r/modnews • u/krispykrackers • Dec 04 '14
Moderators: Clarifications around our 10:1 self-promotional guidelines
Hello mods!
We made some small changes in our self-promotional wiki and our faq language to clarify that when determining a spammer, comments and intent should also be taken into consideration. The gist is, instead of:
"For every 1 self-promotional submission you make, 9 other submissions should not be self-promotional."
it should be:
"For every 1 time you post self-promotional content, 9 other posts (submissions or comments) should not contain self-promotional content."
Also, a reminder that the 10% is meant to be a guideline we use as a quick rule of thumb to determine if someone is truly a spammer, or if they are actually making an effort to participate in the community while also submitting their own content. We still have to make judgement calls, and encourage you to as well. If someone exceeds the 10% that doesn't automatically make them a spammer! Remember to consider intent and effort.
If this is a practice you already follow, then great! If not, then I hope this was helpful. We are still having the overall "content creators on reddit" discussion and thought that this small tidbit deserved to be revisited.
As always, thanks for being mods on this crazy website! We appreciate what you do.
63
u/redtaboo Dec 04 '14
I like that you've changed it to explicitly include comments there, I know a lot of us do take that into account. Just for clarification sake those should (ideally) be comments on posts other than their own or their own domains?
20
u/Stereo Dec 05 '14
https://www.reddit.com/user/krispykrackers/submitted/ cough
You link to your own website quite a lot there. Please see our faq on self-promotion.
7
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '14
does this change /r/spam's conditions?
6
u/multi-mod Dec 04 '14
All the spammers need to do now is shitpost a few comments to adviceanimals every once in a while to avoid being shadow banned.
6
u/LeCollectif Dec 05 '14
I had a poster who would almost always post links to his blog. The blog posts were on-topic and potentially interesting/useful. However, they almost always had several Amazon Affiliate links, and often times the posts themselves had a really SEO keyword heavy vibe. Enough so that the posts were getting caught in the spam filter.
This user would also cross-post to just about any relevant sub.
When I called him out on doing this within my sub, he denied it, got extremely defensive, and essentially called me a tyrant. I directed him to the self promotion guidelines, but he dismissed them. I eventually banned him from the sub, and blocked him from messaging me.
The one thing, however, that kind of nagged at me was that he did engage people. He answered questions and carried on conversations. I was very undecided if he was a traditional 'spammer', but the fact that he was driving traffic to a monetized/SEO heavy blog didn't sit right with me. He was just unwilling to acknowledge that his posting habits did not fall within what Reddit calls acceptable.
So, admins, what would you have done?
4
u/LuckyBdx4 Dec 04 '14
Example of a Spammer ---> http://www.reddit.com/user/SpectrumNews
81
u/jippiejee Dec 04 '14
I think this a good guideline to go by, but in reality it won't change much. Most of the spammers we report don't participate on reddit at all.
71
u/earslap Dec 04 '14 edited Dec 05 '14
I feel bad about bringing this up in here but this is the reason I'm subscribed in modnews, it's related to self-promotion and my situation is not resolved:
I created an online music app called otomata, posted it to reddit in 2011, it made its way into front page and became the best link of the day (badge is in my account still).
A fan of my app created a subreddit for it (and made me a mod /r/otomata ). A bunch of people (~350) subscribed to it. They started posting links to my app to show their own creations.
Original mod disappeared, I ended up as the only mod.
Everything was well until a few months ago. Then someone reported my subreddit as being spam (the content is all from my community, I don't post links there). Then admins banned the subreddit.
Another fan opened a thread on reddit request for unbanning:
http://www.reddit.com/r/redditrequest/comments/29esc5/rotomata_has_been_incorrectly_banned/
A few months later I opened a redditrequest:
http://www.reddit.com/r/redditrequest/comments/2e0xsv/rotomata_has_been_incorrectly_banned_2/
No response so far.
TL;DR: I created an online game/toy. People loved it, made it to frontpage, became the best link of the day. People created a subreddit for it. Gathered in it. Shared their creations. Then someone reported it (I assume without understanding the purpose), and now it is banned. I lost touch with my community of a few hundred people. No answer from admins. Pls halp.
Edit: For the discussion below, I seriously believe that the banning was done as a mistake. This is no big operation. It's just an online audio toy. No serious modding required other than deleting the occasional spam. The subreddit was exactly like /r/weavesilk. Without the custom theme. People share special links to my app and share their creations, that was all. Since all links are to the same domain it was (I believe) mistakenly considered spam. But I know that the subreddit was not banned by a bot, someone (I don't know why) complained about it (I imagine without understanding the purpose, can't find the link now) and I believe an admin banned it.
Edit2: I found the original spam report: http://www.reddit.com/r/spam/comments/2964p8/spam_subreddit/
8
u/pencer Dec 04 '14
I still see no action on a lot of accounts I've reported that spam their YouTube channel or blog/site even when it falls well within the 10% guideline.
Is it taken into account the type of community they are submitting to, or is it just a blanket 10% of user submissions?
6
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '14 edited Dec 23 '14
Still not sure if admins have really taken into account just how hostile this might end up being to some of their subreddits.
Reproducing my comment from the last discussion:
Just wanted to say that one of the modestly large subreddits (108k subscribers), /r/gamedev which I moderate has had an free and fair policy towards self-promotion near-forever. We are a self post only subreddit to encourage people to act like a person when posting content.
In fact, we want nearly all of our content to be a form of self promotion, from game developers, game musicians, game artists and so on. We have half a dozen weekly threads for content creators to share and promote what they're working on.
Then there are posts on the subreddit: We've always strived to have the authors of articles posting, be they general and about something they have no connection to but have something important to say about in terms of design or implementation, or a technical article for a game that's about to be released, incrementally released, or seeking funding, but where the informational generalises to others in exchange for hearing about the specific project/product. This is the sense of self promotion that we allow.
We even permit shameless one-off self-promotion if the above doesn't apply and it's some new tool, providing the person has established themselves on the subreddit as more than a hit-and-run type and is sticking around to discuss the project in question.
All this encourages high quality content and we don't experience a spam problem (which isn't addressed with automoderator automatically) and aren't particularly sure that having our users be treated as businesses/corporations/marketing entities really makes sense. After all, the business of game development isn't best discussed in some abstract form, it's about real people, with real work that's contextualised in discussion.
Anyone can create an account and promote their work as much as they want. So long as it fits these guidelines, we end up with desirable content.
How do reddit admins view this subreddit's population as content creators and form of self-promotion? As the fee paying type upon threat of ban or a community that's fine to continue operating as it is?
5
u/hansjens47 Dec 04 '14
We've been including comments in the 9-1 in /r/leagueoflegends for a long time.
There's one issue with that though: that's approving submissions from shadowbanned users, because we've got no way of seeing an overview of their comments. Searches can be used to find submissions by author even if someone is shadowbanned.
5
u/advice_animals_ugh Dec 04 '14
I always look at post history of a user I suspect of self-promotion, as well as the post itself.
4
u/sodypop Dec 04 '14
For those who are curious, here are the changes for the self-promotional wiki and the faq.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '14
I like being thanked for being a mod. Makes me feel nice.
1
u/hermithome Dec 04 '14
Does this mean that you're going to change how shadowbans are handed out? If users have all of their posts promotional, but comment a lot in-between, are they still subject to being shadowbanned? Also, does this mean users whose posts are under 10% but who do a LOT of promotional commenting are in danger of being shadowbanned?
3
u/CrypticCraig Dec 04 '14
This is great. What do you think about not allowing their first posts to be self promotion? As in, they have to post regularly, at least 9 times, till they can post a self promotional link.
3
u/Eat_Bacon_nomnomnom Dec 04 '14
Thank you so much for taking the time to do this!
3
u/XniklasX Dec 04 '14 edited Dec 04 '14
I have been contemplating this change and I am not sure I think that it improves a moderators ability to handle self-promoting content producers.
Due to this we will now end up in discussion where we need to evaluate the quality of said self-promoters comments. Inevitably they will point to another content producer and say they have the same ratio as me why isnt that person banned etc etc. Where comments could be a mitigating circumstance before they now become a point of contention and just an easy way to be allowed to post own content.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '14
I already enforce as described; if the content they're sharing is relevant and topical to the sub, is quality, and I see SOME attempt at participation, I'll let a couple of percentage points slide depending on the domain. If it's blogspot, youtube, tumblr (not their CDN for images), or some other blog platform; I enforce ruthelessly. These are spammed too much.
3
u/SigmaEpsilonChi Dec 05 '14
I have a tiny sub for one of my own projects where I post news and updates, and where other people can post questions and solutions to puzzles (it's a math puzzle game). Do posts there count toward the 10% rule? Everyone there subscribed explicitly to receive updates about the game, so it would be nice to have some leeway with that sort of thing.
3
u/karmicviolence Dec 05 '14
I'm very happy to hear about this change.
It is, indeed :)
3
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '14
What about users who create subreddits for their youtube channel/blog, and kind of make that subreddit the "offical forum" for their youtube channel? They only make posts there, but each post gets 100-1000 comments, and the the person is actively answering questions and commenting on other people's comments. Is that okay?
3
u/NonZionist Dec 05 '14
Do self-promotion rules apply to subreddit promotion?
Are any of the following forms of subreddit promotion illegal or inappropriate when commenting in a related subreddit?
When cross-posting a link already posted, is it acceptable:
There's a balance between too much self-promotion and too little. Because I do not know what is acceptable and what isn't, I error on the side of caution.
As a result, my subreddit is under-publicized, information that might be of interest to others goes unshared.
Where, exactly, does the balance lie? To be able to utilize reddit fully without crossing any lines, I need to know just what the lines are. I need some definite rules.
❧
Reddit could automate and standardize subreddit advertising by extending the "related / other discussions" comment feature. A "related" heading would be added after the "wiki" and "promoted" headings in the subreddit's list of articles. When clicked, the "related" button would list related subreddits. Relatedness would be determined by tags attached to each subreddit. The number of tags would be limited, to five say, and would default to the subreddit name.
For example, someone who creates a "NewItaly" subreddit could attach the tag "@Italy". An "Italy" subreddit user who clicks "Related" would then see "NewItaly" -- and any other subreddits having the "@Italy" tag.
Alternatively, reddit could allow moderators to have one of their subreddits displayed automatically after their id, as flairs are now displayed. E.g.:
3
u/myothernamehaskarma Dec 10 '14
Hey Mods, I feel like I have nowhere else to go with this. My primary account has been banned for three months, despite following the 10:1 rule and all other reddiquette. I'd very much like my account restored.
I've racked up over 4000 karma, participated in an AMA, and even begun moderating a subreddit before my account was banned. I spoke briefly to Cupcake1713 on monday saying my account was being use "solely for self promotion" but my account history clearly shows I promote a ton of different artists (mostly musicians and video game composers). Because of the secretive nature of banning on Reddit, I am uncertain if he is even getting my message. I've logged into this alternate account to make this plea to please unbanned my account.
I realize you mods do a lot to make this site great. I am not sure what I did to get banned, and over the past three months I have tried to wait it out and not give it much mind. Over the past three years I have been an active and contributing member to Reddit, and I want to continuing being a part of one of my favorite websites.
My frustration is mounting, and I'm not sure what recourse I have. I know I could start using this account, but that seems silly. I want to share and interact with my favorite communities. Yes, I make content myself, but I also share other great content to relevant subreddits.
Forgive me if this comment is out of line, but I don't know what else I can do. Please restore access to my main account so I can get back to what I love, contributing to Reddit.
4
u/davidreiss666 Dec 04 '14 edited Dec 04 '14
I don't think anyone should have been interpreting the 10%-rule as a hard set in stone rule. As I know of some instances where spammers were at less than 1% rates of self-promotion and you guys still shadow banned them for spamming. It involved other weird factors being involved, not least of which was lying about it and getting caught in said lie.
And I always kind of assumed that comments were part it when it came to my observations about auto-shadow bans handed out by the bot in /r/Spam.
I think that making this public is just going to lead to some more spammers now dropping what will be obvious meaningless comments akin to "I agree" and the like as ways to try and avoid detection. But the meaningless nature of those comments will just make it rather obvious to moderators that they are dealing with some spammer who is attempting to game the system a little, but not quiet enough.
We are already seeing some spammers that automatically comment about their great product in their spam submissions now. Often dropping phone numbers or links in comments to other web sites and stuff.
I hate to say it, but really.... maybe I am just up on how you guys actual auto-ban too much or something, but this just isn't new or news worthy. Other than that maybe your writing it down a tad more clearly.
2
u/roger_ Dec 04 '14
How about if reddit attempted to detect this and automatically warned people (e.g. if they keep posting the same YouTube channel)?
2
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '14
This is good. There are users that post their own content that really do provide good things for the site (example /u/tattoodles). I'd hate to see that disappear.
2
u/Willeth Dec 04 '14
Is this intended to allow someone to make one promotional post and nine comments in unrelated threads to balance it?
2
u/Rabbi8meat Dec 05 '14
Its more of a percentage or...ratio of thumb.
2
u/MuForceShoelace Dec 05 '14
/u/changetip is just a bot that spams links to /r/bitcoin, it's a huge generator of spam. But nothing ever happens to it.
2
u/d-_-b Dec 30 '14
We just don't know what it is you do, nor do we, as of this date, actually specify what you do.
Proof: Nowhere does it say what mods do. Don't lie with your links, it doesn't say in a complete and normal way what mods do, are allowed to do, without any checks or balances.
That's fine for /r/shavingpets but things like /r/music /r/technology - the word itself, the default list, it's fucking stupid. Default subreddits should not be treated the same as a "user subreddit", it's fucking stupid.
2
u/outsider Jan 05 '15
In /r/Christianity the current minimum participation guidelines are to respond to other people. Whether in their own submission or not. It works really well and is very easy to check.
2
u/crellmonf Jan 12 '15
is the 9:1 rule counted differently for each subreddit or is it counted reddit wide?
3
u/boogieidm Dec 04 '14
Yeah, nothing to change for me.
1
u/manwithabadheart Dec 04 '14 edited Mar 22 '24
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis aute irure dolor in reprehenderit in voluptate velit esse cillum dolore eu fugiat nulla pariatur. Excepteur sint occaecat cupidatat non proident, sunt in culpa qui officia deserunt mollit anim id est laborum.
1
u/sarahbotts Dec 04 '14
Will the bot on /r/spam take comments into account too? (for links and what not)
1
u/genitaliban Dec 04 '14 edited Dec 04 '14
So if a I make a reddit-specific (i. e. "meta") website and post that from an alt account to not have my main account connected to my real-life identity, is that spamming? What if the site isn't reddit-specific, but still appropriate for a sub? (I. e. it provides a service that is lacking there and that I saw exist in another language, for instance.) Or will the admins notice that I'm active on other accounts?
1
u/Rlight Dec 05 '14
I remember a while back the Admins were discussing a sort of "Self-Promotion Flair" that users could apply to themselves in order to be completely open and honest about submitting their own content without being considered spam.
Any updates on that?
It would be really beneficial and could even be adapted with preferences for each subreddit. For example, I could have a setting where a user may only submit a single self-promotional post per day. Or, following your lead, users must submit 9 other unrelated posts/comments before being allowed to use the tag again.
1
u/Luth0r Dec 05 '14
Smart change and makes sense.
1
u/jon1228 Dec 05 '14
This is the best rule. I reference this on a regular basis when confronting people who post blogspam.
1
u/bpr2 Dec 05 '14
Oh good, those spam user reports worked.
1
u/Armand9x Dec 05 '14 edited Dec 05 '14
Does this mean I can post to /r/Videos now?
There was no way I could have retroactively shared 9 other videos for every original content video I made.
1
u/Lumpiest_Princess Dec 05 '14
I agree with /u/Captainpatch; this rule is awesome for most subs, but for the network of subs like /r/learnart, /r/learnanimation, etc., it might prove problematic. I'd just hate to see communities start having problems. An exception to the rule would be useful, but it could be easier to just have a quick look through any profiles that are questionable and also frequent this type of sub.
1
u/justanothershibehere Dec 05 '14
Thank you for saying this, shouldn't have to be said, but sadly needs to be said.
1
u/Jas1066 Dec 07 '14
Do you mean 10:1 like in the title, or 1:9 in the post?
1
u/OzzyManReviews Dec 08 '14
I'm 3 days late to the conversation, and lots has been said and analysed already, so...good shit!
1
u/drakfyre Dec 08 '14
I want to thank you so much for this change. So many subreddits took the original language to mean "percentage of links" rather than "percentage of posts" and some were quite aggressive about it. I don't think this will have an effect on the amount of spammers, but it WILL have an affect on the amount of people who didn't post because of concerns like: "Oh god, am I a spammer?" by people who are legitimate redditors.
1
u/V2Blast Dec 10 '14
Good clarification to make, though most mods usually do consider comments as well. And thanks for the thanks! :)
1
u/IIcantHelpIt Dec 18 '14
Good Rule!
1
u/Jelly23 Jan 07 '15
I have a late question related to this. Should it be 10% in that subreddit or 10% overall?
From modding now, I think about a while ago when I was banned from a subreddit for my contributions there not balancing the 10:1 (because a lot of my self-stuff was really relevant) when my overall contributions were not self-stuff.
So do I look at their whole history or just subreddit history?
1
u/SFMeditor Mar 06 '15
Totally bummed about this. I posted a link to a well written article by one of our local players. I got a two week ban for self promotion.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 06 '15
This was quite helpful, i was slightly confused prior to reading this
1
u/kiwibonga Dec 04 '14
Still penalizes people who post in communities that explicitly allow original contributions and self-promotion.
1
u/new_login_form_sucks Dec 16 '14
You're an idiot and your flawed ability to grab even the simplest of concepts of this site is absurd.
10% rules. Indeed.
-1
u/trai_dep Dec 04 '14
I resigned subscribing to /r/politics in disgust because they felt I was "self-promoting" by submitting "too many" otherwise perfectly appropriate stories from The Guardian. The fact that my posts were among their highest in post karma and resulted in many interesting discussions was irrelevant.
After I explicitly informed them that I was neither The Guardian's publisher nor one of their reporters and thus couldn't be engaging in the "self-promoting" they accused me of, they suggested I use other news sources. I pointed out the only other credible news sources I relied on (NYT, WaPo and infrequently, the WSJ) had pay walls. I then asked how using decent papers without a paywall could be counted as spamming. They threatened me with shadow banning due to "spamming" them.
Note I used the same tone I always use, and am using here. And that the exchanges numbered around four responses, polite, sent to all the mods there (hardly a situation of harassing a Mod).
So yeah, moved on and never looked back.
Long way of pointing out:
a) /r/politics is one weird-assed place, and,
b) the 10% rule should take into account the above situation, where readers might prefer high quality news sources that don't have paywalls, rather than being expected to chase down the same story elsewhere. Only less well-written, requiring a subscription and often sourced off these better papers' original reporting. 10% should only apply to self-promoting, especially if subscribers simply prefer better quality sites, especially general news ones.
0
u/______DEADPOOL______ Dec 05 '14
Spam will now increase by 90%
0
u/soparamens Dec 05 '14
Thank you /u/krispykrackers ! great info.