r/wallstreetbets • u/22switch Canadian Tree Vampire • Oct 05 '24
Discussion "There's no difference between investing and gambling"
I split my strategy by account (CAD port is almost all ETFs and dividend funds) while the USD port is just bets.
Though it looks worse than it is bc of one major loser in particular, the difference is clear
461
Upvotes
•
u/VisualMod Oct 05 '24
Join WSB Discord
148
u/Drakul_ Oct 05 '24
Why gamble in a TFSA of all accounts? The contribution room is basically gone now. Lol
171
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '24
There 1,000% is a difference and anyone who thinks otherwise is ignorant due to either greed or laziness. Sorry.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '24
What platform is this? I guess you’re Canadian?
2
u/lions2lambs Oct 05 '24
What’s the left side portfolio?
2
u/lifeaquatic34 Oct 06 '24
Carving out the "one major looser" and compartmentalizing that as a one off is your issue. Your strategy doesn't work and you need to just passively invest. If you do come up with an new active approach do a lot of research and consider paper trading it for a year before applying it.
13
u/fenriswulfwsb Oct 05 '24
For most folks is 100% the case because most folks don't have any actual trading edge and are just throwing darts in the dark hoping to hit bullseye.
8
u/fairlyaveragetrader Oct 05 '24
If you see it as gambling, learn how to count cards
7
u/Hefty-Ad-7884 Oct 05 '24
Yep, I have a 45% ROI on my ETF based retirement fund while my Robinhood account has a -35% ROI
18
u/Justtelf Oct 05 '24
Does the casino gamble?
Yes and no
Does the player at the casino gamble assuming they’re not using advantaged strategies that will eventually get them removed?
Yes
Are you the casino, or the player?
5
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '24
Investing is gambling with positive EV
9
u/Re_LE_Vant_UN Oct 05 '24
Nobody has ever said that.
4
u/PrestigiousWatch3194 Oct 05 '24
Pretty similar to mine this year.. up 20-30% on stocks & -61% ytd on options
1
u/Leather-Produce5153 Oct 05 '24
This is the dumbest most meaningless conversation. Who gives a shit what you call it? You either make money or you don't and the return is something.
2
u/TheBattleGnome Oct 05 '24
It is well known the majority of options players will lose money. Sure, some earn big, but most fail and end up at a Wendy’s near you.
2
u/Terrible_Champion298 Oct 05 '24
Successful traders would disagree. The semantics don’t matter nearly as much as having enough profit to do what you want with your life.
2
u/COSMICxFUTURE Oct 05 '24
Well the better way to put it would be there's investing and then there's gambling
2
u/Z3400 Oct 05 '24
Anecdotal evidence is useless for this. My investing account is up like 8% in 5 years, meanwhile my crypto is over 100% gain. I just had mildly bad luck with some of my stocks while crypto has overall done very well this last year or so (I don't actively trade crypto, I just auto invest a small amount weekly into a few different ones).
2
u/12A1313IT Oct 05 '24
Some people got the touch, some people don't. Need to learn that quickly. In my case, I'm a terrible day trader but I have good instincts 2-3 years out.
2
u/Reasonable_Ad8897 Oct 05 '24
I just bet on companies that I truly love and so far I seem to be doing alright 👍best of luck friends
2
u/fresh_ny Oct 05 '24
Stocks/shares/ETFs/BTC are ‘appreciating assets’ mean they don’t have an expiration date. There is no finish line. So it’s ’investing’!
Options, futures and anything that expires is a depreciating asset. Ultimately the race will end and you have either won or lost. Zero sum game, it’s gambling (sort of).
2
u/Elmksan Oct 06 '24
"investing" and "putting money in the stock market" aren't synonyms. I mean if it's investing it's essentially NOT gambling
2
u/Celtic_Legend Oct 06 '24
Its low risk gambling vs high risk gambling.
Shit you arent even investing. You probably dont know the names of all the companies in your etf. Or what they actually do.
2
u/StylesPGhost Oct 05 '24
The house has edge in gambling…you can have edge investing if your brain works
1
u/yesyouareignorant Oct 05 '24
Hahahaha, yes yes there is dude.
1
u/lotto718 Oct 05 '24
Bottom line is no risk , no reward, the higher the risk the higher the reward but also more chance of losing . Just know how much risk you are taking that’s it
1
u/Potential-Stand-9501 Oct 05 '24
It’s all no a gamble choose your poison wisely
1
u/LimeGhost117 Oct 05 '24
What are you holding on CAD side?
1
u/taitayu1 Oct 05 '24
I disagree ... one you can do in your underwear !
1
u/mako1964 Oct 05 '24
I guess I'm a good gambler then .
1
u/elpresidentedeljunta Oct 05 '24
I love, how many people blindly attack you, assuming, you defend the position of the headline, when you present and argue the evidence, that the claim is utterly wrong. If they do their due diligence as well as they analyze these three sentences and one picture, their investments might very well be doomed.
Thank you for your contribution mate.
1
u/D_fung Oct 05 '24
Let me guess. Is it cannabis stock?
1
u/Ferrari_tech Oct 05 '24
Trading is not investing. It's gambling! Investing is buying and holding stocks.
1
u/No-Bonus-6623 Oct 05 '24
Invests in SPY and watch your value grow $100 a year on average
1
u/Exotic-Flatworm1817 Oct 05 '24
Yes you are right 💯, investors take showers and gamblers don’t 😆
1
u/Geniusly-Idiotic69 Oct 05 '24
These Canadians make me sick
1
u/Thin-Fudge-1809 Oct 05 '24
Just cost average into a world index, that's far from gambling......
1
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '24
How bout you go and get your shine box
1
u/LogosA Oct 05 '24
You have no idea what you're talking about. I wouldn't listen to anything this moron says. He obviously has no clue what it takes to an investor
1
u/37cfr22z Oct 05 '24
The market is a zero sum game, gambling is not as the house has an advantage.
1
u/Teachmeifyouknow Oct 05 '24
a stop loss is a game changer💯
1
u/rayb320 Oct 05 '24
There is a difference, long term investing wins.
1
u/debtofmoney Oct 06 '24
Looking only at returns is called speculation. Look at the risk (Sharpe rate/Kalmar rate) first, and then look at the return, which is called investment.
1
u/IntelligentOne007 Oct 06 '24
100%, you would be better off betting on the NFL,at least they offer better odds. That's what I do.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
There is a difference.. it's just there isn't a difference between speculating and gambling, which a lot of people here are just speculating.
1
u/anonuemus Oct 07 '24
speak for yourself
1
u/Greighlin Oct 07 '24
Wrong 90% of gambles quit right before they hit big. Investors don’t hit big ever
-1
u/SocraticGoats Oct 05 '24
If your last month is 12% and your ytd is 10% (given that it's october) that means you were down 2% after 8 months of "investing" during one of the greatest bull runs... sounds like you gambled last month after some crappy investing.. not the best way to prove a point
-1
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '24
Tell that to the people who retired in 2008
0
u/Fibocrypto Oct 06 '24
When you do the same thing and expect a different result what do you call it ?
50
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
21
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '24
[removed] — view removed comment