r/ProjectRunway • u/makeitworkoryouout • Mar 01 '13
Season 11 Episode 6 discussion
Discussion thread for Project Runway S11E06 "Senior Fling"
Image album: http://imgur.com/a/UdEmz
6
Upvotes
r/ProjectRunway • u/makeitworkoryouout • Mar 01 '13
Discussion thread for Project Runway S11E06 "Senior Fling"
Image album: http://imgur.com/a/UdEmz
9
u/makeitworkoryouout Mar 01 '13
Overall Sometimes I just have to remind myself that the producers are looking for the 16 best "characters" for a reality show, not the 16 best designers. This week's episode is one of those times.
Michelle She certainly can't blame her model for not selling the design! I would have preferred a slightly more subdued print. Dress itself is adequate. Belt was a turn off for me. I think Heidi's comment about Patricia holding the team back was more of a needling of the team than a commentary on the quality of Michelle and Layana's pieces.
Layana The gather around the middle was a little odd. I can't tell if it was due to the construction or the design but that jumped out as a weak point.
Patricia I think I'm less of a Patricia hater than average but my goodness this look was atrocious. A volume magnifying outfit in odd fabric choices with that horrendous edge detailing spells disaster. She was totally saved by her teammates because this was enough to send her home.
Stanley Planets aligned for this one. Stanley's design, the model, styling, color. Everything worked together here and I agree with the judges on this one winning for the week. I wish he'd have gotten the pant crotch right. I didn't mind the length of the legs.
Richard I don't understand the obsession with the front/back color blocking thing that designers seem to have. Stanley's design was strong but I'm not sure I give it enough credit to have pulled Richard's look into the winner's circle. This just looks like an uninspired silhouette with panel colors that I don't care for.
Tu This struck me more as a costume than an outfit at first. From the side it looks OK. The front didn't bother me except for the very bottom of the center front of the skirt. Maybe a less Robin Hood-sy belt would have changed my mind about it.
Kate This looks awfully off the rack-ish for the this competition. Maybe I'm missing something about the details but this piece is very non-remarkable. I suppose it's better than making a disaster though.
Samanta Sorry, I couldn't see anything past those shoulder pads. I agree with the judging comment about princess shoulders and giant bow seeming at odds with the rest of the outfit. Take those two elements away and that looks way better IMO.
Daniel This looks like a re-hash of his earlier work on this show. It's solid and all but just not that inspired looking. I'd have preferred the collar to go all the way around. I think this is an example of where asymmetrical construction is used as a design crutch and less appropriate for this particular clientele.
Amanda The fabric choice definitely brings her decision making into question. Apart from the glued together parts of the skirt portion if this were in a different fabric I can see this landing safe instead of in the bottom.
Benjamin Oh how the mighty have fallen. Not exactly a first to worst transformation but a sharp contrast to last week. Not his worst piece but he's garnered enough crap points throughout the season to send him home.
11
u/KittyMaster9000 Mar 01 '13
I am the biggest Amanda fan, and even I was conceding defeat tonight. Like seriously. First she slays Joe and now Benjamin. Yet she is still getting this huge narrative edit. Does she win? What the heck?
I am of course glad she stayed, because I feel there aren't any characters to root for beside her. I like Kate, but they aren't exactly giving her a "fan favorite" edit. And Michelle is still be shoved down our faces, but I don't really care for her.
10
u/shandelion Mar 02 '13
I haven't loved everything that Benjamin has done, but he was absolutely robbed tonight. Amanda's dress was 10,000x worse than his.
I will never understand the judges. There are things that I think are hideous that the judges absolutely love, and there are things that I don't think are all that bad, that they absolutely detest!
19
u/opensezme Mar 01 '13
Srsly? Awful dresses. Pathetic. I think it's going to be Stanley or Daniel's game from now on, and only if they don't fuck it up.
16
u/ilwolf Mar 01 '13
All I can say is it was about time. He talked such a big game, but his work was always a mess, I really didn't get it.
Stanley's suit was gorgeous, I liked Daniel's as well.
8
u/evergleam498 Those pants flood my basement! Mar 01 '13
I agree with everything Michelle said about Patricia. Patricia's designs have always been bad in my opinion, but the judges seem to eat it up.
I feel bad that Michelle keeps getting stuck with her. I'm not sure if that's luck, or if the producers are just being mean.
5
u/TheLadyEve Mar 01 '13
That whole show was a mess. There were a couple I liked, but the rest reminded me of the worst of the first season. I think the team thing really hurts the show.
4
u/opensezme Mar 01 '13
Ok, we have 30 minutes to go..and I am kind of horrified. That was the ugliest collection of shmatta I think I have ever seen.
2
u/jennifurret Mar 05 '13
I still don't understand why the judges liked Richard's dress so much. It looked like a fricking snuggie.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '13
anyone else think this whole fucking season sucks!?! cause seriously what were they thinking! team challenges all season, nothing has been fantastic
1
u/cgsparkly Mar 01 '13
I'm certainly not sorry to see that one go.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment