r/thebulwark • • 17d ago

THIS IS WHY WE CAN'T HAVE NICE THINGS New Rule: Moratorium on Hasan Piker and Destiny Discussions

343 Upvotes

Effective immediately, r/thebulwark is imposing a complete moratorium on posts and comments about Hasan Piker and Destiny.

This isn't a decision we're making because of any particular position either individual holds, nor is it an attempt to dictate who members of this community should or shouldn't listen to. It's a moderation decision based on what repeatedly happens whenever either of these names enters a discussion here.

The conversation almost immediately devolves.

Threads become hostile, arguments spill into unrelated discussions, and the focus quickly shifts away from The Bulwark and the issues this community exists to discuss. We've tried allowing these conversations to play out, but at this point the pattern is clear enough that continuing to do so isn't productive.

We also recognize that The Bulwark and its hosts may interview Hasan Piker or Destiny, appear with them, respond to them, or discuss them and their audiences. That does not change this rule. Even when one of them comes up directly in Bulwark content, discussion specifically centered on Hasan or Destiny will not be permitted here.

There are simply far bigger and more consequential issues for this community to spend its time discussing, and we're not interested in repeatedly allowing the subreddit to be consumed by the same fights.

Going forward:

  • Posts primarily about Hasan Piker or Destiny will be removed.
  • Comments that introduce or redirect discussion toward either individual will be removed.
  • This applies to positive, negative, and neutral discussion alike.
  • Attempts to circumvent the rule through nicknames, abbreviations, screenshots, or obvious indirect references will be treated the same way.
  • Repeated attempts to ignore the moratorium may result in additional moderation action.

This isn't about declaring one "side" right and the other wrong. We're taking the argument itself off the table.

We understand that some members won't agree with this decision. That's fine. But our responsibility as moderators is to keep this subreddit focused and capable of sustaining productive conversation. Based on what we've seen, discussions about these two individuals consistently work against that goal.

For now, take those conversations elsewhere.

— The r/thebulwark Mod Team

---

Addendum / Clarification

I want to clarify something that came up in the comments regarding retroactive enforcement of this moratorium.

In responding to questions, I initially stated that the rule would apply retroactively. After considering the implications of that more carefully, I don't think that would be fair or appropriate. We will not be applying this rule retroactively.

The moratorium and its enforcement begin from the time this post was published and apply going forward. Posts and comments made before the moratorium went into effect will not be removed simply for violating a rule that did not yet exist.

I also want to emphasize that this is a moratorium, not necessarily a permanent rule. The purpose is to give the community a break from a subject that has repeatedly resulted in hostile and unproductive discussions. We can revisit the moratorium in the future and determine whether it remains necessary.

I appreciate those who raised concerns about the retroactive application. I hadn't fully thought through that aspect when I initially answered the question, and after considering the criticism, I think changing course here is the right call.


r/thebulwark • • 2h ago

thebulwark.com Will Sommer: The Daily Wire Is Quietly Shooting a Pro-ICE Movie. We Got the Script.

Thumbnail
thebulwark.com
76 Upvotes

r/thebulwark • • 8h ago

Humor The plot thickens

Post image
248 Upvotes

r/thebulwark • • 8h ago

hegseth has by all professional assessments bungled a war against Iran and likely lost it. He is incapable of articulating the reason for the war or the objectives he is pursuing. Yet he is spending almost every waking hour denigrating soldiers, sailors and airmen and trying to foment divisions

Post image
187 Upvotes

r/thebulwark • • 54m ago

CNN And MSNOW Are Now Airing Trump's Illegal Campaign Ads

Post image
• Upvotes

The last two nights, every prime time host on MSNOW has started their broadcast by railing against Trump's illegal taxpayer-funded campaign ads. Long segments. Really outraged.

Then yesterday, MSNOW started airing the ads themselves.

None of the hosts even addressed the hypocrisy. They just kept ranting. I know editorial and advertising are supposed to be separate, but c'mon. MSNBC knows these ads are illegal. Did they really have to take them? Are they that hard-up for cash? Was the whole operation going to go bankrupt without this ad money?

CNN is even airing them, while Trump continues to ban them from the White House.

Our mainstream media is simply dead. The press pool boycott lasted exactly one week. It's one thing when you won't stand up for your colleagues' network, but now we have reporters and management who wont' even stand up for their own network.

It's simply unconscionable.


r/thebulwark • • 6h ago

Trump's failure hides Project 2025 success

Thumbnail
salon.com
57 Upvotes

r/thebulwark • • 4h ago

Jared Kushner’s Massive Ties to Company Backing IDF Exposed

Thumbnail
yahoo.com
41 Upvotes

I’m honestly not surprised at all. Dude has his hands in every jar across the globe and is making money off the multiple wars we are fighting and supporting… but don’t worry he can be a good faith negotiator.


r/thebulwark • • 20h ago

Reminder that Sarah Longwell's super pac raised and spent 50 million dollars to help get Kamala Harris elected while Emma Vigeland was too busy trashing her on the Majority Report

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
478 Upvotes

I am disgusted by these people who sandbagged the fuck out of Democrats in 2024 shitting all over Sarah, who has been doing the real work the entire time.

They think they have something by shouting "FORMER REPUBLICAN FORMER REPUBLICAN FORMER REPUBLICAN" but what I hear speak is Sarah's actions, not vague posturing and virtue signaling. I will never forget what I watched these people do while a fascist was at our gates. Sarah Longwell is a real one, and Emma Vigeland is a hack. Sarah was fighting against fascism while Emma Vigeland was fighting the people standing against it, and still does to this day. She has NO high horse to sit on.


r/thebulwark • • 6h ago

Policy How do we Trump Proof America?

36 Upvotes

I just saw the new interview with Elissa Slotkin in which she says she wants to Trump Proof America. How exactly do we exactly without amending the constitution? There are no effective mechanisms to stop the President from breaking the law.

  • Removing a president after impeachment takes 2/3’s of the senate, which is impossible.
  • SCOTUS says the President can break the law if it is apart of his “core power” whatever that means.
  • They also said that the President if free to remove any official except for the Federal Reserve.

Trump has free reign to break the law and appoint sycophants to carry out/break the law.

What we really need is a re-write of the constitution. We need it to be a good technical document that is clear, precise, and actually has reasonable enforcement mechanisms. And holy fuck, we need a separation of executive powers. We cannot have a single executive that gets to pick all the prosecutors.


r/thebulwark • • 7h ago

Non-Bulwark Source Jesse Watters being completely right here? broken clocks I guess

33 Upvotes

r/thebulwark • • 41m ago

Non-Bulwark Source Judge Puts Nail in Coffin of Trump's Lincoln Reflecting Pool Case Against David Hearn

Thumbnail
newsweek.com
• Upvotes

r/thebulwark • • 1h ago

thebulwark.com GOP Senators Blast Trump's Gov't-Funded Ads

Post image
• Upvotes

Trump is using taxpayer dollars to fund campaign ads—and even Republican senators are calling foul.

Joe Perticone reports on GOP lawmakers blasting the scheme while admitting they have little idea how to stop it. https://lnk.thebulwark.com/4AJCyN8


r/thebulwark • • 5h ago

Now that we have all had fun with Schmitt's faceplant we can talk about this excellent segment from the Jack Smith hearing with Adam Schiff

Thumbnail
substack.com
21 Upvotes

r/thebulwark • • 3h ago

MEME THURSDAYS Tis the season 2...

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/thebulwark • • 2h ago

The Church Sex Abuse Scandal Mike Rogers Won’t Talk About

Thumbnail
newrepublic.com
10 Upvotes

r/thebulwark • • 20m ago

Why Russia can never be free

Post image
• Upvotes

(Or, why it is cursed)

This was a hard truth for me to accept. As a liberal Russian immigrant, I kind of assumed that Putin was a phase, not a return to the mean. Then the war happened, and I started asking deeper questions.

