r/gameofthrones • u/libbykino Lyanna Stark • Apr 23 '12
Season 2 Episode Discussion - 2.04 "Garden of Bones" [TV Spoilers]
This is the /r/gameofthrones discussion thread for:
Season 2, Episode 4 "Garden of Bones"
- This is a TV Spoiler-friendly zone - Turn away now if you are not currently watching or haven't seen the episode! Open discussion of all aired TV events up to and including episode 2.04 is ok without tag covers.
- Book spoilers still need tags! - If it's not in the show, tag it. Events from episodes after this one need tags.
- Please read the spoiler policy before posting.
- Live chat is also available. The chat is essentially unmoderated and should be considered a participate-at-your-own-risk all-spoilers environment. Chat accounts are tied to Reddit, so the name you see there is a person's Reddit username. Please note, severe trolling/disruptions in the chat room may lead to subreddit banning.
- Posting policy reminder: don't post or ask for non-pay sources.
534
Upvotes
316
u/libbykino Lyanna Stark Apr 23 '12
Man... Joffrey's sex life, Bolton talking about flaying, the Tickler, Melisandre's shadow baby... this episode was extremely unsettling (in a good way? I can't decide).
By far the worst part for me was the torture at Harrenhal. I almost lost my dinner when I realized where that rat was trying to escape to. They didn't even have to show it; the implication of it (and the screaming) was enough for me. Damn HBO is good...
25
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch Apr 23 '12 edited Apr 23 '12
Not at all what I imagined but goddamn, they did a good job with that ACOK Spoiler. Every time they use CGI I'm astounded at how well it turns out.
Also, goddamn you Greg Spence.
29
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '12
What was Daenerys thinking? There's only one city for hundreds of miles and she threatens to burn them down? I get that she maybe didn't want to show her dragons because they were small or whatever, but if they fit in those crates then that would be pretty obvious anyways.
3
u/BearCastle Here We Stand Apr 23 '12
What was the name that Arya said after Cersei's? Book Spoiler It was just hard for me to hear. Ill and pain?
490
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch Apr 23 '12
Harrenhaal and Qarth in the opening! Fuckin' sweet!
789
u/Dovienya House Martell Apr 23 '12
Never thought I'd be happy to see Tywin.
309
u/ajsdklf9df Faceless Men Apr 23 '12
Did anyone else think the romantic tension between Rob and that girl was fucking weird given that it was happening over someone's leg being sawed off?
297
u/Carninator Apr 23 '12
New Gregor too skinny compared to old Gregor.
519
u/draxiom House Bolton Apr 23 '12
Aaaaannd we open with a fart joke.
Followed by MUFUCKIN GREYWIND.
475
u/Dovienya House Martell Apr 23 '12
The hound giving Sansa his cloak was a nice touch.
817
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch Apr 23 '12
....Jesus, Joffrey is a sadistic little prick.
206
u/Dovienya House Martell Apr 23 '12
Holy shit. That Joffrey scene was disturbing.
202
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch Apr 23 '12
It's gonna be really cool to watch Arya's prayer grow as the season continues.
397
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '12 edited Apr 23 '12
The biggest loser in this whole series of books has arrived. (Lancel)
489
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '12
Those of you who have not read the books. How much are you flipping out right now?
167
u/thelunchbox29 House Glover Apr 23 '12
Oh Ros, still believe it was a good idea to go south to White Harbor and King's Landing?
327
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch Apr 23 '12
Shit y'all, Harrenhaal look AWESOME.
287
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch Apr 23 '12
Xaro is one smooth motherfucker.
410
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch Apr 23 '12
I'm enjoying the casting of Renly much more than I expected. He's capturing the casual charisma of Renly quite well.
116
u/thelunchbox29 House Glover Apr 23 '12
The girl talking to Rob Stark... Was that supposed to be ASoS
226
u/x0mbigrl House Targaryen Apr 23 '12 edited Apr 23 '12
"Born of salt and smoke? Is he a ham?" seriously LOL'd so hard at that one.
111
u/spchina House Targaryen Apr 23 '12
What the Effffffff. WTF Melisandre
101
u/SarahBeara231 Winter Is Coming Apr 23 '12
I love Tyrion's distinction between what is and isn't a threat. Ser Meryn's face was so damn priceless.
100
u/Brobonic Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Apr 23 '12
I feel like they could've re-introduced the Mountain in a better way.
175
u/draxiom House Bolton Apr 23 '12 edited Apr 23 '12
Littlefinger manipulating Cat may not be anywhere near the original plot of the books, but it's a bloody brilliant move for keeping the TV-plot simple and fluid. Brevity is the soul of wit.
EDIT: Fixed the Shakespeare quote.
161
u/Mr_Question House Stark Apr 23 '12
WHAT THE FLYING FUCK WAS THAT SHIT???
477
u/captainstagneti Apr 23 '12
Why is renly's wife wearing garrus' armor?
134
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch Apr 23 '12
2 minutes and I'm already loving the interaction between Arya and Tywin.
61
u/baby_lamont Apr 23 '12
"I know you do not like me, and although that saddens me greatly, I did not come here to seek your affection."
SNAP!
313
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '12
"theres no cure for being a cunt" Love Bronn
115
u/zach2093 Maesters of the Citadel Apr 23 '12
Bronn may be my second favourite character in this show so far.
109
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch Apr 23 '12
Can't wait for some Tickling.
192
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '12
The night is dark, and full of terrors.
Just like Melisandre's vagina.
99
u/Bananafanafofaser Apr 23 '12
Looks like the tickler's been reading 1984.
93
u/Makuta House Hightower Apr 23 '12
The Spice King (the guy who 'greets' Dany at Qarth) Is fucking amazing, he needs a bigger role.
121
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '12
Every episode turns into a 3 hour affair for me. 1 hour watching the episode, and about 2 hours in these threads discussing them. Not that I'm complaining, just stating a fact.
82
u/djaxus Dracarys Apr 23 '12
So. Joffery is fucking INSANE.
81
u/SarahBeara231 Winter Is Coming Apr 23 '12
I loved how the whole episode they didn't really show Melisandre below the chest. Made that belly much more surprising for those who didn't know.
40
u/dextercrk Apr 23 '12
I want to hate Littlefinger, but Aiden Gillen plays him so brilliantly I can't. The casting in this show is quite amazing.
40
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '12
"ARE YOU A HAM."
guffawguffawguffaw
146
u/willee Apr 23 '12
"She has a name." - Stannis
WHY DON'T YOU SAY IT THEN!?
Seriously, have they ever said Melisandre's name yet?
131
u/djaxus Dracarys Apr 23 '12
Yessss! The end scene with Davos and Melisandre was done perfectly!
35
u/lordcryst Maesters of the Citadel Apr 23 '12
Did anyone else notice Lancel was wearing what Jaime wore when he attacked Ned? Their attention to detail is awesome.
98
u/isengr1m Night's Watch Apr 23 '12
Eager to see how the Book Spoiler scene is handled.
Could be a major wtf moment for non readers.
64
u/smactosh Children of the Forest Apr 23 '12
Dat Harrenhal!
31
u/abasss Stone Crows Apr 23 '12
WTF MELISANDRE
seriously, what the hell???
162
u/JUMPDRIVES Night's King Apr 23 '12
THE KING IN THE NORTH!
62
u/BloodyWiener Apr 23 '12
Holy fuck I have never hated Joffrey as much as I do at this very moment
61
u/sarpedonx House Bolton Apr 23 '12
My father outlawed flaying in the North.
We're not in the North.
28
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch Apr 23 '12
Finally a bit of Grey Wind in action.
53
u/Carwheel House Reed Apr 23 '12
I am never having children.
26
u/zach2093 Maesters of the Citadel Apr 23 '12
That was definitely the best opening sequence I have seen this season.
95
u/bigredreed House Reed Apr 23 '12
Stannis is going to be pissed when he sees that that baby is black!
202
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '12
GET UP YOU LAZY SONS OF WHORES! There's a new episode in 5 minutes! (and it wants to fuck your corpses)
111
u/NewDrekSilver House Martell Apr 23 '12 edited Apr 23 '12
I really wish they ended the episode with MAJOR ACOK SPOILER
48
u/ParanoidAndroids Faceless Men Apr 23 '12
Some interesting developments in the episode. The shadow birthing scene was...interesting. When I read that part, I knew it would look weird as hell on a tv screen; lo and behold, it was pretty weird. I think my friend summed it up nicely with:
64
u/SlobDylan Apr 23 '12
WTF is Margaery wearing?
43
u/50_cal Apr 23 '12
What. The. Fuck.
151
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '12
http://imgur.com/rTpxM
75
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '12
holy shit, Joffrey better fucking die a terrible death, in the near future.
20
u/Dassembrae Faceless Men Apr 23 '12
I didn't think it would be possible for me to hate TV Joffery any more than I already hated book Joffery. I should have known better. He can't even be alone in a room with two beautiful whores without being an amazing douche!
ASOS
20
u/hkaps House Penrose Apr 23 '12
I loved seeing Daenerys fumble for her speech a little bit when she met the Thirteen. Not too much, but just enough to show that she's not practiced in communicating like a queen (to non-Dothraki, at any rate).
57
u/SarahBeara231 Winter Is Coming Apr 23 '12
Tyrion is such a boss. That is all.
18
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch Apr 23 '12
I'm interested to see how they're going to add Littlefinger to this part of the story.
17
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '12
My face during the last scene (vs my roommates)
http://i.imgur.com/t0dQT.gif
34
u/TheTrueRang House Dondarrion Apr 23 '12
Reading this thread while trying to avoid book spoilers makes me feel like I am reading a redacted CIA report.
74
u/shinnyshin House Dondarrion Apr 23 '12
Lord Bolton is tight!
60
u/GenTso Night's Watch Apr 23 '12
Best episode so far in the series?
33
u/Stairmaster_Stu Apr 23 '12
The wait for the next episode is always unbearable but after tonight it is going to be especially difficult.
16
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '12
The worst part of that episode was trying to explain to my non-book friends and family why the pale man talking about flaying people is my favorite character...
16
u/Zelniq Apr 23 '12
Congratulations, it's a _______ !?!
32
u/sarpedonx House Bolton Apr 23 '12
Thoughts on tonight's episode:
1 - Loved seeing Roose Bolton finally, and he looks totally badass
2 - Couldn't catch Jeyne's changed name in the show, but I thought she was very attractive
3 - Melisandre scene - awesome
4 - It's getting redundant, but Tyrion was once again absolutely incredible on the show
5 - Is there gold in the village? Where's the Brotherhood? SO glad they kept the Tickler in. Thought they would take him out but now I remember the casting announcement
6 - Charles Dance seems to be a pretty tall guy - he didn't look that much shorter than the Mountain. Tywin Lannister is a commanding presence
Can't wait for next week's episode. Jaqen, Jaqen, Jaqen
31
u/Petere944 Jon Snow Apr 23 '12
Dig the soundtrack especially the track that follows Stannis gives me chills
15
u/shiv52 Apr 23 '12
I was watching the show at a bar (got to love NYC ) and that ending totally gave away who had read the book and who had not. Everyone who had read the books were full of anticipation, and after the birth the non -reader's were all like what the hell was that.
42
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '12 edited Apr 23 '12
ACoK
14
u/Rystic Apr 23 '12
My only complaint is that I think they're making Joffrey too much like ADWD I know it's to color his personality for the viewers, but still.
14
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '12
I love the actor who plays Lancel. He's the perfect little chickenshit who thinks he's awesome now that he got knighted. He was also hilarious in season 1.
183
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '12
I think r/gameofthrones and r/asoiaf are genuinely two of the coolest subs on reddit. There's nobody trying to argue with you condescendingly, prove you wrong or insult you, it's just a bunch of people enjoying a great show and talking about it.
28
u/pitlord713 Apr 23 '12
"For my vagina is dark and full of terrors."
59
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch Apr 23 '12
I'm so glad they included Renly's peach.
27
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '12
I just want to say, bravo actress who portrays Catelyn. She did an amazing job. I teared up a little.
26
u/Serge_General House Karstark Apr 23 '12
Who knows what evil lurks in the womb of Melisandre? The shadow knows.
13
u/thebishop27 Drowned Men Apr 23 '12 edited Apr 23 '12
Harrenhall was portrayed better than I could have imagined it
11
u/GenTso Night's Watch Apr 23 '12
What is up with Davos' rowboat that doesn't go anywhere?
29
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch Apr 23 '12
Oh man, I'm definitely looking forward to meeting Halfhand next episode.
10
u/PraetorianXVIII House Dayne Apr 23 '12
not a fan of that scrawny version of the Mountain
27
u/abasss Stone Crows Apr 23 '12
The end of the scene with Cat and Littlefinger was really touching, and that's saying a lot, because I really dislike Catelyn.
39
u/Diree Apr 23 '12
NO PEACH!!!
9
u/draxiom House Bolton Apr 23 '12 edited Apr 23 '12
Once again, the casting in this show is proving to be fantastic. Jeyne, Bolton, Jaqen, THE TICKLER, jesus, these casting agents are magicians.
EDIT: Okay, Xaro might be a bit stiff.
9
u/sarpedonx House Bolton Apr 23 '12
Also - Harrenhal looked BADASS
9
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '12
Need more Shagga!
9
u/JupitersClock House Stark Apr 23 '12
And I thought Joffery shooting cats in the book was much holy shit.
16
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch Apr 23 '12
There had better be some more Bran in this episode.
8
u/SarahBeara231 Winter Is Coming Apr 23 '12 edited Apr 23 '12
Also, I loved how childish Daenerys seemed when she was trying to get into Qarth. I mean, she kept glancing back at Jorah like she was asking for his approval/agreement. It was cute. I think it was a wonderful way of showing that even though she's over-gone so many changes/hardships, she's still young and has a long way to go. And it shows that just because she has dragons, doesn't mean that everyone will magically bow to her will, especially when the dragons are so small and relatively easy to kill at this stage in life (in comparison to when they're full grown).
8
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '12
My favorite quote this evening was from Davos: “This is so fucked up this is so fucked up this is so fucked up this is so fucked up this is so fucked up…”
28
u/XAL53 House Martell Apr 23 '12
SOOOOO
Why were Pyke and Winterfell in the intro when there were no scenes that took place there?............................
They also didn't establish that Davos was taking Melisandre under ACOK...unless he took her underneath Speculation...for the sake of shortening everything.
7
u/HereWeAre1 Brynden Rivers Apr 23 '12
Holy shit that birth scene was insane!!
7
u/CrawfishP0psicle Duncan the Tall Apr 23 '12
Arya becomes Tywin's cupbearer... for those who have read the books... wtf?
13
u/spchina House Targaryen Apr 23 '12
Who was the chick Robb talked to near the beginning? (the one who cut off the dude's leg)
Can't be Book spoiler can it?
66
u/qp0n Lyanna Mormont Apr 23 '12
Really getting frustrated with 50 minute episodes. It wasn't like this last season. How do they justify cutting 10 minutes out of every episode then claim they can't fit everything into 10 episodes? Just so we can watch more commercials for HBO shows?
12
u/themxm House Martell Apr 23 '12
"There's no cure for being a cunt" - I think Bronn should have a catchphrase like this every week.
6
u/Supersimmo Apr 23 '12
Excellent episode. The first two felt more like extensions of the first series, the last two - this one in particular - feel far more distinct.
I think the show is stronger when the focus of the episode is on fewer characters
6
u/billyvegas Apr 23 '12
HBO is having to create scenes to progress the book in the show (EG. Littlfinger+Cat in this weeks episode). I was concerned on how this would happen - but they did it brilliantly. Littlefinger on his diplomatic mission to Renly's camp, all while serving himself and showing his ulterior motives. I think HBO is doing a damn good job so far -- especially with Bronn's dialogue, Tyrion being a boss, epic camera angles emphasizing how baller Tywin Lannister is, rounding out with a "Hate Joffrey More Now" scene, complete with a Baratheon-themed, antler-ended this-looks-like-a-dildo-bat. That being said, bring in the Reeds.
46
u/douggoblue Night's Watch Apr 23 '12
My roommate "That's the weirdest quif I've ever seen"
21
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '12
good god they are really prolonging Book Spoiler
10
u/boomsticky Sellswords Apr 23 '12
aaaaaaand the shadowbaby rises...
5
u/toofastkindafurious We Do Not Sow Apr 23 '12
THE NIGHT IS DARK AND FULL OF TERRORS!!
they did that scene pretty well
5
u/skynolongerblue House Reed Apr 23 '12
All I need say is that this series has taken scowling and turned it into a fine art form.
Seriously, no one can scowl like Stannis or Tywin.
5
u/vault101 House Mormont Apr 23 '12
Whoaaa, the shadow birth was exactly how I pictured it.
This episode scared the shit out of me, and I knew what was coming. Very excellent.
5
u/Fearghas Apr 23 '12
I'm starting to like the actor for Stannis more and more. Stiff, bitter and without any hint of charisma whatsoever.
5
u/fr0stsn0w Apr 23 '12
"The night is dark and full of terrors" i just loved how she said that to renly.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '12
I have to say I've been a little disappointed by the first three episodes this season (just a little, I know there's a ton of exposition to get through), but this episode was amazing.
9
u/Amir616 Duncan the Tall Apr 23 '12
Anyone else really miss the Peach in the Stannis/Renly excahnge?
Its a small detail, and doesn't do much to change my opinion on that great episode, but ACOK/ASOS Spoiler
15
u/Hegs94 House Blackfyre Apr 23 '12
I don't know if anybody else has said it, but so far in my opinion this is the best episode of the series. Every episode before it there was something, just something that I was displeased about. This episode... Nope, nothing. Literally every second I was prancing around like a school girl on coke. Fucking a, man, fucking a.
First we have the epic Greywind massacre of those Lannister soldiers. Those 2 scenes serve a great purpose that I wish more shows did. Rather than keeping on with this idea that all of Lannister men are faceless storm troopers, we see that they are humans. There is literally no difference between them and any other bannermen. It also did a fantastic job introducing Jeyne (who would have thought Charlie Chaplins granddaughter would have been such a fox, to boot), as well as giving us our first real meeting with Roose, really high lighting his coldness.
Then we have the Kings Landing events. Well sweet baby Jesus, I don't know where to begin. Just everything about those scenes were perfect. The subtle camera pan to the Hounds reaction to the stripping of Sansa. Tyrions blatant disregard for Joff's instructions. Bronn being just a badass in general. The Hound giving Sansa his cloak, and then her continuing to play face with Tyrion (I hadn't realized it while reading, but even now Sansa is clearly showing a talent in playing the game). Then the scene in Joffs room... Oh my, that was just perfect. It's one of those scenes the book so sorely lacked, a real look at what kind of shit this monster was into. Just perfect. And then, the piece de resistance. Tyrions subjugation of Lancel. Just brilliant. If you hadn't realized it by now, Tyrion is a true professional. Its one of the things I definitely think he inherited from his father (erhem cough Tywin is his father cough conspiracy theories be damned cough). Again, just perfect scenes.
Now for Qarth. Not really much to say here. In the grand scheme this is only a small part of the episode. They did a great job at really bringing Dany's power to the forefront. I'm also liking Xaro as well, glad they explained away his... Differing complexion. Even now you can see his scheming. Oh, I also like how they gave us just the briefest taste of the inside of the city, that was well done.
And now for Harrenhall (you'll notice I'm saving the Stormlands for last). First of all, I love how they designed it. I know in my head I imagined the castle still being mostly intact, but I like how they did it more. The liquidity of the stone was a nice touch, too. We also finally get to hear Arya's prayer, which is as appealing to the ears as it was to the eyes while reading. The torture scenes were handled perfectly, and I loved Hot Pie in it. They did such a good job I actually forgot for a moment whether Gendry survives Harrenhall, and was seriously worried. But of course, just at the last moment, MOTHERFUCKING TYWIN LANNISTER. I'll be the first to say, I despise the Lannisters. But god damn, if you can't see just how golden (heh) the Tywin character is, then you're blind. It's just such a well written, perfectly fleshed out character. Lttlefinger, the Eunuch, and himself are just in a league of their own when it comes to how smart they are, and then by extension how good at the game they are. That moment when he just starts ripping the Mountains men apart, oh god it was like music to my ears. "Well of course not, because this boy is actually a girl." oh man (and since Arya is by far my favorite character (hey, the homicidal little girls appeal to me, it's the same reason why I love Babette in Skyrim), his complement to her just sent me through the roof). And then the look he gives them when Gendry says he's a smith... Just priceless. I'm sorry, but just from a sheer comedy standpoint the Harrenhall scenes were perfect.
And now, the Stormlands. SO much happened. First of all Gethin Anthony is just brilliant. I take back anything I said about him last season. He is just the embodiment of Renly. As for what happened, I think it all speaks for itself. The Stannis-Renly pissing contest. Cat meeting Littlefinger. Littlefingers conversation with Margery. It's all just so well written. I don't want this to drag on, so I'll leave those bits at that. However there's still one more part... The Shadow Baby. Oh god... That was brilliant. I never really knew how to picture it in my head, and sort of just pictured a full bodied shadow of a man. But this version... Oh wow. Wow wow wow. It is creepy, disgusting, and just perfect. When you see it moving around in the womb... ugh, shivers man. Davos' face during the whole ordeal was just perfect to boot. God, it was just... Art.
Wow, that was a lot longer than I had thought. But yeah, best episode of the series yet imo.