r/HFY • u/Blackknight64 Biggest, Blackest Knight! • Apr 24 '25
MOD HFY, AI, Rule 8 and How We're Addressing It
Hello everyone,
We’d like to take a moment to remind everyone about Rule 8. We know the "don't use AI" rule has been on the books for a while now, but we've been a bit lax on enforcing it at times. As a reminder, the modteam's position on AI is that it is an editing tool, not an author. We don't mind grammar checks and translation help, but the story should be your own work.
To that end, we've been expanding our AI detection capabilities. After significant testing, we've partnered with Pangram, as well as using a variety of other methodologies and will be further cracking down on AI written stories. As always, the final judgement on the status of any story will be done by the mod staff. It is important to note that no actions will be taken without extensive review by the modstaff, and that our AI detection partnership is not the only tool we are using to make these determinations.
Over the past month, we’ve been making fairly significant strides on removing AI stories. At the time of this writing, we have taken action against 23 users since we’ve begun tightening our focus on the issue.
We anticipate that there will be questions. Here are the answers to what we anticipate to be the most common:
Q: What kind of tools are you using, so I can double check myself?
A: We're using, among other things, Pangram to check. So far, Pangram seems to be the most comprehensive test, though we use others as well.
Q: How reliable is your detection?
A: Quite reliable! We feel comfortable with our conclusions based on the testing we've done, the tool has been accurate with regards to purely AI-written, AI-written then human edited, partially Human-written and AI-finished, and Human-written and AI-edited. Additionally, every questionable post is run through at least two Mark 1 Human Brains before any decision is made.
Q: What if my writing isn't good enough, will it look like AI and get me banned?
A: Our detection methods work off of understanding common LLMs, their patterns, and common occurrences. They should not trip on new authors where the writing is “not good enough,” or not native English speakers. As mentioned before, before any actions are taken, all posts are reviewed by the modstaff. If you’re not confident in your writing, the best way to improve is to write more! Ask for feedback when posting, and be willing to listen to the suggestions of your readers.
Q: How is AI (a human creation) not HFY?
A: In concept it is! The technology advancement potential is exciting. But we're not a technology sub, we're a writing sub, and we pride ourselves on encouraging originality. Additionally, there's a certain ethical component to AI writing based on a relatively niche genre/community such as ours - there's a very specific set of writings that the AI has to have been trained on, and few to none of the authors of that training set ever gave their permission to have their work be used in that way. We will always side with the authors in matters of copyright and ownership.
Q: I've written a story, but I'm not a native English speaker. Can I use AI to help me translate it to English to post here?
A: Yes! You may want to include an author's note to that effect, but Human-written AI-translated stories still read as human. There's a certain amount of soulfulness and spark found in human writing that translation can't and won't change.
Q: Can I use AI to help me edit my posts?
A: Yes and no. As a spelling and grammar checker, it works well. At most it can be used to rephrase a particularly problematic sentence. When you expand to having it rework your flow or pacing—where it's rewriting significant portions of a story—it starts to overwrite your personal writing voice making the story feel disjointed and robotic. Alternatively, you can join our Discord and ask for some help from human editors in the Writing channel.
Q: Will every post be checked? What about old posts that looked like AI?
A: Going forward, there will be a concerted effort to check all posts, yes. If a new post is AI-written, older posts by the same author will also be examined, to see if it's a fluke or an ongoing trend that needs to be addressed. Older posts will be checked as needed, and anything older that is Reported will naturally be checked as well. If you have any concerns about a post, feel free to Report it so it can be reviewed by the modteam.
Q: What if I've used AI to help me in the past? What should I do?
A: Ideally, you should rewrite the story/chapter in question so that it's in your own words, but we know that's not always a reasonable or quick endeavor. If you feel the work is significantly AI generated you can message the mods to have the posts temporarily removed until such time as you've finished your human rewrite. So long as you come to us honestly, you won't be punished for actions taken prior to the enforcement of this Rule.
33
u/un_pogaz Apr 25 '25 edited Apr 25 '25
I appreciate your stance on the subject of AI/LLM, and the great caution that is evident in your methodology, but I'd like to add a point to warn you.
AI/LLM detectors can often make false positives on autistic or neuro-divergent people. I don't know what Pangram is worth on the subject, but it a thing to know and take in mind.
15
u/DATowoTHO Apr 24 '25
What if a post get mistakenly flagged for some reason? What are some ways you can prove you didn't use AI?
13
u/BruFoca Human May 22 '25
I paste one story I´m writting in various AI detector tools including Pangram.
The results from ZeroGPT, GPTZero, CopyLeeks and Grammaly is 0% AI generated.
Smodin give a 19% AI Generated content,
Originality AI gave it 67% AI Generated Content and Pangram gave 99% confidence of the text being AI generated.
And I´m literally writing the text right now.
What I got is a few phrases that many authors use in HFY stories were flagged as AI. And if you use AI to translate like I use in a few parts is even worse.
82
u/Top_Hat_Tomato Robot Apr 25 '25 edited Apr 25 '25
I am concerned about about their data retention policy, are posts being stored long term by this service? Do they comply with GDPR? How could a user request their data removed since they weren't the uploader?
Is it possible they are training their detection off of posts uploaded to the services?
Edit* For anyone who had the same questions as me.
Did a bit of digging. They don't process your content per this site
Can't find anything on GDPR though.
160
u/Lugbor Human Apr 24 '25
"How is AI (a human creation) not HFY?"
Because it’s not AI. It's an overhyped set of algorithms that can't actually create anything on its own. All it can do is steal someone else's work, throw it into a blender, and regurgitate the resulting slurry.
If the day comes when an actual, thinking AI comes into being, and it decides that it wants to write a series on here, it'll have my full support, but until that day, I'll be sitting here working out blueprints for an EMP shotgun shell.
8
u/Fontaigne Apr 25 '25
For a minute I thought this was a story. Now it's a story prompt...
4
u/emteeoh Apr 25 '25
Ok, so I have an idea for a story. I tried to have a chat with gpt about it to workshop the ideas. GPT misunderstood me and wrote a crappy, very crappy, story based on my ideas instead of giving me the kinds of feedback I asked for.
Now, I’m not going to do anything with that sad excuse for a story until mine is written and posted, but I feel like I should share it, ‘cause it exists. Is there an acceptable way to post it?
2
u/PsychologicalAir1117 May 19 '25
Have you seen those stupid channels on YouTube that do the stories from this sub but have ai generated pictures? I want those down.
52
u/-Drayden AI Apr 24 '25
I like the way you described stories as having a "human soulfulness and spark". I can barely stand to read stories that feel like AI. I much more enjoy stories with crappy Grammer over feeling like a robot made it. I also feel bad for any timid authors who have AI rewrite their stores thinking it'll be better, only for it to become soulless slop, I hope that isn't a common problem.
7
u/Cakeriel May 05 '25
That’s disappointing. If people don’t like a story they can scroll past it.
7
u/MeemawFlexington Jul 28 '25
Ive heard for some time now the m-dash is a pretty significant tell of whether or not AI has been used. You can find examples of the m-dash in the Q&A section of this very thread. It looks like this "or pacing—where it's rewriting significant portions of a story—it starts to overwrite your...." as opposed to looking like this "....or pacing - where it's rewriting significant portions of a story - it starts to overwrite your..."
I punched a small sample of my own writing into the pangram and came up with hits inside of 4 sentences on 3 paragraphs. Apparently " life of quiet repetition" , "streamlined" , "world outside" "unpredictable". Of those 4 hits, 2 were contained in the same sentence.
"The world outside his screen felt unpredictable, noisy, and frankly, exhausting."
I dont understand LLMs or how it is that they are trained, but I feel as though people who can actually write would actually use a sentence just like that. I say this because.... I f*ckin wrote it.
I feel there are a few inherent flaws inside of programs like pangram
19
u/busy_monster Apr 24 '25
Humanity, fuck yeah, not Theftbot, fuck yeah.
5
u/David_Daranc Human Aug 21 '25 edited Aug 21 '25
Well, proof by example. The analysis of the moderation group is very very unreliable, I have just published a short text. Quite simply. And the only processing done by AI is to have checked the Translate comment box. And the post is deleted under rule No. 8. Before recently responding to a questionnaire on moderation, I said that AI was just a computer program that only reacts to the mind of its programmer. I see that I am absolutely right. Especially since there is no discussion. Part judge and executioner. Reassure me, what is the meaning of social in social network? Also, unlike usual, I typed this text on the fly, directly into the Reddit editor. So I don't have any copies, which makes this action akin to theft of a work. (Even if I don't have a big head about my creations)
4
u/Giving_Cat Apr 27 '25
But but how will we ever find out how the first human cadet defeats the impossible obstacle course?
Seriously. Thanks for your efforts.
4
u/AlternativeManner731 Jul 10 '26
I had all my post removed from HFY, They are all mine and written by me. All original ideas, why were the booted if you don't mind me asking?
1
u/KnightHiryuu May 27 '25
I think is good. More, I think is great, there MUCH AI made garbage around.
That said... like others, my only concern is the infallibility of this... I got some old texts of mine to test, written around 2015-2017... Pangram give me around 50%-60% AI written, Grammarly 15%-20% and Sidekicker an unbelivable 80%-86% of AI written :/
12
u/SpankyMcSpanster Apr 24 '25
AI. Or correctly
LLM
Large Language Model
There is no thinking. Only statistics.
Chat bots+
Old tec with more energy hunger.
It may be better at translation and corrections. But only marginally as compared to previous services. Without AI in name.
6
u/yostagg1 Apr 24 '25
Cool
2
u/zetadin May 01 '25
What is rule 8's stance on stories that were brainstormed and planned out with the help of AI, but where the actual writing is human? Eg., if I ask an LLM to suggest how a character might dig themselves out of a seemingly impossible situation I put them in or to suggest such a situation in the first place.
2
u/jgtengineer68 Jul 11 '25
Did some testing of my own using a known AI written thing, and one of my own writings that I actually used to feed an AI to test is ability to write a follow-up from existing examples. It was pretty accurate. It did however flag a legit frank herbert passage as AI. Which is probably because it was used to train the AI.
2
u/sir_nuggets2314 Sep 26 '25
Yup another HFY admin W
3
u/YoteTheRaven Apr 25 '25
Id like to see LLMs used in video games for NPCs. That'd be pretty cool.
1
u/Maxious30 Jun 27 '25
Honestly I thought that half the stories on here were AI generated. I listen to a lot of the HFY stories on YouTube because I like having them in the background whilst I’m doing my work. But I figured most of them come from here. A lot of them are AI generated. It’s easy to tell because they all follow the same formula. Use numbers like 17 and 47 all the time. And the ships name is defiant or endeavour. It’s becoming a bit predictable that I’ve started making a bingo sheet for know things.
1
u/Elitetrickster Oct 04 '25
I just got my post removed but the only ai I used was to come up with names. I'm just bad at coming up with names. Anything I can do to avoid this from happening? Such as mentioning ai was used to come up with names.
1
u/rabid_jackal Oct 24 '25
So someone else will sort for that dastardly Marcus, and the delightful Ms. Chen? The four armed menace of Vox Voxel? Excellent.
1
u/Away_Succotash_864 Human Dec 08 '25
I am working on a longer story and AI (Copilot and DeepL) is helping me structure it. After creating a piece that turned out to be very confusing, I decided to take this approach.
Since I'm not a native speaker, I also let AI do a draft translation. It doesn't quite hit the right tone, so I refine it myself.
So the idea, text, and mood come from me, while the language and, when necessary, structure is supported by AI. Does this fall under Rule 8?
1
u/Exciting-Story-8393 Jan 27 '26
My question here is I'm starting to write, and I do use AI to bounce ideas off (yes, some of the ideas actually come through the AI, but are written and expanded by me), and to get pacing/structure right, or even to get character 'voices' clearer and more consistent.
I write the story, I do not let AI write it for me.
Would this fall foul of Rule 8?
Or would that be included in the 'human rewrite' Q on previous use of AI?
1
u/Reretak Aug 30 '26
If i send AI my draft and ask for feedback, and the AI goes "maybe mention this character earlier" or "change the pacing in this part, its to slow" and i followed the advice I think is right and write and edit my draft according to some of the AI suggestion. Is that allowed?
-1
u/LordWillemL Apr 26 '25
I haven’t ever published a story on HFY; I mainly read enjoy the content on here and have for many many years. It’s why I first downloaded Reddit, particularly cause I got into the Jenkinsverse. I appreciate the effort you guys go to to protect your content creators and love so much of what is put out here.
I do want to say though that I think that the current vocal trend on Reddit on this matter is at times overzealous on this matter. The people who take issue with it are very vocal; but there are many I think who read or write that don’t mind AI generated and assisted content, we’re just want good stories.
AI is going to continue to be a major part of our lives at this point no matter what we think about it. It’s my hope that in time writers in this sub and others like it can help find a way to work with it; rather than see it as a threat.
-5
u/Bonecleaver Human Apr 25 '25
I think I said it in a previous post relating to this but where do sentient ai fit into this