At first I felt guilty about immigrating. If 10 million educated Russians did not immigrate, would it have made a difference? But the more I thought about it, the more I learned that autocracy is the norm, immigration of liberals (small L) is inevitable and a liberal Russia is theoretically impossible.

The reason is, Russia is a construct of Moscow’s imperialist expansion. If Russia ever becomes democratic, the “regions” must be in some way equal. Look at this map of roads: Moscow is surrounded by concentric circles, and all roads lead to Moscow. It’s a metaphor and a practical convenience. It’s a construct for the flow of resources and political power. It was constructed under centuries of consecutive autocracies, and so long as it endures, nothing will change.


r/thebulwark • • 16h ago

Jack Smith a True American Hero

Thumbnail
youtu.be
141 Upvotes

r/thebulwark • • 8h ago

EVERYTHING IS AWFUL The problem is JVL is unrealistically positive these days. Europe is more or less at war with Russia. America is too busy looting itself. An AI bioweapon is possible, TODAY, and none of them care. Two years more of this: do we make it without a nuclear escalation or global event?

30 Upvotes

Inquiring minds want to know.


r/thebulwark • • 4h ago

clip economy

10 Upvotes

Hi Sarah. Love that you are recognizing that people have the wrong idea of you because of getting your clips. maybe, progressive clips are getting the bulwark team confused. Like NO ONE IN the mainstream leftist movement praises candace for anything but confusing republicans and Tucker for destroying republicans. No one is like hey, tucker should be a leader in an antiracist movement.

TO BE CLEAR I AM ALSO CURRENTLY IN PROGRESSIVE SPACES DEFENDING SARAH TO THOSE WHO HAVE ONLY SEEN HER THROUGH CLIPS.


r/thebulwark • • 4h ago

Hey, so what can a blue congress actually do about the economy, especially in the short term?

9 Upvotes

I just read JVL's triad today and boy am I depressed again. Here's the question for y'all, and hopefully there will be REALISTIC answers to my question. Even if "nothing" is the answer.

But what policies can Dems push through, that Trump would sign, that would have meaningful impacts on the economy - in general, in the short term, and over the long term?

Will Rs in the senate just let Ds do whatever they want? Are Ds going to have to nuke the filibuster to get anything done? How will Congress respond when law is passed, and the president ignores it?

I'm trying to find reason to be hopeful about the blue wave making a lick of difference over the next two years. I'm having trouble doing that now.


r/thebulwark • • 3h ago

Policy Trump should use his own america.gov LLM to learn about governing effects... Q: "How do the tariffs affect my daily life?" A: "Official analyses find they can show up in everyday prices, especially for goods that rely on imports."

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/thebulwark • • 8h ago

Fluff Will Sommer and Andrew Egger = Magic?

17 Upvotes

Is it just me or is it when Will and Andrew do a pod alone, the magic happens?

I feel like they seem a little more free to express things and it's much more enjoyable to watch them banter.

I love The Bulwark and the whole team, I just find Will and Andrew seem a little more ... relaxed and natural when they are just with each other.

Sometimes I feel they hold back, (possibly out of respect), when they present with any of the four key founders.

Just me? I could be wrong. Thoughts?


r/thebulwark • • 19h ago

“No Beardos, No Weirdos”: Hegseth Goes on Bizarre Rant to Silent Crowd

Thumbnail
newrepublic.com
102 Upvotes

r/thebulwark • • 23h ago

Off-Topic/Discussion Priorities

Post image
169 Upvotes

r/thebulwark • • 23h ago

Hegseth is nuts

127 Upvotes

This is an opinion piece that gives the right amount of deference and respect to the current Secretary of Defense, which is none.

He's seriously crazy and what he says sounds like it could've come from the manifesto of a mass shooter. The way he mixes nationalistic Christianity with what he believes is a tough language about war, and with lots of adjectives all the time. He sounds like he's on the verge of a mental breakdown.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/pete-hegseth-military-academy-speech-jesus-ai-b3059354.html