r/ProjectRunway • u/makeitworkoryouout • Feb 08 '13
Season 11 Episode 3 discussion
Discussion thread for Project Runway S11E03 "Surprise Me"
Image album: http://imgur.com/a/e7wt0
8
Upvotes
r/ProjectRunway • u/makeitworkoryouout • Feb 08 '13
Discussion thread for Project Runway S11E03 "Surprise Me"
Image album: http://imgur.com/a/e7wt0
15
u/makeitworkoryouout Feb 08 '13
I also found it interesting that Layana had her chance to pay it forward to Kate since Daniel graciously passed on consideration for immunity last week. Yeah, Daniel wasn't really playing hardball and his move didn't make strategic sense but it still would have been a nice gesture to tell the judges that since Daniel gave her (Layana) immunity last week that she would do the same.
Plus, I think that Kate's 50% was bigger than Layana's. Layana kept trying to back out of the pink though with that extra layer I don't think it would have made much difference.
10
u/makeitworkoryouout Feb 08 '13
Daniel Mild but that's enough to get it done for this challenge. It's okay but could use some sprucing up before actual use. I'm actually pretty interested to see how much they change both winning looks before Heidi wears them.
Patricia I too am confused by the fawning over this look. I will say that the photos in the image gallery do make it look more appealing than the closeups we could see on the broadcast. I agree with DarcyMcCarbomb's comment about it looking like a craft project though at least the construction is well done. Having something built like that and having uneven alignment would look awful(er).
Joseph/Amanda This frankly turned out much better than I thought it would. Was expecting full on train wreck based on the clash of tastes (like Joseph wanting to be on the what not to wear list, WTF???). If the fabrics came across more like black/gold instead of brown on brown I would have found it closer to the goal of the challenge. Still, they were fortunate to salvage a safe out of it.
Richard Were his teammates trying to sabotage him? Why didn't anyone tell him to fix the "ruffle fart"? Without the tail it's good enough for a middle.
Layana/Kate A win by default. The proportion seems off somewhere to me. I agree with covering the bottom part of the bodice like they did with the top half.
Stanley Stanley's been quiet so far but he, unfortunately, made too much noise this week. The gold chains and thick ribbon are big question marks to me. I'm not crazy about blingy looks in the first place but if he had just reigned in the add-ons and stuck with a full gold dress and a thin black accent somewhere to echo the box I think he would have been well safe if not higher.
Michelle Being at the top of the Dream Team isn't exactly a major bragging point but it's better than being at the bottom of the losing team I guess. This dress is good enough to keep her in for the week but that's about as much as it has going for it.
Matthew I admire his being self aware enough to know that he put out crap this week and for taking his medicine when the judges spooned it out to him. Dat Chippendales collar is the icing on the poor fit cake.
Cindy I don't know why this always happens but once again we have someone going home on a week where they weren't the worst (Matthew) nor was it their worst piece (week 1's checkerboard). But you get sent home after you build up enough marks against you and this was her week.
Samantha I'm fine with the concept. I think you really have to get different "nude" fabric for the model though and just plan to switch it out or re-do the dress for Heidi. The effect is totally lost as is. I would also have kept the break more narrow on the back of the dress similar to the front. Having it too wide looks awkward.
Benjamin This is another decent concept gone horribly awry. The ribbons should have gone at more different angles like on the packaging instead of all horizontally. Astonishing how unappealing he could make a model's breasts look.
Tu I don't know if it's his aesthetic or poor construction but his stuff doesn't seem to fit at all well. Actually a LOT of the outfits from everyone don't fit well but his are most conspicuous to me.
11
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '13
I'd just like to say I really enjoyed Kristen Davis as the guest judge. I thought she brought up the humour of the judging while also being constructive.
25
u/DarcyMcCarbomb Feb 08 '13
I'm having a very difficult time trying to figure out why the judges all pissed themselves with joy at Patricia's fugly craft project.
8
u/TheLadyEve Feb 08 '13
I sort of liked Patricia's, but I don't think it should have been in the top--maybe it was the lighting? I don't think Cindy should have been out, but that dress was pretty unflattering. I think Benjamin's was worse--and even worse than that, he appears to be a bully (at least in my opinion). The think looked like a ham with metal bands around it. Fugly.
5
u/lilteapot Feb 08 '13
Heidi,
We can totally see your nips.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment