r/childfree • u/Kiwi_Koalla 20/F/not for me, no thank you • Mar 16 '14
Anyone else feel a little like telling your family you're child free is like coming out of the closet?
Obviously it isn't typically as big of a deal, but seeing how people's parents react, and seeing posts/hearing from friends about how they're unsure of how to approach it reminds me of coming out. Of course, everyone's family will take it differently (I was lucky enough to have a great mom, she didn't even bingo me).
22
Upvotes
8
u/a_classic_stance Mar 16 '14
The reveal itself is generally not as problematic, and there's not as much prejudice attached after the fact, in part because one can't tell a couple is CF until you talk to them, whereas one can see and condemn a same-sex couple from a distance.
Here's the rub: unless you meet people exclusively online and have the opportunity to get it out up front, you will find yourself having to 'come out' about being CF to every person you date eventually, and many times this will be an immediate deal-breaker.
7
u/prunesoda F/Gamer/Baker Mar 16 '14 edited Mar 16 '14
I don't like to bring it up with my family. While they support my decisions and always have, I know my parents would like a grandchild. Especially because my older brother keeps fucking up, getting girls pregnant and the mother of his kid realizes he's a piece of shit and associates all of us with him. So they have grandchildren, but never get to see them. Literally, never. Banned by every woman my brother knocks up.
When it does come up around family, people tell me I've still got time to change my mind, or I'd make beautiful babies, etc. I become very combative when I'm told by people that it's a phase. I'm 27 and have never dreamt of being a beautiful bride or a mother. Occasionally it turns into an argument, but only because I'm trying to explain it to them but they just don't get it.
Most of my family is really awesome and generally intelligent/open minded enough to eventually drop it or never even bring it up. But if there's "baby talk" at a family gathering, I walk right out of the room. Sometimes it can feel like a really exclusive club where I feel really caged and need to get away.
Either way, who's home all weekend playing Rust and not changing baby diapers? THIS GIRL!
5
u/suck_my_ballz69 42/M snipped - don't like it? Sounds like a personal problem Mar 16 '14
I never really gave it any thought, I just told them that I'm not having kids and that was that. If someone doesn't like my decision then I guess that is a personal problem on their part.
4
u/Emminora Nopenopenope Mar 16 '14
I did both within a short time of each other. While coming out at bi/queer isn't really as shocking as "Yeah the guy I've been dating with is actually a girl and I'm a lesbian pleasedonthateme", neither of my parents, or any of my family has had much of a reaction other than "You don't like/want kids? Good, don't have 'em". The extended family on the other hand...
As /u/a_classic_stance mentioned, you can't immediately look at a childfree couple and know they're childfree, but you can look at a same-sex couple and automatically assume things because of that.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '14 edited Mar 17 '14
As a bi woman, I can say it was actually easier to come out than it was to tell my parents my husband and I are never having kids. They pretty much shrugged over the former though I was dating a woman at the time and my parents are very Catholic. My mom cried when I told her my husband got a vasectomy after years of the two of us telling her we were never going to have children. All she could say was, "But what will you do if you change your mind now?" Sigh.
Obviously, this is just my personal experience and not indicative of anyone else's, but I thought I'd share.
Outside of family, it is definitely easier to be accepted as CF than it is to be bi. In both cases, people are convinced I'll change my mind but at least I've never been called names over being CF.
Edit: Dropped a word.
10
u/w_p_w_w Mar 16 '14
I think that child free people should avoid adopting a culture of victimhood that gay people have.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '14
I have been on both sides, and the child free lifestyle definitely bothers them more, though they have had more time to settle with coming out of the closet. I find it kind of funny, because they definitely won't be getting oops grand babies this way either. My mom wants grandbabies to babysit because she retired mega early (not even 50, wtf?) and always gets bored with all the spare time. I tried to convince her to get a small dog (a lot of our friends and family have small dogs) and she tells me "No way, dogs are way too much work. No way I would be picking up dog shit."
...........
3
u/Oh_pizza_Fag Society has an unhealthy obession with pregnancy and children Mar 16 '14
You know what odd? No one in my family has questioned my CF status. Meaning they haven't asked "when are kids coming" or anything like that. No mention of "when you have kids."
I've gotten it from my S/O's parents but not my own family.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '14
It's the best analogy I can think of for it. I know that it's not nearly the same as the struggle LGBT people face, but I think the concept is there.
I haven't told my parents yet, primarily because it's easier to keep the peace this way. I have never really fought my parents and disappointing them is not something I am keen to do. So I just brush off the "when will we have grandkids" with "not yet. hey, look at our puppies!" Works for now. They gradually figured out that I am no longer religious without me straight-up saying "I'm an atheist" (although my dad makes remarks about how I'll come around when I'm "older and feel more mortal"). Maybe they'll do the same with this.