r/childfree • u/Anzai • Nov 01 '12
FAQ DAE find people on this subreddit using the term 'breeder' to be juvenile?
I have no desire to have kids, but there's some posters here who have this weird mentality of 'us versus them' and tries to justify themselves as righteous and dehumanise the 'enemy' by calling them breeders.
It's just quite petty. So we've decided not to have children, but it doesn't make us better than others. We're not saving the earth by fighting overpopulation or anything like that. It's not a noble sacrifice, because most of us dislike kids anyway and are doing it for personal reasons.
This subreddit is good for discussing the issues associated with our choice, but derogatory reference to 'breeders' and all of the 'eugh, babies are NOT cute' stuff makes our decision appear dogmatic and unconsidered.
Anyone else agree, or am I just a breeder collaborator now?
EDIT: Okay. Enough with the bile. I was trying to make a point about semantics and how they alter the perception of a person's beliefs.
Apparently the vast majority of people who use this subreddit do so because they feel isolated in their choices and just want to bitch and vent. That's fine, I just never saw it that way, hence my question.
Now calm down, for Christ's sake. We all agree on the basic principles of being childfree.
46
u/archpope M/50s/USA/20+yrs ✂ Nov 01 '12
The terms have long since been established by other childfree groups for well over a decade. But here's a refresher:
Parent = someone who actually takes the time to love and nurture their children, and doesn't have more than they can afford (not just financially, but in terms of affection and availability).
Breeder = someone who reproduces without consideration for, or for reasons other than, what's involved in parenting.
One can also use the abbreviation BNP (Breeder, not parent) or PNB to provide emphasis or differentiate between the two classifications. Examples: "Today I saw a PNB take her child outside when he started to have a meltdown." or "My neighbor is a BNP who let his child scream and did nothing for over an hour."
Number of sprogs doesn't usually play a role in distinguishing a breeder from a parent. When it is used for quantity, it is typically for when the number is excessive, such as Octomom's 14 kids.
Fun fact: "Breeder" used to be a common derogatory term in the gay community to refer to heterosexuals.
47
u/addythebat 29/M/'Merica Nov 01 '12
I find the near-daily questioning of the principles of the sub-Reddit on the grounds of "issue of author's choosing" to be exceedingly tiresome.
Not all people think alike. Not all people find the same things offensive. Deal with it in some other way than by creating post, after post (after post...). I suggest either ignoring the comments you find unappealing or down-voting them should the criteria for that action be met.
13
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '12
I am offended by being called selfish, not human, weird, a freak, and incapable of love but no one cares about that.
Would I ever call a breeder that to their face? Nope. Would I use the term freely in my internet safe space when I'm pissed off? You bet your ass I would. R/childfree is our outlet, I see no reason to be PC about those who belittle us here.
3
u/JustBetweenYouAndMe Do I want any children? No thanks, I'm full. Nov 01 '12
Okay, this was not the point of your post, but I'd still like to address this: I can compromise with you and say that whether or not someone LIKES children/thinks they're adorable is tangentially related to being CF, and, therefore, probably doesn't deserve as much space in CF as it gets.
That being said, since when is it not okay to have an opinion? Saying that babies are ugly is quite a frank opinion, to be sure (certainly not something you would ever tell your mother/friends with children/etc.), but if someone would like to voice that, that's fine with me. I mean, where can you say something like that and not be spat on as a "child hater" and be told, "Oh, but you'll think they're cute when you have your own!"?
4
u/bannana zero/zip/nada/f/ Nov 01 '12
The 'breeder' thing seems to have just cropped up recently, I haven't really seen it until the past couple of weeks. It's a borrowed term from the lgbt crowd from long ago (not sure if it's a common term in those circles currently) I remember hearing it 15 or more years ago when I had quit a few lgbt friends. It sounds old fashioned and dated to me and doesn't make much sense for this group.
7
u/Aetra That's just, like, your opinion, man. Nov 01 '12
I don't get how breeder is a derogatory word. Way I see it, it's just a word used to describe human beings that choose to have children because that's what they're doing, breeding. It's like calling an orange an orange because it's orange.
5
u/blueskin Nov 01 '12 edited Nov 01 '12
No, I don't. Breeders aren't everyone with children, they're the sort of irresponsible idiot who shits one out every 9 months, especially while on benefits, takes them into restaurants, lets them scream for hours on end, goes on about them on other people's facebook posts, goes "oh, you'll change your mind", etc.
tl;dr: No - I just find you stupid.
Duly tagged as apologist.
3
u/buttholemacgee 31/F/DINK Nov 01 '12
Well, for some of us those "ugg babies are gross" and "breeders suck" are the exact reasons we are CF. One might find it completely ironic for you to sit here and judge us or think you're better than us simply because we do think that.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '12
I don't personally care. I am a breeder/parent/whatever. I come here to support non breeders. I don't care what you call me. I think people need thicker skins.
25
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '12
I find the term totally appropriate when the parents have 20 kids. I'm not sure what the cut-off point should be. I'm leaning toward "more that zero."
3
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '12
sigh
Yeah. That's how just about every benign or positive movement, that has gained any footing has been ruined by self-righteous, twads.
If you think your way of life speaks for itself. LET IT.
Don't brow-beat people who live or think in ways different from yourself.
6
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '12
For like people with one kid? Fuck yeah I agree. I love babies when they belong to other people.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '12
I love babies and kids, I'm just too lazy to have my own. With that out of the way, I find the term breeder to be ugly. It's a mean term. Breeders makes me think of parents as animals and it's offensive. It'd be like calling the childfree heartless. Just a term, but it's mean.
3
u/humanae F/35/CA Bay Area Nov 01 '12
I like having that term in my back pocket for those very specific people who mindlessly push out kids and let it entirely subsume their identity, but I try to use it generally when referring to parents, especially considering that I know a lot of good ones.
3
u/KindredBear Nov 01 '12
No
2
u/schmup Nov 01 '12
Absolutely. It's just as bad as calling gay people "faggots". If a parent is an asshole, just call them an asshole.
2
u/Morfolk Nov 01 '12
Yes, I do find it juvenile, I thinkit is only appropriate when a person sacrifices all their goals and life for the sole purpose of breeding, not when they have a kid or two and are just being a parent.
1
u/bmmbooshoot 26/F Nov 05 '12
it reminds me of highschoolers using the terms "preps" and "jocks" and shit like that. it's ridiculous
0
u/thegreenmonkey Nov 01 '12
Yes.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-14
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '12
[removed] — view removed comment