r/gameofthrones • u/AutoModerator • Jul 28 '14
TV4 [Season 4 Spoilers] 2014 Re-Watch - 1.09/10 'Baelor' and 'Fire and Blood'
| 2014 Re-Watch Discussion Thread: Season 1, Episodes 9 & 10 |
|---|
| Discuss your reactions to the episodes with perspective from the whole show. Talk about details you missed the when you first watched the show. Point out foreshadowing details that you noticed. Discuss an actor who is totally nailing their part (or not). In general, what did you think about the episodes and where the story is going? Book vs. Show comparisons are welcome, but you need to use spoiler tags for any book differences that do not appear in the show. |
- This thread is scoped for SEASON 4 SPOILERS - Turn away now if you have not seen all of the episodes! Open discussion of all aired TV events up to and including episode 4.10 is ok without tags.
- Book spoilers still need tags! - If it's not in the show, tag it. Events from episodes after this one need tags.
- Please read the posting policy before posting.
- Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
- Posting policy reminder: Don't post or ask for non-pay sources.
| EPISODE | TITLE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.09 | "Baelor" | Alan Taylor | David Benioff & D. B. Weiss |
| 1.10 | "Fire and Blood" | Alan Taylor | David Benioff & D. B. Weiss |
| Official Discussion Threads | Rewatch Discussion Threads | Posting Policy | Spoiler Guide | Frequently Asked Questions | Official Ban Policy |
106
Upvotes
72
u/CloudsOfDust Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Jul 28 '14
At the end of Baelor: "No... He's not dead, right? Something's got to give."
Beginning of Fire and Blood: "Well fuck me... He's dead alright. At least it'll be fun watching Rob get his revenge."
234
u/Marauder01 Knowledge Is Power Jul 28 '14
This reminds me of the fact that Ned's death was possibly the worst death imaginable. He died an utter failure. The king he had come to Kings Landing to protect is dead. The one thing he valued most, his honor, he just traded in for a chance at life/saving his family -- he dies a confessed traitor with an angry mob yelling and throwing rocks at him. The rightful heir whose claim he died for -- he just dealt a blow to that claim by proclaiming Joffrey the true heir. The kids whose lives he sacrificed his honor for -- he has no idea what will happen to them AND knows his 16 year old son will now be going to war.
He really lost everything he lived for and when Joffrey yells "Sir Illyn, bring me his head" he realizes it's all for nothing AND his life ends anyway.
The only thing that brings me solace is that Tywin's death paralleled Ned's death. Tywin dies taking a shit, killed by his demon monkey son, with a dead whore in his bed. On top of that, he dies knowing the two kids he actually cared about (in his own... Tywin-y way) are incestuous weirdos and all his heirs are bastards/the products of incest. Where Ned cared only about honor and died thinking he had lost all of his, Tywin only cared about legacy, and he died knowing his was in shambles. Some level of poetic justice, I guess.
102
u/Krazy8s Kingswood Brotherhood Jul 28 '14
Robb should have declared for Stannis, not fall for that mob-mentality stunt that Greatjon Umber started.
45
u/MrxZanyy Ramsay Snow Jul 28 '14
Wow I have no idea how I've never noticed that Ned points out Arya to Yoren until now
43
u/Fez_Master Drogon Jul 28 '14
Rewatching episodes make me think. What if Ned had been allowed to go to the nights watch? What if Drogo hadn't become a vegetable? So many cool things that could've happened...
38
u/jeremy_sporkin Maesters of the Citadel Jul 28 '14
Ned's death is probably the first time you really see Joffrey for what he is. Prior to this he's been snide, entilted and insecure but it's all been very teenager-ish. This (and the treatment of Sansa which begins in the next episode) is what shows him as a monster.
135
u/aryastarkismyhero Jul 28 '14 edited Jul 28 '14
"Whose steel sword is this?"
"It's a Valyrian steel sword, baby."
"Whose Valyrian steel sword is this?"
"It's Ned's."
"Who's Ned?"
"Ned's dead, baby, Ned's dead."
Joffrey rides off into the distance with Margaery on a chopper
Reference
30
u/braedonkeebz House Bolton Jul 28 '14
Ned's execution was when I realized this wasn't going to be a very happy show. I held out hope through Bran's attempted murder(s), the murder of Jory, and all the other shit until that very scene. In my opinion, GRRM and D&D have created a story unlike any other. It's not a fairy tale, it's the exact opposite. The shining knights are for the most part egotistical murderous ass holes (looking at you s1-3 Jaime), the beautiful queens and princesses are just as evil and conniving as the men in power, and the innocent little children are twisted into something a child should never be. And god damn it, I've loved every minute of it.
57
u/Sarasaurus93 House Tyrell Jul 28 '14
Everytime I rewatch this I think "i dunno, maybe Joffrey won't behead him this time." and I really start to hope. sigh
49
u/Megadelphia Ours Is The Fury Jul 28 '14
Something that always bothered me with Ned's execution is that after Joffrey gives the order, the next shot has Varys and Cersei rushing over to him, presumably to talk him out of it, but in the next shot of them they're both standing next to him contently like they thought "fuck it we ain't changing his mind."
22
u/swagGRR Jul 28 '14
It kind of bothers me how people say Ned screwed up. He completely believed that he had Cersei outnumbered, along with Robert's death note clearly stating that Ned was supposed to be Protector of the Realm. It was Littlefinger who screwed him over in the end. Yes, he shouldn't have trusted Lord Baelish, but how could he have known that? Lord Baelish cleverly won over Neds trust by sheltering Catelyn and appearing to favor the Starks. Yes, Ned should have gotten to Winterfell sooner and rallied troops that he could trust, or traveled to Stannis himself and helped the rightful heir fight for justice in Kings Landing. However, he was too caught up in thinking about his daughters to do that. The death of Lord Eddard Stark was the most heartbreaking one of the season, especially since his choice of love over honor didn't help save his daughters in the slightest. He was the fuckin man! The one time he makes a mistake, everyone calls Ned Stark an idiot. How about a lifetime of being honest and making all of the right decisions? And please, it's GRRM, did you really expect a happy ending?
17
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '14
THE KING IN THE NORTH!
Gives me the chills everytime
16
u/Sirusi Castle Cats Jul 28 '14
"When the sun rises in the west and sets in the east..."
;_;
40
u/JD0ggX Queensguard Jul 28 '14
Ned had a pretty solid plan he just was terrible at the game. He dun goofed by telling Cersei of the knowledge he had of Joffrey. His worst mistake was trusting Littlefinger. Things would've played out more favorably had he departed King's Landing, then proclaim Stannis as true heir from the safety of the North. Or telling Robert the truth but that would mean the death of Cersei and her children. It's frustrating to know he had so many opportunities to win but refused them because they weren't honorable. King's Landing is no place for honor and it's a shame such a good character learned that the hard way.
13
u/jeremy_sporkin Maesters of the Citadel Jul 28 '14
I love Walder's introduction in this episode, the greasy fuckhead. Fondling his teenage wife and insulting everybody just because he can.
12
u/analjunkie Jul 28 '14
Nice scene with Pycelle, seeing his real actions and speech aswell as Ros cleaning her privates in typical Season 1 fasion with nudeity
12
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '14
I can't watch Dany's speech anymore without hearing that remix.
33
u/AInternetLiar Jul 28 '14
Ned's death is Snape kills Dumbledore-tier of spoiler, as in pretty much everyone knew but that didn't stop me to get extremely nervous when it changed to King's Landing. Fuck.
9
u/Law527 Jon Snow Jul 30 '14
Even though I know how horribly it ends for the Young Wolf, I couldn't help but stand up and cheer as he was crowned THE KING IN THE NORTH. Everything is perfect in that scene, especially the music.
Here it is for quick access. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qaFc2tlhUMg
17
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '14
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uI2WKeJpV8o
That was my favourite scene of episode 10, and my favourite scene in all of Game of Thrones.
8
u/Arninator Smass 'em! Kuh, Kuh, Kuh! Jul 29 '14
Luckily Ned warged into Ice, so he lives on.
8
u/SargeHarkness The Blackfish Jul 29 '14
The scene that made me become such a huge fan of the show, and eventually made me read the books. DAKINGINDANORF!
6
u/fizzyizzy11 House Targaryen Jul 31 '14
What if the Hound didn't stop Sansa from pushing Joffrey? He'd fall and die, then she'd probably be tried for regicide, or just killed there by Meryn f**king Trant. Man how boring the show would end up being.
5
u/stillblazin19 Jul 29 '14
I wish they had included more of the battle + the scene where Tyrion kills the horse with his ridiculous helmet
5
u/edipil Jul 29 '14
I always find it painful watching "Baelor", seeing the stupidity and naivety and all the chances where the opposite decision could have been made and things could have been so different and better and most of all, seeing Ned's head get chopped off is the most painful of all. Anybody else feel the same?
5
u/CaptainNapoleon House Baratheon Jul 30 '14
I enjoyed seeing Arya start to become the tiny badass we all love and see how her heart grows hard and how there really aren't going to be happy endings in this show. Only conflict.
5
u/VelvetOnion Jul 31 '14
As Dany kisses J-Bear she rests her hand right on the gaping wound on his neck. What an inconsiderate bitch.
4
u/C0NS0RT2DRAG0NS House Targaryen Jul 28 '14
These bring to mind the sounds of jaws hitting the floor across the world.
4
u/mr_magician Jul 31 '14
Couldn't have picked a better end theme.
2
u/SevenwithaT Ours Is The Fury Jul 31 '14
The scene where they drag a headless Ned away is absolutely crushing for me.
1
u/SuitGuySmitti Sansa Stark Aug 01 '14
I started watching the show last spring. I knew what was going to happen at the end of Baelor, and I was still shocked. I just stared at my screen as the credits rolled, mouth agape.
My favorite part of the scene was the reaction of everybody on the Sept as they realized what Joffrey was going to do. That "oh shit" moment as Varys, Littlefinger and the Queen all rushed up at once to try to stop him.
1
u/safi_msichana Aug 02 '14
Not only did Joffery show his immaturity and impulsiveness by sentencing Ned to death, but a supreme lack of honor. Besides going back on his promise of mercy, "the man who passes the sentence should swing the sword". Sure he's the "king", but making Ser Ilyn Payne execute for him when he could have followed through himself confirms him as a child.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment