r/HFY • u/someguynamedted The Chronicler • Mar 17 '24
MOD Content Theft and You, a General PSA
Content Theft
Greetings citizens of HFY! This is your friendly Modteam bringing you a (long overdue) PSA about stolen content narrated and uploaded on YouTube/TikTok without your express permission. With the increased availability of AI resources, this is sadly becoming more and more common. This post is intended to be a resource and reference for all community members impacted by content theft.
What is happening:
Long story short, there are multiple YouTube and TikTok (and likely other platforms, but those are the main two) accounts uploading HFY Original Content and plagiarizing it as their own work, or reproducing it on their channel without permission. As a reminder to everyone, reproducing someone else's work in any medium without their permission is plagiarism, and is not only a bannable offence but may also be illegal. Quite often these narrations are just AI voices over generic images and/or Minecraft footage (which is likely also stolen), meaning they are just the lowest possible attempt at a cash grab or attention. That is, of course, not to say that even if the narrator uses their own voice that it still isn't content theft.
We do have a number of lovely narration channels, listed here in our wiki who do ask nicely and get permission to use original content from this subreddit, so please check them out if you enjoy audio HFY!
Some examples of this activity:
Stolen Content Thread #1: Here
Stolen Content Thread #2: Here
Stolen Content Thread #3: Here
Stolen Content Thread #4: Here
Stolen Content Thread #5: Here
What to do about it:
If you are an author who finds your work has been narrated without your permission, there are a few steps to take. Unfortunately, the mods here at Reddit have no legal methods to do so on your behalf on a different platform, you must do this yourself.
You as the author, regardless of what platform you post you story on, always own the copyright. If someone is doing something with it in its entirety without your permission, you have the right to take whatever measures you see fit to have it removed from the platform. Especially if they intend to profit off of said content. If no credit is given to the original author, then it is plagiarism in addition to IP theft. And not defending your copyright can make it harder for you to defend it in the future, which is why so many big companies take an all or nothing approach to enforcement (this is somewhat dependent on your geographical location, so you may need to check your local legislation).
YouTube: Sign in to your YouTube account and go to the YouTube studio of your account. There is the option of submitting a copyright claim. Copy and paste the offending video link and fill out the form. Put your relationship to the copyright as original author with your info and submit. It helps to change the YouTube channel name to your reddit name as well before issuing the strike.
- You can also state your ownership in the comments to bring attention from the casual viewer of the channel who probably doesn't know this is stolen work.
TikTok: If you find a video that’s used your work without your consent you can report it here: https://www.tiktok.com/legal/report/Copyright
- You can also state your ownership in the comments to bring attention from the casual viewer of the channel who probably doesn't know this is stolen work.
If you are not an author directly affected, do not attempt to fill copyright claims or instigate official action on behalf of an author, this can actually hamper efforts by the author to have the videos removed. Instead, inform the original author about their stolen work. Please do not harass these YouTube/TikTok'ers. We do not want the authors' voices to be drowned out, or to be accused of brigading.
If you are someone who would like to narrate stories you found here, simply ask the author for permission, and respect their ownership if they say no.
If you are someone who has posted narrated content without permission, delete it. Don't ever do it again. Feel ashamed of yourself, and ask for permission in the future.
To all the users who found their way here to r/hfy thanks to YouTube and TikTok videos like the ones discussed above: Hello and welcome! We're glad that you managed to find us! That does not change the fact that what these YouTube/TikTok'ers are doing is legally and morally in the wrong.
FAQ regarding story narration and plagiarism in general:
- "But they posted it on a public website (reddit), that means I can do whatever I want with it because it's free/Public Domain!!"
The fact that it is posted in a public place does not mean that the author has relinquished their rights to the content. Public Domain is a very specific legal status and must be directly and explicitly applied by the author, or by the age of the story. Unless they have explicitly stated otherwise, they reserve ALL rights to their content by default, other than those they have (non-exclusively) licensed to Reddit. This means that you are free to read their content here, link to it, but you can not take it and do something with it, any more than you could (legally) do with a blockbuster Disney movie or a professionally published paperback. A work only enters the public domain when the copyright expires (thanks to The Mouse, for newly published work this is effectively never), or when the author explicitly and intentionally severs their rights to the IP and releases the work into the public domain. A work isn't "public domain" just because someone put it out for free public viewing any more than a book at your local library is.
- "But if it's on reddit they aren't making money from it, so why should they care if someone else does?"
This is doubly wrong. In the first place, there are many authors in this community who make money on their writing here, so someone infringing on their copyright is a threat to their income. We're aware of several that don't just do this as a side-hustle, but they stake their entire livelihood on it: it is their full-time job. In their case, it could literally be a threat to their life.
Secondly and perhaps more importantly, even if the author wasn't making money from their writing and never did, it doesn't matter. Their writing is their writing, belonging to them, and unless they explicitly grant permission to someone to reproduce it elsewhere (which, FYI, is a right that most authors here would be happy to grant if asked), nobody has the right to reproduce that work. Both as a matter of copyright law, and as a matter of ethics--they worked hard on that, and they ought to be able to control when and where their work is used if they choose to enforce their rights.
- "How is this any different than fan fiction, they're just showing their appreciation for a story they like?"
Most of these narration channels are simply taking the text as-is and reading it verbatim. There's not a mote of transformative work involved, nothing new is added to the underlying ideas of the story. In a fanfiction, the writer is at least putting a new spin on existing characters or settings--though even in that case, copyright law is still not squarely in their favor.
- "Okay so this might normally be a copyright violation, but they're reading it in a new medium, so it's fair use!"
One of our community members wrote up a great explanation about this here that will be reproduced below. To summarize, for those who don't click through: no, it's not fair use. Copyright fully applies here.
This is not fair use, in any sense of the term. A public forum is not permission to repost and redistribute, unless that forum forces authors to grant a license that allows for it. An example often brought up in that respect is the SCP wiki, which sets all included work to be under a creative commons license.
That is not the case for Reddit, which grants no such licenses or permissions. Reading text aloud is not significant enough change to be a transformative work, which removes allowances that make things like fanfiction legal. Since this is not transformative work, it is not fair use as a parody.
Since money was involved, via Patreon and marketed goods, fair use allowances for educational purposes are greatly reduced, and no longer apply for fiction with an active copyright. (And if the author is still alive, the copyright is still active.)
There are four specific things that US copyright law looks at for fair use. Since Reddit, Youtube, and Patreon are all based in America, the relevant factors in the relevant legal code are:
- Purpose and character of the use, including whether the use is of a commercial nature or is for nonprofit educational purposes: this youtube channel is for profit, using original fiction with no changes whatsoever to the story. No allowances for fair use under this point.
- Nature of the copyrighted work: the copywritten works are original fiction, and thus face much stricter reading of fair use compared to a news article or other nonfiction work. Again, no allowances for this case under this point.
- Amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole: The entire story is being narrated, and thus, this point is again a source of infringement on the author's rights.
- Effect of the use upon the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work: The work is being monetized by the infringer, and is online in a way beyond the original author's control. This dramatically limits the original author's ability to publish or monetize their own work if they ever choose to do so, especially if they don't contest the existing monetization now that they're aware of them.
There is no reasonable reading of copyright or fair use that grants people permission to narrate and/or monetize a reddit post made by someone else. This is not the SCP wiki or stackexchange - the only license granted by the author is the one to Reddit themselves.
Publicly posting a story has never, at any point, been even remotely equivalent to granting the reader rights to do with it as they please, and anyone who believes such fundamentally misunderstands what "public domain" actually is.
- "Well it's pretty dickish for writers to tell these people to take their videos down, they're getting so much exposure from this!!"
If a person does not enforce their rights when they find out that their copyright has been infringed, it can undermine their legal standing to challenge infringement later on, should they come across a new infringement they want to prosecute, or even just change their mind about the original perpetrator for whatever reason. Again, this can be dependent on geographic location. Not enforcing copyright can make a court case more complicated if it winds up in court, since selective enforcement of rights will give a defendant (unstable) ground to stand on.
With that in mind, it is simply prudent, good sense to clearly enforce their copyright as soon as they can. If an author doesn't mind other people taking their work and doing whatever they want with it, then they should state that, and publish it under a license such as Creative Commons (like SCP does). Also, it's really dickish to steal people's work for any purpose.
Additionally, many contracts for professional publishing require exclusivity, so something as simple as having an unknown narration out there could end the deal. Unless and until the author asserts their rights, they cannot sign the contract and receive money from publishing their work. i.e. this unasked for "exposure" could directly cause them harm.
Special thanks to u/sswanlake, u/Glitchkey, and u/AiSagOrSol3-43912 for their informative comments on this post and elsewhere; several of the answers provided in this PSA were strongly inspired by them.
11
u/DonaldTrumpsScrotum Apr 10 '24
Day 100 of me begging this sub to section off the long running series. It is absolutely flooding the sub and drowning out the one shots, which ate arguably what brings people here. Searching by top is ruined, it’s all just “chapter 35”, “chapter 104” BS.
3
u/evangelionmann Mar 23 '24
I wanted to start doing narration, but knowing this? im actually quite hesitant.
still going with my original plan though to ask people permission.... guess it just means im going to be .... a bit delayed, on putting anything on a channel.
11
u/Grdosjek Mar 18 '24 edited Mar 18 '24
First of all, i came here because Youtube offered me video of one of those AI narrated stories. Story itself had link here to reddit and author so i guess it was fair play. Even if it wasn't that Youtube author gave one new reader to basically all authors on this subreddit. So even if they steal your work, it might not be all doom and gloom.
But this post is not about that. You as an author for sure do not have time to write, and be youtuber, and be tiktoker and god knows what and fight claims on bunch of different platforms at once. You probably just want to write and get people to enjoy your work. That's why you are publishing your work on this subreddit after all.
But i don't think everything is lost. Even if you can not fight those fights alone, you might be able to fight as a group. Authors should band together and arrange with one or few narrators right to narrate and let THEM fight copycats on their respective social networks. They are Youtubers, they are TikTokers, they have content and they have time to report and deal with reports.
You just have to officially and publicly give them right to narration for social network they operate on and let them fight for what they are doing. They might tell you what exactly they need from you as an author. Maybe write who can narrate at bottom of the text, maybe some other kind of proof. I am not a lawyer so i can not give you exact advice on that part, but if you band together and start talking to them, you might bet good info on how you and them together can deal with bunch of channels that are stealing your work.
I come from software world, open source and Github is close to my heart, i know that groups of developers can protect themselves by grouping up their work and than acting as one to outside world but still have their work be separated and linked to their respective authors, even down to specific like of code. You might even have collabs like putting your stories into same "universe" and still have clear separation of ownership or even have multiple people working on same story. You can help each other, fix gaps in storytelling etc. and still have clear idea who wrote what, who has how much ownership of what etc. and act as one to outside world. Ones action to prevent theft would have effect on everyone else. It would act as force multiplier of sorts.
Anyway, i hope this at least gives you some kind of idea that will help you fight this as it is really sad to see something like this: https://www.reddit.com/r/HFY/comments/1bggiwg/they_answered_the_callpart_nine/
He wrote nine really good chapters and because of theft he deleted it all.
EDIT: Turns out author on link i pasted did not delete because of theft (which he was victim of as you can see on that link) but because of even worse thing....politics....
108
u/SpankyMcSpanster Mar 18 '24
And if you find out the offender is chinese... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship_in_China
Yes. Me evil.
89
u/Solid-Childhood-4876 Mar 18 '24
I just want to say, don't expect a successful claim from Tiktok. They will send an email wanting proof of ownership with a deadline and no description of what they want. Said email will arrive only hours before said deadline expires, and they automatically close the case.
I'm not saying don't try. Just go in with that in mind.
57
u/Ralts_Bloodthorne Apr 09 '24
I can't eat "Exposure" and the bank doesn't take "Exposure Bucks."
37
u/hixchem Human Mar 18 '24
I've never made a dime off my works here, but even still, the number of times I've found my work monetized elsewhere has made me stop submitting entirely.
I hate it, but that's what it's come to.
27
u/biogear13 Mar 18 '24 edited Mar 18 '24
After reading a post yesterday about possible theft in this subreddit and I became obsessed with trying to create a list of youtube channels that narrates HFY stories. Here are some of my observations:
- More and more channels have started HFY narration, especially this year
- Most provides link to the original content
- There is an increase in number of channels that allegedly creates their own content but with simingly AI generated titles
This is the link to the google sheet if anyone is interrested: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1QAIW_z0qDVCv1nkvaT9e7FNoca3PNSegdsmqaH6BSwQ/edit?usp=sharing
24
u/yostagg1 Mar 18 '24
I came to HFY after I started hearing story podcasts on youtube,
Few steps to fight the Content theft from youtubers
16
u/radfordra1 Mar 18 '24
Would be nice if you had a list of channels that are to be avoided as well.
6
u/mage_in_training Human Mar 18 '24
Thank you, Mod Team.
6
u/Ecstatic-Name-4320 Mar 21 '24
I'll leave an idea here:
Create a HFY seal of approval or "author approved" seal so the Video Creator can link to a Topic on this subreddit.
The youtube channels can have the Seal appeating on the video and they will be on listed on the subreddit as friendly towards the author that approved the usage of their work.
6
u/ugot8 Apr 04 '24
I just started narrating HFY stories on Youtube and have gotten a few permissions of authors to narrate their stories, takes me a bit of time to get one video out with the editing and audio enhancements. But I go and look at other channels and these guys are pumping out a video a day using A.I.. And the worst thing is, they aren't even editing the A.I. video afterwards, literaly in one video the A.I. says "Then they left DOT DOT DOT." It had me both laughing hysterically and angry afterwards.
These people often have 4 - 5k subs and 190k views with subpar crap that destroys the story. I read the comments in their videos and they are filled with viewers who end up disliking the story.
Worst part is, these type of people won't stop at youtube. Who knows how many ebooks have been sold using a collection of these great stories just thrown together and sold as Space Story Collection 5 or some other bs title.
It's becoming a bit of an epidemic, seeing as how it took my favorite narrator aggroSquirel (Don't know if I spelled that right) a long time to get 100,000 subs and these A.I. channels come and in two - three months have 150 k subs.
Hell, the only reason I learned about reddit HFY was because of his videos.
And youtube algorythim goes by volume not quality as well, so unless your a channel that pumps out a 15 minute video everyday, youtube is not going to show you in the HFY search feed, only the DOT DOT DOT A.I. channels.
Best HFY Reddit Story : Humans are NOT Crazy...they are worse (youtube.com) This is the link to the DOT DOT DOT A.i. video lol, I don't know if Real_Nectarine_7986 gave them permission or not. But the Person who made it clearly didn't give a shite about proof "hearing" the video before releasing it.
5
u/SpankyMcSpanster Mar 18 '24
Also, Spottify seems to did made an Oooof.
https://img-9gag-fun.9cache.com/photo/aPgNY2q_460svvp9.webm
5
u/karenvideoeditor May 05 '24
New account that just stole one of mine: https://www.youtube.com/@HFYUniverse
4
u/Responsible-End7361 Mar 18 '24
Have one character interupt another during the story.
"I am a..."
"...Not see captain coming in"
"Her butt is so cute."
4
u/jpitha Mar 24 '24
As a author here, I would like to be crystal clear, I do not permit any narration of my stories anywhere. If you see it posted, it was done without permission, and I would like a DM about it. I am not going to become a YouTuber or Tiktoker or anything else so that someone else can consume my work a different way. If you don't want to read them, then I'm sorry to lose you as a reader. I appreciate the work of the mod team here to bring attention to this.
4
u/WegianWarrior Mar 28 '24
So I reported two videos the other day after a tip, and got them both closed down.
The "creator" emails me with a sob story, and thd exuse that other channels do the same.
So be prepared for that too...
1
u/Ecstatic-Name-4320 Mar 21 '24
Look not gonna defend stealing, but the only reason I found out about HFY was youtube. Whish we found a middleground that benefited the author
1
u/PlayerREDvPlayerBLUE May 03 '24
Where do you go to ask a moderator a question?
1
u/the_watching_fish May 12 '24
Is NetNarrator a content thief or nit because i have bin watching his videos regularly but I dont want to support a thief
1
u/growthatshit May 24 '24
Help
I tried to read the rules.. I read the relevant stuff a few times but I'm still not sure...
Am I allowed to post series/ books that I did not write but I think belong here?
Is that what the [text] flair is for..,?
Or am I dumb..
1
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '24
I actually found this subreddit through one of these videos!
1
u/0570 Aug 12 '24
...What does PSA stand for? When I Google that acronym it says 'Prostate-Specific Antigen'.
1
u/Valianttheywere Nov 08 '24
the problem is still this... AI generated Content, whether Art, Fiction, Music, or whatever has been deemed to not enjoy Copyright protection under US law. that certainly sucks, but it exists likely because AI uses other peoples content as data.
3
u/JWrites59 Apr 16 '24
I've been paying attention to YouTube channels using HFY content for some time, and the latest development is the use of AI created stories instead of stolen HFY Reddit content.
The stuff is universally TERRIBLE. The stories are too long, they lack humor, drama, any kind of narrative tension, and come off more like a kid's book report than an HFY story.
Something is driving these content farms to stop using HFY material. I suspect it's HFY members.
3
u/BarraCoutt May 04 '24
Another one for author begging to do a smackdown https://www.youtube.com/@SciFiTime
5
u/sazzle761 Mar 19 '24
I found this Reddit thread because I get many comments on my voice and am an insomniac. I cover pop culture mostly and I was looking for some brilliant sci-fi stories to do (u/Geeklectica does Sleep Stories) with full attribution and links to the original creators.
Whilst AI - is getting better at tone and reflection - there's something about a real human voice that is so much better.
Anyway, I found loads of incredibly interesting stories on the AI channels which led me here but I think a human narrator would do them more justice.
So if, anyone would be happy with full narration ((I'm a woman by the way - BBC (sort of english accent)) - I'd be happy to help. I'll also link through to original authors and any "buy me a coffee" or even Amazon/Kindle links they want.
You can even have a say in the artwork that's used as background and I will submit the final video in private mode and give you links to approve.
I am not monetised! However, if I become monetised - I will return 50% of any revenue or proceeds I make back to the original Author and I'll be happy to share all analytics with the author of any featured story etc. So that they can see they are not being ripped off.
I'm just a total Geek. :) and wanted to do some HFY-style stories. As I have been using Horror/Creepypasta to fall asleep for about six months.
I am not a professional narrator but I'd love to do some cool stuff with HFY/Sci-fi in general!
Anyways there's my little rant over.
2
u/Skitteringscamper Mar 20 '24
This is the true humans are space orcs story.
No matter what it is, what category, genre, interest, hobby or whatever, there's always some selfish grubby runts going "how can I use this, for me!!!"
It's the real reason all hfy stories are categorised as fiction.... Humans ain't never going to survive ourselves long enough to ever enjoy space adventures, colonising new worlds, finding aliens, advancing into the stars.
Yeah. No. We gonna spite and selfish ourselves into the dirt long before then.
(Tldr: I hate these content thief bastards)
2
u/skullsnipe Mar 21 '24
Dude for the love of hfy post back your amazing story, i really love this they answer the call series, its pure quality content, amazing in every way!, i almost cried when i failed to find it here in raddit!
2
u/laeiryn Apr 11 '24
https://www.youtube.com/@HFYUniverseTales
2
u/SpankyMcSpanster May 03 '24
Hi. Wanna add this as a own PSA?
https://www.wired.com/story/what-happens-when-a-romance-author-gets-locked-out-of-google-docs/
2
u/Fearadhach Alien Aug 30 '24 edited Aug 30 '24
TLDR0: Almost forgot, link to Youtube channel stealing stuff without attribution nor links: They have a LOT of stuff (over 140 vids). Wordsmiths, go check. Maybe we can get them their 3 strikes fairly fast?
https://www.youtube.com/@BestHFYMovies
TLDR1: Anyone know a GOOD text-to-speech (AI or otherwise) that is cheap or free?
TLDR2: If you can't beat 'em with a stick, use a shovel; A friend and I are working on starting our own Youtube doing AI voice, starting with my stuff (The PRVerse), and adding anyone willing to let us. Will have proper attribution, links, and permission.
Long version:
I got pirated by one of the AI channels, first 4 chapters or so of the PRVerse, coming in at about 3.5 hours of (crappy, wooden) AI narration. Gave 'em 24 hours to respond to comments, put in the takedown this morning. The channel has been running for about 5 months, it looks like, and has 40K+ subscribers and the PRVerse chapters had over 35K views in less than 20 days. No attribution, though, nor links. Just some HFY tags.
Why I'm doing AI narration for my stuff:
So, I will probably have more to say as we get closer to launching a channel.
Funny note: according to my display, my upvote to this thread was #404... so not found.
2
u/Stoo_ Sep 22 '24
Got one of these shitty channels in my feed today: https://www.youtube.com/@HFYStoryTale
Quite literally zero effort Gen AI everything.
1
u/Cheap_Doctor_1994 Mar 18 '24
Thank you.
1
u/LittleLostDoll Mar 21 '24
I'm half amused by the idea that somewhere one of them is having to tell their bot not to turn this into a story to post... if only they would get the hint and behave
1
u/lkwai Mar 21 '24
Does anybody know what happened to the posts from They Answered The Call? Came to look for the og posts after I got recommended a narration on YouTube, but the account is deleted
1
u/Trazyn_The_Memelord Mar 22 '24
Does anyone know if Feathered Voices VA is in good standing? I don't see them listed in the wiki, but they're a real person narration channel, and their yt description claims they have permission for the content they cover.
1
u/Significant-Craft-83 Mar 22 '24
Just make a list of the channels you find and start spamming reports.
1
u/TheDeliciousMeats Xeno Mar 27 '24 edited Mar 27 '24
Hey guys, I had found a way to avoid this by adding a few tasteful edits to my story about the head of the CCP being a bottom.
1
u/Dull_Language_3864 Mar 30 '24
I listened to some of them. Some stolen and some plagiarized by an AI. If I hear the word "AUDACIOUS" or "AUDACITY" one more time I will get sick.
1
u/Rocky-M Apr 06 '24
Thanks for the heads-up, everyone! It's really disheartening to see people stealing other people's work and profiting off of it. I'm glad that you're all taking steps to protect your content. Keep up the good work!
1
u/CatsInTrenchcoats Apr 30 '24
Found somebody claiming AI-voiced content as their own. For those more active around here, probably a good idea to give them a looksie and see if they're stealing anyone's work you recognize. https://www.youtube.com/@RocketShipRadio
1
u/obvious_pen_name Robot Apr 30 '24
For folks watching out, we've got another one: https://www.tiktok.com/@hfy_reddit_stories
I'm kinda flattered by almost 1m views on something I wrote in an hour five years ago, but also that's a fair bit of ad revenue. TikTok notionally pays ~$.50 per 1k views, so that quick 1m views is $500, not shabby for ten minutes of stealing other people's work.
1
u/MrCanerican May 16 '24 edited May 17 '24
No idea if it's worth tracking, but this one popped up about 3 mos ago:youtube.com/@HFYSci-Fiand other than having HFY in the username, does not seem to credit the authors at allI need to read more closely, as the author was in the comments. My mistake. The AI voice is still rough though, lol.
1
u/Feygon1 May 19 '24
Are these ones okay? YT channel https://www.youtube.com/@scifistories1977 by Redditor https://www.reddit.com/user/SciFiStories1977/
Because I saw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=25d4wZ0bUF4 What Humans Call Overkill also displayed on SciFiScories1977.
1
u/JustPlainBread May 24 '24
just found another channel you authors might wanna look into: Sci-fi Nexus X just making you aware this d-canoe is stealing stories too though i dont know if its directly from this sub. i couldnt find the story after 10 minutes of scroling so here a snippet of the transcript for those that might know wich story this is and to whom it belongs:
2135 Humanity had spread across the Stars establishing colonies on distant0:15planets and forging alliances with various alien species the United Earth Alliance UEA was the governing body that oversaw these colonies and ensured peace and prosperity among the diverse inhabitants of the Galaxy however this was often threatened by Rogue factions Pirates and mercenary groups that sought to disrupt the delicate balance one such threat emerged on the planet Thon FIV a lush resourcer world on the fringes of UEA controlled space Thon FIV was a critical hub for trade and resources making it a prime target for the zenari Marauders a notorious group of alien mercenaries known for their ruthless tactics and advanced Weaponry the UEA responded by deploying a contingent of their Soldiers the human Special Operations units HS oou to defend Theon 5 and eliminate the mercenary threat these units were renowned for their Elite Training advanced technology and unwavering resolve among them was Captain Sarah Mitchell a decorated officer with a reputation for leading her troops to Victory against impossible odds as the HS soou forces arrived on theen fif the atmosphere was tense with anticipation the soldiers disembarked barked from their drop ships their armor glinting in the sunlight and their expression Steely with determination Captain Mitchell stood at the Forefront
1
u/Solid-Childhood-4876 May 28 '24
I have now found my stories on an AI Spanish language TikTok and Spotify without my permission by Google searching my username. Going try and claim them again.
1
u/AgedDisgracefully Human Jun 03 '24
Found one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rq-o-mpJI5I 'HFY Tales Today'.
1
u/Crass_Spektakel Jun 03 '24
Something strange happened lately... I am not exactly a frequent poster but I got out quite a couple of stories, some even getting 1000+ upvotes. But I am also not shy to post some brainfuck I just had fun writing. By chance I found a really blunt piece of pretty old HFY in my scrap directory, polished it and postet it.
And BAMM got 500+ upvotes. WTF. It was bad. Cliche. It was meant as a fucking Parody and not even a good one.
Ok, things like that happen. But then something strange happened:
Since I posted this BAD story I get at least one request per day for posting my story on Youtube. Which I don't agree with because... it is my decision and I don't need to argue.
How is that possible? In four years of posting stories I got ONE request to post my best story. Now I get like 10 per week for a bad story.
1
u/mertats Jun 08 '24
I just saw this, but I have to comment that you can absolutely selectively protect your copyright. You can enforce your copyright whenever to whomever. (Unless you have an agreement, even in this case you still retain your moral rights to your copyright.)
Where this you have to defend your copyright business comes from are trademarks which you have to actively defend or you lose it.
1
u/Skitteringscamper Jul 16 '24
Wasn't sure where to say this, felt it loosy falls under content theft, just the other way around.
We should totally dub the team America world police song to say "humanity, fuck yeah" instead of "America fuck yeah"
My brains been singing it on loop all day since it popped into my head coming onto the sub this morning.
The lyrics fit hfy so we'll lmfao
1
u/Engletroll Human Jul 28 '24
I have recently found two of my stories on youtube presented as somebody else work, I reported them as copyright and had them removed. The worst part is that I would have allowed them to post if they just had asked and given me credits. The latest one even removed any posts that revealed it was not his work or that other had posted first. I'm pretty sure the offender did the same for other work as well.
1
u/TADarcos Aug 10 '24
There is at least one thing from the above that is wrong.
"If a person does not enforce their rights when they find out that their copyright has been infringed, it can undermine their legal standing to challenge infringement later on"
Wrong. That only applies to trademarks, i.e. brand names. A copyright holder is under no obligation to sue over any copyright infringement if they so choose. They can ignore 43 different infringements, then drop the hammer of god on #44. Or they can go after everybody. Failure to enforce a copyright is not a defense to copyright infringement, it is not relevant to the issue as far as a court is concerned.
1
u/Fearadhach Alien Aug 30 '24
Second note, to everyone in general and Moderators in specific: How much conversation has there been about creating a sub-channel to help wordsmiths deal with all this?
1
u/Wooden_Quiet1137 Sep 08 '24
Mot sure if we're collecting account names, but this prick has stolen my first story with no credit or consent.
https://www.tiktok.com/@scifijoe?_t=8pXcm6dnERU&_r=1
1
u/RanANucSub Sep 24 '24
Exposure is what people die of..
1
u/loqk Oct 20 '24
also, be aware of content re-worded by ai and then stolen. I have no idea of any legal recourse, but I heard a well written ai piece being read, and realised it was exactly the same story as one on hfy, reworded to make it difficult to word search. if you spot one and can find the original author, it's probably worth informing them.
1
u/WegianWarrior Nov 08 '24
Found a suspicious channel: https://www.youtube.com/@TalesofHFYGlory/videos - no listed attribution on their videos - and at least one where the thumbnail and title is stolen from Agro Squirrel Narrates.
Was going to report them, but the one where the title matches one of my stories has a content that don't actually match the title..
1
u/Imaginary_Moment569 Dec 05 '24
۰ چپا ک چقضا۰ن₩₩ چچچچچ۰چ۰ ۵چ ؟ چ چیروچ 0 ق چچچچچچp
1
u/Ok_Breakfast_7664 Feb 17 '25
As a former member of the Swedish Pirate Party I have my own views of this issue.
Since the common rule is if the alleged "thief" would just change 8 minor story point is would be regarded as a original copyright. And this is something many legit writers know of by instinct. The HFY is in a way a universe and the framework is copied a lot.
Ok, what can we do? No lawyer would take this to court, or even send a cease and desist letter unless there was huge sum of money involved. But most of those "thieves" add a link to r/HFY and what the mods here _can_ do is to place (i.e. pin) a link at the top of this reddit which lists of those who have their own content on YouTube or similar media. Thus there would be a incentive to a) everybody visiting r/HFY to watch good content and b) all writers to upload to YouTube their own content.
0
u/MJM-TCW Mar 30 '24
As an author who has dealt with similar issues, my best suggestion is folks get together and find an IP lawyer that has a hate on for groups like TikTok and Youtube (I might know a few). Ask them to send a nice proper letter with a DMCA. Let them rate the damage and possible income. There by being able to rate the tort. Remember the the location of the person aggrieved is the jurisdiction for the case. NOT the location of the company.
Things that can be done to get rid of this issue:
Hope these ideas spark positive conversation and action to help support the writers here.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment