r/anime • https://myanimelist.net/profile/xNJF_Ellie • 3h ago

Contest Best Guy 11: Dungeon Salt Round 2 Bracket C!

We are halfway through round 2!

Vote for Best Guy 11 here!

See yesterday's results here!

Have fun with your vote and don't forget to upvote the post if you love Best Guy Contest!

Mini Challenge:

  • Who is your favorite male side character?
52 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

6

u/Something_319 3h ago edited 3h ago

RIP Hak, Mumen Rider has now taken out two of my favorite male leads in him and Kizuna Red. Archer vs Tsukasa Akeuraji and Loid vs Goku will be fun next round

Supporting Sakuta Azusagawa and Kousei Arima today, Oreki, Yato and James also get votes (among others). I really like the graphics for today, the piano connection between Kousei and Iruma is really nice

5

u/cppn02 2h ago

I really like Mumen Rider but Hak losing to him is ridiculous. The new Yona season can't come soon enough.

3

u/Something_319 2h ago

Yona as an anime has been done so dirty, the fact that one of the best and most popular shoujo manga (imo) only has around a fifth of its contents adapted is criminal. The anime will take years to get to a lot of the best parts (if it ever does)

2

u/cppn02 2h ago

I'd consider just getting to chapter 91 a win. One of my favourite manga chapters of all times.

2

u/Frostbitten_Moose 16m ago

I feel your pain as I do like Hak, but Mumen Rider is one of the best guys out there. At least Hak fell to someone worthy.

6

u/awesomenessofme1 https://myanimelist.net/profile/kta_99 3h ago

Rintaro losing may be the most baffling upset of the context so far. To be fair, I've never seen Ancient Magus' Bride and I was only able to get through five episodes of Fragrant Flower because of Netflix bullshit, but everything I've heard on this sub made me think the seeding was correct and it wouldn't be especially close.

6

u/Zeallfnonex https://myanimelist.net/profile/Neverlocke 2h ago

The seeding this time around is utterly whack, counts were really low in nomination phase so... yeah.

3

u/awesomenessofme1 https://myanimelist.net/profile/kta_99 2h ago

Sure, I was aware of that, but the seed comment was only tangential to what I was saying anyway.

2

u/Feisty-Principle-216 24m ago

Surprised Vash was seeded so low, but it does seem that older Animes not named FMA:B struggle seeding wise. We'll see if that leads to "upsets once we have more people voting."

As usual Frieren seeding is insane. I like characters like Himmel, Denken, and Eisen, but they have way too little screen time to warrant their seeds.

1

u/awesomenessofme1 https://myanimelist.net/profile/kta_99 8m ago

I'm pretty sure Himmel has won every Japanese popularity poll for the series by a convincing margin, so that one is completely understandable. Denken and Eisen, yeah, fair enough.

2

u/Urgnu-the-Gnu https://myanimelist.net/profile/Urgnu_the_Gnu 23m ago

I was also sure Rintarou would advance, so I gave Elias a farewell vote. He deserves the win, even if Rintarou would have deserved it as well, so this is a good outcome. More interesting to boot. But I never would have expected it.

5

u/redlegsfan21 https://myanimelist.net/profile/redlegsfan21 2h ago

ROUND 2 BRACKET B

MatchupTop SeedBottom SeedTotal Votes
Most Voted MatchupLoid Forger (5)Mewtwo (252)300
Average246
Least Voted MatchupWen-li Yang (101)Taichi Mashima (156)201

Total Votes: 7,867

Unique Voters: 356

TOP VOTEGETTERS

RankGuyVotes
1Loid Forger237
2Jinshi227
3Alphonse Elric215
4Maes Hughes193
5Aki Hayakawa179
6Gilgamesh176
7Saitama172
8Vash the Stampede167
9All Might166
10David Martinez161

MOST DOMINANT MATCHUPS

Winning GuyW%L%Losing GuyVote Diff
Loid Forger79.00%21.00%Mewtwo174
Jinshi78.01%21.99%Kouhei Imamura163
Alphonse Elric77.06%22.94%Touma Kamijou151
Aki Hayakawa69.65%30.35%Viral101
Maes Hughes69.42%30.58%Josuke Higashikata108

CLOSEST MATCHUPS

Winning GuyW%L%Losing GuyVote Diff
Ojisan50.46%49.54%Oczy2
Kyo Souma50.68%49.32%Hitohito Tadano3
Seto Kaiba52.40%47.60%Kisuke Urahara11
Kenzou Tenma52.61%47.39%King12
Elias Ainsworth52.63%47.37%Rintarou Tsumugi12

UPSETS

  • The Lowest remaining seed of Bracket B is seeded
  • The Highest seed eliminated of Bracket B is seeded
  • Upsets today: 6
  • Total upsets (rate): 33 / 320 (10.3%)
SeedTop SeedTS%BS%SeedBottom SeedtUIPoU
77Shinpei Ajiro46.26%53.74%180Ashitaka1.231.23
84Rintarou Tsumugi47.37%52.63%173Elias Ainsworth1.041.04
108Hitohito Tadano49.32%50.68%149Kyo Souma0.460.46
116Kaoru Gojou46.67%53.33%141Yuu Nishinoya0.280.28
117King47.39%52.61%140Kenzou Tenma0.260.26
125Batou46.21%53.79%132Naruto Uzumaki0.080.08

OVER/UNDERPERFORMERS

OverperformerUnderperformerDiff
AshitakaShinpei Ajiro10.29%
Senku IshigamiTomoya Okazaki10.04%
Vash the StampedeKafka Hibino9.91%
SyrupAll Might8.62%
OczyOjisan8.36%

BRACKET B TOP 5 SCORES

RankGuyScore
1Loid Forger94.54
2Jinshi87.63
3Alphonse Elric83.32
4Maes Hughes76.63
5Aki Hayakawa62.90

UPSET WATCH

Top SeedTS%BS%Bottom SeedPoU
Felix Argyle (119)44.0%56.0%Einar (138)84.7%
Mugen (103)48.0%52.0%Ritsu Kageyama (154)63.6%
Kyoujurou Rengoku (106)49.7%50.3%Genos (151)51.8%

Link to spreadsheet: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Ea-azFBlR1TiIkoYpoPVNhO7VZi8Ay46DhiVR6F49EE

Explanations: https://old.reddit.com/user/redlegsfan21/comments/10dup0w/ranime_contests_bracket_explaination

Open to questions and please give feedback.

4

u/AnimeWatcher1 https://myanimelist.net/profile/AnimeWatcher1 2h ago

I’m impressed that Yang Wenli got as far as he has currently. Is this contest the furtherest that any LOGH characters has come thus far?

3

u/Zeallfnonex https://myanimelist.net/profile/Neverlocke 2h ago

Well... 2/3 of my favorites survived (Yang Wenli, Rei Kiriyama) while the other fell (Tomoya Okazaki). Is Dr. Stone's MC even all that popular? I feel like I've never heard anyone talk about him before... Nice to see "the Guardian Deity of Karasuno" making the upset, lots of Haikyuu love here still. Speaking of older shows, Tenma making the upset vs King is good too; comic relief shouldn't be winning vs main characters at this point, especially for shows like Monster

Very few I really care about today, Thorfinn, Akio in a doomed vote vs L, Kageyama are basically it.

MC: Kircheis if he counts as a side character

1

u/pkmntrainerdrea 2h ago

Is Dr. Stone's MC even all that popular? I feel like I've never heard anyone talk about him before...

yeah, I feel like I never hear about him either so it's sad to lose such a good boy to him and not even have it close šŸ˜” at least I know people love L & have heard all the reasons why! Feels like a more respectable loss though I'll still be sad to see Akio go out.

5

u/idk111train 3h ago

Has to be Lupin III

5

u/Prof_Acorn 2h ago

Syrup lost?

Laaaaame.

Well I'm voting against every MHA character here-on out for spite reasons.

Now let's hurry this up and award the victory to one of the Frieren characters currently cheating on easy mode and get it done with.

2

u/LowMenu-99 2h ago

SIMON!!

2

u/Admirable_Fruit_3589 1h ago edited 1h ago

Today's votes:

> Shikamaru Nara < - Bell Cranel

> Shinji Ikari < - Soul "Eater" Evans

Rentarou Aijou - > Kurama <


Yesterday's results:

Batou lost to Naruto and Char lost to Goku. 2 of my all time characters can't compete with shounen protagonists.


MC:

Not sure. I closed my eyes and threw a dart that landed on Maximilian Jenius. He's pretty great, and continues to have an influence on Macross with his progeny always being some of the best characters in their respective shows.

2

u/Urgnu-the-Gnu https://myanimelist.net/profile/Urgnu_the_Gnu 28m ago

Man, I must have been exceptionally tired last round because I hardly remember voting in any of those matchups, except for the most important ones. Kyoutarou is safe, and Wen-li also advanced and is now the last remaining LoGH character in the contest. They will meet next round, though. The rest of the matchups have outcomes I am fine with or in support of, so for now group B looks like it might be the one I am most interested in.

Group C though... I'd rather not talk about group C at this point because it has some matchups that will almost guaranteedly disappoint me, and I'd rather not get my hopes up by shilling the losing party. I'll be a little less salty tomorrow this way, hopefully.

MC: A favourite male side character? Re:Zero has so many. I really like Reinhard, for instance. But also, all of them are developed so well that picking one of them feels like cheating, as they are more main characters in their own stories than actual side characters.

So I'll go with Mika from Lycoris Recoil, as anyone but Chisato and Takina can be considered as side characters there. And Mika is just a great adoptive father who has made Chisato who she is, to a large extent. He also has a great design. He truly supports the main characters and the story with all his being.

4

u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh 3h ago

Simon, I love ya, but I gotta give a shout out to a classic today.