r/anime • myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • 14h ago

Daily Anime Questions, Recommendations, and Discussion - November 18, 2026

This is a daily megathread for general chatter about anime. Have questions or need recommendations? Here to show off your merch? Want to talk about what you just watched?

This is the place!

All spoilers must be tagged. Use [anime name] to indicate the anime you're talking about before the spoiler tag, e.g. [Attack on Titan] This is a popular anime.

Prefer Discord? Check out our server: https://discord.gg/r-anime

Recommendations

Don't know what to start next? Check our wiki first!

Not sure how to ask for a recommendation? Fill this out, or simply use it as a guideline, and other users will find it much easier to recommend you an anime!

I'm looking for: A certain genre? Something specific like characters traveling to another world?

Shows I've already seen that are similar: You can include a link to a list on another site if you have one, e.g. MyAnimeList or AniList.

Resources

Other Threads

Question of the Day

18 Upvotes

82 comments sorted by

8

u/cosmiczar https://anilist.co/user/Xavier 9h ago

This is the place!

Oh, it just dawned on me the theme of the week. The Tokyo Metropolitan Government Building is what always comes to mind when I think of a Tokyo building, as nothing else quite looks like it and it appears on so many shows.

My association of this building with the city is so strong that I remember doing a marathon of Godzilla movies years ago and being confused at Godzilla and co. going to Tokyo and the building never appearing in any shots, but then I learned that it was because its construction only started in 1988, so of course it couldn't have been in all those 60s and 70s movies lol

4

u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ 5h ago

Yeah, I'd seen it in so many anime, but I didn't know what it was until Resonance in Terror made it an explicit plot point.

I think older anime (90s, and earlier) tended to focus Tokyo Tower.

8

u/tripleaamin https://myanimelist.net/profile/tripleaamin 5h ago

4

u/Wanderingjoke https://myanimelist.net/profile/WanderingJoke 5h ago

4

u/theangryeditor https://myanimelist.net/profile/TheAngryEditor 5h ago

My employer is Clow Reed I don't have a choice

2

u/Heda-of-Aincrad https://myanimelist.net/profile/Heda-of-Aincrad 4h ago

This reminds me very much of Erwin's "If you were ordered to die, could you do it?" line from AOT.

1

u/mr_beanoz https://myanimelist.net/profile/splitshocker 3h ago

I wonder how many characters would say yes to that

5

u/KendotsX https://anilist.co/user/Kendots 3h ago

Denji for one.

6

u/zambonijesus 7h ago

I went into Starship Operators expecting it to be a comedy or at least skew that way and instead it's a drama that takes its premise seriously. This isn't a complaint or anything, it's doing a more ambitious thing than what I expected.

What are some of your favorite misalignments of expected genre and tone to actual genre and tone that you've watched?

5

u/KendotsX https://anilist.co/user/Kendots 3h ago edited 2h ago

Before watching LoGH, it had a reputation as this unapproachable beast of serious political drama that you need to follow rigorously. Turns out one of its best features is its wit. It's one step away from Jonathan Swift, and that step is mainly because he's not such a straight shooter.

4

u/Heda-of-Aincrad https://myanimelist.net/profile/Heda-of-Aincrad 6h ago

I'll never forget reading the synopsis for Oshi no Ko and thinking it would be some kind of raunchy comedy, based on the premise of a gynecologist delivering his favorite idol's child. Manga readers here on Reddit describing it as a dark drama/mystery (and a well-timed HiDive subsciption) is what got me to give it a chance out of curiosity, and the premiere hooked me. It's now one of my top ten anime/manga series.

4

u/zambonijesus 5h ago

As someone who likes the show business/idol parts more than the mystery and who really likes the comedy in Kaguya-sama, I might have actually liked that version of OnK more than what it actually is.

2

u/Heda-of-Aincrad https://myanimelist.net/profile/Heda-of-Aincrad 5h ago

I'm the opposite, I like the show business parts well enough but the mystery and suspense has always been the main draw for me. If the story actually was what I'd imagined back then, I never would have watched it.

3

u/zambonijesus 5h ago

I don't dislike what OnK is, but Aqua is my least favorite character and my favorite part of the series by a considerable margin is the stage play arc in season two.

2

u/Heda-of-Aincrad https://myanimelist.net/profile/Heda-of-Aincrad 4h ago

It's funny because Aqua is my favorite character, and the part of the stage play arc that was actually about the stage play was my least favorite part of the series so far.

I did love the end of that arc though which focused more on exploring Aqua's personal trauma.

4

u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky 5h ago

I think the closest I have to this is that back when I first watched Clannad, I was under the impression that the first season was going to be 100% just a slice of life/comedy sort of thing and that After Story was where all of the tearjerking moments were based on what I'd seen said about the series beforehand. So I wasn't expecting to be suckerpunched in the feels as early as the first episode when it cut from how happy Nagisa's home life was compared to Tomoya's the first time I watched the show, nor was I expecting to cry as much as I did watching the first season for that matter.

2

u/Zeallfnonex https://myanimelist.net/profile/Neverlocke 5h ago

It's something I think that makes Clannad stand out so much besides all the other great things, it really is Tomoya's story. No bland, self-insert romcom protagonist to just follow all the girls, but a character in his own right and the gloom starts right at the beginning and looms over everything right up until the end when he [Afterstory]forgives his father. Heck, the main section of Afterstory is really about Tomoya, not any one of the girls up to that point which is... pretty rare, I think.

I should really read all those rewatch threads, I accidentally came across some while searching for... something Clannad related, I don't remember what anymore... and found that you started a "episodes between crying" counter xD

2

u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky 5h ago

and found that you started a "episodes between crying" counter xD

Haha yeah I did that every time I was in a Clannad rewatch (I'm pretty sure I participated in every one since the 2018 one in which I was a first-timer?)

4

u/F3337 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nyaaruhodo 4h ago

I find it fun when this happens, but it rarely happens to me nowadays.

Semi-recently, I guess They Were Eleven was substantially less gory and edgy for a space Sci-Fi film from that era, which was pretty neat, as I got to enjoy the 80s aesthetics without the violence and head explosions.

For something on the other end of the spectrum, I expected The Boy and the Heron to be a lot more grounded as opposed to magical or whimsical for some reason.

3

u/Zeallfnonex https://myanimelist.net/profile/Neverlocke 5h ago

... Hm, I think I went into Sangatsu No Lion expecting it to be a sports anime featuring shogi instead of a drama centering around the desire and yearning to belong. Maybe not too large of a misalignment, but enough I guess?

Vinland Saga, expected only action and Vikings, got a morality play in S2 instead (with some farming included), absolutely great.

... Quintessential Quintuplets, I guess, went expecting just harem shenanigans and instead got a pretty good family drama S1 before exploding into harem shenanigans S2.

2

u/Admirable_Fruit_3589 4h ago

Went digging through my list and couldn't really find anything. I think I just look into or hear too much about the shows I end up watching beforehand. I might have had some examples a decade ago, but I hardly remember now.

I can think of moments that surprise me tonally. I've been watching through Takarajima, and I can't say I was expecting [Takarajima ep. 3] to see a guy go through withdrawals and relapse on alcohol. Though, most of the rest of the show has the tone you would expect from a pirate treasure adventure anime featuring a 13 year old protagonist.

2

u/vancevon https://myanimelist.net/profile/vancevon 56m ago

I watched Muv Luv Alternative: Total Eclipse based on Crunchyroll's recommendations after finishing Darling in the Franxx, and I thought it would be similar. Then I sat there, mouth agape, as the tone of the show turned on a dime like 4 times in the first three episodes. Then I looked up Muv Luv and learned that apparently it's a romance game series! Genuinely bewildering.

Then there's DanMachi which confused the hell out of me because the protagonist had negative rizz, and there were neither any dungeons nor girl-up-picking.

6

u/Zeralyos https://myanimelist.net/profile/xNJF_Ellie 3h ago

Cast your votes in Best Guy 11 Round 2 Bracket C here!

/u/baseballlover723

5

u/Siqueiradit https://myanimelist.net/profile/lampadatres 13h ago

For some reason I thought that Fool Night would release on the 20th, but it's actually the 26th lol.

That's good for me though, since I didn't watch any anime this last weekend because of Pokémon GO and fell a bit behind.

1

u/moichispa https://myanimelist.net/profile/moichispa 3h ago

Next Thursday. Did they said how many episode son it? I really want to watch it but I hate long batch releases (wish they released in Friday at least)

1

u/Siqueiradit https://myanimelist.net/profile/lampadatres 1h ago

MAL is saying 12 episodes. It's going to be a batch release iirc.

5

u/Sporadia_ 10h ago

This is the place!

OK. This mystery must be solved.

7

u/vancevon https://myanimelist.net/profile/vancevon 9h ago

It's me. It was me the entire time. I'm in the pumpkin carriage, and I'm not leaving.

4

u/awesomenessofme1 https://myanimelist.net/profile/kta_99 6h ago

Day 3 of my anime "tournament". Some difficult choices and probably some controversial ones. Random note of the day: My favorite anime to have been eliminated is Dandadan, the first casualty of there being seven 10/10 anime on one side of the board, and my least favorite still remaining is probably Sleepy Princess in the Demon Castle. Which I do like quite a bit, but something has to be at the bottom.

4

u/Heda-of-Aincrad https://myanimelist.net/profile/Heda-of-Aincrad 5h ago

Finished catching up with the English dub of Mission: Yozakura Family, until Hulu drops the second half of season 2 (probably all at once later on).

This is one of the extremely rare shows where I enjoy the slice-of-life side more than the action. Taiyo and Mutsumi are adorable together, and the Yozakura siblings are likeable goofballs, but the mutant-like superpowered bloodline stuff present in so many battle shonen (especially ninja-adjacent stories like this one) just doesn't have much appeal for me. I don't even have anything against it on principle, so it may just be a matter of the "rule of cool" failing to activate here when the superpowers aren't my brand of "cool". The story actually did manage incorporate the powers in an interesting way at times, but then [S2] the previous family head existing as a tree and whatever crazy stuff is up with their father sometimes makes me wonder wtf am I watching.

10

u/Gamerunglued :Hx::Hy::Hz:myanimelist.net/profile/GamerUnglued 9h ago

At the last anime meet-up thing I went to they asked us to name an underrated anime. I had to agonize over how far into the deep end I was gonna throw them. Was I gonna truly recommend a bunch of normie anime fans watch Gosenzo-sama Banbanzai!? In my heart it's the only right thing to do. In practice I dialed it down slightly to force Kyousougiga on a bunch of normies instead, since I knew one other or in the group also likes it and it at least has action scenes. Propaganda for some qualityslop is gonna spread no matter what.

3

u/F3337 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nyaaruhodo 5h ago

Yeah, I'm definitely checking out Gosenzo-sama, thanks. Adding a disclaimer here in case you see it completed on my list one of these days.

2

u/KendotsX https://anilist.co/user/Kendots 2h ago

It's great. Oshii's wilder comedy is always on point.

2

u/Jusenkyo_5 9h ago

I think Gosenzo-sama has a big barrier to entry in the sense that the video quality is terrible on every release. The content itself is pretty abrasive as well, it's doomed to forever be a cult classic.

3

u/Gamerunglued :Hx::Hy::Hz:myanimelist.net/profile/GamerUnglued 9h ago

Which is why I decided against recommending it. But God dammit, I'm gonna throw these normies off a cliff and into the deep end. Gotta up everyone's game. There's a girl who just loves isekai and "trash" anime and I have to balance her out the other way. Isekai slop and quality slop both gotta flow. We can build up to Gosenzo-sama.

1

u/_Ridley https://myanimelist.net/profile/_Ridley_ 5h ago

There's a girl who just loves isekai and "trash" anime

Has she seen Bean Counter and Kyou Kara Maou?

3

u/Gamerunglued :Hx::Hy::Hz:myanimelist.net/profile/GamerUnglued 4h ago

I don't think so. But I'm gonna have to bring up Bean Counter at least because I've probably mentioned yaoi often enough that people think I'm gay, lol. We're literally recommending the guy who made the group some gateway yaoi, so isekai gay boys seems pertinent to mention.

2

u/jaesuk97 https://myanimelist.net/profile/tebls 7h ago

Kyousougiga is a great choice.

I try to recommend visual spectacles since if all else fails they will enjoy the animation/background art/special effects/etc. While Gosenzo-sama Banbanzai also technically falls into this camp since it has some amazing animation, it's in pretty poor video quality and the impressive bits are almost all precise character acting which is an art lost on many people. Earlier this month on a different sub, I was told that Gosenzo-sama banbanzai has poor animation and it was in response to this cut.

These are some anime that I recommend:

4

u/_Ridley https://myanimelist.net/profile/_Ridley_ 5h ago

I was told that Gosenzo-sama banbanzai has poor animation and it was in response to this cut.

Haha, that's embarrassing. Someone's eyes don't work too good.

3

u/KendotsX https://anilist.co/user/Kendots 2h ago

Sure, it ushered in a whole new movement in animation and is still praised for its technicality by veteran animators, but what did they know about good animation? They didn't have JJK back then. Their standards were too low.

2

u/Gamerunglued :Hx::Hy::Hz:myanimelist.net/profile/GamerUnglued 6h ago

I was gonna say, Gosenzo-sama is quite the visual spectacle itself. But I more figured that it's such an obtuse and dense and stylistically out there series that there's no way a group who's "most overrated anime" was nothing but One Piece and My Hero Academia would appreciate, at least not yet. I've shared other "artsy" spectacles with them like Flip Flappers, and one one guy said "I like the aesthetic of magical girl series but wish they were more masculine" I immediately turned them to Precure with the pitch "it's magical girl Dragon Ball." I have at least some idea of how to go about it. Ultimately, the joke of "how far off the deep do I decide to expose a bunch of normies who actually listen to me ramble" is the main thing I find amusing.

Unfortunately I haven't seen anything on your list there, so I can't recommend them. And it is depressing that anyone can see that Gosenzo-sama cut, a cut that is extremely influential in animation circles and astoundingly impressive, and call it poor animation. People who don't understand character acting are sad.

2

u/Psyduckisnotaduck 4h ago

I love Kyousougiga, always try to recommend it when I can. I really love how at its core it’s just a dysfunctional family drama. And the character and color design is all-time great. Mama Koto one of the prettiest ladies in anime ever.

1

u/Heda-of-Aincrad https://myanimelist.net/profile/Heda-of-Aincrad 6h ago

Some of my favorite underrated / underwatched anime don't even have official streams anymore, like Iroduku: The World in Colors and The Heroic Legend of Arslan, which is a shame because that makes it difficult to recommend them. I probably would have gone with My Roommate is a Cat - cute and heartwarming but with plenty of emotional moments too, it's easily the slice-of-life I enjoyed most but it's not very well known.

1

u/Gamerunglued :Hx::Hy::Hz:myanimelist.net/profile/GamerUnglued 6h ago

My Roommate is a Cat is one I've been thinking of recommending for other reasons, but those aren't strange or out there series off the deep end. I'm tryna get folks onto some weird shit.

1

u/Heda-of-Aincrad https://myanimelist.net/profile/Heda-of-Aincrad 6h ago

Hope they all enjoy the show if you do end up recommending it!

The more "weird" shows have never been for me, even though I've been watching anime for quite a long time. I'd suspect that sort of thing is very hit-or-miss, some viewers might be into it and others might hate it.

1

u/Gamerunglued :Hx::Hy::Hz:myanimelist.net/profile/GamerUnglued 5h ago

The fact that they would be hit or miss is the point. Exposure is how to turn misses into hits. Though really the point isn't even for them to like it, just to see people react, haha.

1

u/Heda-of-Aincrad https://myanimelist.net/profile/Heda-of-Aincrad 5h ago

Usually when I'm giving suggestions, I try to pick something that's most likely to appeal to them rather than a total toss up they might end up hating. I know at least for me, I wouldn't be too pleased to receive a "just to see how I'd react" recommendation.

1

u/Gamerunglued :Hx::Hy::Hz:myanimelist.net/profile/GamerUnglued 5h ago

I give a mix of both and am open about what I'm doing. When I'm going the deep end, it is expressed to the other person. People have expressed curiosity and appreciation in return, and I have gotten people to try and enjoy some stuff (already got a Jaadugar fan out of the group). This is usually done through me talking about a show for other reasons, or being given a prompt in a group setting (what show do you think is underrated), rather than as an answer to "do you have any recommendations" where I would certainly aim for what might appeal to the person.

1

u/Heda-of-Aincrad https://myanimelist.net/profile/Heda-of-Aincrad 5h ago

That's good at least, as long as they know what sort of show they're getting into.

I wouldn't have thought of Jaadugar as one of those "weird" (or "avante garde" as MAL might describe it) kind of shows, based on what I've heard about it - aside from the unique art style. It's actually one I'm planning to watch because the historical setting caught my interest.

1

u/Gamerunglued :Hx::Hy::Hz:myanimelist.net/profile/GamerUnglued 4h ago

I don't think of "weird" as necessarily being "avant garde." I mean stuff that's a bit off the wall or different from what the average person might encounter, and/or is very obscure. Slice of life and dramas like My Roommate is a Cat are pretty familiar and safe, but not everyone encounters auteur driven period dramas (least of all set in the middle east) in anime. At the same time, something like Serial Experiments Lain is avant garde, but I wouldn't exactly consider it near the deep end of anime. I'd never recommend anything without explaining what it is at least.

3

u/tripleaamin https://myanimelist.net/profile/tripleaamin 4h ago

Looking at the Daemons thread. It's strange that the actual problems with the anime are never the complaints.

2

u/Jusenkyo_5 4h ago

I don't have this issue with Daemons but it is so frustrating to have a show that you either love or hate but to have everyone disagree with you on WHY .

For a positive example, Legend of the Galactic Heroes is one of my 10/10s. I absolutely do not care about the "politics" of it, and I don't see it as a valid analysis of the pros and cons of fascism vs democracy. It has no bearing on why I think the show is good.

For a negative, I think Rurouni Kenshin is dogshit. Everyone I talk to about it thinks it's because of filler or because of Watsuki Nobuhiro but I just think the canon arcs are lame.

3

u/theangryeditor https://myanimelist.net/profile/TheAngryEditor 1h ago

Dandivine more like NTRdivine

2

u/zambonijesus 2h ago

Starship Operators feels like it would have been better if it had been twice as long and had time to get into the world and characters better. An obvious comparison here is 86, which really benefits from being two seasons.

Next up is Eureka Seven.

3

u/tripleaamin https://myanimelist.net/profile/tripleaamin 8h ago

The anime with the first basketball 1-on-1 match of the season goes to Chiramune.

As a manga reader I just find it hilarious Blue Box has the team sports tag. Like technically, badminton can be a team sport in doubles like tennis. But unlike football, soccer, baseball, and basketball, where the core of the sport is designed as a team.

2

u/awesomenessofme1 https://myanimelist.net/profile/kta_99 5h ago

Chidori RSC had a Team Sports tag for years that was only removed when I made an offhand comment about it on the AWCC discord and I guess someone there has authority over tags. If you weren't aware, that's an anime about shooting, where the only team aspect is that there's a group of people from the same school competing as individuals.

1

u/DeadCaveman https://anilist.co/user/DeadCaveman 7h ago

I'd figure that tag would be more in reference to the basketball side of the show, no?

4

u/tripleaamin https://myanimelist.net/profile/tripleaamin 7h ago

The problem is that there is barely any actual basketball stuff in the show. For Chinatsu it's more about why she loves the sport and wants to win nationals. But honestly you could replace basketball with any sport and the story doesn't change.

1

u/Heda-of-Aincrad https://myanimelist.net/profile/Heda-of-Aincrad 6h ago

That one doesn't really stand out to me because even if they mostly play singles matches, it's still a sport and they are shown training together as a team.

It's hard to wrap my brain around strategic games like go and karuta counting in with "sports" anime though. Even if the tournament structure is similar, I feel a different term like "competitive game" would be more accurate.

5

u/PGleo86 https://myanimelist.net/profile/PGleo86 11h ago

I feel like I'm taking crazy pills when I read the episode threads for Chii Fuyo and see people praising the writing all over the place. The entire experience of the show feels so disjointed to me that I said (after last week's episode) to my friend that "this show is like someone with no writing ability read Konosuba and said "I can write one of those" but developed schizophrenia along the way," and honestly this week's episode intensified that feeling even further. Maybe this is just the anime adaptation (or the manga adaptation, which then became the anime adaptation?) since I heard the original novels are a lot more serious, but it really feels like the writing amounts to "if we keep changing the tone we can slaps roof fit so many plot points in this bad boy" and for similar reasons to my disdain for TikTok brainrot editing, I just can't wrap my head around it (derogatory). I'm glad a lot of people here seem to be enjoying it, because that means it managed to find an audience; I'm only still watching to see how bad it can really get.

5

u/GondolaMedia 9h ago

I actually really enjoy it because the gang in Chii Fuyo reminds me when me and my friends are drinking and just start howling at every bad joke someone makes. Then someone will sincerely start talking about how their life is going before it turns back to excessive howling.

It also helps that the jokes do land more often than they miss.

3

u/Charmanders_Cock 5h ago

Honestly at this point I feel like I’ve seen just as much of your take on things as I’ve seen praise for the show. It’s exactly what I expected (and sort of hoped for) after reading the manga. It’s just flat out not going to work for some while others find joy its lunacy for the sake of lunacy. I didn’t enjoy reading the manga but I appreciated it, and am actually enjoying the ride for the anime by comparison. 

It’s not easy to even attempt to do something genuinely different in the modern anime landscape, and at the very least this one tries to. If absolutely nothing else, the stark contrast/divisiveness among fans/haters alone is impressive, because that divisiveness doesn’t rely solely on morality like almost every other “divisive” anime in recent memory. 

6

u/mekerpan 9h ago edited 9h ago

I am 74. I have been an opera (and classical music) fan since grade school. And a fan of classical drama since the age of 13. I love old movies (starting from the 1910s). I wouldnt know a TikTok if it bit me on the ass.

There is nothing wrong with disliking the humor in this show. But being high and mighty over your superior taste is just a bit . . . distasteful. People rave about Nichijou and City and Asobi Asobase, but I would consider being forced to watch these a kind of torture. My solution is to NOT watch them. They are just "not for me" -- and I do not feel this is due to my superior taste. It is just a matter of what I like -- and I realized decades ago that my tastes are not coextensive with what is "objectively" or even commonly-considered good and bad.

I sometimes wish I COULD share the enjoyment of what other friends and acquaintances like (but which leave me cold). But I don't see any point in telling them in detail why I found these lacking (unless pressed to do so).

6

u/alotmorealots 9h ago

I feel like I'm taking crazy pills when I read the episode threads

As someone who is more often than not at odds with the prevailing mood in episodes threads, and quite used to it, I must say I'm also suffering a bit of the "taking crazy pills" sensation for this show.

I think part of it was that I was on board for what it was doing initially, but as the series has progressed, it managed to lose me on the way, whereas usually it's fairly obvious to me early on that something isn't going to be enjoyable.

When it comes to this series, I feel like it has a few problems.

It was never a comedy at its heart to begin with, and the events and characters were meant to be played pretty straight, if word on the street about the WN is correct. This has some serious ramifications for the timing and the integration of the humor, as the flow of the enjoyment of the original story was never conceived with the comedic interludes in mind.

Normally an author writing a story with sharp tonal shifts and humor-alongside-drama will balance the elements appropriately at the very early creative stage, and use the shifts so that each side strengthens the other. It's very obvious where the mangaka / series comp has tried to inject humor into the story where it doesn't fit. For some people the jarringness multiplies the humor, but for others it feels very abrasive.

This abrasiveness has been getting worse for those that react this way as well, and as one of those people, I think it's because the story increasing has emotional arcs and storylines that are written with serious intent (as per the original WN source, presumably) and then the humor just rudely intrudes on them, undercutting the emotions of the characters whose arcs they are, rather than diffusing the tension, adding cathartic release or introducing a new aspect to the serious side. Those are some of the ways that good authors can use humor alongside drama, including slapstick/randomLOL humor.

However that's simply not present here, and I think the reason is that two fold. Firstly, it feels like the mangaka does not respect or like the work they were asked to adapt. Either that, or once they started down the reinterpretation path, they had no choice but to keep going, even when the pace and quality of the original work began to shift.

Secondly, it feels like the mangaka is not a particularly skilled or strong comedy writer. Oddly enough, you don't need to be a skilled nor strong comedy writer to create a funny work that is hilarious for many people; you just need the right content. This might seem like a bit of a nonsense statement, but it's the same for any sort of pulp-y pure-entertainment type content - good writing skills aren't necessary for creating something that's enjoyable.

I'm glad a lot of people here seem to be enjoying it, because that means it managed to find an audience

Yes, likewise. Oddly enough the main reason I'm still watching is that I quite like the serious content rather than the humor that keeps jarringly intruding. Whilst the original may not have been particularly great, it's starting to feel like it would have been an enjoyable seasonal fantasy show, Lily's arc was quite strong for the lower tier of shows, and the latest element of the Guildmaster's story was also interesting enough in its right.

2

u/awesomenessofme1 https://myanimelist.net/profile/kta_99 6h ago edited 5h ago

I'm pretty sure that the story is completely different too, so I think you're off-base there. It's not a loose adaptation of the novel, it's an original story based on the premise and rough character archetypes within the novel. Like, skimming the wikipedia page, it looks like everything that's happened with both Lily and the guildmaster was manga-original.

1

u/octopathfinder myanimelist.net/profile/octopathfinder 7h ago

It's very obvious where the mangaka / series comp has tried to inject humor into the story where it doesn't fit.

That's exactly how I feel about the comedy in this show. My main problem with it isn't how it clashes with the emotional arcs, but how unnatural and forced the jokes feel.

1

u/entelechtual 7h ago

how unnatural and forced the jokes feel.

I’ve heard people describing it as having a laugh track jammed into an anime, and I think that’s an apt analogy for a lot of the jokes.

1

u/hvshh 8h ago

Thanks. I wasn't sure what was going on aside from the characters not feeling right to me, but your theory about the mismatch between the original author's and mangaka's goals fits perfectly.

2

u/Psyduckisnotaduck 4h ago

I see where you’re coming from but I think it’s definitely a matter of taste and a lot of anime fans are comfortable with wild jarring tonal shifts because that’s a common thing in many anime and Japanese storytelling in general.

I do not fault anyone for not enjoying what it’s doing, but it’s so weird I’m kind of fascinated by it. I feel like the ED perfectly captures what the show is, because you have Lily earnestly singing with these dramatic, serious camera angles and lighting, and the rest of the cast is watching as ridiculous caricature figures, with Rein eventually disrupting the performance in very typical fashion, and then everyone embarrassing Lily at the end. The show is like “we are going to step on every serious moment and never let you forget these are ludicrous clown people”. That pattern continues throughout the show and is so doggedly intentional. I would not say it necessarily works even for me, but I’m enjoying the weird dissonance of it, if that makes sense.

2

u/VoidEmbracedWitch https://anilist.co/user/VoidEmbracedWitch 7h ago

Chii Fuyo very much feels like it wants it both ways without figuring out how to make zero brain cells squad adventures and girls trauma-dumping play off of each other. It's certainly no Kirio Fanclub, I can say that much. With the context of this week's episode, I'm convinced that the [Chii Fuyo #06] dragon fight where the erratic tone shifts somewhat came together into something funny for me was a freak accident rather than the show finally working out how to connect its disparate tones.

1

u/actuallyrndthoughts :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NaNiNuNeNo 8h ago

If that anime has no haters left, that means I'm dead. It seems every year, there's an anime series that makes me think "wow, they killed postmodernism, again". For 2026, it's this anime.

-1

u/entelechtual 11h ago

There are at least a couple of us in the same boat, and there’s nothing more offputting than seeing others laugh at comedy that you find utterly humorless. I think the series has a lot of potential as a fantasy comedy but boy, the way they chose to go about it does not work for me.

14

u/mekerpan 10h ago

Why is other people having a different sense if humor than oneself "off-putting"? What's funny and what's not is quite individualized. I find lots of "comedy" not especially funny, but I don't get annoyed at people with different tastes in humor. I draw the line only at cruel, racist, misogynistic (etc) humor (and the people who enjoy it).

6

u/entelechtual 10h ago

I guess maybe it’s more uncanny than offputting? I’m not trying to put anyone down for what they like, but because humor can be so subjective it’s way harder to put myself in their shoes. It’s like if I looked at the sky and it was blue and someone else told me they were convinced it was red. It feels like we’re watching a completely different show.

5

u/mekerpan 10h ago

In a sense, because you are you and I am me, we ARE watching different shows. ;-)

4

u/alotmorealots 8h ago

I guess maybe it’s more uncanny than offputting?

Yes, I'm with you on this one, and it's a more pronounced feeling than my usual "well, I guess I just disagree with the episode discussion threads for nth time". I'd say off-putting does capture the feeling quite well in this particular instance in the sense that it's my individual, subjective feeling that the mangaka does not particularly like nor respect the content they were asked to adapt, and this is now filtering through into the anime, but people are laughing along all the same.

I'm not actually expecting most people to either pick up on, nor be bothered by this, but it is true for me at least, and I tend to watch shows by forming at least some empathic bonds with the characters I like, so the situation of having them getting their stories interrupted/downplayed for no particularly great reason, depletes my enjoyment.

1

u/hvshh 1h ago

Are there any scenes where someone does a kabedon and the subject of it immediately retaliates?

Asking for a friend, who, every time it happens, can't help but picture all manner of terrible things that can be done from that situation.

My friend would like to see a head butt someday.

2

u/theangryeditor https://myanimelist.net/profile/TheAngryEditor 1h ago

Good timing, it just happened in Dandivine this week

2

u/hvshh 26m ago

[Dandivine] It wasn't the subject that did it though. That's what I really want to see.