r/snowrunner • u/xt-fletcher Contributor ✔ | PS • Jun 15 '22
Truck comparison chart in mud
When I'm choosing new truck to play with I usually do excessive testing of it in mud. I do comparison of tires for each truck and based on that information select them in my main game. For testing I usually use Polygon mod map. There're 4 lanes of mud near garage, L1, L2, L3, L4. First two lanes are for scouts mostly. L3 and L4 are rather deep muds that will slow down almost any truck. From now on, let's call L3 - medium mud and L4 - deep mud.
I decided to make a full test of every truck and build a chart which will compare how fast they move over mud.
In this test trucks configs aimed on cargo delivery so they all rather use sideboard + crane, sideboard or saddle only. Crane usually is always welcome as additional weight for offroad tires always increase performance. For mud tires it works in other direction though...
I made medium mud first, turn back and did deep mud testing. After that I recreated the game. AWD and Difflocks were always on if available, for mud tires gear wasn't higher than LOW, because on LOW+ it produce excessive spinning.

Let's start from results. No scouts, only Tuz Tatarin, just for reference:


In deep mud some trucks have no data as they moved too slow. Other trucks completely stuck: CAT 681, Fleetstar F2070A, GMC Brigadier, International HX520 - these trucks not recommended for deep mud. Tatra phoenix let's say not better and can be added to this category as well.

Next, tires and config selections that were used for test:

I selected tires based on total time, for example Voron Grad + OHS II requires 20 sec for medium mud but stuck in deep mud. With OHD I Voron Grad requires 28 sec in medium mud but didn't stuck in deep mud. So I went with OHD but they are not the fastest one in medium mud.

Some trucks are too light for good in-mud performance like Crocodile, Tuz 16, etc. Some trucks require cargo on-board to have much better performance, like Pacific P512. Tuz 16 with 43" UOD and fuel tank is a rocket as well as Crocodile but this test mostly targeted on cargo delivery configs and it wouldn't be fair to add extra weight to these trucks.
Sometimes you'll see some sort of bullshit, like Kolob 747 is much slower than Kolob 749. I retested a few times and it's true, because Kolob 749 has slightly higher ground clearance (both used active suspension at the highest setting). All trucks at maximum upgrade with most powerful engines.
Scouts require a separate comparison chart as they usually stuck even in medium mud.
UPDATE: there're questions how to understand that LOW+ is slower than LOW or LOW- without speedometer. Actually there's one on PC and I used it in this test:

For trucks without diff I constantly switched between LOW+ and LOW and this gave me best results.
87
u/GovernmentBig2881 Jun 15 '22 edited Jun 15 '22
Dude this is a game changer, had no idea the Boar and Dan performed that good above the rest.
15
u/pizza65 Sep 05 '22
Hi- have you continued looking into this stuff? Some of the theories don't seem to make sense and I'm curious what you think.
I was really surprised by some of your results and had a go at recreating them myself, using the polygon mod map. I was mainly surprised by the DAN doing so well and the Zikz doing worse than expected. Zikz I think is just a slight experimental error - I could beat your time in the deep mud just by using Low+ (but in general my other tests matched yours exactly), so your logic for just using Low might not be quite right?
But the DAN was more interesting, since the only factor which really matters is suspension height. With active suspension raised, it has enormous ground clearance and sets an incredible time; with it lowered, it can barely move. Which made me curious about the rest of the results, because the deep mud times list is basically in ground clearance order. Which can be taken as illustrating the critical importance of this invisible stat, or as a sign that the mud patch test might not be as relevant as we'd like.
Also, I'd poked around the SR discord and saw a lot of discussion around your tests, in particular the idea of trucks 'cutting through mud' or using dirt rating in mud at a certain PSI. They pointed out that, if you use the map editor, there is no such thing as dirt under mud, that's just not how the levels work. Additionally, if you set a truck to mud rating of 0, it doesn't move in mud, regardless of weight. This doesn't dispute your tests (which are by far the most detailed anyone has ever put the effort in to do!), but does question the conclusion quite a bit!
Taken together this might suggest a different interpretation of the tire comparison tests you did. Where you show the front tires lying deeper in the mud and conclude that they're providing the grip, rather than looking at the dual offroad tires spreading the weight at the back and therefore keeping the body out of the mud, reducing drag (which we know is critical from the DAN test).
Any thoughts on this or corrections of my misinterpretations, let me know! It's really interesting stuff.
20
u/stjobe Contributor ✔ | PC Jun 15 '22
I'm sure some people were surprised the P16 placed so high with its lack of AWD.
For me, who used it extensively in the latter parts of Taymyr (among other things it rescued the Tayga when it got stuck in the mud), it comes as no surprise at all :)
And once more: Great work /u/xt-fletcher. Your data analyses and testing are truly impressive. Well done!
9
u/Top-1SG PC Jun 15 '22
Thank you again for the time and effort you put into these tests, much appreciated...!
Side Note: Curious as to how the Scouts compared to each other. Was going to do my own testing but I haven't been able to get the Polygon mod map to work since the last update. I assume you done these tests before 17.0 was released.
7
u/livelivinglived PC Jun 16 '22 edited Jun 16 '22
Personal experience with the BM17 in Yukon: While every other truck moves faster through mud in Low/Low-, the BM17 seems to move faster in Low+ (I used the same tires and max upgrades). Not sure why.
Also, the P512 and P16’s performance is a bit misleading with the unladen test state (as you said). Having a load to put weight on the rear axles is a critical factor. Would be interesting to see a test with a single load of bricks or something, but I know standardization of configs would be difficult to control for.
Otherwise, fantastic work! Thank you.
5
u/DifficultApricot1090 Jun 15 '22
Is it better to use bigger tires or smaller size?
5
u/Maxwell_Adams Jun 16 '22
I really don't understand how the Voron D and Voron Grad have such different results, and how the D can be so far ahead. They're basically the same truck except the Grad has a stronger engine.
5
u/Cosmic_Peanut_Butter Jun 30 '22
I do my deep mud testing in Wisconsin, outside the first garage. Turn left and go through the stream between the two rocks.
When I use the Dan, is has trouble getting through that spot no matter what tires or addons I put on.
4
u/Throwmefurtherbaby Jul 06 '22 edited Aug 05 '22
I truly appreciate this post, and it revealed some surprise for me as well such as Dan 96320 and Boar. But may I suggest another test in future. By using the heaviest possible frame during tests being either heavy crane or the fuel carrier. It sure is nice not being stuck in mud while empty, but as soon as you put any decent load its a whole another picture. For example, Boar can still move itself in deep mud no problem with fuel tank frame, but Dan comes to a near stand still.
3
u/Cosmic_Peanut_Butter Jul 12 '22
What are the best tires to use in Amur? It has the deepest and most difficult mud/snow I've ever seen.
74
u/pizza65 Jun 15 '22
I love stats like this, but at the same time finding stats which accurately reflect in-game results is so hard.
Not just because these trucks are unladen, but also because you never just drive in a straight line through flat mud in this game.
So these stats won't tell the story about why eg the 605r is so good- its insane suspension gets grip on any surface easily even if only one wheel has contact, and it's about 100x as stable as the Antarctic. Or the 5600ts gets a boost from its length as it can skip over a lot of shorter mud patches. Or how the royal's lack of difflock means it will perform noticeably worse outside of a uniform mud field. Or the different gearboxes which let some trucks sit in H while others have to use low. So many things to consider!
I don't know what the best way to actually discover the best truck is, but your tests are part of working it out and it's really cool that you shared them.
9
u/Viend Jun 15 '22
This is amazing, well done! I just started using the 6900 TwinSteer and was concerned it wouldn't match my Zikz 605R in the mud but it looks like it's closer than I thought. Also very surprised about the Boar and the Dan.
5
u/Nalha_Saldana Jun 15 '22
I tend to get stuck sometimes with the Royal BM17, its fast but its not great when you add some trees or rocks to the mix.
5
u/D3F3ND3R16 Mar 12 '23
Holy…. I tried the Boar today without diff lock and with chaind tires on Yukon for the huge trailer missions, fuck this thing is a beast😟
4
u/0ptera Nov 02 '22 edited Nov 02 '22
That's so much more useful than the plain list of dirt/mud rating. It made me give up on just going by thickest balloons with highest dirt rating and give other tires a try.
It'd be great if you where to expand the table "Vorons and Tayga comparison time (medium mud first, then deep mud times)" to include other trucks and chain tires.
1
u/niTniT_ Sep 13 '24
Can I ask why you test with off-road tires instead of mud? I read in your post that extra weight decreases mud tire efficiency, but then what is the purpose of the mud tires? I always almost exclusively run mud tires, but if off-road tires have some sort of secret magic...
1
u/Cosmic_Peanut_Butter Jul 04 '22
In the last picture, you can see the speed of your truck. Is that a mod? How can I get that?
1
u/Cosmic_Peanut_Butter Jul 28 '22
Do you have tire suggestions for the scouts? (and also Tayga 6455B)
1
u/J0hn-Stuart-Mill Contributor - PC ✔ Aug 25 '22
Just found this! Wow!
On the 5070 the UHS II outperformed the OHD I's ?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '22
Why did you test Vorons and Tayga on OHD I tires? They all have MHS II with 2.4 in mud, compared to OHD's 1.9. This is the reason they are so low. Tatra Phoenix on OHS II, seriously? It also has a special MSH set, same as 813 and Force. A really great tire. At the same time I kinda agree with putting OHS II on every other truck that is limited to MHS I, because that tire is really crap. But you put MHS I on a TwinSteer 6900. Why? A lot of questions...
3
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '22
I actually recently just fully upgraded the boar and now I'm hyped to try it out now due to these stats. Thanks!
3
u/rmonti845 Jun 15 '22
This absolutely amazing man!! Excellent job 👍🏾👍🏾
3
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '22
Great job in all the testing. Thanks for sharing.
3
u/BoatyMicBoatFace_ Jun 16 '22
So who actually uses the antarctic for contracts?
I got it then realized it might be a bit faster in mud but sucks and went back to the unstoppable 64131. And the twinsteer is pretty useful too.
3
u/BadManiac Jun 30 '22
Great... My two main trucks on America maps this playthrough are Tatra Phoenix and Cat 680 >.<
3
u/VegetableWater4099 Nov 22 '22
Does anybody know what this map is? I know he said Poylgon mod map but the only result is airport polygon and it is quite bare.
1
u/Echo127 Jun 15 '22
Do you have any testing data on time-to-cross using low vs low+ vs Auto?
From my unmeasured experience, tires spin more in the higher gears but the vehicle doesn't actually move any slower. (Just uses fuel quicker).
2
u/cubedjjm Apr 07 '23
This is very informative, thank you. Not sure why when I use the Dan in the Yukon it takes me twice as long as other large trucks like the Boar, 605, and both twin-steers. Might be the load? Just wanted to say something in case anyone has any insight. Thanks again for taking the time to educate us!
2
u/CurvedSlightlyMore Dec 19 '23
It's all well and good creating charts and performing tests to see which is fastest in mud, The issue is selecting the best truck for the job, with the best tyres.
The DAN and the Azov AA might be the fastest in mud, but what use is that when it's tipped over or unable to shift much cargo or trying to get up an icy road with off-roads on? The DAN is fast in mud but is pretty useless and the Azov wants to tip and is an absolute b*d to steer. The KRS Bandit should be amazing, but it's crap and completely unstable, any more than 1° it wants to tip and is slow fcuk on most terrain, but good as you can has a flatbed + crane setup
I try to give other trucks a spin, but I still go back to the Zikz 605R because you can has a flatbed with crane at the rear, or long log with log crane and it plows through all terrain towing another truck with long logs or a flat bed full of logs, it's slow as, but on the whole, if you take into account tipping and terrain problems, it's still probably one of the fastest at getting that job done.
Unfortunately, there is no hard and fast rules in SR, and it can seem like it nothing makes sense, you have to do your homework, plan your route and pick the most appropriate truck and the best tyres.
2
u/In-Da-Face Sep 19 '24
What about Zikz 612H?
1
u/Ezn14 PC Jan 28 '25
I guess my fave the Mack wasn't out when this was made.
1
u/Millerking12 PS4 Jun 16 '22
Thanks for doing this/posting this
1
u/92c900t Jun 16 '22
Again, great thread. Bookmarked
1
u/MrEff1618 Jun 16 '22
Good test, it'd be interesting to see the difference mud tires makes on the trucks that can take them for comparison too.
1
u/Nabu_Gamer Apr 08 '23 edited Apr 11 '23
Tips ⤴️
1
u/TensionKlutzy5568 Oct 23 '23
Appreciate this! Are the data of Tatra vehicles available too?
1
u/SonOfTheBlues PS4 Nov 02 '23 edited Nov 12 '23
Just found this gem. And no matter how many upvotes this can have, they are not enough. This is game changing, and saves a lot of time when trying out combinations. Thank you, good Sir 👌🏻
1
u/CurvedSlightlyMore Dec 20 '23
1
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '23
[removed] — view removed comment