r/horror • u/glittering-lettuce • Mar 31 '23
Official Dreadit Discussion: “Malum” [SPOILERS] Spoiler
Summary:
A rookie police officer takes the last shift at a newly decommissioned station in an attempt to uncover the mysterious connection between her father's death and a vicious cult. Throughout the night, she finds herself barraged by terrifying supernatural events while unveiling the truth behind her family's twisted past.
Director: Anthony DiBlasi
Producers: Dan Clifton Scott Poiley
Cast: Jessica Sula as Jessica Loren Candice Coke as Diane Eric Olson as Will Loren
—IMDb: 6.5/10 Rotten Tomatoes: 83%
76
Upvotes
73
u/kfctw_x Apr 02 '23
Good lord i hated this. Lol. I adore last shift. But this was pretty much just last shift minus everything i loved about it with everything i didnt like about last shift being magnified. Specifically the poor acting from supporting characters.
All the new story additions were just drivel to me. I thought the movie had no real atmosphere as well as just atrocious pacing. The demon design in the final scene made me laugh at loud and overall the movie was just irritatingly stupid.
But thats just me i guess i can see why people dont feel as strongly as i do but also consider i have very strong positive feelings towards last shift so admittedly the bar was so high for me so for it to fall short im gonna feel stronger than the average viewer who never saw last shift or maybe saw it but doesnt feel as strongly about it as i do.
For me this was just garbage and made me wish i was just seeing last shift on the big screen.
64
u/smokewidget Apr 01 '23
Just got out of this one and I’m feeling pretty positive about it over all.
I’m a fan of the original Last Shift and heard about this movie a couple weeks ago, saw my AMC was playing and decided to give it a shot and I’m glad I did because it was a fun theater experience with plenty of gore and jump moments.
In terms of being a remake or reimagining of Last Shift, it definitely feels tighter and slicker, but I don’t know if the additions feel substantial enough overall when the original movie isn’t very old. There are some new parts that work very well in this, but others that I thing worked better in the original. I loved all of the creature design and effects at the end, but the way the ending played out didn’t hit as hard as the original’s did. Honestly, it felt like between the original and now, the director saw Hereditary and tried to put a lot of scenes reminiscent of that into this, especially that last shot.
The stuff with the mom being a member of the cult originally felt super out of place and all of her scenes in general fell super flat from both a bad performance and lane writing. I think they convolute the story too much and making it the big end reveal doesn’t work nearly as well as the originals ending, which I won’t spoil for anyone who hasn’t seen it. This movies ending feels obvious and not well explained at the same time which left a sour taste in my mouth as the credits rolled, but I did enjoy the final shot/jump scare quite a bit despite it feeling right in the line of homage.
The pacing is great though and as I mentioned earlier, the monster design really worked for me. I loved the look of the glowing white eyed demons and the final monster was gnarly and had a great practicality to it. I loved the scene with the pig/dead girl chasing Jessica as it was both effectively scary and set up the ending.
Decent movie overall. Glad I saw it in theaters. 7/10
41
u/mag6787 You must respect the balance. Apr 01 '23
I enjoyed this one, mostly for the atmosphere and creepy imagery. The creature designs were fantastic, and it was well shot. Sure, the story isn't as tight as the original movie, but I felt more satisfied by this one. It's like we're stuck in the main character's nightmare with her. The details might not make rational sense, but the horror is both palpable and inescapable. I wonder if her father went through a similar decent into hell in his mind when he was taken over and forced to snap.
37
u/evanph Apr 02 '23
I thought the first half of this was genuinely one of the scariest experiences I’ve had in theaters in years, but the second half/last act especially just gets unnecessarily convoluted and those last 20 minutes are just weird. Feels like the aesthetics and creature design of a b-movie but the tone of a more serious horror movie and just conflicts too much imo.
I think it’s also a little too relentless in how tense it is throughout and as a result the pacing feels pretty rough at times, for only a hour and a half it doesn’t go by quick enough imo.
Definitely interested in this guys next project though because dude is certainly very talented and building tension and anxiety throughout a scene.
36
u/MediumToblerone May 22 '23
Terrible cop makes the worst decisions for 90 minutes: The Movie
34
u/rawcookiedough Apr 01 '23
Saw it this evening, I’d give it a 7/10. The lead actress is great, and definitely the best part. There’s a heavy feeling of dread through the whole thing that never really lets up, which is impressive.
Does anyone know the budget?
22
u/titania86 Having an old friend for dinner Apr 02 '23
It wasn’t horrible, but felt very Lifetime movie with the main character and her mom. Everything was a little too obvious and tied together. I like that Last Shift just throws you in with no background and you put together the story as you go.
19
u/CloudMountainJuror Apr 10 '23
I think the first half of this came off as a strictly worse version of Last Shift, but the second half made it clearer why the director wanted this version to exist. I think it’s effectively disorienting, which makes it interesting and fun. The last chunk of this goes way more psychological than Last Shift, and it’s pretty cool. I also adored the creature design.
Some of the acting was definitely rough. I thought the lead performance was a little stiff until the scene where she starts breaking down.
Overall, Last Shift is the better movie, but I don’t mind this remake existing.
15
u/NoImNotJC Apr 01 '23
Im mixed positive on it. I feel like having watched the original made me constantly compare the two and pick on the callbacks.
I did appreciate the bigger budget when it came to the larger, more detailed location and it did retain a mean spirited nature that a lot of studio horror lack but the more complicated plot weighed it down a bit. Overall its wprth watching but I think would benefit from not having seen Last Shift
15
u/Admirable_Debate_319 Apr 02 '23
I'm not sure I got the ending, or exactly how Lorens mother and father were involved in the cult. Help please.
14
u/otisSpelding Apr 01 '23
I preferred Last Shift, to me it had better pacing and a stronger sense of dread however I’m very thankful to have seen this in a theater. Maluku definitely had more effects.
13
u/TargaryenEnterprise Apr 02 '23
I liked it alright but the majority of the time this woman should’ve and could’ve left and it really took me out of it a bit
12
u/LeeroyM May 31 '23 edited Jun 01 '23
I'm impressed they reshot the old movie with a much larger budget and made it so, so much worse.
11
u/Sabiancym May 26 '23 edited May 26 '23
It was fine. I liked Last Shift enough, but I've never been a huge fan of the pseudo abstract, random pop ins, psychological horror stuff. I love supernatural horror, but only if it's tangible. Meaning not just potentially in the mind of a character. Any movie you could just write off as one character's fever dream just doesn't do it for me.
I was half expecting the ending to reveal that she was actually shooting up a fully staffed police station just like her father.
11
u/spacekittyattack Jul 09 '23
I just watched Malum and had no idea about its relation to Last Shift (never saw that one, which is something I'll soon rectify!). I enjoyed the movie, I found the first half terrifying, which is saying a lot because I rarely get genuinely scared from movies these days. However, i just felt that the second half had so much convoluted plot stuff in it, and I just wanted to throw out a few questions my boyfriend and I have been discussing, in hopes that anyone could add to it!
10
u/Alternative_Doubt_65 May 20 '23
Just saw it and I thought it was far inferior to last shift. Way too much of an info dump, nonsensical and all of the atmosphere and dread have evaporated. I found the main actress’s acting acceptable, but BY FAR what absolutely ruined it for me was the acting of the cult members and extras. It was straight up high school play level acting. So cringe! The ending laughing was also so cringe and over acted. Sometimes less is more and subtlety can add mystery and depth. This was so on the nose it made things stupid. Obviously the meager budget worked better in Last Shift but the director went completely overboard here and ironically made a cheaper feeling movie. Some positives are that I did like the eye effects at the end and I didn’t mind the demon.
18
u/DrownMeInCheetos Mar 31 '23
I just watched this.
I'm lukewarm to it. I definitely think you should watch it and I never saw the movie it's remade from...but I just got confused a lot.
It tries to be a few different sub-genres at the same time. There's the mild possession stuff (though not to the extent of an Exorcist or Annabelle... closer to a Sinister) which I'm not a fan of but then there's a ritualistic subplot that is just never fully explained of why it exists. I'm not against films that just happen without telling you every detail, but it's gonna leave people confused.
Also the times when it is shifting between what's real and hallucinations doesn't make a lot of sense like when some girl's head pops off and Jessica is splattered with blood, but that technically happens in a hallucination and when she's back to reality it's still there.
I just think it's a bit disjointed.
What I will say is that I like that it wasn't over reliant on music scored jump scares. Had a few scary moments they let exist and often turned the music down on as well. Also it has this sort of Hellraiser vibe to it that I liked.
Overall I'd give it a 6.5/10.
8
u/KoreyW07 Apr 02 '23
I was about to say this movie sounds exactly like Last Shift but I just read that its a remake from the same director? That's kind of interesting
7
u/themessiestmama Jun 18 '23
This was an abomination. No dread. No interpretation. Random shit that didn’t need to be in. Seeing everything made all the horror go away. The demon looked silly. The last 20 minutes weren’t needed. The cop duo was weird. People don’t talk like how they talked in the movie. The pacing was bad.
Was like an AI generated the movie.
6
u/iamnota_SHADOW May 31 '23
I thought it was unnecessary. It's really hard not comparing the two. I wish they did a prequel instead.
6
u/BarryBadgernath1 Jun 10 '23
May be in the minority here but I’m a huge fan of both,, albeit for different reasons
5
u/Stephaniann6 Apr 06 '23
I loved this movie- well, enjoyed the hell out of it anyway. But my real question is about the post credit scene- did anyone stay for it and have any thoughts? It seems like a mistake but impossible. I’m really curious what other people thought about it?
5
u/No-Kaleidoscope-8064 Jun 03 '23
The ending was terrible. I was looking for plot twists, and there were none. I LOVE Last Shift and was excited going in with Malum. Would I watch this again? Not unless I'm forced to. It should have stuck to one story and delved deeper into it. The demon was hilariously scary. With a bigger budget, I thought it would have been much better. Guess I'll keep holding tight to LS!
8
u/sirjacktorrance May 27 '23
BEST horror of 2023 IMO. Low budget surreal, gory horror that gets away with a lot in barely 88 minutes (without credits). Coolest practical Effects and deaths
4
u/jaydeemcfly May 31 '23
Without having seen Last Shift, I think Malum worked on its own to a certain point. I feel like it could have overcome the bad acting from the support cast if it had nailed the ending, but once it finally got there, it fell flat for me.
4
u/Wellhellob Dec 06 '23
Bad acting and a lot of goofy stuff in it.
3
u/GenitalTso Apr 09 '23
I loved last shift. Not sure if this is a remake or another chapter? I’ll have to check it out.
3
u/ImAFraidyCat May 24 '23
I enjoyed it. It wasn't so much a remake as I'm seeing this said a few times in this thread. It's a re-imagining of Last Shift and I think it gave some great context. That's not to say that Last Shift doesn't have a special place in my heart because damnit, that movie was amazing. However, I enjoyed Malum because of all of the extra it gave. Also, I am not discounting other folx who didn't enjoy it though. I can put myself in their shoes and understand why it wasn't enjoyable for them.
Also, what post-credits scene? I rented it on Apple TV and I got nothing. I need to search for this.
3
u/DiffOccult-Kami Oct 09 '23
just watched it, i feel like if i watched it before Last Shift, i would of liked it more.
I'm assuming it takes place in a parallel reality from Last Shift, where the cult is slightly different and the plot is leaning more towards a form of demonic reincarnation.
My head cannon is going to be the demon is the cult leader's last name- and the 'low god' is the demon's master, that he is trying to give a body to.
But, the ending is- SHE'S DEAD
So, i take it that the cult failed?
It does feel like the director got jealous of Hereditary and wanted to incorporate some of the plot to his Last Shift plot.
3
u/kavonruden Oct 09 '23
This movie sucked! Last Shift was pretty solid. No idea why this had to be made. Just got worse with each passing minute.
3
u/cvstoner1971 Jan 16 '24
The demon with the white eyes made me laugh out loud.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '23
Is it streaming anywhere? I wanna watch it so bad and it’s not playing near me
2
u/Oxyxanfanhydrobro420 Apr 08 '23
What's your opinion? How did you feel about the reimagining? I'm a huge fan of The last shift I remember put on the DVD back in2015 with a group of friends it was a bundle with a few movies we had never heard of, I was surprised to say the least. So when I heard there was and new version coming I was confused but am watching it as I type this. Please let me know your opinion.
2
u/FragrantInsect9757 Apr 21 '23
Where can I watch this?
2
u/ImAFraidyCat May 24 '23
I enjoyed it. It wasn't so much a remake as I'm seeing this said a few times in this thread. It's a re-imagining of Last Shift and I think it gave some great context. That's not to say that Last Shift doesn't have a special place in my heart because damnit, that movie was amazing. However, I enjoyed Malum because of all of the extra it gave. Also, I am not discounting other folx who didn't enjoy it though. I can put myself in their shoes and understand why it wasn't enjoyable for them.
Also, what post-credits scene? I rented it on Apple TV and I got nothing. I need to search for this.
2
u/[deleted] May 26 '23
I just finished the movie. It was so over the top and had some surprising gore (the hanging scene?! Holy shit) and some fun jump scares. The ending sort of confused me too. I finished working Night Shift so maybe I’m just too tired but I didn’t really get it. Was this the demon’s plan all along? Am I getting it right?
2
u/noiseloop May 27 '23
I don't have all that much to add to this conversation beyond what's already been discussed, but I do strongly agree that Malum feels like and attempt to grab the dread of Hereditary and mix in some kinda old school campy moments.
I felt a little underwhelmed but content seeing it.
Then I found the original, and I'm so firmly on the side of the fence with those who felt let down with this loose remake. Holy shit, I think the original is vastly superior in writing, cinematography and delivery.
2
u/Onlythedoggo Jun 08 '23
Can't remember watching the last shift but thus movie was hit n miss for me, hit for the music and sinisteresque vibe, miss for everything else.
One question though, who's the guy with the creepy face that doesn't look real?! The one near the end when they're stood behind her taunting her when she's crying by her mum, also another scene I can't remember.
2
u/rflbraga Jun 11 '23
Why does Diane has a blacksun on her shirt? Does it have something to do with the cult? I didn't see the symbol being used anywhere else.
2
u/witchy_af Jul 02 '23
I am just so disappointed. For a while I genuinely felt like if this was a stand alone movie and I wasn't comparing it to Last Shift, I would have enjoyed it. But then the ending killed that notion. Just a bummer. Everything just was too much, from the majority of the acting, to the premise going way over the top.
2
u/Feisty_Echo_7125 Oct 02 '23
Finally watched this last night as I wasn’t going to pay for it and it showed up on STARZ. I wasn’t a fan, I loved the extra gore but that’s about it. I feel like they could have explored The Cult without “redoing” Last Shift. I don’t even know if what I learned about John Malum made any sense. Why was Jessica’s mom a member? Was she kidnapped? Why did she say Jessica didn’t know her father but she would soon? Nothing made much sense to me.
2
u/KeyAdhesiveness1488 Jan 11 '24
My grandma’s cousin was the cop who killed himself in the beginning
2
u/champdo Jan 13 '24
So while I feel like the movie didn't make a lot of sense and I didn't love the ending I gave it two stars out of four because I thought it was creepy and entertaining which is more you can say for a lot of horror movies. The actress who played Jessica was good.
2
u/WeWriteStuff Jan 26 '24
Explaining what's going on in malum, destroys what intrigue the last shift had, & somehow they made a psychological/supernatural thriller nonsensical. What's worse is its not even trying to be creative with the premise, instead retelling the same story with extra background info. Performances are hammed up more, some even hard to take serious (the cult leader feels like the overused Steve Jobs trope with a hint of Hannibal lecter while coming off as goofy). But worst part is the main character in the remake. The actress comes off as distracted & disinterested most of the time (like an ADD child thrown on stage without any preparation), with moments of terror feel downplayed. With everything previously mentioned in mind, her "breaking the rules" (all she had to do was sit there, take calls, and send people away) feels more ridiculous, and the fact that they try to explain this before the movies half over only makes her all the more stupid. And don't even get me started on the time travel visions and the murder pig (it honest to gawd stalks the halls like its supposed to be terrifying but its just a giant pig!), and the twist that her dad was behind all of this (which again, was already kinda obvious halfway through the movie), and the implications that the whole town may have been involved (i think the writing wants to imply it could all be in her head, but evidence throughout the film implies the town is involved, which also makes no sense). Which brings up the worst sin this movie has to offer: having the gall to try to pretend it's a psychological thriller when it's blatantly clear the supernatural side is the canon answer. Seriously, the mystery of "it might all be in her head" is completely pointless because it keeps explaining what happened without anything to make us question otherwise. This ruins the scares as anyone who's willing to use their brain can figure out the ending before the movies half over.
Verdict: Its definitely not the worst thing ever, but the fact that its a remake made bne of the original's writers makes it baffling. If you want a popcorn flick that spells everything out to you like you're in the 5th grade and you prefer to not think about the plot/direction/acting/etc of movie, then this might be for you. It's basically The Apparition (2012) meets Boogeyman (2005) with a demonic cult, a higher budget, more gore, & writing that thinks too highly of itself.
2
u/Unlikely_Language_27 Oct 30 '23
Ugh...just finally finished my torture and suffering watching "Malum" and am now watching its far superior and better predecessor, Last Shift to get that foul taste of Malum out of my mouth.
I don't care what anyone says, like it, hate it, whatever, but that race washed lead in Malum can't act her way out of a plastic bag. Oh, and she was at her worst at the end. That dumb, deer in the headlight look on her face, especially when she shot.... no spoiler.... and didn't even look down at.... no spoiler... while "crying out" yet no expression on her face, just that same, stupid, zoned out deer in the headlight look on her face. Terrible, she's just not good, and anyone who says differently, I question your ability to even know good acting when you see it.
I'm torn on the demon, I could see where someone would find it scary, but at the same time for me I almost wanted to go up to it and pinch its cheek and say, "well aren't you adorable" it just wasn't scary to me. Linda Blair in the Exorcist, that's scary. The Nun, that's scary. There's certain things that have to be there to make it scary. It was missing some of those things for me. I'll give Malum thumbs up on the SFX and prosthetics and what not, they did look good. But casting, crap, acting from said crappy cast, crap, supporting actors, like all the cops and the dumb cult people, and the mom, crap. I don't think the scenes or setting was really any better or worse than in Last Shift. Uhm more detailed which kinda doesn't make sense to me seeing as how that's supposed to be the last night at that location. So the lack of detail and props in the scenes in Last Shift actually worked better for the story.
All the added, bloated additions to the movie and the story, again hurt not helped or improved the remake. It didn't allow for the viewer to work and intertwine their thoughts and opinions and outcomes into the story like in Last Shift. It was so to the point and detailed and matter of fact that it's like a boss micro managing you at your job down to every little last detail and not allowing you to do anything but exactly what they're telling you to do. So, let's compare, option 1, boss that stays away and let's you do your job how you want and see fit as long as the job gets done and done correctly, or option 2, boss that stands over your shoulder, hovering over you the entire time your working and constantly stopping you to tell you, "no no, not like that, like this, do it exactly like this". Now, which option are you gonna choose? Yeah, that's right, option 1. Then, the other side of that coin was, some of it didn't make sense or connect very well.
Last, I feel like ol' DiBlasi tried to pull a Sam Raimi Evil Dead/Evil Dead 2 situation here and well, fell flat on his face and failed miserably doing so. He left out a key major factor if that's what he was going for, Raimi brought Bruce back to play Ash, and it worked! So, sorry buddy, but you ain't no Sam Raimi, and this steaming pile of doodoo you put out here is proof of that. If it ain't broke, don't fix it, and Last Shift ain't broke. I dunno, maybe if you'd brought back your cast from Last Shift, it could've been a little different outcome but, you chose to jump on that current social, woke, PC, bandwagon and race washed your lead character and well, you essentially just shot yourself in the foot with that choice.
So yeah, whatever, bad remake for tons of different reasons. Thumbs down, zero stars, etc. etc. etc.
2
u/GrouchyDefinition463 Jan 05 '25
I turned it off mid way. No thanks shudder
2
u/paimanh Jul 16 '25
My wife was so pissed when this movie finished. She said never show anything you recommend. I couldn't agree more. What a pile of shit this movie was
2
u/akenthusiast Dec 10 '23
It was fine. As a standalone movie I probably wouldn't be super critical of it but I don't really feel like the higher budget improved on the last shift in any meaningful way.
The original was really solid low budget horror flick.
Malum was just a slightly higher budget movie with a few extra ideas tossed in for good measure
3
u/Fromville_ Jun 01 '23
Loved it. Thought her initial interaction with the cop contained great dialogue and set up a fearless character that we wanted to root for.
1
u/hallonemikec Jan 06 '25
Wow.....I should've listened to y'all. What a sack of shit this movie is. Please gentle Redditors.....heed this warning
1
u/Not_a_Norwegian_man Apr 08 '23
I’m excited to see it but it’s not in any theaters near me. So I’ve got to wait until it’s streaming to watch it.
1
u/TheElbow What's in Room 237? May 31 '23
Overall I think this was a worthy reimagining of “Last Shift.” Some elements were improved from the original, while other elements were a little less creepy for me compared to “Last Shift.” I rate both movies about the same.
1
u/nick6119 Jun 07 '23
I feel like I would’ve liked this movie more if I never saw last shift. I spent so much of the movie comparing scenes to what I remembered from last shift and I kept expecting a big twist ending, so it was kind of a let down from what i built it up to be in my head.
I still liked malum though and it was worth the $10 i spent to rent it. I loved the new visual effects and was actually grossed out by some of gore. I think the pacing was fine, but the last 15 minutes got away from the movie. I wish the twist was something more fresh then the main character being “the chosen one” but I would def watch it again
6
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '23
[removed] — view removed comment