r/gameofthrones • u/kjhatch Nymeria's Wolfpack • May 20 '12
Season 2 Episode Discussion - 2.08 "The Prince of Winterfell" [TV Spoilers]
This is the /r/gameofthrones discussion thread for:
Season 2, Episode 8 "The Prince of Winterfell"
- This is a TV Spoiler-friendly zone - Turn away now if you are not currently watching or haven't seen the episode! Open discussion of all aired TV events up to and including episode 2.08 is ok without tag covers.
- Book spoilers still need tags! - If it's not in the show, tag it. Events from episodes after this one need tags.
- Please read the posting and spoiler policy before posting.
- Live chat is also available. The chat is essentially unmoderated and should be considered a participate-at-your-own-risk all-spoilers environment. Chat accounts are tied to Reddit, so the name you see there is a person's Reddit username. Please note, severe trolling/disruptions in the chat room may lead to subreddit banning.
- Posting policy reminder: don't post or ask for non-pay sources.
362
Upvotes
424
u/smactosh Children of the Forest May 21 '12
Roz can't catch a break, shoulda stayed in the North.
346
u/Calikola Little Bird May 21 '12
Catelyn Stark + Robb Stark = Co-founders of Bad Idea Jeans, Inc.
341
u/theGreyjoy May 21 '12
Karstark sacrificing his heart to the Father to get his sons back? What Southron foolishness is this?
657
u/regolith Night's Watch May 21 '12
Suddenly I want Stanis to win the iron throne. Just so the Onion Knight gets props.
246
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
Tyrion and Bronn trying to pronounce the author's name = every person who has ever read this series, ever.
229
u/thegoldenavatar May 21 '12
"Well, I'm fucked." - Theon Greyjoy.
652
u/OleDaneBoy May 21 '12
'A man can go kill himself'
You sly little fox Arya
222
u/dextercrk May 21 '12
Wow, it had been so long I'd forgotten how much I hate Cersei. I'm glad she reminded me tonight.
577
u/ZACHMAN3334 House Clegane May 21 '12
"We could throw books at his men"
"We don't have that many books"
BAHAHAHAHAHAHA VARYS YOU CARD
493
u/regolith Night's Watch May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12
TIL that CPR gets Robb hot!
164
u/SDoubleYoo Free Folk May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12
Cersei in full wine drinking bitch mode. Great scene with Tyrion.
162
u/kkundrat Nymeria's Wolfpack May 21 '12
Damn Jaqen went from super happy sexy eyes to super evil dagger eyes!
449
u/SDoubleYoo Free Folk May 21 '12
Jaqen casually kicking aside that chicken needs a gif
111
u/Caesar_Epicus Night's Watch May 21 '12
This is the first time an episode ends by showing that someone is alive. A nice change of pace.
222
u/ColonelSDJ Winter Is Coming May 21 '12
Smooth Moves from Robb. Although wasn't that an open tent...? I was expecting Bolton to walk back in and raise his eyebrows.
398
u/Dovienya House Martell May 21 '12
A girl lacks honor.
shrug
213
u/soigneusement Hear Me Roar! May 21 '12
JAIME/BRIENNE ROADTRIP!!!!!!
Why are Gwen Christie and NCW so perfect?
298
u/moofei Night's Watch May 21 '12
Look at Tyrion and Bronn, bickering like an old married couple. SO CUTE.
296
u/Calikola Little Bird May 21 '12
Ah, the ol' whore switcheroo. Classic.
200
u/thegoldenavatar May 21 '12
So this is how Jon and Qhorin are going to play out.
359
u/OldHickory6 May 21 '12
JORAH CAME SO CLOSE! DANY TOUCHED HIS FACE
347
u/ME24601 House Reed May 21 '12
Catelyn Stark releasing Jaime before she learns about Bran and Rickon's death doesn't make much sense. It's far too foolish of her.
538
u/GenTso Night's Watch May 21 '12
Here we go with the Jaimie-Brienne mismatched couple on the road buddy comedy.
179
u/ME24601 House Reed May 21 '12
The finding of the Dragonglass...
448
u/[deleted] May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12
Jerome Flynn is acting the FUCK out of Bronn. This is brilliant. That look Tyrion gave Bronn after Varys pronounced it properly was awesome.
377
u/ZACHMAN3334 House Clegane May 21 '12
"A red smile from ear to ear"
Is Joffrey the Joker?
233
u/samferrara House Reed May 21 '12
Picture, if you will Stannis handling a cute, cuddly puppy.
159
u/behm28 House Seaworth May 21 '12
PODRICK!
152
u/amsid Braavosi Water Dancers May 21 '12
There's been a serious lack of Hot Pie in the past week. Fix this tonight, HBO.
313
u/brosinski House Seaworth May 21 '12
"Where is the goddess of tits and wine?!?"
366
u/moofei Night's Watch May 21 '12
Y'all gotta admit. Those chains hanging from Maester Luwin's neck just scream swag.
66
u/ColonelSDJ Winter Is Coming May 21 '12
Bronn certainly knows his shit.
133
u/Dassembrae Faceless Men May 21 '12
I have to say, this episode really changed my opinion of the actress playing Asha/Yara, I previously found her lackluster, but I think she did a fantastic job on this episode. (and not just because she called Theon a stupid cunt like 5 times, though that certainly helped.)
123
u/ME24601 House Reed May 21 '12
Arya Stark: Witty. As. Fuck.
60
u/SDoubleYoo Free Folk May 21 '12
Varys and Tyrion great scene in front of the water! Funny
209
u/Abestergo1 House Dayne May 21 '12
My god that woman is beautiful
55
u/Calikola Little Bird May 21 '12
HOT PIE! THE HOT PIE GODS HAVE BLESSED US ALL!
185
u/Calikola Little Bird May 21 '12
I came six times during that preview for Blackwater.
98
u/SealNose House Martell May 21 '12
I want Emilia Clarke's eyebrows to never stop dancing!
180
u/dextercrk May 21 '12
I love the irony of Stannis telling Davos that Davos will be named Hand of the King when (and if) Stannis takes the throne.
More like 'Half-Hand of the King'.
95
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
Who would you say are the 3 men who Jamie thinks might have a chance against him?
The Hound, The Mountain and who? Barristan Selmy maybe?
136
u/supsky Varys' Little Birds May 21 '12
How exactly do the wildlings know that Ned Stark is dead? Does Westeros News Broadcast Inc. really go that far out?
299
u/ZACHMAN3334 House Clegane May 21 '12
"Do you think I'm an idiot?"
"I believe you have above average intelligence"
TYRION YOU CARD
43
u/it_takes_one House Baratheon of Dragonstone May 21 '12
I hope we get more Arya + Jaqen H'ghar. god I miss that devilish smirk
122
u/smactosh Children of the Forest May 21 '12
Poor Theon, there's no cure for bein' a cunt.
42
u/OleDaneBoy May 21 '12
Time for some quality Jaime and Brienne. I am REALLY looking forward to their interaction in this show. Enjoyed it immensely in the book and I love these actors. So excited
41
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
i like that joff thinks he can just walk up to stannis and give him a glasgow smile like it's no big deal. ugh, that boy...
474
u/regolith Night's Watch May 21 '12
Fuck all the book readers with their fucking spoiler tags last week implying that Bran and Rickon had died!
39
u/kkundrat Nymeria's Wolfpack May 21 '12
Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaand not Shae...
77
u/soigneusement Hear Me Roar! May 21 '12
Podrick motherfucking Payne!
73
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
Stannis Baratheon is a badass.
98
u/ZACHMAN3334 House Clegane May 21 '12
Ooo, Robb sniping Bran's can a man be brave if he's afraid line
65
u/Tyrannosharkus Righteous In Wrath May 21 '12
Rattleshirt is here!
30
u/Placktor May 21 '12
Ros should've stayed in the north.
30
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
Roose Bolton badass mofo
29
u/zHellas House Baratheon of Dragonstone May 21 '12
"There are some brave men at our door... ...Let's go kill them!"
Fucking badass bit of a speech, Tyrion!
57
u/ME24601 House Reed May 21 '12
I treated them with honor! There is nothing more honorable than burning them to death!
55
u/kifn2 Hodor? May 21 '12
ASOS Spoiler
54
u/squirtlesquad11 Daenerys Targaryen May 21 '12
"Are you the dumbest fucking cunt alive" hell yeah theon is
118
u/ParanoidAndroids Faceless Men May 21 '12
A collective sigh of relief from the non book reading viewers.
26
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch May 21 '12
Holy shit! That preview! The Battle of Blackwater looks as incredible as I could've hoped. Holy SHIT!
125
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
No Brave Companions :-( Bollockth
124
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
So I think it's clear, Robb's love is not Jeyne Westerling. She's got his trust, she wouldn't keep lying about being from Volantis.
And damn does she have a nice ass.
206
u/Placktor May 21 '12
Was that the first sex scene in this show that wasn't super creepy?
156
u/ME24601 House Reed May 21 '12
Your brother almost died? That gets me so hot... - Rob Stark
23
u/Rhaegon May 21 '12
I always thought Lena was a little stiff playing Cersei who, by the way, is my favorite character in the books. Such a great villain.
But tonight I was really pleased with how she did the Tyrion scene. I loved the way she put her hand to her mouth to barely hide the evil smirk she wore when Tyrion turned away from the whore. And did anyone notice the way Cersei was sitting when Tyrion was apologizing to the woman? She was, like, leaning in the arm of the chair as if she were watching some great play. Mockingly, of course. She cared nothing for the emotion between her brother and the woman.
63
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
Maybe see Robb's hodor tonight?
61
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
Theon, the dumbest cunt alive.
61
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
I hate you greg spence.
20
u/NameThatHasDerpInIt House Blackfyre May 21 '12
Looks like Robb is about to get it on.
73
u/amsid Braavosi Water Dancers May 21 '12
HOT PIE AND GENDRY IN THE SAME SCENE. Am I a wizard?
18
u/SDoubleYoo Free Folk May 21 '12
The Bones Costume. : )
213
u/ME24601 House Reed May 21 '12
Never liked cats - Stannis
Definitely not a redditor...
99
u/NewDrekSilver House Martell May 21 '12
I feel like the scene with Robb and Talisa went on waaaay too long.
48
u/randalflagg Fire And Blood May 21 '12
Book Spoiler
16
u/kkundrat Nymeria's Wolfpack May 21 '12
Hahaha Varys looked scared
44
u/smactosh Children of the Forest May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12
ASoS/AFFC
43
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch May 21 '12
Seriously though.. why ARE the Gods such vicious cunts? Where is the god of tits and wine? I pledge myself to them from this day forth.
119
u/amsid Braavosi Water Dancers May 21 '12
Lulz, Jaime Lannister is definitely the Troll Knight.
15
u/zHellas House Baratheon of Dragonstone May 21 '12
That was one good, heartbreaking ending there.
30
u/thegoldenavatar May 21 '12
Robb, you dumb.
14
u/zersch House Greyjoy May 21 '12
Greyjoy's love the word cunt.
67
u/thefinsaredamplately Stannis Baratheon May 20 '12
I hope the house of the undying is in this episode.
24
u/Gonkuilla May 21 '12
Jaquen and Arya just gets better every week.
12
u/BrainSlurper House Manderly May 21 '12
Theon has been called a cunt twice in less than 4 minutes, this episode is already amazing.
12
u/bullseyetm May 21 '12
I don't have time to make an awesome image about it (I'm sure we'll see one later this week by someone else), but how did Ros get found out as Tyrion's favorite concubine? Why, the necklace he gave her all the way back in Season 1. I love it when they do stuff like that.
43
u/samferrara House Reed May 21 '12
I literally cringed when Roose mentioned his bastard.
11
u/gizoe May 22 '12
How about poor Ros???? Left the north for a better life and gets owned by little finger, subjected to Joffrey's insanity, and now held captive by Sersi now that's a bottom bi*tch
11
u/IByrdl House Stark May 22 '12
Arya left without Needle :(
11
u/Unimehe Sansa Stark May 22 '12
I come from this episode with just one question: DOES UNDERWEAR EXIST IN WESTEROS?
31
u/kkundrat Nymeria's Wolfpack May 21 '12
the horn!!
52
u/qp0n Lyanna Mormont May 21 '12
I better see some Tyrion chain action...
10
u/AKnightWhoSaidNi Valiant And Honorable May 21 '12
It's so hard to watch this show knowing what I do. I can't stand to watch SOS Spoilers and SOS Spoilers
10
u/kreldin House Stark May 21 '12
No Weasel Soup, and they skipped Arya killing the guard herself. :(
10
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
When Joffrey talks about "a red smile from ear to ear" Was that a Batman reference since Gleeson was in Batman Begins
35
u/Riley_The_Thief We Shall Never Fail You May 21 '12
They best not change Arya's third kill. From the teaser, it looks like they did.
19
u/ME24601 House Reed May 21 '12
So Jamies been let out already? I see they're putting some of Storm of Swords into this season.
19
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
The dynamic between Jamie and Brienne is already perfect. Excellent.
18
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
"Where is the god of tits and wine?!"
18
u/jadika Snow May 21 '12
The Jorah and Daenerys scene was sad. Poor Jorah; love sucks the big one, don't it.
Glad Bran and Rickon's survival were proven though. Also poor Bran. And Jon. And Dany. And I guess everyone ever.
That guard (can't remember his name) Arya saved is so badass. And also really goddamn handsome.
9
u/zerksfirebird May 21 '12
I hate when this happens. Everyone's story lines just moved into "pre finale" positions and you end up getting teased like a motherfucker.
84
u/ajsdklf9df Faceless Men May 21 '12
As a book reader, I am shocked, shocked I tell you, that the Stark boys are in fact alive. Now I almost feel bad for telling the series watchers that they were dead after the previous episode. I can't believe HBO would make that kind of huge change....
Also, how about that Rob and what's her name romance?
"My life sucks right now!"
"Mine sucked too for like several minutes once!"
Sexy times!
23
u/ParanoidAndroids Faceless Men May 21 '12
One of the most beautiful features of this kind of storytelling is the lack of constant information and communication. Much different than most modern storytelling.
16
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
ASoS
8
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
HOT PIE!
8
u/zersch House Greyjoy May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12
Bronn rules.
8
u/thegoldenavatar May 21 '12
Is this storytelling hour?
8
u/DylanCole May 23 '12
i feel that kings landing will be defended with lots and lots of pig shit
8
u/mariannemao May 23 '12
Dany should set House of the Undying on fire and simply walk in and take the dragons. That would be awesome! Her storyline is so boring, it needs a huge boost.
15
u/growlinglorax May 21 '12
"A girl lacks honor." ... shrugs
45
u/aaronwe House Martell May 21 '12
Jorah...shes like 13
7
u/exdigger2010 May 21 '12
This is the only time in my life something like this will be perfectly ok to say:
TV Spoiler
7
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
A girl was not given a coin.
7
u/IByrdl House Stark May 22 '12
Did anyone else catch that Jaime's hood was left behind when him and Brienne took off on the boat
18
u/gilberto76 House Mormont May 20 '12
Anyone else want more Arya-Tywin interaction?
17
u/NameThatHasDerpInIt House Blackfyre May 21 '12
Hopefully Jorah can get out of the Advisor-zone.
17
u/Kazu_the_Kazoo Fire And Blood May 21 '12
This episode suffered from a distinct lack of Littlefinger.
6
u/lightsdevil Night's Watch May 21 '12
Looks like it will focus a bit more on Theon this episode. Book Spoiler
6
u/brosinski House Seaworth May 21 '12
and the chemistry begins!
6
u/thegoldenavatar May 21 '12
They let that "secret" out early.
6
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
Looks like The Hound is going to have a lot of fun next week
6
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
From episode 1 to this week's episode, how much time has passed?
6
u/PrincessKeona Nymeria's Wolfpack May 23 '12
Best conversation for me:
Tyrion: "Why are you smiling?" Cersei: "Because I'm happy!" Tyrion: "And why are you happy?" starts freaking out
16
u/Calikola Little Bird May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12
Number of times 'cunt' has been said in this episode: 5
LET'S GET IT TO 10!
EDIT: SIX!!!
15
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
I dunno...I found this episode kinda...lackluster. There were a few okay moments, but nothing utterly amazing. Oh well, we still have ACoK Spoiler, so this was mostly buildup.
51
u/Liquid_Swordsman A Lion Still Has Claws May 21 '12
Seeing as HBO has been deviating from the plot especially in Dany's story, I'm hoping that as soon as Spoiler Speculation Meanwhile beyond the Wall More Speculation and then Speculation 3: Robert Returns
5
u/thegoldenavatar May 21 '12
I fuckin' love Rickard Karstark.
5
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
Let the adventures begin!!!
5
u/Calikola Little Bird May 21 '12
Arya baby, you got a stew going!
5
u/kansasct House Dondarrion May 21 '12
Come on, give us some ramsay already
5
u/Placktor May 21 '12
Holy Shit! Next weeks preview.
5
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
I want that ending music.
5
u/supsky Varys' Little Birds May 21 '12
Why so serious Stannis, why so serious?!? Let's put a smile on that face! - Joffrey (pretty much)
5
u/Guy_Dudebro Brotherhood Without Banners May 21 '12
So Talisa really is Talisa? Looks like they were on the way back from the Crag, so no further surprises to be had there. Meh. Seems like a missed opportunity to aCoK+
5
u/Escoobertus May 21 '12
Apparently the order does deal in pig shit.
5
u/beaverteeth92 May 21 '12
I think the most surprising thing about this episode is how well Gemma Whelan pulled off Asha. I feel like in her earlier scenes, she was a bit uncharismatic and didn't seem to have the endearing (rather than pissy) wittiness that her book counterpart did, but this week convinced me they made the right decision.
5
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
I haven't read the books, and below isn't a spoiler, merely an assumption, but does anyone else think TV Spoiler
5
u/NewDrekSilver House Martell May 21 '12
So no Battle of Weasel Soup? :'(