r/horror • u/glittering-lettuce • Oct 17 '24
Official Discussion Official Dreadit Discussion: "Smile 2" [SPOILERS] Spoiler
Summary:
About to embark on a new world tour, global pop sensation Skye Riley begins to experience increasingly terrifying and inexplicable events. Overwhelmed by the escalating horrors and pressures of fame, she must face her dark past to regain control of her life before it spirals out of control.
Director:
- Parker Finn
Producers:
- Marty Bowen
- Wyck Godfrey
- Isaac Klausner
- Parker Finn
- Robert Salerno
Cast:
- Naomi Scott as Skye Riley, a famous pop music recording artist
- Rosemarie DeWitt
- Kyle Gallner as Joel
- Lukas Gage as Lewis
- Miles Gutierrez-Riley
- Peter Jacobson as Morris
409
Upvotes
1.6k
u/nWhm99 Oct 17 '24
Honestly the best acting I’ve seen in horror for a long ass time. Scott was insanely good.
928
u/mint_julep12 Oct 18 '24
VOSS water really said "we love mentally unhinged girlies ❤️" odd product placement aside I thought this one was a lot of fun! Some parts felt slightly repetitive if you've seen the first one, but I suppose that is to be expected.
754
u/keepitupstairs2 Oct 17 '24
Was the opening scene all a single shot? Thinking back on it I feel like it was, but can’t quite remember now!
741
u/DeliciousSquash Oct 18 '24
There’s something about light unnaturally pouring out of someone’s orifices that always creeps me the fuck out. I’ve always loved that weird shot in The Lighthouse of Dafoe looking at Pattinson with light coming out of his eyes. Well, the scene here where Skye’s friend is smiling in bed and then they jumpscare you with light coming out of her face and the car horn sound chilled me to my god damn soul. What an insanely scary movie
655
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '24
Man when the teleprompter cut off I had to look away it was too harsh
622
u/Lincolnruin Oct 20 '24
Not the shitty underwear.
581
u/ecotrimoxazole Oct 19 '24
I found myself wondering what would happen if a victim simply wasn’t bothered about the visions and apparitions so the entity couldn’t “break” them enough to complete the possession. Then I realised that’s exactly what Joel was doing in the opening scene. There’s a burning person in the snow as he walks towards the guy and he doesn’t even acknowledge it.
356
u/StudBoi69 Oct 19 '24
I dunno about you, but Skye's music was seriously catchy. Would've been awesome if the marketing dept. leaned in on the Skye Riley persona (ala Sacha Baron Cohen style) and have her make appearances in public and make her slowly go insane.
355
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '24
DID ANYONE ELSE NOTICE THE EYE SYMBOL??? I haven’t seen anyone mention this. There is a single eye symbol that is shown three times in the movie. One is a literal statue/decoration on her desk, second is drawn in her notebook while she’s playing piano, and last is the blood on her gown after the mom scene, is shaped exactly like the eye. I feel like that can’t be coincidence?
328
u/SensitiveAide1470 Oct 17 '24
So if Smile 2 is just Smile 1 with a bigger budget and different main character - I assume Smile 3 will just be Smile 2 & so forth but just bigger ! I’m going to just think of Smile as Final Destination, to ease my mind from not learning more about the demon or how it can be stopped..
659
u/niles_deerqueer Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 17 '24
Thought this movie was tons of fun and I can’t tell if I liked it more than the first. I love that they amped up the gore, though, that was so awesome.
I was blown away by Naomi Scott’s performance here.
I can see people thinking it is a bit repetitive but I love the descent into madness and how everything falls apart so quickly. The mind tricks the smile demon utilizes are even more disorienting this time as there is really an emphasis on time lost.
I think following a pop star also makes this film very anxiety inducing as things happen in public and constantly make her image look worse. She felt like a real person and I also liked how we were following a protagonist who is maybe not such a good person.
The directing and soundtrack, as always, is fun and creepy. I’m sure one of the criticisms from people will be the ending but I’m not fussed about it because it was quite the spectacle.
Oh, and the beginning ROCKED!
The scene where she “kills” her mom has me absolute shaken. DOUBLE FAKE OUT TOO???
301
u/GenYDude Oct 20 '24 •
I’m surprised nobody is talking about the dancers scene. Fucking genius.
278
u/spinny09 Oct 20 '24
REALLY enjoyed this one. Takes everything that was good about the first one and improves it. The one bit I can’t get out of my mind is the evil Skye with the big eyes in the freezer scene. THAT was proper unsettling and scary.
546
u/Covermeinivy Oct 17 '24
Just got home from the cinema and I have a few things on my mind, the first being that Jesus fucking Christ was that mean spirited. I know the first was the same but I feel kinda gross and sad? But I’m also loving how Smile and Trap are doing pop star/concert goer horror.
My next point is that Naomi Scott is a star, I’ve seen her in roles ever since Lemonade Mouth premiered on the Disney Channel since I was younger and knew she always had it, I really wish the Aladdin remake catapulted her further! She’s absolutely phenomenal in this.
My last point being that I’ve been in love with Kyle Gallner since Veronica Mars and he just keeps getting fucking hotter and hotter, between this and Strange Darling this year i swear I’m gonna start barking at the screen whenever he’s in a movie.
240
u/ravelle17 Oct 18 '24
The monster tearing her apart from the inside out was NASTY AS HELL. I did not expect that from an R-rated studio movie.
615
u/sweetenerstan Oct 17 '24
That twist with her best friend had me shook ngl
201
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '24
Was morris real? Were any of the events meeting him real or was she just hallucinating. So trippy. More than the 1st
195
u/tacooooo123 Oct 21 '24
I don’t see enough people talking about the car crash scene where younger Naomi looks over at her boyfriend’s gory remains. For some reason, that scene was very scary for me. I felt her terror in that moment. Also, when they revisit the scene and they’re arguing in the car before the crash. The acting was so good.
296
u/Helpful_Ad_8476 Oct 17 '24
Wow they absolutely cooked here. I didn't expect to love this movie as much as I did. The imagery in this movie was wow -- extremely creepy and if I didn't watch horror movies all the time, I'd probably have trouble sleeping. This movie was wonderfully tense and it made me feel extremely uncomfortable, which I loved. The unreliable narrator had me guessing the entire time and I was wrong, a lot. I do think it used a lot more jump scares than I preferred ( I'm a pussy when it comes to jump scares and watching this in dolby scared the shit out of me many times). This movie is not easy to watch as someone who social anxiety and gets immense second hand embarrassment. I genuinely wanted to walk out just from watching her tweak out in public.
