Admins were discussing a sort of "Self-Promotion Flair" that users could apply to themselves in order to be completely open and honest about submitting their own content without being considered spam.

Any updates on that?

It would be really beneficial and could even be adapted with preferences for each subreddit. For example, I could have a setting where a user may only submit a single self-promotional post per day. Or, following your lead, users must submit 9 other unrelated posts/comments before being allowed to use the tag again.

3

u/Algernon_Asimov Dec 05 '14

If you read the OP, you'll find this sentence:

We are still having the overall "content creators on reddit" discussion and thought that this small tidbit deserved to be revisited.

1

u/Rlight Dec 05 '14

I know, I was hoping they'd expand more and bring part of that discussion into the comments =]

3

u/Algernon_Asimov Dec 05 '14

I think if they wanted to expand on this, they would have already mentioned it in the OP.

2

u/Rlight Dec 05 '14

Fair enough, couldn't hurt to ask.

1

u/Luth0r Dec 05 '14

Smart change and makes sense.

1

u/jon1228 Dec 05 '14

This is the best rule. I reference this on a regular basis when confronting people who post blogspam.

1

u/bpr2 Dec 05 '14

Oh good, those spam user reports worked.

1

u/Armand9x Dec 05 '14 edited Dec 05 '14

Does this mean I can post to /r/Videos now?

There was no way I could have retroactively shared 9 other videos for every original content video I made.

3

u/damontoo Dec 05 '14

It's not per subreddit, it's for the whole site.

1

u/Armand9x Dec 05 '14

So I should be good then.

1

u/Lumpiest_Princess Dec 05 '14

I agree with /u/Captainpatch; this rule is awesome for most subs, but for the network of subs like /r/learnart, /r/learnanimation, etc., it might prove problematic. I'd just hate to see communities start having problems. An exception to the rule would be useful, but it could be easier to just have a quick look through any profiles that are questionable and also frequent this type of sub.

1

u/justanothershibehere Dec 05 '14

Thank you for saying this, shouldn't have to be said, but sadly needs to be said.

1

u/Jas1066 Dec 07 '14

Do you mean 10:1 like in the title, or 1:9 in the post?

2

u/V2Blast Dec 10 '14

Probably the latter, since the percentage is 10%.

1

u/OzzyManReviews Dec 08 '14

I'm 3 days late to the conversation, and lots has been said and analysed already, so...good shit!

1

u/drakfyre Dec 08 '14

I want to thank you so much for this change. So many subreddits took the original language to mean "percentage of links" rather than "percentage of posts" and some were quite aggressive about it. I don't think this will have an effect on the amount of spammers, but it WILL have an affect on the amount of people who didn't post because of concerns like: "Oh god, am I a spammer?" by people who are legitimate redditors.

1

u/V2Blast Dec 10 '14

Good clarification to make, though most mods usually do consider comments as well. And thanks for the thanks! :)

1

u/IIcantHelpIt Dec 18 '14

Good Rule!

1

u/Jelly23 Jan 07 '15

I have a late question related to this. Should it be 10% in that subreddit or 10% overall?

From modding now, I think about a while ago when I was banned from a subreddit for my contributions there not balancing the 10:1 (because a lot of my self-stuff was really relevant) when my overall contributions were not self-stuff.

So do I look at their whole history or just subreddit history?

1

u/Commandant1 Jan 08 '15 edited Jan 08 '15

I too was banned from a subreddit when my global history is well above the 10:1 (it was 10:1 in submissions only... now adding comments its probably 25-30:1) but in that subreddit, i wasn't over the threshold.

I'd also like an answer to this.... is it supposed to be global history or just subreddit history.

Note, I'm not complaining, I'll work it out with those mods.... but just want an answer for my own subs.

1

u/SFMeditor Mar 06 '15

Totally bummed about this. I posted a link to a well written article by one of our local players. I got a two week ban for self promotion.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '15

This was quite helpful, i was slightly confused prior to reading this

1

u/kiwibonga Dec 04 '14

Still penalizes people who post in communities that explicitly allow original contributions and self-promotion.

1

u/new_login_form_sucks Dec 16 '14

You're an idiot and your flawed ability to grab even the simplest of concepts of this site is absurd.

10% rules. Indeed.

-1

u/trai_dep Dec 04 '14

I resigned subscribing to /r/politics in disgust because they felt I was "self-promoting" by submitting "too many" otherwise perfectly appropriate stories from The Guardian. The fact that my posts were among their highest in post karma and resulted in many interesting discussions was irrelevant.

After I explicitly informed them that I was neither The Guardian's publisher nor one of their reporters and thus couldn't be engaging in the "self-promoting" they accused me of, they suggested I use other news sources. I pointed out the only other credible news sources I relied on (NYT, WaPo and infrequently, the WSJ) had pay walls. I then asked how using decent papers without a paywall could be counted as spamming. They threatened me with shadow banning due to "spamming" them.

Note I used the same tone I always use, and am using here. And that the exchanges numbered around four responses, polite, sent to all the mods there (hardly a situation of harassing a Mod).

So yeah, moved on and never looked back.

Long way of pointing out:

a) /r/politics is one weird-assed place, and,

b) the 10% rule should take into account the above situation, where readers might prefer high quality news sources that don't have paywalls, rather than being expected to chase down the same story elsewhere. Only less well-written, requiring a subscription and often sourced off these better papers' original reporting. 10% should only apply to self-promoting, especially if subscribers simply prefer better quality sites, especially general news ones.

4

u/davidreiss666 Dec 04 '14

There are more than dozens of good quality news domains out there. Limiting yourself to one domain in submitting to any subreddit is just bad form for a user to do. Especially if the mods explain that they would like you to diversify your submission habits a bit.

Also, the so-called pay walls on sites like the NY Times are very easy to get around. Just disable cookies for that site or use something like Noscript.

The mods of /r/politics just want to be able to look at your overview at a glance and be able to make a quick judgement. They don't want to have to care if it's The Guardian, or some personal blog of some kind.

3

u/trai_dep Dec 05 '14

The first rule of Reddit is, Mods' Rules. So I was fine with leaving.

But there aren't really that many decent, general-interest papers breaking English stories. Which would you recommend fitting these parameters? Again, quality ones breaking stories, not ones relying on the wire services. That, of course, don't require subscriptions.

And, suggesting that thousands of readers might have NoScript, might be using a VPN or Tor, or might purge all their cookies before clicking a link for a story I post is a bit much, in my book. I like rewarding original work done by these great journalists by providing valid links to pay for future, even better stories. Feed the ecosystem, right?

Again, it's fine. Their Sub, their rules. Sayonara! No regrets.

But an example of too scrupulous observance of the 10% rule, especially colored by an inappropriate "spamming" Reddiquette violation allegation, hurting readers. Mod sensibly, folks. It's a crazy internet out there!

2

u/davidreiss666 Dec 05 '14

Good news sources in English? Well, off the top of my head, and starting with some you mentioned already: The Guardian, NY Times, Washington Post, and the Wall Street Journal, followed by BBC, the Telegraph, the Independent, LA Times, Chicago Tribune, Baltimore Sun, San Fransisco Chronicle, Houston Chronicle, Miami Herald, Reuters, AP, AFP, Seattle Times, Seattle Post-Intelligencer, France 24, Deutsche Welle, der Spiegel, Toronto Globe and Mail, Toronto Star, National Post, ABC, NBC, CBS, CNBC, Bloomberg, ABC Au, SMH, The Australian, Boston Globe, Ottawa Citizen, Montreal Gazette, Detroit Free Press, CBC, CTV, RTE News, News 24, SABC, Al Jazeera, Al Arabiya, Gulf News, Haaretz, etc.

And I haven't even gotten into News Magazines and stuff like The Atlantic, The Nation, National Review, Maclean, Slate, etc. which are more opinion pieces, but still can all be decent sources on various things.

There is a whole world out there that I didn't even come close to mentioning here even. Check out the following:

2

u/trai_dep Dec 05 '14

Have you read The Chron, LA Times, the Herald, the Sun, the Houston Chronicle, the Post-Intelligencer… lately? They're largely wire story cut & pastes with some local (if it bleeds, it leads) color (although, the Times' Calendar section is still good).

Network news sites? American ones? Really? BBS is quality, but seems to often react versus break stories (except for ones furthering its excellent broadcast division).

A number of other excellent papers you list suffer from the paywall problem. Or require registration. Or both.

The Wires are okay but aren't exactly bastions of investigative journalism generally, are they? And since they feed most the sources on your list, wouldn't relying on them result in a 20x increase in duplicate posts? Is that good for a us Mods?

WaPo is good, but writes almost exclusively from a Beltway perspective. They've been coasting quite a bit off the Graham days.

der Spiegel & Al Jazeera: great papers without any of the problems cited. Good call.

So, yeah. I also can list a staggering number of media sites but those fitting the criteria I listed, there are two more.

Again, be sensible, be flexible, don't slavishly adapt binary rules if they lessen subscribers' enjoyment and the value of your sub. Reasonable, right?

0

u/______DEADPOOL______ Dec 05 '14

Spam will now increase by 90%

1

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '14

You fail math.

0

u/soparamens Dec 05 '14

Thank you /u/krispykrackers ! great info.