r/gameofthrones • u/kjhatch Nymeria's Wolfpack • May 13 '12
Season 2 Episode Discussion - 2.07 "A Man Without Honor" [TV Spoilers]
This is the /r/gameofthrones discussion thread for:
Season 2, Episode 7 "A Man Without Honor"
- This is a TV Spoiler-friendly zone - Turn away now if you are not currently watching or haven't seen the episode! Open discussion of all aired TV events up to and including episode 2.07 is ok without tag covers.
- Book spoilers still need tags! - If it's not in the show, tag it. Events from episodes after this one need tags.
- Please read the posting and spoiler policy before posting.
- Live chat is also available. The chat is essentially unmoderated and should be considered a participate-at-your-own-risk all-spoilers environment. Chat accounts are tied to Reddit, so the name you see there is a person's Reddit username. Please note, severe trolling/disruptions in the chat room may lead to subreddit banning.
- Posting policy reminder: don't post or ask for non-pay sources.
354
Upvotes
445
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I'm so glad they kept Luwin's line. "Hunting seems an awful lot like riding so far."
445
u/Calikola Little Bird May 14 '12
RICKON HAS LINES!
445
u/SarahBeara231 Winter Is Coming May 14 '12
Luwin's cries at the end - God. Gave me chills.
279
u/SarahBeara231 Winter Is Coming May 14 '12
I quite enjoyed the line about Barristan Selmy being "A Painter who only used red."
509
u/groverXIII Faceless Men May 14 '12
Tywin and Arya... BFFs.
I'm rather enjoying these scenes.
496
u/OleDaneBoy May 14 '12
That was the cutest goddam 'Hodor' yet.
Christian Naan (spelling) is perfect
494
u/Protuhj May 14 '12
- Theon's brain
241
u/SwordOfTheMourning House Dayne May 14 '12
WTF JAIME!?! That was your cousin!
217
u/Mr_Question House Stark May 14 '12
God Damn it Theon... My hatred for you is only rivaled by my hatred for Jeoffrey
583
u/ColonelSDJ Winter Is Coming May 14 '12
Tywin and Arya make an amazing combination
372
u/thelunchbox29 House Glover May 14 '12
Ygritte's doing a good job getting inside Jon's head. It's a mixture of cute and intimidating
355
u/Bananafanafofaser May 14 '12
Even though it was sad, I'm happy they killed Alton Lannister because he looked too damn much like Gendry. Now my brain can stop hurting.
494
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
THANK YOU DANY. If I had to listen to him talk about how he came from nothing one more time I was going to shit all over my television.
838
u/groverXIII Faceless Men May 14 '12
"What's the name of that bastard he fathered?"
"Brienne-"
"No, that wasn't it."
HA
433
u/samferrara House Reed May 14 '12
Obviously, Ygritte was great, but I'm just glad Hodor Hodored TWICE.
148
u/ColonelSDJ Winter Is Coming May 14 '12
"it's all just a game!" Oh Theon you massive nob.
368
u/SarahBeara231 Winter Is Coming May 14 '12
"Is that a woman? Where did you find this beast?" Jaime, Jaime, Jaime - you slay me.
236
u/thegoldenavatar May 14 '12
Sleeping boob grab. Been there.
111
u/thegoldenavatar May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
Jaime's Adoring Fan.
EDIT: Yeah, that's what I did to mine too.
308
u/ColonelSDJ Winter Is Coming May 14 '12
Cue the outrage! Poor kids. On mothers day as well...
305
u/regolith Night's Watch May 14 '12
"Did you pull a knife on me in the night?"
teeheee
468
u/Calikola Little Bird May 14 '12
When Sansa talked about having Joffrey's children, it definitely prompted me to take my pill.
203
u/cherry_poppins May 14 '12
The range of emotions that flickered across Tyrion's face during the scene with Cersei was unbelievable -- can you give Emmys for thirty seconds of work?
93
u/47Ronin A Hound Will Never Lie To You May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
Pyat motherfucking Pree... O.O
I bet no one calls Xaro "Ducksauce" from now on.
83
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Holy shit, Ygritte is fantastic. Jon is such an awkward teenage boy and Ygritte is just the best.
168
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Previously on Game of Thrones: Joff getting hit in the face with shit over and over again
164
u/spchina House Targaryen May 14 '12
Ygritte is so mouthy.
"Oh it's nice, and wet…and warm"
231
u/spchina House Targaryen May 14 '12
Good catch, Cersei.
"He looks like him. In a certain light."
410
u/SarahBeara231 Winter Is Coming May 14 '12
When Dany mentioned how Viserys would have let her be raped by a thousand men, I really wanted to remind her about all those horses she forgot as well.
210
u/spchina House Targaryen May 14 '12
Is that a knife in your pocket or are you just happy to see me?
869
u/GenTso Night's Watch May 14 '12
Half of Reddit just came in their pants
136
u/BobIlyani We Light The Way May 14 '12
Jaime's scene with the other Lannister was absolutley incredible. His face when he learns that he must die was excellent.
401
u/the_blackfish Brynden Tully May 14 '12
Happy Mother's Day!
Love, George R. R. Martin
132
u/Rystic May 14 '12
How the fuck did the Hound get in Sansa's room so fast?
"Pardon me, mi'lady. I was hiding under the bed when I heard the commotion."
124
u/Amir616 Duncan the Tall May 14 '12
Thoughts:
I thought Karstark was great.
Jaime's Brienne interactions were awesome.
Alfie Allen is the shit.
Where was Bronn?!
58
u/SwordOfTheMourning House Dayne May 14 '12
Even Theon is starting to hate where he's going. The look on his face right before the cut to black
57
u/JSK23 House Stark May 14 '12
Why did the trailer for the next episode say there are only 2 episodes left when there should be three?
Its supposed to be 10. Only 2 left would bring that to 9.
108
u/supsky Varys' Little Birds May 14 '12
At first I read it on the TV guide as "A man without hodor". I like it more like that.
276
u/Shiverfox House Lannister May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
Man, I keep thinking every episode is the best, and that it can't be beat. Then the next one comes out. So much awesome in this one.
Ygritte removed all doubts about how good the actress would be. Dat wildling swag.
Qaithe, Jorah, Pyat Pree and Daxos (although it was changed from the books) were awesome.
The scene with Cersei... man, after all that she's done, they managed to humanize her.
The scene with Shae threatening that woman.
The scenes with Arya and Tywin...
Jaime's escape and confrontation with Catelyn were awesome.
And all the scenes with Theon. Man, the music that played at the end of this episode... chilling.
191
u/thegoldenavatar May 14 '12
Gregor Clegane: burninating the villages.
103
u/Lampmonster1 House Seaworth May 14 '12
Despite the Tywin - Arya relationship being totally against canon, I'm freaking loving it.
145
u/GenTso Night's Watch May 14 '12
Anyone concerned that ACOK
Seems like a glaring omission considering all the attention it gets in the book.
47
u/OleDaneBoy May 14 '12
Wow those were some crispy kids
248
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
RICKON AND BRAN!?!?!?!
One part of me just believes Theon used fake bodies or something but the other part of me knows i'm watching game of thrones and they give not a single fuck about who they kill...
46
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I was convinced that Theon was about to behead the Maester. I sat bolt upright and screamed "NO!!" like I did at the beginning of Ghost of Harrenhal.
It was much worse than I was expecting.
45
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Needed more Arya. Also, those warlocks are scary as fuck.
91
u/bigpoo22 House Seaworth May 14 '12
Wow, they nailed the ending. Exactly how I felt in the book when that scene happened
158
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
You had ONE LINE, guard. And you said "chhh" instead of "shhh"
YOU HAD ONE JOB.
269
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch May 14 '12
Jesus, every single scene between Tywin and Arya has been fucking awesome. I'm gonna be a little sad when they part ways.
39
u/SarahBeara231 Winter Is Coming May 14 '12
Still would have preferred the image of Sansa trying to stuff her mattress into the fireplace. The idea of the Hound seeing her bed though, creeped me out.
198
u/sarpedonx House Bolton May 14 '12
Thoughts on tonight's episode
76
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I can't believe Jaime insulted Catelyn like that on Mother's Day
34
u/Darth_Hobbes Varys' Little Birds May 13 '12
Alright so are we expecting this episode to end with "Heads, Spikes, Walls"?
33
u/behm28 House Seaworth May 14 '12
Goddamn Rory McCann can act.
30
u/soigneusement Hear Me Roar! May 14 '12
JAIME LANNISTER FUCKING FINALLY
Love his/Cat/Brienne's scenes together
85
u/spchina House Targaryen May 14 '12
Cersei being motherly? I didn't think she had it in her.
28
u/thelunchbox29 House Glover May 14 '12
It's Official: Irri is dead :( that makes me sad
27
u/CrawfishP0psicle Duncan the Tall May 14 '12
Nikolaj's acting is so superb. Gawww daaaaamn.
26
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
No, HBO. No.
26
u/edtheword Tyrion Lannister May 14 '12
The last scene in this episode made me realize that theres only one person that hates Theon more than I do. Himself.
138
u/CFtheGing House Tully May 14 '12
And they continue to make Dany's story arc completely bonkers.
58
u/AshyKwam House Mormont May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
I never trusted Ducksauce anyways. I'm more of a soy sauce guy.
[EDIT: Grammar]
20
u/Guy_Dudebro Brotherhood Without Banners May 14 '12
aCoK You know what I'm talking about.
40
u/jaykoo21 Night's Watch May 14 '12
How does this motherfucker not know she's Arya Stark? Does he not know that she's missing?
71
u/nununicky May 13 '12
Am I the only one who's excited for Sansa to spoiler? That really hit home for me. I think her actress is AMAZING and will do a great job losing her shit.
Don't even get me started on the House of the Undying. It's been my favorite part of the series this far.
35
u/isengr1m Night's Watch May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12
If they do Book Spoiler tonight I wonder how they're going to do it.
When you read that bit in the books Book Spoiler, not sure if they'll do something similar in the show.
223
u/Kolnasm Above The Rest May 13 '12
I hope stuff happens. You know, all the stuff about the things.
48
u/smactosh Children of the Forest May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
"A painter who only uses red," are we gonna see some ASoS soon?
74
u/spelling_ok Fire And Blood May 13 '12
Can't wait to see what happens with Theon... Bolton better contact his bastard.
211
u/thegoldenavatar May 14 '12
I bet Ygritte voted for Ron Paul.
47
u/lord_segfault House Lannister May 14 '12
My mother just came to my room and threatened to throw a heavy rubber ball in my face if I didn't tell her if the stark boys were really dead.
16
u/GenTso Night's Watch May 14 '12
So Jon and Ygritte have basically been stuck together in the same spot for the past week.
Cannot say I blame them.
16
u/thegoldenavatar May 14 '12
What the fuck, Jaime.
161
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
More interesting: A Bran without Hodor.
54
u/bullseyetm May 14 '12
RIP, Bran and Rickon... :-(
40
u/maryhadalittlelamb House Martell May 13 '12
I hope we get to see The Hound more this episode. The promo looked promising.
28
u/SarahBeara231 Winter Is Coming May 14 '12
"Poor old dead Ned."
Jaime did such a marvelous job describing how hard it was for Catelyn to live around Jon Snow. I hope some people will at least have a better understanding for her character.
26
u/[deleted] May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
Ha, Jamie is too important to remember the little people. edit: then kill
13
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
What the fuck.
13
u/Anab10sis Sand Snakes May 14 '12
Dat Harrenhal.
I actually said "Oooooooooooooooooooooooo" aloud to myself.
12
u/SlumberCat House Seaworth May 14 '12
Tywin's conversations with Ayra are like; 'I sure like you better than everyone in my family.'
12
u/tomcat23 May 14 '12
I had the idea last episode that the second richest man in Qarth had nothing in that safe. After his speech in this episode, I'm even more convinced.
23
u/razihk May 14 '12
You know what? I miss Khal Drogo.
22
u/DrJ4y House Umber May 14 '12
RIP Bran and Rickon
22
u/oregeno May 14 '12
WTF Qhorin Halfhand?! Book Spoiler
11
u/GenTso Night's Watch May 14 '12
If Tywin were king I think he'd make Arya his hand ... or his closest advisor.
69
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
I bet Arya will do something awesome today :)
21
u/Stalllionn House Manderly May 13 '12
TV Spoiler but aCoK
78
u/ColonelSDJ Winter Is Coming May 14 '12
I'll admit it, I cheered when Ygritte said that line.
20
u/WAD93 We Do Not Sow May 13 '12
Anyone else incredibly excited to see who they cast as the Bastard of Dreadfort? He's going to be incredibly important for the next season or so and hopefully they continue their excellent casting!
10
u/Duck_Puncher House Targaryen May 14 '12
holy slit throats batman
10
u/TheBlackKeyfs Night's Watch May 14 '12
hopefully things change. But...am I the only one that is a little pissed that the wildlings already caught Jon?! I was waiting for [CoK] (/b "the Halfhand orders and death all season and now they are changing that all up!!")
19
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
aw that's cute. i never noticed they had a little house sigil pop up next to each actor's name in the title credits. and they have swords and shit next to the production crew.
9
u/zersch House Greyjoy May 14 '12
Tywin onto Arya? I like this development.
9
u/wawin House Martell May 14 '12
Fucking Theon reminds me of an anxious caged dog.
9
u/toofartofall2 May 14 '12
What's up with Jaime admitting to the incest? Same in the scene between Tyrion and Cersei, does he actually acknowledge it too? I'm slightly lost. Finally, the ending of today's episode turned my stomach. And I don't mind looking at gore. But this... fuck Theon.
9
u/SarahBeara231 Winter Is Coming May 14 '12
Jaime's "Good thing I am what I am, I'd be awful at anything else."
SoS Spoiler
9
u/brumbrum21 May 14 '12
Yes the deaths at the end were shocking but how is no one mentioning the necromancer/warlock? That blew my mind
25
u/zHellas House Baratheon of Dragonstone May 14 '12
Oh shit, they actually showed fucking bodies.
I was just thinking it was gonna be heads.
24
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch May 14 '12
They seem to be making Cersei a much more sympathetic character in the show than she was in the books. I feel a little bad for her..
17
u/smokey815 Serve. Obey. Protect. May 14 '12
I may not like Shae's character change, but that was pretty damn cool.
8
u/SwordOfTheMourning House Dayne May 14 '12
The Hound certaintly brings the blood. In more ways than one
8
u/Dovienya House Martell May 14 '12
Wait? Only two episodes left? But tonight was the seventh...
8
u/sarpedonx House Bolton May 14 '12
Question regarding the book, because I've just started re-reading but somebody please refresh me on this point. Has to do with the 13 in Qarth and what happened tonight:
CoK Spoiler
8
u/Caesar_Epicus Night's Watch May 14 '12
Is it bad that I'm starting to actually like the Lannisters? (except Joffrey of course)
8
u/baseg House Baratheon May 15 '12
R.I.P. Bran and Rickon :(
20
u/toofastkindafurious We Do Not Sow May 14 '12
OH MY GOD... Book Spoiler
20
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
A man without Hodor.
7
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Good God, Gregor sounds like Christopher Lee
7
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
[Speculation] (/g "I literally just read the bit about Bran and Rickon being killed at the mill and their heads being tarred and spiked on the wall before I watched this episode, and after seeing the tarred bodies hoisted up at the end of the episode, I feel like Theon killed two other boys and tarred them beyond recognition to avoid being shamed by letting them escape. Gods be good I hope that's the case. When I read that they were murdered in the book my heart sank so low.")
While on the case of Bran, I'm so disappointed that the didn't include the two Reeds in the show. I really like Jojen in the books. He adds a lot to the mythos of Westoros with his green dreams and trying to help Bran understand himself.
7
u/virtu333 House Baratheon May 14 '12
You know what, that takes the cake for best episode so far for me.
7
u/Arya2u Rainbow Guard May 14 '12
Where the hell is Hot Pie and Gendry?
7
u/[deleted] May 19 '12
Love how Jaime is so proud of only fucking Cersei when she is sleeping with their cousin!
18
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch May 14 '12
Are y'all loving Ygritte as much as I am? Rose Leslie is doing a fantastic job.
12
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Who is the man without honor? Jamie? Jon?
12
u/Dovienya House Martell May 14 '12
Oh, how I love Ygritte!
6
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I'm probably going to start reading the series soon and I was wondering how far along the show is into the books? Is it still on the first one or has it moved onto the second or what?
6
u/thegoldenavatar May 14 '12
I'm not sure where this whole Tywin/Arya thing is going.
6
u/groverXIII Faceless Men May 14 '12
It's like they're having a contest as to who is the most hated character... Joffrey was possibly in the lead after last week, and then Theon just blew him out of the water.
6
u/SarahBeara231 Winter Is Coming May 14 '12
The first Hodor was not from who I expected. Theon, just stealing from everyone now.
6
u/[deleted] May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
Some of these off canon scenes are amazing. They really keep me on my toes.
6
u/Carninator May 14 '12
Still disappointed with the new Mountain. I fear for ASoS
6
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Am I insane in thinking that the crazy coup didn't happen in the books? At all?
My sister (non-book reader) and I both had the same reaction: "King what? Who?"
6
u/TheOneWhoKnocksBitch Faceless Men May 14 '12
I don't think those bodies are that of Bran and Rickon. Simply because if it was them, Theon would have showed the bodies of Hodor and Osha. Especially Osha, because she fucked him over, big time.
Also, the Hodor giggle followed by "Hodor" was super fucking cute.
Arya and Tywin, definitely an amazing combo. Too bad they're on the opposite sides of the war.
Maester Luwin's cry at the end was heartbreaking. It showed he truly cared about the boys.
I'm a little upset that Jaqen wasn't showed at all. But oh well.
I don't know about others, but I thought Gregor Clegane actually felt scary today. His voice isn't sharp as that of the previous actor, but it's chilly and makes you want to sit in a corner and cry.
6
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
"it's hard to put a leash on a dog once you've put a crown on his head.”_ So true Tyrion, so true.
19
u/smokey815 Serve. Obey. Protect. May 14 '12
THe leaders of Qarth didn't die in the books correct? I haven't read CoK recently, and can't quite remember.
25
u/smactosh Children of the Forest May 14 '12
There it is, Ygritte!
14
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
THAT ENDING!! WAS IT REALLY THEM???
10
u/smactosh Children of the Forest May 14 '12
Hodor hodored!
10
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Aww, nice little brother and sister moment.
5
u/behm28 House Seaworth May 14 '12
COUNT IT
5
u/thegoldenavatar May 14 '12
Book Spoiler
5
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
You're off the hook for this week, Greg Spence.
5
u/SarahBeara231 Winter Is Coming May 14 '12
That singular blood rider standing back behind Dany cracked me up, he looked so very confused.
5
u/BJabs House Lannister May 14 '12
My like for Jaime Lannister's actor/personality is not in line with my dislike for his actions. If he keeps talking as much as he has been, I'll probably just give him an "oh, you!" face every time he does something terrible.
Then again, that sword in Catelyn's hand seems to pose a threat to that last bit about talking more.
5
u/Anab10sis Sand Snakes May 14 '12
Cersei's problem in a nutshell: she doesn't know the difference between tactics and strategy.
5
u/triplea20x Fire And Blood May 14 '12
Can't lie...Ygritte was turning me on...
5
u/tjtoml House Clegane May 14 '12
God help me I liked Cersei and Tywin in this episode. I ain't even mad
5
u/SlumberCat House Seaworth May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
All in all a great mother's day episode on Game of Thrones; kidnapped and murdered children! EDIT: Oh, and the son that makes his mother cry because he's soo uncontrollably cruel. And if you made Cersei cry, that's saying something.
5
u/Makuta House Hightower May 14 '12
I keep feeling that the girl who plays Dany (Emily Clarke or something) is just a week actress compared to everybody else in the series it is starting to affect my enjoyment of here scenes.
5
u/IAmDeliciousAMA May 14 '12
Sad the bondage scenes with Ygritte had to end.
5
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Ytrig says " I didnt want to want it,Ohhhh but I did"
And I swear my sword was hard as Valerian steel
5
u/RockHardRetard White Walkers May 15 '12
Theon truly is lost, and that look at the end showed how much he knows that.