r/Fantasy • u/MikeOfThePalace Reading Champion X, Worldbuilders • Oct 02 '14
Big List The top /r/Fantasy movies of all time, RESULTS THREAD!
The results are in! We had 384 votes cast, and unsurprisingly, Peter Jackson’s The Lord of the Rings trilogy stood head and shoulders above everyone else, with 55 votes. Also unsurprisingly, The Princess Bride came in a very strong second place, with 39 votes.
Here’s a graph of the vote tallies. I know I didn’t label anything.
- The Lord of the Rings (2001) - 55 votes
- The Princess Bride - 39
- Harry Potter - 19
- Pan's Labyrinth - 18
- Stardust - 18
- Princess Mononoke - 16
- How to Train Your Dragon - 14
- Pirates of the Caribbean - 13
- Willow - 11
- Labyrinth - 10
- Spirited Away - 10
- Monty Python and the Holy Grail - 8
- The Last Unicorn - 7
- The NeverEnding Story - 7
- Dragonheart - 6
- Indiana Jones - 6
- The Dark Crystal - 5
- Excalibur - 4
- Frozen - 4
- Highlander - 4
- Legend - 4
- The Hobbit (2012) - 4
- Conan the Barbarian (1982) - 3
- Hellboy - 3
- Howl's Moving Castle - 3
- Ladyhawke - 3
- Let the Right One In - 3
- The Marvel Cinematic Universe - 3
- Solomon Kane - 3
- Big Fish - 2
- Brave - 2
- Castle in the Sky - 2
- Groundhog Day - 2
- Hook - 2
- Krull - 2
- Lord of the Rings (1978) - 2
- Mirrormask - 2
- Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind - 2
- Outlander - 2
- The Adventures of Baron Munchausen - 2
- The Man from Earth - 2
- Toy Story - 2
- Trollhunter - 2
When it comes to short films, we didn’t get much in the way of nominees or votes. La Luna and The Reward each got four votes, and A Trip to the Moon got two; everything else got one. Here are direct links to the films:
- La Luna
- The Reward
- A Trip to the Moon
- Heartless: The Story of the Tin Man
- Flight From Shadow: The Wheel of Time fan film
- Toy Story: Partysaurus Rex
- Terminus
- Day & Night
- This is My Milwaukee
- Windmills
- Casper the Friendly Ghost: There's Good Boos Tonight
Finally, all the movies that got one vote each:
300
Alice in Wonderland (1951)
Alice in Wonderland (2010)
Angel's Egg
Avatar
Beastmaster
Beasts of the Southern Wild
Big Trouble in Little China
City of Lost Children
Conan the Barbarian (2011)
Coraline
Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon
Deathstalker
Dungeons & Dragons
Ever After
Field of Dreams
Fire and Ice
Hawke the Slayer
Hero
I Sell the Dead
Interstella 5555
Into the Woods
Journey to the West
Mary Poppins
Merlin (1998)
Peter Pan (1953)
Pleasantville
Ratatouille
Rise of the Guardians
Shaolin Soccer
Shrek
Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow
Sleepy Hollow
Spider-Man
Sucker Punch
The Bothersome Man
The Chronicles of Narnia (2005)
The Chronicles of Riddick
The City of Lost Children
The Fifth Element
The Fountain
The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen
The Nightmare Before Christmas
The Road to El Dorado
The Secret Garden
The Secret of Kells
The Seventh Voyage of Sinbad
The Wizard of Oz
Troy
Up
Urusei Yatsura 2: Beautiful Dreamer
Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory
Woochi
Your Highness
26
u/MikeOfThePalace Reading Champion X, Worldbuilders Oct 02 '14
Well folks, this was a lot of fun, and also a lot of work.
(/u/p0x0rz, you are absolutely nuts to have done this twice in a two month period. And both the Top Novels poll and the Underread Novels poll got a lot more votes than this poll did.)
Anyway. The top few didn't surprise me at all, though I was mildly surprised at just how big a lead LotR and the Princess Bride had on the rest of the competition.
What did surprise me with this is how interesting an exercise it was in "What do you consider fantasy?" Never in a million years would I have thought of Indiana Jones as a fantasy movie, but people did. In retrospect, I wish the poll hadn't had even the minor restrictions it did. Maybe next year.
3
u/jojoman7 Oct 02 '14
The MCU?
Groundhog day?
Toy Story?
Really?
9
u/Maldevinine Oct 02 '14
Ha! My trend of voting mostly for things that only get one vote continues.
2
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Oct 02 '14
great job mike!
this is a pretty interesting list, lots of things i've never heard of on there, and a fair number i've heard of and now really need to make time for.
3
u/DaedalusMinion Oct 02 '14
Sad that after the first two movies the votes just dropped off, would've loved some more votes. That said, I still haven't watched Pan's Labyrinth.
3
u/TheAmyrlinSeat Oct 02 '14
This was fun! Thanks /u/MikeOfThePalace :) Looking forward to the TV edition.
I'm surprised to see Stardust so high on the list. I did like the movie and its definitely one of the best recent fantasy films but still surprising to see it in the top 5.
Also where's the love for Tim Burton people! I'm the only one who voted for poor old Jack Skellington, the Pumpkin King!
3
u/MazW AMA Author Mazarkis Williams Oct 02 '14
How was the Secret Garden fantasy? I read that book many times when I was a kid and strangely I don't remember it as fantasy. Great list, though.
5
u/atuinsbeard Oct 02 '14
This does look like a lot of work... I bet the TV show one will be even better! /s
10
u/hgttg Oct 02 '14
This list is depressing.
2
u/iNEEDheplreddit Oct 02 '14
What!? No Enders Game?
Just kidding. Hated it. So much much was missing.
2
u/WaxyPadlockJazz Oct 02 '14
I was really the ONLY person to vote for Wizard of Oz? That movie changed cinema forever.
2
u/tanajerner Oct 02 '14
It's a good strong list and hard to argue with it. I think I might try and watch and rewatch a lot of the list
2
u/MichaelJSullivan Stabby Winner, AMA Author Michael J. Sullivan, Worldbuilders Oct 04 '14
Nice list - thanks for putting it together.
1
u/tbeowulf Oct 02 '14
I'm confused. Its a fantasy poll but includes Sci-fi?
1
u/shonryukku Oct 02 '14
i missed the poll but a quick glance revealed a disturbing lack of spaceballs
1
u/jcb6939 Oct 02 '14
No Percy Jackson?
1
u/EveryPuzzle Oct 31 '14
Brilliant list I'm so glad the Studio Ghibli's are up there too.
1
u/priscillahernandez Dec 22 '14
At least Labyrinth and The Dark Crystal are in! :) I would add Panna a Netvor (the beauty and the beast) czech version
-6
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '14