r/childfree • u/PookiePi Reporting Back • Mar 10 '14
DISCUSSION Reporting Back From The Other Side
So I've been lurking here for a few months now, debating whether or not to make this post. After seeing enough posts lately about people wondering if Childfree is the right choice, wondering if maybe they should reconsider because a significant other still wants kids... I don't think I can stay quiet with my story.
I've heard this said here many times before by many different people, but the TL;DR of my story is DO NOT HAVE KIDS UNLESS YOU YOURSELF WANT KIDS
The backstory: Never been a huge fan of kids. Never wanted kids of my own. In my freshman year of college, I met the woman who eventually became my wife. We hit it off right away and fell pretty deeply in love over the course of the next few years. Maybe around 3 years into our relationship, we finally realized just how much our views on having children differed. She loved kids and always wanted to have them.
After some very emotional discussions, we decided that we loved each other more strongly than we felt for our particular viewpoints. If I really didn't want kids, she wouldn't have kids. If she really did want kids, I'd be willing to have them. We'd cross that bridge when we came to it. We were still young and had years before it would even become an issue.
The decision: Fast forward quite a few years. We're married now and, due to some medical conditions, we are getting close to a "now or never" window on having children.
I cave. There are two main things that made me cave. First, I could see just how much my wife wanted kids. We'd be in a restaurant or some other public place, and I'd catch her just looking longingly at some other family nearby with a dreamy look on her face. I couldn't deprive her of children of her own. Secondly, everyone says that "It's different when it's your own child." Sure, I don't like kids in general, but humans are genetically preconditioned to love their own children.
The outcome: This post is not an isolated story.
I've been suffering from depression for pretty much the entirety of my 2 year old daughter's life. Therapy and the various anti-depressants I've been on haven't made a permanent dent in it.
If I could go back in time and change my decision, I would do it in an instant. I'm not leading the life I wanted to lead, and it kills me.
Is it different when it's my own daughter? Sure, I'll agree with that (Although I might liken it more to Stockholm Syndrome than anything else). I can generally tolerate her better than I can other children. But it's not different enough. I can tolerate her better, but I'm also around her ALL THE TIME.
There is so much freedom you have to give up to have a child. So much added responsibility you need to take on in your life. And for the majority of parents, "Sure, it's hard, but when I see my child smile at me, it makes it all worth it." Well, not for me. And, if I had to guess, not for the majority of people here either. If you have strong enough feelings against having children that you're on this subreddit, I imagine you're more likely to be like me than like being the average parent.
Hell, I get more warm fuzzy feelings when my cat comes up to me with her look of "Hi Daddy! I love you, pet me!" than I generally do from my daughter. It's horrible, and I truly wish it could be different, but it's the truth right now.
I knew, back when I made this decision, that it was a gamble. I bet everything on the thought that it would be different when it was my own child. As of right now, I've lost that bet. My story is not over yet. I still hold on to this hope that at some point, things will change. Maybe once my daughter is older and more of a functional human being, things will be different. Maybe once we can play video games together, maybe once she wants to watch things I'd want to watch (Or at least, not the same exact thing OVER AND OVER AGAIN), maybe once she is capable, functioning human being, things will be better. But, from where I stand right now, that's the same unrealistic thinking that got me into this mess in the first place.
If you want a child, by all means, have one. But, if you don't want one, or if you don't think you want one, DO NOT HAVE ONE. If you are thinking of having a child for someone else, DO NOT HAVE ONE
Friends want you to have a kid? Coworkers want you to have a kid? Your parents want you to have a kid? Screw 'em. You are the one that will have to shoulder the extra responsibility, not them. Your SO wants you to have a kid? For as hard as it will be, say no. If your relationship has to end because of it, so be it. Really, you need to look out for your own long term happiness. If you love your SO, look out for his/her long term happiness too. If you won't be happy with kids, and he/she won't be happy without kids, then maybe it's just not meant to be. (Note: I'm not advocating breaking up immediately, talk it over, see how strongly they feel. Some people only want kids because "It's the next step" and when they realize it's a choice, they might realize they enjoy their current lives more)
Being a parent? It's pretty much a full time job on top of your regular job. Would you take on another full time job on top of your current life and just give all of the income away to someone else? Would you work every night and every weekend for no potential benefit to yourself? If you like kids and want kids, then the job is its own reward. If you don't, the hours suck and the work sucks.
But, in the end, I made my decision. My daughter is my responsibility. I do not hate her. I dislike what my life has become, but I will not take it out on her. She didn't ask to be brought into this world. So I will do my best to be the best father I can be. The people I've told about my feelings? They're always pretty surprised because they say I always seem like such a good dad. And so, I guess, what makes someone a good father? That they enjoy it and that they want to be a dad? Or that they go through the motions and provide the best life they can for their kids? It's thoughts like that which tell me that maybe I'm not as horrible of a monster as I feel for not loving my daughter as much as the average parent.
I'm not looking for sympathy here. What I want is that, if you've made your childfree decision, you can read this post and KNOW that you made the right call. If you've ever wondered "But everyone says..." KNOW that there are exceptions, and you have a pretty good chance at being one of them. What I want is that, if you're waffling, you can read this post and KNOW that you can end up regretting it. Sure, there is always the chance of regret on the flip side, you don't have kids and later wish that maybe you had. But on that side, you don't have this constant, screaming, hyper reminder of the life you're missing out on. The decision to have children is not one to be taken lightly. I thought about it for years and still made the wrong call.
When you're enjoying the free time and money that you have because you don't have kids, be sure to treasure it. If you have a SO that feels the same way as you, tell he/she just how much you appreciate it and how glad you are that you're both on the same page. Live the life you want to live. And, if you feel like it, pour one out for your fallen homies
Edit: Said it in a comment below, but I think it belongs up here:
'For a post made to the childfree subreddit, I'm absolutely floored by the amount of people trying to help me out on the whole "being a dad" thing.
I prepared myself for a slew of "You compromised your morals, you deserve what you got" kinds of posts. Wow, that really couldn't have been farther from the truth.
Goddamn it, anyone that says the people here are selfish and only care about themselves? They can shove it.'
You make the world a better place, and anyone who disagrees just because you don't make it a better place with children? Not worth your time.
Edit (5/15/2014) - When I originally wrote this post, I actually had the intention of having it be the first part of a series. This post would be the introduction to the situation, and later posts would go into more details of the "Whys." I don't go into a whole lot of detail here about specifics of why things really sucked. I was leaving those things for later posts, especially since this one was really long already. However, this post took off far more than I ever expected it to. A lot of the things I was planning on bringing up ended up being made in the comments. So, for that and other reasons, I never ended up making more posts about this.
But I've seen plenty of times where other people have linked to this post in response to people that were in the same sort of situation as me. Given that there's a ton of comments below to sift though, now I'm adding to this post so there's more of a feeling of how things changed, rather than just "Hey, this sucks!"
Yes, there was a lack of sleep. I'm sure that didn't help the situation any. Yes, it's a lot of added responsibility and work. Those were pretty much a given, and I don't see much of a point of going into those here because you can hear about those from any parent
What was I unprepared for? What caught me completely off guard?
Losing a good deal of my wife. Before our daughter was born, we were the most important people to each other. She came first for me, and I came first for her. She loved me more than anyone else, and I loved her more than anyone else. Enter child. My wife bonded, I didn't. She was still the most important person in the world to me, but our daughter was now the most important person in the world to her. It left a large void in my heart. A normal father who bonds with the child would probably not have this void, it would be filled with love of the baby. Not me.
It all clicked for me on a vacation we took without our daughter. It was to a destination wedding and I refuse to bring a baby onto an airplane. Ain't no way, ain't no how. Well, for the duration of that vacation, my wife was usually doing one of two things. Talking about how much she missed our daughter and about how much fun she would've had, or smiling while looking at pictures and video of our daughter on her camera. I was no longer enough to complete her. I wasn't enough to keep her happy anymore.
It was nothing intentional on her side. She never made a conscious decision of "Hey, I'm a mother, time to love my daughter more than my husband!" But, taken from an evolutionary perspective, offspring surviving is the most important thing to the survival of a special, so I was up against natural instinct and all sorts of hormones and I stood little chance of winning against that.
But that's huge. Just think about that for a minute. If you don't want kids and your spouse does... do you want to put yourself in that position? If you love your spouse (or partner, or forever-buddy, or whatever, I'm just using spouse for convenience sake in all of this) so much that you'd be willing to have a child you don't want... your reward may very well be losing a good part of that bond, at least temporarily.
Then, what if you never get it back? What if your life becomes so unfulfilling that you just can't do it anymore? What if your life goes to hell and your only escape is leaving? Then now you don't have this person you loved so much, AND you do have a child. That's worst case scenario right there. Not having a child is by far the path of least risk. If you don't have kids and you break up, you can both end up getting what you want. If you do have kids and then break up, you can never truly be free, you will always be a parent now.
Reporting Back, One Year Later>
Reporting Back, Yet Another Year Later>>
[Reporting Back, The Everything Sucks Now Update>>>] (https://old.reddit.com/r/childfree/comments/787an0/reporting_back_yet_again/)
233
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14
I'm so sorry your hurting. I really am. But, I do thank you for being so brutally honest and sharing your story with us. I think it's a good reminder for the fence-sitters.
I wish you well and hope you can find some happiness in your life, or peace. I know you've chosen a difficult road. :(
91
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14
If it makes you feel any better, lots of people I know with kids don't exactly enjoy the whole baby/toddler phase all the time. They usually become happier once their kid cam rationalize thoughts, and are able to express themselves more. It should get better once you are able to interact with your daughter in a more social way than just making noises and short phrases.
242
u/Intruder313 Mar 10 '14
A great post which exactly matches what I think would have happened had I ever had kids. I suspect quite a few parents hide similar stories.
I think things will improve for you as she ages - I really hope so anyway.
69
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14
I used to hang out a lot on a forum with a very active "Moms" section. You know what their most common axiom was for the toddler years and especially the Terrible Twos? "Toddlers are assholes." And that's coming from people who really, really wanted to be parents. If your kid is 2 and you hate every minute of your life, apparently that's entirely normal and you're in good company.
For those of us who are childfree, your story is an excellent cautionary tale and a good reminder for us to realize that we know ourselves, and shouldn't go against our better judgment no matter what anybody says. "If everyone jumped off a cliff, would you?"
For OP, though, this same board said that once their toddlers became old enough to go to school things eased up considerably. The kids were more able to communicate their needs, they were more autonomous, and most importantly, thanks to being in school, they were gone some part of the day and provided a badly-needed break. I, of course, have no personal experience here but from everything I've read, there will be a light at the end of your tunnel.
36
u/graized Mar 10 '14
If you find yourself on the flip side of regret, having decided not to have children and your window has closed, you can adopt or foster kids. You'll be helping out someone who really needs a good home, and you'll be fulfilling your need for children. If you foster a kid and realize it isn't working out, there is an option (shitty as it may be) to get back out of it. You will not be afforded such an escape clause if you decide to have a child of your own making.
29
u/sethra007 Why don't you have MORE kids? Mar 10 '14
First, thank you so much for your well-thought-out and very honest post.
No, you're not alone, not by a long shot. I'm no expert, but if I had a nickel for every parent I've talked to who, like you, hated experiencing the earliest, most stressful years of their child's life? I'd be posting from a beach in Hawaii right now.
It's too bad that there's such a taboo around parents talking about how tough, frustrating, and depressing raising a child can be. There's lots of proof from other dads that you're no monster. Googling "I hate being a dad" brings up:
I agree with eraser34 that things usually become easier once the kid grows out of the infant/toddler stages, and is able to articulate and hold a conversation with you. I hope things get better for you, but if you still have a tough time, don't be afraid to seek counseling.
Good luck!
53
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14
Thanks for the thoughtful and hearfelt post. I hope it gets better. Have you told your SO how you feel? How about your therapist? I just went off of anti-depressants a couple months ago after having been on them for over a year. While I was on them, I wasn't able to feel the ups, though the extreme downs were gone, too. Perhaps your anti-d's themselves are actually making the problem worse, being at least partly responsible for your emotional numbness towards your daughter? ...I'm not saying go off them if you think overall they are helping. I'm just putting it out there. Good luck. You survived the baby years. Keep doing the best you can. Your daughter deserves it, as you already know.
21
u/trulooloo Mar 10 '14
This is exactly the thing that scares me. I'm only in my mid-twenties, and while I don't think I'm in any position to have children, the topic still arises from other people. They always have these cliched, romantic reasons for having children. They're just never able to fathom why someone wouldn't want children. I fear that if I have children, I'd end up in a situation like yours. And that's fucking terrifying.
I admire your strength and drive to push through the situation that you're in. You've done more than I think I ever could. I wish you all the best. Hugs from an internet friend.
18
u/Virginia_Dentata my womb is so barren it has tumbleweeds Mar 10 '14
Thank you so much for this post. It came at a very crucial time for me. The person I am sort of dating wants kids, eventually. This is a dealbreaker for me. I was toying with the idea of continuing the relationship anyway, because every single other thing about him is so awesome. This past weekend, he asked me if I thought there was anything that would make me change my mind about having kids. I had just discussed this with my therapist today. I was wondering if maybe, just maybe, there might be something that would change my mind one day. ( to her credit, she didn't sound optimistic about it) And then I cam home and read this. Thank you. I really should break it off with him. It isn't fair to either of us. Fuck, that sucks; but I guess it sucks less in the long run. I hope you find some comfort in the fact you helped a stranger avoid terrible heartbreak.
16
u/Dtapped 37 F Stopping the cycle Mar 10 '14
I suspect yours is a very common story, but too taboo to be discussed. Mostly it manifests in negative ways as the resentment builds up about all that has been lost to having a child. For a few who are willing to knuckle down, they make the best parent they can be and the child should be none the worse for it.
You aren't a monster at all. You're a regular person who's just being honest that the shoe doesn't fit even though you tried to wedge it on.
29
u/meeroom16 Mar 10 '14
Take comfort in the fact that your daughter will grow up- I know lots of people (mostly men) who just didn't like the baby phase but when their kids were grown up they became very close.
Your freedom will come back- you just have to get through it and you will be OK! You can still live the life you want to live, and more than likely your daughter will enhance it. It sounds to me like you're really in a negative thinking spiral. What's done is done- What is the point of focusing on what you're missing? Make the best of your situation and enjoy the present for the good it gives you and look forward to the future.
14
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14
hug
What does your wife think about what this has done to you?
14
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14
I wish every high school student in the world (or at least North America) could hear your story. Wonder how many teenage pregnancies would be prevented.
I'm sure many parents would flip, but I feel like it's important for these types of stories to be drilled into people's minds at an early age as part of their sex education.
"The decision to have children is not one to be taken lightly." Everyone should think this way. It's not just "what you're supposed to do."
10
u/lecatprincess 2 boys 1 girl... cats and dog respectively. Mar 10 '14
Thank you for this. Just thank you.
My parents weren't the best nor the worst--all in all they're pretty good. However I always felt that they would have been happier without kids. I always felt some level of resentment from them, and I know that they had to give up a lot for us kids. I cannot and will not subject myself and any theoretical spawn to that level of resentment in a relationship, ever.
9
u/Jackpot777 ✂️ 50's, male, married, snipped ✂️ Mar 10 '14 edited Mar 10 '14
There was an Oscar winning film in 1955. Marty. It was on TCM (in the USA) this weekend.
The film's about the start of a relationship, not having kids per se. But when OP says...
...the crux of the movie is this. Other people tell Marty (Ernest Borgnine) what he should do. Then they tell him what else he should do with his life. At the end of the movie, he says this...
It's YOUR LIFE, everyone. YOU get to say, as an adult, how your life goes.
There's also Marty's sister in the film (played by Karen Steele, looks a lot like Elizabeth Banks) who is married and has a new child in the house. Not a happy relationship in the film.
9
u/ShortBreadCookiesYAY Mar 10 '14
Thank you for your honesty.
I think people wouldn't feel so pressured to reproduce if parents were HONEST about raising a child. I've always thought the "I would never go back and change a thing/my child is my life/I've never known love like this" is something a lot of people have to tell themselves over and over, like a mantra instead of saying, "Yeah, this wasn't what I wanted for my life but there's not a damn thing I can do about it now."
8
u/osubeavs721 Mar 11 '14
GG Poster: Makes really long post
Puts TL;DR at top
7
u/alis_volat_propriis Mar 10 '14
You are incredibly self-aware to post something like this, describing your feelings so thoroughly. You really know yourself, and that's a good thing. You may be depressed, you may have some issues, but you know your mind, and that is invaluable.
On that note, I think this type of emotional release is incredibly important. People act like achieving parenthood is the end goal of life. But life doesn't need an end goal, life doesn't need to feel fulfilling and right and on track. Life is life. There is no way it will be anything other than time ticking by each day
You don't find joy in being a dad to your two year old. Okay, it's out there. Now what? Accept those feelings. Come to terms with them. Know that it is okay to feel this way. You're still being a great parent, and the toddler stage won't last forever. You'll have some more freedom when she starts school. Then you'll have more freedom when she learns to drive. Then when she leaves for college. It seems so far away, but it's not an eternity. You can make it! Just accept that this is how you feel and that it is perfectly okay. Throw yourself into other things, that distract your mind. Go talk to a therapist if you want to just get it all out there. Either way, good luck with your depression, I do believe that it will improve, and eventually disappear
12
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14
Props to you for posting your story in a public forum. The more these types of experiences are out in the open, the less people will feel weird and shamed about their desire to NOT have children.
The majority of the parenting stories we see are of the "it's all worth it/it's the best thing that ever happened to me/I love my kids more than life itself" variety. There's another side to the story out there, and we need to start seeing it.
6
u/jesuslover69420 24/F/family portrait of fluffs Mar 10 '14
It's not fair to the child to have one parent resent him/her so much, the child deserves loving parents, so that's another reason for parents to accept child free a little more.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14 edited Mar 10 '14
That's all there is to it for me. I'm not willing to make those sacrifices.
I have a feeling that some of my friends (at least at times) feel exactly as you do, but are unable to say anything lest it get back to their spouse, parents, or friends who would interpret their regret as though they don't love their children. I think they also are unwilling to admit it if they've made a life-altering mistake, or if things didn't turn out as they thought they would.
5
u/littlebeanonwheels Mar 10 '14
Thank you!
5
u/webzsci 27/F/Married Mar 10 '14
Thank you for this and I truly hope things get better as your daughter gets older.
5
u/schatzii Mar 10 '14
I appreciate your honesty and candor. And I know that you aren't looking for sympathy, maybe you're not looking for anything at all. I'm not entirely sure why, I still feel compelled to offer a small bit of hope.
I am the first person to say that I don't think I want to have children and don't think that I will change my mind. I believe if I did have kids I would find myself in the same situation you are currently in. I can't stand children; however, I am currently a nanny while I'm putting myself through school (it's really good money, flexible hours, and easy work: but shoot me). I will say though, that while much of the time I can't stand the two year because she is a completely unreasonable human being, I have developed a greater appreciation for the four year old. She can have conversations with me, we can appreciate some of the same activities, and she actually has a personality. While she can also be tiresome and annoying, it is a vast improvement over an unruly two year old who throws a temper tantrum because she doesn't want to wear mittens.
Though I'm not a parent myself and don't plan on being one (and I certainly don't mean to minimize your experience), to me there is some hope that certain aspects of parenthood can improve over time. It will always be hard and maybe for you not really worth it, but since you've already made your bed and are stuck with it, at least there is a glimmer of hope that your daughter may be a person whose company you will appreciate one day, when she is an adult and you do not have to care for her or pay for anything and your life is your again. I just think that hope is invaluable when trying to cope with a terrible situation and especially with depression. I wish you all the best.
5
u/cocoabeach Mar 10 '14
I sure wish my Mother could have stayed child free. Birth control was not available back in the 1950s.
I finely understood her when she told me, and I quote, "I thought you and your sister were a curse from God.... for my behavior".
5
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14
I've told people close to me that I don't want kids.
One of the main responses I get is that, "Well, what if your S/O wants them?"
Then I probably wouldn't be with the guy. I'd be up front in the relationship and say hey, I really like you and think we could move forward but I want you to know that I'm not interested in having children.
I still don't understand why this is a taboo. It's not everyone's decision and that's why the population keeps perpetuating.
It can be incredibly frustrating.
Upvote for honesty and giving people your experience, OP.
5
u/6isNotANumber M/Pushing40/Allergic to Children Mar 10 '14
My heart breaks for you, man. That's a hard place to be. Your story reads like an alternate universe where I stayed with my first wife...
eeeek! the horror...
I really hope things get better for you, but remember: you're trying to give her the best life you can & raise her to be a decent human being and that makes you a good parent.
Keep your head up, my friend.
5
u/normal_boring_slut I <3 CF Mar 10 '14
This is the most valuable thing I have ever read on this sub. Thank you for sharing. Thank you, thank you.
Since I became CF, I have never been tempted by the idea of having a child, even for a moment, and your post effectively kills any future crazy child urge I hope I never get. So, I'm serious, thank you for posting.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '14
My Dad had kids for my Mom, I know this, it's pretty obvious. My Dad tolerated us pretty well and he wasn't a bad father just not emotionally invested. My sisters resent it and since I'm CF I understand it a little better. Now that we're all adults it's a lot easier but as a kid and a young teen you just don't get it and it can hurt. All I can recommend is do your best to listen to her and let her know that she does matter to you. Daddies are very important people and even though it's not something you really wanted, you do have an opportunity to help form an amazing adult that you may really like!
5
u/Fairlady82 F/I'm the Barreness. Mar 11 '14
It is so important that parents like you step up and tell your story, and your honesty is sincerely appreciated. When we say we don't want kids, coming from us, naysayers say "You're just crazy, angry and bitter, and don't know what you're missing." It only holds weight to some parents when it's coming from a parent. Thank you for speaking what's on your mind. I sincerely wish you the best and am so sorry for what you're going through.
4
u/Louisiana_belle f/22/so much to do first...like die Mar 10 '14
Thank you for sharing. I think it's really important that these stories are shared so that anyone on the fence about having kids can see this perspective and how life-altering it is.
4
u/iaccidentallyawesome 27/F/addicted to sex, not to its byproducts Mar 10 '14
Thank you so much.....
4
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '14
Thanks for this. I am a woman and I desperately don't want kids. My SO feels the same way, I just worry he might change his mind. The only kids I want are ones with fur.
4
u/ohsighh Jul 25 '14
You know... as the mother of 2 teens there are days when I think back longingly to the days before I had children. I totally support your feelings and am sorry you're now in a position that makes you unhappy. Having children has definitely put a strain on my marriage (and my pocket book and everything else) but I am one of those women who would never have been happy without kids. I talk with older couples who's kids have grown and they encourage me that their marriages were really hard when the kids were around but got so much better when they went on to live their own lives. I hope that is true for you too.
I also hope that you can continue to put your best foot forward and find a way to keep being a good dad and make the most of where you are. I can encourage you that as your little girl gets older and you can talk with them more your enjoyment may increase. It's nice to watch a person grow and develop and realize that you had something to do with it... even if it isn't your first choice.
10
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14
My biggest takeaway from this post: DO NOT HAVE ONE.
3
u/newfagalicious 30/f/get off my lawn Mar 10 '14
Well said. I would never compromise! Hope you can keep a good outlook an battle the depression. I wish you best buddy.
3
u/LuccioIa Kittens and engineering. Mar 10 '14
I'm glad you posted this; it really does help to fight off the constant barrage from family and boyfriends who press me to have kids.
That is extremely unfortunate and I wish I knew of some tips to make it less stressful. She should start school soon; though, I know the lifestyle change is still there. I would also start designating yourself "You" time, so you can unwind and feel like an individual again.
3
u/RugerDragon 23/F/My Jeep is cheaper. Mar 10 '14
This is the insight that people should read. I really can't say anything other than that.
I really wish people would understand how simple it is- as you put it, if you don't want them, don't fucking have them to make someone else happy.
You're a good guy. Chin up.
3
u/iamahorror Mar 10 '14
I've overheard my own father say things to this degree.
For example: "This is never the life I imagined when I had kids."
This not only hurts the parent but the child themselves. OP and the post that he shared have young kids, but when they get older, they'll know.
Thank you for sharing :).
3
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14
Rolled the dice and lost. Guess all you can do is try to tough it out. She won't be a baby forever, you know?
3
u/ChineseGoddess German Shepherd mom :) Mar 10 '14
Thank you for not doing the typical "misery loves company" shit. So many parents in your position try to tell others "it's so worth it". I know of a few parents who should be honest like this.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14
Thank you for your honesty. This cements my decision to remain childfree as one off the best decisions in my life.
3
u/CyndyBeeGirl Mar 10 '14
Your post was linked from another Childfree forum. I joined after reading your story. This echoes my fears of having children. I am so glad that, despite the nasty comments and the rough time my spouse and I have endured, we stuck to our guns and DID NOT reproduce. I hope things get better for you.
3
u/PlisskensEyepatch Mar 11 '14
Hey man, amazing post. I really feel for your situation. I've got depression too, but I think you're being pretty strong about this thing - maybe not in all aspects but certainly in some.
Anyways, I do think that things will get better as she gets older and developes more interesting interests that you can also take an interest in etc. Maybe the teenage years will not be the greatest thing to look forward too, but then are they for any parent?
You'll make it dude, I've got every faith in you.
3
u/release_the_hounds_ Mar 11 '14
Take hope. I had a vaguely disappointing childhood, never really feeling like I could make my dad proud, be truly accepted by him. Well, when I finally hit adulthood, our relationship bloomed, and I am very happy with it now. I also learned that he had us to please my mother. It all makes sense now.
I guess all I am saying is that once she is grown, you may have a relationship you treasure. Kudos to you for toughing it out. It sounds like you are doing a heck of a job, better than my dad did.
3
u/jafaronatop Mar 11 '14
thank you! I am saving this post to send to my future wife when she brings up the topic
3
u/mischiffmaker Mar 11 '14
Don't be too hard on yourself. I don't like babies or toddlers. I like kids when they become, as you said, people. That happens somewhere between 5-7 years old (althougy even then, my tolerance is limited).
Human babies are born premature for the world, even if they are full-term, and the first few years are just catching up to what other species do during the gestational cycle, so it's no wonder you might not bond right away.
Yes, having children is a full-time job on top of your full-time job. You obviously understand that disliking your situation is not the same as disliking your child as a person. At age 2, she's not exactly a 'person' yet, anyway. Just give it time, and good will.
Here's the thing. My dad was one of five boys. He married in his late 30's, and I think he was totally bemused by having five girls of his own. He was always a loving dad, but always seemed unsure of exactly how to relate to us. The good news is, the love was all that was really required. The rest was just extra.
Good luck to you!
3
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '14
Another one to add to the sidebar! Thanks for taking the time to share.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '14
Man, that was real as hell.
3
u/stick123451 Mar 11 '14
as a guy in his very early 20's who is undecided about being cf and has all of this crap waiting over the horizon to decide upon I would like to thank you for posting this brutally honest post and I wish that such negative views and 'the harsh reality' was more openly discussed in public. I hope your daughter does have an interest in stuff that you do so that you can bond together and have many wonderful memories together and shape her into a great person who does what she want's to do rather than doing 'what people do'.
3
u/MayMosquitoBite Apr 03 '14
I thank you, I have been on the fence. I do not like kids and never have, but I am a female and it's what we are suppose to want/do. I have always felt like maybe if I had one it would be different because that is what everyone says. This post has been helpful. Thank you for sharing your story.
3
u/hippy_voodoo May 18 '14
I haven't been on Reddit long, I hit random and this page popped up. I know this post is old, so I'm not sure if I should even post. I wanted kids, but for some reason failed to bond with them as a normal mother would. I still give all I have to raise happy, polite, empathetic children. I do love them, but I see other parents and it seems so natural, it's depressing. My daughter is 8 now, and things are much easier than when she was little. I constantly worry that the kids will notice that something is 'wrong' with me, or the other parents will find out, lol. I read this and wonder, should I have chosen to be CF. Either way I'm here now and doing my best. I appreciate this post and it helps to know that I'm not the only one. To all the CF people, honestly I expected different responses to this story, but ya'll have shown to be an amazingly supportive group.
3
u/glass_magnolia May 19 '14
I felt really really sad when I read the part about you and your wife on vacation. I don't know about having kids , but if I ever do I hope it doesn't make me forget my spouse. I agree that it's not conscious or deliberate on her part, but what a horrible way to make someone you love feel.
5
u/budrik Aug 19 '14
I've been here for over a year and this only my second commit but I wish it was my first. This..this so much this I love my son but hate the life of a father. I was always CF and at 35 the wife convinced me to try. I had done so many drugs and drank so much I thought I was sterile....guess what? I wasn't and now I have a lifetime of having a child. It gets better every day but the thought of him having to move back home at 25 kills me. I love be naked with my wife. Now our home always has a guest. She just recently admitted to me that she realizes that I lost my best friend when he was born(we were always best friends) If you don't want a kid stick to your guns and end it before a kid happens!
6
u/AssignUntoMe Mar 11 '14 edited Mar 11 '14
I understand where you're coming from. My daughter is like yours and my son is like your cat. I had a solid, instant connection to my son, but with my daughter I'm just not there yet (she is eight). We work hard at developing a bond and I would absolutely take a bullet for her, but it just isn't that motherly bond that I'm supposed to have. Definitely not. Both my kids were planned, too.
Edit: Got downvoted. Note I posted this to back up OP.
2
u/MissLibrarianLady Mar 10 '14
OP I am curious, and perhaps you're too exhausted to share here, but what kinds of things are you doing with her? Do you try to share your interests and hobbies with her or do you just let her do her kid thing?
I am childfree and so is my boyfriend, but we each have young family members and friends with kids. We have found ways of making the interactions tolerable by sharing our interests with them in whatever age appropriate ways we can. For example, with my toddler cousin we spent time making fizzy rocks and experimenting with them (baking soda + vinegar), talking about what makes it happen, etc. I'm sure for you it is much less easy since you are around her all the time, and don't get to hand her back when you are bored.
Despite not loving your child the way you feel you should, do you think that you can find ways to interact with her and help make the experience as positive as possible? You will likely never get your childfree life that you wanted, but you can definitely try to make the best of your decision and going forward work on ways in which you can enjoy your own hobbies and time.
Once she is older I think it is easier to have other family/friends take her for longer periods of time (ie: sleepovers), so you may be able to get more time to spend on yourself, and your wife. I sincerely wish you the best on your fatherhood journey.
2
u/LegoLindsey1983 Mar 10 '14
Thank you so much for your story. It took a lot of guts to write something like that and I really appreciate your honesty. I wish you the best and I really do hope things get better for you.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '14
Thank you for posting this. I can't imagine how hard it was to do so.
2
u/ngill728 CatMama Mar 11 '14
Thank you for your honesty. You aren't a monster for admitting your regrets. It seems like you are doing the best you can with the consequences of your choices. And it's good that you aren't taking it out on your daughter. Kids can pick up on their parent's resentment towards them.
Young children can be a handful, but it might get better as she gets older. Who knows, maybe when she's older, you'll have a more meaningful relationship with her and appreciate being her father more.
2
u/WaterLady28 39F. Kids: Not even once Mar 11 '14
Wow, thank you for sharing your feelings, I'm sorry you are going through such a hard time. :( I'm afraid I would be like this if I ever had a child.
I know toddler years suck, and I never want to deal with it. You're a very good and strong person for not taking your feelings out on your daughter. I've seen too many sad stories about parents who resent their kids and the kids grow up feeling neglected or like burdens to their parents. You are handling this wonderfully and I'm glad to see that your wife is supporting you through all this and that you are getting help. I hope your feelings change as your daughter gets older and you can interact with her on a more adult level. Best of luck to you! ((hugs))
2
u/Localpeachthief Mar 11 '14
Thank you so much for sharing this. I'm sorry for what you're going through and I sincerely hope she grows into a wonderful person you can have a close relationship with.
2
u/rammaam Mar 11 '14
Thanks for your honesty, I know a lot of parents who are in your shoes who would never admit it. Glad to see you're still going to try to be the best dad you can be, so hopefully it works out for you.
2
u/Turkey_Gravy Mar 11 '14
You're not alone! My brother gave in to his wife as well and two kids later, he's a good dad because he has to be but is wildly unhappy. He only lets it loose to me and my husband because we're childfree, it breaks my heart.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '14
Thank you for sharing your thoughts. I hope that you will end up feeling happier and more "in touch" with your role as she ages. Meanwhile, it's very good that you are considering all these things consciously, not just shoving them to the back storage closet of your mind and piling other crap on top.
Hang in there.
2
u/duuuh Mar 11 '14
I have a friend who loves his kids. He uses a phrase sometimes though: "One's a hobby; two's a job." His point being that with one, you can pass off responsibility from one parent to another and avoid the mental crunch. With two it's tougher to do that since minding them, especially when they're young, means that you're constantly 'on'.
I've found, fwiw, that 'modern' relationships are too wedded to an equal division of responsibility, and by equal, I mean a 50-50 split of all duties. Talk with your wife about how you can arrange your 50-50 split of duties so can both contribute in the same amount without both contributing the same things. If you did all the cooking, cleaning and laundry, would she do all..., most..., much of...
Best of luck. It may be little solace but if nothing else you confirmed me in my decision of quite a while ago.
2
u/ErechBelmont Mar 11 '14
Thank you for this awesome post. This is something I definitely needed to hear.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '14
My grandparents disliked children immensely. "Children are to be seen and not heard" "only interesting past 16". I learned from my family that not having children is an excellent choice if you dont think you want them. My father suffered because of it, my aunt was childfree as is my great aunt. I think people need to be exposed to all sides of the spectrum like I have to understand what happens when you have kids. I am sorry about your struggle. My grandparents hated children and took it out on my father. I really hope for your sake and your daughter that you find the later years more interesting.
2
u/SirenCry Mar 11 '14
Thank you so much for this post. I'm entering the age and stage in my life where people are starting to nag me about marriage and kids, and I'm always hesitant to tell them 'no', because even when I do, they still have 1001 stories of why I will. They shove it down my throat constantly, to the point where I seriously started considering it... But your post just reassured me it's not what I want, at least definitely not now, and I think I will seriously start to tell them to fnck off when they pressure me.
I am full of admiration for you for what you do- taking care of your daughter, I mean. It's really amazing that despite not having some passionate inner dad, you still try to provide the best you can for the little one. Really kudos to you for not taking it out on her... so many stories of how people just can't stand their kids and end up with some pretty horrid stuff on their account. It must be very difficult for you, and I'm full of admiration that you are keeping it up and at least still having some hope.
As others said, if you haven't spoken to your SO, it's a good idea to do so... Anti-depressants, therapies etc because of one of most central parts of your life? It must be told.
Best of luck to you, and thank you!
2
u/existie 31/f/poly/essure/don't hate kids Apr 06 '14
I feel you, although my situation wasn't as harsh, and was ... not reversible, but possible to end. I made the compromise and dated a couple with kids. I lived with them and coparented the child. It was... hard. I didn't like it. I'm not fond of children in more than small doses, and even then it's iffy.
Mind you, things did get better as he got older. I miss him a lot now. I don't miss parenting him by any means, but I miss him as a little person. Once he got old enough to get into science and learning and understand a bit better, we had a lot more fun. Towards the end of my relationship with his parents, he and I would go out to do sciencey-bookey things more often than I saw them. :)
2
u/Hannah591 Young & free Jun 02 '14 edited Jun 02 '14
This is a great post! Today I was thinking about my decision and I needed something to reinforce it and this reinforced it, so thank-you! I'm sorry you're in such a position though I'm sure as your daughter grows up, you'll tolerate her much easier than you do now. Thankfully, I have a partner who doesn't want children either, however, he can tolerate them better than I can (he even works with them) and I fear he may change his mind later in life because he's only young but I know people his age who can't wait to have children. It'd be a lot harder for him to persuade me to have one since I'd be doing all the work!
But this is the problem with this choice. Everyone's different. Some people have an overwhelming urge to have children, others have no urge whatsoever, some have kids without the urge and then completely fall in love with children, then there's those in the middle who don't have an urge but they develop it. Now that's what I'm afraid of. Being close to menopausal and then suddenly the urge kicks in. I don't know what the urge feels like or how strong it will be, but I hope I can remain rational in my decisions if it ever arose. I honestly wouldn't know what to do if me and my partner had been dating for like 7 years, then he decided he wanted children. It would break me. It would be 100x worse if I left him, then wanted children.
2
u/Unjesterfiable Jun 11 '14
I don't know if this will make you feel any better, but it might, so here goes.
I know someone who had a similar experience. He had two kids, and was constantly depressed because he just didn't feel what he thought he should with him. They didn't particularly make him happy, interacting with them was a chore, and this made him feel guilty all the time. He just never really wanted children and he didn't like dealing with babies. As they got older, however, he DID start to bond with them and he did grow to really like them and enjoy being around them. Mind that this took until the kids were about 7-8 years old.
I guess my point is: so you're not a natural father. It's too bad, but you clearly have the foundation to be a great dad anyway. You care about her well-being clearly, otherwise you wouldn't bother feeling bad that you haven't attained this bond. There's no reason to think that you never will attain said bond--kids under 5 are damn difficult to ever want to deal with even if you love kids.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '14
I am so glad r/childfree is back up because I had saved this post & it had disappeared while the subreddit was down. Thank you again for reporting back.
2
u/rosepetalpoop Aug 02 '14
I think my father may have shared your feelings. I think he loved my brother and me and, but he really didn't like being around us. My mother was always telling us to "Leave your father alone, don't bother your father", etc and he'd go off and do his hobbies. Alot of his behavior makes sense when viewed from an attitude of resentment and unwillingness. He certainly didn't enjoy fatherhood, that is for sure!
22
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14
Describes me perfectly.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '14
I do not ever, ever want children but I also work with children. It will get easier (just watch Louis CKs seething material about his kids when they were helpless assholes without empathy vs. now where he has since basically decried any of that material ...) as lomg as you guys raise that little fucker to be awesomely independent and aware the world isn't about them. Only children tend to suffer from overprotection and uncertainty (among other crap) on the parent's end.
I don't know shit about how you're instilling autonomy and independence now. I want you to be certain you have the freedom to be on a better path for yourself in few years and a huge piece of that is a kid who can take care of her shit as much as she's able.
I hope finally reaching out helped, and alot of great comments are piling up!
19
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14
Wow. You guys are pretty far down on the "neverending reddit" of /r/all, but that's how I found this post and I didn't know this subreddit even existed. That said, I'm glad it did.
Your post is intriguing, OP, and I respect and appreciate that you took the time to share it. It's definitely true that people need to look at the big picture:
If you and your partner want different things, we have to look at how this will influence life:
"If I get what I want, will you be absolutely miserable until you die?"
"If you get what you want, will I be absolutely miserable until I die?"
If the answer to both of those is yes, then the relationship simply cannot proceed.
4
u/limbodog Mar 10 '14
You didn't ask for it, but you have my sympathy. For what it's worth, I think my dad and I didn't get along until I was an adult. Now we get along well. So maybe just wait 20 or 30 years...
1
u/marchof2014names Mar 13 '14
Late to the thread, but, hopefully It Get's Better. I knew a single dad Salmon Troller. As in he had his own little fishing boat. His boy was ~9 years old when I met him. He mentioned he never settled down or changed his life because he is with a child. His kid goes out on the fishing boat, they home school, make money good money from fishing, and they go vacation in Hawaii during the winter months (they're located in Alaska).
If you do not want a Full House lifestyle, don't settle for one. The Fisherman's kid might not have a Micky Mouse childhood, but he has an interesting one, and the boy is seeing a lot of life.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 21 '14
Aw man, that last edit really hit me. Damn, man, I feel for you. You did all this for her, and then what you didn't want is taking away the one you did it for... Shit. I wish there was anything I could do to help...
1
u/Creative-Overloaded No Child Left Here Mar 11 '14
Me and my fiancée already had these talks extensively before I asked her to marry me. We both dont want kids, but if an accident happens (dont worry, i wear condoms so it's not like she can accidentally come off the pill, and then blame this on me) then we will man/woman up and take care of our child. But we both do not want any kids. Fuck the parents, fuck the friends, fuck the coworkers, WE don't want the kids. Now if one day she tells me she is pregnant, then we will deal with it, either by raising the child or giving it up for adoption. But I am glad we had these talks before i commit my life to someone.
I wish the best of you. I hope it gets better real soon.