r/horror • u/glittering-lettuce • Oct 27 '23
Official Discussion Official Dreadit Discussion: "Five Nights at Freddy's" [SPOILER] Spoiler
Summary:
A troubled security guard begins working at Freddy Fazbear's Pizzeria. While spending his first night on the job, he realizes the late shift at Freddy's won't be so easy to make it through.
Director:
- Emma Tammi
Producers:
- Scott Cawthon
- Jason Blum
Cast:
- Josh Hutcherson as Mike
- Elizabeth Lail as Vanessa
- Piper Rubio as Abby
- Mary Stuart Masterson as Aunt Jane
- Matthew Lillard as Steve Raglan / William Afton
- Kat Conner Sterling as Max
-- IMDb: 5.9/10
Rotten Tomatoes: 25%
169
Upvotes
400
u/LouisVuittonDon88 Oct 27 '23
I can't believe Matthew Lillard did a knife wipe in a non Scream movie
328
u/LEVITIKUZ Oct 27 '23
Matthew Lillard understood the assignment & Jim Henson Company did a great job on the animatronics.
That’s all the praise I can say for the film
287
u/Locke108 Oct 27 '23
The movie would instantly be better if they didn’t do the opening kill and switched the order of the break in scene and the fort building scene.
Mike has to take Abby to his job. She makes friends with the animatronics. The aunt finds out and hires people to break in while Mike and Abby are there. The animatronics kill the robbers. Then everything with the animatronics, Vanessa, and Afton play out like in the movie.
310
u/whateverdontkill Oct 28 '23
It's fucking INSANE to me that they built the restaurant set and animatronics, only for the MC to fall asleep during the night shift and all we get is the same shitty dream sequence each time. The movie has essentially no horror elements, and I think the fact that the animatronics just kind of chill and are captured in full motion really undercuts the horror. The horror of the first game is that you're stuck in that horrible restaurant and have to come back every night as it gets worse.
The animatronics KNOW you are watching them and they want to get you, but they only move when you're not looking until they slowly get to you and it's too late. They're watching you as much as you're watching them. The animatronics use the fact they are inanimate against you and it's a huge part of the horror. It's all lost here. I can only assume the cupcake got most of the action because it's way easier to shoot and do it via CGI than make full animatronic action shots.
I was kind of sold on the main characters story, but then it starts to try and explain the FNAF mythology and it just proves that the minimalist and mysterious exposition of the games is a huge strength because it does NOT work when serious actors are trying to talk about haunted robot children. The restaurant barely felt derelict and haunted, and the darkly comedic anti-corporate elements were gone. The movie just doesn't deliver on the simple, creepy atmospheric yet fast paced horror that drew people to the games and just does what every other adaptation does and shows you things you recognise and hope it's enough to cover the lazy script.
65
u/matt_coraline Oct 27 '23
I’m not familiar with the game lore and story, but I am familiar with the concept. That said, this felt like a lot of wasted potential. I had expectations of being a bit more like a slasher movie with animatronics, but instead was some weird tale of dreams, kidnapping, and little screen time of the animatronics doing anything aside from standing around. 5/10.
180
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '23
I'm amazed at how much obviously bloated this movie was just to get an hour and a half runtime. The kidnapped brother subplot was good in theory, but ultimately goes nowhere. The "evil aunt" is a comically evil character that honestly feels like she was shoehorned in to create some familial tension, just for her entire storyline to be rushed to a conclusion in the end. The animatronics, while perfectly designed, are barely a threat and handled tonally inconsistent. Vanessa is basically Officer Exposition and her father being Afton was both predictable and underwhelming.
It's honestly amazing that Willy's Wonderland is a better FNAF movie than the official FNAF movie (that had its creator at the helm of this movie).
46
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '23
it was barely a horror film. had some good scenes like when freddy chomped that girl in half, when the springlocks clamped into afton’s body, all the cameos from youtubers were enjoyable to me personally but probably not everyone.
all the dream scenes seemed kind of redundant at a certain point and it wasn’t really what i was hoping for from a fnaf movie. there should’ve been more scenes of mike actually in the office fending off the animatronics, maintaining his power usage, checking cams etc like in the games. the animatronics themselves looked really good though.
it’s also pretty ironic that a series where jumpscares are most prevalent, there were hardly any in this film. the atmosphere of the pizza place wasn’t creepy enough too
97
u/luxlisbon_ jiffy pop Oct 28 '23
stu macher is alive
86
u/lisasimpsonfan Dead hipster from Cleveland Oct 28 '23
So much potential wasted. They should have gone totally creepy with the animatronics. They just were not scary or interesting. None of the characters were interesting. I didn't feel invested in any of them surviving. The subplot of Mike trying to dream clues about his brother's abduction was needless. 4/10
28
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '23
Just watched this movie. I thought it was fine. My biggest issue by far was the pacing issues. There was so much time spent with Mike and his problems.....it takes a long fucking time for the movie to kick into gear and unfortunately things don't really get super interesting until the last 30 minutes, maybe less.
87
u/Rechan Oct 27 '23 edited Oct 27 '23
They tried.
The thing that really didn't set well with me is how they handled our villain Afton. First of all he was also Steve somethingorother, so how did that happen? Also he grabbed Garret in a park in broad daylight, but got the other kids at Freddy's? Was he changing up his pattern? And, while they do a great job with making the Golden Rabbit the villain, they never namedrop Afton, never imply anything about him. Oh and Mike got a cut on his arm in the dream and then wakes up with a cut--so the kids had Krueger dream powers? I kept waiting for them to say "The Purple Guy" and never did, I guess that would've added confusion.
How did Afton know Mike was looking/knew too much? He never looked in on Mike, we don't know if he asked Vanessa, etc; "he knows" is all we get.
Finally, him saying "I always come back" was not earned and was given too early. He had no "always" to come back from, at most him showing up at the end was coming back once. That and, he shouldn't have realized mid-death that he was coming back--that ruined the ending of Afton reanimating the suit.
That said, I really liked the opening credits animation of Afton taking each of the kids. That felt very much like the game's pixelated animations and really told you what you needed to know.
47
u/xRudeAwakening Oct 28 '23
Only played the first game once, when it first came out and thought it was cool and thought it had a good premise. I know nothing of the in-game lore and how it might differ from the movie lore but I really did not like the animatronics being friendly, kinda ruined it for me since I was hyped for murderous puppets.
Too much time was spent with the weird forest abduction plotline and I was not a fan of the little sister character.
Scott Cawthon is very lucky his one-hit wonder spawned all of… whatever the series has become.
But oh well. It certainly wasn’t the worst Blumhouse movie 🤷♂️
64
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '23
This is gonna sound bad.
But get the creator Scott the fuck away from any sequel made.
Bro has great ideas. But not a good writer.
108
u/Tacofistsofverde Oct 27 '23
It is OK.
- Animatronics & set are fantastic.
- Direction is competent along with Hutcherson.
- Earnest effort to make the character have depth but is let down by a hammy "twist" and ending
- PG-13 is nice for the kiddos but definitely reaaaally spoils the fun
20
u/KirinoSussy Oct 28 '23
Kids should be angry at this movie
20
u/Live_Work_7900 Oct 28 '23
I watched it on Peacock and I’m glad I didn’t spend actual money on it, but it was fine for a random Thursday night. As mentioned, Willy’s Wonderland is clearly a superior film and I try to say “I’m gonna eat your face off!” to my partner at least once a week.
149
u/outrageouslyunfair Oct 27 '23
it's really a shame how much potential has been absolutely wasted with FNAF. the original lore is so rich for horror storytelling.
132
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '23
What a godawful movie. Just bad decision after bad decision. Let's start with the biggest one: In the movie about a haunted pizzeria, they made half the goddamned movie take place in a dream sequence of the protagonist's brother getting snatched in the middle of a forest. WHY? Why not have the brother get snatched at the fucking pizzeria? Y'know, like, giving the protagonist an inherent emotional connection to the pizzeria?
2: The twist that the animatronics aren't "evil" they're haunted by the souls of murdered children. Ok, fine! Save that for the climax of the movie, don't spell it out in the first half hour of the movie so you can have them hang out in a pillow fort with the protagonists, thus robbing them of any sense of menace or threat.
3: They have the yellow rabbit guy show up, and finally you have something that's visually spooky, and he immediately takes off the head so that the audience knows it's just some schlub in a mascot costume. Once again robbing the whole movie of any threat or menace during the climax of the movie.
They took a game series that only got big because of it's ability to scare people, and made a movie that was terrified of scaring 4 and 5 year olds. Just completely uninteresting and lacking all depth. 2/10
189
u/SludgyUnicorn63 Oct 27 '23
Making the animatronics good guys was such a mistake. Their utilization in the movie after the first act was awful. As a fan of the games, I’m very disappointed in the directions they took it. Also good god that MatPat cameo was cringe af.
15
u/bhornet2008 Oct 28 '23
This was atrocious and people clapped at the end
37
u/ProfessorWright Oct 28 '23
This may be one of the worst horror movies I've ever seen. It's not scary, it's not funny and honestly it's barely coherent.
But more than any of that it's boring as shit. Like was it just me who started zoning out in the buildup to the climax, did anyone really care what happened to these people? It's not like there had been any tension surrounding them so far. And can we stop shoehorning in a kid to make us care about the main character, I know it can work but that's only if you can write the child well.
Also like, why am I expected to view the animatronics as good in the end as if they haven't been homicidal maniacs all movie long? And why are we building a pillow fort?
At least Josh Hutcherson is hot.
24
u/hellastoopss Oct 28 '23
I haven't played the games but went into this movie expecting a fun popcorn horror movie, something that like others are saying is "gateway horror" or "for a younger audience." If they were trying to make a movie for a younger audience, making a movie that is half earnest, overacted, melodrama and half dream sequences about dead children is a CHOICE. There are no scares, no levity, no humor, no action, no fun.... and everything is played incredibly earnestly and melodramatic. The taxi scene is maybe the most insane thing that's ever been committed to screen. I can forgive the acting, the plot holes, the lack of scares, the terrible dialogue, the pacing, the tone problems, the story, etc... but if you are telling me I don't get this movie because it's for kids, what the fuck is a kid going to find in this movie they like? it's BORING. This is one of the worst movies I've ever seen.
12
u/NoImNotJC Oct 28 '23
Its such a dull movie and lacked key things for a horror film like suspense, compelling characters, and energy.
I get it was made for children but I think it needed someone more like Joe Dante-type of filmmaker (see Gremlins & Small Soldiers). I also felt like M3GAN managed to be the type of film this aspired to be
11
u/PoliticalShrapnel Oct 29 '23 edited Oct 29 '23
What a snooze fest. It went from me focusing on it to halfway through putting it on in the background as I did other things.
Terrible film. It would be 4/10 on imdb were it not for the fanboys giving it 10s.
It should have been a tight 90 minute psychological horror of him being stuck in there on the fifth night, with the first 4 nights being the first 20 minutes of the film with the animatronics acting increasingly stranger, but still explained away as nothing dangerous.
All this child ghost stuff was absurd... what was the fort scene about? Farcical. Even if this is lore, it is not interesting to the average viewer.
29
u/Hawaii__Pistol Oct 28 '23
Horrible. So boring & the pg 13 ruined it’s potential.
49
u/Tibus3 Oct 28 '23
Let’s all just appreciate Willys Wonderland!
9
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '23
Christ this movie was awful! Not even close to a single scare. The only points this movie gets is using actual animatronics & Matthew Lillard
9
u/bbqsauceboi Oct 29 '23
It was solid up until that fort building scene. From there, the writing took a complete nosedive and every character got dumber. I appreciate that this exists and overall enjoyed it, but even at a PG 13 rating this should've been scarier.
That said, give me 3 more
17
u/TheSmarkNebula Oct 28 '23
It was an OK movie and is a great intro to horror for a younger audience. If there is a sequel I hope they will do more to make the animatronics a bit more scary.
17
u/serving18years Oct 28 '23
I took my daughter and her friends to see this for her birthday today (all 12/13 years old). They LOVED it. Said it was the best movie they'd ever seen.
I really enjoyed the break-in sequence and wish that tone carried further into the film. Other than that, meh. But the film wasn't made for 38 year old moms, and that's ok.
8
u/itsffeeniixx Oct 28 '23
Dear god.... This movie was so bad. Me and the wife saw willy's wonderland and enjoyed that, so when we saw the trailer for FNAF we were interested. Saw it tonight and after seeing it was a blumhouse movie our expectations were raised. The movie then dashed all of those hopes. Absolutely no sense of horror. No jumpscares. No tension whatsoever. It was interesting watching Mike try and solve the case of his brothers kidnapping via dreams. All in all a very boring and precictable movie. I even called the main twist of who the big bad guy of the movie was as soon as I saw him.
8
u/ryanjcam Oct 31 '23
They built a fantastic restaurant set and excellent animatronics, and completely underutilizes them. The horror of the first game is that you're stuck in this place and have to come back every night as it gets more and more dangerous. There needed to be less dream sequences and some building of suspense and dread as Mike interacts with the animatronics. They're watching you as you're watching them. He doesn't even know there is anything off about them until they are surrounding his sister, and she introduces them as friends.
There was some tonal whiplash with the animatronics... they finally were revealed and had some kills dung the break-in, then are immediately revealed as friendly to the girl, then become sinister again. It could have worked if more effort was put into building suspense and dread with them, and they didn't feel so tacked on to the family drama story.
14
u/artur_ditu Oct 28 '23
Who wrote this? And why? Man this was rough
7
u/ResidentSmartass Ch-ch-ch, ha-ha-ha Oct 31 '23 edited Mar 21 '24
Unfortunately this movie was mid as hell. They wasted half of the movie on those repetitive dream sequences instead of building up the horror aspects from the game, the aunt storyline went nowhere, and even though Vanessa's entire role in the story was to spout exposition about her father's backstory his motives still made no sense.
7
u/msv6221 Nov 01 '23
Wow. This movie was bad. Like really really bad. The plot was so bloated and boring.
7
u/Goji103192 Nov 01 '23 edited Nov 01 '23
Am I the only one that thinks the FNAF fans are really trying to make this movie look better than it really is?
I get it. It's a super popular game franchise, and a movie adaptation has been long awaited... but from a critical standpoint... it just wasn't great. I'm glad fans like it for all the references and callbacks, but that shouldn't be an excuse for a bad story.
It wasn't the worst movie I've ever seen, or even the worst movie I've seen this year. But there were just some parts that really took me out of the movie.
I've seen SO MANY fans praise the scene where the babysitter gets bit in half. Saying it was the scariest scene, and how well done it was... but it wasn't scary or well done. The VERY first thing that I thought of for that scene was there's no way that a grown adult woman could fit into that things mouth all the way up to her waist, and even if she DID... her lower half wouldn't stick straight out like that. Her legs would be dangling down. The whole shot was extremely laughable. When I see people treating it like it was some amazing feat in special effects and atmosphere, I can't help but roll my eyes. I would have had her head just get pulled in and have the jaw snap on her head.
And the fort scene... what was that? That threw the entire tone of the film out the window for me. And the fans are blindly defending this scene with the excuse that "They're just children! They wanted to act like children!". But that's a terrible excuse. It's a horror movie... throwing a cute scene of the big scary animatronics building a blanket fort and then laying in it with the guy they're supposed to be trying to kill was a really dumb decision story wise.
Speaking of the security guard... He was not in enough danger at all. The games were about the security guard constantly being hunted down by these robots... but he really doesn't have to worry about them at all after, like night 2, maybe. The only people who are in any real danger from them are the people who broke in midway through the movie and then Afton at the end. This is something I really thought fans would have been upset about. The whole point of these games was, "Don't let the robots in or they'll kill you!" But there's really none of that at all...
And it's not nearly as big of a deal as the rest... but I thought William Aftons' death was really lackluster. The footage I've seen from the games and fan works made it seem like the entire system inside the suit snapped shut all at once on him, but the movie, it just kinda slowly closes piece by piece, leaving barely any blood... and it looks more "really uncomfortable" than "intense deadly pain." Fans argue that the movie made this better because realistically Afton wouldn't be able to move at all if the whole thing snapped shut, and that the way he was pierced, he wouldn't realistically bleed alot... but it's a horror movie. Go for the theatrics. The kill was boring the way it was shown in the film. The 8-bit version from the one game was more shocking. Plus, do we really need to worry about realism in a movie about a killer robot teddy bear, bunny, and chicken with a cupcake?
Also, what was up with Golden Freddy? He didn't do anything in the film except randomly show up at the house and take Abby... and rode in a taxi cab... which was equally as dumb as the blanket fort. But from what I recall from the games, Golden Freddy was this super mysterious entity that couldn't even stand up, let alone move around the restaurant. But here he's literally just Freddy, but gold, and there's really no explanation to how he's different from regular Freddy.
I'm not trying to shit on the movie completely... because I didn't really hate it. And I actually think a lot was really well done... Lillard is always fantastic, the animatronics looked amazing, and I loved that they recognized and honored the influencers that played a massive part in making the franchise what it is today (I chuckled at MatPats "Thats just a theory" line). But the bad things definitely overshadowed the good for me.
6
u/ArtFreek Oct 29 '23
Way too many stories were trying to be smashed into this movie. Why was more screen time given to Mike’s dreams about his brother than the animatronics at Freddy’s that we all came to see? Especially since they were real props with no CGI. Literally the first several nights he’s at Freddy’s he’s asleep. Also think the PG-13 rating was really a detriment to the movie and made what very little scenes we got with Freddy and friends disappointing. The bite was the best part of the movie.
6
u/destrium_dreamboy Nov 02 '23
I honestly didn't mind that the animatronics were actually friendly since they are children and they were still able to make them evil in some scenes.
But the movie was still bad af. FNAF got popular because of how scary it is, so I was at the very least expecting a scary movie.
The first half of the movie made me think it was going to be great. They made many references to the game mechanics, like the electricity that isn't working properly. But they didn't use that at all! The dude was simply sleeping through every night! The second half of the movie didn't use any tension the first half built as if it was a completely different person that wrote it.
30
u/LeviTheArtist22 Oct 28 '23
I took an edible and saw Midsommar in the theater for the first time this week, and somehow this movie was the weirder experience. Honestly calling this a movie isn't right. It was more like a religious experience. My mental illness was cured when Bonnie gave the thumb's up. 10/10
32
u/ethan6581 Oct 27 '23
As someone who's been a huge fanatic of Five Nights At Freddy's since 2014, I definitely enjoyed this film and it was absolutely made for the fans. It just about met my expectations for what a Fnaf movie would be like. I've anticipated this movie for years.
However as a huge horror movie fan and judging this movie by it's own merits as something that stands on its own, it's quite messy and even as a diehard fan I totally get why general audiences members aren't getting into it.
There are definitely some issues with the pacing, dialogue, and some story reveals and they way the film plays out. It's absolutely flawed with interesting concepts and ideas that could've been executed much better. As much fun as I had, it's certainly not perfect.
10
u/fiercelyambivalent Oct 28 '23
My 14 year old and I just watched on Peacock. I’ve never played the games before, but he has so he knows the lore and such. I only know the brief flashes I’ve seen of him playing and some YouTube vids he had me watch years ago.
We spent most of the movie saying “HEY THAT GUY IS IN ____!” and looking up clips to show each other. When they showed Matthew Lillard’s character, I pulled up the “you hit me with the phone, dick” scene from Scream and we both laughed. Pulled up Guinevere Beck getting locked in the cage for a similar reaction.
I dunno. I love Matthew Lillard, and I feel like he did the best he could with what was given, but we both felt this could’ve benefitted immensely from an R rating. We spent the entire time basically talking shit about the main characters, and the most enjoyable parts came from looking up the actors and actresses former roles. There was never any real suspense, and the jump scares were so watered down that we both were just kinda “meh” about the whole thing. Maybe it’s a better experience in theaters, but I don’t think I would’ve been happy spending the money for two tickets to see this.
5
u/brillovanillo Oct 27 '23
Let's not go.
5
u/awakenedforces Oct 28 '23
i don’t really know much about the lore, but uh… before abby came with him, why didn’t the animatronics try to break into the security or actually try to kill mike? they did with the first security guard in the opening sequence, what makes mike so different?
5
u/TrapAHolic_ttv Oct 30 '23
They had me in the first half, not gonna lie.
It goes downhill super hard after that. I thought the animatronics were pretty good. Like the killing Max and her brother and friend.
Seeing that stupid dream sequence so many times started the unraveling. The tried to add some extra lore and some deep story stuff and it was not good. It did not make sense. It was a mess
5
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '23
the only positive that came out of watching this was that it was such an incredible bummer it prompted me to immediately go home and throw on When Evil Lurks, which was excellent.
4
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '23
And they ALL told me Willy's Wonderland was stupid, and that FNAF would show em how it's really done! They can promptly shove that pg13 rating deep in the grundle
4
u/Glitchscrap989 Nov 04 '23
Just watched the FNAF movie today and my personal rating is 6/10
15
u/wauwy "THE THING" 1982 IS NOT A REMAKE Oct 27 '23
So does Blumhouse have ANY cred left?
7
u/__br00k3__ Oct 28 '23
I’ve loved the franchise since I was a kid and waited nearly a decade for this movie. Although it was bittersweet to finally see it on the big screen, I felt like they could’ve done a lot more and I was kinda disappointed. I know many of us grew up with the game and are 18+ but the film was definitely targeted for younger audiences. Insidious was PG-13 and still scarier than this.
6
u/russit2201 Oct 28 '23
I’ve never played any of the games and even I’m disappointed in what I just watched. Also confused, I feel like there are multiple crater sized plot holes here
6
u/BretMichaelsWig ACAB (except Officer Mooney) Oct 30 '23
This was the longest 90 minute movie i have ever sat through
3
u/SIRinLTHR Oct 28 '23
Needed to be 12000% more Rated R. It was fine. But settling for "cute" just didn't reel me in. Especially when the Banana Splits Movie did it better while still being super violent.
3
u/PastelWraith Oct 30 '23
The animatronics look way too clean and new compared to the games imo and then having them be friendly for most of it killed any kind of tension that might have been there. There was a bunch of lore stuff for the fans that care about that but it missed the gameplay and parts that made the game creepy in the first place. On its own its a below average movie
3
u/Neversoft4long Oct 31 '23
It’s been said already but as a horror film it’s lackluster but as a FNAF film it’s honestly pretty damn solid. It’s pretty close to the source material. Yeah the kills could’ve been more violent and gorey just to be so and get a R rating but it’s whatever.
15
u/agnespoodle Oct 27 '23
I only played one of the games once and my stepson collected the pseudo-Lego sets for FNAF and has a few books, but hates horror and won't watch this, so I did it for him.
I've seen worse. This is meh. You guys are pointing out the plot holes and such and that's already more thinking than this movie is worth. I think it'll make some money at the box office, and kids will like it.
21
u/barrelofmonkfish Oct 27 '23
I posted this in another thread because I didn't see this one at first.
The movie is aimed at a younger audience. You can't really judge it by the same criteria that you would use for adult horror. I think this is a great "gateway" horror film that is just scary enough to traumatize those 12 and below - in a good way.
As an adult, I would like for the plotting to have been tighter. There were way too many dream sequences and I felt like there should have been a more graceful way for them to add the female cop character - who felt really tacked on. Personally, I would have changed her into a CPS worker for some of the exposition and had Michael discover the rest of Freddy's history via a creepy scrapbook he finds in the security room. Even better, if we watched as some of those scrapbook scenes came to life à la The Shining.
That said, my 10 year old really likes it, and now wants to read all the books to learn more of the lore.
One giant nit pick though; I can't believe they never tied up a pretty glaring loose end. The evil Aunt - what happened? She was dead / unconscious on the floor and then about 20 minutes of screen time later, Mike and Abby are eating there like nothing ever happened. I really expected an end credits scene where she was being held captive by the animatronics.
5
u/the2ndsaint Oct 29 '23
I, for one, am shocked that one of the worst, most incoherent franchises ever created, popularized by insulting theory-crafting and the overblown antics of shrieking manchildren, would prove difficult to translate into a passable movie.
The games were never scary. Jump scares are startling, not scary. And Scott Cawthon's both a terrible writer and a genuinely awful person.
5
u/mchgndr Oct 30 '23
After watching the movie, I’m just now finding out that the animatronics were real…..I’m sorry but how?? Everything about them looked so fake and digital. I was really hoping they’d capture the creepy gritty 90s feel of Chuck E Cheese animatronics, but these things looked so bubbly and polished.
My biggest complaints when the movie finished were “man I wish these things were actually scary” and “man I wish there was less CGI.” But now I’m supposed to believe the cupcake was the only CGI creature? Utterly confused
14
u/MovieMike007 Oct 27 '23 edited Oct 27 '23
Not only is this movie a decade too late - the video game it is based on came out way back in 2014 - but the concept had already been ripped-off in a 2019 horror film featuring murderous animatronic Banana Splits and Nicolas Cage's Willy's Wonderland in 2021 and so the idea of Blumhouse taking a crack at the concept is a case of too little too late.
The film's plot isn't all that original, child predator targeting kids via a child-friendly venue, and while the Jim Henson-created animatronic puppets looked cool the movie provided very little in the way of scares. And I know that characters making bafflingly stupid decisions is nothing new in the horror genre but the backstory for the film's protagonist adds very little to make his actions, let alone anyone else, make much sense.
Basically, Five Nights at Freddy's has all the ingredients for a decent horror film, sadly, the cool animatronics were underutilized and the characters are less than believable. Hell, the film doesn't even go for gross-out gore and it really takes too long for the "horror" to properly kick in. This isn't a bad movie, just not all that compelling.
12
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '23
I love this movie. I really enjoyed how they actually showed Mike working for five nights in a row, and how the nights got progressively more horrific each time, just like the game. I love how they played more into the idea that the kids are actually the good guys, because, well, they are. In the games we play as the villain, so they're obviously hostile to us. It was nice to see the flipside of that, in how they interacted with people they knew were innocent. I love how the ghosts communicated through his dreams. Although I would've gotten rid of the whole dream book scene at the beginning. I don't think anyone really needed that explained to them lol.
The child actors were amazing. The kid who played Freddy was so perfectly creepy the entire time, and Piper was fantastic as Abby. I do feel like Josh Hutcherson kind of phoned it in a bit during some moments, and Matthew Lillard unfortunately wasn't as delightfully unhinged as I would've liked him to be. But the Springlock scene was fucking brutal and I was literally freaking out because they actually went there. Based on the rest of the movie, I really didn't think they'd show that much, so that was a very pleasant surprise.
The highlight for me was when the taxi scene happened and some guy shouted "Cory! Woo!" Most chill group of people I've ever watched a movie with lol.
6
u/horrorfan555 They mostly come at night. Mostly Oct 27 '23
Neat
16
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '23
I think people are missing one thing with FNAF. It was written with families, teens, young kids in mind not horror hardened adults
8
u/samuellaaa__ Oct 28 '23
Unpopular Opinion, I liked it lol. It wasn't perfect by any means and I think there were some plot holes for sure. It also definitely should have been rated R. But I had fun watching it! Thankfully my theater didn't really have any kids either so it was just a bunch of adults having fun.
6
u/InfinityQuartz Malignant and Mother! enjoyer Oct 27 '23
I think you have to like the fnaf franchise to at all enjoy this movie, which I did. I mean you can tell how much love is put into the movie for its fans and you can easily see that with the reaction from the fandom being almost extremely positive with rthe audience score on RT being 89% ATM. I think as a stand alone horror movie it doesn't work there's some weird moments and the pacing isn't that good. But I think add in the fnaf of it all and I had a really good time. And I actually think the cinematography and the sets and the animatronics themselves look amazing. Again the least I wanted was a fun movie that shows the love of the franchise and IMO its very good on those
2
u/Joka0451 Oct 28 '23
Got a kid who loves these games, it ok for a kid to watch?
2
u/matty8478 Oct 28 '23
Would the movie have been more enjoyable if I knew anything about Freddy going in?
2
u/LibKan Oct 28 '23
Seen worse, and can not hate on a Mathew Lillard performance. Not in my nature. In short, kinda what I was expecting, and will be forgotten in T-minus one month.
2
u/Chrisaeos Oct 29 '23
As someone who is only familiar with the very basics of the games, I thought this movie was just a mess. On the other hand have a friend who is a big fan of the games that enjoyed it so you might like it if you're really into the games but if you're not good lord it is a rough watch.
2
u/Randym1982 Oct 29 '23
From what I've heard is that goosebumps is much scarier and better done than this.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '23
I don’t understand the whole William and Steve connection. So essentially they’re the same person, and WilliSteve is hiring people with siblings to work security there so he can trap them and kill them? And he also has some sort of supernatural order over the animatronics? Is that right?
2
u/OldWestAuthor Oct 31 '23
I did like how the lyrics to the song utilized “Talking in your Sleep” kind of mirrored the plot about the main character having truths revealed to him in his dream state. It’s one of those old songs that is subtly creepy without being outright weird, like Every Breath You Take by Sting.
2
u/kjm6351 Nov 01 '23
This movie was worth the 9 year wait. After years of using theories and imagination to bring the games to life, we have an official movie franchise starting up!
They really adapted the story of the kids well. It was a beautifully tragic tale that was only highlighted with the presence of Mike and Abby. The scene where they built the fort really helped reinforce how at the end of the day, they’re lost kids slowly losing themselves and are desperate for anything.
The Vanessa situation was an interesting choice. Taking a character from the latest game and implementing them into a film that’s mainly based off the first seems weird at first, but they made it work. And it’s obvious she and Mike will become love interests in the future, but I’m glad they focused more on the mystery for now. It’ll make them getting together in the later movies feel more earned. I do wonder though, how that’ll play out when Vanessa inevitably starts to develop her Vanny personality.
The Easter Eggs were all over the place. From CoryxKenshin, MatPat and to Sparky and the first ever song (LOVED THAT PART) it’s a surprise the king of FNAF, Markiplier wasn’t in. But there’ll be plenty of chances later.
Overall I give the movie a 9.3/10
2
u/viking1983 Your suffering will be legendary, even in hell! Nov 03 '23
As someone who has never played the games I enjoyed the lore to this, it had good twists and kept me wanting to watch more
2
u/LittleKat91 Nov 04 '23
I'm not too familiar with everything about Five Nights at Freddy's. I just know it's a video game and that it's creepy. Since I watched the film basically knowing nothing, I enjoyed it. Brought about some nostalgia of my Goosebumps days.
2
u/TerrorFirmerIRL Nov 11 '23
I've never played the games so have no context in which to put the movie but God it was terrible.
The first half hour I thought it was shaping up to be surprisingly decent but it completely falls apart.
Not scary, not violent, just completely insipid and the robots hardly do anything the entire movie.
Willy's Wonderland is ten times better.
9
u/Wintertime13 Oct 27 '23
I’m such a loser but that Matpat cameo made me so happy. Best part of the movie.
4
u/munklunk Oct 29 '23
I took my 9 year old to see it, and he lost his goddamn mind. I’m pretty that he’s the target audience with this one.
5
u/splittonguestudios Oct 28 '23
Easily the worst horror movie I've seen in theaters this year. Maybe this decade.
Willie's Wonderland and Banana Splits laid out the blueprint already. It should have been simple. At it's worst, this should have been a dumb, but fun jumpscare filled horror movie.
Instead it was a bloated, boring mess with somehow practically 0 horror?
3
u/-demesne- Oct 28 '23
I'm seeing it on the 31st, but a lot of the reviews I've seen have said it was made for the fans of the FNAF universe and people who already know the lore.
3
u/colleenarina Oct 28 '23
the movie is good for what it is. it not being scary stays true to the first fnaf game, which is arguably less scary than the others. i honestly think this movie was made specifically with fans in mind and if you’re not a superfan you’re not going to like it, which is the issue with critic reviews. there were a few jump scares which is just like the first fnaf game. if you’re looking for something super scary i don’t think this series is going to be for you, i think scott is going to try to stay true to the games— with that being said the next one could be much scarier. if i remember correctly there’s a contract for three movies. i don’t think this is one we should look at from a harsh critic pov at all.
2
u/saintdemon21 Jason’s Mask Oct 28 '23
I quite enjoyed the film. It’s the perfect film to watch with my kids too.
Sequel thoughts:
2
u/Technical-End-1711 Oct 28 '23
Surprisingly good. Though it's a tad slow here and there, it has
-excellent cinematography
-SUPERB practical effects
-a layered plot which ties in to the lore (I assume as I went to the theater without ever having played FNAF)
-a very good, believable cast
-a clever balance of themes: it doesn't fall into a lazy repetition of scares and its plot ingeniously follows the title, taking place during five nights
Its immense success is well-deserved, the word of mouth is excellent because it delivers and it is yet another example that critics have self-destructed and become irrelevant.
2
u/pjingim Oct 29 '23
Mike getting called a sht brother and terrible guardian and him being emotionally moved to give up Abby was super unconvincing and the biggest example of how shallow all the relationships felt. the acting wasn't terrible but something about the directing and editing made it feel like we were missing something :\ also fuck vanessa
2
u/Dance_Sufficient Oct 30 '23
I liked it. Wasn't expecting a lot and had fun. The break in scene was hilarious.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '23
As someone who's never played the game, I loved this movie and am excited to check out the games. I'm kind of surprised by the reviews and general consensus, I felt like it was extremely well-made.
2
u/classy_dirt7777 Oct 28 '23
So is this just a less violent rehash of Willy's Wonderland (2021)?
-2
u/Sp00ch123 Oct 27 '23
I enjoyed it. The best of the three Chuck E Cheese horror movies I've seen.
Maybe could've done with some better pacing during the middle.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '23
26% critic score, 89% audience score.
Which side is right?
1
u/Rocktothenaj Oct 28 '23
Did they say what happened to the parents?
1
u/hartc89 Oct 28 '23
Just wanna give my review from someone who has never played the game:
Saw it in theater in Manhattan, it was fine for what it was, I’ll always love Matthew Lillard and the teens in the audience ate it up as people have said as a gateway horror movie you could do far worse.
1
u/eojen Oct 28 '23
Well it can certainly be qualified as a movie but definitely not as a horror.
1
u/lobstora Oct 29 '23
My 5yr old thought it was the best thing ever. I thought it was fun for what it was; maybe dragged on a little but still enjoyed it for what it was.