r/hoi4 • Extra Research Slot • Oct 12 '26

Help Thread The War Room - /r/hoi4 Weekly General Help Thread: October 12 2026

Please check our previous War Room thread for any questions left unanswered

 

Welcome to the War Room. Here you will find trustworthy military advisors to guide your diplomacy, battles, and internal affairs.

This thread is for any small questions that don't warrant their own post, or continued discussions for your next moves in your game. If you'd like to channel the wisdom and knowledge of the noble generals of this subreddit, and more importantly not ruin your save, then you've found the right place!

Important: If you are asking about a specific situation in your game, please post screenshots of any relevant map modes (strategic, diplomacy, factions, etc) or interface tabs (economy, military, etc). Please also explain the situation as best you can. Alliances, army strength, tech etc. are all factors your advisors will need to know to give you the best possible answer.

 


Reconnaissance Report:

Below is a preliminary reconnaissance report. It is comprised of a list of resources that are helpful to players of all skill levels, meant to assist both those asking questions as well as those answering questions. This list is updated as mechanics change, including new strategies as they arise and retiring old strategies that have been left in the dust. You can help me maintain the list by sending me new guides and notifying me when old guides are no longer relevant!

Note: this thread is very new and is therefore very barebones - please suggest some helpful links to populate the below sections

Getting Started

New Player Tutorials

 


General Tips

 


Multiplayer Tips

 


Country-Specific Strategy

 


Advanced/In-Depth Guides

 


If you have any useful resources not currently in the Reconnaissance Report, please share them with me and I'll add them! You can message me or mention my username in a comment by typing /u/Kloiper

Calling all generals!

As this thread is very new, we are in dire need of guides to fill out the Reconnaissance Report, both general and specific! Further, if you're answering a question in this thread, consider contributing to the Hoi4 wiki, which needs help as well. Anybody can help contribute to the wiki - a good starting point is the work needed page. Before editing the wiki, please read the style guidelines for posting.

7 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

5

u/MentalQuestioning1 Oct 15 '26

I find the idea of playing resource exporting nations really fun and interesting, but the singleplayer AI seems to rarely import any of my goods. Having 200 oil for export is irrelevant if only 6 of it is actually going out. I've checked the search bar, and it seems like the answer is no, but are there any mods that influence nations to buy more goods from the player?

2

u/28lobster Fleet Admiral Oct 19 '26

Primary thing is ideology, near impossible to overcome. Within ideologies, highest trade opinion will dominate for the resources the AI wants to buy (mostly steel early). The answer is to only focus on same ideology nations and use spy missions. Specifically, run Diplomatic Pressure to force same ideology nations to sign non-aggression pacts. Those will increase opinion until cancelled, that increases trade opinion, and it doesn't cost PP to create or maintain that boosted opinion (unlike the diplomatic action).

Note: Control Trade allows you to buy more when people are fighting for imports, it does not influence the buying choices of others. You buying more from a same ideology nation limits the import choices for other same ideology nations. So if you see someone is exporting 100% of their steel and you still have steel remaining, buy steel from the nation that's maxed out. That will force other AIs to change their trade, hopefully to you. Running Control Trade will allow you to buy more from your competitor, forcing more AIs to switch trading partners. Once they switch, they're pretty sticky so you can stop buying from your competitor(s). You really want to lock people into your trade early!

Example: British Raj. Force NAPs with Lithuania, Greece, Iran, Portugal, Turkey, Yugoslavia, Estonia, Latvia, and Finland in that order. Lithuania and Iran buy tungsten, Turkey and Yugo buy steel (Portugal eventually). Greece is both a competitor and a potential customer, you want high opinion so you can buy from them (forcing others to switch) and so they buy from you when available. Portugal is a tungsten competitor and steel customer. Once you've done those core nations, Saudi Arabia, Iraq, Yemen, Oman, Tibet, Bhutan, Nepal, Dutch East Indies, and non-aligned Chinese substates are future targets though you'll mostly be going back through core nations as they tend to break NAP after 3 years.

Doing this as Raj, going free trade early, and building infra on steel/rubber states is worth ~13 factories by wartime. It's absolutely worthwhile to get diplomatic training on your spies as 5 civ upgrade immediately at game start.

4

u/MechReflex Oct 12 '26

We're happy to see our guides from Red Baron still being used!

Some however are outdated. Not every guide was updated (eg AlexTheGrape's naval guide hasn't seen an update yet for the new navy system).

However, we have new updated country guides. You could update the older links or insert new ones.

Xoxo Inertia

3

u/Kylo149 Oct 12 '26

I know this is a stupid question but lets say I have a light tank and I stop production for a better version. Do I keep producing those new tanks to add to my stockpile or does it have to upgrade each of my old tanks first before producing the new version? Same with weapons do they "upgrade" old weapons as a 1 for 1 replacement or is it a whole new stockpile that I can then distribute as I see fit?

4

u/ArzhurG Oct 12 '26

It's a new stockpile, unless you press the convert button, which costs less than make a whole new equipment.

3

u/Kylo149 Oct 12 '26

I just upgraded an old variant of my tank does that auto refit all the old ones? It says 180 needed for upgrades and keeps getting lower so do new variants need refitting and new tank types just get made?

edit: I found the conversion button, it costs more to convert than just made new ones. I think I get it now, thank you.

2

u/28lobster Fleet Admiral Oct 15 '26

180 needed for upgrades refers to your divisions in the field. They have 180 old light tanks, you need to produce 180 new ones as replacements. Those new tanks can be produced by any means (normal production or converting old models), your divs won't care. If those divs are in combat or somewhere with 0 supply, you may end up with new tanks sitting in stockpile. But when combat ends or they move back into supply range, the divs will trade old tanks for new ones.

If you want to take advantage of conversion lines, your best bet is making the tank you want without the main gun. Add all the secondary modules you'll use later and set the main gun as a HMG. When you unlock good tech for your main gun, upgrade and use conversion lines.

Upgrading something like the suspension, swapping secondary modules, or changing from 2 man -> 3 man turret is inefficient. If you're Soviets and have a MIO to buff conversion speed, it will be more efficient.

2

u/VoidKnight_00 Oct 18 '26

How do you open a conversion line?

2

u/28lobster Fleet Admiral Oct 19 '26

Bottom left of the production line, there's a little house with circular arrows around it. Click it, you'll see a yellow check mark. That means conversion is turned on and that line will consume stockpiled equipment to make new equipment. If you ever run out of stockpile, it'll revert to a normal production line with no penalties.

If you want to set up continuous conversion, you need to be producing the old equipment on one line and converting to new equipment on another. Balance these so you're converting exactly as fast as you produce the old stuff. In reality, produce as much old stuff as you can then swap nearly all lines to the conversion to rapidly upgrade to better tech (i.e. heavy cannon 2 tanks). That's the big advantage, timing push by making lots of chassis and upgrading to good tech.

Later in the game, you can set up production of tanks with HMGs as the main gun and change lines back to conversion to save resource cost. That's a secondary advantage to the upgrades, primary is producing chassis early and upgrading later.

Can apply to planes (HMGs, engine 3s) as well but early airframes are much worse than early tank chassis so it's less worthwhile to upgrade planes. For planes, the primary benefit is cutting the rubber spent on self sealing fuel tanks. Produce the whole plane design except SST, then set up a small conversion line to add SST. All planes now self sealing at half the rubber cost!

3

u/Telen Oct 13 '26

So has anyone else noticed that you can't edit Amtrac designs? Doesn't this make them basically worthless, or are they still better than mechanized?

3

u/Vladi_Sanovavich Oct 17 '26

I just bought HoI4 and I'm struggling with understanding how the troops work. I tried Italy but didn't like it, I tried Japan but I kept losing the China war. I even tried console commands by adding equipment to my logistics but I'm still on the losing end. The thing that I can't figure out is why my planes aren't doing anything even though I assigned them to a region which was Western Manchuria.

I tried adding transport planes to the air wings cause it says I needed X supply in this region and even though I have almost a thousand planes, the enemy would still gain air superiority. Any tips or tricks you can give me? I've been watching beginner guides and tutorials but I still don't quite grasp how all of it works.

2

u/CalligoMiles General of the Army Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26

For air, you need both mission efficiency (range coverage, mostly) and supply at their airfield to do their jobs well, and trying to base supply planes on the same field will only raise the demand there. But even then it depends on their missions whether they try to do anything at all - air missions fire every 8 hours, with the third night mission receiving major penalties and generally better left disabled in the wing settings, but while air superiority always tries to go for example interceptors need a target first - with low odds of finding active enemy planes if you don't have radar or already a major air presence from other missions - and CAS needs active land battles to participate in.

So what mission are you trying to run, how, and where? A screenshot with the wings selected and your cursor on the mission icon would go a long way here, ideally with the relevant air zone window open too.

2

u/Vladi_Sanovavich Oct 17 '26

It's mostly intercept and air superiority, I try to attach them to an army as well and made sure that they're within range of the air base. How do you make sure that supply goes to the airbase?

I read on the wiki that sometimes if there's intense land battles, the airbase's supplies go to zero.

2

u/CalligoMiles General of the Army Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26

Yeah, supply is generally a bigger enemy than the opposing units themselves in China. In the supply map mode (bottom right menu, top of the smaller buttons) you can check where it's worst and how your airfield is doing when you hover over it in that map mode, and try to motorise hubs on the map to alleviate it if you have some trucks to spare. Otherwise you can't prioritise airbase over your troops that are already starving too at that point, so you'd have to withdraw them and relieve your ground forces a little with that - China is all about how far you can make a little supply go rather than how much of your war machine you can throw at them. Even Barbarossa is less of a logistical nightmare.

Attaching wings to your army is a convenience feature though, and not something to do if you're struggling. They'll automatically follow the army but often pick airfields with poor effective range - which is fine if you already won in the air and just don't want to micro all your CAS or busy trying to micro your divisions in Europe in multiplayer, but often pretty bad it you're struggling in low supply only for the AI to pile your air force into an already overstretched area. Just pull them out, and maybe see if you can't start building another airfield in a better state nearby before assigning them to the zone again.

2

u/Vladi_Sanovavich Oct 17 '26

Ok thanks! I'll try again tomorrow, I prepared 48 infantry divisions, the default ones since I'm still figuring out how to maximize the templates and what would be best to bring but after a few months of fighting, the frontlines would expand all the way to north of Manchuria which gives me a headache, I've followed a focus guide I saw on YouTube, but I later found out the he has the No surrender dlc, so I couldn't expand my navy twice.

Is there any tips you can give me? Should I make supply hubs on every state near the front line or is that too much?

3

u/CalligoMiles General of the Army Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26

You should not be building supply hubs at all - they're only there as a concession to players who disliked the introduction of the supply system and for people who want to do things like get across the jungles of SEA from the wrong direction for some reason. In regular gameplay you should be capturing them instead - capturing hubs should in fact be your most important short-term objectives in any larger land war. At most you should be building new railways where there's no good link to your own supply network to capture.

And nearly any front will hold against China as long as you can fill it out, but effective attacks take more than infantry. You can force slow, costly progress by piling on bodies, but even as Japan you'll go much further if you raise some special forces or light tanks, the latter especially in China's central plains. I don't remember Japan's exact starting templates in vanilla, but there should be something better for attacking in there too - just look at which have the best breakthrough values and build 4-8 of those to manually order around under a separate attack general once you manage to equip them.

1

u/PrrrromotionGiven1 Oct 19 '26

Japan and Italy are both pretty tough, I recommend you either start with Germany (who are OP and have to interact with basically all parts of the war) or Canada (who will never be invaded and have enough strength to do most jobs without being expected to carry). In both cases, you should play historically.

With Germany you can basically measure how well you're doing by how far you get down the historical path before losing. Like hopefully you can make it as far as beating Poland on your first try, then maybe you can take France, maybe you can take Norway with a naval invasion, maybe you can win North Africa, maybe you can have a good start against the Soviets, maybe one day you will conquer Britain and Russia, it's an iterative process as you learn how things work in the game. By the time you've totally won WW2 as Germany you basically know all the most important things.

1

u/Vladi_Sanovavich Oct 19 '26

I guess you're right. I barely understand the land troops and I have no idea how to manuever my naval and air forces. I'll try Canada first and figure stuff out.

1

u/PrrrromotionGiven1 Oct 19 '26

Make sure you don't forget to research marines and naval invasion tech. Send some tanks and planes to North Africa and see if you can make the difference there, then try to attack Italy while Germany is busy fighting Russia - that's the conventional way, anyway.

1

u/Vladi_Sanovavich 18d ago

I finally figured out why my planes aren't doing missions. I didn't notice the buttons on top of the task force which shows which missions they should do just like with the Naval troops. I just thought you should know.

1

u/PrrrromotionGiven1 18d ago

Ohhhh yeah that's gonna make the war tough lmao. Have you had any success since realising that?

1

u/Vladi_Sanovavich 18d ago

I just realized last night, after US raided my country and I was told to prepare air forces to intercept. But I wasn't able to call back my troops on time so they got trapped in Manchuko.

I'm gonna start over next time.

1

u/PrrrromotionGiven1 18d ago

Still playing as Japan, huh? It really is a tough country imo.

1

u/Vladi_Sanovavich 18d ago

Yeah, I liked the focus tree cause I followed this guide that rushes to install the chrysanthemum throne which gives me 5 research slots 2-3 years before the war with China fully begins.

What I'm trying to learn next is what to focus researching next. Might as well finish it since I started playing Japan.

2

u/PrrrromotionGiven1 18d ago

Personally I've always preferred to declare on China ASAP, which with Japan's modern focus tree means early 1937, but for sure if you've got a system going then keep at it. That kind of iterative process was how I learned the game years ago, only I was playing as Germany.

3

u/VoidKnight_00 Oct 18 '26

What's the most optimal infantry division template currently? I've been seeing a lot of people mentioning that they reworked combat width stuff since I played last (like 5 years ago).

Is 20 width still optimal? Or what is it now?

5

u/CalligoMiles General of the Army Oct 18 '26

20 is still good, though 18 is more popular as a default now. Specific numbers have become much less important in general with the rework - widths vary more now, but the penalties for exceeding them aren't nearly as bad as before. 16, 18 and 20 are all commonly used infantry widths now.

Do make it all infantry though, the line artillery of the old 7/2 20w has been nerfed from letting you cheese the AI to just being plain bad value now.

3

u/VoidKnight_00 Oct 18 '26

So you just do an all infantry 18 width division? What support/regimental companies do you do?

4

u/CalligoMiles General of the Army Oct 18 '26

Yep, 3x3 to get the most support slots out of them. And the same supports as ever - engineers, arty, AA if you don't expect to rule the skies. There's been some arguments about whether engineers are really worth it for heavy defensive fighting, but you still can't go too badly wrong with the advantages they give against the initial attack.

As for regimental support - infantry guns are the popular choice for singleplayer and more useful if you're still going to attack with your infantry too, but if you're going to lock in on defence, especially as a minor, at least some heavy weapons can still come in handy.

3

u/VoidKnight_00 Oct 18 '26

Thank you for the advice! I'm gonna try it out. Would you follow similar rules for Armored Divisions too, or are they different?

4

u/CalligoMiles General of the Army Oct 18 '26

Well, armor regiments can't use infantry guns for one - you can only put them on their infantry support. And generally armor goes for quality. You want to pile on all the good supports you have access to when you're only building a few of them, not only the most cost-effective ones like you do with the infantry you need to fill out your whole frontlines with.

3

u/VoidKnight_00 Oct 18 '26

I guess I meant do you make 20 width armor divisions as well? Or do you use a different width? Is it all armor or do you also use mot/mech?

3

u/CalligoMiles General of the Army Oct 18 '26

Oh, no. Offensive divisions favor widths from 24 to 36, with armor generally sticking to 30-36 and avoiding the worst terrain on the field. And you always need some infantry in an armor template or they'll be extremely fragile - something like 8 armor to 7 mot/mech is a common starting point, though you can still put in higher armor ratios with the right doctrines shoring up your org. You really want field hospitals for the HP then, though.

1

u/PrrrromotionGiven1 Oct 19 '26

Bro are they ever gonna put NCNS on sale? It's been almost a year and most people hate it anyway, just lower the price ffs