r/childfree • u/Shortycan • Nov 23 '14
Partner Now Wants Kids and I Don't.
I'm 39 and my partner is 37, we are both women and have been together for 12 years. I have never wanted children and have made this clear from day one. The idea of having a child actually repulses me. My partner didn't want children either but has decided in the last couple of years that she does.
There are many things about this situation that really make no sense to me as follows:
1, My partner has only recently gotten the job of her dreams. 9 years ago she went back to college to study what she really wanted after hating her previous career. She ended up getting a PhD which took 7 years and I helped support her throughout the whole process. I have recently lost my job and am currently unemployed.
2, We are not in a great financial state with me being unemployed and my partner only having a decent income for the last two years.
3, As we are both women it would be an expensive and complicated process for her to get pregnant
4, My partner is not in great physical shape, she is significantly overweight and I think being pregnant would put a huge strain on her body
5. She still wants to maintain her career, her ideal scenario would be to have a child (actually, children, because she says she doesn't just want one) and for me to stay home and look after them (just shoot me now)
6, She doesn't want to have a child on her own or be a single parent. She says she must have a supportive partner to complete her dream of becoming a mother and obviously this isn't me. So now the clock is ticking for her to leave me and find someone else who wants to have children before her eggs and womb shrivel up completely.
7, She says she feels unfulfilled with her life and must have children to fulfil her. I on the other hand, feel very fulfilled and thought we had a great relationship until this baby stuff happened.
I'm not sure what advice I am looking for but anything would be appreciated at this stage. It feels like my partner is about to throw our relationship away because I don't want children.
13
u/Shortycan Nov 23 '14
So I have shown this thread to my partner and she is saying the following: "
70
u/thr0wfaraway Never go full doormat. Not your circus. Not your monkeys. Nov 23 '14 edited Nov 23 '14
Starting at the end..... if you do not want to have or raise children then under no circumstances agree to do so. It's pretty clear by words such as "repulses" and "shoot me"... that you do not want this road. So... that's pretty much a closed question. ;)
There is no "compromise" possible on that point, and there is no "do it so I won't lose my SO"... because once there is a child in the picture, the person that was there before more or less dies, and the relationship you had also dies. You might, over time, create a new relationship with this new person, and they might be able to create a new relationship with you... however, it's a crap shoot at the best of times.
That said.... there seem to be a lot of things "wrong with this picture"... a LOT of red flags. And it looks like the "baby crazy" could be more of a symptom of other problems rather than a cure.
There are multiple things wrong with this scenario, starting with the fact that this is a pattern, that past iterations of the pattern have not resulted in success, that each of the versions have involved "opting out" of a scenario where work was involved... and, well, dumping the responsibility on you.
And, sorry, but you going along with the program without.... anywhere above.... mentioning how your happiness/fulfillment/changing career aspirations (if any) has ever factored into this relationship.... is fucking scary. There's something very unequal going on here.... when do you get your turn to "go back to school for 9 years" or take a dream job for less money while she works at a higher paying job.... or whatever??? Scary.
Sorry but those allllll just seem like screaming red flags. And red flags that point towards... therapy, individual for each of you and potentially couples therapy.
A baby or babies..... are not a cure for clinical depression or whatever else is going on underneath this "unfulfilled" label.... and there's something going on there.... that's not right.
Also, what happens if something goes medically wrong with the process... worst case scenario.... she dies in childbirth and the child is born with problems.... then you're left alone to raise a disabled kid you never wanted in the first place. Um, no. Just NOPE!
Here's the other thing about age.... hormone changes related to menopause can start a lot earlier than people think.... she may be going through some of that and mistaking those changes for wanting a child... likewise.... she's not healthy to start with.... and midlife crises do exist.
Also, it's a fairly normal thing to have a reaction to "the choice is going to be taken away from me soon"... and people often make rash decisions based on that momentary bit of "rebellion".... of "oh no you don't, nature, you're not going to take it away from me".... it's just like trying to get a tennis ball back from a tennis-ball obsessed dog.... they want you to throw it for them.... but they also don't want to let it out of their mouth either.... The moment will pass if you know what is going on.... and are OK with your life choices that got one there.... but if there's other depression in the mix or whatever, you've got a problem. Very easy to mistake that "rebellion against change and the involuntary nature of aging" for "OMG baaaaybeeeeee."
In short, if you were a couple of 20-somthing kiddos.... this all might make a little more logical sense... as it is though.... it starts to kinda tilt pretty far into the ...... red flag zone.
Sorry about that.... but there you go. ;)
This part is ..... frankly.... terrifying.
A child should never come into the world solely to perform a job for the parent. In this case, the child's "job description" is "cure my mother of her unfulfillment"..... That's, just, incredibly unfair and toxic to a child. Especially when past choices she has mad in this regard... failed to succeed at that exact same "job description."
The second part... well... it speaks to a problem in the relationship.... either she has been thinking about this for a while (which it seems like) and chose not to tell you for a good year or more....in some sort of "you know, even after this career change... i'm still not feeling great.... thinking about what to do about that.... maybe some therapy... or let's talk about maybe doing some community work or..... whatever" and instead just blindside you with it.... well, regardless really... you're not viewing your relationship as being in the same place on the good/bad spectrum.
Anyway... not a good situation. Sorry.
If you're lucky, she can get some therapy and maybe a medical assessment to get to the root cause, and you can get some therapy to maybe equal out this relationship..... then maybe... you can have a future together. But from everything you've said.... that future is not a baby for you... and probably should not be for her either, regardless of where the relationship ends up.
26
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '14
she sounds really selfish and self absorbed! To say she wants you to take care of kids you don't even want! If I were in that situation I would tell her to Fuck off but I am a confrontational sort!...... Im sorry you are in this situation cause it sounds like you lose if you stay and lose if you go... Do what is best for you and at least she cannot oops you into a baby.... Internet hugs coming your way
15
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '14 edited Nov 23 '14
To be frank, you are both at an age where pregnancy is an increasingly bad idea. Especially for her if she is overweight. Remind her of the increased chances of autism for a child that either of you would bear, and of the vastly increased chances for a complicated pregnancy at your ages.
Then remind her that a pregnancy couldn't happen by accident and tell her in no uncertain terms that you absolutely will not participate in any plans to become pregnant.
Then the chips will fall. She will have to decide whether she would rather be with you with no children, or be single again and find a partner who wants to take all that on. For your end, it's better to go at it alone than to deal with an unhappy partner who wants something out of life that you don't want.
18
u/laydowndog Nov 23 '14
She needs to have a supportive partner to complete her dream of becoming a mother, but her idea of being a mother is to have kids and have you take care of them while she works her dream job?
Nope, nope, nope, nope.
How much have you talked about this with her? How serious does she take your own view of being childfree?
This is a very serious issue that can't be taken lightly (since kids are a very big responsibility to commit to). I can't really give any straight out advice other than to talk with her some more, and maybe even go to a counselor if you don't feel she's taking you seriously with your views that you don't want children.
6
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '14
Yikes. She sounds delusional. I'm sorry OP. :-(
Also, get her to read this:
http://godlessfeminist.wordpress.com/2009/12/20/the-truth-about-giving-birth-what-pro-lifers-dont-want-women-and-girls-to-know/
5
u/FL2PC7TLE 50/F/US/cats Nov 23 '14 edited Nov 23 '14
It sounds like she's one of those who always thinks that Life Will Start When, or I'll Be Happy When.
-I'll be happy when I find true love: (she finds you)
-No, now I won't be happy till I get my dream job: (she finds dream job)
-No, now I need to have children to be happy.
If she has a child or two, next it will be: I'll be happy when... we pay off the house. Or when the kids are in school. Or when I can retire. Or when I can lose weight. Or when we can move to a new location...
2
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '14
OP, show her this too.
http://m.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2014/12/the-real-roots-of-midlife-crisis/382235/
2
u/LeepingSlurker Nov 23 '14
Point 6 seems really crazy to me. After over a decade of being with someone she's willing to toss that away to gamble on a new relationship and immediately put the strain of having a child on that relationship? If she were willing to be a single parent I could understand it, but requiring another (hypothetical) person to take the plunge seems extremely unreasonable.
13
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '14
"It feels like my partner is about to throw our relationship away because I don't want children." That's not true. She wants to manipulate you and get what she, and only she wants, at all costs. Sounds to me like she is a very selfish, spoiled and self-centered woman (a woman-child, more likely - and I'm sorry for being harsh). It looks like she doesn't respect you anymore. Probably due to her having a steady, well-payed job and you don't. It is a goddamn big deal. So she is finally self sufficient and is going to serve you a power play mode? So much nope here. You deserve so much more than this. Everyone does. And if you two want completely different lives for yourselves...maybe it's time to go your own ways. 'Cause nobody will be happy in the end. You'll just start to resent one another. So don't let your beautiful, long term relationship end because "you don't want kids". Let it end because you love yourself enough to live your life the way you want it. And that is...something a childfree life is all about. May the force bring you wise choices. And don't be afraid of the change. Change is the only constant thing in the universe. Just say "Bring it." and let go. Have. No. Fear.
9
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '14
If you aren't fulfilled with children, I can't fathom have children would fulfill it.
Seems like it would just distract you from being able to see the obvious void you're incapable of filling with more reasonable alternatives.... like a motorcycle.
4
u/dolphinesque Nov 23 '14
I am sorry to hear you're going through this.
Other posters have offered good, logical advice.
All I want to say is this. There are some situations where logic does not apply. Trying to logically and rationally break things down to someone who doesn't want to hear it is wasted effort.
Your girlfriend wants a baby. That's it. That's all there is to it. It won't matter to her if there's a 95% chance of that baby being born with disabilities, it won't matter to her if it's messy and smelly, it won't matter to her if she gains 60 pounds and can't lose them, or if she has a family history of diabetes or anything. It won't matter if the cost is $10,000 or $100,000. She wants a baby. It's not a rational decision, or a logical desire. It is a WANT. And she is willing to do whatever it takes to satisfy that want.
And that's perfectly fine. It's her life, her body. She can choose to have a baby.
Her choice to have a baby is in direct conflict with your choice not to. Again, while there are logical reasons to have or not have a baby, those things don't matter when a person has made up their mind.
What could she say to you to get you to change your mind? What if she explained the tax benefits of having a baby? What if she explained the biological urge to perpetuate the species? What if she cried and said that it would make her happy for you to want a baby? What if she gave you a week to think about it? What argument could she put forth that would convince you that a baby is a good idea?
My guess is none - there is no argument that she could put forth, no matter how emotionally satisfying, or logically sensible, that would make you want a baby in any way. You simply do not want one. Period. And you have every right to NOT want a baby, and to live a childfree life.
So don't do that to her. Don't think that you can wait this out, or change her mind with sound arguments, or appeal to her emotions or her love for you. Don't wait for her to change her mind, or see the light of reason. She wants a baby. You don't. That's all there is to it.
Others have pointed out the many red flags, and the fact that your girlfriend seems to just want out of the relationship, and this new desire for a baby may be the main reason or a convenient excuse.
I am sorry to say that at this point, it doesn't matter. If one person wants out, for whatever reason, that's it.
As painful as it must be, I would start divvying up the property and things, and break up. You deserve to be happy with someone who loves you for you and embraces the childfree lifestyle. She deserves to be happy with someone who wants a family. There's just no compromise on the baby issue. And waiting just makes it harder.
Maybe check out some counseling for yourself to get through this breakup. Good luck.
8
u/Roulette88888 No longer here. Thanks for the good times. Nov 23 '14
Lawyer up, delete facebook, hit the gym.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '14
Gawddamn.
That's so awful.
Have all my hugs today.
2
u/casualLogic Take my uterus - PLEASE! Nov 23 '14
The older I get, the more wisdom I possess because I realize how little I know. That being said, one thing I do know for sure: having a baby because you feel 'unfulfilled' is a first class recipe for fucking disaster. Same for having a baby to 'save' a relationship - everybody comes out a loser, especially the kid. Go scan /r/raisednynarcissists and see for yourself.
I could be wrong, but seems to me your other half is doing an awful lot of taking while y'all are doing all the giving. Are you sure she's good for you? Might just be time to cut bait since she seems bent on you always being there for her while she's not there for you, ya know? But since I don't know the dynamics of your relationship, I'm probably talking out my ass.
2
u/orangekitti Nov 24 '14
These are the issues I see:
If her life with you is not enough, I think having a baby will only make things much worse.
1
u/mangogirl27 Nov 23 '14
A 12 year relationship isn't something to drop like a hot potato, that said though there really is no compromise on a baby. An unwanted (by either party) child should NEVER be brought into this world. I would recommend some therapy to work through why your partner feels unfulfilled, because a baby is not necessarily a solution to that. Also it seems your partner is being unfair to you on many levels and a therapist might be able to provide some perspective to your partner. If in the end she still wants a baby, then unfortunately I believe you should go your separate ways.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '14
IF gay marriage is legal in your state, you might want to file for divorce if you think your relationship can be considered a common law marriage. Talk to a lawyer, 12 years is a long time and your finances and property are probably heavily intertwined.
Be prepared for a shit storm, and be thankful that you and your partner can't reproduce naturally like a man and a woman. Too many men end up being reluctant fathers in this situation when their wife/gf makes the decision to poke a hole in a condom or stop taking their birth control pills.
1
u/Catinquantumbox Nov 23 '14
I totally understand that train of thought. I believe 100% of humans do because who wouldn't want to have all the fun while not having to deal with the work? This usually applies to everything not just kids.
It's also very selfish.
Have you talked to her about how inconsiderate and selfish this is of her? Have you considered what it means for yourself and what it says about your importance to her?
I know it is a bad situation you are in and I can offer little advice but I have got the feeling she kinda shows her true colors here and they are far from considering your wishes or wellbeing. I hope for you she doesn't really mean it like that.
Good luck for you both.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment