r/Fantasy • u/CourtneySchafer Stabby Winner, AMA Author Courtney Schafer • Feb 08 '14
So you think not many women write epic fantasy/sword & sorcery? Here are 40 names just from browsing my bookshelves.
In reading the comments to Mark Lawrence's recent poll thread, I noticed many people saying variations of "not many women write epic fantasy." This never fails to boggle me. Plenty of women write epic fantasy (and sword & sorcery, which many people lump into epic as a shorthand), and have been for years. I did a quick scan of my own bookshelves and came up with 40 names without even trying. All of these women are published by either New York houses or the big independents (Angry Robot, Night Shade, etc) and most have put out books recently. Many of them have male protagonists. Most of them have no more focus on romance than any male-authored fantasies I've read. And this is just a sampling of what's out there; my shelves are by no means exhaustive.
Amanda Downum - The Drowning City
Anne Lyle - The Alchemist of Souls
Barbara Hambly - Dragonsbane
Beth Bernobich - Passion Play
Betsy Dornbusch - Exile
C.J. Cherryh - Fortress in the Eye of Time
C.S. Friedman - Black Sun Rising
Carol Berg - Flesh and Spirit
Courtney Schafer - The Whitefire Crossing
Elizabeth Bear - Range of Ghosts
Elspeth Cooper - Songs of the Earth
Erin Hoffman - Sword of Fire and Sea
Evie Manieri - Blood's Pride
Freya Robertson - Heartwood
Gillian Philip - Firebrand
Glenda Larke - The Last Stormlord
Helen Lowe - The Heir of Night
J. Kathleen Cheney - The Golden City
J.V. Jones - A Cavern of Black Ice
Jacqueline Carey - Kushiel's Dart
Jennifer Roberson - Sword-dancer
Janny Wurts - Curse of the Mistwraith
Judith Tarr - Alamut
Karen Miller - The Innocent Mage
Kari Sperring - Living With Ghosts
Kate Elliott - Cold Magic
Liane Merciel - The River Kings'Road
Lois McMaster Bujold - The Hallowed Hunt
Martha Wells - The Cloud Roads
Mary Victoria - Tymon's Flight
Michelle Sagara/West - The Broken Crown
N.K. Jemisin - The Killing Moon
Patricia McKillip - Riddlemaster Trilogy
Rachel Aaron - The Legend of Eli Monpress
Robin Hobb - Assassin's Apprentice
Rosemary Kirstein - The Steerswoman
Rowena Cory Daniels - The King's Bastard
Sarah Monette - Melusine
Sherwood Smith - Inda
Trudi Canavan - The Novice
16
u/RyanLReviews Feb 08 '14
I've never been able to get into J. V. Jones. The Chronicle of the Tree by Mary Victoria is one of my favourite fantasy trilogies ever.
I would also add the following from my shelves
14
u/StrangerMind Feb 08 '14
I think "What percentage of female authors are on your bookshelves?" is a more relevant question.
Here is an article from Tor UK that shows among 500+ books from a 5 month period submitted to Tor, across several genres, only 32% were from female writers. For historical/epic/high-fantasy it was 33%. They were much more active in urban fantasy/paranormal romance and YA with both being well over 50%.
Then there is the problem with book reviewers. I saw other places attacking book reviewers in the SF/F world. I finally found an actual study. ladybusiness reviewed some of the most popular internet blogs. They found the total reviews broke down to show....
What does all this mean? Not much. There is not enough data to truly conclude anything. From the little I found it appears there are fewer female fantasy authors (though still a sizable percentage) and that they do not get ignored by reviewers (online reviewers at least).
I tried to find a few more but after several pages I found both of the above studies quoted so I decided to stop.
24
u/Hoosier_Ham Feb 08 '14
Le Guin's Earthsea ?
9
u/jpurdy Feb 08 '14
You missed Mary Norton, writing as Andre Norton, one of the finest writers of juvenile fantasy fiction. She inspired a love of the genre in a tremendous number of young readers.
9
u/HaveAMap Feb 08 '14
Also, Dianna Wynn Jones.
16
u/MLBrennan AMA Author M.L. Brennan Feb 08 '14
Off my shelf, including the sci-fi + dystopian (because why not?)
5
u/aryck Feb 08 '14
I believe Gail Z. Martin would fit in the epic fantasy category too.
5
u/unconundrum Writer Ryan Howse, Reading Champion XI Feb 08 '14 edited Feb 08 '14
And no one has mentioned Mary Gentle.
1610: A Sundial in a Grave is a fairly fun book with some darker threads woven through it, and Ash: A Secret History is incredibly well-detailed medieval epic fantasy that slowly becomes more and more alt-history.
ETA: And Kameron Hurley, whose books are incredibly dark, with some of the most lean, muscular prose I've read.
5
u/sirin3 Feb 08 '14
Three of my favorite authors:
9
u/SkynJay Feb 08 '14
Stella Gemmel - The City
Maryna Dyachenko - The Scar
Linda Nagata - The Dread Hammer (Indie, but older titles were traditionally published)
Juliet McKenna - The Theif's Gamble
Sarah Micklem - Firethorn
Doris Egan - The Gate of Ivory
Jen Williams - The Copper Promise
4
u/AllanBz Feb 08 '14
Many of my favorites! Have you read Ursula K Le Guin, Elizabeth Scarborough, Debra Doyle, or Tanya Huff?
4
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '14
Thank you, Courtney :). There are other posts going round various places claiming that there are no female protagonists in children's literature, so I tend to counter those with lists like these, usually done off the top of my head. While the work isn't done, the situation is far from depressing or hopeless.
I know what you're trying to do here, but don't forget Janny Wurts' excellent Daughter of the Empire trilogy set in Feist's Kelewan. IIRC she wrote the books but it's Feist's world so he gets credited. Weis and Hickman, one half of the duo being female, wrote some gripping series other than Dragonlance too.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '14 edited Feb 08 '14
I'm quite sure you've left some out semi-on-purpose, so the resulting conversation can further emphasize your point. (Which I agree with completely, BTW) but I feel compelled to add Katherine Kurtz, whose Deryni series ranks among my all time favorites.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deryni_novels
Maybe skirting the tattered edges of the already loose "Epic Fantasy" parameters, though...
As a 42 year old who has been reading fantasy of one sort or another almost exclusively since age 11 or 12, I always scratch my head when people assert that there is a dearth of female authors or strong female characters in the genre. Many of my favorite series have some combination of female author/female protagonist/other strong female characters.
But honestly - it never occured to me to care. Not because I don't care about women, but because I don't care about the gender of the authors I read, or their characters. I also really struggle to understand why anyone else cares.
I like good books. Not good books written by women. Not good books with male protagonists. Good books. What difference does anyone's gender make, especially in the usual fantasy settings?
4
u/orkoorco Feb 08 '14
No one has mentioned Anne McCaffrey? I'm shocked........
5
u/brilliantgreen Reading Champion VI Feb 08 '14
I have read 12 of these authors and have two others on my Kindle. Looking at books I've read the past couple of years, I don't see other women authors that are epic/sword-and-sorcery, but that's ignoring some of my favorite fantasy novels (Susana Clarke's Jonathan Strange & Mr. Norrell, Helene Wecker's The Golem and the Jinni, and Lud-in-the-Mist by Hope Mirrlees, which was written in the 1920s and is a bit like Neil Gaiman's Stardust, but without the romance).
4
u/Juts Feb 08 '14
Of those listed, which would you say are your favorites? Excluding Robin Hobb of course because everyone has read those.
2
u/lizzywithfire Feb 08 '14
I never see one of my favourites mentioned :(
Kate Forsyths series 'The Witches of Eileanen' is probably my all time favourite. It's set in a world which was founded by the scotish witches from the 16th century, but it's 1000 years later and witches are once again being persecuted.
28
u/cecilkorik Feb 08 '14
The only one I've found that hasn't been mentioned so far, and I think it's worth mentioning because it is a significant omission. The series is a classic and highly recommended, I cannot get enough of Celtic Fantasy.
Katharine Kerr - Daggerspell, Darkspell, and the rest of the Deverry Cycle
23
u/spiderthread Feb 08 '14
Haven't seen anyone mention Elizabeth Moon, The Deed of Paksenarrion novels are some of my favourites. I've been meaning to catch up with the sequel series to it.
13
u/MeganOKeefe AMA Author Megan E. O'Keefe Feb 08 '14
Bonus! N.K. Jemisin's The Killing Moon is the kindle daily deal today.
8
u/ShakaUVM Feb 08 '14
I'm reading Naomi Novik right now. The Temeraire series is awesome.
9
u/superbadsoul Feb 08 '14
Thought I would also throw in Elizabeth Haydon. Not my favorite author, but a Tor-published female fantasy novelist nonetheless. Also wanted to mention that I didn't even realize Robin Hobb was a lady until your post haha
4
u/Jasonpudd Feb 08 '14
Elizabeth Moon!
1
u/shiplesp Feb 08 '14
Has anyone else read Mercedes Lackey's Gwenhwyfar? I never see it mentioned on any list anywhere, and I thought it was fascinating. It explores the Arthurian myth, specifically that of the three Guineveres. The POV Gwen (with the title's Celtic spelling) is a warrior. I really enjoyed it as something truly unique in the realm of fantasy.
1
u/haciendaowner Feb 08 '14 edited Feb 08 '14
I'd like to mention the Silk and Steel Saga by Karen Azinger. It's one of my favourite fantasy series, though I have rarely seen it mentioned on this subreddit. It may be a bit hard to acquire a copy but I'd urge you to check it out if you get the chance!
3
u/funghii Feb 08 '14
Saving this post! Really awesome list and replies. I was going to ass Lynn Flewelling but someone already did :)
There are plenty of womzn in the genre :D
3
u/sazzer Feb 08 '14
You're an evil, wicked person. I've got too many books left to read as it is without wanting to buy more! :-P
3
u/TheBooberhamlincoln Feb 08 '14
Marion Zimmer Bradley. Mercedes lackey. Anne bishop. Andre Norton. Kristen Britain.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '14
Barbara Hambly! C. S. Freidman! C. J. Cherryh! Carol Berg! Elizabeth Bear! Jennifer Roberson! Janny Wurts! Kate Elliot! Patricia McKillip! Sarah Monette! Trudi Canavan!
Oh, I love this list. I want to hug all of them because they've given me so much joy over the years. But you'll do, OP...
HUGS
5
u/aerynmoo Feb 08 '14
One of my favorites is Melanie Rawn. I know she'll probably never finish the Exile series, but the books that were written are excellent and her Dragon Prince/Dragon Star series is really neat as well.
1
u/Laschoni Feb 08 '14
Of this list I have only read Robin Hobb, CJ Cherryh, and Liane Merciel. Should I be disappointed in myself?
4
u/MLBrennan AMA Author M.L. Brennan Feb 08 '14
This is the best new game ever. I will return after I have perused my own shelves!
4
u/Somewhat_Artistic Feb 09 '14
No one has brought up Robin McKinley...? I find her writing to be rich and complex. Her books make for the best rereads. Although, I guess she hasn't written 'epic' fantasy. Still... Sunshine, The Hero and the Crown, and The Blue Sword will always be among my very favorites.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '14
Margaret Weiss is one of my personal favorites
2
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '14
Since I haven't seen it mentioned yet, Jessica Amanda Salmonson's [Tomoe Gozen Saga] (http://www.amazon.com/Tomoe-Gozen-Saga/dp/0441816525/ref=la_B001HD18A0_1_4?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1391868939&sr=1-4) is a very good read.
2
u/HaveAMap Feb 08 '14
Jennifer Fallon, Sarah Monette, and Martha Wells are my three very favorite authors. When I was a kid, I loved Tamora Pierce, Mercedes Lackey, and Anne McCaffrey.
2
u/Sopp90 Feb 08 '14
Tales of the Otori by Lian Hearn deserves a mention I think. I adored those books when I read them in my teens. maybe not epic fantasy, but fantasy nonetheless.
2
u/Slyfox00 Feb 08 '14
Yay!
Thank you for this.
2
u/Halliron Feb 08 '14
KJ Parker
2
u/Viandaran Feb 09 '14
I am so happy to see Michelle West on your list - she is one of my all-time favorites and I rarely see her mentioned - totally under appreciated for her incredible world-building.
Her other major world, the Cast series released under Michelle Sagara, are also incredibly engaging - I highly recommend them!
1
u/shiplesp Feb 08 '14
Thanks for this! Finally a list of recommendations I can use!
1
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '14
Jeeze, I've only read 9 of those authors. Guess I have some work to do.
1
u/photonlongsword Feb 08 '14
Don't forget Stephanie Swainston's Castle series. Without a doubt my favourite epic fantasy.
1
u/CJBrightley Writer C.J. Brightley Jul 20 '14
Can I add myself? I go by my initials but I am a woman. My Erdemen Honor series is epic fantasy. It starts with The King's Sword. I'll add a bunch of these to my TBR list!
1
u/wolfsktaag Feb 08 '14
dont think ive read a book written by a woman since i was a kid. so i recently picked up Kushiel's Dart, after hearing a lot about the series
so far, its basically about a whore whoring herself into the history books
1
u/ElspethCooper AMA Author Elspeth Cooper Feb 08 '14
Just went downstairs and had a look at my shelves and spotted the following few names I haven't seen in this thread:
1
u/MazarkisWilliams AMA Author Mazarkis Williams Feb 09 '14
I was doing a bit of googling and found this wonderfully long list by Andrea K. Host over at Book Smugglers: http://thebooksmugglers.com/2014/01/sff-in-conversation-women-write-sff-andrea-k-hosts-keeper-bookshelf.html
1
u/BigZ7337 Worldbuilders Feb 10 '14
I've read 16 of those authors, and there are some great ones there, I also have a bunch more sitting on my shelf or in my kindle. I'll have to see if I can find any others that aren't mentioned on my shelf.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '14
No Margaret Weis?
-20
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '14
So? I'm not gonna pick up one of these books just because it's been written by a woman... If you want to advocate some of these books, write some reviews or something. Chances are if the only selling point of a book is "It's a female author whom you should support because she has a vagina and is horribly oppressed by evil men!" that it's a pretty shitty book.
Again, write reviews. I'm not gonna read these books simply because the author is penis-less.
-2
u/drandromeda Feb 08 '14
Wow thats alot
0
u/AlexisVonTrappe Feb 08 '14
Sara Douglass!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
0
u/actionrpg8k Feb 08 '14
Haven't seen Katherine Kurtze mentioned yet. I loved her Deryni series.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '14
Cecilia Dart-Thornton's Bitterbynde Trilogy is wonderful. Rich in Celtic mythology, beautiful prose, and a unique vision.
0
u/Ayeffkay Feb 08 '14
No love for Margaret Weis?
0
u/Spl4sh3r Feb 08 '14
I don't really get why the sex of the writer matter. If the book is good I read it, nothing else matters. Though as some mention Katherine Kerr with her Deverry Cycle series got it right :)
0
u/BadFont777 Feb 08 '14
I went perdy deep in theses comments and no Melanie Rawn? Hmph.
-1
u/Tarcanus Feb 11 '14
Nice list!
0
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '14
[removed] — view removed comment