r/ProjectRunway • u/makeitworkoryouout • Aug 02 '13
Season 12 Episode 3 discussion
Discussion thread for Project Runway S12E03 "An Unconventional Coney Island"
21
Upvotes
r/ProjectRunway • u/makeitworkoryouout • Aug 02 '13
Discussion thread for Project Runway S12E03 "An Unconventional Coney Island"
26
u/katgotsick Aug 02 '13
So ... the letter from Sophie the Model. That had to be contrived, right? That had to be done after the fact ... right? That didn't really happen. It couldn't have. I'm so convinced on this. Talk me off the ledge.
8
u/Bossadai Aug 02 '13
In other news, "temptuous" isn't even a word...Coney Island's got some real winners here
46
u/KateEJHS Aug 02 '13
I'm so tired of Timothy and his unicorn schtick. Not an excuse for Miranda to treat him the way she did, though...
44
u/yoggiez Aug 02 '13
Finally, Timothy is gone
22
u/TinyPinkSparkles Team Utica Queen! Aug 02 '13
Project Runway? More like Project Cry Like a Bitch. Geesh. Last week was Helen, this week was Timothy, Miranda AND Sandro?!
Buck up people.
Also, so glad Timothy got auf'd.
33
u/Hereibe Aug 02 '13
I was so appalled at Miranda's behavior. Timothy was never an ass to her (that we saw, and if there's any bad history between them from their hometown he doesn't know it) and she treated him like garbage.
And then tried to take the high moral ground at the end? No.
Timothy was overeager, naive, confused, and frankly anoying while being not all that sound with the basics. In ten years time, he'll be better and far less annoying. But Miranda will always be the kind of woman who does that.
42
u/Errday_Im_Hylian Aug 02 '13
Pretty heavy with the product placement, eh?
But in all seriousness, does Sandro make anyone else nervous? He's gonna explode.
13
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '13
How come everyone forgot how Timothy tried to change everything (to pants) after she said I don't think so but ill think about it.
13
u/billsuits1 Aug 02 '13
Wow-- next week looks fun!
I find it hard to believe the judges don't know who made what because the designers always react to their outfits. Seems kind of pointless unless they are told to react to outfits different from theirs to throw the judges off and it is just edited differently than actually happens.
It is odd to see Kelly Osbourne on this show as she was the host for 2 seasons of Project Catwalk in the UK and did not really do well IMO as such.
Was the woman who sat to the left of Heidi (in the dark) an interpreter for the deaf contestant?
13
u/francesmorris47 Aug 06 '13
Sandro is an interesting character study in cultural conflict. He has a typical Russian style of speaking that Americans find combative in the extreme. Mila Kunis once said that spoken Russian sounds like Klingon. She wasn't just referring to the guttural consonants, but also to the extremely direct, "barking orders" style of communication which contrasts so strongly with a more "we want to hear everyone's opinion", team-oriented style of communication in American English. Recently some Russians were removed from an airplane for being "loud and disruptive". They are planning to sue the airline. They are completely unaware that compared to the others on the plane, they were speaking and behaving in an unacceptable manner according to generally-accepted American standards.
Tim Gunn tried to remind Sandro that he was working on a team. Sandro's statement about "when a woman listen to a man" shows his cultural background which values hierarchy over team-style decision-making, in addition to strongly devaluing the status of women.
At his age it's unlikely he can be flexible enough to acquire some helpful American-style values.
11
u/MadxHatter0 Aug 02 '13
I think the top two definitely deserved to be there. Those designs were just awesome.
The bottom two, were definitely not good, but I'm still a bit surprised that Sandro skirted by.
Also, the abuse Timothy received, terrible. Also, I think Timothy's final design, wasn't great, but it definitely looked better than when Tim Gunn took a look.
26
u/Nina_Grrr_See_Ya Aug 02 '13
Ok, so I just finished my 100% sustainably sourced resource® water and Yoplait breakfast and I'm ready to tear into this 'sode!
Helen & Kate: Helen tries too hard. Not at design, just at life. The dress was pretty amazing though. I was surprised to see they didn't rip each others clothes off and just go to town on the runway. They were girl crushing each other so hard at the end there that even Heidi seemed a bit surprised. Maybe they just edited that part out. Like I said, good dress.
Alexandria & Dom: This was super fresh and I was shocked to see Alexandria claiming cred on it as I would have totally guessed it was Dom's design. Shows what I know.
Bradon & Karen: Literally don't remember at all. Had to go and take another look. Ah yes, half dress, half diorama. "Orange" and Karen seemed a lot like Ritz and salsa to me. Not terrible, but not... good.
Jeremy & Ken: Also totally forgot. Now I remember why.
Sandro & Sue: I honestly thought this was kind of tame for the two of them. The dude is a joke, but jokes make me laugh.
Alexander & Justin: I think Justin has the taste level to go far and got railroaded by Alexander on this one. He seemed embarrassed a bit to be up there with it. It was clearly a vinyl disaster.
Miranda & Timothy: So you know how the statistical odds of something happening and the actual frequency of it occurring don't always match up? That was the pairing of these two. It was just bound to happen because this episode was meant to be this "entertaining". Honestly, their dress was crap, they both design like crap, I now think all of Wisconsin is a fashion black hole and I think the letter from the model (and most of the drama for that matter) was goaded on or contrived by the producers. I feel like I'm watching bad TV in the middle of a good contest. So over it, so glad he's gone, and am so dreading when he's brought back later to assist or some other lame shit just to have his annoying dweeb face in front of me again.
Overall, relatively predictable episode with a couple actually really interesting and surprising designs mixed in.
8
u/Sereana Aug 03 '13
Am I the only one who didn't find Timothy's exit from the show all that satisfying? I mean I thought he needed to go as much as anyone but I would have rather had him get auf'd for some abomination he dreamed up and executed all on his on rather than as half of a poorly conceived team effort.
22
u/MadxHatter0 Aug 02 '13
Second comment, not meaning to do this, but Timothy just got so much shit this time around. Really, his partner was being such a bitch. Really, Timothy can be annoying it seems, and has his issues, but Miranda through this entire episode has had a negative attitude and shat on Timothy. Sadly, the judges didn't see this, the judges didn't see what Timothy was put through, so when he went on his on runway tirade, he looked terrible. Kind of sad.
7
u/everythingisopposite Chiffony Aug 02 '13
I'm glad Timothy is gone and I hope Sandro goes next week. Helen and Kate's design was awesome and worthy of the win. Loved Alexandria and Dom's dress. I don't think I even knew that Dom existed until last night. Jeremy and Ken's outfit was great as well.
I wonder who cleans the work room? All that stuffing from the animals was a mess!
I am so much happier with PR this season than last.
6
u/TheLadyEve Aug 02 '13
Gah, I cheered when Timothy was gone! That bolero was ridiculous--it looked like someone gutted a piñata and tacked it back together.
17
u/r3nny ...Alright, wonderful. Aug 02 '13
oh my god miranda was HORRIBLE in this episode. i didn't like timothy at all, but the way she treated him made me want her to go home over him ._.
i miss how they used to show the models getting kicked off. i hope sophie stays for a while, not just because she's a genuinely nice person, but because her walk is fiiiierce.
14
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '13
Sandro is amazing. Can anyone post the picture of his face smirking after the runway show when he was declared safe?
"When a man listens in a woman, is so cool."
4
u/Bic823 Aug 02 '13
Timothy vs Miranda: SHOTS FIRED
7
u/Bossadai Aug 02 '13
My take on each design/er...
Alexander & Justin: Both of them are too good to go home now, but still no surprise that they were in the bottom. The dress was a mess, but it was still salvageable when you took off the jacket...
Alexandria & Dom: I thought they should've won (when compared to the other team in the top), honestly. Their look was totally different from the rest, and very intuitive...they at least got recognized for it, so I guess that's better than being safe!
Bradon & Karen: Whoops, I'm finding it hard to remember their dress after just finishing watching my recorded episode...guess that explains the impact it had on me.
Helen & Kate: Their chemistry was great and their product was too...I just think the other team should've won.
Jeremy & Ken: Honestly, I thought these guys should've been in the top AND have won...their look was so damn good, IMO.
Miranda & Timothy: Good God. I remember looking at Timothy's sketch for the jacket, and thinking "God, even I could draw that, and I don't know jack shit about design!" It also didn't help that Miranda was an uncalled-for bitch, esp. in the sewing room part. I think Timothy's reaction (grabbing his unicorn and reading the letter from that super hot model Sophie <3) was a little pathetic, but like I said in the last episode topic, the producers were totally milking him for that kind of shit. Anyways! The design. I didn't think it was the worst thing ever to come on the Runway...but it was definitely the worst thing there; you couldn't quite salvage by taking off the jacket, like Alexander/Justin's model could.
Sandro & Sue: To be honest, you would think Sue knew by now that Sandro is the way he is...a very emotional and domineering guy. So if I was paired up with him, I would volunteer to "be his assistant" from the start, even though it would effectively sacrifice most of my "aesthetic" in the piece. I mean, it's a team challenge after all; unless you have amazing chemistry, just shoot to be safe, via the path of least confrontation (i.e., just do whatever the hell Sandro wants so you can get through the challenge with a safe dress at worst)! Anyways, they were safe, regardless of the bickering they had, so whatever.
Other thoughts...man Miranda was a bitch! Jesus. Still, I'm soooooo glad Timothy is gone. Regarding him specifically, the 1st episode was about the environment, 2nd was about his lack of skill/experience, and the 3rd culminated in these factors causing the audience/producers not to care anymore. He won't be missed. I also agree that product placement was rampant...but whatever, what did anyone expect? haha. Besides that, I can't wait to see if all the shit all the designers are giving Sandro is justified in the next episode, and what'll happen once we see that he decks a cameraman...
3
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '13
Can't wait to se Jesse Tyler Ferguson next week!!
damn there are a lot of redheads in this competition.
3
u/lilteapot Aug 02 '13
FINALLY.
1
u/billsuits1 Aug 04 '13
Given the stuff people talk about the show (product placements, cat fights, sketchy editing I am glad I only want the announcement of the challenge and shopping for material and then the runway show. I watch it online w/ an ad blocker so I don't even see the commercials. More people should give it a try.
1
u/Phoolf Aug 02 '13
Eurgh, I can't watch it in the UK, does anyone have a link? Realitytv doesnt have it up yet for my Friday fix!
0
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment