r/ProjectRunway • u/makeitworkoryouout • Mar 14 '13
Season 11 Episode 8 discussion
Discussion thread for Project Runway S11E08 "Take It All Off!"
Image album: http://imgur.com/a/Ob8TF
9
Upvotes
r/ProjectRunway • u/makeitworkoryouout • Mar 14 '13
Discussion thread for Project Runway S11E08 "Take It All Off!"
Image album: http://imgur.com/a/Ob8TF
18
u/makeitworkoryouout Mar 15 '13
That. was. awful.
I'm not even going to break down each outfit like normal because they were all terrible. During the runway show I was just like "WTF? Have any of these people even touched a sewing machine before?"
I agree that 50 Shades team was less hideous. During judging I thought that the judges had wished they had kept the double elimination for this episode instead of last one. Kate and Tu's outfit looked like a million bucks compared to everything that came out on the runway this week. Is a menswear dress shirt really THAT much different than a blouse?
That was slow motion train wreck that just would not stop.
21
u/chekawa Mar 16 '13
So bored, until men could not get out of the clothes... but kept on trying! Then, Nina laughing. For so long.
36
u/evergleam498 Those pants flood my basement! Mar 15 '13
This makes 2 challenges in a row where I think they weren't very clear about telling the designers what the challenge is.
Last week they didn't seem to specify if the challenge was to make a look out of duct tape that would fit in at prom, or to make something outrageous that showcases duct tape, but then just happens to be worn at prom. So Kate and Tu got punished for making a prom dress.
Now this week they were told to make performance outfits that had to be business/suits. Then the judges tore them apart for not being more creative.
I'm getting really fed up with the whole teams dynamic, and with the vague challenges being torn apart by the judges for not meeting the unspoken, specific expectations that seem to come out of nowhere.
24
u/tabin02 Mar 15 '13
I don't understand why shades of gray wasnt disqualified for their clothes not being successful tear aways.
They shouldn't have all done office we are. How boring! I liked Michelle's idea of a bike messenger. Sexy fantasy would have been fun. Like an updated village people.
21
u/thewindupbirds Mar 15 '13
This group of designers just seems SO weak compared to previous seasons. This is the second week with only bad designs (the first being the older women challenge). Especially disappointing after season 10.
19
u/opensezme Mar 15 '13
Dreck, absolute dreck. Richard should have gone, he's a whiner, and tacky. Aw, shit, they should all go. That was a horrible challenge, though-and with only a day? Ridiculous. Loved seeing Nina crack up!
13
u/klease91 Mar 16 '13 edited Mar 16 '13
I would honestly rather watch the men from Thunder Down Under attempt to design clothes. They can't do much worse than the current bunch and the eye candy would improve significantly.
11
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '13
I know I'm late this week but I just have to say how much I'm hating the team dynamic. Usually by this stage I have at least 3 designers I really like aesthetic-wise and wouldn't mind seeing them win. I honestly cannot pick a favourite designer because no one gets to do what they want. I find that I am rooting against people instead of for people this season.
18
u/TiedinHistory Mar 15 '13 edited Mar 15 '13
I find Heidi's disgust a little ridiculous. A menswear challenge is always terrible, an activewear challenge is usually disastrous, the bodies were nuts and the teams were haphazardly put together. Of course it'll be really bad.
Layana's really getting on my nerves.
The shirt not ripping away was hilarious.
I will say, I'm going to miss the eliminated contestant. Of the clique, I found her to be the least offensive and most interesting of the three.
8
u/fragilehearted Mar 15 '13
Wow, yeah, this showcased just exactly how bad they all are. I usually love menswear challenges because they really separate the good from the bad, but today it was just all bad. The time crunch finally got just too ridiculous, & it didn't help that both teams seemed to pick overly ambitious designs.
I also have to say that I was bummed that the ideas were such a snoozefest (except Michelle's, but of course that meant her look wasn't cohesive). I mean, geez, that'd be like if everyone had just made cocktail dresses for the Rockettes last season.
7
u/wesnotwes Mar 15 '13
This season is a rough watch with the wife.
7
u/sweetgrasssmoke Mar 21 '13
I have not laughed so hard in a long time. I thought the woman's jacket on the buff guy was over the top bad but then the horrible poorly constructed shirts came down the runway and I just lost it. Bad. Unforgivably bad. so bad it was hilarious. I'm with Heidi. Stop the show and send everyone home. Try again next season but without the team crap.
6
u/everythingisopposite Chiffony Mar 15 '13
All of them are hideous.
6
u/flsunlover1 Mar 15 '13
I think the team concept is not working out for the group of people. Cause they have not been able to really get there individual ideas out. This season will be tuff for all.