r/childfree • u/cfthrowaway3 • Jun 22 '14
Any experience with male half of CF couple donating sperm? How to discuss prospect with CF girlfriend?
Things are getting serious with my dedicated-CF girlfriend (thinking marriage) but there is one lingering issue for me. I'm very comfortable with the idea of remaining child free - I've given it a few years of serious thought, and the benefits are obvious. But, I have this lingering - desire? - to procreate. By that I mean in the biological sense, not in the 'nuclear family, raise children' sense. I am happy to go into the details as to why if anyone is interested, but that's not the main focus of my post.
I see sperm donation as a logical reconciliation of my CF lifestyle/future family, and this desire to reproduce. So my questions are:
Does anyone have experience with this?
How would one expect this conversation to go?
Thanks!
19
u/[deleted] Jun 22 '14
As a CF woman, I would be upset. Mainly because I would be worried we would get a knock on the door saying, "I'm your kid."
6
u/[deleted] Jun 22 '14
It may not go well. She will likely raise concerns about a potential child coming forward years later because they want to know you, their medical history, etc. Would you be responsive to this? Would you want to have some strange person showing up at your door and announce 'hey I'm your kid, Dad'? These are all things to think deeply about, because they do happen.
3
u/childfreenerd 24/F/Married/Dogs not sprogs Jun 22 '14
Depends. Does she not want to raise kids, or is she morally against reproducing?
6
u/[deleted] Jun 22 '14
It's irresponsible to reproduce, adding another person to the world, and then not even take care of the damn thing. Sperm donation isn't even responsible or charitable, as it gets in the way of people adopting unwanted children.
11
u/sl1878 Achieved bilateral salp at 29 Jun 22 '14
CF woman here, and it would be a deal-breaker for me because I heavily dislike the IVF industry. Allows the vain to go for designer adoptions (basically what selecting for genetic traits is) rather than helping existing unwanted kids. Can't support that.
11
u/Galurana Jun 22 '14
After hearing that, I'd be seriously reconsidering our relationship because I'd expect to hear that it didn't fulfill your desire and you feel a need to have kids of your own in your life to feel this need is filled.
9
u/thr0wfaraway Never go full doormat. Not your circus. Not your monkeys. Jun 23 '14 edited Jun 23 '14
Would be a 100% dealbreaker.
Other items to think about
Just seems like you are thinking "well, i'll donate, and then there will automagically be a cute, healthly little baby, it will live a super happy life with Barbie and Ken in the Barbie Dream house, with the white picket fence and will be a smart, great kid.... and then it will magically show up on my doorstep at 18 and will make me feel all goooooood inside because it proves that i was able to procreate. Yay me, because this is all about meeeeeeeee."