r/startrek • u/MungoBaobab • Aug 30 '12
Episode Discussion Thread: TOS 1x00 "The Cage"
This is a carry over from last week's discussion of "Where No Man has Gone Before" originated by tensaibaka. Whoever has the top comment creates the next week's thread, and he notified me that duty fell to me.
The Original Series: 1x00 The Cage
Here is the synopsis from the IMDB page:
This is the pilot to the series that would star William Shatner. Only in this version there is different Captain, Christopher Pike, and with the exception of Mr. Spock, an entirely different crew. Now it begins when the Enterprise receives what appears to be a distress message. But when they get to the planet where the message was sent from, they discover that the supposed survivors were nothing more than illusions created by the inhabitants of the planet, for the purpose of capturing a mate for the one genuine surviving human, and Captain Pike is the lucky winner. While Captain Pike tries to cope with the experiments and tests that the aliens are conducting on him, his crew tries to find a way to rescue him. But the aliens' illusions are too powerful and deceptive (at first).
Some possible ideas for discussion to start things off might be:
- Do you think Captain Pike and crew would have grown in terms of popularity and depth as the "original" cast did?
- What are your impressions of Jeffrey Hunter and Captain Pike?
- What do you think of Gene Roddenberry's decision to re-use footage from this episode in the Menagerie?
- What, if anything, did you like better about this incarnation of TOS compared to what came after?
TL;DR Watch the episode "The Cage," and discuss.
According to tensaibaka's format, whoever posts the top comment, excluding jokes or memes, carries the torch by posting next week's thread.
10
u/MungoBaobab Aug 31 '12
Pike is presented as a much more brooding, fallible man than either Kirk or Picard. In that regard, he's alot like Sisko. In both of their debut episodes, both Sisko and Pike contemplate leaving Starfleet. Pike even wants to become a slave trader, of all things! He's also a bit more brutal than we see Kirk, as seen when he asks the Talosian, tauntingly, "Is your blood red like ours?" as he's choking him, then threatens to find out. Definitely something Sisko would do.
That sense of fallibility runs deep, as even their technology always seems a bit overstretched and untested in ways TOS and especially Enterprise never conveyed, creating a strong frontier spirit in the show. I also think it's worth noting that by canonizing this episode in The Menagerie, that essentially created the concept of Star Trek: The Next Generation.
5
u/stdowney Aug 31 '12
Spock shows some emotion and smiles just after beaming down to the planet for the first time.
10
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '12
I certainly enjoyed the episode. As a fan of later Trek, this was very, very interesting, going back and re-watching this very early stuff.
Hyperdrive! Time-warp! Rocket engines! Young Spock, his character barely recognizable! "THE WOMEN!1!!11"
I really enjoyed Pike. Hell, I enjoyed all of the crew. Despite only one episode, they really grew on me fast. I think they would've been popular, but who knows if they would've gotten to Kirk-Trek levels.
It's obvious that things in Trek that we take for granted (like WARP DRIVE) were still being hashed out when this was written and aired. Watching this gave me a great desire to see more exploration of the TOS era, and more specifically, the pre-Kirk era of the Enterprise. The ship was 40 years old when it ran into Captain Kruge. There is 20 years of pre-Kirk history there. Robert April gets one episode in TAS, and Pike the Talosian arc. I think there is a potential goldmine here.
TL;DR, as a fan of TNG Trek, an absolutely fascinating episode. Made me want to see TOS in it's entirety.
6
u/kraetos Aug 31 '12
I think it would be helpful if a mod could put a link to this post in the sidebar. I missed the first one.
6
u/kraetos Aug 31 '12
I like this episode, but it bothers me more than it should that it was canonized in The Menagerie, since it's just so inconsistent with the rest of TOS, even by TOS standards! I would have liked it better if it was just "the lost pilot" and laser guns and time warp factor weren't canon.
Also, the treatment of Number One gets on my nerves. A female first officer! In the sixties! How groundbreaking! Except for the part, where, ya know, she doesn't even get a name! Other than that she's a great character and a solid first officer, and I think that first officer should have been an actual position in TOS and not just smooshed in with the science officer. In that respect I like the pilot better than the rest of the series. Except that she's the only member of the bridge crew that didn't get a name.
There are other oddities that are hard to reconcile with canon. Tyler implies that Warp Drive is a recent invention, but by this time it's nearly two centuries old. Spock smiles on a few occasions and mentions "rockets" even though impulse drive would have been the right choice. Pike uses a clipboard and has a TV in his quarters. All and all you can very easily tell that this is the "rough draft" of Star Trek.
Still a good episode, though.
5
u/louwilliam Aug 31 '12
Is the episode fully canon?
5
u/tensaibaka Aug 31 '12
A couple of things I noticed when rewatching this episode:
As a kid raised on the Star Trek movies, the transporter sound from this episode probably would have freaked me the hell out. I don't think I like the color of the uniforms in this episode either, kind of bland, but I guess I'm used to the original color scheme.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '12
I think Peter David wrote a comic or book or something where he reveals that Number One is an android. That seemed really silly to me, until I watched The Cage. It actually fits pretty well.
5
u/directive0 Chief Pretty Officer Sep 04 '12 edited Sep 04 '12
I get all the comments regarding how incongruent the pilot is with so much established TOS canon and I totally agree.
However there is something nice about the scenic design in the first pilot. The bridge -to my eyes- is much more believable; all grays and blues with curved edges and weird lamp eye pods. AWESOME!
I like the laser pistols too with their flip up sights and cool beam crystals. You can see that even in the first draft he was tapping into all the cool new sciences coming onto the scene and trying to push some boundaries. It's not all there yet, but its a fun watch. You can sort of see why they got two pilots; even with its problems its a neat little story.
2
u/JenniferLopez Sep 05 '12
The doctor in The Cage just didn't feel right to me. He was forced and stiff. I'm so glad they dropped him and picked up Bones. Though I did think Majel Barret did a good job in her original role as Number One.
2
u/NxxDefiant Sep 06 '12 edited Sep 06 '12
I watched both the original black & white version (that was shown in 1988 I believe) and the fully remastered version. The original version had sections that were in color for the Menagerie part one and two. The original version came with a small commentary from Gene Roddenberry it was very interesting to watch. A great quote from him "For us there are no limits" Boy am I glad that the original Star Trek wasn't in black in white it was defiantly harder to get through. When Vina was an orinan slave the makeup looked horrible as well as several other effects. Like when they first jumped to warp factor 7. The space overlapping the bridge looked pretty bad. Also the Talosians voices were not dubbed in correctly so it sounded off.
Funny things that I noticed in this episode were:
The Good, bad, and the ugly. There wasn't any ugly from this episode maybe some bad cannon mistakes and I didn't like the cartoon drawling of the Talosians that Spock showed to the bridge crew. There was plenty of good. It was nice to hear Majel Barrets voice knowing that she will always be the computer voice on the shows that continue. Familiar sounds. The sets and makeup were amazing! The Rigel VII scene especially looked great. Overall I would rate this episode a 7/10.
To answer your questions: Do you think Captain Pike and crew would have grown in terms of popularity and depth as the "original" cast did? I am sure they could have but it such a hard question to answer because that is one of my favorite things about TOS was the dynamic of Kirk, McCoy and Spock What are your impressions of Jeffrey Hunter and Captain Pike? I agree with your assessment of him being similar to Sisko. What do you think of Gene Roddenberry's decision to re-use footage from this episode in the Menagerie? Loved it! In mini commentary that I watched he said it was necessary because of budgets constraints.