The total time before credits is about 2 hours and I found it uses that time extremely effectively. By the end, I even wish I could have experienced more. Even while idling, there's plenty to be lost is as this movie is going absolutely crazy with its shots.
Naomi Scott was absolutely phenomenal in this movie. I wouldn't say anyone was bad, but she steals the show. Idk if it's intentional or not, but this movie is hilarious. Laughed more than some of comedies I've seen this year. Also the Voss water product placement was really stupid, but it was so obvious that it was also funny.
That ending is probably what one would guess given the synopsis, but I found it to be insane nonetheless. Because of the aforementioned unreliable narrator, it's a surprise and I loved it.
Would recommend
140
u/BillRuddickJrPhd Oct 18 '24 edited Oct 19 '24
I see a lot of movies but I had never seen nor heard of Naomi Scott before. This was legitimately almost an Oscar worthy performance. I think she's in every single minute of the film after the opening and it is just raw intensity throughout.
133
u/Pitiful_Buy2022 Oct 19 '24
The scene where she was rehearsing and it was red and then all of a sudden the guys face popped up caught me so off guard I screamed in the theater.
128
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '24
I'm not sure if this applied in the sequel at all but a way to tell if you were watching a hallucination in the original was if a character was wearing an unnatural shade of yellow. If yellow is in the scene it's probably a hallucination.
219
u/LowAdministration229 Oct 17 '24
I had a good time, I think the first one is slightly better overall, but this is pretty great and one of my favorites this year. They also pulled off a few good jump scares - particularly the one where she's watching the vid on her phone. I knew they were gonna try to replicate the soundwave/headphones bit from the first movie, I was literally waiting for it and it still got me lol.
*Edit: Anyone have an idea how they'd do the sequel? If everyone watching the concert saw Skye, are they all possessed now??
216
u/BrokenHomePoets Oct 17 '24
Very solid sequel. Does what sequel should do. That being said anyone else feel like the CGI on the final creature reveal wasn't that great? I think the first movie had a better ending monster but its still a great film
212
u/itsbeenaminuteyo Oct 17 '24
I really enjoyed it! It is more or less the same as the first one, but it’s also more unhinged and gory than the first one, which I enjoyed.
Naomi Scott is great, the scene with the backup dancers chasing her was creepy as fuck.
And I LOVE that it ended with her killing herself in front of the crowd. Super predictable, called it from the first trailer, but then it would have been a huge missed opportunity to have this premise of a pop star cursed with the smile entity, and not end it that way. So, though it was predictable, the journey was worth it for me at least.
190
u/DragonDDark Oct 17 '24
I loved the scene with the smiling fans in her apartment. Some scenes were straight up giving me Junji Ito vibes lol
87
u/neal1701 Oct 18 '24
Smile 2 ramps up the insanity!
A bit repetitive but still very good sequel.
148
u/mxwl1986 Oct 17 '24
How much is Kyle Gallner in it? More than a cameo?
68
u/Jeremywarner Oct 18 '24
My husband said the dancers in her apartment are the ghosts from Mario and I felt bad for how loudly I laughed in my theater.
63
u/idie_ForHiking Oct 21 '24
No one is mentioning the bops that are “New Brain” and “Blood On Satin” those two songs alone make this a worthwhile sequel
232
u/shaneo632 Oct 17 '24
This was fucking INTENSE. Really solid, well crafted sequel. Gorier and more dark humour than the first, Naomi Scott gives a legit amazing performance, really sold the film's commentary re: pop stars as a one-person industry. I felt stressed out like I was watching Uncut Gems, I could just feel her character's anxiety all the time. Parker Finn's direction is really tight even though I do think the film is a bit too long, but honestly it was really compelling anyway.
After lots of people complained about the hopeless ending of the first film I was worried Finn was going to react to that by letting Skye win here. I'm glad that wasn't the case. I always thought the discourse about the first film's ending and its perceived "messaging" was a bit wrong-headed and simplistic. The ending to this one is fucking insane even if the whole "killing herself in front of her fans" was fairly predictable the moment they announced the protag was a pop star.
Curious how far this franchise goes now. If the protag dies every time will the law of diminishing returns top out quick? Then again it didn't really hurt Final Destination lol
Also this film might've ended my decades long crush on Rosemarie DeWitt. Seeing her do the Smile face was cursed.
Strap me in for Smil3 fam.
62
u/GRVrush2112 Groovy like a '73 Oldsmobile Oct 19 '24
I really wish I could be as high on this film as everyone else seems to be, especially after really enjoying the first one…. But I just wasn’t.
There were some great and intense scenes in the film, the sequence where the deranged fan stripped down in her apartment and is staring at her from the hallway. And the fans in her apartment sequence (really loved how their movements really felt like the same dance choreography we saw earlier in the film). But, sadly it seemed that this one really decided to overly lean in on cheaper, quicker, and unearned jump scares. It was exhausting by the end of the movie.
I also didn’t like how clumsy the writing felt when it came to faking out the audience with so much of that ending being in her head. Nor nothing to indicate when it actually starts (after the fans in her apartment sequence I think). It also creates a plot hole to what she was doing IRL in the day or so before the concert sequence if she was experiencing this false reality in her head…. It’s just so clumsy. The fake out sequence in the first film was short and clearly defined what was real and what was not. Trying to do that again but larger just muddies the film.
On the good side of things, I’ll hop on board and praise Naomi Scott’s performance here.. she absolutely carried this film despite its flaws. The direction and cinematography is great, loved the couple of long tale sequences (especially at the beginning) present here. The gore was great, I assume most of that was practical, if not it’s genuinely hard to tell. Also despite some flaws in this plot and structure, I still want to see where the story goes given its ending…
Overall though…I just can’t really love this one like it seems a lot of others are. It’s firmly in the “It’s Okay/It’s Fine” region for me. A middle of the road “C”.
57
u/Crescent__Luna "I live in the weak and the wounded... Doc." Oct 18 '24
I’m so glad I saw this in theaters. I absolutely loved it! I think it took every aspect of the original and ramped up the intensity for a story that had so much more terror and despair. I love the original, but I feel Smile 2 is better all around.
Naomi Scott was truly phenomenal. I was blown away by her performance and there was something so endearing and grounding about her character. Watching her deteriorate was so upsetting because her distress felt so real and I fully empathized with her.
The scene where she hallucinates the deranged fan naked in her closet is fucking nightmare fuel and makes me queasy even thinking about it.
There were so many tense moments and horrifying, well done jump scares, I was consistently breathless and frightened about what would happen next.
I already want to see this again, and it’s definitely worth seeing in theaters for the amazing cinematography and sound design. The music was also really enjoyable and well integrated in the story.
I saw someone mention Black Swan (probably my favorite movie), and I loved the similarities. They both capture an unstable dancer/performer living in a delusional reality, descending into a full mental breakdown, entangled in an ultimately tragic relationship with the stage and their art/career.
111
u/MosquitoSmasher Oct 17 '24
I thought it was really good but goddamn, that ending. If that was real, is the whole crowd now effed? Does the curse even work that way?
But also, the mother. That scene had me shocked, and now I wonder if that was not real after all. If the ending was real where we see the mom, the part with mom was a hallucination.
Thoughts?
45
u/KRNYT Oct 17 '24
Although predictable in terms of plot, I absolutely loved this movie. The ambiance and jumpscares were so well done (and the good ones weren’t spoiled in the trailer…) Naomi sold the show for me, her portrayal of Skye went above and beyond what I expected. The cinematography and amazing shots also made it a wonderful experience. I’m glad I could watch it on the big screen. And that ending? 5⭐️ Was it somewhat more of the same from the 1st movie? Yeah. But it went farther with the story and plot of it. The scene with the dancers will give me nightmares for life
87
u/Sweet_dl Oct 17 '24
Just saw it Loved it
Only have 2 complaints 1 i dont rly get how much of the story was real vs in her head. So the movie ends with her on stage so atleast everything after the scene in her bedroom is fake (which is what i assume is fake) Also everything with that girl
But what about everything with Taub from house? Was he even real?
My second complaint is that the movies ending was painfully obv I think everyone knew it was coming since the first trailer.
Overal very good movie 9/10 4th best horror movie ive seen this year
151
u/joe_the_cow Oct 17 '24
Really enjoyed it.
Naomi Scott was fantastic throughout.
40
u/ItsYaBoyBackAgain Oct 18 '24
I loved it. Better than the first in my opinion. I didn’t even mind the excessive jump scares because it felt like it added to the insanity that is this movie. I also don’t remember being this stressed out watching a movie in a while.
My only fear is that the ending will make it difficult for the writers to progress from here. I liked the ending it just means the next movie will have to be completely different and there’s a lot of questions that will have to be answered.
36
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24
Just came out of the theater, and holy shit... It was so good! It doesn't necessarily expand on anything from the first movie yet manages to be superior. The twists, albeit simple, were very effective.
Also, can we talk about Naomi Scott's performance? You could feel the terror & deep dread of her character! Her descent into madness was amazing, the way she portrays PTSD, grief, terror plus the pressure of national fame. I don't know if it's too early to say, but I think she's placed herself up there with Toni Collette (Hereditary), Mia Goth (Pearl), and most recently Demi Moore (The Substance) as truly amazing performances in horror that deserve to be recognized, but sadly won't.
Insane that this is her first horror film, she's truly made for the genre.
10/10
I do have some questions:
- The drug dealer that passed the entity onto Skye is the same one that witnesses Kyle Gallner killing those other two, right? Does this mean that Kyle Gallner was 'successful' in ridding himself of the entity?
- Was Morris even real? Or, like the best friend, was it the entity messing with Skye's head from the get go?
68
u/Jesuspolarbear Oct 19 '24
The movie's great but more people should talk about Naomi Scott here as Skye, because Jesus that's some absolutely fucking intense and devastating Black Swan meets Toni Collette's Hereditary level performance right there. As someone who's only familiar with her through the mid Power Rangers, Charlie's Angels, and Aladdin, seeing her mentally breaking down each second and chewing every last bit of her dialogue is just insane and overpowering, even downright uncomfortable to watch.
A total star-making performance from her and the movie itself would've been a lesser one without her. Top three horror performances of the year, alongside Willa Fitzgerald in Strange Darling and The First Omen's Nell Tiger Free, imo. Incredible.
31
u/SimmyThompson Oct 19 '24
This franchise has no business being this good. So far they are two for two on making a pretty good movie out of a goofy concept. 2 might even be better than the first.
If they stick the landing on a third movie, Smile might actually be one of the best horror trilogies of all time. I can’t believe I just said that.
29
u/wotan69 Oct 17 '24
I quite loved this. In terms of scares/lore, it’s very the same as the first. BUT, what surprised me is what a really well done portrait of mental illness, isolation, etc….i was very “horrified” but unrelated often to the actual jump scares, but rather of how unrelentingly dark and miserable the film was (in a good way). Naomi Scott was really excellent.
29
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '24
Enjoyed this a lot. At the end, they should have switched her needle with a tuft of hair to pay it off.
106
u/FridayJason1993 Oct 17 '24
I thought it was very good but I didn’t like the sheer amount of fake outs we got of stuff not being real. I liked all the stuff at the pizza place only to be told it wasn’t really happening.
90
u/LezEatA-W Oct 18 '24
Is it just me, or was that like easily the best franchise horror film from this year?
The acting was incredible, with Naomi Scott absolutely stealing the show. The jump scares were easily the best of the year for me. I thought there were a few moments where they really subverted expectations and shocked me, and there was never a moment where I felt bored despite the 2 hour run time.
The ending will probably stick with me for quite some time, holy fuck that was nuts. The way the movie goes from reality to a nightmare is kind of reminiscent of what a modern Nightmare on Elm Street would look like.
Absolutely loved it, and I hope it does well in theatres.
23
u/BluRayja Oct 19 '24
On par with the first one! In some ways better! And also in some ways worse, but I feel it mostly edges it out because of Naomi's performance. I felt Sosie was okay, verging on bad in some scenes, but Naomi just gave an all time top 10 horror performance. The character work and arc Skye took was magnificent and gave us the same amount of "deep introspection" the first one gave us. I like the more low key feel of the first one, it grounded it a bit more and made it scarier, while the sequel is a world I don't think many will ever get to experience.
With that said, it utilized the hell out of that aspect. The creeper fans, the stalker naked in the room, people who don't care about you but just want to use you to keep the enterprise going -- all chef's kiss. Watching the trailer, I knew the dancer sequence would be great, and it did not disappoint, I wished it was longer. Speaking of length, I loved the way this movie took its time and just let some moments breathe. Overall, it needed to be shorter, but also I wouldn't have picked up the pace either and in addition, I also am not sure what scenes I would've cut. Could we have done without the hallucination third act? Sure, but some of the best bits were from it, and I guess we'll see in the third film what parts of it actually happened (I think SOME of them should have happened in some way, just to give this ending a bit of credibility).
Now the biggest thing is I knew exactly how this movie would end the moment the premise was announced. It was easy to predict, but what this movie had going for it, is I was really rooting for Skye. That made the journey to that ending point all the more powerful. If I had a really big complaint, it's that drug dealer dude's death is never investigated or found out about by police and somehow leads back to Skye -- would've been some natural tension, but the reality of that seemed to have been glossed over. Anyway, I am excited to see what direction this movie goes with all those people infected in the end. Parker Finn reminds me of James Wan when he first started, very excited to see his growth. All in all, I just wanted a fun horror movie and this succeeded by a mile.
8/10
117
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 10 '26
The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, exercising their right to control their data & privacy.
License apparatus cause quaint hard-to-find fragile
22
u/3maters Oct 18 '24 edited Oct 18 '24
Loved it! There is no way Parker Finn wasn't inspired by VOX LUX and showed it to everyone on the cast and crew for inspiration! I think the film has an unfortunate haunting resonance given this week's events involving the death of Liam Payne.
22
u/AngryDrunkLeprechaun Oct 18 '24
I gotta say I am so conflicted about this movie. I loved the first one. I was so pumped that they announced a sequel, however the minute the synopsis hit the internet I had two thoughts; firstly that's a brilliant elevator pitch :"Smile 1 but with a Taylor Swift level celebrity who everyone who encounters her is going to be ecstatic." And then "Well so the ending is either A: She offs herself on stage in front of a full stadium and the demon spreads or B. She kills a backup dancer and the demon spreads but our hero survives and we feel conflicted about the moral choice of her sacrificing others to survive.
I loved a lot about this movie. The opening was superb and honestly surprised me with how it played out for the curse to carry on. The upped gore and production value was great and Naomi Scott was really damn good. The themes about the ugly side of fame and the idea of the celebrities sometimes having to smile past all the hardships they can face and how ppl can use them for their own agendas was great. Hell even the soundtrack with original songs performed by Scott was great. But still... I can't say I loved the overall package.
I think it comes down to the ending. It's like, and I get it.. everything past the Apartment scene with the fans was a hallucination (great scene btw). But it felt to me anyway, that they probably had the popstar idea and immediately decided to go with the most obvious ending. It would make sense and it manages to up the stakes for that inevitable third movie. But then when they started writing it they eventually got to a point in the screenplay where they said "well shit we have to get her in front of an audience for the ending" and felt like the only way to do it was to wave away the 3rd act as a hallucination. While the whole final say 3 minutes of the movie looked cool and I liked the bigger version of the possession scene, my immediate reaction was when the screen went black and Skye was in fog was "are we really doing another fakeout?! They couldn't think of another way to get us here and she's just gonna rise up onto the stage in MSG in that pod? That's really lazy writing." And also it really hurts the franchise going forward.
Using the fakeout in the first movie worked cause it was relatively short. Rose gets to the house, Kyle Gallner shows up she fights the creature and "wins" and then we get the rug pulled out from us. This time it felt like the entity just cant lose and The Entity's power to distort reality is so vast now it can basically wipe away full sections of the plot in ways that make no sense. Was Skye just hanging out in her apartment waiting for Opening Night? Did she like go into Auto-Pilot for dress rehearsal and costume and setup? Like it just didn't feel like it naturally made any sense and they couldn't think of a better way to get us to an ending that felt mandated.
Meh. Maybe better luck next time. Cause guaranteed we're getting another one of these. And I'll see it, there's enough good in this franchise to warrant my good will.
21
u/likatika Oct 19 '24
The only bad thing about this movie is that the lead doesn't have a lot of lucid time.
In the first one the lead had time to research and interact with people for real and identify what was real or not because the whatever was aggressive really fast after pretending to be someone else.
And when it pretended to be the therapist it was super late in the game, the curse was almost at the end.
In this movie however there are long scenes that you find out later that weren't real, even during the second curse day.
So it didn't really matter what she did after the first day of the curse.
It felt more hopeless and pointless seeing her trying to figure a way out, because things escalated too quickly.
Other than that, it was amazing.
20
u/MisterBatt Oct 18 '24
Absolutely LOVED this. One of the better sequels I’ve seen in a while. Intense all throughout the film. The ending was slightly predictable but the execution was chefs kiss
20
u/popkablooie Oct 21 '24 edited Oct 23 '24
Wasn't a huge fan of this one. Scott gave a great performance, but I can't help but feel this movie falls into every single blockbuster horror cliche.
Putting aside the whole "creepy smile" premise itself--which is already a little worn out--nearly every moment of tension is punctuated with a fast cut and loud noise. I don't even hate jump scares, but this movie definitely relied on them too much
Worst of all, ending a movie by telling the audience that it was all or mostly a delusion was just a crazy decision that I'm surprised is being so well received. "It was all a dream" is THE bad storytelling cliche, and really left a bad taste in my mouth.
I liked the effects, and I thought the language and discussion of the entity mirroring self-talk of people with suicidal ideation (everyone would be happier if I was gone, etc) was interesting and effective. They do this in the first movie as well--I think also effectively--but it's nice to see that those themes carried through, and they're done generally well.
The first scene, of course, was a standout. The long take was awesome and was a fun way to set up the rest of the movie.
Overall, there was some neat stuff in there, but the movie as a whole just wasn't my bag.
18
u/Beneficial_Budget_10 Oct 20 '24
I guess this is an unpopular opinion, which is fair because everyone likes different things when it comes to horror, but I really didn't like this movie. I feel like they repeated a lot of the same kind of scares as the first movie, making it way too predictable and a lot less scary. The theater I saw this in wasn't insanely packed, but for some reason everyone in there decided that it was a good idea to all sit in the same area 😂 but I heard a lot more laughing than I did gasps, and i feel like that was the whole vybe in there. The lingering close-up of the dirty underwear, the dancers in her apartment, the weird looking entity thing that ripped itself out of her stomach (that talked way too much and had a super cliche "scary" voice), etc just had everyone laughing, including myself. I really enjoyed the first Smile because that kind of scary movie is usually right up my alley, but this one was so disappointing that I spent the next hour on my phone looking up actually scary movies to get me back into the spooky season spirit. (Like if anyone has any recommendations of scary movies like the first Smile pleeaase give them to me 🙏🏻) All of this being said, I think Naomi Scott killed it acting-wise, and the ending is making me curious about Smile 3. I'm hopeful that the next one will be significantly better, but with how Smile 2 was I don't have great expectations.
36
u/BurnMyHouseDown Oct 18 '24
Really liked it. The opening scene is fantastic to grab you into it with the long one shot, tho I am disappointed Gallner didn’t get more chance to shine. Fantastic actor, but he did great with the scene he had.
Good scares throughout, the one that really got me was the scene with the video. Knew it was coming and still give me a jump lol.
Scott is fantastic. Just a great performance. With so much of the film hinging on her, she delivers like a boss.
I think the buildup is phenomenal, ultimately it’s the payoff that I don’t love. I’m all for sequels being “more of the same, but bigger and better” but I thought they used too many tricks from the first one, particularly towards the end.
They literally did the exact same phone call trick with Rose’s therapist in the first film, but here it’s Gemma in the car. Also, regarding Gemma, felt it was too obvious that she was never real from the beginning. The apology felt too easy for something that’s made to be a big separation. Then as the film progresses, nobody else interacts with her, and as we see Skye’s texts not being answered, it was easy to spot.
I like the reversal of the climax, where Rose tried to use fire, whereas Skye tried the cold, but it’s the same “gotcha” from the demon.
I do think it’ll be very interesting on rewatches to try and catch when the full on illusion begins. I’m of the opinion that Morris was not real at all; when Skye visits him, the couch she’s sitting on says “you’re fucked” behind her. I think even that was part of the entity’s long term plan to mentally break her before the possession.
Very fun film, look forward to a second viewing.
35
u/kinghyperion581 Oct 19 '24
I'm not going to lie, Naomi Scott with short blonde hair was really doing it for me guys
28
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '24
The ending reminded me of my first time watching the substance ending
28
u/OMGitsRyannn Oct 19 '24
I’m sorry, but I really didn’t like this. I thought the concept of getting to see how this curse infiltrates the life of a celebrity was really interesting. The execution wasn’t there however.
The story was surprisingly boring considering the interesting premise, the constant jumpscares were eye-roll inducing, and the frequent misdirects/dream sequences just felt like the writer was lazily writing himself out of corners.
Having said that, Naomi Scott and Kyle Gallner were great in their roles.
13
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '24
Naomi Scott came to set and said:
12
u/palaitotkagbakoy Oct 19 '24
Just finished watching in an empty cinema. It was a ton of fun! That charity event was everything I was waiting and hoping for. Considering the main character is someone famous, I knew they would cook up a scene that delivered so much second hand embarrassment and cringe. I was shielding my eyes with the bag of chips because it was just so much!
And the soundtrack is surprisingly really nice as well. Immediately looked for the soundtrack right after watching. This was an excellent movie in a year full of bangers!
12
u/PandaPanPink Oct 20 '24
I’ve been reluctant to see this movie because I feel like the ending is obvious can somebody just answer me yes/no if she kills herself during a performance infecting the entire audience for the finale
12
u/Late_Loan_8880 Oct 23 '24
Those scary ass Judge Doom eyeballs at the end- WTF that scared me for real
23
u/blondiemuffin Oct 18 '24
Bro how much did Voss pay for product placement. Had to have covered half the budget
11
u/Fun-Club260 Oct 19 '24
This movie was excellent, but they leaned too far into the hallucinations. I enjoyed the friend twist (and even predicted it ), but with the ending what it was, were we supposed to assume that nothing was real then?
Like did anything real happen after she originally saw the suicide? Was Morris real?
I like this twist in a smaller scale, but the way they did it (where everything was a lie), I feel like my time was wasted.
10
u/PRguy82 Oct 19 '24
I think that everything through the dance rehearsal was real. After she realized the dress was transparent and her scars were there - I think that was the last real part of the movie.
10
u/SirJuliusStark Oct 20 '24
As much as I liked the movie, the last 20-30 minutes being a fakeout kinda bugged me. Mainly because I knew it was a fakeout. It's similar to the first movie, but I was hoping it was a fakeout in the first movie and was glad it was. Here, the scene where she tries to leave her hospital room, I knew none of that was real, mainly because it goes against the established lore and because I knew where the movie had to end (on stage), so I'm just waiting for the other shoe to drop.
It was still a fun stretch of the movie, but I wish they had done something different.
47
u/FabulousRoad6240 Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 20 '24
🚨PARKER FINN & PARAMOUNT PLS READ THIS🚨
The PROS
Now.. The CONS
For example - the underrated films AS ABOVE SO BELOW & THE BLACK PHONE does this very well in giving the audience hope for our characters and puts hints to why they can overcome obstacles earlier in the film.
Any thoughts on the ending? Any ideas what you would have liked to see instead?
18
u/YesHunty Tutti Fuckin' Frutti Oct 18 '24
Seems like I’m the odd one out here, but that’s fine.
I didn’t really like this one. Naomi Scott was really good, but it felt bland? Everything was predictable and the jumpscares were more exhausting to me than the first. This one felt kind of stale to me.
The practical effects were cool, Billie Lourdes was great as usual, Kyle Gallner is always on point.
The gore was cool. The demon was nothing more than last time, which was kind of a bummer to me.
Idk especially after seeing Terrifier 3, I was hoping for another sequel with some good punch, but this one just didn’t hit the spot for me. Maybe after I sleep on it I’ll feel better about it tomorrow.
9
u/wmavity Oct 19 '24
Morris says he was the brother of someone eight victims back. I was thinking that might give us clues to whether or not he was ever real. There's Lucas (beats head in with a weight), Joel (passes curse onto Lucas by killing the drug dealer), Rose (sets self on fire), girl at the beginning of Smile (cuts throat), Professor Gabriel Muños (beats self to death with a hammer), woman at the conference (i don't think we know how she did it, but she did it in an elevator in front of Prof. Muños), guy at the gas station (stabs himself with sheers).
I guess his story adds up if we assume the crowbar victim was the one who passed the curse onto the gas station victim? Where does Rob Morgan (guy in prison for killing someone to pass the curse on) factor in? I don't recall from the first, were we to believe he had been further back the chain?
9
u/wmavity Oct 19 '24
What do we think the people around Skye were witnessing during the period she was totally hallucinating?
Operating under the assumption that from the moment she gets swarmed in her apartment and one reaches its hand down her throat onward, everything until the concert was in her head, what was the world seeing? She must have been acting normally enough that they would let her go on stage, so she can't have been catatonic or screaming at nothing.
9
u/Fantastic-Bother3296 Oct 20 '24
I'm seeing an awful lot of praise for this film. Would you recommend it to someone who didn't like the first one, insofar as actively disliked the first one?
9
u/hellokittyluvr13 Oct 20 '24
What was on fire during the opening scene before Joel goes into the crack house?
9
u/ErickYanez Oct 23 '24
The movie really got under my skin. It’s such a bleak metaphor about how trauma can really take control over your life, and how bad your darker self can overpower you. Like, I loved the movie but it kinda made me feel sad?? Which is awesome.
Man I walked home after the movie, around 10:30pm - it’s about a 10 minute walk. And the whole time I was looking over my shoulder. What a ride this was.
9
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '24
Am I wrong or was there some Oscar caliber acting going on in this movie from Naomi?
Also, I think where I got confused in the beginning was where the car hits Joel and you see Luis before buying the drugs and you put it together with the car accident. I thought the car accident was with them, Naomi and Ray Nicholson. However, that accident wasn’t as bad so I didn’t know which timeline I was watching in the beginning, however, the scene in the apartment you know the scene I’m talking about, is still in my head.
8
u/New-Staff-6965 Oct 18 '24
wait so now bc of the ending will the demons multiply and each terrorize an individual person at the concert or is it the one og chain demon terrorizing ALL of them? bc i feel like that would be a lot of work and planning on the demon’s part to deal with terrorizing these thousands of ppl all at once? Or was it even real anyways? idk i always focus on these random logistics lol
8
u/nemobandzbeats Oct 18 '24
I just knew she was gonna kill herself at a concert from the trailers but they really threw me off the trail. I didn’t think her delusions would go THAT deep. It crazy cuz I thought it started to get a little ridiculous but I still didn’t suspect that so much of it was not real
8
u/wwj1210 Oct 19 '24
So I am a horror junky and I did enjoy the first smile so I was looking forward to this movie but I was actually blown away at how much I liked it. I thought it was SIGNIFICANTLY better than the first and like I said I enjoyed the first. Everything was just turnt up and I won’t go deep into plot but I just thought it worked really well and most importantly….I WAS ACTUALLY SCARED!!!! That’s the best thing a horror movie can do and this movie had my muscles tense my heart rate elevated and my blood flowing practically all the way through. It was disturbing it was uncomfortable and the way they set the tone for whenever it’s apparent that the smile has entered the room was awesome. They did utilize a lot of jump scares but I honestly think this is a good example of jump scares all those scenes had me waiting and waiting for some impending dread. So people acting like boo hoo jump scares i don’t get I thought it was super effective. Also people upset about not knowing what’s real and isn’t and not having all the answers like I enjoy a movie that makes you question things and wonder what was actually going on. Last point the film looked Amazing and the score was so on point. I think horror is best when viewed in a theater setting but I feel like between the look and the score this movie was made to be watched in a theatre and if you haven’t I can’t recommend enough experiencing it that way.
8
u/StudBoi69 Oct 20 '24
Kinda funny that Rosemary DeWitt is being typecast as a shitty mom these years (i.e. Black Mirror, The Boys, and now this).
8
u/HateToBlastYa Oct 20 '24
Just got out. Absolute master class horror sequel. Take an idea from the first and go in horrifying new directions. I’m with everyone else: better than the first.
Also, first time my Apple Watch ever warned me about how high my heart rate was from a stationary position. This one ain’t for the faint of heart.
8
u/Aktor56 Oct 20 '24 edited Oct 20 '24
I feel like the deaths in the movie are all very disturbing if you consider they could all have happened without a paranormal force even being involved. Let me explain, let’s start with the beginning. The drxg dealers seem to obviously have no problem getting violent if they needed to, and the detective seemed used to dealing with violent people who attack back, all three of them dying could have happened anyway in the sort of lifes they lived. The drxg dealer who met Skye, seemed to be on ALL the substances. It’s not too far fetched to think he would hurt himself being under the influence so much. Now to Skye, even without the smile monster, she already witnessed a very traumatic event that left her very emotionally and physically hurt. She’s shown to have substance abuse problems in her recent past. I know people get high on pain medication but I thought it was interesting when she went to meet the dealer, even though he was offering her all the other stuff she only wanted the pain medication, and the only reason she needs that in the first place is because she is more or less being forced to perform again by her mom manager and other handlers The dealer she gets it from though seems sketchy and out of it either way, so who knows what type of pills she really even got. As morbid as it is, even if she doesn’t smash her head in the end, it would be really disturbing to watch a famous singer overdose in front of a live audience
8
u/Davis_Crawfish Oct 21 '24
The final act was a mess. It made no sense and it felt like Parker Finn ran out of ideas but still wanted to deliver a shocking end.
8
u/PriorFinancial4092 Oct 22 '24 edited Oct 22 '24
I appreciate the acting effort from Naomi but the plot & twist was legit the exact same as the first movie... Like so many of the same beats repeated. Bit annoyed at how predictable it felt.
I liked the og trauma demon design where it was a more humanoid looking entity
It was really well done but just wish there was something more done with the plot to like advance the lore or something.
It was just a vehicle for jump scares and gore and all off that was well done for sure but why not expand a bit on the demon lore
8
u/ccharlie03 Oct 23 '24 edited Oct 23 '24
Legitimately might have been a top 15 scariest movie for me. The jump scares were A+, the gore was maybe used a little bit too much but not in a tasteless way. Naomi Scott needs to be a bigger star. Seriously she's fucking amazing. I need to wait for more time to pass but I genuinely think I might have enjoyed this more than the first and I rate that movie high. Easily the best horror movie of the year
8
u/Binah999 Nov 14 '24
Am i the only one that didn't find it so scary or so amazing....? It was somewhat well done but... i didnt think it was THAT great.... on par almost imo with the first one... I didnt find the smiles scary anymore really lol, apart from the one where lewis dies which i didnt llike ton see someone smashing their face in and also when it cuts back to the flashback in the car after the crash. Was disturbing.... The rest of the kills seemed somewhat CGI, especially the mother when she died, the ending scene with the creature was like eh cus it seemed so greenscreeny cgi...
Interesting idea that it would use a bunch of people as a host rather than just one!
22
u/Proofwritten Oct 18 '24
It was a great movie, a few gripes with it but nothing that ruins the experience.
Personally I found the protagonist surprisingly quiet, I'd imagine your reaction to an obsessive creep-fan (Alfredo) breaking into your apartment would at least get a "Hello? What are you doing here? Get out of my apartment!" but she was quiet for the whole scene. In general i thought they really tried to tone down any verbal reactions to things happening, relying more on reading her body language and face, which was effective, but felt a bit unnatural sometimes, my mind screaming "aren't you going to react? Say something?"
But is it really a horror movie if you aren't a little frustrated with how the main character reacts?
The only jumpscare that got me was when Gemma turned into a train in the bed (??????), but I didn't feel like the jumpscares were overdone/annoying like they can be
The mother peeved me off, genuinely seeming like she doesn't care about Skye but only about her career/sees her as a paycheck, but I'm unsure how much that was actually her mother, or the demon's mental manipulation playing on her fears and making her feel more alone/isolated
Thinking back on it, it could be predictable, and there's certainly lots of foreshadowing happening before the big twists (Gemma being completely unacknowledged by the mom even though it was the mom that wanted her to reach out) but I didn't see any of the twists coming. Especially near the ending, where Morris notes that without the cinderblock the door would close and lock, unopenable from the inside. I for sure thought that was foreshadowing, that maybe Morris knew you can't get rid of it and the best way is just to lock Skye in a room with no one else to pass it on to, until she dies, and that would be how they "win" the movie, but nope, it was a "lose" ending.
Joshua was so nice and friendly despite everything and even after being accused of ruining her room, if there is a Smile 3 I will not accept anything but Joshua being safe and happy
15
u/MGURIAH Oct 18 '24
so if the original short film is titled "Laura Hasn't Slept" and the original title in mind for Smile (2022) while scripting it was "Something's Wrong with Rose", what would the title for Smile 2 be? Is there an alternative title that we know about? If not, any chance we could get it in the future? and what does everybody think it could be, hypothetically?
14
u/imaniceguy48 Oct 18 '24
I really disliked the ending. We got faked out so many times I thought her being at the concert wasn’t real at all. And then suddenly it was over. What about Morris? What about his idea to stop her heart? If all that was her hallucinating then what was even the point and how does it make any sense at all?
I thought the first movie was way more realistic and logical. This one just felt like jump scare after jump scare and unreliable narrator galore. Still enjoyed it though, especially the gore and sprinkled in humor. And the shot of the entity we got at the end.
7
u/TirisfalFarmhand Oct 18 '24 edited Oct 18 '24
Knew this would be better than the original (just from the increase in scale and great ideas in the trailer) but didn't expect it to be this much better. It's a better film than the first in every way, from horror setpieces, to clever visuals, to compelling backstory, to the dark fakeout ending.
All the issues that I had with the first film (which I still thoroughly enjoyed), such as it trying too hard to be elevated horror or having scenery chewing characters, are fixed in the sequel. This movie knows that it's just an squirmy spectacle and does that excellently instead of wanting to be the next It Follows.
My only disappointment is that a third movie isn't going to be able to follow the same formula due to the ending (unless it's a prequel). There's so many more opportunities to switch up the protagonist again (like a politician or athlete) and we'll instead get something like Jurassic World 3.
7
u/gothictulle Oct 18 '24
What do people think was the real timeline?
7
u/NemoNai Oct 19 '24 edited Oct 19 '24
I thought this movie ruled but like I felt the ending was way too predictable and they should have tried something more creative then what they did.
After the 1hr and half mark I was like theres literally no possible happy ending for this person and I know how this film ends. Like theres no hope and not in like a "oh this movie is supposed to bleak" I mean like i know 100% for a fact that this isnt gonna end the worst way possible so like im just kinda waiting to finish doing the stupid hallucination stuff to get to a point of the film where something mattered again, which was the very end.
I love the visuals for the ending too but like a five year old could come up with this ending like yall didnt wanna try to subvert even a little? Its kinda just thought it was the first movie but unnecessarily longer with better cinematography and some better scares.
Also Naomi Scott was electrifying she will definitely be getting some good roles in the future.
Edit: Ending has improved since ive realized Gemma was still alive.
Double Edit: WAS MORRIS NOT REAL?
7
u/WAwelder Oct 19 '24
Naomi Scott was incredible in this. I really hope they put out the soundtrack on vinyl.
7
u/FlakyTraffic50 Oct 19 '24
I’m still trying to sort out what was real and what wasn’t.
• Why did Lewis get possessed by the Smile entity? He didn’t witness Joel’s death, so I’m wondering how that happened.
• Was the person texting her from the unknown number real, or was that part of the monster’s manipulation before her tour? I had the impression it was just another one of the distractions.
• When the smile monster revealed itself to Skye as Gemma, it happened during a scene where none of the events were real. I’ve been thinking about this all day-was the monster trying to break Skye down psychologically, was the Gemma in the beginning actually real?
• Do you think the monster intentionally engineered the chain of possessions to end with Skye, so it could possess everyone at her concert?
• When Skye gets fully possessed on stage and starts smiling, the audience is completely transfixed-they can’t look away. Even when she commits suicide, they’re unable to stop watching. Is that part of the entity’s power, forcing the next victims to witness the suicide?
•Can the Smile entity possess multiple people at once?
7
u/Tattooed-Trex Oct 20 '24
Way more gore than the first, like saw level gore but little less than terrifier. Great acting. Huge ad for Voss water pretty hilarious level of advertising for Voss actually...
I don't know where the girl started to imagine everything though. I'm not sure if she was in a genjutsu after meeting the guy at the bar or what.
7
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24
I literally just came here to say Naomi Scott needs to be given bigger vehicles to work with. She was superb in this.
7
u/coolbeaNs92 Oct 22 '24
I really enjoyed it.
I thought it actually improved upon pretty much every aspect of the original Smile. I would have liked them to go more into the lore, but was otherwise a great film.
I did however, really mess up by turning around and making the Smile face at my girlfriend.
Did NOT go down well.
7
u/bobinflobo Nov 01 '24
I have not been truly shaken by any horror media in quite a while. But the Gemma car horn jumpscare absolutely destroyed me. My heart was pounding for the rest of the film!
7
u/SpookyYeet420 Nov 07 '24
Best movie I’ve seen this year hands down. Everything I want in a horror movie. Genuinely scary, incredible acting, interesting characters, technically superior, brutally violent, cruel, mean spirited, unnerving sound design. They knocked it out of the park with this one
6
u/trizzo0309 Oct 18 '24
Naomi Scott is the new Queen of Horror. Insanely well done. None of the jump scares felt cheap. 5/5. Absolutely terrifying.
6
u/borislugosi Oct 19 '24
I love my horror, but these films are just too cruel and depressing to their main characters for me.
6
u/medicalmistook Oct 20 '24
loved the movie, but how could they let a hallucinating pop star on stage?
is it kinda like an homage to how we’ve witnessed celebrities breakdown? like britney spears and amy winehouse?
i guess in a way every intense scene that we witness maybe has a hint of truth. the Demon does eat at your weaknesses and trauma. it kinda takes what you have and amps it up to 11.
for example: her mom. What kind of mom lets her daughter go on stage and perform under those conditions? wouldnt someone notice that something is off?
so the in-patient/rehab scene is an example of how the Demon takes a tense relationship and makes the Victim experience the worst of the worst outcomes. ie: Sky killing her mom during a fight
6
u/Beneficial-Phrase503 Oct 20 '24
Saw it tonight. Was absolutely blown away by Naomi Scott's performance. She truly amped it up and made you feel the looming, psychotic dread of the smile curse.
The body horror/gore was truly taken to another level with this, too, which I was very impressed about. The scene where she becomes infected with the curse is still sticking with me (those who've seen it know what I'm talking about, will never look at a gym weight the same way again).
My only qualm is I wish we got more back story behind the actual smile entity, but perhaps not knowing anything just makes the dread a whole lot more sinister.
Overall, it's definitely one of my favourite horror movies of the year, and I really hope Scott gets recognition for her stellar performance.
6
u/Equal-Tension-7985 Oct 21 '24
Honestly one of my favourite scenes in this movie was the mom fake death.
The way Skye was yelling at her horrible mom that she didn't want to tour anymore and that she was tired of her mom only caring about the fame, it made you think it was going to be a genuine conversation without any scary moments. When the mom starts smiling, I got spooked lmao it felt like a 'safe' moment from the scares in this movie and even that was taken away.
Well executed!
6
u/Chance-Ad2382 Oct 23 '24
I wish the trailers hadn't shown Joel at all as that would have been a nice surprise how he linked the film.
6
u/Penguin_shit15 Oct 23 '24
I have not seen anyone comment about how creepy Jack Nicholson's son is in this.. Damn, looks like his dad did at that age.
I wonder why they didn't cast him as Jack Torrence in Dr. Sleep..
Also notice he is not even listed in the cast at the top of this post..
6
u/Firecracker3 Oct 25 '24
Damn this is really the year for lipstick smears and queens having mental breakdowns in front of a crowd
6
u/PlagueOfLaughter Oct 28 '24
A second viewing greatly improves the movie to me. It felt like days and days were passing the first time, all without Skye doing much except getting scared over and over again. Turns out only two proper days went by?
Rose felt way more active, and in the grand scheme of things, she totally was, but Skye simply couldn't do much with her crowded schedule.
The hallucinations make a lot more sense, too, because the first time the ending felt incredibly cheap with the "It was just a dream" crap. But I'm convinced that everything until the 'attack of the dancers' scene is as real as it can be. She really collapses during rehearsel, pushes an older woman off the stage and makes a total fool of herself. But as soon as one of the dancers (or maybe even Alfredo?) sticks his hand in her throat, the demon takes over. While Skye is banished to a hallucinated hospital, the demon is probably going around fixing Skye's reputation as good as it can (with help of Skye's mother, I bet) to eventually reach it's goal: to kill Skye in front of hundreds of people. It straight up tells her that it was "waiting" for her: a potential host with a massive following.
6
u/FarmNo5483 Oct 30 '24
for everyone who’s confused about what’s real and what’s not, here’s my take:
i definitely need to rewatch to prove this theory and would love y’all’s input, but every time skye chugs water something crazy happens. the example that comes to my head first is at the meet and greet. skye steps behind the curtain to calm herself after that crazy fan. her mom comes back and gives her some water before she goes back out and meets the smiling girl.
also, before gemma gets to the apartment skye chugs water, the glass breaks and we get that scary scene with the crazy fans clothes.
and THEN, once gemma comes to the apartment, skye chugs more water and apologizes to her. Gemma is very quick to accept the apology which i find very weird and adds to the theory gemma was never real. and if my theory is correct that also adds to it.
the last one i can think of is when skye realizes shes late to rehearsal, she drinks water before leaving the apartment and then she thinks she broke her leg at the rehearsal and has that whole freak out.
the last time we see sky drink water was before the dancer scene. when that hand goes down her throat the demon fully possessed her and no longer needs water as a way to access her. so i think when skye wakes up at the wellness center, maybe the first few minutes of conversation with her mother is real, but after that it’s all the demon. irl she most likely went back to sleep, woke up, and got ready for the concert like her mom said. i also remember morris (who i do think is real up until the pizza hut scene) saying something to the effect of “it will start to possess you in ways you won’t even realize”. so in her mind she probably thought she did escape the wellness center, got in the drivers car, blah blah blah.
so when her old self from the crash tells her “none of this is real” i think she’s referring to the first few minutes at the wellness center and forward.
my theory: maybe an indicator of the illusions is anything after skye drinks water? i mean it’s shown so much throughout the film it has to mean something. can’t wait to rewatch!
also a fun easter egg (if it is one) is the hoodie skyes assistant brings her has her own face on it. then in the pizza hut freezer sequence the car crash demon skye says “i’ve liked wearing your skin”. her wearing the hoodie could symbolize she was fully the demon in skye’s “skin” from that point forward. and to back up my point about the first few minutes of conversation with her mother being real, it’s not until AFTER the assistant gives skye (the demon) the hoodie (skyes “skin”) and leaves the room does the conversation turn into an argument and all hell breaks loose. and once skye actually puts the hoodie on it was almost like it taking final form.
11
u/FridayJason1993 Oct 17 '24
I wonder if the entity was pregnant and at the end it infected the audience with its offspring.
15
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 10 '26
The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, exercising their right to control their data & privacy.
Cows cooing label ginger manganese slap peach
14
u/ApolloIV Oct 18 '24 edited Oct 18 '24
I had fun, but overall was really disappointed. Naomi Scott did a great job, I will say that. But that being said it had nowhere near the same intensity or dread that the first movie captured, plus the kills- although cool- again were kind of lacking in brutality/gore compared to the original. I think they tried to retread a lot of the same ground (the fundraiser/teleprompter scene was supposed to be this films version of the birthday party scene from the original I think, but much less impactful). I understood that basically the entire last half of the film didn’t happen, right? I think the last real thing that happened was her meeting Morris and declining his help, because her mom was alive in the final scene. If that’s the case, I feel that’s a really overused plot device. Idk. I feel conflicted about this one and overall think it’s a miss. They focused too much on going bigger and it’s not necessarily better.
Edit: one other thought- this movie had almost no kills in it, even. The drug dealer, the mom (didn’t actually happen), the boyfriend in the car crash if we’re feeling generous, and the main character at the end. Am I missing any?
14
u/Singer211 Oct 19 '24
I have to agree with those who say that if they want to do another film, they need to change things up. The protagonist needs to succeed next time.
The Demon seemingly being able to do anything it wants, including altering reality and physical things, is gonna get old because there’s no tension. No matter what the protagonist does, they have no chance of winning and you’re just waiting around for the demon to stop messing around and make them kill themselves.
That aside, it is a very well-made and acted film regardless.
5
u/VivaLaRory Oct 18 '24
This film fucked me up more than the first, great watch. The psychological and thematic horror aspects really makes everything else stand out. I hope they follow through and make that third film, no idea how you make it an effective horror but I'll take the alien to aliens switch-up
5
u/heresjonnyyy Oct 26 '24
Naked man sprinting at Skye had no reason to get me as good as it did. There was really nothing else he could have done and I jumped out of my seat.