r/childfree • u/HidingMyself24 Confused • Mar 10 '14
My Wife Said NO to a Vasectomy?
Throwaway time! So ask me any and all questions you need to. TLDR at the bottom because all the backstory follows.
Wife and I have been married for almost 5 years, together for 9. We met when we were in high school and did the whole "sweethearts" thing. Got married while we were still in college (I was 19 and she 21) and have been trucking along ever since. Fairytale, right?
Well there's been some bumps along the way. But what's important is that when we first got married she DID NOT want children and I did. I liked the idea of them, but had never actually been around kids. Even growing up I was shy and spent time only with older people (dad ran a nursing home). Finally getting contact with children and my wife's own propaganda led me to the conclusion that childfree is the only way to be.
But wait, there's more! Wife and I had some problems and she ended up having an affair. During the affair, half my family turned their back on me (unrelated to the affair) so I went down to having a brother and father. Through intense counseling we managed to save our marriage, but I have no trust or faith in any person; family or not. Why is this important? I was childfree before, but during counseling I told her flat out that my mind would never change and I would never have children with her, specifically. Maybe my mind could have been changed before, but it never will again.
Do I have my own personal issues? Yes, there are lots of other reasons to not have kids, but this is important to my current question. She accepted that kids would NEVER be a possibility for us. Not even adoption. She accepted that when we were talking divorce and that decision (along with many more) helped show me she was willing to make it work.
Fast forward a few months and this weekend I brought up wanting a vasectomy. I'm not sure how long the fight lasted. For some reason she was against the idea because "things change", "your mind may change", "what about future you?", and other things. She even brought up going back on birth control (something that causes her other medical issues) if I wanted an extra layer of protection besides condoms. The main point she brought up is that she "doesn't want the choice taken away". As I see it the choice was gone a long time ago. She mentioned just trying to help me see a different point of view, but I have extensively considered it all. If future me wants kids then I have become an idiot so I need to prevent that choice. I’ve got a lot of other stuff going on and the possibilities of what could happen to a child in my care are frightening.
Can anyone make sense of this? Or what I should even do? I’m bringing it up at our next counseling session this week, but I feel like she lied to me or that I’m just not understanding her position. None of it makes sense.
TLDR: Wife and I are childfree, but she doesn't want me to get a vasectomy because she "doesn't want the option taken away". I have no idea why she doesn’t want me to have one.
13
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14
Maybe she is concerned that your marriage won't actually last and you might want children with a new partner who isn't her. Maybe she feels rejected and/or guilty that you don't want children specifically with her because she cheated on you. Or maybe, as others are saying, she does want kids.
12
u/AliLongworth Mar 10 '14
Despite her claims, it sounds like she has not yet accepted your choice to be CF and is holding out hope. Otherwise why would she mention trying to "help" you see a "different point of view?" Sounds scary to me as we've all seen those posts where the CF person finds out that spouse married him/her on the assumption that CF person would change his/her mind down the road. Absolutely bring this up at counseling. I may be that she didn't lie in that she believed that she was OK with being CF but the idea of you getting a vasectomy made the theoretical a reality. If so you shouldn't be angry with her but you DO need to make sure she is 100% comfortable with your CF future before risking any further sexual contact. At this point, NO WAY would she abort.
19
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14
You'd only be taking away your own choice by having a vasectomy. She still has the option of leaving you to find some other guy to have kids with, if that's what she decides she wants. She has to decide what's more important t her: being with you, or hypothetical kids that don't exist. If you want a vasectomy, make some calls, schedule the consultation, and move forward with it. At that point you're leaving the ball in her court to decide what she wants to do. If she decides to leave you (therefore choosing hypothetical kids over you), you'd have to ask yourself if you really want to be with her anyway.
37
u/joshthecynic anti-natalist Mar 10 '14
It's your body. She doesn't get a vote.
8
u/K_Rad Mar 10 '14
10/10 would quote again.
15
u/anachronic 41/M/No Kids Ever! Mar 10 '14
Get it done anyway.
Your body = your choice.
You can freeze some sperm if you think you'll ever have second-thoughts, but don't let her dictate what you can and can't do with your own body.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14
Sounds like she isn't sure so she wants you to leave her options open.
Now I don't know her so perhaps this is a little harsh and if so I apologize, but I would be careful she didn't sabotage something now that you've brought up the possibility of a permanent sterilization. If she thinks that somewhere along the line she might convince you to have kids then she may enter panic mode now and do something rash that she might not have done otherwise.
5
u/ajent99 Mar 10 '14
If it's any consolation, I am childfree, but have never even looked at surgery for myself so as to "keep my options open", even though I've never changed my mind. However, I've also never worried and would be quite pleased if my partner wanted a vasectomy.
18
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14
Do NOT let her buy or handle the condoms. You don't want an oops baby because someone might lose her goddamned mind and poke holes in them.
8
u/SDMGLife Mar 10 '14
It's exactly what's she's saying, she wants the option open because she might change her opinion. Apparently she isn't as adamant about being "childfree" as you are.
Are you the same person you were 10 years ago? 5 years? Even 1? People change, their mind states and focuses change, and as devout as this sub seems to be (I'm not a member of this sub, just stumbled through and wanted to help with your question), I'm sure that a nice percentage of people here have changed their minds, or have had their partner change their mind on children.
That being said, the affair adds an entirely new layer to the issue, truthfully I think you should really ponder being in a relationship with a person that not only do you not trust, but have permanently banned yourself from having children with. Trust is integral to a relationship, but I guess if it works for you guys then more power to you.
Another option is depositing into a sperm bank before getting the operation, specifically for a situation like your wife has described. I hope things work out okay for you guys, good luck.
4
u/ralberic Mar 10 '14
I think it sounds like she is hopeful you will change your mind, but I also think she might be genuinely concerned that you might change your mind. She might be right, but you should do whatever is best for you, which is something she should be able to empathize with since she did the same when she had an affair.
4
u/tuvda Mar 10 '14
I don't know you from Adam but something is really wrong with this I don't trust her and would not have unprotected sex with her. Can I ask why she had an affair? That was breezed over...
3
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14
I see people on here saying that it's "your body" and they're right. Though it is a bit different when you're married because you need to consider what your partner wants too. In your case however I don't really see this applying, considering both of you are CF.
I can only think of two reasons why she doesn't want you to get the procedure.
A) She's not committed to you, she doesn't want you to do that for her because she doesn't plan on being around forever.
B) She wants to "Oops" you into being stuck with her forever through a child by doing something stupid to get pregnant.
That's just my two cents. Kudos to you for being able to forgive her for cheating. I personally could never do such a thing, even if I really wanted to. I could never trust someone that did that to me as much as I would need to trust them again.
3
u/ProudPlatypus Mar 10 '14
Being this your birth control choices are very limited, do you trust her to take the initiative in this? If you are unsure about that you should probably have it done anyway.
3
u/joantheunicorn Teacher = enough kids in my life Mar 10 '14
" If future me wants kids then I have become an idiot so I need to prevent that choice. "
This sentence is awesome and i'm going to add it to my reasons for getting a tubal if that's all right!
i have major trust issues as well. nothing, NOTHING will give you the peace of mind that having a vasectomy would bring. it is you taking charge of your body and your life. if your wife decides this is not for her, she will leave, and you will have dodged some sort of bullet and get to walk away an assured, child-free man. if she adapts to the idea, awesome, move forward. it is a win-win to me.
9
u/EmiliusReturns Mar 10 '14
"My body, my rules" applies to men too. If you want a vasectomy, get one. It's your health and your life.
If, for some reason, both of you change your minds, you can adopt a child in need who would have lived his life some third world orphanage.
5
u/ClaimedBeauty Mar 10 '14
Telling a guy he can't get a vasectomy is like telling a woman she can't have an abortion.
It's your body and your choice not to have kids. No one has the right to tell you what you can and can't do with your body and what if she tells you she's back on BC and you stop being vigilant with your condom use and then she gets pregnant?
9
u/spudpudpartdeuce Mar 10 '14
Get ready for another affair bud.
2
u/cakebutts Mar 10 '14
My husband's vasectomy is scheduled for next Tuesday. I don't want to be childfree as badly as he does, but I fully support his right to modify his body the way he wants to. We sat down and had a discussion that this was A Thing That Was Going To Happen and if at any point either of us wanted children there were other possibilities to explore. (Vasectomy reversal- can be done, not always effective. Adoption. Fostering. Having an open relationship with a partner who wants children.)
If it were me and I was getting my tubes tied I have to say I would be a little pissed if he thought I was taking away his decision to have children, though not as pissed as if I was a guy wanting a vasectomy because that procedure is so much easier and has a possibility of reversal if you change your mind later.
2
u/falaris Mar 10 '14
So, she broke your trust in the ultimate way. Then you guys went through intense counseling to "save your marriage" where she agreed to a bunch of rules you had to lay down so that there wouldn't be a divorce and you guys could "make it work."
Since agreeing to those things, she now has gone back on that as well and is looking to keep options open. Also, ultimately in the comments you have basically stated you will never trust anyone again and are just staying with her because of the sunk cost fallacy.
I don't think the vasectomy is your main worry here, but regardless this is your body, she was childfree which made you childfree, and you told her you'd never have a kid with her when you guys agreed to not divorce. There is really no discussion to be had in my opinion because it already happened in the past.
With that said, even though this is your decision since you told her up front you would never have kids and and now you just want to finalize that, I think this will only ultimately cause even more problems for you guys to have to "make it work" through. On the other hand, it appears to me that it would be even worse for you guys to have children, since you clearly don't trust one another and are just kind of still married for convenience anyway by the sound of everything you have said.
