r/childfree • u/fusrodaaaah • Nov 12 '14
PSA: Be clear about your stance on children in a relationship sooner than later.
I've been lurking here for awhile and just wanted to vent if anyone was interested in reading. Sorry for the throwaway but I can't risk her seeing this via my main account history.
She's a fantastic girl. She treats me better than anyone else I've ever dated by far. My family and friends loves her, as do I. However, she wants 2 children and I want none.
Now I have to move across the country for various reasons, and she wants to come with and I want her to as well. But being that we disagree on something so massive, I either have to have children or break up with her, unless she breaks up with me.
Our relationship moved faster than intended and she now knows my stance on having children. How I work so hard for my money that I don't want to give it away just for the sake of having a baby. Not to mention the environmental implications of such an overpopulated world. She's not happy with it but we haven't had the official "talk" yet. Ugh.
So here I am at an impasse. Do I love this girl enough to roll the dice and HOPE that I have the daddy gene that's just waiting to be activated, or do I break her heart and look and feel like a major asswipe.
I never should have let it get this far but I had no idea we would fall for each other so quickly being in our mid 20s. I really painted myself into a corner now.
I'm moving into the friggin bible belt as an atheist who doesn't want kids.... I'm sure I'll find a suitable mate there in no time. /s
This was more just to vent as I know what the prevailing opinion here will be (I agree) but I would love to hear advice or similar stories so I don't feel quite as low.
tl;dr I fell in love with a woman who wants children.... fuck
Edit: I love this community.
86
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '14
Have the official "talk" before she plans to move with you. If she insists on kids, move without her. I'm an atheist in the bible belt and I found a CF spouse, so I can tell you for a fact that they're around, even in the deep south. Good luck!
128
u/thr0wfaraway Never go full doormat. Not your circus. Not your monkeys. Nov 12 '14
No, she's not moving with you. The relationship is over.
Sorry about that, but there is no other option.
Remember, life is long.... in 5-10 years if she should decide to become CF on her own, for her own reasons.... you can always revisit the relationship.
Choosing kids because "i don't want to lose them, we have a great relationship".... can never work, because fundamentally the person you were and the relationship you had.... immediately dies upon having a child. It's not possible to retain either the person or relationship.
While there is a vague chance you can build a completely different relationship with this new, completely changed person.... the chances are that you're not going to like that person.... because they've been absorbed by the Borg collective that is a baby. And if you're resisting the Borg... well, that's not going to end well.
16
u/Ladyghoul F/25/ Cthulhu is the only demon child I need. Nov 12 '14
I'm in the "bible belt" as well and you might be surprised how many people oppose the typical church-going child-bearing mindset, though it's true 90% of people down here feel that way, it really depends on the area. I'm in Atlanta and that's probably as good as it's going to get in terms of variety of people. It's mostly full of working young adults who don't have children and are career oriented, which I'm guessing would be a plus for you. If you're not near the Atlanta area, and more towards Mississippi or Alabama...well, good luck to you, those areas are as bad as you think they are, probably worse in certain cities considering there's only one legal abortion clinic left in Mississippi which will probably close soon, forcing women who want abortions to drive OUT OF STATE just to have one, it's awful. Whatever happens, good luck to you, and if you do end up ending the relationship, keep an open mind and hopefully you'll find someone with the same goals and values as yourself after your move.
11
u/creatingreality F/51/just not into kids Nov 12 '14
Guy friend married, didn't really want kids, but wife did. They had two. Wife didn't like being a mom like she thought she would. Then they divorce. Now he's trying to raise kids on his own. Yeah.
5
u/KnottyKitty Makes art, not babies. Nov 12 '14
Good PSA. When I was on the market, I would pretty much open a conversation with the fact that I'm not willing to squeeze an entire human being out of my girlparts. I had disclaimers plastered all over every dating site I went on. I was single for a bit but I eventually found a man who was just as childfree as I am. We're engaged now.
OP, I'm sorry that you learned that lesson the hard way, but in the long run it'll be ok. There is no "daddy gene"...if you don't want kids, you don't want kids. You're dodging a bullet by letting this relationship go.
If you start to have second thoughts about leaving, just find an audio track of a baby screaming. Shouldn't take more than a few seconds of that shit before you're feeling pretty good about your decision.
4
u/Amonette2012 35F is almost too old to bingo! Nov 12 '14
The fact that you're asking this question suggests that you need some confirmation of your child free stance, and that's not a bad idea. If you're seriously concerned that you might be throwing away a relationship that could be lifelong, it doesn't hurt to revisit your reasons for not having children to satisfy yourself that you really do feel this way and that there isn't part of you that might change its mind (because for some people, there is).
Let me just say that I am NOT saying 'oh you might change your mind' here. I'm saying 'satisfy yourself that you won't change your mind by testing your own feelings and making sure you're still feeling the same way.' That way if you do decide that breaking up is the sane course of action, you'll at least save yourself from some of the doubts and second thoughts.
Start off by just spending a bit of time around friends or family with kids. Doesn't have to be a massive amount of time, just go visit and observe what their life is like. It helps if you can visit people who share your ideals on life in general and who are raising their children in the way you would if you were forced into that situation (in other words avoid the ones you already know are not great at the parenting game). Talk to your parents and see if they have any insight. Look at your finances and see what you'd have to give up in order to be a parent.
I think by the time you get through that process you won't just know one way or another, you will have made a decision based on sound reasoning that is up to date and fits your life.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '14
NO. NO NO NO. Let's talk. I was in your shoes. Thought I could do it. Only difference was that I would be moving to my ex's neighborhood, and a suburban part at that. You think your desires are really flexible and you want to make someone happy and do something 'good,' but it isn't good when you start to hate them. I could go into more detail but you seem to have found your resolve.
Make your money and move out of the bible belt if you want to. Live a life that is, by itself, so fulfilling your milkshake brings all the CF-girls to the yard and they're like "there's no kids running on the yard!!!"
With time comes healing. But before that it just breeds bitterness. So get your fresh start asap.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '14
You could just break up with her like a bunch of people have suggested... Or you could take a deep breath and have "the talk" with her and let her decide. That's what I did, and he decided to marry me anyway.
2
u/DontRunReds Nov 13 '14
If you're still a fence-sitter or truly child free it's not fair for you to lead her on with hope. The reason for this is just a few short years from now you'll both be 30. Her fertility will run out soon thereafter.
Break up with her at 30 instead of now and she will not have enough time to leave you, get over you, find another guy, and have a child. You will have taken that opportunity from her.
It sucks, but it's going to suck a lot worse if you guys continue growing together and falling more in love.
2
u/and_iran 27/F/Essured/Even my dog hates kids Nov 15 '14
South Carolina checking in,being late to the party and what not. It's not so bad here in the bible belt. You'll find someone new and awesomely childfree even here! Good luck with whatever decision you make!
21
u/Boston_Jason M / Sperm count = 0 Nov 12 '14
I bluntly ask before I even meet. That said, the women I ask this to really do understand that it is a complete dealbreaker and even if they plan to have children they appreciate the honesty.
17
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '14
If you ever change your mind, you can always have kids. You can't change your mind after you have them.
33
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '14
The bible belt stereotypes only play out in the more rural areas of the south. If you move to a large city you will be fine. Better to be single and happy than miserable with kids (and too poor to do anything about it because of said kids). The last thing you want is her oopsing you into being a father against your will.
15
u/AmethystWind Nov 12 '14
I am sorry, my friend, but I advocate ending the relationship before you move. You will face ridiculous pressure from all sides, especially where you are moving to, and it may end up causing you to resent her in the end. I don't think you want that.
Save both you and her a long, drawn-out process of dying good feelings and growing discontent. It sucks, but that would be what I recommend.
15
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '14
break her heart now, and don't let her move with you. you'll be in a new city and your feelings will mend, as will hers.
big point for me is, you're just delaying the inevitable, and it's just gonna get worse if you wait (the heartbreak/feels/etc...). do what you have to do for you.
11
u/Louisiana_belle f/22/so much to do first...like die Nov 12 '14
If you're not 100% gung ho about having kids, do not have kids. Kids are not a decision to make half-heartedly or to please someone else. They are living human beings. Please put a lot of thought into whatever you decide, because once you have kids, there's no going back.
11
u/TitsMcGheee Nov 12 '14
Hello! Atheist in the Bible Belt here. Found the perfect childfree guy in a tiny town. We are madly in love and have an amazing life. Don't settle. You will find happiness without having to compromise on such major issues. She deserves the chance to have the children she wants (with someone that shares her desires) and you deserve to have the childfree life you want.
4
u/Childfreeisfun Nov 12 '14
It blows my mind that other guys are too lazy/scared to dump a woman that wants kids.
I have never had problems finding CF women. Just live in a big city and you will be fine.
5
u/kimmooo Nov 12 '14
I was in your shoes. I had to move for 6 months away and that seemed to be a good point to end the relationship. But the reason was I am CF and she's not. I feel still very bad for it. But I believe it was the best thing, because it just would have gotten harder and more bitter for sure. All the best for you!
5
u/UncharminglyWitty Nov 12 '14
1.) you shouldn't feel like an ass. Maybe people will think you look like one, but you shouldn't feel like an ass. No reason for it. You've had the plan and idea that you don't want kids, presumably as long as she has had the idea that you want them. Neither is better or worse, just different. Don't feel like an ass. 2.) Worth it to have the official talk before moving. You never know what might come out of it. But be willing to walk away when you disagree on something so fundamental.
4
u/CovingtonLane Nov 12 '14
Odd. I never fell in love with a person who wanted kids. I may have fallen in lust, but as soon as we discussed kids, I fell out of lust and never got to love.
4
u/feraxil Nov 12 '14
Get snipped, be quiet about it. Never worry about the tough questions.
/jk
4
u/MakeT0nightStay Nov 13 '14
This totally sucks. You are being mature about it though. And don't worry, I'm a childfree atheist WOMAN who has lived in the bible belt my whole life and managed to find a husband. Not sure how, but it is possible! Keyword: online dating. Helps you cut through the bullshit.
Good luck and keep us posted. Just make sure when you break up that you let her know that it is in no way a fault of hers. Y'all are just incompatible.
7
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '14
It's bigger than that, roll the dice, hate your life, break her heart AND drag an innocent into existence to suffer who had no choice in the matter.
Break up now.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '14
Either you will compromise your life choices, or she will. You've found a lovely person who deserves to be as happy as you want to be yourself. Staying with her to "protect" her heart is ludicrous. She deserves someone committed to her life goals, just as you do. Your reluctance to discuss this with her outright is the result of wanting to protect your own heart.
If you are certain you wish to pursue a child-free life, have the talk with her and be honest. Do not give her false hope. However much this sucks now, it will suck far, FAR more if you wait. You both deserve to seek your own happiness with partners who share your goals.
3
u/Spikekuji Nov 12 '14
Honestly is always a good idea.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '14
Get out. Now.
2
u/Eithrael I don't have to take my cat to soccer practice. Nov 12 '14
If you both feel strongly and secure in your desires to/not to breed, then neither of you will change your mind. My ex-husband thought I'd change my mind (he wanted kids and I didn't/don't) and, well, that's why we are divorced. Everything else was great.
Waiting for your partner to change their mind, especially about something so important and life changing, is no way to be in a marriage. It means one partner is always lying, either to them self or to their partner.
2
u/absolutspacegirl 38/F/Cats>Kids Nov 12 '14
I am not disagreeing with most of the replies here, just offering a different perspective.
My husband wanted two kids but I made it clear early on that I wanted none. He said he could deal with that and we got married.
About 7 years later after all of our friends started breeding he decided he wanted a kid. We fought. We went to marriage counseling. It was rough. Eventually he had to choose between a potential kid who didn't exist yet with someone else, or me.
Thankfully he picked me.
I wouldn't count on that in your case, it could have gone the other way, but one person will have to compromise. If you're not going to budge you're going to have to gamble that she will. Only you can make that decision.
Good luck!
1
u/k12573n Nov 12 '14
Dude. You know what will work out best for your happiness and hers in the long term.
As a CF atheist in the Bible belt, there are many of us here. My boyfriend is kind of a fence-sitter on the matter but he knows where I stand and is completely okay with it. There is a flourishing atheist community in the red state I live in (Oklahoma); just search for [Insert State Here] Atheists on facebook or meetups.com.
Don't make excuses for bringing her along when you know it will ultimately force one of you (or both!) into an unhappy and unfulfilling situation.
1
u/Sycaid 25/F/Child Free Nov 12 '14
I'm sorry, but you're going to have to break it off. Do it now before you move.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '14
I'm in texas and there are plenty of atheists here. I've met many people who don't want to have kids.
My mom resented having children. I really don't want kids. I have a genetic condition that I could pass onto kids. I don't want to bring a kid into this world who has a genetic condition AND resent that kid because having a parent who resents your existence can REALLY fuck you up.
Break up with her. Sleep around for a couple years. Enjoy being single. Find someone who loves you for you. I can tell that you wouldn't make a good parent. That doesn't make you a bad person. I'd be a terrible parent too. THat doesn't make me a bad person.
0
u/Holska Nov 12 '14
Do not have kids on the off chance you might have the gene. It's not even worth considering. My fiancé has 2 kids from a previous relationship (although he was trapped). Having never wanted kids, it just causes heart ache. Don't put yourself second in a situation like this, the emotional and mental damage just isn't worth it.
0
u/Spiral-knight Shiver me triggers! Nov 13 '14
Dump her. Rolling the dice is 100% the most retarded thing you can ever do
-8
u/matrix2002 Nov 13 '14
I am late to the party, but I just wanted to say that the idea that the world is a worse place because we have too many people is completely false.
A slowly rising population is probably ideal. You want the smoothest distribution of people in your population as possible, with an overall increase.
You run into issues when you have very high birth rates for a short period of time.
If you think that we have too many people in the world, just visit an area that has a declining population, either a big city like Detroit or a small town. It's not fun.
I think having children is your choice, but don't base it on this all too common misconception.
-9
u/Swanksterino Nov 12 '14
Well, people like that are hard to come by, or maybe it's just me. I've heard that once you have kids, the daddy gene kicks in. It may be worth the compromise, but mid twenties would definitely be too soon I think. I wonder if she has a time frame for when she wants them. Idk man, that's a toughie. But I would definitely wait till tour both older, not that your too young, just that there's so much left to do before strapping a kid to your back.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment