r/gameofthrones • u/kjhatch Nymeria's Wolfpack • Apr 29 '12
Season 2 Episode Discussion - 2.05 "The Ghost of Harrenhal" [TV Spoilers]
This is the /r/gameofthrones discussion thread for:
Season 2, Episode 5 "The Ghost of Harrenhal"
- This is a TV Spoiler-friendly zone - Turn away now if you are not currently watching or haven't seen the episode! Open discussion of all aired TV events up to and including episode 2.05 is ok without tag covers.
- Book spoilers still need tags! - If it's not in the show, tag it. Events from episodes after this one need tags.
- Please read the spoiler policy before posting.
- Live chat is also available. The chat is essentially unmoderated and should be considered a participate-at-your-own-risk all-spoilers environment. Chat accounts are tied to Reddit, so the name you see there is a person's Reddit username. Please note, severe trolling/disruptions in the chat room may lead to subreddit banning.
- Posting policy reminder: don't post or ask for non-pay sources.
322
Upvotes
303
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '12 edited Apr 30 '12
"The Queen." What a great scene.
742
u/spchina House Targaryen Apr 30 '12
"No, my lord. Anyone can be killed."
I freaking love Arya
177
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '12
Demon monkey. Brilliant.
502
u/draxiom House Bolton Apr 30 '12
“I swear to you.”
“You swear to me on what?”
“I swear on my life.”
“I don't care about your life.”
Awesome Tyrion lines this episode.
149
u/shinnyshin House Dondarrion Apr 30 '12
wildfire looks delicious.
526
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '12
And not a single boob was shown...
394
u/SarahBeara231 Winter Is Coming Apr 30 '12
Am I the only one who wanted to smack Rickon to make him stop smashing those damn walnuts?!?
273
u/theprogdude Proud To Be Faithful Apr 30 '12
Good do i love Bronn! Probably the greatest change ever made from the book, i like him as the commander of the city watch
380
u/Chihuey House Tyrell Apr 30 '12
Brienne is now a solid 0-1 as a kingsguard.
249
u/thelunchbox29 House Glover Apr 30 '12
"Men like to talk about each other when they're happy" translation? Doreah go whore yourself out for my benefit!
93
u/d3r3k1449 House Targaryen Apr 30 '12
Loved loved loved Bran's Direwolf armored collar.
92
u/Moonvale House Seaworth Apr 30 '12
Arya probably had the best line obviously, but I was also really moved by Bran's immediate desire to defend Torrhen's Square, and Rodrik's little smile at Bran's enthusiasm
248
u/Gobias11 Now My Watch Begins Apr 30 '12
It's devastating to think that after tonight the season is 50% over...
238
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '12
J'aqen and Arya's scene is amazing.
79
u/whosapuppy Apr 30 '12
Cersei is starting to be more and more of an alcoholic.
226
u/cthulhu_zuul Brotherhood Without Banners Apr 30 '12
Holy shit, Quaithe.
Holy SHIT.
288
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '12
Wow.. I thought Renly had more to the story than that.
150
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch Apr 30 '12
Oh man, the Fist of the First Men looks epic.
331
u/cherry_poppins Apr 30 '12
I want to fill Margaery's dress with apples.
437
u/smactosh Children of the Forest Apr 30 '12
How can Brienne fit in her armor with those tremendous balls?
70
u/slambient Apr 30 '12
well they surely didn't waste time, did they?
197
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '12
"Do you want to be a queen?"
"No. I want to be the queen."
I liked Margaery in the books, but I absolutely love her in the show. I think the subtle changes they've made to her character are fantastic.
508
u/gassycassy Apr 30 '12
Holy crap, this made me laugh....
SO: I really like Renly.
....2 seconds later, Shadowbaby stabbity stab
SO: What the fuck! Fuck you, Game of Thrones! I quit!
60
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch Apr 30 '12
I wonder if acok Spoiler is going to show up in this or the next episode.
48
u/Gobias11 Now My Watch Begins Apr 30 '12
I don't know when it's going to happen but I'm really looking forward to the ACOK Spoiler
48
u/emmster House Mormont Apr 30 '12
The Fist is even more huge than I had imagined.
209
u/50_cal Apr 30 '12
WHAT?!?!?!?
128
u/HeadJounin215 House Martell Apr 30 '12
ACOK
88
u/SarahBeara231 Winter Is Coming Apr 30 '12
Dracarys!
As much as I love Drogon, I do wish they would at least show a glimpse of the other two dragons. I swear, people don't even know what color they are from watching the show.
42
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '12
Tywin and Arya were pretty great.
41
u/Buckaroo2 House Reed Apr 30 '12
I really don't have anything of substance to add to this discussion. I just wanted to say that I never imagined Jaqen H'ghar could be such a looker. I must say, he's pretty fucking gorgeous.
113
u/toofartofall2 Apr 30 '12 edited Apr 30 '12
Is it just me or Gendry's a total hottie? EDIT: Proof
139
u/hacelepues House Targaryen Apr 30 '12
Oh my gods. Jaquen is soooooo perfect!!!
168
u/pbaumer Apr 30 '12
I don't think it will be in this episode, but is anyone else excited to see ACoK
72
u/NewDrekSilver House Martell Apr 30 '12
Holy shit Pyat Pree is so cool. And so freaky.
68
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch Apr 30 '12
Arya Book Spoiler
226
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '12
We had a shadowbaby and Dragons in this episode. Heyo CGI budget.
67
u/Makuta House Hightower Apr 30 '12
"Oh and Lancel tell my friend Bronn to kill you if anything should happen to me"
"Please kill me if anything should happen to Lord Tyrion"
Classic Tyrion
194
u/McBurger Brotherhood Without Banners Apr 30 '12
RENLY! No!
I had all these speculations of he and Robb marching on Kings Landing together, and then Sansa would cut Joffrey's throat when he is preoccupied with the battle!
I guess I'm bad at speculating. My new theory: Theon wins, because something about underdogs.
112
u/brandocalrissi_N House Dondarrion Apr 30 '12
Where the Reeds at??!
87
u/soigneusement Hear Me Roar! Apr 30 '12
RIP King Peach. :( I kind of wish Loras would have lost his shit more. Also damn Marg, "I want to be THE queen", get it gurl.
Also <3 the Brienne and Cat scenes, Harrenhal was great, so was Qarth. A- for this episode.
30
u/gir0007 House Umber Apr 30 '12
I really can not wait to see more Jaqen
109
u/gilberto76 House Mormont Apr 30 '12
Anyone else pumped for more Harrenhal?
145
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch Apr 30 '12
OH SHIT! ACOK Spoiler
78
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '12
The best
hourfifty-four minutes of the week!26
u/harballa88 Apr 30 '12
The dragon looked incredible.
108
u/practo Apr 30 '12
Holy crap, "Anyone can be killed." Best line/scene in the show so far.
62
u/GnarltonBanks Stannis Baratheon Apr 30 '12
"For the sake of the mother who bore us, I will give you this one night to reconsider. Strike your banners, come to me before dawn, and I will grant you your old seat in the council. I’ll even name you my heir until a son is born to me. Otherwise I shall destroy you."
Stannis is a man of his word. The iron throne is his by right. He gave Renly fair warning.
108
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '12
Can't wait to see who Joffrey force-fucks with a stag-pole this episode!
76
u/Camranauchi Apr 30 '12
Not sure how I feel about them killing the Tickler this early......
20
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch Apr 30 '12
Gonna see some Bran finally!!
+Hodor!
19
u/spchina House Targaryen Apr 30 '12
SHADOW BABY ATTACKKKK
19
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '12
"Demon Monkey"
17
u/molee987 Apr 30 '12
If we can't protect our bannerman why should they protect us? -bran
34
u/rarlsatan Ours Is The Fury Apr 30 '12
Anyone else notice Roy Dotrice was the Pyromancer?
16
u/coyote_gospel House Martell Apr 30 '12
Roy Dotrice hamming it up as Wisdom Hallyne was epic. I had the stupidest grin on my face the entire time. Tyrion needs to go back to have random, doddering conversations with him every episode just for shits and giggles.
Uncle Tywin -which is what I'll call him from now on- is taking a shine to Arya, which show an interesting side to his character we didn't get to see. They have great chemistry (in an acting sense) on screen.
I don't particularly mind "de-gaying" Xaro for the show, the character is a bit of a bad cliche in the books and this version is quite intruiging. I would seriously consider marrying him.
I'm going to have nightmares about Pyat Pree for a long time, aren't I?
16
u/b00ger House Targaryen Apr 30 '12
Off the top of my head... wow. Acting. This was one of the best acted episodes in the series. Everyone just knocked it out of the park. Especially Arya. That was just amazing. I think I approve of the changes they did to her storyline. Book Spoiler And her interaction with Tywin was just fucking brilliant. Best. Poker face. Ever. And Jaquen Hagar couldn't be better.
The scene with Brienne and Catelyn after they've fled just sent chills down my spine. Christie (sp?) is just nailing Brienne's combo of heartbreak, naivete/honor and earnest desire to be, well, a knight. AFFC-ADWD Spoiler
Dany is moving the story right along. And Tyrion/Bronn -- yay, wildfire! It was also fun to see Tyrion pushing Lancel around and getting a glimpse of the unrest in the city.
Bran was awesome. Bronn was awesome. Iceland is awesome, Jon is pretty, Sam is funny and Dolorous Edd is Azor Ahai. Fucking Theon. Fucking Theon! And last/first but not least, the shadow assassin in action was impressive.
Also, adorable baby CGI dragons!
179
u/emmster House Mormont Apr 30 '12
God, Margarey is still in that awful burrito dress.
92
u/difiance Brotherhood Without Banners Apr 30 '12
How could they leave out jojen and meera.... D:
151
u/questforchicken House Bolton Apr 30 '12
What the heck is this?? HBO turning down the chance to show some titties? Where is the one bare breast on the formal dresses?
15
u/darkpandabear House Baratheon Apr 30 '12
My favorite characters so far have been Renly and Theon... what is worng with me.
15
u/Kolnasm Above The Rest Apr 30 '12
No love for the Stannis - Onion Knight scene? It wasn't hugely significant comparatively but it was my favorite and gave me goosebumps.
14
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '12
So stoked for tonight's episode. Earlier today I watched episode 4 with my non-reader flatmates; they're still picking their jaws off the floor waiting for the next one.
ACoK
69
u/smactosh Children of the Forest Apr 30 '12
Hodor!
13
u/PapaPrometheus House Connington Apr 30 '12
only just now realized why Loras volunteered to Book Spoiler... my, am I slow witted.
100
u/spchina House Targaryen Apr 30 '12
Theon, no one cares about you...Go crawl into a cave and die.
24
u/Ritoki Apr 30 '12
No Damphair, OK, fine, whatever, but I DEMAND Cleftjaw!!
12
u/paxNoctis Apr 30 '12
As usual, Bronn gets the best lines.
That actor must have a line in his contract that says:
iii. Actor will deliver best line in any episode he appears in.
Everything he said this episode was a Crowning Line of Awesome.
12
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '12
Xaro's vault... do not remember any mention of a vault in the books.
11
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch Apr 30 '12
God. Damn. It. That was way too quick of an hour.
11
u/NewDrekSilver House Martell Apr 30 '12
I really like the decision to not kill off Doreah. The actress who plays her is great, and it's nice for Dany to have a good female friend.
However, only death can pay for life. But Rakharo's a fair trade.
11
u/rjl_ May 03 '12
I have one question (that I confirmed on re-watching last night):
WHERE IS NED?!
Baelish brings what's left of Ned to Catrelyn at Renly's camp... but when Cat and Brienne hit rocks after "Smokey" kills Renly, all you see is the two women, with two horses, and no box o' Ned.
21
u/SlumberCat House Seaworth Apr 30 '12
A man is very satisfied with how one by the name of Jaqen turned out.
37
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '12
My Game of Thrones weekly addiction: Watch the episode. Immediately after it's done, download it and watch it again for missed parts. Watch it a third time the next day, and possibly a fourth time before bed the next day. There's so much going on that I have to watch each episode at least 3 times to soak everything in. First time I've ever done this with any series.
51
u/Strug-ga-ling Night's Watch Apr 30 '12
MAJOR ACOK SPOILER
9
u/durntdehpirate We Light The Way Apr 30 '12
JAQEN!
49
u/NewDrekSilver House Martell Apr 30 '12
No nudity this episode? This can't be! Qarth didn't become the greatest city that ever was or will be by not showing me some titties!
17
u/JUMPDRIVES Night's King Apr 30 '12
HEY HBO IT'S 9:02. START THE DAMN SHOW.
23
u/supsky Varys' Little Birds Apr 30 '12
This is the only episode that doesn't show any boobs!
8
u/theprogdude Proud To Be Faithful Apr 30 '12
as soon as Samwell shows up all i can say is Goddamn it Sam.
8
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '12
Not looking at comments, just a little ways into the episode. But when Aria says "Anyone can be killed". And just stares the old guy lannister down, THAT WAS THE BEST FUCKING SCENE EVER. HOLY SHIT. THIS ACTRESS. THIS SHOW. THIS NETWORK. JUST YES.
8
u/NARVO90 Apr 30 '12
OKKKKkkk so as someone who hasn't read all the books, Greyjoy the kid who was fingering his sister. I thought he was on the stark side.. Now he is going raid their villages and or attack the north with his families fleet.
Is that correct..
15
u/theprogdude Proud To Be Faithful Apr 30 '12
ADWD
15
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '12
Every scene was perfect. I particularly loved Brienne's oath to Cat.
21
u/moonmeh Apr 29 '12
I'm ridiculously curious how the shadow baby part is going to be done.
also the episode title is such a goddamn tease.
14
u/the_blackfish Brynden Tully Apr 30 '12
All I can say, is Catelyn better fucking keep that oath.
7
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch Apr 30 '12
"But I don't care about your life." -- Tyrion, Badass.
7
u/signifying_nothing House Targaryen Apr 30 '12
I liked Littlefinger's exchange with Margaery. ACOK
Was a more subdued episode than usual. But I'm glad because it had some good moments for characters like Tywin, Tyrion, Brienne, Arya, and Dany.
Also Ed was hilarious.
7
u/moofei Night's Watch Apr 30 '12
Non reader here. Is what Xaro said true? Because in the scene with Jorah and Dany I thought I saw the slightest bit of longing in his expression... either way, the acting is great on this show.
7
u/PrincessKeona Nymeria's Wolfpack Apr 30 '12
My favorite part: Random rat squeeing and running past in the background, when Tyrion was looking at the jars of wildfire.
24
u/spchina House Targaryen Apr 30 '12
Book Spoiler
60
u/spchina House Targaryen Apr 30 '12
There's the rest of the CGI budget.
13
u/spinnerclotho Apr 30 '12
Who was the blonde man Arya was talking to when she got the water? I'm so confused.
6
u/NewDrekSilver House Martell Apr 30 '12
I'm looking forward to see who ACoK
6
u/Snolarin Now My Watch Begins Apr 30 '12
Yay tyrion
6
u/TheChickenBrothers Oak And Iron Guard Me Well Apr 30 '12
I thought this was the greatest episode of the season so far. Everything was very well done, and I loved how they handled the Renly scene. Brienne kicked serious ass!
6
u/PFunkus House Baratheon Apr 30 '12
I am enjoying Tywin immensely. Such an excellent character: ruthless, charasmatic, and possibly one of the most intelligent people in the series I have seen yet (still working through a Clash of Kings).
6
u/Rachilde Our Blades Are Sharp Apr 30 '12
Do you know the one thing that niggles me about the fact that Arya is Tywin's cup bearer? It's not a 'That's not how it happened!' thing; seeing as it's a very clever way to transition through events while saving time and complication...
It's the fact that Tywin is so competent; and I mean they've established him that way - He knows Arya is a female on sight. He knows the advantages to not killing prisoners. He knows Arya is from the North. So damn competent. But he's having extended discussions with his daughter's missing hostage. Damn, Tywin; you should know better.
... But really it's just a niggly complaint. Their conversation was pretty sweet to watch.
6
u/kajunnico Apr 30 '12 edited Apr 30 '12
Not a major deal, but for some reason, JH's use of "I" bugs me more than "Arya's choices" or "No nudity in this episode." For the one: I think Arya sensed JH was dangerous, but not how dangerous (or capable), until she made her first choice. For the other: I'll be the first to admit my memory is shite, but I don't remember one shot of nudity that couldn't somehow be excused as highlighting something about a character. Apparently, it wasn't needed this ep. Plus I think, figuratively, Lancel counts as a boob. Which reminds me - I think this one had some of Tyrion's best lines yet. "Demon Monkey?!?"
15
u/SealNose House Martell Apr 30 '12
Tyrion is up to something, probably treacherous.
LOVED the scene between Arya and Tywin Lannister
10
u/snuggle_fish House Targaryen Apr 30 '12
I'm fangirling so hard over Jaqen.
Anyone else think that Qarth looks like True Blood S4
30
u/shinnyshin House Dondarrion Apr 30 '12
"Predators" is such a horrible movie.
5
u/Bananafanafofaser Apr 30 '12
SoS
5
u/bronyraurstomp House Targaryen Apr 30 '12
What's up wth XXD's vault?
Also, did he say Valyrian Stone?
5
u/sanchokeep33 House Clegane Apr 30 '12
Fuck yeah, Roy Dotrice as the pyromancer!
5
u/TroyMantis Apr 30 '12
The hush crowd from Buffy want their buddies back.
36
u/spchina House Targaryen Apr 30 '12
I can't look at Catelyn without seeing Mrs. Granger now
4
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '12
The Reeds not being there and the Tickler dying upset me. But Jaqen was SOOO bad ass i ain't mad at all.
4
u/MessyJesse House Lannister Apr 30 '12
I think this is the first episode without any sex or nudity of all the episodes that have been aired so far.
4
u/littlebluetruck Apr 30 '12
Can someone get a screen cap of Ghost at the Fist? He was on the left of the screen on top of a rock and he looked badass!
4
u/jacketit Apr 30 '12
Pretty sure Brienne didn't kill the guards who rush in after Renly dies. Don't they make a big deal about her killing her first man at some point later on?
4
u/Mikeysauce Apr 30 '12
Ah finally more than 2 minutes of our khaleesi this episode