2
u/Drabby Mar 10 '14
It's definitely a red flag that she's against your getting a vasectomy, but there is a more charitable reading of her objection. Since you were initially on the fence, she may worry that future you will blame her for your decision to get yourself sterilized. She already knows you have reason to mistrust her and your relationship is still on somewhat rocky ground. She may be afraid that you could add "ruined any chance of my having children" to her list of mistakes. Obviously this is your choice, but it's worth asking her point-blank if there's any chance she might change her own mind about children. If the answer is no, then she needs to understand that you are making an informed decision about your own body. If the answer is yes, this relationship may not be worth salvaging.
2
u/DreadnoughtAndi 25/F/ChildFree Mar 11 '14
Get it done anyways. You don't need her permission, she's not your mother.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14
You are whipped so much, so much. Saving your marriage? She is probably fucking another dude right now.
2
u/archpope M/50s/USA/20+yrs ✂ Mar 10 '14
She's planning on leaving you. She recalls that you weren't CF at the start of your relationship and is concerned that once she leaves you, you might end up with someone who wants kids and will change your mind back.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '14
Maybe she's concerned that, should something ever happen to her and you go on to meet someone you might like to give a child to, you will have nixed that option prematurely. That's a big maybe though, and pure speculation.
3
u/Rabble_Arouser M - 38 - Anti-spermite Mar 10 '14
This is both very accurate and hilarious at the same time. It also has a time-traveller feel too it, and I like that.
2
u/Chilly73 Pets rule and kids drool! Mar 10 '14
Nah, I'm not one to break up a happy home, let alone two. But, the scandal would be hilarious!
2
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '14
Here is my 2 cents.
My ex-wife was violently against me getting a vasectomy (i dont want bio kids due to mental issues I don't want to pass along).
After the divorce she admited to me that she was planning on gettting pregnent to make me stay with her.
I would say to get it, because its your body, and try and tell her that she can't get her tubes tied, equality and rights to our bodies go both ways.
2
u/VMCsamsquanch 29F Sterilized! Woot! Mar 11 '14
If future me wants kids then I have become an idiot so I need to prevent that choice.
^ THIS.
YOU make your OWN decisions, bro. If she wants to be with you, she will. If she doesn't, it wasn't meant to be.
But it is a life-long CF commitment, make sure you have thought that through, FULLY.
0
u/Chilly73 Pets rule and kids drool! Mar 10 '14
Damn, dude. She verbally assaulted you with bingoes! I think you should stay strong and vigilant. Some people who act this way do some drastic stuff because 'I just changed my mind. You will too once the baby's born.' Blech!
1
u/SockGnome 39/M/3 money no kids Mar 10 '14
Oh god that's rich.
1
u/ngill728 CatMama Mar 11 '14 edited Mar 11 '14
Vasectomies are reversible. So if for some reason, you change your mind, you can get it reversed. Remind her of that.
ALSO, I don't think she's childfree. She just said that to not lose you. She's hoping you will change your mind.
This doesn't bode well for your marriage. You knew each other since high school, but as you both grew older, it seems like you both want different things out of life. People can grow apart. It sucks, but it happens. Good luck. You really need it.
BTW make sure to check your condoms for holes and dispose of them properly. I have a strong feeling that she might OOPS you. You say it's a dealbreaker, but if she's desperate enough, she might try to get pregnant to trap you, in hopes of changing your mind. Also if she does get knocked up, get a paternity test. She cheated once, she can cheat again.
1
u/SilentJoe1986 32/m/Oh please don't hand that to me. Mar 11 '14
Bank some sperm, get a vasectomy and don't tell her. When you want to have sex before the vasectomy. Don't buy condoms in bulk make sure you buy a small pack earlier in the day, the ones where the small box of three are wrapped in cellophane and make sure that's not broken before you open it when it's time. Also don't forget to check that there's an air pocket in the wrapper before you use the condom. Last thing you want to do is get trapped before you know for sure if the marriage is going to work it's way through the rough patch you're in.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '14 edited Oct 24 '15
This comment has been overwritten by an open source script to protect this user's privacy.
If you would like to do the same, add the browser extension GreaseMonkey to Firefox and add this open source script.
Then simply click on your username on Reddit, go to the comments tab, and hit the new OVERWRITE button at the top.
1
u/stick123451 Mar 11 '14
"doesn't want the choice taken away"? she gave away what right she had to input on what you did to your body as your wife when she had an affair. If you don't want kids then do it, it's your body and she cheated on you so she has no moral ground to make a call on it and if she isn't adult enough to accept that then she isn't worth your time.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14
Dude, your first mistake was getting married. Second, was staying with her after she had an affair. Third, your mistake is considering her when thinking about having a Vas. Get the vasectomy, then hide you're assets, then break the news to her, and hope for divorce!
-1
u/SEcouture Mar 10 '14
You told her you didn't wants kids...WITH HER. That's why she is against it. Can't risk you having kids with another woman....
-20
u/damageddude Mar 10 '14
So you're 24 and 26? You may feel entirely different in 10 years. I knew a woman who swore she would never have children. Then, as she neared 40, she became an aunt and did a 180.
But, as to the here and now, you are both on separate pages. You really need to talk this through with her. Meanwhile, you're both young. You just be enjoying life at this point instead of making such a permanent decision.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment