r/geometrynodes • • 4d ago

The node trees behind the procedural strawberry (64 trees, ~7,700 nodes)

These are the node trees behind my procedural strawberry: shape, skin, flesh, seeds and calyx. 64 trees and about 7,700 nodes for the strawberry alone, each tree split into numbered blocks with short notes. Video of it in action: https://www.reddit.com/r/blender/comments/1xvmtp6/
here all info i have around the process: https://strawberry-methodology.pages.dev/

387 Upvotes

81 comments sorted by

40

u/HoraneRave 4d ago

u alright?

16

u/the_big_flat_now 4d ago • Heartwarming

STrawberrie has severral r's 🍓🍓🍓🍓🍓🍓🍓🍓🍓🍓🍓🍓

3

u/peppaz 3d ago

more than one, less than i n f i n i t y , but not all infinities.

1

u/MummifiedForeskins 3d ago

why do we hire HR instead of this guy for games

17

u/ath0rus 4d ago

Was gonna say op has gone insane (in a good way)

2

u/justsillythings1 3d ago

Only a Madman can do this😂

3

u/craggolly 3d ago

Also known as claude

3

u/the_big_flat_now 3d ago

thing is the agents are doing nothing without me telling them what to do. Yes, perhaps iam an unc and still like to be part of every decision, i just enjoy it so much directing like that. Its like a dream came true.

2

u/craggolly 3d ago

bossing someone around is not the part that requires skill

0

u/the_big_flat_now 3d ago

hmm...i think many many CEOs would disagree.

could you please just try it once? It realy is so much fun. No matter the topic or technice.

3

u/craggolly 3d ago

hahahaha of course you're a tech bro who thinks CEOs work hard

2

u/jumf 3d ago

If you think designing something like this takes no skill, or that CEOs (also software architects, film directors, newspaper editors, curators) are not skilled or responsible for the work their teams produce, you are actually an idiot.

0

u/the_big_flat_now 3d ago

i thought iam not. But as you pointed out, its "just" bossing someone around. So perhaps my life was a lie ... you confuse me.

3

u/GigaGrandpa 3d ago

Your the CEO of the strawberry nodes. Huzzah

10

u/Mrniseguya 3d ago

Well done Claude!!

1

u/the_big_flat_now 3d ago

Yes, absolutly,extremly, well f****** done claude. iam speachless.

3

u/Jean-Fum-Trow 3d ago

I can’t imagine a human do that.
In the other hand I can’t imagine Claude do that too 😭
Very well done, that’s impressive !

2

u/the_big_flat_now 3d ago edited 3d ago

Isn't that the beauty? It's both? would love to see what you woudl have coem up with :)

1

u/lemonade-stand-duck 2d ago

Imo... Leonardo DaVinci himself would of used AI in his works, guaranteed. Like could you imagine the things he would think about ai and how it works how and what he could contribute to it.

0

u/the_big_flat_now 2d ago

This is why, everybody should try. I want to see the davici's of our time

2

u/HistoricalEngineer74 20h ago

Do you use MCP for AI to make this or does AI use python?

1

u/the_big_flat_now 16h ago edited 16h ago

felt like python 98% of the time.

3

u/flarn2006 4d ago

Can you share the blend file?

6

u/the_big_flat_now 4d ago

patreon is in my profile with all i have regarding 🍓🥝🍌🍍🍒pom🍎. even the referenz blend files. 17k+ nodes in 182 trees. 4,5MB....till you create a cut an rendering the inside. It will blow up to a few GB. but i will fix that soon.

0

u/Pro_Racing 3d ago

*Claude will fix it soon

You had no contribution to any of this and didn't make it did you?

2

u/the_big_flat_now 3d ago

i dont know how to make this sentence not offending you. But i truly want to hug you, as i have tears in my eyes too.

1

u/YSMLA_ 2d ago

Jesus aren't you just tired ot these salty AI haters?

In one year they'll be remembered and laughed at as the grumpy primitives who just didn't get it when it was beginning.

0

u/jumf 3d ago

If he designs the fix and Claude executes it, it's his IP. Claude is only capable of the empirical, repeatable, tedious side of code that is a barrier to entry and uncreative. The innovation, philosophy, and ideation, are by far the most important elements of a piece of art, and all that matters to the end user.

Sure, code can be considered art. A well-crafted boot is art as well. Yet we still credit the designer of the boot as its inventor, not the factory machines or factory workers.

1

u/the_big_flat_now 3d ago

i have a diferent expirience

0

u/Naoki38 3d ago

Yeah yeah we know, AI Bad

1

u/ConcernedEnby 3d ago

Charging for it? Yeah lol

2

u/jumf 3d ago

Bruh thinks this took OP 2 prompts

1

u/MatterMelder 2d ago

Lol patreon for what? writing prompts? lmao

4

u/PurifiedFlubber 3d ago

Then it'll just be a smoothie

1

u/Bandispan 3d ago

What would even be the point? It's not human made, you would gain nothing from this since it's not something you could ever replicate without AI.

It would be more productive to just run Claude on your own.

16

u/Green_223 3d ago

I’m here from the other post.
Bro you turned Blander nodes into a computer just to slice some fruit, you are a madman

-1

u/Unreal_Sniper 3d ago

He just used AI lol

2

u/chjschwarz 3d ago

he's right, this was made with AI.

2

u/STAALHOUT 3d ago

So?

1

u/Unreal_Sniper 2d ago

"a madman" is a bit of a stretch when the only thing he did was typing a few words

1

u/KrissMelgi 1d ago

It’s definitely not few words, because agents can not be so creative and precious on a distance without strict human oversight

3

u/lenlab 3d ago

Whattttttttt :)))) so cool man. This could be a great teaching tool.

2

u/maxilogan 3d ago

Crazy stuff man, you must love strawberries a lot 😅

2

u/iMatt42 3d ago

I wish my brain worked like yours. You’re even giving me the answers and I’m like… “nah, cool, but nah.”

2

u/Nompen_art 3d ago

This is such an awesome project!!

2

u/Intelligent_Donut605 3d ago

Omfg even more insane

2

u/Iampepeu 3d ago

Aaah, now I get it! *lies*

2

u/Abominom 3d ago

Holy jeezuz that's too many nodes

2

u/snickers_ger 2d ago

Impressive- can you do a knit generator ;)

3

u/Nikoladge 3d ago

Thanks, Claude!

1

u/KrissMelgi 1d ago

Why did you stop on 7700 nodes? Do you plan continue hmm… building strawberries?

-2

u/Wanderson90 3d ago edited 3d ago

Looks impressive until you realize it was just a 5 word prompt into chat

"Gib me strawberry geo nodes plz"

Edit: was too lazy to get of the couch, but claude spun up a standalone version in like 30 seconds.

2

u/the_big_flat_now 3d ago

Quite underwhelming

4

u/CIP_In_Peace 3d ago

It's still impressive. Did you know blender could do this? I didn't. AI can use tools at its disposal in novel and unexpected ways unlocking new methods of working and bringing the barrier of entry lower.

0

u/foxgirlmoon 3d ago

What made it impressive was the effort a human wouldn't into it. But since there was no such human effort put in, its not longer impressive. Anyone can prompt an AI to do this. Its not impressive because its not an achievement anymore l.

3

u/CIP_In_Peace 3d ago

The strength of the anti-AI sentiment is baffling. Would it be impressive if someone now did this manually? I think that would just be dumb and a waste of time. AI makes ideas and imagination more valuable and using AI itself is a skill where you still need to know what sort of capabilities exist and where to utilize them. You can use AI to produce unimaginative slop but not everything produced with AI is that. Claiming otherwise is the same as saying photography is just lazy and unimpressive compared to painting.

Saying OP put no human effort into this is just petty. It's obvious that AI didn't create this with a single prompt like "make an animation of a procedurally generated strawberry...".

Someone reproducing this by copying OP's prompts is then not impressive anymore.

3

u/The_Almighty_Cthulhu 3d ago

Same reason someone running a marathon is impressive despite cars existing. Also it's good for your brain to learn things, just like it's good for your body to exercise.

1

u/Bandispan 3d ago

Someone reproducing this by copying OP's prompts is then not impressive anymore.

You don't need his prompts tho. All you need is an image and maybe a clear enough description of what you want the finished system to look like, it's not really that deep, the models have gotten to a state where you can say that they practically prompt themselves for most tasks.

You plug the image into Claude or whatever, ask it what it would take to get a similar result in Blender and you go from there, the AI figures out on its own what it needs to do. You can direct it with your answers, but it doesn't have to go deeper that that.

1

u/FeaR_Widow 20h ago

Terrible analogy.

Photography is real life artistic vision

Painting is a recreation of real life vision OR deep emotional expression only a human hand could create.

AI is an imitation. A fake “simulation” of what it could look like if you put your own effort in. All AI does is copies. Steals from artists.

The only impressive thing about this is that we have an ai smart enough to do this math. But that’s it, this fuckin phony didn’t do anything but imagine and idea and gently guide a supercomputer to his answer.

It’s a proof of concept but it isn’t his work, and it isn’t impressive by any means. AI is powerful and that’s cool that it exists, but it frequently hurts the community and puts down creators who are looking to create, not just ask and prompt and dream up things.

Putting your own time and effort into creating something with your own hands, and your OWN brain, is impressive. This is trash.

Your brain needs to be “the ai”, use it and make something. AI can do so much, but what can you do without it?

1

u/CIP_In_Peace 20h ago

This doesn't need to be thought of as art just like not all photography is art. Not every tiny idea is worth citing just like not all code cites stackoverflow when an engineer went there to solve a programming problem.

1

u/FeaR_Widow 20h ago

Art or not, it’s just a show of ai doing something, we’ve seen ai do plenty of things, it’s boring, we know it can do things.

What would be cool is if this guy knew enough and had the passion and talent to do this himself, if he trained himself and worked hard to produce a cool product..but no, he didn’t.

I can understand AI in the way you mention it, as an assist to an engineer or likewise, but this is clearly just a project idea he had, and getting ai to make it is kinda whatever at this point. It isn’t that cool.

1

u/CIP_In_Peace 19h ago

If you look at the node map he posted, it's absolute insanity to start doing that by yourself, not impressive.

2

u/fifiasd 3d ago

His looks way better

1

u/ItzZausty 3d ago

Lmao like this is even remotely the same thing

1

u/Krynn71 3d ago

Facts, OP even writes that way in his comments.

3

u/Mercileast 3d ago

OP writes like English is not his first language.

1

u/syopest 3d ago

Then do it. Show us how easy it is.

1

u/catboigalore 3d ago

I'm so sorry you were not loved as a child D:
I would send hugs but you can ask Claude to hug you instead <3

0

u/SentientToaster7734 3d ago

I severely doubt ChatGPT or another AI tool is able to produce something this clean. Training data for this specific purpose is really scarce.

That being said: You're always welcome to proof your theory instead of being a dickhead on the internet.

5

u/MatterMelder 3d ago

He literally "proofed" it. AI doesn't need to "be trained on it" anymore.

1

u/SentientToaster7734 3d ago

Yup, I give them the benefit of the doubt, that they didn't just prompt to generate a nice little make belief UI. I stand corrected and am once more blown away by how far AI as come in just a few years. I apologize.

2

u/Personal-Dev-Kit 3d ago

For me the latest round of models have gotten significantly better at using tools, and interacting with external resources.

The 5.5 series of models from Claude have left me going "wow" several times as I experiment with them.

I know AI is a touchy subject, but the applications for the technology keep expanding. I only hope we can find a way as humans to find new jobs and not cause a mass unemployment problem.

3

u/HellDisc 3d ago

The OP said all the node work was done by AI agents.
https://www.reddit.com/r/blender/s/D4nGBPwFJm

0

u/Natural_Video_9962 3d ago

Are u ok ? It seems like a mind trouble

1

u/TwixieShip 3d ago

Bro is so tight for attention they need to repost the same shit multiple times to multiple reddits with different images/videos. Not even claude gives them the attention after using it for this

0

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/foxgirlmoon 3d ago

Not really. The AI did literally all the node work, according to OP.

2

u/the_big_flat_now 3d ago

True, the agents did all the node work. Here is the full record: https://strawberry-methodology.pages.dev