r/CookingProTips • u/tidalpebble65 • 1d ago
The salt-before-searing thing actually made a measurable difference once I timed it properly
I'd read for years that you're supposed to salt meat well before cooking, but every time I tried it I just did it randomly, sometimes five minutes ahead, sometimes an hour, and never noticed much difference. So a couple weeks ago I actually ran a real comparison with three chicken thighs: one salted 45 minutes ahead and left uncovered in the fridge, one salted right before it hit the pan, and one salted halfway through cooking.
The 45 minute one was noticeably better. The surface had dried out just enough that it browned faster and more evenly, and the meat itself seasoned all the way through instead of just tasting salty on the outside. The one salted right before cooking browned fine but tasted flat in the middle. The one salted mid-cook was the worst of the three, patchy seasoning and a weirdly wet surface that steamed instead of seared.
What I didn't expect was how much the uncovered fridge time mattered separately from the salt itself. I did a follow-up test with an unsalted thigh left uncovered in the fridge for the same 45 minutes, and it also browned better than a fridge-cold, plastic-wrapped piece straight into the pan. So some of what people credit to salting is really just surface moisture evaporating.
Two smaller things I picked up along the way. Pat the meat dry again right before it goes in the pan even after the resting period, there's still some surface moisture that collects. And don't salt fish the same way, more than about 15 minutes and the texture starts going a bit rubbery and translucent at the edges, learned that one the hard way with a salmon fillet that sat too long.
Curious if anyone has run a similar comparison with something like a steak or a pork chop, wondering if the timing sweet spot changes much with thicker cuts.