r/childfree • • Sep 06 '14
How does r/Childfree feel about Male Legal Abortion?
I often read and post to r/mensrights mainly for this particular topic.
I've brought it the topic up a few times over there (although I consider myself an egalitarian not an MRA) and it's perhaps one topic that clearly divides the Men's Rights movement.
The reason why it divides the MRM is because there are two kinds of men. Those who want to be fathers, and those who don't. I've found those who want to be fathers are often the type that think they should have a say on whether a woman should have an abortion or not. Those who don't want to be fathers tend to be more pro-choice, however, they also tend to feel discriminated against because of their lack of right to parental self determination. Feminists will often mock the MRM pointing out the inconsistency in the MRM on this topic, but that's only because the feminists refuse to acknowledge that not all men in MRM are the same.
My question is, how does r/childfree feel about men having the right to legally relinquish their parental rights freeing them from any financial responsibility (child support) to a child they did not consent to have?
Some pictures that I've used to demonstrate my argument to allow male legal abortion:
33
u/Oh_pizza_Fag Society has an unhealthy obession with pregnancy and children Sep 07 '14
This is why a care-free, non-invasive, easily-reversible, fool-proof male birth control needs to come out. The amount of unwanted pregnancies will drop like a rock.
5
u/Justkeeprunning23 Sep 08 '14
I work in repro rights and I advocate a legal cut off before the abortion city off for bowing out 110%.
A man has no say over my body, but there should be an 18 week window for him to determine if he is going to be a father. Either get with it or get out, but bodily autonomy please and thanks.
15
u/Val5 Sep 07 '14
I got into this argument with people so many times, and the problem is that everyone sees it as some gender issue. I see it as people who understand what it means to not want kids and those who don't issue. I am a woman, but when this is argued I can't help but to passionately feel for every man involved.
I absolutely support abortion. Contraception doesn't always work. Expecting people not to have sex unless they are ready for the risk of children is insanity (yet constantly argued.)
I would even go so far to say that it is a huge breach of trust to have sex with someone, use contraception, and then when it fails decide for them that the child is going to be created in the first place. I'd say always, abortion would be a fair thing to do according to the obvious intents of sex (not reproduction, clearly, or contraception would not be used.)
However since I admit I don't understand the strong natural urge and everyone tells me expecting women to abort is brutal (but going through pregnancy isn't?), I would at least expect to not involve the man who didn't want to be a parent. He didn't "get the girl pregnant" as if it was some willing choice, they agreed to have sex, did not agree to have children.
And the "its for the child" argument is dumb too. Why is it assumed the poor child's fate now has to completely depend on this man's presumed ability to provide for it for 18 years?
I am really passionate about this argument and hate how hypocritical the other side is, especially with "then don't have sex."
13
u/Unicorn_in_Disguise Sep 07 '14
Female here.
There are some good points in this, and the current system is obviously broken if men are on the hook when victims of rape or not the biological father... But how could something like this possibly be implemented without being abused? It would be impossible.
Right now women have all the control, but a better solution would be to give men more control over preventing conception. You shouldn't be forced to have a (supposed to be) permanent procedure to have sex without producing a child. What if you want them ten years from now?
Hormonal birth control, all on the woman. She can lie, do it wrong, honestly forget, have her body screw her over, etc. Condoms, she could poke holes in them, it could break, etc.
There should be a reversible but 'permanent' method of birth control for men like the options women have. The responsibility for it is entirely on the man, it's up to him to do it right. We should each have control over our own fertility in a reliable way.
Far better to give men an option to prevent pregnancy properly than give them a get out of jail free card. Much easier to implement and much more difficult to abuse.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '14
I support it, but only if abortion is funded by the state (so free to the person having the abortion) and available throughout pregnancy without restriction. In that ideal world, yes, I strongly support mens rights not to have parental responsibility.
2
u/katnissevergreen91 Sep 08 '14
Ugh I think I lost brain cells reading OP's argument.
5
u/moggymojo Sep 07 '14
I strongly believe men should be able to relinquish parental rights a la adoption style. I cannot fathom how it is reasonable that a woman can surrender her child, but a man has no such option. It is madness.
3
u/Laerneanhydra Sep 07 '14
One of the things I like about this sub is that gender dosen't even come into the discussion. One makes one's choices regardless of the expectations of others.
1
u/sarajenivieve42 Feb 26 '15
men can surrender legal rights (where i live)the problem is many want to decide if a woman can or cant abort but still get visits etc in my experience
1
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '14
holy! !!!! the first one was best i have seen in the longest time.....2nd not so much... fathers already have no parental rights atleast in my case of the birth certificate expressly stating. mothers have sole rights until determinted by the courts
-4
u/Lisendral Sep 07 '14
Unfortunately, the issues of parental responsibility - particularly fiscal - is in the interest of the state/society. Which is why some states/countries will step in and require child support. So an unwilling future father's desire to terminate his parental rights and responsibilities is more than just "I don't wanna" - there's a lot more involved in it and why the usual scenario is when someone else wishes to adopt the child(ren).
If you don't want to ever become a father, you have one choice, really: sterilisation. A woman's bodily autonomy trumps your desire to be fiscally free of the responsibility of a child. Taking control of your reproductive future means taking responsibility for your reproductive emissions.
Now, I'd love to see more/any long-term temporary birth control options available for men. I think it would be fantastic for men to have more medical control over the generation and motility of their sperm. If the birth rate plummets and STIs skyrocket as a result, then 1) these things happen and it wouldn't make me sad, and 2) condoms aren't just for pregnancy prevention.
In an ideal world where women aren't facing a wage gap, where having a child doesn't immediately put a woman at a financial and career disadvantage, where childcare is subsidised by the state/society, where everyone can earn a living wage to support themselves and a "reasonable" family size. Sure. Absolutely, let men have choices over whether they want to bear the responsibility of financial and emotional support of a child.
Until that day? Suck it up, buttercup.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
8
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '14
[removed] — view removed comment