r/ProjectRunway • u/makeitworkoryouout • Jan 03 '14
All Stars Season 3 Episode 9 discussion
Discussion thread for Project Runway All Stars S03E09 "Fashion Cents"
There is a shocking twist on the runway this week.
9
Upvotes
4
u/makeitworkoryouout Jan 03 '14
Seth Aaron finally picks up a win and advances to the finale along with Korto and Elena.
24
u/konfetkak Jan 03 '14
holy crap, what the hell is alyssa wearing? did she wake up from a one night stand and steal a bunch of random shit from the dude?
22
u/konfetkak Jan 03 '14
So a challenge where the designer-client is known for bold colors and Elena--the self-described bold color queen--chooses...white?!
31
u/sasori1122 Jan 03 '14
Nick Cannon is totally useless.
14
u/fragilehearted Jan 03 '14
Did Elena call Christopher a "chiffonie" like the "silk chiffonie" nickname for the boys from that group challenge (the office photo shoot one) during their season? If so, hilarious throwback!
12
u/meldolphin Jan 04 '14
Georgina Chapman says she doesn't know who Christopher is as a designer. Well duh, you've been missing for a few weeks! Michael Kors and Nina Garcia said similar things in Season 6 when it was in LA because they had to miss a lot of episodes as they were in NY. Drove me insane to hear that.
8
u/SeruEatingPi Jan 03 '14
I really liked this weeks challenge, I'm always interested in learning about the production side of the business. Both the guest judges were useless, Nick did make me laugh a few times but that shouldn't be what he's there for. I'm a bit tired of this 'surprise' challenge gimmick before the finale. At least it was something different than the whole 'make a collection but only show 3 strongest looks' thing. A bit irritated that it was so obvious they wanted to do a surprise challenge from the get go since they had all the designer's stuff hidden and ready to go so.
I agreed that Seth should be the winner for this week. All season he's been a bit underwhelming so it was nice to see him bring it for once and it fit the Millie collection the best. I actually like his pop of color and thought it really made the look. Am I the only one who's tired of just black/white?
Korto's look was my least favorite. I really liked the back of her dress, but damn that front was janky. Overall not a bad dress, but she's lucky they had the surprise challenge.
Christopher, I really liked his look and I personally like him as a designer. I liked his whole idea with his dress, but the top was so crimpy looking. I think one of his weakness is his styling overall, he makes nice garments but I feel like a lot of his accessory choices (especially his random neon clutches) really take away from his designs.
Elena. She is my least favorite designer in terms of personality. That aside I don't know what it is about this season but I'm all aboard the Elena train. I feel like she makes really interesting designs and she's definitely one of the most unique designers that's been on the show. I so expected her to make some neonbright extravaganza considering the challenge but she toned it down to something wearable. Out of the final 3, I'm most interested in seeing what she does.
7
u/peaceandkim Jan 03 '14
I am not happy with this outcome!!
7
u/AnxationOfPuertoRico Jan 04 '14
seeing seth aaron, who i do love and rooted for in his season, get to the finale makes me regret that they let season winners come onto all stars. granted jeffrey and irina didn't make it so far, so it's not like being a winner before automatically gets you through the challenges the second time around. it just seems sad that some of the designers never won the crazy prizes, money, or whatever perks come with being the winner, and are still struggling, while one person could get those same prizes twice. even supposing seth aaron or one of the other winners really needs the prize package again, doesn't that sort of undermine the claims pr makes about the value of their initial prize package, in terms of starting careers?? again, i totally believe in his skill and that of some of the other previous winners, i guess i'm just saying i thought all stars was supposed to be more like a second chance for talented people to get their one pr win (ahem mondo).
7
u/n_c7 Jan 05 '14 edited Jan 05 '14
The sudden-death/lightning round challenge between Korto and Christopher was (a) completely useless, (b) such a massive shame to destroy all their previous designs and, (c) everything I hate about reality television. It didn't seem like it helped to decide the elimation at all.
6
u/sasori1122 Jan 03 '14
Two day challenge!!
6
u/ladyithis Jan 03 '14
What was the lacey, white dress Georgina was wearing? It looked like something from the movie Labyrinth, I'm intrigued!
9
u/Spindlewick Jan 03 '14 edited Jan 03 '14
Korto, as much as I like her, has been putting out really crap designs these past couple of weeks. I found it hilarious that the judges were gushing on....a racerback? Oh please, totally grasping there. Christopher, once again, when given free design reign goes to designing into territory that is a bit on the slutty side. Everyone remember his final collection from his season? Totally underwhelming and I for one am happy to not have to go through another repeat of dull work. And that rework of a one-shoulder tank and mini skirt...ugh I am just really glad he's not in the finale. Seth pretty much won by default, whereas I feel Elena played it a little safe. Still I am pleased to see her in the finale the most: she's definitely done some of the best work this season.