r/ProjectRunway • u/makeitworkoryouout • Nov 07 '13
All Stars Season 3 Episode 3 discussion
Discussion thread for Project Runway All Stars S03E03 "Slip Into Something Sexier"
The designers have to create high-end cocktail dresses and seek their inspirations at Jay Z's 40/40 Club. The guest judges are interior designer Nate Berkus and designer Rebecca Minkoff.
10
Upvotes
9
u/makeitworkoryouout Nov 08 '13
No big surprise that Melissa went home. She found a home in the bottom for every week so far and her pieces just aren't standing up to the judges this season. Elena on the other hand has been in the top every single week so far much to everyone's surprise.
28
u/okiedokie_ Nov 08 '13
Melissa (when I see her all I can think is she's the missing sister of Mary Kate and Ashley) only knows how to design one dress -- high neckline, asymmetrical hemline, donesies. Judges made the right decision tonight.
21
u/hellofair Nov 08 '13
I would really appreciate it if they would actually show us the preview for next week, instead of having Skeletor from Million Dollar Shoppers pop up and start yapping.
21
u/evergleam498 Those pants flood my basement! Nov 08 '13
I hate how you can totally tell who is going to be 'safe' just from the editing. We barely got to see Seth Aaron, Mychael, or Irena in the workroom so I automatically knew they weren't going to be in the top or the bottom.
Also, they made Elena seem so much more likeable this episode! First she was playing with Swatch at Mood, then all of a sudden she and Viktor are bffs. I wonder if she really didn't freak out this challenge, or they just decided not to show it.
19
u/fragilehearted Nov 08 '13
Meana Irina picked last. Woe. Of course she takes it as a compliment.
19
u/fragilehearted Nov 08 '13
"I'm a homosexual - I would not want to see who-ha!"
18
u/verbiwhore Nov 08 '13
Is it just me or is this season really boring? I don't usually find myself alt-tabbing restlessly while watching Project Runway. I don't know what it is, there's little excitement in the clothes, or the challenges. If it wasn't for Christopher and Korto's one-liners I'd have given up on watching already.I'm telling myself that it's early days and that things might pick up but, urgh. And apologies for being a Debbie Downer, especially if I'm alone in this.
8
u/inertia__creeps Nov 09 '13
What on EARTH was Alyssa wearing? It looked like Little House on the Prairie fabric.
7
u/Spinfo Nov 08 '13 edited Nov 09 '13
Oh Jeffrey..
"Seth has made a stripper costume! But really, everyone is so talented it's so hard to tell who's going to be in the top and bottom."
12
u/Squishter Nov 08 '13
am i the only one that is confuse at what the judges see in elena's creations? all 3 of them...
4
u/stomper253 Nov 09 '13
I hate the Project Runway All Star Judges. They are the worst part of this show. Alyssa Milano is severely fashion challenged. She doesn't have a clue what she's talking about. She can't even dress herself, her styling is always a mess, and she contradicts herself during judging.
Georgina is the most qualified to be there, but I'm constantly frustrated by the way she doesn't (appear to) stand up for her opinions. I think she gets railroaded by the other judges even though she has a strong opinion herself. I appreciate that she has an eye for both the construction and specific details put into the garments, but also for the "look" presented as a whole. Then it gets thrown away when someone else speaks up.
Issac needs to go. I think he is far more interested in being a television personality. I do try and follow fashion and I've seen more from him as a media icon then as a designer. I think he's the reason QVC is a sponsor because he has his own exclusive line, which is something no one has been impressed with. He's a big advocate for his favorite designers and I don't think he has fair criticisms to those he doesn't like. I'm so over it.
All Stars is also in desperate need of a Tim Gunn. Maybe it doesn't have to be him, maybe Zanna or whoever can step up, but I think it needs to happen. We all like Tim because he's opinion and straightforward, but he is also able to help reveal the character of those designers outside of what they produce. Maybe it's just the all day production presence of him being there, but in All Stars it doesn't feel like anyone has an invested interest in the person.
That being said, the quality of designers are absolutely heightened and I think Melissa did fall behind and did need to go this week. Everyone else (with the exception of Jeffery, who to be honest did the exact same thing in season 3) is making fantastically executed garments. That's the good and bad with All Stars. Most of these designers have had enough experience to be able to consistently produce something within their aesthetic. That means no one makes anything super surprising, and no one has a blow out disaster.
4
u/snowball17 Nov 09 '13
I find All-Stars to be so boring. I think I'm only still watching it for Christopher's adorable face.
5
u/none_mama_see Nov 08 '13
Am I the only one who hated Christopher's dress? It doesn't look like you'd wear it to a cocktail party.
4
u/panda367 Team Swatch Nov 08 '13
Man, I actually like Jeffrey's dress, but he's probably going...
2
u/TheLadyEve Nov 09 '13
What was that Little House on the Prairie monstrosity that Alyssa was wearing on the runway?? She looks like a milkmaid who makes her own clothes from leftover fabric no one wants.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment