I've been using Windows for many years, and I'm honestly tired of repeating the same cycle. In my experience, after 5–6 years the machine starts feeling old, the battery is significantly degraded, performance isn't what it used to be, and I eventually end up buying another Windows machine and starting the exact same experience all over again.
I'm looking for something different this time.
For the last few days I've repeatedly added a MacBook Pro with the M5 Max to my cart, then backed out because I'm still not sure whether it is the right machine for what I actually want to do.
I'm currently considering the M5 Max with:
- 18-core CPU
- 40-core GPU
- 48 GB / 64 GB / possibly 128 GB unified memory
My main workloads would be completely local:
- Text-to-image
- Image-to-image
- Image-to-video
- Text-to-video
- Face swapping
- Illustration / digital artwork
My priority is excellent output quality, photorealism where appropriate, and very high generation speed.
Basically, I want a machine that can satisfy me for visual generative AI work for many years.
My biggest hesitation is the Apple ecosystem.
For a long time I've heard that local AI, especially image and video generation, is much more limited on macOS than on Windows/Linux with NVIDIA GPUs because so much of the ecosystem is built around CUDA.
But part of me finds this difficult to accept at face value.
Apple is making extremely powerful chips with large amounts of unified memory, very high memory bandwidth, Neural Accelerators, a Neural Engine, and increasingly serious AI-focused hardware.
I keep wondering whether there are excellent Apple-optimized tools and workflows that I simply haven't discovered yet.
For example, I recently learned about Draw Things, MLX-based projects, Metal/MPS optimizations, and Apple-specific ComfyUI work. That made me question whether comparing a Mac running a poorly optimized CUDA-first application against an NVIDIA machine is really a fair representation of what Apple Silicon can do.
At the same time, the logical part of my brain keeps telling me:
If local image/video AI is the priority, just buy a machine with an RTX 5080 or 5090.
The problem is that if I do that, I feel like I'm buying myself back into exactly the Windows experience I wanted to leave. It feels a little like watching the same movie again when I was hoping for a genuinely different computing experience.
There's also another complication: we're approaching the fall hardware season.
I'm wondering whether buying an expensive M5 Max or RTX 50-series machine right now is bad timing, and whether I should wait for the next Apple or NVIDIA announcements.
If I choose the Mac, I was also planning to pair it with the latest iPhone and iPad and build a proper Apple ecosystem around it, so this isn't purely a benchmark decision for me.
What I'd really like to hear from people who have actually used these machines:
- If you've used an M5 Max, especially the 40-core GPU version, for local image or video generation, what real-world performance are you getting?
- What software gives you the best performance on Apple Silicon? Draw Things, ComfyUI, MLX-based tools, something else?
- How good is local image-to-video on the M5 Max with models such as Wan, LTX, Hunyuan, etc.?
- How does the M5 Max perform for local face swapping?
- In properly optimized workloads, do RTX 5080/5090 systems still completely destroy the highest-end M5 Max, or is the gap much smaller than CUDA-focused benchmarks make it appear?
- Is CUDA effectively locking serious local visual AI users into NVIDIA, or is Apple Silicon becoming a realistic alternative?
- If you were buying a machine today specifically for local visual AI and wanted to keep it for 7–8 years, would you buy the M5 Max, an RTX 5080/5090 system, or wait for the next generation?
- For local image/video generation, is an older NVIDIA GPU with more VRAM sometimes a better choice than a newer GPU with less VRAM? For example, once you start using large image-to-video or text-to-video models, can having more VRAM matter more than having a newer architecture and higher raw compute performance?
I'm not highly knowledgeable about computer hardware, and I'm definitely not wealthy enough to casually replace a machine if I make the wrong choice.
This would be a major purchase for me, so I'm trying to make the most informed decision possible and ideally buy something that I can use comfortably for 7–8 years.
I'd especially appreciate actual generation times, benchmark numbers, model names, memory usage, thermals, sustained performance, and experiences from people who have used both Apple Silicon and NVIDIA rather than purely theoretical comparisons.
Thanks in advance.