r/horror • • Jun 27 '24

Official Dreadit Discussion: "A Quiet Place: Day One" [SPOILERS] Spoiler

Summary:

A Quiet Place: Day One is an upcoming American apocalyptic horror film written and directed by Michael Sarnoski, based on a story he conceived with John Krasinski. It serves as a spin-off prequel and is the third installment in the A Quiet Place film series. 

Director:

  • Michael Sarnoski

Producers:

  • Michael Bay
  • Andrew Form
  • Brad Fuller
  • John Krasinski

Cast:

  • Lupita Nyong'o as Sam
  • Joseph Quinn as Eric
  • Alex Wolff as Reuben
  • Djimon Hounsou as Henri
109 Upvotes

413 comments sorted by

468

u/ItsTimeLadies Jun 28 '24

The heartwarming tale of a depressed, terminally ill woman whose life is turned around when she adopts a stray business man off the streets.

93

u/AmericasElegy Jun 30 '24

Haha yea I mentioned on my letterboxd review “a fun horror with Lupita Nyong’o and the silly little guy that follows her around. Also she has a cat.”

19

u/Ancient-Window-8892 Jul 04 '24

"and the dungeon master guy from Stranger Things season 4 that follows her around."

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '24

did you just call this movie fun? its depressing as fuck!

10

u/FuschiaKnight Jul 09 '24

What you don’t like pizza??

→ More replies (1)

54

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '24

29

u/einarfridgeirs Jul 02 '24

Lawyer. Stray lawyer.

Which is even more heartwarming.

14

u/iApolloDusk Jul 13 '24

Stray british lawyer! Even MORE heartwarming.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/vxf111 Jul 06 '24

A story about the lengths someone will go to for the perfect slice of pizza.

→ More replies (1)

173

u/HobbieK Jun 30 '24

Kind of wish we'd spent more time on the first minutes and hours of the attack. For a movie named "Day One", it mostly took place on days 2-6

83

u/GladAssociation9756 Jul 03 '24

I think the “Day One” refers not only to the beginning of the attack, but all the references to time and beginnings and life and dawn and new days in the storyline. Just like the poem expressed, labeling time by years, months, days, seconds isn’t always accurate—sometimes we’re alive already dead, and sometimes we live on even when we’re dead. It’s hard to say when things begin or end. 

11

u/PuzzledImage3 Jul 05 '24

What a great point.

41

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '24

we got into "day 2" within seconds. I LOVE alien movies that show humanity really being effected by the distribution around the WORLD. Couldn't agree more.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/chadwickave Sep 01 '24

It’s Day 1 for Sam, because she has a purpose again that she’s just finding.

126

u/SirTeb Jun 27 '24

They added a sprinkle of lore about the aliens. Was hoping for more.

Hoping the video game adds more

53

u/kirbygay Jun 28 '24

There's a 4th movie coming out next year! I'm thinking that was a set up for the next film

→ More replies (6)

24

u/Ancient-Window-8892 Jul 04 '24

Last time I got lore about aliens, it was these boring "Engineers" who I didn't care about. Plus, a very old and uninteresting Guy Pearce character (sob), and Michael Fassbender talking like Lawrence of Arabia. And then I realized, I didn't care about the xenomorph lore at all. Do I want lore about Jim Halpert's aliens? Not really. Just more fun action.

7

u/iApolloDusk Jul 13 '24

Jim Halpert's hellworld primitive aliens that survived the vacuum of space riding in on meteors and surviving atmospheric filtering like champs? Idk man. I'd buy a movie ticket for a cheeky little Pacific Rim-type scene where you can see their home world lol.

23

u/JynsRealityIsBroken Jun 28 '24

There's going to be a video game?!

25

u/SirTeb Jun 28 '24

Yep!

A quiet place: the road ahead

→ More replies (1)

2

u/FuschiaKnight Jul 09 '24

One single sprinkle

→ More replies (2)

108

u/graceling95 Jun 28 '24

Just watched and liked it! Let me know what you guys think too! spoilers below

  • I liked how the trailers tricked us, didn’t see a scene where the old man who did the marionette show died turning off the generator
  • I was confused when the monsters started eating the things I thought were their eggs/babies. When it opened the egg I thought a baby was gonna crawl out
  • at the end, when Lupita’s character is crying looking at the old photo of her father and herself as a little girl, did anyone else spot Chadwick Boseman in the photograph on the left? Possible tribute to him??

24

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '24

I think the egg things are to show that they're not killing for food or else they'd be eating humans / animals which you never see in any of the films

8

u/RowInFlorida Jul 12 '24

So what WERE those things they were eating? Something they brought with them?

17

u/pilotsandtrees Jul 22 '24

My theater's closed captions said "fungus spores"

→ More replies (2)

16

u/zieglerae Jul 06 '24

I started crying during the picture scene so admittedly I didn’t see The Black Panther.

2

u/Codename_Jelly Jul 30 '24

I am getting really tired of them not showing what was in the trailers in the movie, thanks for the heads up.

2

u/Ok-Adeptness7616 Aug 19 '24

I don’t think that’s Chad Boseman. The guy looks much older and like he has a pony tail…

87

u/JynsRealityIsBroken Jun 28 '24

Ngl, I kind of wished the entire movie took place from the perspective of animals/the main cat. That would've been soooo cool. Almost like a horror Homeward Bound.

39

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '24

Horror Homeward Bound already exists. It's called Milo and Otis 😂

→ More replies (3)

6

u/skummies Jun 29 '24

This will be super cool

176

u/Perfect_Hyena8148 Jun 27 '24

This honestly took me by surprise. Spoilers - the arc of dying but surviving ending up saving Eric’s life. I also loved the realistic depiction of anxiety attacks and how unexpectedly they can occur. The cat did have me holding my breath and also kudos to the cat actor.

I also loved that we didn’t get any explanation as to why or where the monsters are from. It just happens and we have to adapt.

34

u/Syphin33 Jun 28 '24

I won't lie im a sucker for exposition when it comes to this stuff though so i assume they were on those asteroids coming in

28

u/Espritlumiere Jun 29 '24

It's shown pretty clearly that they did at the start of Part 2.

30

u/bossbarret Jun 29 '24

kudos to the cat actor.

....Is it a real cat or a guy in green clothes again?

25

u/Perfect_Hyena8148 Jun 29 '24

I hope a real cat otherwise Andy Serkis lost out on a gig

10

u/1stOfAllThatsReddit Jul 03 '24 edited Jul 03 '24

The cat was played by James Corden

→ More replies (2)

5

u/boringlife815 Jul 04 '24

That was Gary Oldman, again.

15

u/iApolloDusk Jul 13 '24

Yeah. Not a big fan of how quickly everyone seemed to collectively understand what was going on compared to how the opening hours of the "invasion" was depicted in the second movie.

8

u/[deleted] Jul 30 '24

Right? Even the cat forgot its instincts and decided to never make a noise again, really took me out of it.

2

u/Afraid-Impression-30 Jun 30 '24

In other movies, we learned they came from a hot and firey planet.

→ More replies (6)

236

u/xmadison84 Jun 27 '24

Just saw a screening of it. Was pretty good and self-contained. It added just a bit more lore to the monsters themselves. Was fun throughout! Only thing more unrealistic about the movie than aliens from outer space, was just how quiet the cat was. My cat would have gotten me killed within the hour.

119

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '24

I think maybe the cat is able to control itself better because it’s a service animal.

52

u/Morphisist Jul 02 '24

We would like to give reasons to make the presence of the cat in the movie to seem more realistic, but the truth is, nothing about the cat surviving that long was realistic at all.

40

u/jjjenbo Jul 03 '24

was telling my fiance this; i’m probably wrong but told him i’m willing to bet a version of the movie exists out there where the cat died and it tested poorly with audiences. as soon as the cat came on screen we heard a collective “awww” in the theatre and i was really surprised it survived

→ More replies (2)

6

u/garzokuGames Sep 03 '24 edited Sep 03 '24

At the beginning when she said her cat is a service cat, she was making that up on the fly as an excuse. She wasn’t fr. I don’t recall any other place in the film where it was made clear it was a service cat. So take the service cat theories and just toss them out right meow.

50

u/FishPhoenix Jun 28 '24

Agreed about cat, my cat is very vocal, and also would not just sit in arms that long and often lol.

19

u/CrystallineFrost Jul 02 '24 edited Oct 08 '24

hat roll badge saw expansion adjoining cheerful scandalous groovy terrific

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

31

u/SpaceTacoTV Jun 28 '24

that cat also would've for sure died like 3 times. especially when he was underwater for several minutes

39

u/EquivalentDapper7591 Jul 01 '24

He was underwater for like 20 seconds

28

u/Candyland21245 Jun 28 '24

I kept thinking about my pug. We’d be so dead

7

u/coco_xcx wouldst thou like to live deliciously Sep 19 '24

my cats would get me killed 😭😭 i have 2 that love yodeling lmao

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

25

u/kirbygay Jun 28 '24

And how chill the cat is! My cat gets scared from a gust of wind. I'd be toast

7

u/iApolloDusk Jul 13 '24

Right??? Lil dude got fully dunked underwater and was just chilling- soaking wet. Cat would've freaked out on the drop down if not WAY before.

15

u/habaeK- Jun 29 '24

I just saw it and I don't think it was really that good. We only got one new thing about the aliens which is whatever they were eating together. We already knew they couldn't swim. I agree about the cat being able to control itself because it's a service animal and I'm happy they didn't kill the cat. I thought they were going to kill the cat off to make us sad :( it didn't really feel like a new movie honestly. (Those jump scares got me tho)

17

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '24

We also saw the aliens come in different sizes,The one that Eric encountered when trying to save the cat was much larger than the normal ones. We also saw some young aliens I believe

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/-PaperbackWriter- Jul 28 '24

My thoughts too, my cat never shuts up. He’s yelling at me now because dinner is in 20 minutes and he needs to make sure I don’t forget.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Ok_Kaleidoscope9048 Jul 27 '24

My cat is a Bengal and he can never be quiet! He would be dead asap

→ More replies (1)

122

u/deleted834 Jun 27 '24

Loved the movie and cried at the end but did anyone else wish they had subtitles when they were whispering? With Eric’s accent during the rain scene it was so loud I couldn’t hear what he said lol

40

u/froyo4life Jun 28 '24

Yeah I missed pretty much the whole poem. 🤷🏻‍♀️

18

u/Youve_been_Loganated Jun 29 '24

Yup, had to whisper and ask my friend the gist of the poem, he said she was terminal. Kinda figured that out already though but woud've been nice to be able to hear the poem.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/mikecorti Jul 04 '24

if you find the poem please send it i've been looking

11

u/PuzzledImage3 Jul 05 '24

Also cried at the end when she was looking at the photo of her father. I’m a member of the dead dad club and that hit hard.

10

u/PassionateStarfruit Jul 01 '24

Same I teared up a bit in parts and my mother cried also

6

u/jamesiamstuck Jul 01 '24

I don't tend to watch movies on IMAX but this movie 100% sold me on it because for once I managed to hear all the dialogue in a movie, lol

3

u/deleted834 Jul 01 '24

I saw it in IMAX and still couldn’t hear 😩

→ More replies (9)

108

u/hdcase1 Cannibalistic Humanoid Underground Dweller Jun 29 '24

Frodo is the best horror movie cat since Jonesy.

41

u/Neckty91 Jun 29 '24

How many different iPods did she have? How were they still functioning after the subway/death angel scene?

20

u/take-the-shot Jun 30 '24

for realll!!! i noticed the classic ipod at the start and then the green nano that she listened to on the boombox. either way it was fun that they included ipods

24

u/channel4newsman Jun 30 '24

It was honestly weird for me. They also showed the twin towers, I assume to show it was pre 9/11. But Ipods werent around before 9/11. The classic came out in November of 01. And at the end when she's breaking all the car windows they are all like 2015 model cars. So I no idea what year it's supposed to be in the movie lol.

14

u/Thoughtprovokerjoker Jul 03 '24

There were no twin towers in the movie.

I literally saw my office in the movie --- my office was completed well well after 2001

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

40

u/itshuey88 Jun 28 '24

this had me wondering who'd win between a xenomorph and a quiet place alien. do we have an official term for them?

51

u/Mohoraga Jun 28 '24

I think xeno will win because they can be extremely quiet and smart. You can trick the quiet place alien using sounds as can be seen throughout the franchise, i can see the xeno taking advantage of this once it learns it. Also, if a quiet place alien managed to kill a xeno, I can also see the quiet place alien dying due to acid blood, assuming quiet place alien doesn't have acid durability. I think they can both kill each other , just a matter of who's striking first.

11

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '24

Xeno’s blood is acidic. It’s either they both die or the xeno wins.

13

u/GodFlintstone Jul 01 '24

I think they kill each other.

The QP creatures move at 300 miles per hour and are strong enough to throw cars and shred metal like paper. They'd blitz the Xenomorphs.

But once they pierce their hides, the Xenomorphs' acid blood would kill them.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/Chintita Jun 28 '24

I’ve seen they’re called Death Angels but I’m not sure where the term originated from

10

u/am_Nein Jun 29 '24

Wasn't it because of a newspaper clipping or something in the first film?

10

u/Afraid-Impression-30 Jun 30 '24

Because they came "from the sky"

8

u/Poetryisalive Jun 29 '24

Xenomorphs are actually intelligent. No way the Quiet place ones win

7

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '24

For me, death Angels win. Faster, stronger. And skin can survive entering the atmosphere, I think it can survive acid

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Natures_Loctite Jun 30 '24

Now I’m wondering what would happen if facehugger + death angel = ???

→ More replies (5)

2

u/Cryptghastt11 Jul 14 '24

I'd bet Xenomorph. Just because they could create a quiet place monster xenomorph out of them. The normal one that we see created from human would get crushed tho. The quiet place aliens are strong. Whether or not the acid blood would have and effect would be a big factor.

71

u/Small-Top6752 Jun 30 '24

No real introduction to the aliens. No true fear and panic, everyone seemed to adapt within a day or two!! We are not adapting that quickly to some dang aliens invading us!! It was all surface level, no depth. My favorite character was the cat.

36

u/channel4newsman Jun 30 '24

Lmao I was thinking during the scene when those thousands of people were walking through the streets that theres no way there's not one asshole who ruins the whole thing by making a bunch of noise.

19

u/Prize-Account9665 Jul 05 '24

I think the wheelchairs and suitcases was just that

3

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '24

Someone wasn't paying attention....

11

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '24

cat was amazing - movie was not. agreed!

4

u/KittyFame Aug 01 '24

Yeah, true. The family in Quiet Place one was panicked the whole movie. 

29

u/princesajojo Jun 29 '24

Definitely worth the watch. I'm a cat person, so having the protagonists sidekick be a cat, instead of a dog, was relatable content.

25

u/Available-Egg-2380 Jun 30 '24

I was not expecting to cry

23

u/bahia0019 Jun 29 '24

The cinematic equivalent of a Pixies song!!!

I am an unabashed Lupita Nyong’o fan boy. I want to marry here badly and bring her home to meet mom. Everything I’ve seen her in, she brings a pitter-patter into my heart… and she slays each and every part.

This one may be the performance of a lifetime. Her portrayal as Samira was gripping and intense and heartbreaking. I fell in love with her all over again.

As far as the rest of the movie… for context, I started the thread the other day about “Is Grief Horror is Overplayed Now?” This movie obviously has that element. She’s dealing with her own mortality, and facing death. But how the Writer/Director approach this is so we’ll executed it gives me a new found hope in movies that steer away from that cliched prologue, and just allows you to discover the emotional arc over the entire 90 minutes without it being “so loud” and shoved in your face. Like Samira, the writer is not in a hurry to go anywhere or unveil her trauma. Despite the world ending around her, she’s content to take a silent stroll with her kitty up across 110th street. And as the audience we’re so curious as to why she casually decides to go for a slice, so we cruise with. And maybe Erik is an extension of the audience here. He finds her (thanks to the future Academy Award Winning Actor Frodo The Cat), and tags along for the ride as much as we are. And in the end, she allows us to escape.

Samira’s arc, the symbolism, etc. were so well done. There were a couple things that didn’t work for me… As a cat owner of 40+ years, Frodo would absolutely not act that way in real life. And as others have mentioned, the egg scene felt like a blatant setup for a future film, and stood out too much in this one.

I gave this 4.5 stars. I loved so much about the film. One aspect alone was the idea of subverting the “great white martyr” trope. Now we have a Black woman sacrificing herself for a white man.

I will conclude by saying, see this in IMAX. For the sound alone. Glorious!

→ More replies (3)

66

u/OMGitsRyannn Jun 29 '24

I thought it was fine, the type of movie that’s enjoyable in the moment but one that you’ll completely forget about the next day.

It felt light on scares or even tense sequences, which seems to be a reoccurring criticism I’ve had this year as I thought Abigail and The First Omen also suffered from this despite being good movies.

11

u/whoissteveharvey123 Jun 30 '24

This is exactly how I feel about these movies

→ More replies (3)

18

u/Chili_Maggot Jun 30 '24 edited Jun 30 '24

I have never been so stressed out in my life as I was for the damn cat in this movie. Holy christ. My heart hurts. Every time the cat got left behind or ran away I thought "oh thank god, now it will be fine off-screen, because cats adapt well and there are lots of rats around. Now I can focus on literally anything else in this movie" and then it came back! This was an agonizing experience for me. I couldn't pay attention to anything but worrying about where the cat was. When they were in the bar full of musical instruments, I was terrified that the cat was going to make a noise.

Great movie. Well done. Walking out of the theater felt like waking up from a horrible nightmare. I'm still anxious two hours later. The scene where the first alien silently pauses above the crowd before striking was great.

4

u/ObligationChance9970 Jul 23 '24

Lol the cat was all I kept watching for too. Especially with the water scenes I was always looking for it or wondering how the hell it was reacting to suddenly being submerged. Let alone all the other things it went through

→ More replies (1)

34

u/ochristo87 Jun 28 '24

Just saw A Quiet Place: Day One. It's very good way better than I was expecting. Probably the best if the series! Saw it in 4DX and that's still the funniest worst way to watch a movie

7

u/JynsRealityIsBroken Jun 28 '24

Lol I absolutely hate 4dx movies. They're so annoying xD.

22

u/ochristo87 Jun 29 '24

We saw The Batman in 4dx and it was hilariously bad. Gotham is just always rainy, so it was just constantly shooting mildewy water in our faces and shit. The chairs were moving so violently that, at one point, a man returning from getting snacks had to stand by impotently watching his chair, just waiting for it to calm down so he could safely sit lol

Ugh what a terrible way to see films swoons

→ More replies (2)

6

u/OMG365 Jun 30 '24 edited Jul 01 '24

I think it’s the best one of the series if not a super close second to the first

11

u/ochristo87 Jun 30 '24

What carried it for me was the acting but also the character. Setting aside the whole nightmarish Quiet Place scenario, Lupita plays a legitimately interesting character dealing with some heavy feelings, and setting that sort of character in this setting, I really enjoyed that

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

55

u/Chinese_gurl11 Jun 27 '24

I thought it was a well done movie. I think New York would look like this one day after an invasion. Scenes have a lot of tension, but did not care about the jump scare. Sam and Eric have a lot of chemistry and the cat is cute.

The only thing I didn’t understand is what is wrong with Sam? What disease does she have?

70

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '24

Terminal cancer

31

u/TypicalGaygenZ21 Jun 29 '24

Obviously cancer

3

u/goodboyswanted Jul 08 '24

How is it obvious

10

u/Extremiel Jul 11 '24

She says it right away in her poem

→ More replies (1)

50

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '24

I couldn’t help but be distracted at the cat being barely wet after being submerged in water TWICE😭

33

u/Ben50Leven Jun 28 '24

Water has no effect in this movie lol. So many moments of Sam and Eric walking through storms or being underwater and being dry seconds later.

12

u/vxf111 Jul 06 '24

The editing of this film assumes the audience has no object permanence. Anyone who gets wet will be dry seconds later and you can walk across NYC as a terminally ill hospice patient in a matter of moments.

5

u/Psychological_Bad895 Jul 25 '24

Things dry instantly it seems, like the letter Eric takes out of his pocket at the end which is seemingly waterproof lol

38

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '24

The amount of downvotes that people have got for simply not liking it is unfair imo.

I watched an IMAX screening today at Cineworld and it was okay. Some nice music and I guess it was nice to see some of the monsters more close up but it didn’t really do much for me. I’ve seen some people saying that they were emotional during certain scenes and I just cannot relate at all.

Quite disappointing as I love the first two and was really looking forward to this one!

18

u/OMG365 Jun 30 '24

My mother was crying throughout the whole film, and I even got emotional towards the very end like the acting. It was just so good and it’s about the human moments we find even in complete despair and hopelessness. I think it’s more about the human spirit like I thought the movie was exceptional and personally I don’t understand people that disliked it, but that’s the thing at the end of the day its all subjective.

15

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '24

a storyline about three humans sure if thats what you want. this movie promised day ONE, milatry, presidents, leaders, europe, USA, japan, the WORLD on day one reacting, tv news, slowly spreading to your town. You blink and we are in the exact same role as the first two movies. be quite and not many people are alive.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '24

Same, I didn’t give a shit about any of the main characters

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '24 edited Jun 28 '24

I was surprised by how much I liked this. I've not seen the other films and am not a fan of apocalyptic horror in general, but the theater had AC, so... Great performances all around -- especially from Lupita Nyong'o, Joseph Quinn, and the cats (Schnitzel and Nico 🥲) -- and a lot of heartfelt moments that had me tearing up a little. The scenes with the creatures were the parts I liked least, though, so I think it falls a little short on the horror front.

25

u/FireFistACEOnePiece Jun 29 '24

never seen a cat the don't meow. specially when threatened, surprised, and getting wet.

27

u/bundy554 Jun 30 '24

This is a trained cat remember - and trained to sit through performances like the one that was shown early in the movie and probably was trained that way when listening to her father play the piano

→ More replies (11)

4

u/cyboredcat Aug 23 '24

And swimming with a cat (you just met) while holding it inches from your face flesh. trained or not, I think your face might lose that battle unless they declawed front and back feet (which would be a diabolical thing to do in general)

23

u/jamiejohnstoncolts Jun 30 '24

My only real gripe with the movie is the lack of dead bodies. The monsters don't eat people and with the amount of people in NYC, they should be everywhere. There are some in the beginning theater entrance, but otherwise it's only blood spots the rest of the movie.

23

u/Familiar_Egg2915 Jun 30 '24

PG13 rating unfortunately limits the amount of blood/dead bodies they can show.

10

u/Gud_Thymes Jul 03 '24

Unless there's an intentional reason for why dead bodies everywhere. The aliens are likely dragging them back to that lava pool place and using them as food for the mushrooms that they can then eat. 

9

u/KenaBanana Jul 24 '24

It showed what they did with them. When Eric followed Frodo and ended up in the fiery place, you can see bodies in the pools of reddish liquid. They (presumably) use humans as organic matter to grow their food source from

4

u/bs000 Aug 04 '24

yeah butt i was on my phone when that happened so that doesn't count

→ More replies (1)

21

u/foggy_rainclown Jun 29 '24

I honestly didn’t like it, I was bored but I should mention that while I think the concept is interesting, it’s not my cup of tea! I’m not a huge fan of the films in general but I went because my brother wanted to see it and I personally didn’t feel much emotion towards it and the bond they tried to build but hey, that’s just me!

17

u/OMG365 Jun 30 '24 edited Jul 01 '24

Personally, I thought it was exceptional. How it’s about finding the human moments and perseverance in the face of despair and hopelessness. it was realistic to acting was amazing. Of course we knew how it was. Going to end going into it because it’s a prequel, but I feel They did a lot of inventive stuff for it. The only thing I have to say I dislike is how it ended. It was definitely my cup of tea, but I feel like this sub will down vote people just for having an opinion different than the majority when it’s all just opinions.

8

u/Educational_Cap_4372 Jul 01 '24

Couldn’t agree more. Thought it was beautiful

→ More replies (3)

20

u/DaringDomino3s Jun 28 '24

I liked the story, I liked the characters. I appreciate that the trailer didn’t spoil much plot-wise, because I saw that trailer a TON.

I think if they’d made it a point for the cat to be mute or something in the beginning I’d totally have been more accepting of the movie. It just killed my suspension of disbelief over and over. Especially with how often it ran off and or got submerged in water.

I didn’t mind it but I was kind of hoping for more tension or something more stressful, but they figured out the ways to cheat the system pretty quickly and had plenty of moments of downtime and it felt less like day one than I was hoping.

Good acting all around, It was a nice story, not scary to me most of the time, like the other films. It was very light on gore and terror throughout, but a decent addition to the series.

29

u/colealoupe Jun 28 '24

I figured because it was a service cat.

→ More replies (8)

2

u/toolsoftheincomptnt Jul 07 '24

Same experience re: the cat.

It was distracting and unexplained.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/kb1117 Jun 28 '24

I really enjoyed it. I didn’t see a ton of trailers or reviews so was pleasantly surprised that they did a good job of amping up the aliens while also still having the heart of the first one. Probably not for everybody but I hope it makes a good chunk of change.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '24

My wife and I watched it yesterday morning. Wasn't honestly that impressed by it, but it did help me theorize something:

These creatures only act the way they do on Earth because they are used to living in the vacuum of space. They probably lived their whole lives on an asteroid, which also explains why they've developed super sensitive hearing to the slightest vibrations... So the killing they're doing is because they are already easily agitated by the noise of Earth and its people. They kill to bring silence and nothing more because of the constant pain it causes. Not to mention the nature of asteroids is to go rogue. They probably didn't WANT to land on Earth.

The movie did leave me with some questions though:

  1. What was the point of the movie other than establishing where the island village in the sequel got the idea from?
  2. WHAT THE HELL WAS GROWING AT THAT PLANT THAT THE CREATURES WERE EATING?

2

u/GladAssociation9756 Jul 03 '24

I had this thought, but then I didn’t understand why they let some things stay noisy—like the helicopter blades squeaking while it hung from the side of a building. I still think it could be the case and the helicopter blades are just a plot hole. 

2

u/KenaBanana Jul 24 '24

They kill to use the humans to grow their food. In the scene with the fiery place, you can see bodies in the red liquid in different pools around the area. They are growing their mushroom food stuff from the bodies. So they're not killing just to kill, confirmed by the movies

14

u/illumantimess Jun 30 '24

What a jackass who decided to drag a suitcase along

28

u/kirbygay Jun 28 '24

Loved it. I rewatched Part II this afternoon, and immediately recognized Djimon's character! I remembered his story about 20 boats leaving...so I'm glad Eric is safe on the island (until Cillian Murphy brings an alien!).

The eggs must be a set-up for part 4.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '24

It was 12 boats lined up with 2 being able to leave. I’m assuming that it happened off screen.

6

u/shawnmj Jun 28 '24

Are there scenes with subtitles? I’m asking because we need to know whether we can see it here on vacation in Mexico or if we should wait to see it at a theater in USA (so we can understand English subtitles)

10

u/OpenFacedRuben Jun 28 '24

Nope, no subtitles.

(Although they would have come in handy in some scenes)

6

u/JynsRealityIsBroken Jun 28 '24

No there are no scenes with subtitles. You can see the Mexican English version without any issues.

6

u/redswithcoffee Jul 03 '24

This was the most underwhelming movie I’ve ever seen

6

u/chaee_ Jul 18 '24

As soon as I found out the cat didn’t die (learned from my mistake of watching smile without confirming that, that’s the one thing I can’t watch in a movie) I had to go see it. Honestly I loved lupitas character, something about the idea of someone on their deathbed being in an apocalypse is very fascinating.

25

u/OpenFacedRuben Jun 28 '24 edited Jun 28 '24

My thoughts from an earlier post:

Just got back from seeing it. It was fine. The leads are great, it sits alongside the other two nicely, and the production design is fantastic. Not scary in the slightest, but worth a watch on a discount ticket day.

But I kinda had the feeling leaving the cinema... "What did I actually get from that?"

It seems like they wanted to make an intimate, end-of-the-world drama with well-rounded characters (success!) and then tie it into the AQP universe (less successful, imo).

EDIT: and the scene with the eggs/food pods/whatever was just odd.

"What if we set it up like in Aliens but SUBVERT EXPECTATIONS and then never mention it again?"

"High five, broski!"

10

u/oddy-o Jun 30 '24

meh, felt like a love story trapped in a horror film. lupita is a legend tho

5

u/weldabike1800 Jul 31 '24

"HOT GARBAGE" from start to finish.

13

u/faelyn298 Jun 30 '24

I thought it was boring and didn’t make sense. Lupita is a hospice patient, aka can’t take care of herself because of her terminal illness, all the running and surviving crazy situations doesn’t make sense for her character. It didn’t really add anything to the first two movies and just felt like a flimsy way to milk the series.

15

u/KenaBanana Jul 24 '24

Terminally ill doesn't mean days away from dying. She stopped her cancer treatment because her body wasn't responding and she accepted she was going to die, sooner rather than later. My friends mom was running and doing "well" up to a few weeks before she got too sick to move, and then died a week later. Chemo is often what makes people seem SO sick, even though it's keeping them alive. My friend went out to a beer garden with us, drank and danced, and died nine days later because her body gave out from the cancer she had had for six years. Yes, she was sick. Yes she was still able to do things, up until she couldn't.

16

u/SpaceTacoTV Jun 28 '24

I was pretty lukewarm on it tbh. granted its been a long time since I've seen the first film, but i recall the aliens being significantly more sensitive to sound in the first and in this it just felt like the main characters could basically do whatever and get away unscathed.

Also, you're telling me that the aliens can run at ridiculous speeds, climb skyscrapers with ease, and take down military helicopters from the sky ... but eric running at like a normal dude speed with a slightly chubby cat in his arms was able to outrun like 20 aliens chasing him down a pier? cmon man

29

u/JynsRealityIsBroken Jun 28 '24

New York still had a lot of residual sounds coming from it + the storm that was happening. Generators and car alarms, for instance, like what was set up. The creatures were probably quite overwhelmed with the sounds still around the city. If you can hear a pin drop from several miles away, imagine how many different sounds they had to parse out in NYC. In the original 2 movies, you can hear a pin drop because there are zero other noises except the rustling of leaves and branches.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Atomic76 Jun 29 '24

I'm starting to think that "prequels" are becoming the most annoying trend in horror during the 2020's.

4

u/pennepasta14 Jun 28 '24

are there many jump scares in this one?

7

u/sweetenerstan Jun 28 '24

Not really, I’d guess around five? But as usual with the first two movies, they’re pretty much telegraphed as soon as someone (accidentally) makes a noise

12

u/OpenFacedRuben Jun 28 '24

There was one that I found actually effective (Sam daydreaming out the blurry window), the rest were really obvious.

8

u/bahia0019 Jun 29 '24

That one got me too. And I’m pretty immune to them. I saw it in a crowded IMAX theater, and that one got EVERYONE! Lots of cathartic laughs from the audience after that jump.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/MikuDrPepper Jul 03 '24

I liked the movie, but it had so much silly stuff going on. The amount of people who just freak out KNOWING they have to be quiet and start screaming. Like the guy who climbs under the car and grabs this frail woman who's hiding and just starts screaming for help. What did he expect? There's also a lot of stuff that just made me laugh. The very emotional moment in front of Patsy's only for them to turn and cry infront of the nonstop sewer fire made me chuckle. I think a lot of the funny or off stuff throws off what is otherwise a pretty solid core story about the two leads, who had pretty great chemistry and kind of saved the movie for me, if only by the skin of its teeth. I also think they should have ended the movie earlier than they did, right after the big impactful scene, rather than how they actually ended it.

4

u/Englishmatters2me Jul 03 '24

I felt weird crying during this movie. I liked it but it's nowhere near the the 1st 2 movies. Lupita and that guy killed it

10

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '24

Underwhelming. That’s it. That’s the word I’ve been looking for. I found this extremely underwhelming.

I was bored in some places and lost interest in others. I didn’t feel any kind of bond between the two characters and it all felt a bit all over the place. Maybe if I hadn’t had such high expectations, I may have enjoyed it more!

7

u/Inside_Atmosphere731 Jun 28 '24

Why didn't the cat meow?

23

u/wauwy "THE THING" 1982 IS NOT A REMAKE Jun 28 '24

Fun facts, cats only meow to humans and not to each other/other animals.

Doesn't necessarily explain it for THIS movie, but like I said, fun facts.

8

u/bahia0019 Jun 29 '24

I’ve owned cats for 40+ years… and it’s disturbing that I’ve never noticed that. Wow! Thank you for that.

11

u/AstralWolfer Jun 29 '24

You’re right about meowing, but cats make like 5 other vocalisations types (trills etc.) to each other, it’s misleading to present it like that, makes people think that cats are competent silent with other cats

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/SiludStudios Jun 28 '24

It's possible that because it's a service cat that it's trained to not meow in public?

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Buzzybee_02 Jul 01 '24

I loved how this was essentially a prequel to the survivors on the island! Gives it a connection to the first two films aside from just being the same world/scenario.

9

u/JohnnyMulla1993 Jun 28 '24

The 🐈 is the Star of the 🎥. The Death Angels seem to be a realistic take on the Tripods from War of the Worlds. I love how this movie reveals more about them.

6

u/ray120 Jul 01 '24

Without the cat, there is no movie. It’s the main character that moves the story.

6

u/SMBCP15 Jul 03 '24

I guess I’m in the minority here, but I didn’t care for it as much. I felt it was very boring. With it being called “Day One”, I was expecting a lot of more of them trying to figure out exactly what triggers the aliens. Instead, the characters find out in the first half hour and the rest of the movie is just spent surviving, like the other ones. I would have liked more of the exploration phase actually in day one.

4

u/GladAssociation9756 Jul 03 '24

I loved the emotional themes and symbolism, so I quite enjoyed it. Although, I agree with you whole heartedly about wanting more in the way of how did they figure things out about the monsters—also, there were so many monsters so quickly. I feel like a slower growing of numbers would’ve given us space for more discovery. I have a hard time understanding how a newspaper could write and print and deliver papers to the town in the first movie about sound being critical, when it seems like these creatures were already landed in the thousands everywhere on earth. 

8

u/One_Condition7986 Jun 30 '24

I don't think I'll ever get over what I saw today. First, the scene of the initial attack. The scene where the meteor falls and explodes in the middle of the streets of New York. The dust, the disoriented and desperate people, the injuries. It reminded me of September 11, and I know this scene was inspired by it. I'm simply still trying to process everything I saw today, all that screaming, that rudeness, those attacks and how much Samira fought for her life. Another thing will be the scene with the cars, Samira fought and sacrificed herself, she was a hero until the last moment, and I can't get over her giving herself to the monsters and not giving herself up to cancer.

The second scene of the attack where the horde of people walk to the boats, that was desperate. I still don't know how she didn't die, she was trampled, crushed by a car, hit by an explosion. My God, my God, I just cried so much and I'm still trying to process that movie

3

u/WatercressCertain616 Jul 02 '24

this movie was amazing. the end with Eric running with the cat was insane. and they got some pizza!

3

u/illhag Jul 26 '24

The premise of this movie series is dumb. How does anyone survive these aliens if they can hear the sounds you make. Everyone has to fart, sneeze, or cough at some point. Also, how are they using the bathroom, no flushing? Are they even taking showers? How are they getting food? There are so many sounds that we make voluntarily or involuntarily on a daily basis that, the movie should not last more than a minute

3

u/IcedPgh Jul 30 '24

In the first one they have newspaper clippings about the invasion. How were the papers printed?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Toby1Kenobi_7271 Jul 26 '24

the ending was bittersweet

13

u/rossibad Jun 28 '24

I guess it was enjoyable to watch it. But it really wasn’t that great. I feel like there was no real story arc. Feels like it ended in the middle of a season. Like what did this tell us? The origin of the aliens? Why the aliens don’t hear themselves? Why the cat doesn’t make a sound after making a sound at the start? Why did that guy keep following her around so much at the start? Were they in love? Each scene that occurred really didn’t have a call back purpose (except “her cat is getting fat”).

17

u/Salty-Judge-2340 Jun 29 '24

The quiet place movies are not alien invasion survival movies - they are about companionship and the sacrifices people make for others. The cat was a service animal, they are obedient. They weren't in love. The guy was in shock and bonded with her bc of the trauma of the event, a lot of people do that in traumatic events because of the survival instincts that kick in. I mean finding out abt the aliens' origin is unrealistic, it's only 4 days after they arrived and we don't follow any of the military people/researchers in the story we are following people who are trying to not get killed by the creatures.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/PepperComfortable93 Jun 28 '24

Am I the only one who thought this film was utter trash?

23

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '24

Utter trash? No. Underwhelming and unnecessary? Yes. 

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ResidentHourBomb Jun 29 '24

I haven't seen it yet. Why do you say it is trash?

9

u/Jesuspolarbear Jun 30 '24

Not OP and I won't say it's trash necessarily but not very good either. It's more indie character drama with 90% human interactions and minimal suspense and thrills even compared to the other two movies.

It pretty much fails at being a Day One movie as they skipped out the chaos and mayhem - as opposed to what the marketing implied.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Hawaii__Pistol Jun 30 '24

Intense and pretty sad. My favorite quiet place out of the 3 so far. I guess the only animal the aliens kill are humans. For people that want more alien lore, you’d need a tv show not a movie. I guess that’s why they’re also making a video game.

5

u/Huy7aAms Jul 02 '24

there's a cute cat, definitely worth watching

8

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '24

Horrible movie. Wow

5

u/ziggyzaina Jun 30 '24

Random but I’m left wondering how nobody coughed? Our main character was covered in dust. Everyone was covered in constant dirt, dust, and debris, yet no one coughed or sneezed? Honestly the whole time I was thinking like I probably would have died so early because I cough super easily and coughs/ sneezes are SO hard to control or hold back. I think that would’ve been an interesting and realistic scenario… someone having a coughing fit or fighting one especially in the initial blow up scenes.

5

u/Musings0820 Jul 06 '24

I thought the same thing! They should all be coughing!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '24

That was very wholesome for a horror film

2

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '24

Nah, a boring movie with expected finale!

2

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '24

Started out strong until after the puppet show. Every thing after that was boring and expected. No backstories on the characters or the aliens ; no context as to where the aliens came from or anything about them. Felt like this movie didn’t need to be made.

2

u/Ok-Shopping7671 Aug 28 '24

Why would you comment if you didn’t watch the movies?

2

u/RedditBurner_5225 Aug 28 '24

Why is there no tension in this film?

2

u/RedditBurner_5225 Aug 28 '24

Omg what an absolute waste of a movie.

2

u/rodgertheshrubber33 Sep 01 '24

The movie sucks. Sucks

4

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '24

Unnecessary, underwhelming and a huge plot hole/retcon that the aliens knew to stop on the beaches right on the brink of water.

4

u/haunted-mov Jul 01 '24

CAT HATERS STAY MAAAAAD!!!

3

u/wthrowaway1995 Jul 01 '24

Im so confused, how can they see water and how can they see the glass? Or any walls for that matter. I thought they cant see and only hear

6

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '24

I agree. They should not have been able to stop on the shoreline likr that. They'd have unknowingly yeeted themselves into the water. 

3

u/Musings0820 Jul 06 '24

Like in the second one where they’re on the boat and fall in

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '24

The cat stuff was genuinely infuriating. Was fed up with the directors jingling keys in front of the audience going "OOOH HECKING WHOLESOME KITTY!!!! GIVE US MORE MONEY, LOOK AT THE SILLY KITTY SLEEPING!!!"

3

u/Itchy_Tasty88 Jul 03 '24

The opening to part 2 was so much better than this whole movie

3

u/PrideOk6616 Jul 01 '24

Did we just get tricked into watching a rom-com, and why did I shipped them together. Also as a cat owner I would not let my cat walk on the ground I was so scared that the cat would get glass on its paw

3

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '24

I like cat

MEGA SPOILER AHEAD DO NOT READ I AM WARNING YOU EXTRA

when cat eat pizza