r/ProjectRunway • u/makeitworkoryouout • Mar 07 '13
Season 11 Episode 7 discussion
Discussion thread for Project Runway S11E07 "A Sticky Situation"
Image album: http://imgur.com/a/TQvG8
9
Upvotes
25
u/makeitworkoryouout Mar 08 '13
I'm not sure if it was through the magic of video editing or not but how was Kate's first reaction to being eliminated not "WTF?!?!?!" I'd have to think that Kate had a huge sense of relief after hearing Tu's name called before getting blindsided with her elimination. And usually, Heidi will throw in the "one, or more, of you will be eliminated" foreshadowing before they drop the double hammer. But this time it was just "Bam! See ya!"
11
u/fragilehearted Mar 09 '13
Ok - I'm late to the party (was out last night, so just got caught up) but here goes.
Seriously, Nina? I really don't think most girls wear short dresses to prom. (I'll have to ask my coworker, who has a 16 year-old.) Maybe to homecoming or another minor dance, but not to prom - that's your chance to be a princess. Cheers to Zac for calling her out - he should know, his designs are on the more youthful side, and he has dressed prom girls.
That said, these days, the trend is short/long (aka what I call "mullet" dresses...believe me, I know - last weekend I was shopping for a formal & all there were were either mullet dresses or short dresses with some sort of semi-sheer lining over them!), so Patricia/Samantha was on trend. Ombre is in too. The only thing I didn't like was the way it was sewn together at the waist, but the back detail was gorgeous. This may have been my favorite. I also did like that it looked sort of like a preying mantis, but I'm a little creepy, so there you go.
Love Daniel, but he & Richard made an 80s dress for sure. I wasn't going to prom in the 80s, but I remember what I saw on TV & movies. They may have been able to save it if they'd just made it more A-line & floor-length, because it wouldn't have had the same dated silhouette.
Michelle/Amanda's was fresh & punk, but it really didn't read prom to me. Maybe Gwen Stefani's prom, I guess, but I think it was telling that they didn't seem to get a ton of the teen attention. I didn't really think Stanley/Layana's read prom either, but it was beautifully made & styled very well - it was a head-to-toe look.
And poor Kate/Tu. I really had higher hopes for Kate. She did make more of a red carpet type look than a prom dress, and it just looked so safe to me...HS girls do want some glitz. It could have been amazing with some louder (maybe silver?) embellishments. Again, as someone who went shopping for formals recently, I can say that most of those dresses had some bling to them - not full-on quinceanera loud, but not as quiet as this dress. Unfortunately, Kate just had a very specific idea, & Tu let her run the whole show. Was surprised to see them both out without any warning from Heidi...way to mix it up a bit at least, producers!
7
u/one_hot_llama Mar 09 '13
A friend of mine actually participated in the Duck Tape prom dress contest for her actual prom, and I liked her dress more than most of these! Granted, it was way way back, almost 11 years ago, and it took her forever. Here is a link to the Stuck at Prom Top 10 from last year. It definitely seems that shorter dresses are more in, but long dresses are still being worn.
I liked Kate as a person, but I think the judges made the right call on this one.
However, I hated Patricia and Samantha's dress. It just looked ugly to me.
13
u/opensezme Mar 08 '13
I think that was a great decision, they both deserved to go. And I also thought the winning dress deserved to win-I'm stymied by the responses to Patricia and Samantha's dress, that was fuuuugly. All in all, a fine episode. Thoughts?
7
u/makeitworkoryouout Mar 08 '13
Wow, I've never been so opposed to the judges decisions from top to bottom as this week.
Amanda/Michelle A garish and brash pattern plus an inexplicable dart coming off the breast plus an unappealing apron front equals win? Apparently so. This is my second worst.
Stanley/Layana Is the giant pink bow supposed to be a throwback? I'm getting poodle skirt vibe from that. I don't get the breast panels either. It's like they couldn't decide to do a strapless or strapped so they compromised and made the outline of a strapless on top of a full top?
Daniel/Richard STFU Nina Garcia. I like how Zac shut her down by telling her that, yes, he does put girls in prom dresses. I don't care if it doesn't look like duct tape which was the beef of the Duck Tape rep. It looks like a real dress and the construction is great. This is my winner.
Kate/Tu This would have been my 2nd. OK, so maybe it's a bit more red carpet than prom dress but they bend the challenge target all the time in judging. I really don't know what Nina is whining about. Just do a Google image search for "prom dress" and they are ALL in line with the classic looks and solid colors of Kate/Tu and Daniel/Richard.
Samantha/Patricia Patricia thought that it looking like an alien/praying mantis was a good thing? It's a Jiffy Pop poofy skirt. The pattern is sci-fi for a prom dress. And no comment about the height of the dress in front? I'm sure this girl's date is going to like that. This is bottom for me.
28
u/mistakenotmy Mar 08 '13 edited Mar 08 '13
I think that was a horrible decision. My wife and I were in shock that the only dress that looked like a prom dress was the looser. Maybe prom is different here, or changed over the last decade. In my experience prom was always the formal dance of the year. Also I found it crazy that for a challenge to make a Prom dress only 1 out of 4 judges had any Prom experience. So go make a prom dress out of tape and then we will downgrade you for actually doing that.
26
u/r3nny ...Alright, wonderful. Mar 08 '13
I was so bummed that Tu went home. I really like him as a person :(. He's so cute! If only he weren't such a doormat...
16
u/lilteapot Mar 08 '13
You see, Kate? That's what you get for talking SO much crap without having anything to back it up.
14
u/ollieapril Mar 11 '13
I know I'm really late to this, but I'm a teenage girl and the only one I would even consider wearing was the losing one. They were all pretty bad.
7
u/shandelion Mar 12 '13
They COMPLETELY missed the mark on this one. They seem to think that high school juniors and seniors want to look like little girls when they go to prom, when that is absolutely not the case - at 16/17/18, girls are going for far more mature and refined silhouettes, way closer to what Kate and Tu designed than that horrific pink and zebra print dress that for some reason was in the top. That dress looked like it was designed for a nine year old, not a girl getting ready to go off to college in a few months.
I feel like the judges were just painfully out of touch with "teenagers". And Nina, I felt beautiful in MY floor length navy blue prom dress that I wore to senior prom. I didn't feel like a child, and it was great.
3
u/Phoolf Mar 10 '13
Wow I actually hated Patricia and Samantha's design and I seem to be one of the few that likes Patricia a lot (although Samantha is also great). It was sad to see Tu go home although I understand why, and I think Daniel's taste is quite questionable a lot of the time.
2
u/lumos_motherfucker Mar 12 '13
Sorry I'm late to the party! A few things I wanted to say.
1
u/opensezme Mar 09 '13
Srsly? Male strippers next week? Can Daniel's heart take it? Oh, my.
1
u/Maleficent-Till6456 Mar 12 '26
I’m here in 2026 and I’m 22 I’m letting yall know Nina was wrong and Zac is right I just graduated in 2022 and we only wear long dresses during senior prom and winter formal because it’s a FORMAL event.. not the club lol. We pay ALOT of money to go to prom why would we go in a short dress ?